Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / Pinocchio

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
wmg

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Monstro's rage at the climax was motivated for fear of bad publicity]]
You're Monstro, a giant monster whale. You've established yourself quite nicely as [[TheDreaded the terror of the deep]]. None of the sea creatures can utter your name even. [[TheJailer Nothing escapes your belly, ever.]] You pride yourself upon it. Then one day a lit fire from inside [[StatusQuoIsGod disturbs your tranquil binge eating]], forcing you to sneeze mightily, and there go two insignificant people... ''swimming away from you''. As a beast of nature, driven by instincts, you'd think hunger is the sole driving force for your enraged state. No, what makes you terrifying is you're a [[ItCanThink monster with a brain]]. Two tiny people don't even count as a snack, [[PragmaticVillainy they are not worth the effort to get one's self all worked up and chasing after.]] ''[[PrideBeforeAFall But your ego won't allow it.]]'' If the other oceanic creatures hear about this, ''you'll be a laughing stock''. [[RevengeBeforeReason You have to chase them. You must catch them. Swallow them again. See that shore? What about that shore?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* He’s not in it for the money, since in all honesty, Pleasure Island is just about the worst business idea ever. Not only do you have to pay to build the damned place, but you also have to pay to repair it every time you use it…and there’s just no way this is economically feasible. No, he’s in it ForTheEvulz. The money just keeps people like the Fox and the Cat happy, so they can continue collecting stupid little boys for him.




to:

* Actually, that’s what I always thought too.

Added: 1445

Changed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fishing inside Monstro; Pinocchio\'s direction sense







to:

* Not necessarily. Fishing inside Monstro could have sustained Geppetto.



** Whoa. That right there? *FridgeBrilliance. Particularly if you consider that the residual magic somehow "knew" to transition from pigs to donkeys, in order to show the boys they were being literal...ya know.

to:

** * Whoa. That right there? *FridgeBrilliance.FridgeBrilliance. Particularly if you consider that the residual magic somehow "knew" to transition from pigs to donkeys, in order to show the boys they were being literal...ya know.


Added DiffLines:


[[WMG:Pinocchio can feel the earth's geomagnetic field.]]
%% May need to be moved to a page about "Christmas in Cartoontown" once that gets a summary.
Pinocchio's nose gets longer when he is under stress. In the book, it's a more generic [[TheTell tell for different kinds of stress]], but in animated adaptations, this tic is [[PinocchioNose limited to lying]], and there's a difference between lying (saying what is not, on purpose) and being mistaken. ''WesternAnimation/ChristmasInCartoontown'' has a scene where someone asks Pinocchio for directions, and we see a close-up on Pinocchio's face until it becomes clear that his nose won't get any longer. This focus on Pinocchio's lie tic implies that Pinocchio must be [[TheNavigator confident in the direction]]. So one of two things must be true:
* In RealLife, [[http://www.buzzle.com/articles/the-effect-of-magnetism-on-plant-growth.html geomagnetism affects plant growth]]. Being a wood {{golem}}, Pinocchio has plant sense. This would end after he takes human form.
* Alternate hypothesis: A wearable compass like the [[http://www.cracked.com/article_20604_6-ways-technology-can-give-you-super-senses_p2.html North Paw compass]] exists in the animated fairy tale universe. It measures Earth's geomagnetic field and vibrates part of a band worn around the user's ankle. This ends up training the brain to figure out where north points, and the effect would persist after he takes human form.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Paradoxes


Imagine if he said, "Either my nose will grow or dinosaurs come back to life."

to:

Imagine if he said, "Either my nose will grow or dinosaurs come back to life.""
* Jossed. In the book other forms of stress cause his nose to grow. So telling a paradox would likely cause the same effect as telling a lie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**Whoa. That right there? *FridgeBrilliance. Particularly if you consider that the residual magic somehow "knew" to transition from pigs to donkeys, in order to show the boys they were being literal...ya know.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Probably the only thing that could change them back in this movie is the Blue Fairy. She'd probably do it, but not before reminding the boys that it was their own foolishness that got them in this predicament. She'd give them a second chance and maybe the boys would be better behaved after what happened.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Lampy ends up being sold to a Tijuana Donkey Show]]
He turned into a donkey when The Coachman and all of his workers were busy loading the other boys turned donkeys into crates for manual labor. It is likely that the manual labor donkeys get sold and shipped first and then the boys that turn to donkeys later get shipped to places like Tijuana for sick pleasure purposes. Pinocchio would've also be sold there if not for Jiminy and the Fairy Godmother turning him back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: The Coachman is actually a demon who is turning boys into donkeys just to be a dick]]

to:

[[WMG: The Coachman is actually a demon who is turning boys into donkeys just to be a dick]]dick]]

[[WMG: Pinocchio is Omnipotent]]
Imagine if he said, "Either my nose will grow or dinosaurs come back to life."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Donkey from Shrek is one of the kids from Pleasure Island who could still talk]]

to:

[[WMG: Donkey from Shrek {{Shrek}} is one of the kids from Pleasure Island who could still talk]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: The Coachman is [[IMMeen]]'s father]]

to:

[[WMG: The Coachman is [[IMMeen]]'s IMMeen's father]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The Coachman is [[IMMeen]]'s father]]
Why hasn't anybody done a theory like this, i mean, sit for a while and think about it


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Jossed by the very utterance of "stuffed with sawdust". He was based on a plush donkey to begin with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


He lost his tail in an escape attempt. The trauma from that whole experience explains why Eeyore is depressed. The rest of the gang of the 100 acre wood doesn't know about Eeyore's depressing back story, except maybe Owl, who used it as blackmail material to steal Piglet's house.

to:

He lost his tail in an escape attempt. The trauma from that whole experience explains why Eeyore is depressed. The rest of the gang of the 100 acre wood doesn't know about Eeyore's depressing back story, except maybe Owl, who used it as blackmail material to steal Piglet's house.house.

[[WMG: The Coachman is actually a demon who is turning boys into donkeys just to be a dick]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Updated to meet new Nightmare Fuel criteria.


* [[Tropers/TheMightyHeptagon This troper]] always liked to think so as a kid. Not necessarily because I think it's likely, but because the image of the boys turning into donkeys and being shipped off to the salt mines was literally '''''[[HighOctaneNightmareFuel keeping me from sleeping]]'''''.

to:

* [[Tropers/TheMightyHeptagon This troper]] always liked to think so as a kid. Not necessarily because I think it's likely, but because the image of the boys turning into donkeys and being shipped off to the salt mines was literally '''''[[HighOctaneNightmareFuel '''''[[NightmareFuel keeping me from sleeping]]'''''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


If Pinocchio himself appears in the movies, than an appearance of a P.I. donkey can be canon too.

to:

If Pinocchio himself appears in the movies, than an appearance of a P.I. donkey can be canon too.too.

[[WMG: Eeyore from Winnie The Pooh was one of the kids from Pleasure Island who could still talk]]
He lost his tail in an escape attempt. The trauma from that whole experience explains why Eeyore is depressed. The rest of the gang of the 100 acre wood doesn't know about Eeyore's depressing back story, except maybe Owl, who used it as blackmail material to steal Piglet's house.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Pleasure Island is really of the Isle of Aeanea--the island where Circe turned Odysseus' crew into pigs]]

to:

[[WMG: Pleasure Island PleasureIsland is really of the Isle of Aeanea--the island where Circe turned Odysseus' crew into pigs]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This applies to both the original novel and the Disney film. In Literature/TheOdyssey, Circe lived on Aeanea, a mythical island that was supposedly off the west coast of Italy. By the time of Pinocchio, Circe was long gone but enough residual free-standing magic existed for the boys turn to into donkeys if they stayed there long enough.

to:

This applies to both the original novel and the Disney film. In Literature/TheOdyssey, Circe lived on Aeanea, a mythical island that was supposedly off the west coast of Italy. By the time of Pinocchio, Circe was long gone but enough residual free-standing magic existed for the boys turn to into donkeys if they stayed there long enough.enough.

