Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / ArrestedDevelopment

Go To

OR

Added: 585

Changed: 397

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: Subverted at first in "Making a Stand", where a montage of stills is put to several different songs made for the series in an attempt to "make it funny". At one point, TheNarrator mentions that it was "pretty funny to ''Yellow Submarine''... but who could afford it?", at which point the music cuts out. Parodied later in the episode with a second montage set to a similar-sounding "Yellow Boat".

to:

* SuspiciouslySimilarSong: SuspiciouslySimilarSong:
** One recurring track playing throughout the show, ''I Get Up'', has an intro and beat similar to ''Everybody's Got Their Something'' by Nikka Costa, which itself was used in the pilot.
**
Subverted at first in "Making a Stand", where a montage of stills is put to several different songs made for the series in an attempt to "make it funny". At one point, TheNarrator mentions that it was "pretty funny to ''Yellow Submarine''... but who could afford it?", at which point the music cuts out. Parodied later in the episode with a second montage set to a similar-sounding "Yellow Boat".

Added: 805

Changed: 471

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FriendlyFandoms: With ''Series/{{Succession}}''. Both shows are comedies about the dysfunctional children of a wealthy business magnate and their inability to function in the real world, albeit ''Succession'' is a bit more on the serious side. The characters themselves even have similar counterparts to ''Arrested Development'' (though not exact, as Kendall Roy is a bit more incompetent than Michael, Tom a flailing suck-up rather than a barely closeted failed psychiatrist in Tobias).

to:

* FriendlyFandoms: FriendlyFandoms:
**
With ''Series/{{Community}}''. Both shows were CultClassic sitcoms about unusual premises, and they share Creator/TheRussoBrothers as directors for their first few seasons. It helps that stars from both shows make cameos in the other series, with Creator/DanHarmon himself even appearing in one episode.
** There's also some overlap with
''Series/{{Succession}}''. Both shows are comedies about the dysfunctional children of a wealthy business magnate and their inability to function in the real world, albeit ''Succession'' is a bit more on the serious side. The characters themselves even have similar counterparts to ''Arrested Development'' (though not exact, as Kendall Roy is a bit more incompetent than Michael, Tom a flailing suck-up rather than a barely closeted failed psychiatrist in Tobias).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In season 4, one of the running jokes is a terrible, cheaply shot, early '90s movie about the Fantastic Four. Many fans assume it's completely made up, but that's an [[Film/TheFantasticFour actual movie]], and in fact the circumstances of production in-universe are similar to what actually happened, although the actress who played Sue Storm is actually named Rebecca Staab.

to:

** In season 4, one of the running jokes is a terrible, cheaply shot, early '90s movie about the Fantastic Four. Many fans assume it's completely made up, but that's an [[Film/TheFantasticFour actual movie]], and in fact the circumstances of production in-universe are similar to what actually happened, although the actress who played Sue Storm is actually named Rebecca Staab.Creator/RebeccaStaab.

Added: 1505

Changed: 1072

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpiritualSuccessor: In addition to being a hilarious sitcom in its own right, ''Arrested Development'' is also probably the best comedic reimagining of Classical Greek tragedy that you'll see on the small screen. It could easily be a modern retelling of Creator/{{Aeschylus}}' ''Theatre/TheOresteia'' (with a few elements of [[Theatre/OedipusTheKing the]] [[Theatre/OedipusAtColonus Theban]] [[Theatre/{{Antigone}} trilogy]] thrown in), with the Bluths standing in for the House of Atreus. All the tropes are there: intergenerational conflict, random mutilation and disfiguration, a powerful BigScrewedUpFamily's fall from grace, a complex web of backstabbings and infidelity, an [[EvilMatriarch ambitious scheming matriarch]] manipulating a clueless patriarch behind his back, an OnlySaneMan son trying to right his parents' wrongs, boatloads of IncestSubtext, and a surreal courtroom trial at the climax--all set against the backdrop of a brutal war in Asia Minor (though one involving [[UsefulNotes/TheWarOnTerror battle tanks]] instead of [[UsefulNotes/TheTrojanWar a big wooden horse]]).

to:

