History YMMV / AngelBeats

16th Feb '17 1:41:02 AM echochan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* StrangledByTheRedString: Many fans felt that the [[spoiler:Otonashi and Kanade hookup]] at the finale came a bit too unexpected, as until that point it is never made evident that his feelings for her are romantic or more intense that a tepid friendship. This is one of the most divisive points of the series, and a good part of the people who didn't like the finale would have seen it better without they hooking up or at least counting on more development. Then again, given the short run of the anime, the latter would have been difficult to pull without fall in a probably not better received RomanticPlotTumor.
** The same thing occurs with [[spoiler:Yui and Hinata]] in episode 11. Considering the only sort of expression either has expressed at each other are various levels of annoyance, it comes as quite a surprise when [[spoiler:not only does Hinata say he loves Yui but [[UpToEleven wants to marry her]]]]. Even if [[spoiler:it was to help her pass on]], it's still really sudden and doesn't come with a lot of buildup.

to:

* StrangledByTheRedString: Many fans felt that the [[spoiler:Otonashi and Kanade hookup]] at the finale came a bit too unexpected, as until that point it is never made evident that his feelings for her are romantic or more intense that a tepid friendship. This is one of the most divisive points of the series, and a good part of the people who didn't like the finale would have seen it better without they hooking up or at least counting on more development. Then again, given the short run of the anime, the latter would have been difficult to pull without fall in a probably not better received RomanticPlotTumor.
RomanticPlotTumor.It doesn't help that the anime made it seem like Kanade was taking the role of surrogate sister up until that point.
** The same thing occurs with [[spoiler:Yui and Hinata]] in episode 11. Considering the only sort of expression either has expressed at each other are various levels of annoyance, it comes as quite a surprise when [[spoiler:not only does Hinata say he loves Yui but [[UpToEleven wants to marry her]]]]. Even if [[spoiler:it was to help her pass on]], it's still really sudden and doesn't come with a lot of buildup.This becomes more apparent when compared to the development of Hinata and Yuri's relationship in the prequel manga, which seems much more romantic in nature. In comparison, Yui and Hinata's rushed relationship seems more sibling-like.
19th Oct '16 5:32:09 PM Valiona
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** The setting is in some ways similar to the version of Yasogami in ''VideoGame/PersonaQShadowOfTheLabyrinth'', as a high school populated by Shadows, "NPC" characters with basic programmed responses to people, and the spirits of people who lived short and unfulfilling lives ([[spoiler:although there's only one in Persona Q's case, and the cast of both Persona 3 and 4 are all alive... for now]]). Going off this, Yui also has some similarities with [[spoiler:Rei, also known as Niko]], since both of them died quite young after being unable to do many things because of their conditions, and ultimately pass on with the help of the guys they like (Yui has Hinata and [[spoiler:Rei has Zen]]).



* FunnyAneurysmMoment: Yui prevents Hinata from winning his team's baseball game in episode 4. Six episodes later, [[spoiler:Hinata helps her move on by promising to marry her in her next life even if she's paralyzed in that life too, meaning if it weren't for him ''she'd be stuck in Purgatory for a long time!'']]

to:

* FunnyAneurysmMoment: Yui prevents Hinata from winning his team's baseball game in episode 4.4, realizing that [[spoiler:if he makes the catch that's exactly the same as the one he failed to make in life, he'll move on]]. Six episodes later, [[spoiler:Hinata helps her move on by promising to marry her in her next life even if she's paralyzed in that life too, meaning if it weren't for him ''she'd be stuck in Purgatory for a long time!'']]
31st Aug '16 2:15:16 PM Twiddler
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* CounterpartComparison: Yuri is often referred to as [[LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya Haruhi]] with a different hair color and outfit.
30th Jul '16 11:49:30 PM SingElise
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** This troper has to disagree. The fact that [[she was paralysed in life and cared for by her mother]] should not make her an unacceptable target. The fact that Hinata can attack her at all would be amazing to her. She spent all her life probably being handled with kid gloves, and it's in her character that the last thing she'd want to to be treated differently.
29th Jul '16 12:16:02 AM luisedgarf
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** In a more meta-example, the whole deal with Otonashi [[spoiler:becoming a organ donor after dying]] is this when Jun Maeda, the scriptwriter, recently announced [[spoiler:he will need a heart transplant]].
28th Mar '16 4:43:30 PM Cybaria
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** This troper has to disagree. The fact that [[she was paralysed in life and cared for by her mother]] should not make her an unacceptable target. The fact that Hinata can attack her at all would be amazing to her. She spent all her life probably being handled with kid gloves, and it's in her character that the last thing she'd want to to be treated differently.
18th Mar '16 4:07:41 PM DavidDelony
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* VindicatedByHistory: After receiving some flak for not developing some of the characters, due to the [[ExecutiveMeddling imposed halving of the number of episodes]], the series has become one of Key's most popular properties. The series female characters [[TheMerch dominate Key's merchandising tables]].

to:

* VindicatedByHistory: After receiving some flak for not developing some of the characters, due to the [[ExecutiveMeddling imposed halving of the number of episodes]], the series has become one of Key's most popular properties. The series series' female characters [[TheMerch dominate Key's merchandising tables]].
18th Mar '16 4:07:09 PM DavidDelony
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* VindicatedByHistory: After receiving some flak for not developing some of the characters, due to the [[ExecutiveMeddling imposed halving of the number of episodes]], the series has become one of Key's most popular properties.

to:

* VindicatedByHistory: After receiving some flak for not developing some of the characters, due to the [[ExecutiveMeddling imposed halving of the number of episodes]], the series has become one of Key's most popular properties. The series female characters [[TheMerch dominate Key's merchandising tables]].
24th Jan '16 3:40:54 PM SingElise
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Neither would be a MEH anyway, since nobody gets killed permanently in the main setting of the series; at worst, she's just [[KickTheDog punting puppies]].
19th Nov '15 5:55:17 PM chucknormie
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** The same thing occurs with [[spoiler:Yui and Hinata]] in episode 11. Considering the only sort of expression either has expressed at each other are various levels of annoyance, it comes as quite a surprise when [[spoiler:not only does Hinata say he loves Yui but [[UpToEleven wants to marry her]]]]. Even if [[spoiler:it was to help her pass on]], it's still really sudden and doesn't come with a lot of buildup.
This list shows the last 10 events of 124. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=YMMV.AngelBeats