[[WMG: Donkey from Shrek is one of the kids from Pleasure Island who could still talk]]
If Pinocchio himself appears in the movies, than an appearance of a P.I. donkey can be canon too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


E.g. a day on P.I. is, say, a month outside the island, which would explain why Geppetto's house/workshop looked like it had been abandoned for weeks although Pinocchio was seemingly only gone for a day or two. This would also explain the line "Not a bite for days..."

to:

E.g. a day on P.I. is, say, a month outside the island, which would explain why Geppetto's house/workshop looked like it had been abandoned for weeks although Pinocchio was seemingly only gone for a day or two. This would also explain the line "Not a bite for days...""

[[WMG: Pleasure Island is really of the Isle of Aeanea--the island where Circe turned Odysseus' crew into pigs]]
This applies to both the original novel and the Disney film. In Literature/TheOdyssey, Circe lived on Aeanea, a mythical island that was supposedly off the west coast of Italy. By the time of Pinocchio, Circe was long gone but enough residual free-standing magic existed for the boys turn to into donkeys if they stayed there long enough.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None






to:

* [[Tropers/TheMightyHeptagon This troper]] always liked to think so as a kid. Not necessarily because I think it's likely, but because the image of the boys turning into donkeys and being shipped off to the salt mines was literally '''''[[HighOctaneNightmareFuel keeping me from sleeping]]'''''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This came from a page on TVTropes that states that some of the people he hired would expect to be paid. He's actually ''losing money'' rather than gaining. How's that for LaserGuidedKarma?

to:

This came from a page on TVTropes that states that some of the people he hired would expect to be paid. He's actually ''losing money'' rather than gaining. How's that for LaserGuidedKarma?LaserGuidedKarma?

[[WMG: Pinocchio spends more time on Pleasure Island than the film shows]]
In the book, he spends five months on the island. Who's to say he didn't spend that much time there in the film? The movie probably only showed the first and last days he was there--anything more would have been redundant. Either that, or...

[[WMG: Time flows differently on Pleasure Island than it does in the "real" world]]
E.g. a day on P.I. is, say, a month outside the island, which would explain why Geppetto's house/workshop looked like it had been abandoned for weeks although Pinocchio was seemingly only gone for a day or two. This would also explain the line "Not a bite for days..."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


And they go and rescue the donkeys. They also tell other townspeople, and everyone invades the island to save the donkeys. It just takes place after the Disney film. Not that there should be a sequel of course.

to:

And they go and rescue the donkeys. They also tell other townspeople, and everyone invades the island to save the donkeys. It just takes place after the Disney film. Not that there should be a sequel of course.course.

[[WMG: The Coachman goes bankrupt soon after the Pleasure Island incident]]
This came from a page on TVTropes that states that some of the people he hired would expect to be paid. He's actually ''losing money'' rather than gaining. How's that for LaserGuidedKarma?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


And they go and rescue the donkeys. They also tell other townspeople, and everyone invades the island to save the donkeys.

to:

And they go and rescue the donkeys. They also tell other townspeople, and everyone invades the island to save the donkeys. It just takes place after the Disney film. Not that there should be a sequel of course.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Pinocchio eventually tells Geppetto about Pleasure Island]]

And they go and rescue the donkeys. They also tell other townspeople, and everyone invades the island to save the donkeys.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG:Pinocchio is a bad liar because he's a golem.]]

Pinocchio meets the definition of a wood {{golem}}. Some golems are branded with a word for "truth", such as Hebrew אמת (''emet''). So deviating from the truth causes him great pain and stress, which sets off his PinocchioNose.


[[WMG:Figaro is a FunnyAnimal as an adult cat like Gideon is.]]

