Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / BrownsPineRidgeStories

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* AluminumChristmasTrees: The "Brazier" mentioned in "The Race" would likely be mistaken by some readers as a [[BrandX made up restaurant]] for the story, but it does exist. Most readers, particularly those born 1990 and after, would recognize it as [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dairy_Queen#Dairy_Queen_Brazier Dairy Queen]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Tastes Like Diabetes is now a disambig between Sweetness Aversion and Sickingly Sweet. Zero Context Example entries and entries that do not fit anywhere else will be deleted.


* TastesLikeDiabetes: The ninth ("A Rose for Miss Winnie") and thirteenth ("Love and a Red Wagon") stories seem to be written for this effect.

Removed: 333

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse.


* HarsherInHindsight: A prior version of the main page jokingly, though intended to be ribbing in an [[AffectionateParody an affectionate way]], referred to the first book as being SnarkBait. In light of certain personal difficulties (which will be withheld for privacy reasons), the original author didn't find it as being humorous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* HarsherInHindsight: A prior version of the main page jokingly, though intended to be ribbing in an [[AffectionateParody an affectionate way]], referred to the first book as being SnarkBait. In light of certain personal difficulties (which will be withheld for privacy reasons), the original author [[DudeNotFunny didn't find it as being humorous]].

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: A prior version of the main page jokingly, though intended to be ribbing in an [[AffectionateParody an affectionate way]], referred to the first book as being SnarkBait. In light of certain personal difficulties (which will be withheld for privacy reasons), the original author [[DudeNotFunny didn't find it as being humorous]].humorous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HarsherInHindsight: A prior version of the main page jokingly, though intended to be ribbing in an [[AffectionateParody an affectionate way]], referred to the first book as being SnarkBait. In light of certain personal difficulties (which will be withheld for privacy reasons), the original author [[DudeNotFunny didn't find it as being humorous]].

Changed: 2429

Removed: 714

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moved to the Headscratchers subpage


** The Joyriders from the fourth story ("The Strawberry Cow") can easily be the subject of this. Were they Jerkasses who committed their actions out of some sort of mean-spirited sense of entertainment as the author believes or were they [[GoodOlBoy Good Ol' Boys]] in a case of drunken-induced OneCrazyNight that got out of hand who otherwise wouldn't have been involved in such an incident while sober?-JesseMB27

to:

** The Joyriders from the fourth story ("The Strawberry Cow") can easily be the subject of this. Were they Jerkasses who committed their actions out of some sort of mean-spirited sense of entertainment as the author believes or were they [[GoodOlBoy Good Ol' Boys]] in a case of drunken-induced OneCrazyNight that got out of hand who otherwise wouldn't have been involved in such an incident while sober?-JesseMB27sober?



* DesignatedVillain: The Joyriders. While what they did (drinking, driving, and firing firearms at the same time) was certainly irresponsible [[spoiler: and eventually brought about their own deaths]], but the lack of details regarding their reasons for [[spoiler: killing Ole Strawberry]] fails to give a sufficient reason to regard them as evil.-JesseMB27
* {{Headscratchers}}: In the eleventh story, why is Gary taking cookies that neither belonged to him in the first place nor asked for permission to have? And no it isn't simply a case of him being a [[{{Delinquents}} Delinquent]] due to him showing a fear of being punished for being caught later in the same chapter. Unless he is trying to portray himself as a RuleAbidingRebel of somesort, there is no explanation provided for this OutOfCharacterMoment.-JesseMB27
* HilariousInHindsight: In the Twelfth chapter, the author refers to his car as "Franchise/MyLittlePony" without any knowledge of the aforementioned franchise nor its [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic certain well known recent adaption]]. Granted, while Brown's Pine Ridge Stories was published in May 2014, but the author alleges to have used the quoted phrase in 1969, thirteen years before Hasbro even created the MLP series.-JesseMB27
* {{Squick}}: In "Paying Attention", Gary seeks to get the attention of a young girl of his same age by performing a stunt. This would likely attract reactions of "Aww" at first, but it is then revealed that the girl, whom the author had met for the first time that day, [[spoiler: was a cousin of his]]... Oops.-JesseMB27
* TastesLikeDiabetes: The ninth ("A Rose for Miss Winnie") and thirteenth ("Love and a Red Wagon") stories seem to be written for this effect.-JesseMB27
* ValuesDissonance: One can probably tell from reading the fifteenth story ("A Tragedy and a Miracle") that Georgians (and for that matter Southerners in general) prior to the 1960s failed to provide adequate, if any, day care as shown by the fact that Mrs. Dollar had to take care of her infant grandchild while at work as a Cafeteria lady. Now while it should be noted that the account is set in 1937, when the Great Depression was ongoing and thus many people didn't have the funds for Child daycare facilities for working-parents, but even then the fact that working-class people's children aren't seen as being as worth cared for so that other working relatives can focus on their jobs still stands.-JesseMB27

