Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Still some ambiguity, moving back to open
Deleted line(s) 553,563 (click to see context) :
[[WMG: Jewelry Bonney [[spoiler:is the daughter of a Tenryubito]]]]
Oh yeah, with this one, you can easily see why Akainu would be fucking terrified that she's running around [[spoiler:With this theory, she may not necessarily be that young, but she's so damn spoiled she doesn't a) act with any maturity (no noble we've seen so far has) and b) give a damn about other peoples lives. If her parents even cared the slightest bit about her, for any reason at all, would be enough to explain why she is walking around free currently. Hell, if this is true, it would be enough to get her a 100 million bounty on the spot.]]
** What hurts this theory, by my own admission, is the fact that absolutely no one has mentioned this even once when it would normally be mentioned a dozen times. [[spoiler:Though it could be that noble pirates aren't exactly scarce. Sabo certainly wanted to be one badly enough, and Whitey Bay was certainly dressed pretty fancy.]]
*** [[spoiler:Considering Chapter 722 revealed that Doflamingo is a World Noble, despite also being a [albeit former] pirate, Bonney being related to the Tenryubito isn't that out there.]]
*** [[spoiler:...How exactly is that revelation relevant to that theory? It's not like that spoilered person and Bonney are related, they're two completely different pirates.]]
*** [[spoiler:They're saying she's related to the Tenryubito in general, not Doflamingo in particular, so their statement probably is more relevant to the theory in light of that.]]
* [[spoiler:Kuma's her father, so unless he's a former World Noble, that looks jossed.]]
* The central premise is confirmed, while most other assumptions are jossed. Bonney [[spoiler:is the biological child of a World Noble, but was born to Ginny, an escaped slave-wife, and raised by Kuma.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[WMG: Jewelry Bonney [[spoiler:is the daughter of a Tenryubito]]]]
Oh yeah, with this one, you can easily see why Akainu would be fucking terrified that she's running around [[spoiler:With this theory, she may not necessarily be that young, but she's so damn spoiled she doesn't a) act with any maturity (no noble we've seen so far has) and b) give a damn about other peoples lives. If her parents even cared the slightest bit about her, for any reason at all, would be enough to explain why she is walking around free currently. Hell, if this is true, it would be enough to get her a 100 million bounty on the spot.]]
** What hurts this theory, by my own admission, is the fact that absolutely no one has mentioned this even once when it would normally be mentioned a dozen times. [[spoiler:Though it could be that noble pirates aren't exactly scarce. Sabo certainly wanted to be one badly enough, and Whitey Bay was certainly dressed pretty fancy.]]
*** [[spoiler:Considering Chapter 722 revealed that Doflamingo is a World Noble, despite also being a [albeit former] pirate, Bonney being related to the Tenryubito isn't that out there.]]
*** [[spoiler:...How exactly is that revelation relevant to that theory? It's not like that spoilered person and Bonney are related, they're two completely different pirates.]]
*** [[spoiler:They're saying she's related to the Tenryubito in general, not Doflamingo in particular, so their statement probably is more relevant to the theory in light of that.]]
* [[spoiler:Kuma's her father, so unless he's a former World Noble, that looks jossed.]]
