History YMMV / EdEddnEddy

*** Eddy ripping her mouth off her face in the bizarro "One + One = Ed" episode is also satisfying for viewers irritated by her constant yelling.

** Any time Sarah gets her comeuppance is unbelievably satisfying. Especially in "Little Ed Blue" when she's left terrified at Ed yelling at her.

** Marie -- she has a much larger fanbase than any other Kanker, and possibly, any other female character in the show, probably because she dresses like a punk rocker and she gets some memorably snarky one-liners towards her sister's antics.

** In "[[Recap/EdEddNEddyS2E5EenyMeenyMineyEd Eeny Meeny Miney Ed]]", Eddy tricks Ed into thinking Double D is an alien. A few years after this episode, [[Creator/SamuelVincent Double D's voice actor]] would play an extra terrestrial in [[WesternAnimation/MartinMystery another show]].
** In ''[[Recap/EdEddNEddyS4E22HeresMudInYourEd Here's Mud In Your Ed]]'', Eddy tricks Jimmy with a Smileyville scam, which promises numerous attractions with a colorfully drawn out map - with the actual "Smileyville" being a trashy alley with none of the promised attractions. Just a little over twenty years later, the ''Theatre/WillysChocolateExperience'' in Glasgow used a similar method of scamming unsuspecting parents (a website full of AI generated images promising colorful attractions) and the actual experience ended up featuring none of that.

* JerksAreWorseThanVillains: This is the usual sentiment towards Kevin and especially Sarah due to their mean-spiritedness towards the title characters, and both are the most vocal haters of the Eds and their antics. Meanwhile, the Kanker sisters are the closest thing to the recurring villains (until the movie), as they stalk, bully, and physically harass the Eds and everyone else ForTheEvulz, but they get much less hate than Kevin and Sarah; in fact, out of the Kankers, Marie and [[HiddenHeartOfGold May]] are [[EnsembleDarkhorse particularly popular]], and fans are generally more forgiving to the Kankers because they actually like the Eds and torment them in a LovingBully way (instead of just hating them like Kevin and Sarah do).

* JerksAreWorseThanVillains: This is the usual sentiment towards Kevin and Sarah due to their mean-spiritedness towards the title characters, and both are the most vocal haters of the Eds and their antics. Meanwhile, the Kanker sisters are the closest thing to the recurring villains (until the movie), as they stalk, bully, and physically harass the Eds and everyone else ForTheEvulz, but they get much less hate than Kevin and Sarah; in fact, out of the Kankers, Marie and [[HiddenHeartOfGold May]] are [[EnsembleDarkhorse particularly popular]], and fans are generally more forgiving to the Kankers because they actually like the Eds and torment them in a LovingBully way (instead of just hating them like Kevin and Sarah do).

** Some argue the rot started to begin as early as late season 3 and season 4. While there are still a lot of great and iconic episodes in them, it was also when the humor of the show started to become more [[SadistShow actively malicious]] towards the title characters, with Ed and Double D suffering repercussions for things they had no part in and even Eddy suffering DisproportionateRetribution for some of his more minor scams. The most infamous examples from these seasons are "[[Recap/EdEddNEddyS3E23IfItSmellsLikeAnEd If It Smells Like An Ed]]" and "[[Recap/EdEddNEddyS4E13YourEdHere Your Ed Here]]", which are single-handedly responsible for turning Jimmy and Kevin into TheScrappy for many, respectively. This was also around the time the characters started to become more {{flanderiz|ation}}ed, and the Eds (especially Eddy) started to lose more of their redeeming qualities.

* ValuesDissonance: Some of the characters' behaviors (particularly in the first few seasons) can be rather difficult to [[PlayedForLaughs play for laughs]] in an age where the long-term effects of bullying are taken much more seriously, especially since these characters can be seen as [[KidsAreCruel harmful stereotypes of children]].