Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / WITCH

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


I'm not saying that it's a rip-off of Buffy, because it's far from it and they actually are very different (and equally good) shows, but there are a few subtle ShoutOuts which imply that the creators could inspiration from the 90s sensation.

to:

I'm not saying that it's a rip-off of Buffy, because it's far from it and they actually are very different (and equally good) shows, but there are a few subtle ShoutOuts which imply that the creators could have taken inspiration from the 90s sensation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: W.I.T.C.H is at least partially inspired by BuffyTheVampireSlayer]]
It was made well after Buffy became iconic, so it's possible.
I'm not saying that it's a rip-off of Buffy, because it's far from it and they actually are very different (and equally good) shows, but there are a few subtle ShoutOuts which imply that the creators could inspiration from the 90s sensation.

Firstly, Cornelia Hale is exactly like Cordelia Chase. Both the RichBitch / AlphaBitch, as well as both being TheLancer, the ButtMonkey and they both even have similar names! In one episode of the cartoon series, a character even accidently ''calls Cornelia Cordelia!''

Secondly, Will Vandom looks a lot like Willow Rosenberg, don't you think? They're also both dorky, shy and good with computers/electronics. The only difference is that instead of being TheChick, Will is TheLeader. They both also take slow but seriously major [[TookALevelInBadass levels in badass]] (Willow become a seriously powerful witch/Will gaining the power of ShockAndAwe in season 2). Again, Will's name is Willow without the 'ow'.

Caleb in the cartoon at least appears to have at least been mildly influenced by both Angel and Spike. He has the broodiness and loner archetype that made Angel so popular, for example. You could also compare his persona to that of Spike's if he wasn't evil. A BadAssLongcoat? Check. A young wild man into rebellion and impulse? Check. A man living a completely different life to the protagonists forced to join them before discovering he doesn't really fit in with the human world (but staying anyway for that special blonde someone)? Check.

Both Buffy and W.I.T.C.H also have elements of FeministFantasy, and are very big on the idea of [[ActionGirl Action girls]].

Added: 517

Changed: 184

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternatively Heatherfield is in the neighbouring Republic of Benglait, right on the border. The reason they called the Interpol was because Benglait had recently barely avoided a civil war and still had an hell of a terrorist problem (Diabolik still hadn't got the chance to [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge settle his score with them]]), and the people in the country police who would normally deal with a possible Diabolik heist were too busy with the terrorists.

to:

** * Alternatively Heatherfield is in the neighbouring Republic of Benglait, right on the border. The reason they called the Interpol was because Benglait had recently barely avoided a civil war and still had an hell of a terrorist problem (Diabolik still hadn't got the chance to [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge settle his score with them]]), and the people in the country police who would normally deal with a possible Diabolik heist were too busy with the terrorists.
* Different alternative: they live in the Clerville of the AlternateContinuity of the cartoon. They suspected Diabolik, but didn't send Ginko because there wasn't enough evidence yet.
* Another different alternative: they live in the Clerville of the ''other'' AlternateContinuity, the one that is similar to the US seen by the Europeans (just like Heaterfield) and where Diabolik (here called DK) is still a metropolitan legend. Given the mysterious cases of almost impossible heists where every possible witness has been killed, someone in Heaterfield's police department believed that the mysterious King of Terror had come there and called whoever he could, with the Interpol sending their people.
Willbyr MOD

Changed: 38

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
hottip markup is outdated, see cleanup thread


More specifically, the W.I.T.C.H. series is set in the future (possibly extreme far future?) of the YGO universe. The recent villain Nihila is an Egyptian sorceress whose name was erased from history after her first defeat caused her to become SealedEvilInACan. Although the motive wasn't exactly the same, YGO set a precedent for this with what happened to the identity of a [[Anime/YuGiOh certain Nameless Pharaoh]]. There are also hints that the magic in both series may be the same magic.[[hottip:*: Wall of Text alert!]]