* The central premise is confirmed, while most other assumptions are jossed. Bonney [[spoiler:is the biological child of a World Noble, but was born to Ginny, an escaped slave-wife, and raised by Kuma.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
[[center:[-[[WMG/OnePiece One Piece WMG Main Index]] | [[WMG/OnePieceOpenOne Open Theories, Part One]] | [[WMG/OnePieceOpenTwo Open Theories, Part Two]] | [[WMG/OnePieceOpenThree Open Theories, Part Three]] | [[WMG/OnePieceConfirmed Confirmed Theories, Part One]] | [[WMG/OnePieceConfirmedTwo Confirmed Theories, Part Two]] | [[WMG/OnePieceJossed Jossed Theories, Part One]] | [[WMG/OnePieceJossedPartTwo Jossed Theories, Part Two]] | [[WMG/OnePieceJossedPartThree Jossed Theories, Part Three]] | [[WMG/OnePieceStrawhatCrew Straw Hat Crew]] | [[WMG/OnePieceFriendsAndAllies Friends And Allies]] | [[WMG/OnePieceWarlordsAndEmperors Warlords And Emperors]] | [[WMG/OnePieceMarinesAndGovernment Marines And World Government]] | [[WMG/OnePieceOtherCharacters Other Characters]] | [[WMG/OnePieceHistoryAndLore Plot, History and Lore]] | [[WMG/OnePieceMeta Meta]] | [[WMG/OnePieceSilly Silly And Just For Fun Theories]]-]]]
to:
[[center:[-[[WMG/OnePiece One Piece WMG Main Index]] | [[WMG/OnePieceOpenOne Open Theories, Part One]] | [[WMG/OnePieceOpenTwo Open Theories, Part Two]] | [[WMG/OnePieceOpenThree Open Theories, Part Three]] | [[WMG/OnePieceConfirmed Confirmed Theories, Part One]] | [[WMG/OnePieceConfirmedTwo Confirmed '''Confirmed Theories, Part Two]] Two''' | [[WMG/OnePieceJossed Jossed Theories, Part One]] | [[WMG/OnePieceJossedPartTwo Jossed Theories, Part Two]] | [[WMG/OnePieceJossedPartThree Jossed Theories, Part Three]] | [[WMG/OnePieceStrawhatCrew Straw Hat Crew]] | [[WMG/OnePieceFriendsAndAllies Friends And Allies]] | [[WMG/OnePieceWarlordsAndEmperors Warlords And Emperors]] | [[WMG/OnePieceMarinesAndGovernment Marines And World Government]] | [[WMG/OnePieceOtherCharacters Other Characters]] | [[WMG/OnePieceHistoryAndLore Plot, History and Lore]] | [[WMG/OnePieceMeta Meta]] | [[WMG/OnePieceSilly Silly And Just For Fun Theories]]-]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[WMG: Jinbei will manage to catch up to the crew in the two-week interim.]]
Two weeks would give him plenty of time to escape Big Mom, recover if he was injured, and meet up with the rest of the Straw Hats on Wano. And although it's a bit of a stretch, maybe he'd also carry a bit of extra news with him, since Wano is isolated from the rest of the world.
* Jinbe's [[TheBusCameBack bus did come back]] in Wano, so for all intents and purposes, this is confirmed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[WMG: Vivi and Cobra's ancestors were forced to hide the truth about the foundation of the World Government]]
The Nefertaris were among the 20 founding families of the WG centuries ago but were the only family that decided to not move to Mariejois and become Celestial Dragons. Why? Maybe they were lied by their allies about the Ancient Kingdom, thinking they were eradicating an evil regime, or [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone they realized the extent of their actions]] and were disgusted by themselves. Either way, they wanted to reveal the truth to the world at large but were threatened with the destruction of Alabasta by the newly formed Dragons, and were probably also forced to destroy any document that could lead to the truth. They, however, had later a part in the creation and posing of the Poneglyphs around the world.
* Confirmed
The Nefertaris were among the 20 founding families of the WG centuries ago but were the only family that decided to not move to Mariejois and become Celestial Dragons. Why? Maybe they were lied by their allies about the Ancient Kingdom, thinking they were eradicating an evil regime, or [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone they realized the extent of their actions]] and were disgusted by themselves. Either way, they wanted to reveal the truth to the world at large but were threatened with the destruction of Alabasta by the newly formed Dragons, and were probably also forced to destroy any document that could lead to the truth. They, however, had later a part in the creation and posing of the Poneglyphs around the world.
* Confirmed
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[WMG: One of Sanji's brothers will be a major ally.]]
To go along with the above WMG of Sanji's father becoming a major villain, maybe one of Sanji's brothers (or other siblings, if he has any) will side with him to take down their father; either for personal reasons or because he/she thinks Mr. Vinsmoke went too far.
** Chapter 826 has introduced Yonji, who has the same exact reaction to beautiful women as his older brother Sanji. Unless ''all'' male Vinsmokes are that way, he could be a good candidate since he may share Sanji's chivalry towards women.
** If I had to bet, it would probably be the second son. The first and Yonji seem to be too evil so far. At the very least, the second son called the first on his bullshit when he said he "couldn't wait to see Sanji", so it's a good sign.
** Isn't it going to be his sister? One Piece had used female-villain-turned-good plots several times (ex: Robin, Viola, even Vivi and Nami to minor extent) and she kinda reminded me of how Nojiko acted to Nami.