* SpiritualSuccessor: SpiritualSuccessor:
**
In addition to being a hilarious sitcom in its own right, ''Arrested Development'' is also probably the best comedic reimagining of Classical Greek tragedy that you'll see on the small screen. It could easily be a modern retelling of Creator/{{Aeschylus}}' ''Theatre/TheOresteia'' (with a few elements of [[Theatre/OedipusTheKing the]] [[Theatre/OedipusAtColonus Theban]] [[Theatre/{{Antigone}} trilogy]] thrown in), with the Bluths standing in for the House of Atreus. All the tropes are there: intergenerational conflict, random mutilation and disfiguration, a powerful BigScrewedUpFamily's fall from grace, a complex web of backstabbings and infidelity, an [[EvilMatriarch ambitious scheming matriarch]] manipulating a clueless patriarch behind his back, an OnlySaneMan son trying to right his parents' wrongs, boatloads of IncestSubtext, and a surreal courtroom trial at the climax--all set against the backdrop of a brutal war in Asia Minor (though one involving [[UsefulNotes/TheWarOnTerror battle tanks]] instead of [[UsefulNotes/TheTrojanWar a big wooden horse]]).horse]]).
** According to WordOfGod, the show was intended to be a White-Collar PlayedForLaughs take on ''Film/TheGodfather''. George Bluth was meant to be the stand-in for Vito Corleone, and Michael, GOB, Lindsey, and Buster corresponded with Michael, Sonny, Connie, and Fredo Corleone respectively; The incest subplot between Vincent and Mary inspired the subplot between George Michael and Maeby; Carlo Rizzi matches up with Tobias. etc.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Redundant


** Lucille's jokes about Lindsay being fat sound especially mean since Creator/PortiaDeRossi admitted to suffering from eating disorders.

Added: 779

Removed: 776

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed


* QuestionableCasting:
** Creator/SethRogen playing a younger George Bluth Sr. in flashbacks in Season 4, due to bearing little resemblance to Jeffrey Tambor. That said, those who have seen Tambor in his younger days in films such as ''Film/AndJusticeForAll'' will note that he did bear at least a passing resemblance to Rogen. It really doesn't help that his scenes usually have him opposite Creator/KristenWiig, who is absolutely ''uncanny'' as a young Lucille.
** Even more pronounced in the second half of season Season 5 with Creator/TaranKillam as a young George Sr., and especially Creator/CobieSmulders as a young Lucille. It later turns out that this is actually from a ShowWithinAShow, making it an in-universe example of both this trope and AdaptationalAttractiveness.



* WTHCastingAgency:
** Creator/SethRogen playing a younger George Bluth Sr. in flashbacks in Season 4, due to bearing little resemblance to Jeffrey Tambor. That said, those who have seen Tambor in his younger days in films such as ''Film/AndJusticeForAll'' will note that he did bear at least a passing resemblance to Rogen. It really doesn't help that his scenes usually have him opposite Creator/KristenWiig, who is absolutely ''uncanny'' as a young Lucille.
** Even more pronounced in the second half of season Season 5 with Creator/TaranKillam as a young George Sr., and especially Creator/CobieSmulders as a young Lucille. It later turns out that this is actually from a ShowWithinAShow, making it an in-universe example of both this trope and AdaptationalAttractiveness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Merged trope


* SpiritualAdaptation: In addition to being a hilarious sitcom in its own right, ''Arrested Development'' is also probably the best comedic reimagining of Classical Greek tragedy that you'll see on the small screen. It could easily be a modern retelling of Creator/{{Aeschylus}}' ''Theatre/TheOresteia'' (with a few elements of [[Theatre/OedipusTheKing the]] [[Theatre/OedipusAtColonus Theban]] [[Theatre/{{Antigone}} trilogy]] thrown in), with the Bluths standing in for the House of Atreus. All the tropes are there: intergenerational conflict, random mutilation and disfiguration, a powerful BigScrewedUpFamily's fall from grace, a complex web of backstabbings and infidelity, an [[EvilMatriarch ambitious scheming matriarch]] manipulating a clueless patriarch behind his back, an OnlySaneMan son trying to right his parents' wrongs, boatloads of IncestSubtext, and a surreal courtroom trial at the climax--all set against the backdrop of a brutal war in Asia Minor (though one involving [[UsefulNotes/TheWarOnTerror battle tanks]] instead of [[UsefulNotes/TheTrojanWar a big wooden horse]]).

to:

* SpiritualAdaptation: SpiritualSuccessor: In addition to being a hilarious sitcom in its own right, ''Arrested Development'' is also probably the best comedic reimagining of Classical Greek tragedy that you'll see on the small screen. It could easily be a modern retelling of Creator/{{Aeschylus}}' ''Theatre/TheOresteia'' (with a few elements of [[Theatre/OedipusTheKing the]] [[Theatre/OedipusAtColonus Theban]] [[Theatre/{{Antigone}} trilogy]] thrown in), with the Bluths standing in for the House of Atreus. All the tropes are there: intergenerational conflict, random mutilation and disfiguration, a powerful BigScrewedUpFamily's fall from grace, a complex web of backstabbings and infidelity, an [[EvilMatriarch ambitious scheming matriarch]] manipulating a clueless patriarch behind his back, an OnlySaneMan son trying to right his parents' wrongs, boatloads of IncestSubtext, and a surreal courtroom trial at the climax--all set against the backdrop of a brutal war in Asia Minor (though one involving [[UsefulNotes/TheWarOnTerror battle tanks]] instead of [[UsefulNotes/TheTrojanWar a big wooden horse]]).

