History YMMV / EverAfterHigh

** [[ShippingGoggles Is Darling actually Apple's 'prince']] or did the curse undo itself because of the CPR?

* UncannyValley: Cedar's dolls normally suggest her puppet heritage with her lipstick, but her 2016 "total puppet" SDCC doll gives her wide eyes and a functional dummy-style jaw, which is much creepier than it probably should be. The donkey ears and long nose don't really help matters, either. There appears to be a slightly broken base between fans who love the doll and appreciate all the references to the original Pinocchio story, and those who think it's simply creepy. Since Cedar's situation is presented as a ''bad'' thing, it's possible that the uncanniness is intentional.

* FoeYay: One of the more popular pairings in the PeripheryDemographic is Apple/Raven, with their clashing viewpoints sometimes being considered to resemble BelligerentSexualTension. Helped by neither Raven nor Apple actually hating the other (and both have in fact claimed to love the other), with nearly all of their conflict stemming from trying to get the other to see their point of view.

* AccidentalInnuendo: Alistair and Bunny's relationship could give "go down the rabbit hole" a much filthier interpretation.

* MemeticLoser: Dexter gets this a ''lot''.

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: Some had this reaction to the new theme song.

** The fans' reaction to the little screen time Cerise has.
** Many have expressed a desire to see Dexter struggle with trying to be a hero, as it is mostly an InformedFlaw.

* Moe: Almost all of the female characters (especially the Royals). [[AllLovingHero Apple]], [[FriendToAllLivingThings Ashlynn]], [[HairOfGoldHeartOfGold Blondie]] and [[BunniesForCuteness Bunny]] in particular are seen as especially huggable. The fandom takes Ashlynn's moe and ''runs with it''.

* CrossoverShip: Several with characters from ''Toys/MonsterHigh'', predictably enough.

** Apple White has quickly become a Base-Breaking Character. For some fans she is an adorable, sweet and kind character who genuinely cares about her fellows, including her designated enemy Raven Queen; for other, she is a rather selfish and annoying spoiled brat and a less interesting and more bland character compared with Raven. Also many fans are divided on whether she's a ParodySue or a played-straight Purity Sue.

** Because of fans love of having Daring become the Beast, shipping him with Rosabella has become popular. This creates issues with Daring/Apple shippers.

** Despite the fact that they are pretty much in a HappilyArrangedMarriage, most fans don't seem to support Daring/Apple, since the majority of fans ship them with others. It doesn't help that they barely interact and have a lot more ShipTease with others. And now there's the fact that [[spoiler: Daring wasn't Apple's Prince Charming in the first place, as his kiss wasn't able to wake her up after biting on a poison apple.]]

* CatharsisFactor: Considering Apple seems to get away with being with being selfish, fans finally rejoiced in ''Dragon Games'' when Raven angrily calls Apple out for being selfish (and she can only retort with "At least my mom will be proud of me") and again, and this time it's a "TheReasonYouSuck"Speech that gives Apple a DespairEventHorizon.

* CatharsisFactor: Considering Apple seems to get away with being with being selfish, fans finally rejoiced in ''Dragon Games'' when Raven angrily calls Apple out for being selfish (and she can only retort with 'Atleast my mom will be proud of me') and again, and this time it's a "TheReasonYouSuck"Speech that gives Apple a DespairEventHorizon.

* CatharsisFactor: Considering Apple seems to get away with being with being selfish, fans finally rejoiced in ''Dragon Games'' when Raven angrily calls Apple out for being selfish (and she can only retort with 'Atleast my mom will be proud of me') and again, and this time it's a "TheReasonYouSuck"Speech that gives Apple a MoralEventHorizon.

* UncannyValley: Cedar's dolls normally suggest her puppet heritage with her lipstick, but her 2016 "total puppet" SDCC doll gives her wide eyes and a functional dummy-style jaw, which is much creepier than it probably should be. The donkey ears and long nose don't really help matters, either. There appears to be a slightly broken base between fans who love the doll and appreciate all the references to the original Pinocchio story, and those who think it's simply creepy. Since Cedar's situation is presented as a ''bad'' thing, it's possible that the uncanniness is intentional.

