Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / SlumdogMillionaire

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HypeBacklash: It won Best Picture at the Academy Awards, which fueled all sorts of complaints about it. Western audiences disliked it for simplistic drama and (for them) unexpectable Bollywood cliches, which seemed out of place in awarded film. Western Bollywood fans started to complain about truly annoying NewbieBoom and suddenly the entire genre being viewed through poor imitation. Indian audiences hated it with passion for the PovertyPorn angle and Oscar only made things worse. And Bollywood actors had various, often personal reason to trash it anyway.

to:

* HypeBacklash: It won Best Picture at the Academy Awards, which fueled all sorts of complaints about it. Western audiences disliked it for simplistic drama and (for them) unexpectable Bollywood cliches, which seemed out of place in awarded film. Western Bollywood fans started to complain about a truly annoying NewbieBoom and suddenly the entire genre being viewed through poor imitation. Indian audiences hated it with passion for the PovertyPorn angle and Oscar only made things worse. And Bollywood actors had various, often personal reason to trash it anyway.

Added: 81

Changed: 247

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWoobie: Jamal. Because after seeing [[JustForPun how much crap he's gone through]], you can't help but want to give him a big hug.

to:

* TheWoobie: TheWoobie:
**
Jamal. Because after seeing [[JustForPun how much crap he's gone through]], you can't help but want to give him a big hug.
** Latika. She was sold into sexual slavery by [[spoiler:Jamal's brother Salim]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: Maman and his gang blinding little boys to become beggars and prostituting underage girls is the most obvious one. He is like the darkest interpretation of TheFagin from ''Literature/OliversTwist''.

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: Maman and his gang blinding little boys to become beggars and prostituting underage girls is the most obvious one. He is like the darkest interpretation of TheFagin from ''Literature/OliversTwist''.''Literature/OliverTwist''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MemeticMutation: Anil Kapoor's pronounciation of the word, "Millionaire."
* MoralEventHorizon: Maman and his gang blinding little boys to become beggars and prostituting underage girls is the most obvious one. He is like the darkest intepretation of TheFagin from Oliver Twist.

to:

* MemeticMutation: Anil Kapoor's pronounciation pronunciation of the word, "Millionaire."
* MoralEventHorizon: Maman and his gang blinding little boys to become beggars and prostituting underage girls is the most obvious one. He is like the darkest intepretation interpretation of TheFagin from Oliver Twist.''Literature/OliversTwist''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmericansHateTingle: India did ''not'' take kindly to this film for having needlessly glamourised [[StopBeingStereotypical negative]] [[SimSimSalabim stereotypes]] about their country and the city of Mumbai and for portraying India as more impoverished than it actually is. In fact, many Indians were dismayed that Slumdog actually won so many awards.

to:

* AmericansHateTingle: India did ''not'' take kindly to this film for having needlessly glamourised glamourized [[StopBeingStereotypical negative]] [[SimSimSalabim stereotypes]] about their country and the city of Mumbai and for portraying India as more impoverished than it actually is. In fact, many Indians were dismayed that Slumdog ''Slumdog Millionaire'' actually won so many awards.

Changed: 165

Removed: 151

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NauseaFuel: How to leave an outhouse over a river with only two exits, a jammed door and... guess it.
** If it makes you feel any better, the actor was actually jumping in a substance made of peanut butter and chocolate (basically a liquid Reese's cup).

to:

* NauseaFuel: How to leave an outhouse over a river with only two exits, a jammed door and... guess it.
** If
it makes you feel (though if it's any better, consolation, the actor was actually just jumping in into a substance made of peanut butter and chocolate (basically a liquid Reese's cup).and peanut butter, hardly the most disgusting thing to be covered in).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Poverty Porn is not YMMV


* PovertyPorn: From the left to right, the film has been accused of this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Prem Kumar, the game show host crossed it when he tried to cheat and even lied about Jamal and had him tortured for supposedly "cheating". The policemen themselves qualify for torturing someone on hours without proof and even if they were right it was DisproportionateRetribution.

to:

** Prem Kumar, the game show host crossed it when he tried to cheat and even lied about Jamal and had him tortured for supposedly "cheating". The policemen themselves qualify for torturing someone on for hours without proof and even if they were right it was DisproportionateRetribution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HypeBacklash: It won Best Picture at the Academy Awards, which fuelled all sorts of complaints about it. Western audiences disliked it for simplistic drama and (for them) unexpectable Bollywood cliches, which seemed out of place in awarded film. Western Bollywood fans started to complain about truly annoying NewbieBoom and suddenly the entire genre being viewed through poor imitation. Indian audiences hated it with passion for the PovertyPorn angle and Oscar only made things worse. And Bollywood actors had various, often personal reason to trash it anyway.

to:

* HypeBacklash: It won Best Picture at the Academy Awards, which fuelled fueled all sorts of complaints about it. Western audiences disliked it for simplistic drama and (for them) unexpectable Bollywood cliches, which seemed out of place in awarded film. Western Bollywood fans started to complain about truly annoying NewbieBoom and suddenly the entire genre being viewed through poor imitation. Indian audiences hated it with passion for the PovertyPorn angle and Oscar only made things worse. And Bollywood actors had various, often personal reason to trash it anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HypeBacklash: It won Best Picture at the Academy Awards, which fuelled all sorts of complains about it. Western audiences disliked it for simplistic drama and (for them) unexpectable Bollywood cliches, which seemed out of place in awarded film. Western Bollywood fans started to complain about truly annoying NewbieBoom and suddenly the entire genre being viewed through poor imitation. Indian audiences hated it with passion for the PovertyPorn angle and Oscar only made things worse. And Bollywood actors had various, often personal reason to trash it anyway.

to:

* HypeBacklash: It won Best Picture at the Academy Awards, which fuelled all sorts of complains complaints about it. Western audiences disliked it for simplistic drama and (for them) unexpectable Bollywood cliches, which seemed out of place in awarded film. Western Bollywood fans started to complain about truly annoying NewbieBoom and suddenly the entire genre being viewed through poor imitation. Indian audiences hated it with passion for the PovertyPorn angle and Oscar only made things worse. And Bollywood actors had various, often personal reason to trash it anyway.
Tabs MOD

Removed: 185

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarWorm: "JAI HO! (''[[GratuitousForeignLanguage Baila, baila!]]'')". The equally Oscar-nominated [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vHUQht1HRmY O... Saya]]" (featuring M.I.A) as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This doesn't come out of nowhere quite as much if you're familiar with Bollywood films, which use "everybody dances" endings often. If you aren't, it will probably just invoke a FlatWhat.

to:

** This doesn't come out of nowhere quite as much if you're familiar with Bollywood films, which use "everybody dances" endings [[DancePartyEnding Dance Party Endings]] often. If you aren't, it will probably just invoke a FlatWhat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AmericansHateTingle: India did ''not'' take kindly to this film for having needlessly glamourised [[StopBeingStereotypical negative]] [[SimSimSalabim stereotypes]] about their country and the city of Mumbai and for portraying India as more impoverished than it actually is. In fact, many Indians were dismayed that Slumdog actually won so many awards, to the point where so much as ''mentioning'' the movie can qualify as a BerserkButton to them.

to:

* AmericansHateTingle: India did ''not'' take kindly to this film for having needlessly glamourised [[StopBeingStereotypical negative]] [[SimSimSalabim stereotypes]] about their country and the city of Mumbai and for portraying India as more impoverished than it actually is. In fact, many Indians were dismayed that Slumdog actually won so many awards, to the point where so much as ''mentioning'' the movie can qualify as a BerserkButton to them.awards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Is it ok now? I think the original version was cut short due to Rule Of Cautious Editing Judgment.

Added DiffLines:

* HypeBacklash: It won Best Picture at the Academy Awards, which fuelled all sorts of complains about it. Western audiences disliked it for simplistic drama and (for them) unexpectable Bollywood cliches, which seemed out of place in awarded film. Western Bollywood fans started to complain about truly annoying NewbieBoom and suddenly the entire genre being viewed through poor imitation. Indian audiences hated it with passion for the PovertyPorn angle and Oscar only made things worse. And Bollywood actors had various, often personal reason to trash it anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Per cleanup, must explain what about it they find lacking.


* HypeBacklash: It won Best Picture at the Academy Awards. And that is all we shall say on the matter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Prem Kumar, the game show host crossed it when he tried to cheat and even lied about Jamal and had him tortured for supposedly "cheating". On that matter the police themselves qualify for torturing someone on hours without proof and even if they were right it was DisproportionateRetribution.

to:

** Prem Kumar, the game show host crossed it when he tried to cheat and even lied about Jamal and had him tortured for supposedly "cheating". On that matter the police The policemen themselves qualify for torturing someone on hours without proof and even if they were right it was DisproportionateRetribution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And while not as much politically-charged, the movie has been also heavily accused of being a poor Western imitation of Bollywood movies, with utter disregard of their conventions and only looking on the surface-level cliches. Creator/AmitabhBachchan rallied people against the movie, feeling personally insulted by "his" presence in it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[AmericansHateTingle Indians Hate Slumdog Millionare]]: India did ''not'' take kindly to this film for having needlessly glamourised [[StopBeingStereotypical negative]] [[SimSimSalabim stereotypes]] about their country and the city of Mumbai and for portraying India as more impoverished than it actually is. In fact, many Indians were dismayed that Slumdog actually won so many awards, to the point where so much as ''mentioning'' the movie can qualify as a BerserkButton to them.

to:

* [[AmericansHateTingle Indians Hate Slumdog Millionare]]: AmericansHateTingle: India did ''not'' take kindly to this film for having needlessly glamourised [[StopBeingStereotypical negative]] [[SimSimSalabim stereotypes]] about their country and the city of Mumbai and for portraying India as more impoverished than it actually is. In fact, many Indians were dismayed that Slumdog actually won so many awards, to the point where so much as ''mentioning'' the movie can qualify as a BerserkButton to them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: Slum boss Maman is [[FauxAffablyEvil charming, friendly and cheerful]] to orphans he meets, offering the young Jamal and Salim [[BaitTheDog ice cold coca colas]] and offering them a place to stay. It is revealed Maman takes in orphans to use as a begging ring for him, and the kids are just free labor. Even worse, cripples earn more money, so when children display good singing talent, Maman has them blinded with acid to increase the revenue. When Salim and Jamal escape, Maman captures their friend Latika and several years later gives her the name 'Cherry' while intending to use her as a child prostitute. The only reason he hasn't done so already is as a virgin, she's worth a great deal of money. When he finds the young Salim and Jamal, he immediately plans to kill them, declaring "Maman never forgets."

to:

* CompleteMonster: Slum boss Maman is [[FauxAffablyEvil charming, friendly and cheerful]] to orphans he meets, offering the young Jamal and Salim [[BaitTheDog ice cold coca colas]] and offering them a place to stay. It is revealed Maman [[BadSamaritan takes in orphans to use as a begging ring for him, him]], and the kids are just free labor. Even worse, cripples earn more money, so when children display good singing talent, Maman has them [[EyeScream blinded with acid acid]] to increase the revenue. When Salim and Jamal escape, Maman captures their friend Latika and several years later gives her the name 'Cherry' while intending to use her as a child prostitute. The only reason he hasn't done so already is as a virgin, she's worth a great deal of money. When he finds the young Salim and Jamal, he immediately plans to kill them, declaring "Maman never forgets."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PovertyPorn: From the left to right, the film has been accused of this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmericansHateTingle: And Indians hate Slumdog Millionaire the same way, for having needlessly glamourised negative stereotypes about their country, or even a prominent city. In fact, many Indians were dismayed that Slumdog actually won so many awards.

to:

* AmericansHateTingle: And [[AmericansHateTingle Indians hate Hate Slumdog Millionaire the same way, Millionare]]: India did ''not'' take kindly to this film for having needlessly glamourised negative stereotypes [[StopBeingStereotypical negative]] [[SimSimSalabim stereotypes]] about their country, or even a prominent city. country and the city of Mumbai and for portraying India as more impoverished than it actually is. In fact, many Indians were dismayed that Slumdog actually won so many awards.awards, to the point where so much as ''mentioning'' the movie can qualify as a BerserkButton to them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: Where to start? Maman and his gang blinding little boys to become beggars and prostituting underage girls is the most obvious one. He is like the darkest intepretation of TheFagin from Oliver Twist.

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: Where to start? MoralEventHorizon: Maman and his gang blinding little boys to become beggars and prostituting underage girls is the most obvious one. He is like the darkest intepretation of TheFagin from Oliver Twist.

Changed: 100

Removed: 65

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* HypeAversion[=/=]HypeBacklash: It won Best Picture at the Academy Awards. And that is all we shall say on the matter.
* MemeticMutation: See BecauseDestinySaysSo and SayMyName.
** Also, Anil Kapoor's pronounciation of the word, "Millionaire."

to:

* HypeAversion[=/=]HypeBacklash: HypeBacklash: It won Best Picture at the Academy Awards. And that is all we shall say on the matter.
* MemeticMutation: See BecauseDestinySaysSo and SayMyName.
** Also,
Anil Kapoor's pronounciation of the word, "Millionaire."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: Where to start? Maman and his gang blinding little boys to become beggars and prostituting underage girls is the most obvious one. He is like "an even darker" version of Fagin from Oliver Twist.

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: Where to start? Maman and his gang blinding little boys to become beggars and prostituting underage girls is the most obvious one. He is like "an even darker" version the darkest intepretation of Fagin TheFagin from Oliver Twist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MoralEventHorizon: Where to start? Maman and his gang blinding little boys to become beggars and prostituting underage girls is the most obvious one. He is like "an even darker" version of Fagin from Oliver Twist.
** Prem Kumar, the game show host crossed it when he tried to cheat and even lied about Jamal and had him tortured for supposedly "cheating". On that matter the police themselves qualify for torturing someone on hours without proof and even if they were right it was DisproportionateRetribution.
** Javed Khan as a crime boss was obviously beyond it but onscreen examples are the abuse and scarring of Latika.
** For that matter Salim became his willing henchman and helped him prostitute Latika and betrayed his own brother.
** Finally what started it all was the cold-blooded murder of their mother and other random civilians by extremists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If it makes you feel any better, the actor was actually jumping in a substance made of peanut butter and chocolate (basically a liquid Reece's cup).

to:

** If it makes you feel any better, the actor was actually jumping in a substance made of peanut butter and chocolate (basically a liquid Reece's Reese's cup).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If it makes you feel any better, the actor was actually jumping in a substance made of peanut butter and chocolate (basically a liquid Reece's cup).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Already on their page.


* TearJerker: The ending. But in a ''good'' way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It also could be seen as a reference to the earlier scene when they are kids. Before Jamal is about to sing for Maman, he asks Latika to dance with him and performs a silly dance for her. Some of the dance moves he does are repeated during the Jai Ho dance and the kid actors reappear during the dance, highlighting how the two are finally together.

Top