Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / PartiallyKissedHero

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnintentionallySympathetic: Draco Malfoy is probably supposed to be seen as the obnoxious, dickish SmugSnake he is in canon, but he goes through so much horrible shit that the reader can't help but feel sorry for him.

to:

* UnintentionallySympathetic: Draco Malfoy is probably supposed to be seen as the an obnoxious, dickish SmugSnake he is in canon, who brings the bad things that happen to him on himself, but he goes through so much horrible shit that the reader can't help but feel sorry for him.

Added: 219

Changed: 260

Removed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----



** But Dumbledore and Snape get it worst of all. Dumbledore is depicted as a self-serving sadist who deliberately arranged for Harry to be mistreated and secretly holds enormous influence over the government and society of magical Britain, being ultimately responsible for ''all'' of its social ills. Snape is depicted as Dumbledore’s enthusiastic henchman who uses Polyjuice Potion to run a child sex ring.

to:

** But Dumbledore and Snape get it worst of all. Dumbledore is depicted as a self-serving sadist who deliberately arranged for Harry to be mistreated and secretly holds enormous influence over the government and society of magical Britain, being ultimately responsible for ''all'' of its social ills. Snape is depicted as Dumbledore’s enthusiastic henchman who uses Polyjuice Potion to run a child sex ring. Filch and Moody are also involved with Dumbledore's evil scheming -- the former as his one-man CleanupCrew and the latter as his personal assassin -- but since they don't feature as prominently in the fic as Dumbledore or Snape, they get off comparatively lightly.



* UnintentionallySympathetic: Draco Malfoy is probably supposed to be seen as the obnoxious, dickish SmugSnake he is in canon, but he goes through so much horrible shit that the reader can't help but feel sorry for him.



* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: A spell cast upon [[spoiler:Snape]] causes him to horribly torture [[spoiler:Draco Malfoy in the Slytherin common room]], in front of, among others, first year students. The timing is such that Memory Charms can’t be used on any of the kids. Regardless of the trauma, somehow [[spoiler:Draco]] lives, and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it’s just deserts for him to be [[spoiler:turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program in which he has to bear ''twenty-four children'' to Crabbe’s and Goyle’s fathers, who think that BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception]], and forced to allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name and no family. Thus, it’s understandable why he is more than willing to [[spoiler:become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so that he can’t be raped or abused anymore]]. If that were not enough, [[spoiler:Narcissa]] says at one point that, [[spoiler:“All three of them [[[ParentalIncest Lucius]], Rabastan and Rodolphus] were far more interested in Draco than they ever were in [her] or Bellatrix.”]]

to:

* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: TheWoobie: A spell cast upon [[spoiler:Snape]] causes him to horribly torture [[spoiler:Draco Malfoy in the Slytherin common room]], in front of, among others, first year students. The timing is such that Memory Charms can’t be used on any of the kids. Regardless of the trauma, somehow [[spoiler:Draco]] lives, and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it’s just deserts for him to be [[spoiler:turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program in which he has to bear ''twenty-four children'' to Crabbe’s and Goyle’s fathers, who think that BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception]], and forced to allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name and no family. Thus, it’s understandable why he is more than willing to [[spoiler:become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so that he can’t be raped or abused anymore]]. If that were not enough, [[spoiler:Narcissa]] says at one point that, [[spoiler:“All three of them [[[ParentalIncest Lucius]], Rabastan and Rodolphus] were far more interested in Draco than they ever were in [her] or Bellatrix.”]]

Added: 199

Changed: 194

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: Dumbledore is way past this to the point of ridiculousness, apparently from long before the start of the story. Harry crosses it in Chapter 9, when he kills [[spoiler:Snape]] for the first time.

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: MoralEventHorizon:
**
Dumbledore is way past this to the point of ridiculousness, apparently from long before the start of the story. story.
**
Harry crosses it in Chapter 9, when he kills [[spoiler:Snape]] for the first time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Dementors are depicted as showing far less restraint than they do in canon, with one attempting to kiss Harry for no apparent reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Goblins are said to live off cruelty, to the point that they kidnap and torture human children to sate their desires to harm people.

Changed: 5090

Removed: 266

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cleanup.


* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Many readers think that Harry was corrupted by the bit of Voldemort's soul that got freed by the Dementor's kiss.
* ArcFatigue: The author interrupted his own narrative to dive into a series of side-plots and digressions that had ''absolutely nothing to do with the central story'', including time travel, the space race, and now a fight with vampires. Several of the story's reviewers have used the phrase "gone off the rails", while other reviewers have said things along the lines of "lost sight of the original plot" about the author.
** Most events of the story are never relevant or referenced again, meaning that ArcFatigue can set in very rapidly as the reader starts to see it as an unrelated series of vignettes.

to:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Many readers think that Harry was is corrupted by the bit of Voldemort's Voldemort’s soul that got gets freed by the Dementor's kiss.
Dementor’s Kiss.
* ArcFatigue: The author interrupted interrupts his own narrative to dive into a series of side-plots and digressions that had ''absolutely have absolutely nothing to do with the central story'', story, including time travel, the space race, and now a fight with vampires. Several of the story's story’s reviewers have used the phrase "gone “gone off the rails", rails”, while other reviewers have said things along claimed the lines of "lost author has “lost sight of the original plot" about the author.
plot”.
** Most events of in the story are never relevant or referenced again, meaning that ArcFatigue can set in very rapidly as the reader starts to see it the fanfic as an unrelated series of vignettes.



-->Every so often the entire Harry Potter universe offends me so deeply that I just have to react by folding, spindling and mutilating it.
* DesignatedHero: Harry. See also: MoralDissonance.
* DesignatedVillain: Dumbledore, whose list of crimes is so long as to be laughable. Same for Snape.
* FridgeBrilliance: Of ''course'' Harry's crossed the MoralEventHorizon (and then [[CrossesTheLineTwice circled around]] and crossed it again... and again... and again...), the whole story gets kicked off by him ''[[DrunkOnTheDarkSide absorbing a piece]] [[ThisIsYourBrainOnEvil of Voldemort's soul]]''. This would be much more interesting if the author appeared to realize it, though: See also TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot.
* FromBadToWorse: You can map the mental breakdown, both of the Fic and the author chapter by chapter. It’s as horrible at its sounds.
** From casual murder to mass brainwashing to people-are-property to very Hitlerian takes on racial types to ''nuking the Middle East because of Islam and not caring it initiates the collapse of human civilization''.
* MoralEventHorizon: Dumbledore is way past this apparently from the start to the point of ridiculousness. Harry crosses it in Chapter 9, when he kills Snape for the first time.
* NauseaFuel: [[spoiler:Snape's head exploding]] and the aftermath. In-universe, it makes Madame Pomfrey throw up; considering she's the school nurse, and has inevitably seen some gruesome and disgusting stuff, it really says something about how revolting it was.
* NightmareFuel: Chapter 9. [[spoiler: Snape tries Legilimency on Harry, only for Harry to rebound the effects on him, making him claw out his own eyes, breaking his mind, and finally making Snape's head explode, while he's screaming in complete agony the entire time. This is in front of a class full of third years.]]
* RonTheDeathEater: ''Like you wouldn't believe''.
** Ron gets off rather lightly compared to other characters Lionheart bashes, but he's portrayed as a self-centered, obnoxious boor who only pretended to be friends with Harry, partly because Dumbledore recruited him to do so, and partly for his own selfish reasons.

to:

