Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / SaladFingers

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This theory might explain things about how the ResetButton works in Salad Fingers' world. For example, in Episode 10 he seems to have become elderly due to a Rip Van Winkle-like sequence of events, but his aging is undone by the next episode. This makes sense if he's sometimes replaced with a younger version of himself, as is explicitly depicted in Episode 13. Further, it might explain his apparent insanity as being the result of CloneDegeneration over time.

to:

This theory might explain things about how the ResetButton works in Salad Fingers' world. For example, in Episode 10 he seems to have become elderly due to a Rip Van Winkle-like sequence of events, but his aging is undone by the next episode. This makes sense if he's sometimes replaced with a younger version of himself, as is explicitly depicted in Episode 13. Further, it might explain his apparent insanity as being the result of CloneDegeneration over time.time.

That Salad Fingers' "platoon" is related to the process depicted in Episode 13 is further suggested by the fact that Episode 13 contains the first military reference in a while — Salad Fingers' last words, "Give my regards to the colonel."

Added: 3664

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----

to:

----
[[WMG: The events of Episode 13 are not a one-off but rather something that regularly occurs in Salad Fingers' world— Salad Fingers is regularly killed and replaced by a clone in some form of TwinMaker system, which grants him a sort of ResurrectiveImmortality. He asexually reproduces clones that share his memories in some way, and is later killed and eaten by the clone. This occurs in ''both'' Episode 6 and Episode 13, at minimum. He is aware of this process.]]

Doubles of Salad Fingers have been depicted at various points throughout the series. In particular, they are shown in Episode 6, Episode 10, and Episode 13 (where the creation of the duplicate is centre focus of the whole episode). They're sometimes exact doubles (as in Episode 6), malformed and unintelligent (as in Episode 10), or "immature" but quickly aging into an exact double (as in Episode 13).

Consistent across all these appearances is doubles of Salad Fingers being cannibals and eating other Salad Fingers. One Salad Fingers eats the other's brains like a zombie in Episode 6, without it being clear which is the "original". The malformed Salad Fingers in Episode 10 are indiscriminately gorging themselves on unidentified seemingly-human viscera. Episode 13 depicts the cannibalism as ritualistic and makes clear the "clone" Salad Fingers has killed and eaten the original.

Episode 9 and Episode 13 both have "offspring" bursting from Salad Fingers's body, which he treats as a normal occurance. This suggests it's normal for him to experience something like budding/blastogenesis. Note that for all the things he's encountered that he's found shocking or frightening, he's never found the presence of a double in itself shocking or frightening. The only possible exception is the encounter between the two Salad Fingers at the end of Episode 6, and in that case one was aggressively making accusations against the other. They are treated with "normalcy", even when they've been an actual threat to him.

In Episode 9, Salad Fingers seems very sick when "blastogenesis" happens and the "offspring" is just an inanimate blob, which he still treats as a child— this is something like a miscarriage. In Episode 13, however, the process results in the creation of a healthy clone. While Salad Fingers teaches this clone some things, the clone is born inheriting knowledge, like to call Salad Fingers "Mr. Fingers", and by the end of the episode, the clone acts like he's had long familiarity with Salad Fingers' [[CompanionCube companion cubes]]. Thus, sometimes the "reproduction" process produces malformed, unviable offspring, but other times it produces a near perfect memory-sharing double. Therefore it is possible that one and the same process be behind the various doubles of Salad Fingers that have been seen in various episodes. The fact that there is usually only one Salad Fingers around is explained by their propensity for cannibalizing each other— and perhaps the cannibalism is necessary in some way, perhaps to pass on memories. As soon as the clone in Episode 13 separates from the original's body, they discuss how delicious the original will be, suggesting they both expect the cannibalism from the beginning.

This theory might explain things about how the ResetButton works in Salad Fingers' world. For example, in Episode 10 he seems to have become elderly due to a Rip Van Winkle-like sequence of events, but his aging is undone by the next episode. This makes sense if he's sometimes replaced with a younger version of himself, as is explicitly depicted in Episode 13. Further, it might explain his apparent insanity as being the result of CloneDegeneration over time.

Added: 82

Changed: 168

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Salad Fingers was raised in an abusive household.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers was raised in an abusive household.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is a woman from an alternate [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarI WWI]] that went nuclear.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is a woman from an alternate [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarI WWI]] that went nuclear.]]