to:

* DesignatedVillain: The Joyriders. While what they did (drinking, driving, and firing firearms at the same time) was certainly irresponsible [[spoiler: and eventually brought about their own deaths]], but the lack of details regarding their reasons for [[spoiler: killing Ole Strawberry]] fails to give a sufficient reason to regard them as evil.-JesseMB27
* {{Headscratchers}}: In the eleventh story, why is Gary taking cookies that neither belonged to him in the first place nor asked for permission to have? And no it isn't simply a case of him being a [[{{Delinquents}} Delinquent]] due to him showing a fear of being punished for being caught later in the same chapter. Unless he is trying to portray himself as a RuleAbidingRebel of somesort, there is no explanation provided for this OutOfCharacterMoment.-JesseMB27
evil.
* HilariousInHindsight: In the Twelfth chapter, the author refers to his car as "Franchise/MyLittlePony" without any knowledge of the aforementioned franchise nor its [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic certain well known recent adaption]]. Granted, while Brown's Pine Ridge Stories was published in May 2014, but the author alleges to have used the quoted phrase in 1969, thirteen years before Hasbro even created the MLP series.-JesseMB27
series.
* {{Squick}}: In "Paying Attention", Gary seeks to get the attention of a young girl of his same age by performing a stunt. This would likely attract reactions of "Aww" at first, but it is then revealed that the girl, whom the author had met for the first time that day, [[spoiler: was a cousin of his]]... Oops.-JesseMB27
Oops.
* TastesLikeDiabetes: The ninth ("A Rose for Miss Winnie") and thirteenth ("Love and a Red Wagon") stories seem to be written for this effect.-JesseMB27
effect.
* ValuesDissonance: One can probably tell from reading the fifteenth story ("A Tragedy and a Miracle") that Georgians (and for that matter Southerners in general) prior to the 1960s failed to provide adequate, if any, day care as shown by the fact that Mrs. Dollar had to take care of her infant grandchild while at work as a Cafeteria lady. Now while it should be noted that the account is set in 1937, when the Great Depression was ongoing and thus many people didn't have the funds for Child daycare facilities for working-parents, but even then the fact that working-class people's children aren't seen as being as worth cared for so that other working relatives can focus on their jobs still stands.-JesseMB27
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That's not how this wiki works.


Until other individuals begin to contribute to this page, my posts will be marked with my signature.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HilariousInHindsight: In the Twelfth chapter, the author refers to his car as "Franchise/MyLittlePony" without any knowledge of the aforementioned franchise nor its [[MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic certain well known recent adaption]]. Granted, while Brown's Pine Ridge Stories was published in May 2014, but the author alleges to have used the quoted phrase in 1969, thirteen years before Hasbro even created the MLP series.-JesseMB27

to:

* HilariousInHindsight: In the Twelfth chapter, the author refers to his car as "Franchise/MyLittlePony" without any knowledge of the aforementioned franchise nor its [[MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic certain well known recent adaption]]. Granted, while Brown's Pine Ridge Stories was published in May 2014, but the author alleges to have used the quoted phrase in 1969, thirteen years before Hasbro even created the MLP series.-JesseMB27
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not YMMV


