History YMMV / PuellaMagiMadokaMagica

23rd Aug '16 11:08:54 AM krimzonflygon2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Opinion is split on Kyubey. He's either a [[spoiler:disgusting, irredeemably evil monster, or an [[CuteIsEvil adorable]], yet [[NightmareFuel nightmarish]], MagnificentBastard [[WellIntentionedExtremist with admirable goals]]]].

to:

** Opinion is split on Kyubey. He's either a [[spoiler:disgusting, irredeemably evil monster, or an [[CuteIsEvil adorable]], yet [[NightmareFuel nightmarish]], MagnificentBastard [[WellIntentionedExtremist with admirable goals]]]]. ''Rebellion'' does '''NOT''' look good for the latter.
23rd Aug '16 11:07:40 AM krimzonflygon2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Also ReadTheFreakingManual.

to:

** Also ReadTheFreakingManual.ReadTheFinePrint, although it's not like [[ManipulativeBastard Kyubey]] so much as hints that there's fine print to read.
23rd Aug '16 11:04:59 AM krimzonflygon2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** Similar to Hitomi, his actions in the PSP game have exacerbated this debate; after he [[spoiler:finds out [[BodyHorror what the MG process did to Sayaka]], and [[KickTheDog calls her]] a ''"disgusting monster"'' to her face... on the other hand, the bonus route goes the opposite end, with him approving of Sayaka being a magical girl]].

to:

*** Similar to Hitomi, his actions in the PSP game have exacerbated this debate; after he [[spoiler:finds out [[BodyHorror what the MG process did to Sayaka]], and [[KickTheDog calls her]] a ''"disgusting monster"'' to her face... on the other hand, the bonus route goes the opposite end, with him approving of Sayaka being a magical girl]].girl]] (and one must remember the first set of circumstances basically had him face-to-face with Sayaka ''while half of her body had decayed'': one could hardly blame him for freaking out).
23rd Aug '16 10:59:26 AM krimzonflygon2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Homura Akemi: A courageous, selfless heroine who [[TheWoobie seriously needs a hug after everything she went through]], or a creepily obsessive StalkerWithACrush who only did everything she did to feel [[EntitledToHaveYou entitled to Madoka]]? While a lot of the show's fans interpret her as the former, some detractors think she's the latter. Some of her fans who believe in the former even jokingly dabble in the latter, making her a MemeticMolester. ''[[Anime/PuellaMagiMadokaMagicaTheMovieRebellion Rebellion]]'' heavily supports the latter interpretation.

to:

** Homura Akemi: A courageous, selfless heroine who [[TheWoobie seriously needs a hug after everything she went through]], or a creepily obsessive StalkerWithACrush who only did everything she did to feel [[EntitledToHaveYou entitled to Madoka]]? While a lot of the show's fans interpret her as the former, some detractors think she's the latter. Some of her fans who believe in the former even jokingly dabble in the latter, making her a MemeticMolester. ''[[Anime/PuellaMagiMadokaMagicaTheMovieRebellion Rebellion]]'' heavily supports [[TakeAThirdOption pretty much merges the latter interpretation.two interpretations]]; a creepily obsessive StalkerWithACrush who [[JerkassWoobie regardless seriously needs a hug after everything she went through.]]
28th Jul '16 10:48:19 AM Anddrix
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* BaseBreaker

to:

* BaseBreakerBaseBreakingCharacter:



* FandomRivalry: A given considering the nature and tone of the series, which makes it something of a BaseBreaker among the MagicalGirl genre's fandom. Its fans not only quarrel with the fans of traditional MagicalGirl shows such as ''Anime/SailorMoon'' and ''Anime/PrettyCure'', but also the fandoms of fellow dark shows such as ''Anime/PrincessTutu'' and ''Anime/IlSolePenetraLeIllusioni''.

to:

* FandomRivalry: A given considering the nature and tone of the series, which makes it something of a BaseBreaker LoveItOrHateIt among the MagicalGirl genre's fandom. Its fans not only quarrel with the fans of traditional MagicalGirl shows such as ''Anime/SailorMoon'' and ''Anime/PrettyCure'', but also the fandoms of fellow dark shows such as ''Anime/PrincessTutu'' and ''Anime/IlSolePenetraLeIllusioni''.
28th Jun '16 9:22:08 AM NausicaaoftheSpirits
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Sayaka's use of the phrase "For realz?" sounds so painfully out of place in the English dub.
2nd Jun '16 8:27:45 AM ImpudentInfidel
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*** There's also a branch that doesn't believe his [[spoiler: VillainsNeverLie claims and think everything he told Madoka about his motives, how his efforts have aided humanity, and how he's emotionless are complete bullshit. He's canonically a ConsummateLiar in all but the most technical sense anyway.]]
2nd May '16 5:00:38 PM Ferot_Dreadnaught
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Sayaka herself has garnered divisive opinions. Depending on the fan, she's either a very well-done and sympathetic [[FallenHero tragic character]], or a whiny WhiteKnight who felt [[EntitledToHaveYou unnecessarily entitled]] to Kyosuke's love.

to:

** Sayaka herself has garnered divisive opinions. Depending on the fan, she's either a very well-done and sympathetic [[FallenHero tragic character]], or a whiny WhiteKnight who and felt [[EntitledToHaveYou unnecessarily entitled]] to Kyosuke's love.
17th Apr '16 7:32:33 AM Edgar81539
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** The two men on the train [[spoiler:when they brag about how they mistreat their girlfriends and have a laugh about it while belittling their intelligence and love for them. Given that they helped make Sayaka give up on being a hero, their implied death was rightly deserved]].
11th Apr '16 7:45:09 PM n3xus
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* CounterpartComparison
** Kyubey is this for any dark variation of the SeriesMascot, particularly [[VisualNovel/{{DanganRonpa}} Monokuma]] and [[Manga/{{Bokurano}} Koemushi]].
** Sayaka: with her water motif, headstrong nature, and her calling herself a UsefulNotes/{{baka}} [[spoiler:in a crucial part of the story]], it's inevitable that she would be compared to Cirno, the [[SmallNameBigEgo boastful]] yet [[TheDitz childish]] [[AnIcePerson ice fairy]] of ''VideoGame/{{Touhou}}''.



* CounterpartComparison

to:

* CounterpartComparisonCounterpartComparison:
** Kyubey is this for any dark variation of the SeriesMascot, particularly [[VisualNovel/{{DanganRonpa}} Monokuma]] and [[Manga/{{Bokurano}} Koemushi]].
** Sayaka: with her water motif, headstrong nature, and her calling herself a UsefulNotes/{{baka}} [[spoiler:in a crucial part of the story]], it's inevitable that she would be compared to Cirno, the [[SmallNameBigEgo boastful]] yet [[TheDitz childish]] [[AnIcePerson ice fairy]] of ''VideoGame/{{Touhou}}''.
This list shows the last 10 events of 984. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=YMMV.PuellaMagiMadokaMagica