[[WMG: David Firth is Chris Cunningham]]

to:

[[WMG: David [[WMG:David Firth is Chris Cunningham]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers eating himself at the end of episode 6 is a metaphor for...]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers eating himself at the end of episode 6 is a metaphor for...]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is based off David Firth's dreams (or nightmares)]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is based off David Firth's dreams (or nightmares)]]



[[WMG: When Salad Fingers seemed to be consuming himself in Episode 5, he was really consuming the little puppet, and remembering consuming one of his platoon members, who look like he does.]]

to:

[[WMG: When [[WMG:When Salad Fingers seemed to be consuming himself in Episode 5, he was really consuming the little puppet, and remembering consuming one of his platoon members, who look like he does.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is a Hive Mind.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is a Hive Mind.]]



[[WMG: There Was a Nuclear War]]

to:

[[WMG: There [[WMG:There Was a Nuclear War]]



* But,wait! It gets worse!

The Great War is the same one in the fallout universe,and it is set in a particularly Bombed area of The United States. The girl that you saw during the picnic episode? She was from Shady Sands,and was looking for some help,because she got kidnapped by raiders but managed to escape and ran off,leading her to this hellhole!

But,wait! If this is set in the fallout universe,where is all the Raiders,or the brotherhood?

Seriously? Who would want to go to the place where Salad Fingers lived? Anyway,the brotherhood only come when there is tech,and the only technology I saw in the series was that bloody radio,and that probably didn't even work in the first place! The raiders also come when there is stuff to pil-- HEY! Wait! Maybe they did come! Maybe Salad Fingers was an odd ghoul living there,with the long fingers and all,and went totally insane when he saw the raiders destroying everything he knew! Maybe he had friends! Those were the sock puppets! Maybe it's set just after the war,since he says to a sock puppet that he didn't see him,since the person who the puppet was based on was a soldier in the great war...

Hey,wait. That doesn't make sense. The Great War was nuclear warfare,so...HOW CAN YOU GO TO A NUCLEAR WAR?

Maybe Salad Fingers meant the resource wars,not the great war. That was probably the nickname for the resource wars.

to:

* But,wait! But, wait! It gets worse!

worse!\\
\\
The Great War is the same one in the fallout universe,and universe, and it is set in a particularly Bombed area of The United States. The girl that you saw during the picnic episode? She was from Shady Sands,and Sands, and was looking for some help,because help, because she got kidnapped by raiders but managed to escape and ran off,leading off, leading her to this hellhole!

But,wait!
hellhole!\\
\\
But, wait!
If this is set in the fallout universe,where is all the Raiders,or Raiders, or the brotherhood?

brotherhood?\\
\\
Seriously? Who would want to go to the place where Salad Fingers lived? Anyway,the Anyway, the brotherhood only come when there is tech,and tech, and the only technology I saw in the series was that bloody radio,and radio, and that probably didn't even work in the first place! The raiders also come when there is stuff to pil-- HEY! Wait! Maybe they did come! Maybe Salad Fingers was an odd ghoul living there,with there, with the long fingers and all,and all, and went totally insane when he saw the raiders destroying everything he knew! Maybe he had friends! Those were the sock puppets! Maybe it's set just after the war,since war, since he says to a sock puppet that he didn't see him,since him, since the person who the puppet was based on was a soldier in the great war...

Hey,wait.
war...\\
\\
Hey, wait.
That doesn't make sense. The Great War was nuclear warfare,so...warfare, so...HOW CAN YOU GO TO A NUCLEAR WAR?

WAR?\\
\\
Maybe Salad Fingers meant the resource wars,not wars, not the great war. That was probably the nickname for the resource wars.



[[WMG: Not only was there a nuclear war, WebAnimation/SaladFingers is a DistantSequel to Film/{{Threads}}.]]

to:

[[WMG: Not [[WMG:Not only was there a nuclear war, WebAnimation/SaladFingers is a DistantSequel to Film/{{Threads}}.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is [[{{Music/Gorillaz}} Murdoc Niccals']] mother. ]]

[[WMG: Salad Fingers is [[Franchise/TheHitchHikersGuideToTheGalaxy The Man Who Rules the Universe.]]]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is [[{{Music/Gorillaz}} Murdoc Niccals']] mother. ]]

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is [[Franchise/TheHitchHikersGuideToTheGalaxy The Man Who Rules the Universe.]]]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is a ShellShockedVeteran.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is a ShellShockedVeteran.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers was a Historian with a Specialty in World War I Who went Mad After a Nuclear War]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers was a Historian with a Specialty in World War I Who went Mad After a Nuclear War]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is a Time Lord]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is a Time Lord]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is raped at the end of episode 4.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is raped at the end of episode 4.]]