* BrokenAesop: The one at the end of "Starliner" ("Never give up and maybe the ugly ducklings you're expecting will become beautiful swans.") could arguably be one. Gary is dreading over the prospect of a Dodge Dart he disliked being the one his father would buy, but then arrives with a [[CoolCar Ford Starliner]] instead. No where in the story does it involve any action on the part of Gary himself to change an unenviable outcome. It would be hoped that it was intended as a SpoofAesop and not one [[{{Narm}} meant to be taken seriously]].-JesseMB27
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ValuesDissonance: One can probably tell from reading the fifteenth story ("A Tragedy and a Miracle") that Georgians (and for that matter [[DeepSouth Southerners]] in general) prior to the 1960s failed to provide adequate, if any, Day care as shown by the fact that Mrs. Dollar had to take care of her grandchild while at work as a Cafeteria lady.-JesseMB27

to:

* ValuesDissonance: One can probably tell from reading the fifteenth story ("A Tragedy and a Miracle") that Georgians (and for that matter [[DeepSouth Southerners]] Southerners in general) prior to the 1960s failed to provide adequate, if any, Day day care as shown by the fact that Mrs. Dollar had to take care of her infant grandchild while at work as a Cafeteria lady.lady. Now while it should be noted that the account is set in 1937, when the Great Depression was ongoing and thus many people didn't have the funds for Child daycare facilities for working-parents, but even then the fact that working-class people's children aren't seen as being as worth cared for so that other working relatives can focus on their jobs still stands.-JesseMB27
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
unfortunate implications need citations


* UnfortunateImplications: The author seems to suggest that only blood relatives are capable of showing concern for children in saying of a an elderly woman that he "assumed this child was her grandchild, because of the age difference, but I knew this wasn't a case of a babysitter caring for a child, because of the gentle loving way she cared for this child."-JesseMB27
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ValuesDissonance: One can probably tell from reading the fifteenth story ("A Tragedy and a Miracle") that Georgians (and for that matter [[DeepSouth Southerners]] in general) prior to the 1960s failed to provide adequate, if any, Day care as shown by the fact that Mrs. Dollar had to take care of her grandchild while at work as a Cafeteria lady.-JesseMB27

to:

* ValuesDissonance: One can probably tell from reading the fifteenth story ("A Tragedy and a Miracle") that Georgians (and for that matter [[DeepSouth Southerners]] in general) prior to the 1960s failed to provide adequate, if any, Day care as shown by the fact that Mrs. Dollar had to take care of her grandchild while at work as a Cafeteria lady.-JesseMB27-JesseMB27
* TheWoobie: Gary Brown presents himself as this at the end of "The Train at Jay Bird".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenAesop: The one at the end of "Starliner" ("Never give up and maybe the ugly ducklings you're expecting will become beautiful swans.") could arguably be one. Gary is dreading over the prospect of a Dodge he disliked being the one his father would, but then arrives with a [[CoolCar Ford Starliner]] instead. No where in the story does it involve any action on the part of Gary himself to change an unenviable outcome. It would be hoped that it was intended as a SpoofAesop and not one [[{{Narm}} meant to be taken seriously]].-JesseMB27

to:

* BrokenAesop: The one at the end of "Starliner" ("Never give up and maybe the ugly ducklings you're expecting will become beautiful swans.") could arguably be one. Gary is dreading over the prospect of a Dodge Dart he disliked being the one his father would, would buy, but then arrives with a [[CoolCar Ford Starliner]] instead. No where in the story does it involve any action on the part of Gary himself to change an unenviable outcome. It would be hoped that it was intended as a SpoofAesop and not one [[{{Narm}} meant to be taken seriously]].-JesseMB27

Added: 673

Changed: 411

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: The Joyriders from the fourth story ("The Strawberry Cow") can easily be the subject of this. Were they Jerkasses who committed their actions out of some sort of mean-spirited sense of entertainment as the author believes or were they [[GoodOlBoy Good Ol' Boys]] in a case of drunken-induced OneCrazyNight that got out of hand who otherwise wouldn't have been involved in such an incident while sober?-JesseMB27

to:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: AlternativeCharacterInterpretation:
**
The Joyriders from the fourth story ("The Strawberry Cow") can easily be the subject of this. Were they Jerkasses who committed their actions out of some sort of mean-spirited sense of entertainment as the author believes or were they [[GoodOlBoy Good Ol' Boys]] in a case of drunken-induced OneCrazyNight that got out of hand who otherwise wouldn't have been involved in such an incident while sober?-JesseMB27sober?-JesseMB27
** The Unnamed woman who is mentioned in the thirteenth story ([[BigLippedAlligatorMoment and never appears after that]]) can also be subject to this. Is she really the child's grandmother as the author believes or is there some other sort of dynamic in play?