* CatharsisFactor: Considering Apple seems to get away with being with being selfish, fans finally rejoiced in ''Dragon Games'' when Raven angrily calls Apple out for being selfish (and she can only retort with 'Atleast my mom will be proud of me') and again, and this time it's a "The Reason You Suck" Speech that gives Apple a Moral Event Horizon.

** Raven's mother, the Evil Queen, was sealed inside her own magic mirror after her story ended. This may have come from ''[[Disney/SnowWhiteAndTheSevenDwarfs Fairest of All]]'', which shows the same thing befalling the movie's Grimhilde.

* FollowTheLeader: Disney Parks released a line of "Attractionistas" dolls as souvenirs from some of their popular rides. The Mad Tea Party ride got [[http://cdn.s7.disneystore.com/is/image/DisneyShopping/7512055890014?$yetidetail$ "Maddie"]], who has teal and purple hair, a teacup-and-saucer hat, and a polka-dot theme. Sound familiar?

* HolyShitQuotient:
** ''Thronecoming'', first we have the meta of the studio making a 45-minute episode when the longest webisode before that was barely ten minutes. Then all the revelations:[[spoiler: ''The Book of Legends'' is a fake and has been since Raven's mother hid the real one in Ashlynn and Briar's room in her high school days, meaning no one has actually signed the thing.]] Apple is really worried that Raven and others denying their destiny and not signing the book will mean everyone she loves will go poof, Raven included. If proof of a bad outcome from not signing the book presents itself, Raven will sign it. Briar is terrified of her destiny because it will mean the loss of all her friends, which prompts her to unbelievable actions, and that's just the tip of the ice berg.
** ''Way Too Wonderland'' has [[spoiler: Raven signing the book and gaining her mother's dark powers so she can beat the bad guy, then using her new powers to lift the curse her mother cast on Wonderland and to give everyone power over their own destiny by destroying the Book of Legends. And Apple decides to support Raven and Briar and the Rebels who want to choose their destiny even though she still wants to follow hers.]]
** In ''Dragon Games'', [[spoiler: Apple frees the Evil Queen! We meet Snow White! Raven almost (unwillingly) joins her mom! Apple is cursed! Daring is not Apple's prince after all, instead Darling is her prince!]]

* [[HoYay Les Yay]]: Has its own [[HoYay/EverAfterHigh page]].

* OddNameOut: Milton and Giles are a set of brothers, surnamed Grimm. This is unique in a cast named after characters, not authors.

** Much like it's sister series, the massive amount of puns is either unbearable or part of the shows charm.

** ''Thronecoming'' then causes the reverse when Daring/Cerise gets teased, as Lizzie/Daring had become popular by time of it's release.

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Apple White: a PoliticallyActivePrincess who only wants what's best for everyone, or a petty manipulative RichBitch who's obsessed with the status quo and will do anything to get her HappilyEverAfter? Your opinion sees to vary based on which side you agree with. To some people, Apple is a perfectionist who believes everything must be done in a single way, or everything in the universe gets thrown into chaos.

* RonTheDeathEater: Apple White has an odd tendency to get the short end of the stick in fanworks. She gets turned into an AlphaBitch, BrainlessBeauty, and DumbBlonde, despite being a ''subversion'' of those tropes. She's a FriendlyEnemy to Raven, a GracefulLoser, and is shown to be a straight A-student with plenty of book smarts. At most, she's a LovableAlphaBitch due to her obliviousness and self-centeredness. One example is the DarkFic ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/11958992/1/A-Deep-Depression A Deep Depression]]'', where Apple and the other Royals (including Maddie and Dexter) brutally bully Raven to the point of her being DrivenToSuicide.