*** After what we've learned in Chapter 840, this is even more likely to be the case.
** It isn't looking too likely right now considering how cruel they were to Sanji, giving him a ''very'' good reason to hate his family's guts. The possibility of a HeelFaceTurn from one of them still remains, but it's not very high yet.
** Aaand chapter 839 brought the chances of this WMG happening to oblivion; between the fact that Sanji's siblings laughed imagining the various ways he'd die after running away when they were kids, Niji's incredibly petty attitude and his beatdown of Cosette which made Sanji hate him even more, there's no way in hell they'll ever be anything more than enemies.
** And now [[spoiler: ''all'' of the brothers are allies!]] So in a strange way, this ended up being true.
** Confirmed for his sister Reiju.
[[WMG: During the Reverie, someone will make an attempt on Cobra's life, and may even be successful]]
After the timeskip Cobra is seen gravely ill, to the point he is confined to a wheelchair to go and attend the Reverie. All this while he intends to ask the World Government about ancient history, and we all know their attitude about the subject. Those are worrisome flags of a possible death of the character. Bonus points if the Ryugyu royals are framed for it, with basically the same consequences Hody's crazy plans would have caused.
* Confirmed (not the Ryugyu framing part, but someone ''did'' get framed). Cobra was killed by [[spoiler: the Five Elders and Imu]] who framed Sabo for it after the fact.
[[WMG: There's a traitor among the Ninja-Mink-Pirate Alliance]]
Inuarashi suspects that a Vivre Card was used by Jack to find Zou. Only the Minks, Raizo, and the Heart Pirates were on Zou when Jack got there. Since we all know Inu "suggesting" that a Vivre Card was used is Oda's way of saying "yeah, Jack definitely had a Vivre Card", the only two possible explanations is that they somehow got somebody's card without them knowing... or there's a traitor on Zou who gave it to them.
* Confirmed. The traitor was [[spoiler: Kanjuro]].
To go along with the above WMG of Sanji's father becoming a major villain, maybe one of Sanji's brothers (or other siblings, if he has any) will side with him to take down their father; either for personal reasons or because he/she thinks Mr. Vinsmoke went too far.
** Chapter 826 has introduced Yonji, who has the same exact reaction to beautiful women as his older brother Sanji. Unless ''all'' male Vinsmokes are that way, he could be a good candidate since he may share Sanji's chivalry towards women.
** If I had to bet, it would probably be the second son. The first and Yonji seem to be too evil so far. At the very least, the second son called the first on his bullshit when he said he "couldn't wait to see Sanji", so it's a good sign.
** Isn't it going to be his sister? One Piece had used female-villain-turned-good plots several times (ex: Robin, Viola, even Vivi and Nami to minor extent) and she kinda reminded me of how Nojiko acted to Nami.
*** After what we've learned in Chapter 840, this is even more likely to be the case.
** It isn't looking too likely right now considering how cruel they were to Sanji, giving him a ''very'' good reason to hate his family's guts. The possibility of a HeelFaceTurn from one of them still remains, but it's not very high yet.
** Aaand chapter 839 brought the chances of this WMG happening to oblivion; between the fact that Sanji's siblings laughed imagining the various ways he'd die after running away when they were kids, Niji's incredibly petty attitude and his beatdown of Cosette which made Sanji hate him even more, there's no way in hell they'll ever be anything more than enemies.
** And now [[spoiler: ''all'' of the brothers are allies!]] So in a strange way, this ended up being true.
** Confirmed for his sister Reiju.
[[WMG: During the Reverie, someone will make an attempt on Cobra's life, and may even be successful]]
After the timeskip Cobra is seen gravely ill, to the point he is confined to a wheelchair to go and attend the Reverie. All this while he intends to ask the World Government about ancient history, and we all know their attitude about the subject. Those are worrisome flags of a possible death of the character. Bonus points if the Ryugyu royals are framed for it, with basically the same consequences Hody's crazy plans would have caused.
* Confirmed (not the Ryugyu framing part, but someone ''did'' get framed). Cobra was killed by [[spoiler: the Five Elders and Imu]] who framed Sabo for it after the fact.