Added: 358

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TastesLikeDiabetes: The ninth ("A Rose for Miss Winnie") and thirteenth (Love and a Red Wagon) stories seem to be written for this effect.-JesseMB27
* UnfortunateImplications: The author seems to suggest that only blood relatives are capable of showing concern for children in saying of a an elderly woman that he "assumed this child was her grandchild, because of the age difference, but I knew this wasn't a case of a babysitter caring for a child, because of the gentle loving way she cared for this child."-JesseMB27

to:

* TastesLikeDiabetes: The ninth ("A Rose for Miss Winnie") and thirteenth (Love ("Love and a Red Wagon) Wagon") stories seem to be written for this effect.-JesseMB27
* UnfortunateImplications: The author seems to suggest that only blood relatives are capable of showing concern for children in saying of a an elderly woman that he "assumed this child was her grandchild, because of the age difference, but I knew this wasn't a case of a babysitter caring for a child, because of the gentle loving way she cared for this child."-JesseMB27"-JesseMB27
* ValuesDissonance: One can probably tell from reading the fifteenth story ("A Tragedy and a Miracle") that Georgians (and for that matter [[DeepSouth Southerners]] in general) prior to the 1960s failed to provide adequate, if any, Day care as shown by the fact that Mrs. Dollar had to take care of her grandchild while at work as a Cafeteria lady.-JesseMB27
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnfortunateImplications: The author seems to suggest that only blood relatives are capable of showing concern for children in saying of a an elderly woman that he "assumed this child was her grandchild, because of the age difference, but I knew this wasn't a case of a babysitter caring for a child, because of the gentle loving way she cared for this child."

to:

* UnfortunateImplications: The author seems to suggest that only blood relatives are capable of showing concern for children in saying of a an elderly woman that he "assumed this child was her grandchild, because of the age difference, but I knew this wasn't a case of a babysitter caring for a child, because of the gentle loving way she cared for this child.""-JesseMB27

Added: 361

Changed: 57

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TastesLikeDiabetes: The ninth story, "A Rose for Miss Winnie", seems to be written for this effect.-JesseMB27

to:

* TastesLikeDiabetes: The ninth story, "A ("A Rose for Miss Winnie", seems Winnie") and thirteenth (Love and a Red Wagon) stories seem to be written for this effect.-JesseMB27-JesseMB27
* UnfortunateImplications: The author seems to suggest that only blood relatives are capable of showing concern for children in saying of a an elderly woman that he "assumed this child was her grandchild, because of the age difference, but I knew this wasn't a case of a babysitter caring for a child, because of the gentle loving way she cared for this child."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HilariousInHindsight: In the Twelfth chapter, the author refers to his car as "Franchise/MyLittlePony" without any knowledge of the aforementioned franchise nor its [[MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic certain well known recent adaption]]. Granted, while Brown's Pine Ridge Stories was published in May 2014, but the author alleges to have used the quoted phrase in 1969, thirteen years before Hasbro even created the MLP series.-JesseMB27
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Headscratchers}}: In the eleventh story, why is Gary taking cookies that neither belonged to him in the first place nor asked for permission to have? And no it isn't simply a case of him being a [[{{Delinquents}} Delinquent]] due to him showing a fear of being punished for being caught later in the same chapter. Unless he is trying to portray himself as a RuleAbidingRebel of somesort, there is no explanation provided for this OutOfCharacterMoment.-JesseMB27
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: The Joyriders from the fourth story ("The Strawberry Cow") can easily be the subject of this. Were they Jerkasses who committed their actions out of some sort of mean-spirited sense of entertainment as the author believes or was this simply a case of drunken-induced OneCrazyNight that got out of hand done by people who otherwise wouldn't have been involved in such an incident while sober?-JesseMB27

to:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: The Joyriders from the fourth story ("The Strawberry Cow") can easily be the subject of this. Were they Jerkasses who committed their actions out of some sort of mean-spirited sense of entertainment as the author believes or was this simply were they [[GoodOlBoy Good Ol' Boys]] in a case of drunken-induced OneCrazyNight that got out of hand done by people who otherwise wouldn't have been involved in such an incident while sober?-JesseMB27
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TastesLikeDiabetes: The ninth story, "A Rose for Miss Winnie", seems to be written for this effect.

to:

* TastesLikeDiabetes: The ninth story, "A Rose for Miss Winnie", seems to be written for this effect.-JesseMB27
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Squick}}: In "Paying Attention", Gary seeks to get the attention of a young girl of his same age by performing a stunt. This would likely attract reactions of "Aww" at first, but it is then revealed that the girl, whom the author had met for the first time that day, [[spoiler: was a cousin of his]]... Oops.-JesseMB27

to:

* {{Squick}}: In "Paying Attention", Gary seeks to get the attention of a young girl of his same age by performing a stunt. This would likely attract reactions of "Aww" at first, but it is then revealed that the girl, whom the author had met for the first time that day, [[spoiler: was a cousin of his]]... Oops.-JesseMB27-JesseMB27
* TastesLikeDiabetes: The ninth story, "A Rose for Miss Winnie", seems to be written for this effect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Squick}}: In "Paying Attention", Gary seeks to get the attention young girl of his same age by performing a stunt. This would liking attract

to:

* {{Squick}}: In "Paying Attention", Gary seeks to get the attention of a young girl of his same age by performing a stunt. This would liking attractlikely attract reactions of "Aww" at first, but it is then revealed that the girl, whom the author had met for the first time that day, [[spoiler: was a cousin of his]]... Oops.-JesseMB27

Added: 501

Changed: 693

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DesignatedVillain: The Joyriders due to a lack of details regarding their reasons for [[spoiler: killing Ole Strawberry]]. While what they did (drinking, driving, and firing firearms at the same time) was certainly irresponsible [[spoiler: and eventually brought about their own deaths]], but .-JesseMB27

to:

* BrokenAesop: The one at the end of "Starliner" ("Never give up and maybe the ugly ducklings you're expecting will become beautiful swans.") could arguably be one. Gary is dreading over the prospect of a Dodge he disliked being the one his father would, but then arrives with a [[CoolCar Ford Starliner]] instead. No where in the story does it involve any action on the part of Gary himself to change an unenviable outcome. It would be hoped that it was intended as a SpoofAesop and not one [[{{Narm}} meant to be taken seriously]].-JesseMB27
* DesignatedVillain: The Joyriders due to a lack of details regarding their reasons for [[spoiler: killing Ole Strawberry]]. Joyriders. While what they did (drinking, driving, and firing firearms at the same time) was certainly irresponsible [[spoiler: and eventually brought about their own deaths]], but .-JesseMB27but the lack of details regarding their reasons for [[spoiler: killing Ole Strawberry]] fails to give a sufficient reason to regard them as evil.-JesseMB27
* {{Squick}}: In "Paying Attention", Gary seeks to get the attention young girl of his same age by performing a stunt. This would liking attract
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Until other individuals begin to contribute to this page, my posts will be marked with my signature.
----

*AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: The Joyriders from the fourth story ("The Strawberry Cow") can easily be the subject of this. Were they Jerkasses who committed their actions out of some sort of mean-spirited sense of entertainment as the author believes or was this simply a case of drunken-induced OneCrazyNight that got out of hand done by people who otherwise wouldn't have been involved in such an incident while sober?-JesseMB27
*DesignatedVillain: The Joyriders due to a lack of details regarding their reasons for [[spoiler: killing Ole Strawberry]]. While what they did (drinking, driving, and firing firearms at the same time) was certainly irresponsible [[spoiler: and eventually brought about their own deaths]], but .-JesseMB27

Top