Added: 241

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added example + updated tense in another


** Creator/JayJohnston's appearances as Officer Taylor are either this or HilariousInHindsight after his arrest for participating in the January 6 United States Capitol riots, especially with his felony charge of obstructing police officers.



** "Here's some money, go see a Star War" is funnier now that Ron Howard [[{{Film/Solo}} is directing a Star War]], also including a lead named Tobias. Not to mention that Season 4 revolves around a large celebration on May 4th ("Cinco de Quatro"), a date informally observed as a holiday by many ''Star Wars'' fans (as in "[[{{Pun}} May the Fourth be with you]]").

to:

** "Here's some money, go see a Star War" is funnier now that Ron Howard [[{{Film/Solo}} is directing has directed a Star War]], also including a lead named Tobias. Not to mention that Season 4 revolves around a large celebration on May 4th ("Cinco de Quatro"), a date informally observed as a holiday by many ''Star Wars'' fans (as in "[[{{Pun}} May the Fourth be with you]]").
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateJokeInterpretation: In the pilot, Lucille claims to love her children equally even though some time ago she admits she doesn't care for GOB. First interpretation of the joke is she simply has a low opinion of GOB. The other interpretation is because she said she loved her children "equally", she's really saying she loved them as much as she loves GOB, which is not at all.

to:

* AlternateJokeInterpretation: AlternativeJokeInterpretation: In the pilot, Lucille claims to love her children equally even though some time ago she admits she doesn't care for GOB. First interpretation of the joke is she simply has a low opinion of GOB. The other interpretation is because she said she loved her children "equally", she's really saying she loved them as much as she loves GOB, which is not at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AlternateJokeInterpretation: In the pilot, Lucille claims to love her children equally even though some time ago she admits she doesn't care for GOB. First interpretation of the joke is she simply has a low opinion of GOB. The other interpretation is because she said she loved her children "equally", she's really saying she loved them as much as she loves GOB, which is not at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FriendlyFandoms: With ''Series/Succession''. Both shows are comedies about the dysfunctional children of a wealthy business magnate and their inability to function in the real world, albeit ''Succession'' is a bit more on the serious side. The characters themselves even have similar counterparts to ''Arrested Development'' (though not exact, as Kendall Roy is a bit more incompetent than Michael, Tom a flailing suck-up rather than a barely closeted failed psychiatrist in Tobias).

to:

* FriendlyFandoms: With ''Series/Succession''.''Series/{{Succession}}''. Both shows are comedies about the dysfunctional children of a wealthy business magnate and their inability to function in the real world, albeit ''Succession'' is a bit more on the serious side. The characters themselves even have similar counterparts to ''Arrested Development'' (though not exact, as Kendall Roy is a bit more incompetent than Michael, Tom a flailing suck-up rather than a barely closeted failed psychiatrist in Tobias).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FriendlyFandoms: With ''Series/Succession''. Both shows are comedies about the dysfunctional children of a wealthy business magnate and their inability to function in the real world, albeit ''Succession'' is a bit more on the serious side. The characters themselves even have similar counterparts to ''Arrested Development'' (though not exact, as Kendall Roy is a bit more incompetent than Michael, Tom a flailing suck-up rather than a barely closeted failed psychiatrist in Tobias).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Maggie Lizer, played by Creator/JuliaLouisDreyfus, is one of the most popular minor characters in the show due to her hilarious pathological liar traits. Many fans wished she was in more episodes.

to:

** Maggie Lizer, played by Creator/JuliaLouisDreyfus, is one of the most popular minor secondary characters in the show due to her hilarious pathological liar traits. Many fans wished she was in more episodes.