Around the time of the New Powers arc when the girls get their upgraded transformations, Will's element/power begins to be referred to as the "power to unite." In the YGO manga, Shadi's first appearance leads to him challenging the Pharaoh to a shadow game to test the unknown power of the Millennium Puzzle. At the end of the 3rd round, the pharaoh boldly declares that the puzzle's power is the "power of unity.[[hottip:*: In the Viz English translations of the manga at least. Online scans translate the puzzle's power as the "power of trust between friends."]]" This means that Will's magic is the same power as the Millennium Items. Or at least the same as the puzzle.

to:

More specifically, the W.I.T.C.H. series is set in the future (possibly extreme far future?) of the YGO universe. The recent villain Nihila is an Egyptian sorceress whose name was erased from history after her first defeat caused her to become SealedEvilInACan. Although the motive wasn't exactly the same, YGO set a precedent for this with what happened to the identity of a [[Anime/YuGiOh certain Nameless Pharaoh]]. There are also hints that the magic in both series may be the same magic.[[hottip:*: Wall [[note]]Wall of Text alert!]]

alert![[/note]]

Around the time of the New Powers arc when the girls get their upgraded transformations, Will's element/power begins to be referred to as the "power to unite." In the YGO manga, Shadi's first appearance leads to him challenging the Pharaoh to a shadow game to test the unknown power of the Millennium Puzzle. At the end of the 3rd round, the pharaoh boldly declares that the puzzle's power is the "power of unity.[[hottip:*: In [[note]]In the Viz English translations of the manga at least. Online scans translate the puzzle's power as the "power of trust between friends."]]" "[[/note]]" This means that Will's magic is the same power as the Millennium Items. Or at least the same as the puzzle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Cartoon!Phobos is a bastard]]
Nothing in the series suggests that women are the dominant sex of their society yet Elyon widely considered the rightful heir. We also see in season two that the former queen favored Phobos over her new born child. Along with the huge age gap between them it all suggests they don't have the same parents (though both are probably the queen's children since he is considered an heir later in the second season. Likely the Queen had a lover before being forced into the undesired, but legal marriage that resulted in Elyon.

Changed: 54

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


They have a deep bond, and [[http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120520210638/witch/images/1/1d/Miranda.png Miranda's human form]] is nearly identical to that of [[http://images.wikia.com/witch/images/2/27/Orube_human.jpg Orube]], Cedric's love interest in the comics, only younger and with Cedric's eyes.

to:

They have a deep bond, and [[http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120520210638/witch/images/1/1d/Miranda.png Miranda's human form]] is nearly identical to that of [[http://images.wikia.com/witch/images/2/27/Orube_human.[[http://storiesfromwitch.files.wordpress.com/2011/02/orube_human.jpg Orube]], Cedric's love interest in the comics, only younger and with Cedric's eyes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Heart of Kandrakar is TheDarkTower. It's the reservoir of mystical energy for the world at the centre of Infinity.

to:

* The Heart of Kandrakar is TheDarkTower.Franchise/TheDarkTower. It's the reservoir of mystical energy for the world at the centre of Infinity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Miranda was intended to be Cedric's adopted daughter]]
They have a deep bond, and [[http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120520210638/witch/images/1/1d/Miranda.png Miranda's human form]] is nearly identical to that of [[http://images.wikia.com/witch/images/2/27/Orube_human.jpg Orube]], Cedric's love interest in the comics, only younger and with Cedric's eyes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: ''{{WITCH}}'' is in the same universe of ''Comicbook/{{Empowered}}'']]

to:

[[WMG: ''{{WITCH}}'' ''ComicBook/{{WITCH}}'' is in the same universe of ''Comicbook/{{Empowered}}'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Irma is a follower of [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discordianism Discordianism]] because of Cornelia]]

to:

[[WMG: Irma is a follower of [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discordianism Discordianism]] UsefulNotes/{{Discordianism}} because of Cornelia]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** During the New Power Saga Will never asked Matt if he still loved her, and they didn't get back together. After that adventure [[spoiler: Matt]] returned to Kandrakar, and, when Yan Lin asked them to choose between taking the tasks or quitting being Guardians, Will was for quitting too, and convinced the others.

to:

** During the New Power Saga Will never asked Matt if he still loved her, and they didn't get back together. After that adventure [[spoiler: Matt]] returned to Kandrakar, and, when Oracle [[spoiler: Yan Lin Lin]] asked them to choose between taking the tasks or quitting being Guardians, Will was for quitting too, and convinced the others.