[[WMG: The finger puppets, and the radio represent Salad Fingers' friends and family from before the Great War.]]

to:

[[WMG: The [[WMG:The finger puppets, and the radio represent Salad Fingers' friends and family from before the Great War.]]



[[WMG: The man in the BBQ apron has similar delusions.]]

to:

[[WMG: The [[WMG:The man in the BBQ apron has similar delusions.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is somehow related to Franchise/{{the Slender Man|Mythos}}]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is somehow related to Franchise/{{the Slender Man|Mythos}}]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers takes place in the TabletopGame/{{Warhammer 40000}} Universe]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad
[[WMG:Salad
Fingers takes place in the TabletopGame/{{Warhammer 40000}} Universe]]



[[WMG: Everything that is happening in the salad fingers world happens perfectly normally]]

to:

[[WMG: Everything [[WMG:Everything that is happening in the salad fingers world happens perfectly normally]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers's home was bombed out while he was in the safety cupboard]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers's home was bombed out while he was in the safety cupboard]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers actually had a sister named Bourdoise, who died in the fallout.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers actually had a sister named Bourdoise, who died in the fallout.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is [[Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer Drusilla]].]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is [[Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer Drusilla]].]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is a survivor of a ZombieApocalypse.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is a survivor of a ZombieApocalypse.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers takes place in an Alternate history of WWI]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers takes place in an Alternate history of WWI]]



[[WMG: WebAnimation/SaladFingers is a survivor of the [[VideoGame/XCom First Alien War]].]]

to:

[[WMG: WebAnimation/SaladFingers [[WMG:WebAnimation/SaladFingers is a survivor of the [[VideoGame/XCom First Alien War]].]]



[[WMG: The girl in episode 5 is just another level of delusion]]

to:

[[WMG: The [[WMG:The girl in episode 5 is just another level of delusion]]



[[WMG: The whole thing never happened]]

to:

[[WMG: The [[WMG:The whole thing never happened]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is an alternate version of Lennie from Literature/OfMiceAndMen]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is an alternate version of Lennie from Literature/OfMiceAndMen]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers takes place in the aftermath of {{Film/Threads}}]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers takes place in the aftermath of {{Film/Threads}}]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers takes place inside the Instrumentality]]

[[WMG: Salad Fingers, WesternAnimation/AdventureTime, and WebAnimation/CharlieTheUnicorn all take place in the same universe]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers takes place inside the Instrumentality]]

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers, WesternAnimation/AdventureTime, and WebAnimation/CharlieTheUnicorn all take place in the same universe]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is the Ruler of the Universe.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is the Ruler of the Universe.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is a scarred war veteran living in our world and hallucinating.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is a scarred war veteran living in our world and hallucinating.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers killed his whole family.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers killed his whole family.]]



[[WMG: There is no way to explain what is happening in the show]]

to:

[[WMG: There [[WMG:There is no way to explain what is happening in the show]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is more than just insane.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is more than just insane.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is Marjory Stewart-Baxter, and some things in the series clue us in on her life before "The Great War."]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is Marjory Stewart-Baxter, and some things in the series clue us in on her life before "The Great War."]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is a preschool children's cartoon that airs in a CrapsackWorld.]]

[[WMG: Salad Fingers is the biological father of Vendetta from WesternAnimation/MakingFiends]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is a preschool children's cartoon that airs in a CrapsackWorld.]]

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is the biological father of Vendetta from WesternAnimation/MakingFiends]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is a woman who tried to have an abortion]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is a woman who tried to have an abortion]]



[[WMG: Andrew Hands is either Salad Fingers' real name, or the name of somebody from his past.]]

to:

[[WMG: Andrew [[WMG:Andrew Hands is either Salad Fingers' real name, or the name of somebody from his past.]]



[[WMG: The ''"CrapsackWorld"'' Salad Fingers lives in is actually extremely localized.]]

to:

[[WMG: The [[WMG:The ''"CrapsackWorld"'' Salad Fingers lives in is actually extremely localized.]]



[[WMG: The world of Salad Fingers was created by an EldritchAbomination.]]

to:

[[WMG: The [[WMG:The world of Salad Fingers was created by an EldritchAbomination.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is merely a senile old man living in his house, suffering from a combination of both PTSD and Dementia.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is merely a senile old man living in his house, suffering from a combination of both PTSD and Dementia.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers has retreated into a hallucinatory fantasy as a psychological defense mechanism.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers has retreated into a hallucinatory fantasy as a psychological defense mechanism.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers is the collective consciousness of the traumatized children living through the horrors of war, abuse etc.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers is the collective consciousness of the traumatized children living through the horrors of war, abuse etc.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers never fought in the Great War, and now is coping with survivor's guilt because of it.]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers never fought in the Great War, and now is coping with survivor's guilt because of it.]]



