Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / BladeOfTheImmortal

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeartwarmingMoments: Manji and Rin are reunited, a bunch of guys hot on Rin's heels. She commands Manji to kill them, but he retorts that he will not kill just anyone simply because she tells him to: He has promised that he will kill 100 evil men to make up for the 100 good men he killed in the past. So, first and foremost, she has to answer him: Are they evil men? Rin near on has a breakdown, tearfully confessing that she does not know if they are evil, she does not know if they really deserve to die, all she knows is that if Manji does not kill them, then they will kill her... This, as it happens, was all Manji needed to hear.

to:

* HeartwarmingMoments: SugarWiki/HeartwarmingMoments: Manji and Rin are reunited, a bunch of guys hot on Rin's heels. She commands Manji to kill them, but he retorts that he will not kill just anyone simply because she tells him to: He has promised that he will kill 100 evil men to make up for the 100 good men he killed in the past. So, first and foremost, she has to answer him: Are they evil men? Rin near on has a breakdown, tearfully confessing that she does not know if they are evil, she does not know if they really deserve to die, all she knows is that if Manji does not kill them, then they will kill her... This, as it happens, was all Manji needed to hear.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Shira's last words are to tell Renzo to give up on his revenge, then telling him never to listen to men like him. While the most popular (Not to mention most in-character) interpretation of that is that it's one last KickTheDog moment to talk Renzo back into his revenge quest, it's ambiguous enough that he could be genuine in his desire to keep Renzo from traveling the same path he did.

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Shira's last words are to tell Renzo to give up on his revenge, then telling him never to listen to men like him. While the most popular (Not to mention most in-character) interpretation of that is that it's one last KickTheDog moment to talk Renzo back into his revenge quest, it's ambiguous enough that he could be genuine in his desire to keep Renzo from traveling the same path he did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
To quote the page, "Do not link to this on the wiki, please. Not even under the YMMV tab."


* SugarWiki/DevelopmentHeaven: Creator/HiroakiSamura personally redrew many pages so that the English-language release could be presented in the left-to-right English reading order without "flipping" the pages (i.e. mirroring them horizontally, a then-common practice which tends to cause BadExportForYou, especially with text). The series ultimately ran for ''30 volumes'' this way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Manji is not portrayed as a straight hero
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeartwarmingMoments: Manji and Rin are reunited, a bunch of guys hot on Rin's heels. She commands Manji to kill them, but he retorts that he will not kill just anyone simply because she tells him to: He has promised that he will kill 100 evil men to make up for the 100 good men he killed in the past. So, first and foremost, she has to answer him: Are they evil men? Rin near on has a breakdown, tearfully confessing that she does not know if they are evil, she does not know if they really deserve to die, all she knows is that if Manji does not kill them, then they will kill her... This, as it happens, was all Manji needed to hear.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Foe Yay has been cut


* FoeYay: Sweet Jesus, where do we begin? With the amount of sexual tension running in between camps, it seems probable that the main cast will just engage in some giant orgy as soon as kill each other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SugarWiki/DevelopmentHeaven: Creator/HiroakiSamura personally redrew many pages so that the English-language release could be presented in the left-to-right English reading order without "flipping" the pages (i.e. mirroring them horizontally, a then-common practice which tends to cause BadExportForYou, especially with text). The series ultimately ran for ''30 volumes'' this way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


---> '''Renzo:'''"[[spoiler: Shira]] is dead. He died all alone. And he was eaten by wild dogs...Torn to pieces! A really terrible death. That's probably the way it should be. A man like him wouldn't [deserve to] die like a human. But what's with ''this'' guy? How many people has ''he'' killed?! He's a big criminal too! Why do you all care so much about him?"

to:

---> '''Renzo:'''"[[spoiler: '''Renzo:''' "[[spoiler: Shira]] is dead. He died all alone. And he was eaten by wild dogs...Torn to pieces! A really terrible death. That's probably the way it should be. A man like him wouldn't [deserve to] die like a human. But what's with ''this'' guy? How many people has ''he'' killed?! He's a big criminal too! Why do you all care so much about him?"