[[WMG: There's a traitor among the Ninja-Mink-Pirate Alliance]]
Inuarashi suspects that a Vivre Card was used by Jack to find Zou. Only the Minks, Raizo, and the Heart Pirates were on Zou when Jack got there. Since we all know Inu "suggesting" that a Vivre Card was used is Oda's way of saying "yeah, Jack definitely had a Vivre Card", the only two possible explanations is that they somehow got somebody's card without them knowing... or there's a traitor on Zou who gave it to them.
* Confirmed. The traitor was [[spoiler: Kanjuro]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding Confirmed theories
Added DiffLines:
[[WMG: Capone Bege's plan will be derailed in the most surprising and delightful ways]]
The moment I read what he's going to do, I thought that's unlikely to happen, whenever Luffy is involved in a plan he will find a way to screw it up, even when it's unintentional. Oda generally doesn't do deaths in the present with a couple exceptions. And finally Big Mom is a literal and figurative human juggernaut, killing a yonko is nigh-impossible (look at how much punishment Whitebeard took before he finally stopped moving). Just doesn't seem likely.
* Hm, well, so far, everything's going according to plan. We'll see soon enough though.
* Well, it was indeed derailed. I'm not sure if you would call it surprising though.... I think just about everybody figured Big Mom herself would stop the missiles in one way or another. Delightful though, I agree. The looks on their faces when she blew the missiles up were pretty hilarious.
[[WMG:Something terrible will happen at the Reverie, and the Revolutionaries will be framed for it.]]
What better scapegoats than them to justify the "cleansing" that the Five Elders want to carry out, after all?
* Pretty much confirmed: [[spoiler: Cobra was killed (something terrible) and Sabo (a Revolutionary) was framed for it]].
[[WMG: Post-Wano, Kaido and Big Mom will both be deposed]]
In turn, their replacements will be Luffy and Edward Weevil, with the Heart Pirates, Kid Pirates, and Firetank Pirates all joining the Grand Strawhat Fleet.
* Alternate guess: Charlotte Katakuri and Yamato will take over their parent's respective crews (with Katakuri renaming the "Big Mom Pirates" into the "Charlotte Pirates"), and lead them in allying with the Straw Hats.
** Base guess confirmed; Kaido and Big Mom have both been defeated and are no longer considered Emperors; and Luffy is now one of the Four. However, it's ''Buggy'' who's the new Emperor alongside him instead of Weevil.
[[WMG: Ryokugyu has wind-based or plant-based Devil Fruit powers]]
Mostly just a line of thought based on the fact that all Admirals to date have had an elemental or at least force-of-nature Devil Fruit and all of them have powers whose typical color associations match up with their title.
* "Red Dog" Akainu/Sakazuki has fiery Magma which is typically associated with red.
* "Blue Pheasant" Aokiji/Kuzan has Ice which is typically associated with blue.
* "Yellow Monkey" Kizaru/Borsalino has Light which is typically somewhere in the white/yellow/gold spectrum.
* "Wisteria (Purple) Tiger" Fujitora/Issho has Gravity which usually has a purple association.
Given this, it would make sense for "Green Bull" Ryokugyu to have a power that fits that theme, and green is usually associated with either wind or plants in terms of elemental colors. Plants might have a bonus point here in that he's been stated to have been fasting for three years, which might be less absurd if he can somehow photosynthesize.
* Confirmed; Ryokugyu does have plant-based powers.
[[WMG: Luffy will defeat Kaido by developing Gear 5.]]
Which, like Gear 4, will involve inflating his muscles and armoring / infusing himself with Haki... but it'll be ''Conqueror's Haki'' this time.
* Alternatively, it will be another form of Gear 4 but this time based on Conqueror's Haki called either Lionman or Kingman
* Confirmed, Luffy does defeat Kaido after developing Gear 5.
[[WMG: Imu is ''not'' Nefertari Lily]]
Chapter 1084 ends with Imu appearing in front of Cobra as he was asking the Five Stars about his ancestor, the only founding member of the World Government who declined to move to Mariejois, who however disappeared and never returned to Arabasta. The quick conclusion would be that Lily did in fact join the Dragons as ''their leader'' and was scrubbed off history to allow her to keep her secrecy as the shadow sovereign of the new world that had been created (the Nefertari dinasty may have passed her story to descendants only orally, escaping the WG's detection for centuries).\\
What if however it was just a big RedHerring and Imu was a different person, while still hailing from the same time as her (possibly thanks to the Ope-Ope Fruit)? Possibly someone who loved her and still holds a grudge, and has now an interest in Vivi because she looks a lot like her ancestor?\\
\\
As for Lily, whatever happened to her that caused her to never return to Arabasta, she may have still left a mark on history, somewhere else.\\
Amazon '''Lily'''.