Figaro is a NearlyNormalAnimal as a kitten. He is Geppetto's cat in Pinocchio and [[ClassicDisneyShorts Minnie Mouse's]] cat in his other appearances, but sleeps in a bed like a person would and walks on two legs sometimes, so there are a few CivilizedAnimal qualities in him. When he becomes an adult cat, he becomes a FunnyAnimal similar to the manner that Gideon is.

[[WMG:Monstro is a Leviathan melvilli.]]
Leviathan melvilli is a prehistoric whale. Monstro can't be a Sperm Whale because they only have teeth on the bottom jaw. The prehistric whale had teeth on the top and bottom jaws like Monstro.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Figaro is an IntellectualAnimal as a kitten. He is Geppetto's cat in Pinocchio and [[ClassicDisneyShorts Minnie Mouse's]] cat in his other appearances, but sleeps in a bed like a person would and walks on two legs sometimes, so there are a few CivilizedAnimal qualities in him. When he becomes an adult cat, he becomes a FunnyAnimal similar to the manner that Gideon is.

to:

Figaro is an IntellectualAnimal a NearlyNormalAnimal as a kitten. He is Geppetto's cat in Pinocchio and [[ClassicDisneyShorts Minnie Mouse's]] cat in his other appearances, but sleeps in a bed like a person would and walks on two legs sometimes, so there are a few CivilizedAnimal qualities in him. When he becomes an adult cat, he becomes a FunnyAnimal similar to the manner that Gideon is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Figaro is an IntellectualAnimal as a kitten. He is Geppetto's cat in Pinocchio and [[ClassicDisneyShorts Minnie Mouse's]] cat in his other appearances, but sleeps in a bed like a person would and walks on two legs sometimes, so there are a few CivilizedAnimal qualities in him. When he becomes an adult cat, he becomes a FunnyAnimal similar to the manner that Gideon is.

to:

Figaro is an IntellectualAnimal as a kitten. He is Geppetto's cat in Pinocchio and [[ClassicDisneyShorts Minnie Mouse's]] cat in his other appearances, but sleeps in a bed like a person would and walks on two legs sometimes, so there are a few CivilizedAnimal qualities in him. When he becomes an adult cat, he becomes a FunnyAnimal similar to the manner that Gideon is.is.

[[WMG:Monstro is a Leviathan melvilli.]]
Leviathan melvilli is a prehistoric whale. Monstro can't be a Sperm Whale because they only have teeth on the bottom jaw. The prehistric whale had teeth on the top and bottom jaws like Monstro.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Figaro is an IntellectualAnimal as a kitten. He is Geppetto's cat in Pinocchio and Minnie Mouse's cat in his other appearances, but sleeps in a bed like a person would and walks on two legs sometimes, so there are a few CivilizedAnimal qualities in him. When he becomes an adult cat, he becomes a FunnyAnimal similar to the manner that Gideon is.

to:

Figaro is an IntellectualAnimal as a kitten. He is Geppetto's cat in Pinocchio and [[ClassicDisneyShorts Minnie Mouse's Mouse's]] cat in his other appearances, but sleeps in a bed like a person would and walks on two legs sometimes, so there are a few CivilizedAnimal qualities in him. When he becomes an adult cat, he becomes a FunnyAnimal similar to the manner that Gideon is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Figaro is an IntellectualAnimal as a kitten, but becomes more of a FunnyAnimal when he becomes an adult cat.

to:

Figaro is an IntellectualAnimal as a kitten, kitten. He is Geppetto's cat in Pinocchio and Minnie Mouse's cat in his other appearances, but becomes more of sleeps in a FunnyAnimal when bed like a person would and walks on two legs sometimes, so there are a few CivilizedAnimal qualities in him. When he becomes an adult cat.cat, he becomes a FunnyAnimal similar to the manner that Gideon is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:



[[WMG:Figaro is a FunnyAnimal as an adult cat like Gideon is.]]

Figaro is an IntellectualAnimal as a kitten, but becomes more of a FunnyAnimal when he becomes an adult cat.

Top