Changed: 105

Removed: 112

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DesignatedHero: Manji. He's almost always played sympathetically despite being known throughout Japan as "the guy who ''murdered 100 people''". Even by the end of the series, he still hasn't become any more of a good guy.
** This fact is even lampshaded by Renzo [[spoiler: when he attempts to assassinate Manji after Shira's death.]]

to:

* DesignatedHero: Manji. He's almost always played sympathetically despite being known throughout Japan as "the guy who ''murdered 100 people''". Even by the end of the series, he still hasn't become any more of a good guy.
**
guy. This fact is even lampshaded by Renzo [[spoiler: when he attempts to assassinate Manji after Shira's death.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: [[AxCrazy Shira]] is a sadistic, misogynistic SerialKiller and the most depraved member of the Mugai-Ryu. When hunting the Itto-Ryu, Shira rapes, tortures and mutilates a [[HookerWithAHeartOfGold kind prostitute]] named O-Ren, leaving her to die after he's done. When he initially teams up with Manji and Rin, Shira puts on a [[WolfInSheepsClothing facade of acting like a human being]], only to torture and attempt to rape another prostitute serving a decoy for the Itto-Ryu leader, trying to murder Rin when she attempts to stop him. Losing a hand to Manji as a result, Shira grows more and more unhinged with dreams of vengeance to the point he willingly submits to twisted immortality experiments to combat Manji. Raping a woman to death and keeping a boy with a grudge against Manji named Renzo as a helper and SexSlave who he violently abuses on a regular basis, Shira proceeds to massacre the Shogunate's forces sent after him and kidnaps Rin. Tying her to a dock, half submerged with a boulder tied to her feet in the dead of winter, Shira attempts to force Manji to choose to [[SadisticChoice drown saving her or leave her to die to face Shira himself]]. Shira proceeds to attempt to murder his other nemesis, O-Ren's beloved Magatsu, while trying to cripple and rape a Shogunate kunoichi assisting him. When finally defeated, Shira uses his last words to implore Renzo to abandon his revenge, only to [[KickTheDog crush his spirit even further]] by spitefully telling him to never listen to men like him.

to:

* CompleteMonster: [[AxCrazy Shira]] is a sadistic, misogynistic SerialKiller and the most depraved member of the Mugai-Ryu. When hunting the Itto-Ryu, Shira rapes, tortures and mutilates a [[HookerWithAHeartOfGold kind prostitute]] named O-Ren, leaving her to die after he's done. When he initially teams up with Manji and Rin, Shira puts on a [[WolfInSheepsClothing facade of acting like a human being]], only to torture and attempt to rape another prostitute serving a decoy for the Itto-Ryu leader, trying to murder Rin when she attempts to stop him. Losing a hand to Manji as a result, Shira grows more and more unhinged with dreams of vengeance to the point he willingly submits to twisted immortality experiments to combat Manji. Raping a woman to death and keeping a boy with a grudge against Manji named Renzo as a helper and SexSlave who SexSlave, whom he violently abuses on a regular basis, Shira proceeds to massacre the Shogunate's forces sent after him and kidnaps Rin. Tying her to a dock, half submerged with a boulder tied to her feet in the dead of winter, Shira attempts to force Manji to choose to [[SadisticChoice drown saving her or leave her to die to face Shira himself]]. Shira proceeds to attempt to murder his other nemesis, O-Ren's beloved Magatsu, while trying to cripple and rape a Shogunate kunoichi assisting him. When finally defeated, Shira uses his last words to implore Renzo to abandon his revenge, only to [[KickTheDog crush his spirit even further]] by spitefully telling him to never listen to men like him.