* Well, Imu is not Nefertari Lili, so that part is confirmed... however the reason Lili and the other Nefertari did not become Celestial Dragons is because they're [[spoiler: part of the D clan]].
The moment I read what he's going to do, I thought that's unlikely to happen, whenever Luffy is involved in a plan he will find a way to screw it up, even when it's unintentional. Oda generally doesn't do deaths in the present with a couple exceptions. And finally Big Mom is a literal and figurative human juggernaut, killing a yonko is nigh-impossible (look at how much punishment Whitebeard took before he finally stopped moving). Just doesn't seem likely.
* Hm, well, so far, everything's going according to plan. We'll see soon enough though.
* Well, it was indeed derailed. I'm not sure if you would call it surprising though.... I think just about everybody figured Big Mom herself would stop the missiles in one way or another. Delightful though, I agree. The looks on their faces when she blew the missiles up were pretty hilarious.
[[WMG:Something terrible will happen at the Reverie, and the Revolutionaries will be framed for it.]]
What better scapegoats than them to justify the "cleansing" that the Five Elders want to carry out, after all?
* Pretty much confirmed: [[spoiler: Cobra was killed (something terrible) and Sabo (a Revolutionary) was framed for it]].
[[WMG: Post-Wano, Kaido and Big Mom will both be deposed]]
In turn, their replacements will be Luffy and Edward Weevil, with the Heart Pirates, Kid Pirates, and Firetank Pirates all joining the Grand Strawhat Fleet.
* Alternate guess: Charlotte Katakuri and Yamato will take over their parent's respective crews (with Katakuri renaming the "Big Mom Pirates" into the "Charlotte Pirates"), and lead them in allying with the Straw Hats.
** Base guess confirmed; Kaido and Big Mom have both been defeated and are no longer considered Emperors; and Luffy is now one of the Four. However, it's ''Buggy'' who's the new Emperor alongside him instead of Weevil.
[[WMG: Ryokugyu has wind-based or plant-based Devil Fruit powers]]
Mostly just a line of thought based on the fact that all Admirals to date have had an elemental or at least force-of-nature Devil Fruit and all of them have powers whose typical color associations match up with their title.
* "Red Dog" Akainu/Sakazuki has fiery Magma which is typically associated with red.
* "Blue Pheasant" Aokiji/Kuzan has Ice which is typically associated with blue.
* "Yellow Monkey" Kizaru/Borsalino has Light which is typically somewhere in the white/yellow/gold spectrum.
* "Wisteria (Purple) Tiger" Fujitora/Issho has Gravity which usually has a purple association.
Given this, it would make sense for "Green Bull" Ryokugyu to have a power that fits that theme, and green is usually associated with either wind or plants in terms of elemental colors. Plants might have a bonus point here in that he's been stated to have been fasting for three years, which might be less absurd if he can somehow photosynthesize.
* Confirmed; Ryokugyu does have plant-based powers.
[[WMG: Luffy will defeat Kaido by developing Gear 5.]]
Which, like Gear 4, will involve inflating his muscles and armoring / infusing himself with Haki... but it'll be ''Conqueror's Haki'' this time.
* Alternatively, it will be another form of Gear 4 but this time based on Conqueror's Haki called either Lionman or Kingman
* Confirmed, Luffy does defeat Kaido after developing Gear 5.
[[WMG: Imu is ''not'' Nefertari Lily]]
Chapter 1084 ends with Imu appearing in front of Cobra as he was asking the Five Stars about his ancestor, the only founding member of the World Government who declined to move to Mariejois, who however disappeared and never returned to Arabasta. The quick conclusion would be that Lily did in fact join the Dragons as ''their leader'' and was scrubbed off history to allow her to keep her secrecy as the shadow sovereign of the new world that had been created (the Nefertari dinasty may have passed her story to descendants only orally, escaping the WG's detection for centuries).\\
What if however it was just a big RedHerring and Imu was a different person, while still hailing from the same time as her (possibly thanks to the Ope-Ope Fruit)? Possibly someone who loved her and still holds a grudge, and has now an interest in Vivi because she looks a lot like her ancestor?\\
\\
As for Lily, whatever happened to her that caused her to never return to Arabasta, she may have still left a mark on history, somewhere else.\\
Amazon '''Lily'''.