Added: 198

Changed: 89

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeparatedAtBirthCasting: Jeffrey Tambor and Tony Hale look like the same person with a couple of years difference.

to:

* SeparatedAtBirthCasting: SeparatedAtBirthCasting:
**
Jeffrey Tambor and Tony Hale look like the same person with a couple of years difference.difference.
** Isla Fisher looks enough like Ron Howard's real-life daughters to pass as a fictional illegitimate one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope renamed


** The Living Classics pageant where actors dress up and reenact classic paintings sound like another one of the show's trademark DanBrowning jokes right? [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2cfBwnP81rY It's a parody of a real event]].[[note]]It's called a "Tableau Vivant," and it was a legitimate and popular form of entertainment for many years.[[/note]]

to:

** The Living Classics pageant where actors dress up and reenact classic paintings sound like another one of the show's trademark DanBrowning FalselyAdvertisedAccuracy jokes right? [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2cfBwnP81rY It's a parody of a real event]].[[note]]It's called a "Tableau Vivant," and it was a legitimate and popular form of entertainment for many years.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* AluminumChristmasTrees:
** In season 4, one of the running jokes is a terrible, cheaply shot, early '90s movie about the Fantastic Four. Many fans assume it's completely made up, but that's an [[Film/TheFantasticFour actual movie]], and in fact the circumstances of production in-universe are similar to what actually happened, although the actress who played Sue Storm is actually named Rebecca Staab.
** Plenty of people outside California didn't know John Beard was an actual newscaster unless they are aware of his [[MemeticMutation "Hackers on Steroids"]] clip.
** The Living Classics pageant where actors dress up and reenact classic paintings sound like another one of the show's trademark DanBrowning jokes right? [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2cfBwnP81rY It's a parody of a real event]].[[note]]It's called a "Tableau Vivant," and it was a legitimate and popular form of entertainment for many years.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved to Trivia


* AuthorsSavingThrow:
** As a result of Michael's long standing UnintentionallyUnsympathetic status, the writers got the hint and made him a blatant {{Jerkass}} as seasons went on, as well as giving the UnintentionallySympathetic Gob a bit more of sympathy.
** Pretty much everything about the Season 5 announcement screams, "Yeah, we'll try and keep the Bluths together more." The season 4 remix opening even changes to state such:
--->'''Narrator''': Now the story of what happens when the one man who was holding his family together finally let go. And the separate journey that eventually gave them no choice but to come back together.
** The main criticism of Season Four was that the cast have separate long-winded adventures, barely interact with each other, and the AnachronicOrder has the story make no sense until the last third of the season where they finally explain a lot of [[BrickJoke hanging jokes and plot points]]. A ReCut of the entire season called "Fateful Consequences" attempts to assemble the season into a more chronological order, placing more emphasis on developing 2 or 3 plotlines in each episode while also being quicker to reveal certain twists (Lindsay and Tobias both going to India for a retreat is covered in the same episode, rather than revealing Tobias was also in India two episodes later). This, in addition to shorter episode runtime but more episodes total, makes it more in line with the style of the earlier seasons.
** The genuinely shocking and dramatic last seconds of Season 4 are very much diluted by Season 5's reveal of the aftermath, which is awkward and a little sad, but nowhere near as destructive as the abrupt presentation of the scene had implied.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Are all of George Sr's HeelFaceTurn attempts faked, or does he try to change and fail?

to:

** Are all of George Sr's HeelFaceTurn attempts faked, or does is he try sincerely trying to change and fail?but failing at it?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It hasn't been twenty years yet.


* ValuesDissonance: "Sad Sack" from Season 2 ages poorly due to a plotline that comes off as transphobic: Lindsay is interested in Steve Holt at the same time as Maeby, but because she lost her voice, Maeby tries to make Steve lose interest by claiming Lindsay is a poorly-passing trans woman, even calling her a "tranny" and giving her a shirt to read that says "shemale", both of which are considered anti-trans slurs. None of the jokes are portrayed in a way to condemn the ignorant mindset unlike the way the show treats racial and ethnic bigotry.

Added: 1683

Changed: 588

Removed: 878

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AudienceAlienatingPremise: The show actually got a decent amount of network support, it lasted 3 years despite being rather expensive to produce, but some theorize that FOX simply did not know how to effectively advertise the show, Emmy winning or not. Basically it's a show about a family of egotistical yuppies where [[OnlySaneMan only one man is trying to do the right thing]], the rest are either [[ExtremeDoormat pushovers]], flawed to the point of being TheLoad, or outright [[UnsympatheticComedyProtagonist unsympathetic characters]]. The complex narrative, intricate business subplots, and IncestSubtext out the wazoo complicates things further. This was [[LampshadeHanging pointed out]] in the third season by Michael: "Maybe we aren't as likable as we think we are."
** [[WordOfGod Mitch Hurwitz]] also himself gave a reasonable accounting for the show's lack of success in [[https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2011/feb/12/arrested-development-mitch-hurwitz-sitcom-cancelled an article written in The Guardian]], framed as a guide on how to get a sitcom cancelled. It gives such "tips" as to [[EightDeadlyWords make all the characters unlikeable]], stuff 20-minute episodes with convoluted overlapping plotlines, and focus greatly on incest, with the final piece of "advice" being: "Make a show for British sensibilities and then show it in America."