Added: 419

Changed: 418

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Renzo:'''"[[spoiler: Shira]] is dead. He died all alone. And he was eaten by wild dogs...Torn to pieces! A really terrible death. That's probably the way it should be. A man like him wouldn't [deserve to] die like a human. But what's with ''this'' guy? How many people has ''he'' killed?! He's a big criminal too! Why do you all care so much about him?"

to:

--> ---> '''Renzo:'''"[[spoiler: Shira]] is dead. He died all alone. And he was eaten by wild dogs...Torn to pieces! A really terrible death. That's probably the way it should be. A man like him wouldn't [deserve to] die like a human. But what's with ''this'' guy? How many people has ''he'' killed?! He's a big criminal too! Why do you all care so much about him?"



* TheWoobie: Makie, who is an unbelievably tragic figure whose life has been nothing but suffering, pain and isolation. The man she loves values her more for her skill than for her as a person, her relationship with her family was dysfunctional at best and she has no purpose in life that she can name. All she can do is resign herself to her own lonely corner of the world and live quietly, troubling and being troubled by none.

to:

* TheWoobie: TheWoobie:
**
Makie, who is an unbelievably tragic figure whose life has been nothing but suffering, pain and isolation. The man she loves values her more for her skill than for her as a person, her relationship with her family was dysfunctional at best and she has no purpose in life that she can name. All she can do is resign herself to her own lonely corner of the world and live quietly, troubling and being troubled by none.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Irrelevant.


** Habaki Kagimura, secret master of the Mugai-Ryu and the shinbangashira--a major figure in the Shogunate--forms the Mugai-Ryu to secretly destroy the Itto-Ryu before luring the organization's strongest members into a trap and destroying them. Capturing series {{Protagonist}}, the immortal man Manji, Habaki subjects him to experiments to perfect immortality for the sake of the Shogun. When ordered to commit seppuku, Habaki uses his time to try to destroy the Itto-Ryu, dealing a series of decisive blows before engaging Anotsu himself with surprising good humor and [[WorthyOpponent mutual respect]], with his only regrets at the end being the [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes loss of the two loves of his life and his dead children]].

to:

** Habaki Kagimura, secret master of the Mugai-Ryu and the shinbangashira--a major figure in the Shogunate--forms the Mugai-Ryu to secretly destroy the Itto-Ryu before luring the organization's strongest members into a trap and destroying them. Capturing series {{Protagonist}}, protagonist, the immortal man Manji, Habaki subjects him to experiments to perfect immortality for the sake of the Shogun. When ordered to commit seppuku, Habaki uses his time to try to destroy the Itto-Ryu, dealing a series of decisive blows before engaging Anotsu himself with surprising good humor and [[WorthyOpponent mutual respect]], with his only regrets at the end being the [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes loss of the two loves of his life and his dead children]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Shira's last words are to tell Renzo to give up on his revenge, then telling him never to listen to men like him. While the most popular (Not to mention most in-character) interpretation of that is that it's one last KickTheDog moment to talk Renzo back into his revenge quest, it's ambiguous enough that he could be genuine in his desire to keep Renzo from traveling the same path he did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Narm:}}

to:

* {{Narm:}} {{Narm}}
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Narm:}}
** The TearJerker of [[spoiler:Shima's suicide]] is somewhat lessened by the most gratuitous use of HighPressureBlood in the series; one stab in the throat results in a ''twenty foot blood fountain.''
** Manji's use of [[spoiler: Arashino's own arm]] to defeat him is pretty cool, but he ''keeps using it for the rest of the scene,'' which is pretty distracting since it's the FinalBattle.

Added: 312

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArcFatigue: Like most long-running manga, it varies depending on who you ask. The most popular choice seems to be the Prison Arc.

to:

* ArcFatigue: Like most long-running manga, it varies depending on who you ask. The most popular choice seems to be the six-volume Prison Arc.


Added DiffLines:

* MoralEventHorizon: After dancing around it for several volumes, Kagimura makes a flying leap across when he orders a shipyard to be made inaccessible to the Itto-Ryu...by ''murdering everyone who works there.''