* Well, Imu is not Nefertari Lili, so that part is confirmed... however the reason Lili and the other Nefertari did not become Celestial Dragons is because they're [[spoiler: part of the D clan]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[WMG: Buggy is now an Emperor]]
It'd be the sort of thing that Oda does.
** Confirmed in chapter 1053: By [[OffscreenMomentOfAwesome means currently unknown,]] Buggy has risen to fill one of the now vacant spots.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
One of the confirmations was shown to be incorrect later on
Changed line(s) 147 (click to see context) from:
to:
** The specific confirmation above is Jossed, but the WMG is confirmed : [[spoiler: Capone ends up being an ally fro Whole Cake Island, but both Apoo and Hawkins are villains working under Kaido in Wano.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is for when creators die and leave work unfinished. Actors don't count.
Changed line(s) 443 (click to see context) from:
[[WMG: [[AuthorExistenceFailure What will be done about Gold Roger's voice actor]] ]]
to:
[[WMG: [[AuthorExistenceFailure What will be done about Gold Roger's voice actor]] actor ]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 482 (click to see context) from:
* [[spoiler: Definitely 100% confirmed by Chapter 999. We still don't know Kadio's species' name yet, we definitely do know now that he is definitely now not a dragon as it is reveal he ate the Mystical Model of the Fish-Fish Fruit (whatever the hell that he meant for now).]]
to:
* [[spoiler: Definitely 100% confirmed by Chapter 999. We still don't know Kadio's species' name yet, we definitely do know now that he is definitely now not a dragon as it is reveal he ate the Mystical Model of the Fish-Fish Fruit (whatever the hell that he meant for now).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 482 (click to see context) from:
* [[spoiler: Definitely 100% confirmed by Chapter 999. We don't know Kadio's species' name yet, we definitely do know now that he is most definitely not a dragon since he ate the Mystical Model of the Fish-Fish Fruit (whatever the hell that he meant for now).]]
to:
* [[spoiler: Definitely 100% confirmed by Chapter 999. We still don't know Kadio's species' name yet, we definitely do know now that he is most definitely now not a dragon since as it is reveal he ate the Mystical Model of the Fish-Fish Fruit (whatever the hell that he meant for now).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[WMG:Yamato will be used to confirm Kaido's species]]
Kaido is AmbiguouslyHuman and there're various hints that he may be a dragon or an Oni. Yamato will be used as a ShowDontTell to put this theory to rest.
* [[spoiler: Confirmed. While we don't know the name of his species just yet, we now know that he is most definitely not a dragon.]]
* [[spoiler: Definitely 100% confirmed by Chapter 999. We don't know Kadio's species' name yet, we definitely do know now that he is most definitely not a dragon since he ate the Mystical Model of the Fish-Fish Fruit (whatever the hell that he meant for now).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Changed line(s) 313 (click to see context) from:
*** I apologize as well, I didn't clearly explain my believe that WMGs are not supposed to be argued with, but only Confirmed or Jossed after the fact. Your suggestion is very interesting, and if true would require further flashbacks to show the aftermath, like how and when Carmel die (she has to be since her power went to Big Mom), how Big Mom got her hands on the Soul power, how the government lost the plot and got a Yonko instead of a Fleet Admiral out of the deal. I like it very much.
to:
*** I apologize as well, I didn't clearly explain my believe that WMGs [=WMGs=] are not supposed to be argued with, but only Confirmed or Jossed after the fact. Your suggestion is very interesting, and if true would require further flashbacks to show the aftermath, like how and when Carmel die (she has to be since her power went to Big Mom), how Big Mom got her hands on the Soul power, how the government lost the plot and got a Yonko instead of a Fleet Admiral out of the deal. I like it very much.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[WMG:Kyoshiro is actually Denjiro]]
We know he faked Hiyori’s death somehow, allowing her to escape. Denjiro has not appeared at all in the present, the only red scabbard not to do so. Perhaps the reason is he’s acting as a mole within Orochi’s shogunate?
* If Denjiro had just dyed his hair and worked it into a pompadour, he could well pass as Kyoshiro. Maybe Kin'emon's dyed hair was brought in as a low-key {{Foreshadowing}}?