** When Will and Matt broke up ''again'' there wasn't the old couple that told Matt to tell Will how he really felt, and they didn't get back together.

to:

** When Will and Matt broke up ''again'' there wasn't the old couple that told Matt to tell Will how he really felt, and they didn't get back together. With that, Will decided to quit when the tasks were offered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: On the possible futures]]
Thanks to the reigning Oracle at the time we've been shown three possible futures of the Guardians. That from [[spoiler: Phobos]] had Will progressively isolating herself from her friends and being dumped by Matt, until she remained alone. The one from Himerish had the girls quit being Guardians at some point and using Orube's home as meeting place until it's seized by the city, after which Will manages to buy it back with the money from her novel inspired to their adventures as Guardians. The last, from [[spoiler: Yan Lin]], is a collection of what the girls would do in this future, with Will being a successful but overworked CEO in a company making pet food, Irma being a ''math teacher'' at an unidentified high school, Taranee being an olimpionic-level runner (and actually competing in the Olympic Games), Cornelia being a successful actress (and still having enough magic to scare into submission an arrogant actor), and Hay Lin being an housewife. How could they have happened?
* First possible future:
** Will surrendered to [[spoiler: Phobos]], but the others managed to save the day anyway, opening a rift that, with time, increased. and [[spoiler: Matt's]] memories of [[spoiler: Kandrakar]] were never awakened, with the end result being the glimpse we saw.
* Second possible future:
** During the New Power Saga Will never asked Matt if he still loved her, and they didn't get back together. After that adventure [[spoiler: Matt]] returned to Kandrakar, and, when Yan Lin asked them to choose between taking the tasks or quitting being Guardians, Will was for quitting too, and convinced the others.
** The alternative past given to us by Himerish, where Will didn't immediately take the Heart of Kandrakar. With time things snowballed in the future we've seen.
** When Will and Matt broke up ''again'' there wasn't the old couple that told Matt to tell Will how he really felt, and they didn't get back together.
* Third possible future:
** Will never moved to Heatherfield but stayed in Fadden Hill and didn't become a Guardian. As result the Guardians had another leader (possibly Orube), while Will, with little friends, threw herself into study and work, becoming a person who has "no time for a coffee, much less for love".

Changed: 63

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Will has a great love for water and is a capable swimmer too.




Added: 743

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The New Power saga revealed that Matt actually is a captain among the White Heralds of Kandrakar, yet Orube (another Kandrakar resident) failed to recognize him (and he failed to recognize her, or even to guess she was an alien), he was ignorant of Kandrakar until Will told him about it and we have seen his mother and grandfather many times. The only explanation I can find is that Matt's past life was an hero elevated as one of Kandrakar's White Heralds upon death that the Oracle reincarnated on Earth just to be safe, suppressing his memories until needed.

to:

The New Power saga revealed that Matt actually is a captain among the White Heralds of Kandrakar, yet Orube (another Kandrakar resident) failed to recognize him (and he failed to recognize her, or even to guess she was an alien), he was ignorant of Kandrakar until Will told him about it and we have seen his mother and grandfather many times. The only explanation I can find is that Matt's past life was an a hero elevated as one of Kandrakar's White Heralds upon death that the Oracle reincarnated on Earth just to be safe, suppressing his memories until needed.


Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The Keeper of the Heart manipulates the [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_interaction Interactive Forces]]]]
According to Will, the origin of her power lies in the bonds. Incidentally, the Interactive Forces are not only at the origins of any physical bond but also explain a good deal of what she and Nerissa have pulled, namely glamours, energy blasts (that other Guardians can only create on Kandrakar and in absence of their elements. The Fire Guardian can do them by focusing her heat into beams instead that fireballs) and barriers, permanently conjuring things out of thin air (Irma did the same once, but was tired and almost fainted, while a weakened Nerissa could do it without ill effects), and disintegrating people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Yes, but the only time they experienced the lack of the gift was in the same issue and never else, so it's pretty safe to assume that the gift is not something they can just give away, and replenishes on its own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe at the start. But she gave it away at the end of the Arkhanta saga.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Not necessarily in a conscious way. Just like Xing Jing gift healed Taranee's eyes to the point of no needing glasses anymore, Hay Lin might have been healed by the same thing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Hay Lin had to wear braces for so little time because of magic]]
In-universe, Hay Lin wore braces for two or three months at most. In RealLife, you wear them for years (I speak from personal experience). I can imagine her using magic to accelerate the job, and a very puzzled dentist wondering what the hell has just happened..
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Matt and Will would have been broken up if the show had continued.]]
It's hinted in the Fiftieth issue of the comics that the two will one day break up (in a possible future where the girls stop being Guardians, granted). In ''S is for Self'' the talent agent was rocking out to Wreck 55 while seemingly unimpressed with the other acts so it's a given that in-universe Matt's band has great potential. Also in the comics Matt's music career has strained their relationship at times and a possible outcome of Season 3 would have had their growing responsibilities cause a mutual (if temporary) break. [[RuleOfDrama For the drama, of course]].
** They temporarily broke up ''twice'' in the comics, both times due Guardianship-related issues (and the second time it was about to become permanent due Will and Matt [[CannotSpitItOut issues at saying 'I love you' first]]), it could happen.
Willbyr MOD