Added DiffLines:

* RootingForTheEmpire: As the series goes on, it gets really easy to start rooting for the Itto-Ryu.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeArt: Easily some of the greatest art in the industry, with dynamic panels, unique designs for every character (mostly), and great storytelling.

to:

* AwesomeArt: SugarWiki/AwesomeArt: Easily some of the greatest art in the industry, with dynamic panels, unique designs for every character (mostly), and great storytelling.

Added: 1466

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Approved by the thread.


* FoeYay: Sweet Jesus, where do we begin? With the amount of sexual tension running in between camps, it seems probable that the main cast will just engage in some giant orgy as soon as kill each other..

to:

* FoeYay: Sweet Jesus, where do we begin? With the amount of sexual tension running in between camps, it seems probable that the main cast will just engage in some giant orgy as soon as kill each other..other.
* MagnificentBastard:
** Anotsu Kagehisa desires a world where "[[BloodKnight the sword excuses all]]". Creating the Itto-Ryu, Anotsu begins to hunt down dojos to eliminate them in order to [[TheSocialDarwinist abolish the stifling sword styles]] from the world in favor of a world of pure determination. Cleverly eluding his pursuers via having prostitutes disguise themselves as him and lead his hunters into ambushes, Anotsu's utter tenacity sees him through other attempts on his life and rallying the itto-Ryu against the shogunate, culminating in a dynamic assault on Edo castle itself. Even to the end, Anotsu remains a complex figure, stopping at nothing to achieve his dreams despite all the wrongs he has committed on his path.
** Habaki Kagimura, secret master of the Mugai-Ryu and the shinbangashira--a major figure in the Shogunate--forms the Mugai-Ryu to secretly destroy the Itto-Ryu before luring the organization's strongest members into a trap and destroying them. Capturing series {{Protagonist}}, the immortal man Manji, Habaki subjects him to experiments to perfect immortality for the sake of the Shogun. When ordered to commit seppuku, Habaki uses his time to try to destroy the Itto-Ryu, dealing a series of decisive blows before engaging Anotsu himself with surprising good humor and [[WorthyOpponent mutual respect]], with his only regrets at the end being the [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes loss of the two loves of his life and his dead children]].

Changed: 27

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: [[AxCrazy Shira]] is a sadistic, misogynistic SerialKiller and the most depraved member of the Mugai-Ryu. When hunting the Itto-Ryu, Shira rapes, tortures and mutilates a kind prostitute named O-Ren, leaving her to die after he's done. When he initially teams up with Manji and Rin, Shira puts on a [[WolfInSheepsClothing facade of acting like a human being]], only to torture and attempt to rape another prostitute serving a decoy for the Itto-Ryu leader, trying to murder Rin when she attempts to stop him. Losing a hand to Manji as a result, Shira grows more and more unhinged with dreams of vengeance to the point he willingly submits to twisted immortality experiments to combat Manji. Raping a woman to death and keeping a boy with a grudge against Manji named Renzo as a helper and SexSlave who he violently abuses on a regular basis, Shira proceeds to massacre the Shogunate's forces sent after him and kidnaps Rin. Tying her to a dock, half submerged with a boulder tied to her feet in the dead of winter, Shira attempts to force Manji to choose to [[SadisticChoice drown saving her or leave her to die to face Shira himself]]. Shira proceeds to attempt to murder his other nemesis, O-Ren's beloved Magatsu, while trying to cripple and rape a Shogunate kunoichi assisting him. When finally defeated, Shira uses his last words to implore Renzo to abandon his revenge, only to [[KickTheDog crush his spirit even further]] by spitefully telling him to never listen to men like him.

to:

* CompleteMonster: [[AxCrazy Shira]] is a sadistic, misogynistic SerialKiller and the most depraved member of the Mugai-Ryu. When hunting the Itto-Ryu, Shira rapes, tortures and mutilates a [[HookerWithAHeartOfGold kind prostitute prostitute]] named O-Ren, leaving her to die after he's done. When he initially teams up with Manji and Rin, Shira puts on a [[WolfInSheepsClothing facade of acting like a human being]], only to torture and attempt to rape another prostitute serving a decoy for the Itto-Ryu leader, trying to murder Rin when she attempts to stop him. Losing a hand to Manji as a result, Shira grows more and more unhinged with dreams of vengeance to the point he willingly submits to twisted immortality experiments to combat Manji. Raping a woman to death and keeping a boy with a grudge against Manji named Renzo as a helper and SexSlave who he violently abuses on a regular basis, Shira proceeds to massacre the Shogunate's forces sent after him and kidnaps Rin. Tying her to a dock, half submerged with a boulder tied to her feet in the dead of winter, Shira attempts to force Manji to choose to [[SadisticChoice drown saving her or leave her to die to face Shira himself]]. Shira proceeds to attempt to murder his other nemesis, O-Ren's beloved Magatsu, while trying to cripple and rape a Shogunate kunoichi assisting him. When finally defeated, Shira uses his last words to implore Renzo to abandon his revenge, only to [[KickTheDog crush his spirit even further]] by spitefully telling him to never listen to men like him.

Changed: 203

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: [[AxCrazy Shira]] is a sadistic, misogynistic SerialKiller and the most depraved member of the Mugai-Ryu. When hunting the Itto-Ryu, Shira rapes, tortures and mutilates a kind prostitute named O-Ren, leaving her to die after he's done. When he initially teams up with Manji and Rin, Shira puts on a [[WolfInSheepsClothing facade of acting like a human being]], only to torture and attempt to rape another prostitute serving a decoy for the Itto-Ryu leader, trying to murder Rin when she attempts to stop him. Losing a hand to Manji as a result, Shira grows more and more unhinged with dreams of vengeance to the point he willingly submits to twisted immortality experiments to combat Manji. Raping a woman to death and keeping a boy with a grudge against Manji named Renzo as a helper and SexSlave who he violently abuses on a regular basis, Shira proceeds to massacre the Shogunate's forces sent after him and kidnaps Rin. Tying her to a dock, half submerged with a boulder tied to her feet in the dead of winter, Shira attempts to force Manji to choose to [[SadisticChoice drown saving her or leave her to die to face Shira himself]]. Shira proceeds to attempt to murder his other nemesis, O-Ren's beloved Magatsu, while trying to cripple and rape a Shogunate kunoichi assisting him. When finally defeated, Shira uses his last words to implore Renzo to abandon his revenge...only to [[KickTheDog crush his spirit even further]] by spitefully telling him to never listen to men like Shira . In the dark world of ''Blade of the Immortal'', Shira stands supreme as the [[BlackAndGreyMorality most twisted, sickening being imaginable]] who lives solely to hurt everyone he comes across.

to:

* CompleteMonster: [[AxCrazy Shira]] is a sadistic, misogynistic SerialKiller and the most depraved member of the Mugai-Ryu. When hunting the Itto-Ryu, Shira rapes, tortures and mutilates a kind prostitute named O-Ren, leaving her to die after he's done. When he initially teams up with Manji and Rin, Shira puts on a [[WolfInSheepsClothing facade of acting like a human being]], only to torture and attempt to rape another prostitute serving a decoy for the Itto-Ryu leader, trying to murder Rin when she attempts to stop him. Losing a hand to Manji as a result, Shira grows more and more unhinged with dreams of vengeance to the point he willingly submits to twisted immortality experiments to combat Manji. Raping a woman to death and keeping a boy with a grudge against Manji named Renzo as a helper and SexSlave who he violently abuses on a regular basis, Shira proceeds to massacre the Shogunate's forces sent after him and kidnaps Rin. Tying her to a dock, half submerged with a boulder tied to her feet in the dead of winter, Shira attempts to force Manji to choose to [[SadisticChoice drown saving her or leave her to die to face Shira himself]]. Shira proceeds to attempt to murder his other nemesis, O-Ren's beloved Magatsu, while trying to cripple and rape a Shogunate kunoichi assisting him. When finally defeated, Shira uses his last words to implore Renzo to abandon his revenge...revenge, only to [[KickTheDog crush his spirit even further]] by spitefully telling him to never listen to men like Shira . In the dark world of ''Blade of the Immortal'', Shira stands supreme as the [[BlackAndGreyMorality most twisted, sickening being imaginable]] who lives solely to hurt everyone he comes across.him.