to:

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: The show actually got a decent amount of network support, it lasted 3 years despite being rather expensive to produce, but some theorize that FOX simply did not know how to effectively advertise the show, Emmy winning or not. Basically it's a show about a family of egotistical yuppies where [[OnlySaneMan only one man is trying to do the right thing]], the rest are either [[ExtremeDoormat pushovers]], flawed to the point of being TheLoad, or outright [[UnsympatheticComedyProtagonist unsympathetic characters]]. The complex narrative, intricate business subplots, and IncestSubtext out the wazoo complicates things further. This was [[LampshadeHanging pointed out]] in the third season by Michael: "Maybe we aren't as likable as we think we are."
**
"\\
\\
However, though the show never caught on when it first aired, the show exploded after its end when it had one of the highest DVD sales for a show and even managed a few UsefulNotes/{{syndication}} deals (100 episodes are considered the standard for a syndicated show, 65 at minimum, Arrested Development had 53). This can be contributed not only to the show's [[CultClassic cult following]], but also, [[ShortLivedBigImpact since the show influenced practically every television comedy that came after it]], more audiences became used and started to like some of the trends this show popularized. This lead to Netflix reviving the show for a fourth and fifth season.\\
\\
[[WordOfGod Mitch Hurwitz]] also himself gave a reasonable accounting for the show's inital lack of success in [[https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2011/feb/12/arrested-development-mitch-hurwitz-sitcom-cancelled an article written in The Guardian]], framed as a guide on how to get a sitcom cancelled. It gives such "tips" as to [[EightDeadlyWords make all the characters unlikeable]], stuff 20-minute episodes with convoluted overlapping plotlines, and focus greatly on incest, with the final piece of "advice" being: "Make a show for British sensibilities and then show it in America."



* ImprovedByTheRecut: Season 4. When it premiered, many fans said the show should have stayed dead. However, this backlash eventually died down, partially due to how [[BrickJoke many jokes were structured to make sense only after the full season had been viewed.]] Once the season got a {{Recut}}, many viewers began to appreciate the twists and [[RewatchBonus Rewatch Bonuses]] that were lost when watched in chronological order.



* VindicatedByHistory:
** The show never really caught on when it was first airing, rave reviews kept it going for three tumultuous seasons. But after it ended the show exploded as one of the highest DVD sales and even managed a few UsefulNotes/{{syndication}} deals (100 episodes are considered the standard for a syndicated show, 65 at minimum, Arrested Development had 53). This lead to be revived as a Netflix show for the fourth season.
** Season 4 itself. When it premiered many fans said the show should have stayed dead. However, this backlash eventually died down. This may be at least partially due to how [[BrickJoke many jokes were structured to make sense only after the full season had been viewed.]] Once the season got a {{Recut}}, many viewers began to appreciate the twists and [[RewatchBonus Rewatch Bonuses]] that were lost when watched in chronological order.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Uncanny Valley is IUEO now and the subjective version has been split; cleaning up misuse and ZCE in the process


* UncannyValley: Something about pre-haircut Lindsay in Season 4 is just ''off'', with some combination of her wig showing off a lot of forehead and what seems to be really unhealthy-looking makeup, which makes Portia de Rossi look very different. This may be intentional, considering that Lindsay is supposed to have had some work done, but it's still odd.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ValuesDissonance: "Sad Sacks" from Season 2 ages poorly due to a plotline that comes off as transphobic: Lindsay is interested in Steve Holt at the same time as Maeby, but because she lost her voice, Maeby tries to make Steve lose interest by claiming Lindsay is a poorly-passing trans woman, even calling her a "tranny" and giving her a shirt to read that says "shemale", both of which are considered anti-trans slurs. None of the jokes are portrayed in a way to condemn the ignorant mindset unlike the way the show treats racial and ethnic bigotry.

to:

* ValuesDissonance: "Sad Sacks" Sack" from Season 2 ages poorly due to a plotline that comes off as transphobic: Lindsay is interested in Steve Holt at the same time as Maeby, but because she lost her voice, Maeby tries to make Steve lose interest by claiming Lindsay is a poorly-passing trans woman, even calling her a "tranny" and giving her a shirt to read that says "shemale", both of which are considered anti-trans slurs. None of the jokes are portrayed in a way to condemn the ignorant mindset unlike the way the show treats racial and ethnic bigotry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maggie Lizer, played by Creator/JuliaLouisDreyfus, is one of the most popular minor characters in the show due to her hilarious pathological liar traits. Many fans wished she was in more episodes.

Top