Changed: 37

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Nightmare Fuel cleanup; see thread for reference


For a place that's supposed to be located in the middle of infinity, Kandrakar is a rather easy place to get to if one has the means. In the YGO universe, anyone with the necessary magic could get into the Shadow Realm from any location. In the W.I.T.C.H. comics, anyone with the proper magic or access to a portal can get to Kandrakar from any location. Kandrakar is the [[EldritchLocation Shadow Realm]] in AFormYouAreComfortableWith. The founders of Kandrakar decided to exploit the accessibility of the Shadow Realm so they could keep watch over all worlds. While they were at it, they changed the Shadow Realm from a dark place that used to be a FateWorseThanDeath[[hottip:*: Sure 4Kids originally came up with the Shadow Realm as an alternative to [[NeverSayDie death]] but it's implied to be [[NightmareFuel a place of torment from which there is no escape unless someone from the outside can release you]].]] into the cloud-filled sanctuary of peace and order that the W.I.T.C.H. girls know it as. This would mean that Kandrakar was founded sometime after the events of YGO, since Yugi and co. had to deal with the full blown horrors that lurked in the Shadow Realm.

to:

For a place that's supposed to be located in the middle of infinity, Kandrakar is a rather easy place to get to if one has the means. In the YGO universe, anyone with the necessary magic could get into the Shadow Realm from any location. In the W.I.T.C.H. comics, anyone with the proper magic or access to a portal can get to Kandrakar from any location. Kandrakar is the [[EldritchLocation Shadow Realm]] in AFormYouAreComfortableWith. The founders of Kandrakar decided to exploit the accessibility of the Shadow Realm so they could keep watch over all worlds. While they were at it, they changed the Shadow Realm from a dark place that used to be a FateWorseThanDeath[[hottip:*: Sure FateWorseThanDeath[[note]]Sure 4Kids originally came up with the Shadow Realm as an alternative to [[NeverSayDie death]] but it's implied to be [[NightmareFuel a place of torment from which there is no escape unless someone from the outside can release you]].]] you.[[/note]] into the cloud-filled sanctuary of peace and order that the W.I.T.C.H. girls know it as. This would mean that Kandrakar was founded sometime after the events of YGO, since Yugi and co. had to deal with the full blown horrors that lurked in the Shadow Realm.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the animated series Cornelia described the look of Elyon's ideal man as tall, blonde and blue haired. Cedric fits this to a T, but so Cornelia. And they were best friends. Or it wasn't just friendship, for Elyon?

to:

In the animated series Cornelia described the look of Elyon's ideal man as tall, blonde and blue haired.blue-eyed. Cedric fits this to a T, but so Cornelia. And they were best friends. Or it wasn't just friendship, for Elyon?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* oh my god, That's Awesome! Fanfic Time!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: A requisite for being Guardians is to be a CovertPervert]]
Just ''look'' at all the crap the current set got past the radar, how Nerissa was eager to get back her looks, and how Orube (all but stated to be a potential Guardian) is apparently capable of tying herself up and mastered how to act sexy on Earth ''very'' fast in spite of being an [[FishOutOfWater alien with little knowledge of Earth's customs]]...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: The W.I.T.C.H. series takes place in the same universe as [[{{Yu-Gi-Oh}} Yu-Gi-Oh!]].]]
More specifically, the W.I.T.C.H. series is set in the future (possibly extreme far future?) of the YGO universe. The recent villain Nihila is an Egyptian sorceress whose name was erased from history after her first defeat caused her to become SealedEvilInACan. Although the motive wasn't exactly the same, YGO set a precedent for this with what happened to the identity of a [[{{Yu-Gi-Oh}} certain Nameless Pharaoh]]. There are also hints that the magic in both series may be the same magic.[[hottip:*: Wall of Text alert!]]

to:

[[WMG: The W.I.T.C.H. series takes place in the same universe as [[{{Yu-Gi-Oh}} Yu-Gi-Oh!]].Anime/YuGiOh.]]
More specifically, the W.I.T.C.H. series is set in the future (possibly extreme far future?) of the YGO universe. The recent villain Nihila is an Egyptian sorceress whose name was erased from history after her first defeat caused her to become SealedEvilInACan. Although the motive wasn't exactly the same, YGO set a precedent for this with what happened to the identity of a [[{{Yu-Gi-Oh}} [[Anime/YuGiOh certain Nameless Pharaoh]]. There are also hints that the magic in both series may be the same magic.[[hottip:*: Wall of Text alert!]]