Changed: 155

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CompleteMonster: [[AxCrazy Shira]] is a sadistic, misogynistic SerialKiller and the most depraved member of the Mugai-Ryu. When hunting the Itto-Ryu, Shira rapes, tortures and mutilates a kind prostitute named O-Ren, leaving her to die after he's done. When he initially teams up with Manji and Rin, Shira puts on a [[WolfInSheepsClothing facade of acting like a human being]], only to torture and attempt to rape another prostitute serving a decoy for the Itto-Ryu leader, trying to murder Rin when she attempts to stop him. Losing a hand to Manji as a result, Shira grows more and more unhinged with dreams of vengeance to the point he willingly submits to twisted immortality experiments to combat Manji. Raping a woman to death and keeping a boy with a grudge against Manji named Renzo as a helper and SexSlave who he violently abuses on a regular basis, Shira proceeds to massacre the Shogunate's forces sent after him and kidnaps Rin. Tying her to a dock, half submerged with a boulder tied to her feet in the dead of winter, Shira attempts to force Manji to choose to [[SadisticChoice drown saving her or leave her to die to face Shira himself]]. Shira proceeds to attempt to murder his other nemesis, O-Ren's beloved Magatsu, while trying to cripple and rape a Shogunate kunoichi assisting him. When finally defeated, Shira uses his last words when being eaten alive by wild dogs to implore Renzo to abandon his revenge... only to spitefully tell him to never listen to men like Shira to [[KickTheDog crush his spirit even further]]. In the dark world of ''Blade of the Immortal'', Shira stands supreme as the [[BlackAndGreyMorality most twisted, sickening being imaginable]] who lives solely to hurt everyone he comes across.

to:

* CompleteMonster: [[AxCrazy Shira]] is a sadistic, misogynistic SerialKiller and the most depraved member of the Mugai-Ryu. When hunting the Itto-Ryu, Shira rapes, tortures and mutilates a kind prostitute named O-Ren, leaving her to die after he's done. When he initially teams up with Manji and Rin, Shira puts on a [[WolfInSheepsClothing facade of acting like a human being]], only to torture and attempt to rape another prostitute serving a decoy for the Itto-Ryu leader, trying to murder Rin when she attempts to stop him. Losing a hand to Manji as a result, Shira grows more and more unhinged with dreams of vengeance to the point he willingly submits to twisted immortality experiments to combat Manji. Raping a woman to death and keeping a boy with a grudge against Manji named Renzo as a helper and SexSlave who he violently abuses on a regular basis, Shira proceeds to massacre the Shogunate's forces sent after him and kidnaps Rin. Tying her to a dock, half submerged with a boulder tied to her feet in the dead of winter, Shira attempts to force Manji to choose to [[SadisticChoice drown saving her or leave her to die to face Shira himself]]. Shira proceeds to attempt to murder his other nemesis, O-Ren's beloved Magatsu, while trying to cripple and rape a Shogunate kunoichi assisting him. When finally defeated, Shira uses his last words when being eaten alive by wild dogs to implore Renzo to abandon his revenge... revenge...only to spitefully tell him to never listen to men like Shira to [[KickTheDog crush his spirit even further]].further]] by spitefully telling him to never listen to men like Shira . In the dark world of ''Blade of the Immortal'', Shira stands supreme as the [[BlackAndGreyMorality most twisted, sickening being imaginable]] who lives solely to hurt everyone he comes across.

Top