* Confirmed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[WMG: Caribou is the Buggy of the New World]]
He has a reason to continue pursuing Luffy. He was introduced as someone to be feared, and after a run-in with a certain Straw Hat he's been reduced to more of a laughing stock. Plus, if Buggy is busy with things like being a Warlord as some other theories suggest, then they need someone else to fill the roll of the guy who chases Luffy even though he'll never beat Luffy. This would also tie in with the WMG of the Fishman Island arc being a mesh or echo of the East Blue events.
* It does seem to be going in this direction, since Coribou has gotten a ButtMonkey Cover Arc, similar to how Buggy did way back when.
**somewhat confirmed, but this isn't a guess with a concrete yes/no. However, guess who Luffy met in prison during the Wano arc, like how he met Buggy in Impel Down? And if what OP meant by "Buggy" was being comic relief, Caribou is ''definitely'' that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 2,3 (click to see context) from:
[[foldercontrol]]
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[center:[-[[WMG/OnePiece One Piece WMG Main Index]] | [[WMG/OnePieceOpenOne Open Theories, Part One]] | [[WMG/OnePieceOpenTwo Open Theories, Part Two]] | [[WMG/OnePieceOpenThree Open Theories, Part Three]] | [[WMG/OnePieceConfirmed Confirmed Theories, Part One]] | [[WMG/OnePieceConfirmedTwo Confirmed Theories, Part Two]] | [[WMG/OnePieceJossed Jossed Theories, Part One]] | [[WMG/OnePieceJossedPartTwo Jossed Theories, Part Two]] | [[WMG/OnePieceJossedPartThree Jossed Theories, Part Three]] | [[WMG/OnePieceStrawhatCrew Straw Hat Crew]] | [[WMG/OnePieceFriendsAndAllies Friends And Allies]] | [[WMG/OnePieceWarlordsAndEmperors Warlords And Emperors]] | [[WMG/OnePieceMarinesAndGovernment Marines And World Government]] | [[WMG/OnePieceOtherCharacters Other Characters]] | [[WMG/OnePieceHistoryAndLore Plot, History and Lore]] | [[WMG/OnePieceMeta Meta]] | [[WMG/OnePieceSilly Silly And Just For Fun Theories]]-]]]
[[foldercontrol]]
[[foldercontrol]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[WMG: Pudding isn't actually acting, she just thinks she is]]
She actually has [[SplitPersonality dissociative identity disorder]], with her good personality being completely unaware of the evil one's existence and the evil one thinking the good personality is fake.
* Jossed, we see her voluntarily turn her fake good girl act back on when she sees Brook in chapter 853.
** Seems that it is unjossed now. Boy that girl has issues...
*Confirmed
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 459 (click to see context) from:
* Confirmed, actually! The reason he's able to swim in the water despite being a DF user is that he's just that big.
to:
* Confirmed, actually! The reason he's able to swim in the water despite being a DF user is that he's just ''just that big.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 459 (click to see context) from:
* Confirmed, actually! The reason he's able to swim in the water despite being a DF user is that he's *just that big.*
to:
* Confirmed, actually! The reason he's able to swim in the water despite being a DF user is that he's *just just that big.*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
[[WMG: In the opposite of [[http://onepiece.wikia.com/wiki/Bruce Bruce]]. San Juan Wolf has a DF that enables him to increase in size.]]
Makes sense on how he was able to be placed in Impel Down, and why he's so big.
* Call that one as good as Jossed, considering that he has to swim alongside the Blackbeard Pirates' raft because he's too big for it.
* Confirmed, actually! The reason he's able to swim in the water despite being a DF user is that he's *just that big.*
Makes sense on how he was able to be placed in Impel Down, and why he's so big.
* Call that one as good as Jossed, considering that he has to swim alongside the Blackbeard Pirates' raft because he's too big for it.
* Confirmed, actually! The reason he's able to swim in the water despite being a DF user is that he's *just that big.*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving the theory about Kurozumi Orochi fruit here
Added DiffLines:
[[WMG: Kurozumi ate the Ryu Ryu/Hebi Hebi no Mi: Model Yamata no Orochi]]
* Hebi Hebi no Mi, Model: Yamata no Orochi confirmed.
* Hebi Hebi no Mi, Model: Yamata no Orochi confirmed.