-->Every -->“Every so often the entire Harry Potter universe offends me so deeply that I just have to react by folding, spindling and mutilating it.
it.”
* DesignatedHero: Harry. See also: MoralDissonance.
Harry, whose ProtagonistCenteredMorality is so extreme that it would most likely make ''Stalin'' terrified.
* DesignatedVillain: Dumbledore, whose list of crimes is so long as to be laughable. Same for Snape.
Snape may not have quite as big a rap sheet, but his own OffscreenVillainy and UndyingLoyalty to Dumbledore causes the same reaction.
* FridgeBrilliance: Of ''course'' Harry's crossed Harry crosses the MoralEventHorizon (and then [[CrossesTheLineTwice circled circles around]] and crossed it crosses again... and again... and again...), )— the whole story gets kicked off by him ''[[DrunkOnTheDarkSide absorbing a piece]] [[ThisIsYourBrainOnEvil of Voldemort's Voldemort’s soul]]''. This would be much more interesting if the author appeared to realize it, though: though. See also TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot.
* FromBadToWorse: You One can map the mental breakdown, breakdown both of the Fic story and the author chapter by chapter. It’s It is as horrible at its sounds.
** From
sounds. It goes from casual murder to mass brainwashing to people-are-property “people-are-property” to very Hitlerian takes on racial types to ''nuking [[spoiler:''nuking the Middle East because of Islam and not caring that it initiates the collapse of human civilization''.
civilization'']].
* MoralEventHorizon: Dumbledore is way past this to the point of ridiculousness, apparently from long before the start to of the point of ridiculousness. story. Harry crosses it in Chapter 9, when he kills Snape [[spoiler:Snape]] for the first time.
* NauseaFuel: [[spoiler:Snape's [[spoiler:Snape’s head exploding]] and the aftermath. In-universe, it makes Madame Pomfrey throw up; considering she's she’s the school nurse, and has inevitably seen some gruesome and disgusting stuff, it really says something about how revolting it was.
* NightmareFuel: Chapter 9. [[spoiler: Snape tries Legilimency on Harry, only for Harry to rebound the effects on at him, making him claw out his own eyes, breaking his mind, and finally making Snape's head explode, exploding his head, all while he's he’s screaming in complete agony the entire time. whole time.]] [[HarmfulToMinors This is in front of a class full of third years.year students.]]
* RonTheDeathEater: ''Like you wouldn't believe''.
wouldn’t believe:''
** Ron gets off rather lightly compared to other characters Lionheart bashes, doesn’t like, but he's he’s nonetheless portrayed as a self-centered, obnoxious boor who only pretended to be friends with Harry, partly because Dumbledore recruited him to do so, and partly for his own selfish reasons.



** The Department of Mysteries holds innocent people captive against their will, most notably Luna's grandmother Alice.
** But Dumbledore and Snape get it worst of all. Dumbledore is depicted as a self-serving sadist who deliberately arranged for Harry to be mistreated and secretly holds enormous influence over Magical Britain's government and society. Snape is depicted as Dumbledore's enthusiastic henchman who runs also uses Polyjuice Potion to run a child sex ring.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: The concept is fascinating and the story actually seems to play it out...but then you realize the author doesn't ''intend'' for Harry to be DrunkOnTheDarkSide and he really is supposed to be the hero and his morality really is supposed to white as the driven snow.
* VillainDecay: Voldemort and the Death Eaters, principal antagonists of the original books, are reduced to a mere sideshow of the overarching Dumbledore-versus-Harry conflict in this fic.
** Dumbledore is killed over a dozen times in the fic, in an extremely casual fashion each time. He's the big villain of the fic, but he never gives the impression he's remotely effective/competent or that he couldn't be disposed of more permanently with some minor effort.
* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: [[spoiler:A spell on Snape causes him to just decide to horribly torture Draco Malfoy in Slytherin common room, in front of, among others, 1st years. The timing on it is such that Oblivate can't be used on any of the kids. Regardless of the trauma of the mooks somehow Draco lives and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where he has to give birth to ''twenty-four children'', sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why he's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so he can't be raped or abused anymore.]]
** [[spoiler:also at one point Nacissa says "All three of them (Lucius, Rabastan and Rodolphus) were far more interested in Draco than they ever were in me or Bellatrix."]]

to:

** The Department of Mysteries holds innocent people captive against their will, most notably Luna's Luna’s grandmother Alice.
[[Literature/AlicesAdventuresInWonderland Alice]].
** But Dumbledore and Snape get it worst of all. Dumbledore is depicted as a self-serving sadist who deliberately arranged for Harry to be mistreated and secretly holds enormous influence over Magical Britain's the government and society. society of magical Britain, being ultimately responsible for ''all'' of its social ills. Snape is depicted as Dumbledore's Dumbledore’s enthusiastic henchman who runs also uses Polyjuice Potion to run a child sex ring.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: The concept is fascinating and the story actually seems to play it out... but then you realize the author doesn't ''intend'' doesn’t intend for Harry to be DrunkOnTheDarkSide DrunkOnTheDarkSide, and he really is supposed to be the hero hero, and his morality really is supposed to white as the driven snow.
* VillainDecay: VillainDecay:
**
Voldemort and the Death Eaters, principal antagonists of the original books, are reduced to a mere sideshow of the overarching Dumbledore-versus-Harry conflict in this fic.
** Dumbledore is killed over a dozen times in the fic, in an extremely casual fashion each time. He's He’s the big villain of the fic, story, but he never gives the impression he's he’s remotely effective/competent effective or competent, nor that he couldn't could not be disposed of more permanently with some minor effort.
* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: [[spoiler:A A spell on Snape cast upon [[spoiler:Snape]] causes him to just decide to horribly torture Draco [[spoiler:Draco Malfoy in the Slytherin common room, room]], in front of, among others, 1st years. first year students. The timing on it is such that Oblivate can't Memory Charms can’t be used on any of the kids. Regardless of the trauma of the mooks trauma, somehow Draco lives [[spoiler:Draco]] lives, and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's it’s just desserts deserts for Draco him to be turned [[spoiler:turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where in which he has to give birth to bear ''twenty-four children'', sired by Crabbe children'' to Crabbe’s and Goyle's fathers Goyle’s fathers, who think that BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, conception]], and forced to allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name or and no family. It's thus Thus, it’s understandable why he's he is more than willing to become [[spoiler:become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so that he can't can’t be raped or abused anymore.]]
** [[spoiler:also
anymore]]. If that were not enough, [[spoiler:Narcissa]] says at one point Nacissa says "All that, [[spoiler:“All three of them (Lucius, [[[ParentalIncest Lucius]], Rabastan and Rodolphus) Rodolphus] were far more interested in Draco than they ever were in me [her] or Bellatrix."]]
”]]

Added: 875

Changed: 53

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RonTheDeathEater: Dumbledore and Snape in particular.

to:

* RonTheDeathEater: ''Like you wouldn't believe''.
** Ron gets off rather lightly compared to other characters Lionheart bashes, but he's portrayed as a self-centered, obnoxious boor who only pretended to be friends with Harry, partly because Dumbledore recruited him to do so, and partly for his own selfish reasons.
** The Dursleys are treated as being far more abusive to Harry than they ever were in canon, giving him horrible injuries and starving him.
** The Department of Mysteries holds innocent people captive against their will, most notably Luna's grandmother Alice.
** But
Dumbledore and Snape in particular.get it worst of all. Dumbledore is depicted as a self-serving sadist who deliberately arranged for Harry to be mistreated and secretly holds enormous influence over Magical Britain's government and society. Snape is depicted as Dumbledore's enthusiastic henchman who runs also uses Polyjuice Potion to run a child sex ring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NauseaFuel: [[spoiler:Snape's head exploding]] and the aftermath. In-universe, it makes Madame Pomfrey throw up; considering she's the school nurse, and has inevitably seen some gruesome and disgusting stuff, it really says something about how revolting it was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Many readers think that Harry was corrupted by the bit of Voldemort's soul that got freed by the Dementor's kiss.

Changed: 4

Removed: 64

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed "Marty Stu", since it is now a Flame Bait example that should not be allowed; see "Flame Bait" page for more details.


* MartyStu: Harry Potter. Of the [[GodModeSue God Mode variety]]



* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: [[spoiler:A spell on Snape causes him to just decide to horribly torture Draco Malfoy in Slythiren common room, in front of, among others, 1st years. The timing on it is such that Oblivate can't be used on any of the kids. Regardless of the trauma of the mooks somehow Draco lives and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where he has to give birth to ''twenty-four children'', sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why he's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so he can't be raped or abused anymore.]]

to:

* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: [[spoiler:A spell on Snape causes him to just decide to horribly torture Draco Malfoy in Slythiren Slytherin common room, in front of, among others, 1st years. The timing on it is such that Oblivate can't be used on any of the kids. Regardless of the trauma of the mooks somehow Draco lives and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where he has to give birth to ''twenty-four children'', sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why he's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so he can't be raped or abused anymore.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeBrilliance: Of ''course'' Harry's crossed the MoralEventHorizon (and then [[CrossesTheLineTwice circled around]] and crossed it again... and again... and again...), the whole story gets kicked off by him ''[[DrunkOnTheDarkSide absorbing a piece]] [[ThisIsYourBrainOnEvil of Voldemort's soul]]''. This would be much more interesting if the author appeared to realize it, though.

to:

* FridgeBrilliance: Of ''course'' Harry's crossed the MoralEventHorizon (and then [[CrossesTheLineTwice circled around]] and crossed it again... and again... and again...), the whole story gets kicked off by him ''[[DrunkOnTheDarkSide absorbing a piece]] [[ThisIsYourBrainOnEvil of Voldemort's soul]]''. This would be much more interesting if the author appeared to realize it, though.though: See also TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot.



* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlotTheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: The concept is fascinating and the story actually seems to play it out...but then you realize the author doesn't ''intend'' for Harry to be DrunkOnTheDarkSide and he really is supposed to be the hero and his morality really is supposed to white as the driven snow.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeBrilliance: Of ''course'' Harry's crossed the MoralEventHorizon (and then [[CrossesTheLineTwice circled around]] and crossed it again... and again... and again...), the whole story gets kicked off by him ''[[DrunkOnTheDarkSide absorbing a piece]] [[ThisIsYourBrainOnEvil of Voldemort's soul]]''.

to:

* FridgeBrilliance: Of ''course'' Harry's crossed the MoralEventHorizon (and then [[CrossesTheLineTwice circled around]] and crossed it again... and again... and again...), the whole story gets kicked off by him ''[[DrunkOnTheDarkSide absorbing a piece]] [[ThisIsYourBrainOnEvil of Voldemort's soul]]''. This would be much more interesting if the author appeared to realize it, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** From casual murder to mass brainwashing to people-are-property to very Hitlerian takes on racial types to ''nuking the Middle East because of Islam''.

to:

** From casual murder to mass brainwashing to people-are-property to very Hitlerian takes on racial types to ''nuking the Middle East because of Islam''.Islam and not caring it initiates the collapse of human civilization''.

Added: 336

Changed: 565

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Most events of the story are never relevant or referenced again, meaning that ArcFatigue can set in very rapidly as the reader starts to see it as an unrelated series of vignettes.



** From casual murder to mass brainwashing to people-are-property to very Hitlerian takes on racial types to ''nuking the Middle East because of Islam''.



** In fairness, the fic starts with Harry absorbing all of Voldemort's memories, thus being able to (for one) take out all but the missing one of his horcruxes offscreen, and Dumbledore is able to destroy him effortlessly in a fight and is a consummate PuppetMaster--so his marginalization makes some story sense given his huge disadvantages to both the other parties.

to:

** In fairness, the fic starts with Harry absorbing all of Voldemort's memories, thus being able to (for one) take out all but the missing one of his horcruxes offscreen, and Dumbledore is able to destroy him effortlessly killed over a dozen times in a fight and is a consummate PuppetMaster--so his marginalization makes the fic, in an extremely casual fashion each time. He's the big villain of the fic, but he never gives the impression he's remotely effective/competent or that he couldn't be disposed of more permanently with some story sense given his huge disadvantages to both the other parties.minor effort.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Please come here to argue for any qualifiers


* CompleteMonster: Dumbledore is made into this, but eventually his crimes become so many and so laughable he [[JumpingTheShark jumps the shark]]. Due to the sheer amount of MoralDissonance, though, a good number of readers consider ''Harry'' to be this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[spoiler:**also at one point Nacissa says "All three of them (Lucius, Rabastan and Rodolphus) were far more interested in Draco than they ever were in me or Bellatrix."]]

to:

[[spoiler:**also ** [[spoiler:also at one point Nacissa says "All three of them (Lucius, Rabastan and Rodolphus) were far more interested in Draco than they ever were in me or Bellatrix."]]

Added: 556

Changed: 188

Removed: 368

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VillainDecay: Voldemort and the Death Eaters, principal antagonists of the original books, are reduced to a mere sideshow of the overarching Dumbledore-versus-Harry conflict in this fic.
** In fairness, the fic starts with Harry absorbing all of Voldemort's memories, thus being able to (for one) take out all but the missing one of his horcruxes offscreen, and Dumbledore is able to destroy him effortlessly in a fight and is a consummate PuppetMaster--so his marginalization makes some story sense given his huge disadvantages to both the other parties.