[[WMG: Salad Fingers 11: Glass Brother is a joke at the expense of theorists]]

to:

[[WMG: Salad [[WMG:Salad Fingers 11: Glass Brother is a joke at the expense of theorists]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Salad Fingers 11: Glass Brother is a joke at the expense of theorists]]
If you've scrolled this far you've already read several different interpretations of Salad Fingers being a victim of some kind of trauma/abuse, whether due to the Great War, an unstable upbringing or his perpetual loneliness. David Firth is well aware of this side of his fanbase, even going as far as to discredit Matpat's video on the subject, saying he was completely off. Firth has said in interviews that many of his videos are inspired by his emotional reactions to the world and media around him (examples being The News Hasn't Happened Yet, David Firth's Health Reminder and several episodes of both Burnt Face Man and Jerry Jackson satirising pop culture, the latter even having an episode poking fun at low quality parodies of Salad Fingers).

The fact that the very next episode of Salad Fingers following Matpat's video was Episode 11: Glass Brother, in which we get a glimpse of Salad Fingers in an abusive household with very direct storytelling compared to the rest of the series, it's possible this is Firth [[FandomNod giving theorists exactly what they want]] [[PanderingToTheBase knowing they will eat it up,]] with Glass Mother even referencing an unseen "father" character at the very end as a cliffhanger to keep theorists busy.

This isn't to say Episode 11 was entirely made cynically or out of obligation to a fanbase demanding answers, but no doubt the episode was at least inspired by this aspect of his audience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Salad Fingers never fought in the Great War, and now is coping with survivor's guilt because of it.]]
This theory is mostly founded in a reading of Episode 7, when Salad Fingers says to his brother Kenneth, "It was frightfully rude of you blokes to leave for the great war without me." His delusions likely began before the war but worsened considerably afterward. Even in World War I's era (presuming that it is the real Great War which Salad Fingers refers to), a man with delusional tendencies would probably have been rejected from the armed forces as unfit for service. Given his occasional hostility to his brother's corpse throughout the episode, it stands to reason that Salad Fingers holds considerably mixed emotions about the men who went to fight, who were likely direct witnesses to the disaster that left the world in its present state, as well as its first victims (hence why confirmed veteran Jeremy Fisher's potential death is shown in relative detail an episode prior). In the aftermath, Salad Fingers has doubled down on his delusional thinking as a way to cope with both his guilt over surviving whereas so many other men like his brother did not and his deep-seated feelings of emasculation and inadequacy over being rejected from service to begin with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Salad Fingers is the collective consciousness of the traumatized children living through the horrors of war, abuse etc.]]
He's not one person. Rather, he's the personification of all the children experiencing the tragic effects of war. The adult tone of some of SF's adventures (saying rusty spoons are orgasmic) are repeated hearsay from either their family or any homeless people they come across and they implement it into child's play without knowing its actual meaning. The radio station reporting on the news gives the children information on the "Great War", and gives them additional topics to work into their worldview, hence its commanding tone as the children consider it the only source of learning they have of the outside world and lets it mend their impressionable minds in disturbing ways (even if it confuses and saddens them). The children were raised in these circumstances and don't consider any of it weird or horrifying as it's part of their everyday life, which would explain SF's casual non sequiturs to everything strange that happens around him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG:The reason why Salad Fingers acts and sees the world the way he does is because he's under the influence of drugs]]
He might be using some kind of drug to calm his nerves and put his mind at ease after all the troubles he has supposedly gone through in his life. The drug he might be using could be hallucinogenic, which is probably why his mental state is so screwy and he has all these weird visions of different people or things. Kind of makes sense if you think about it, doesn't it?

to:

[[WMG:The reason why Salad Fingers acts and sees the world the way he does is because he's under the influence of illegal drugs]]
He might be using some kind of drug (maybe cocaine, LSD, mescaline, PCP, cannabis, ketamine, salvia, or something of the like) to calm his nerves and put his mind at ease after all the troubles he has supposedly gone through in his life. The drug he might be using could be hallucinogenic, which is probably why his mental state is so screwy and he has all these weird visions of different people or things. Kind of makes sense if you think about it, doesn't it?

Top