Changed: 561

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Actually there are two. The first is the special ''5'': in it it's showed that Kandrakar has a wall with the portraits of ''all'' sets of Guardians, and while we don't see it all the Guardians seen are ''all'' females, a fact reinforced by the dialogue of the original Italian edition implying they were all females (the Italian language uses the male version of a term for mixed-gender groups, but the Guardians are always referred with the female version). Later the Trials of the Oracle arc has potential Guardian candidates, and they are ''all'' females.

Added: 1314

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Nerissa's Astral Drop became CarmenSandiego]]
Just ''look'' at the animated version of Carmen: she ''is'' Nerissa with shorter hair. She started stealing because she had no UndeadTaxExemption, then stole eternal youth.
* Alternatively, Carmen is Will's grandmother, and chose both of their names as {{Stealth Pun}}s: Susan because it derives from the Egyptian name for the lotus flower, a symbol of non-attachment (as Carmen, being first an international cop and later a wanted criminal, couldn't stay with her enough for Susan to grow attached), and Wilhelmina (meaning protector) because she had somehow recognized her as a future Guardian of Kandrakar.
** Why not both? It would explain how Carmen recognized Will's fate.
** This parentage would explain why Thomas Vandom was so desperate for money in his appearances in the comic book: he had ''sold Carmen Sandiego's house''. When Carmen arrived to make him pay, Thomas, not knowing that Susan's mother was the royally pissed wanted international thief before him (and assuming he had just messed with her organization by chance), begged to be allowed to pay her back, and was given a time limit. We can imagine Thomas got what he deserved because Susan in the end decided that the gloves were off and contacted her mother, who wouldn't have appreciated...

Changed: 462

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Alternatively Heatherfield is in the neighbouring Republic of Benglait, right on the border. The reason they called the Interpol was because Benglait had recently barely avoided a civil war and still had an hell of a terrorist problem (Diabolik still hadn't got the chance to [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge settle his score with them]]), and the people in the country police who would normally deal with a possible Diabolik heist were too busy with the terrorists.

Added: 37

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[PaperinikNewAdventures Pk or Xadhoom]] will appear in a future issue. if it's PK, the girls will fight evronians... and maybe [[LampshadeHanging point out how different he is from the comic books they read as kids]]. if it's Xadhoom, the girls will realize exactly what will's powers are: pure energy, like Xadhoom.
in universe, it's plausible. dimensional travel has been in the Pk comics and is, literally, the Guardian's job. also, the oracle will inform the guardians that , somehow, [[MetaFiction their Timeline diverged off from Xadhoom's]].

to:

[[PaperinikNewAdventures Pk or Xadhoom]] will appear in a future issue. if If it's PK, the girls will fight evronians... and Evronians... And maybe [[LampshadeHanging point out how different he is from the comic books they read as kids]]. if If it's Xadhoom, the girls will realize exactly what will's powers are: pure energy, like Xadhoom.
in In universe, it's plausible. dimensional Dimensional travel has been in the Pk comics and is, literally, the Guardian's job. also, Also, the oracle Oracle will inform the guardians that , Guardians that, somehow, [[MetaFiction their Timeline diverged off from Xadhoom's]]. Xadhoom's]].
* {{Jossed}} by the end of the comic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


in universe, it's plausible. dimensional travel has been in the Pk comics and is, literally, the Guardian's job. also, the oracle will inform the guardians that , somehow, [[MetaFiction their Timeline diverged off from Xadhoom's]]

to:

in universe, it's plausible. dimensional travel has been in the Pk comics and is, literally, the Guardian's job. also, the oracle will inform the guardians that , somehow, [[MetaFiction their Timeline diverged off from Xadhoom's]]Xadhoom's]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


in universe, it's plausible. dimensional travel has been in the Pk comics and is, literally, the Guardian's job. also, the oracle will inform the guardians that , somehow, [[MetaFiction their Timeline diverged off Xadhoom's]]

to:

in universe, it's plausible. dimensional travel has been in the Pk comics and is, literally, the Guardian's job. also, the oracle will inform the guardians that , somehow, [[MetaFiction their Timeline diverged off from Xadhoom's]]

Top