* VillainDecay: Voldemort and the Death Eaters, principal antagonists of the original books, are reduced to a mere sideshow of the overarching Dumbledore-versus-Harry conflict in this fic.
** In fairness, the fic starts with Harry absorbing all of Voldemort's memories, thus being able to (for one) take out all but the missing one of his horcruxes offscreen, and Dumbledore is able to destroy him effortlessly in a fight and is a consummate PuppetMaster--so his marginalization makes some story sense given his huge disadvantages to both the other parties.

to:

* VillainDecay: Voldemort and the Death Eaters, principal antagonists of the original books, are reduced to a mere sideshow of the overarching Dumbledore-versus-Harry conflict in this fic.
** In fairness, the fic starts with Harry absorbing all of Voldemort's memories, thus being able to (for one) take out all but the missing one of his horcruxes offscreen, and Dumbledore is able to destroy him effortlessly in a fight and is a consummate PuppetMaster--so his marginalization makes some story sense given his huge disadvantages to both the other parties.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----



** In fairness, the fic starts with Harry absorbing all of Voldemort's memories, thus being able to (for one) take out all but the missing one of his horcruxes offscreen, and Dumbledore is able to destroy him effortlessly in a fight and is a consummate PuppetMaster--so his marginalization makes some story sense given his huge disadvantages to both the other parties.

to:

** In fairness, the fic starts with Harry absorbing all of Voldemort's memories, thus being able to (for one) take out all but the missing one of his horcruxes offscreen, and Dumbledore is able to destroy him effortlessly in a fight and is a consummate PuppetMaster--so his marginalization makes some story sense given his huge disadvantages to both the other parties.parties.

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CanonDefilement: Probably intentional, given the header to chapter one.
-->Every so often the entire Harry Potter universe offends me so deeply that I just have to react by folding, spindling and mutilating it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That\'s not Alternate Character Interpretation, that\'s plain contradicting with canon.


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Dumbledore is a CompleteMonster, Snape is a lesser monster and a magical pimp, Ron is just shy of being brain dead, etc.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FridgeBrilliance: Of ''course'' Harry's crossed the MoralEventHorizon (and then [[CrossesTheLineTwice circled around]] and crossed it again... and again... and again...), the whole story gets kicked off by him ''[[DrunkOnTheDarkSide absorbing a piece]] [[ThisIsYourBrainOnEvil of Voldemort's soul]]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: [[spoiler:A spell on Snape causes him to just decide to horribly torture Draco Malfoy in Slythiren common room, in front of, among others, 1st years. The timing on it is such that Oblivate can't be used on any of the kids. Regardless of the trauma of the mooks somehow Draco lives and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where he has to give birth to ''twenty-four children'', sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why he's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so he can't be raped or abused anymore.
** also at one point Nacissa says "All three of them (Lucius, Rabastan and Rodolphus) were far more interested in Draco than they ever were in me or Bellatrix."]]

to:

* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: [[spoiler:A spell on Snape causes him to just decide to horribly torture Draco Malfoy in Slythiren common room, in front of, among others, 1st years. The timing on it is such that Oblivate can't be used on any of the kids. Regardless of the trauma of the mooks somehow Draco lives and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where he has to give birth to ''twenty-four children'', sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why he's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so he can't be raped or abused anymore.
** also
anymore.]]
[[spoiler:**also
at one point Nacissa says "All three of them (Lucius, Rabastan and Rodolphus) were far more interested in Draco than they ever were in me or Bellatrix."]]

Added: 161

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: [[spoiler:A spell on Snape causes him to just decide to horribly torture Draco Malfoy in Slythiren common room, in front of, among others, 1st years. The timing on it is such that Oblivate can't be used on any of the kids. Regardless of the trauma of the mooks somehow Draco lives and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where he has to give birth to ''twenty-four children'', sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why he's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so he can't be raped or abused anymore.]]

to:

* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: [[spoiler:A spell on Snape causes him to just decide to horribly torture Draco Malfoy in Slythiren common room, in front of, among others, 1st years. The timing on it is such that Oblivate can't be used on any of the kids. Regardless of the trauma of the mooks somehow Draco lives and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where he has to give birth to ''twenty-four children'', sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why he's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so he can't be raped or abused anymore.]]anymore.
**also at one point Nacissa says "All three of them (Lucius, Rabastan and Rodolphus) were far more interested in Draco than they ever were in me or Bellatrix."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: [[spoiler:A spell on Snape causes him to just decide to horribly torture Draco Malfoy in Slythiren common room, in front of, among others, 1st years. The timing on it is such that Oblivate can't be used on any of the kids. Regardless of the trauma of the mooks somehow Draco lives and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where he has to give birth to TWENTY-FOUR CHILDREN, sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why he's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so he can't be raped or abused anymore.]]

to:

* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: [[spoiler:A spell on Snape causes him to just decide to horribly torture torture Draco Malfoy in Slythiren common room, in front of, among others, 1st years. years. The timing on it is such that Oblivate can't be used on any of the kids. kids. Regardless of the trauma of the mooks somehow Draco lives and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where he has to give birth to TWENTY-FOUR CHILDREN, ''twenty-four children'', sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why he's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so he can't be raped or abused anymore.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: [[spoiler:Draco/a Malfoy. Apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where he has to give birth to TWENTY-FOUR CHILDREN, sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why he's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so he can't be raped or abused anymore.]]

to:

* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: [[spoiler:Draco/a Malfoy. Apparently [[spoiler:A spell on Snape causes him to just decide to horribly torture Draco Malfoy in Slythiren common room, in front of, among others, 1st years. The timing on it is such that Oblivate can't be used on any of the kids. Regardless of the trauma of the mooks somehow Draco lives and apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where he has to give birth to TWENTY-FOUR CHILDREN, sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations he has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why he's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so he can't be raped or abused anymore.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: Draco/a Malfoy. Apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where she has to give birth to TWENTY-FOUR CHILDREN, sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse her repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations she has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why she's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so she can't be raped or abused anymore.

to:

* TheWoobie[=/=]UnintentionallySympathetic: Draco/a [[spoiler:Draco/a Malfoy. Apparently Perfect Lionheart thinks it's just desserts for Draco to be turned into a woman, forced into a breeding program where she he has to give birth to TWENTY-FOUR CHILDREN, sired by Crabbe and Goyle's fathers who think BEATING THEIR WIVES ensures conception, and allow the other Purebloods to torture and abuse her him repeatedly because thanks to Harry's machinations she he has no title, no money, no last name or family. It's thus understandable why she's he's more than willing to become a fanatical killer like Bellatrix to escape the breeding contracts so she he can't be raped or abused anymore.]]

Added: 319

Removed: 329

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rename


* HighOctaneNightmareFuel: Chapter 9. [[spoiler: Snape tries Legilimency on Harry, only for Harry to rebound the effects on him, making him claw out his own eyes, breaking his mind, and finally making Snape's head explode, while he's screaming in complete agony the entire time. This is in front of a class full of third years.]]


Added DiffLines:

* NightmareFuel: Chapter 9. [[spoiler: Snape tries Legilimency on Harry, only for Harry to rebound the effects on him, making him claw out his own eyes, breaking his mind, and finally making Snape's head explode, while he's screaming in complete agony the entire time. This is in front of a class full of third years.]]

Added: 134

Removed: 130

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* FromBadToWorse: You can map the mental breakdown, both of the Fic and the author chapter by chapter. It’s as horrible at its sounds.



* ItGotWorse: You can map the mental breakdown, both of the Fic and the author chapter by chapter. It’s as horrible at its sounds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Well, Dumbledore *is* very powerful and evil. It\'s not like there are many other options.


* MoralEventHorizon: Dumbledore is way past this apparently from the start to the point of ridiculousness. Harry crosses it in Chapter 9, when he kills Snape for the first time. By the latest chapters, Harry is so far over the MoralEventHorizon he can't see it with a telescope.

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: Dumbledore is way past this apparently from the start to the point of ridiculousness. Harry crosses it in Chapter 9, when he kills Snape for the first time. By the latest chapters, Harry is so far over the MoralEventHorizon he can't see it with a telescope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Yes, it has.


* ArcFatigue: The author interrupted his own narrative to dive into a series of side-plots and digressions that had ''absolutely nothing to do with the central story'', including time travel, the space race, and now a fight with vampires. Several of the story's reviewers have used the phrase "gone off the rails", while other reviewers have said things along the lines of "lost sight of the original plot" about the author. With all this digression, the story is now ninety-plus chapters long, and ''still'' hasn't returned to the original plot, which was the overthrow of the Dark Lord Dumbledore.

to:

* ArcFatigue: The author interrupted his own narrative to dive into a series of side-plots and digressions that had ''absolutely nothing to do with the central story'', including time travel, the space race, and now a fight with vampires. Several of the story's reviewers have used the phrase "gone off the rails", while other reviewers have said things along the lines of "lost sight of the original plot" about the author. With all this digression, the story is now ninety-plus chapters long, and ''still'' hasn't returned to the original plot, which was the overthrow of the Dark Lord Dumbledore.

Top