Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / HarryPotterAndTheMethodsofRationality

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Oh wow, totally screwed my formatting.


[[[[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/WMG/HarryPotterAndTheMethodsOfRationalityConfirmed Confirmed WMG goes here.]]
[[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/WMG/HarryPotterAndTheMethodsOfRationalityJossed Jossed WMG goes here.

to:

[[[[http://tvtropes.* [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/WMG/HarryPotterAndTheMethodsOfRationalityConfirmed Confirmed WMG goes here.]]
* [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/WMG/HarryPotterAndTheMethodsOfRationalityJossed Jossed WMG goes here.
here.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Now that the fic is over, gonna start sorting this page. Help would be appreciated.

Added DiffLines:

Now that the fic is over, this page is currently in the process of being sorted for Confirmed and Jossed WMG's.
[[[[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/WMG/HarryPotterAndTheMethodsOfRationalityConfirmed Confirmed WMG goes here.]]
[[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/WMG/HarryPotterAndTheMethodsOfRationalityJossed Jossed WMG goes here.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Except that in MOR horcruxes work totally differently.




to:

** Except that in the early chapters it's mentioned that the last straw for Petunia marrying Vernon was that he wanted to call their son Dudley Dursley...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A Horcrux is not a soul fragment or a ghost. It is a backup of the brain-state of the caster, stored on some physical medium. (Think Joss's DollHouse or Charles Stross's ''Glasshouse'' here, among other sources.) Restoring from this backup, however, requires a target to restore onto; with current levels of magic technology, that means a living human being's brain, which is overwritten with the restored brain-state.

to:

A Horcrux is not a soul fragment or a ghost. It is a backup of the brain-state of the caster, stored on some physical medium. (Think Joss's DollHouse Series/{{Dollhouse}} or Charles Stross's ''Glasshouse'' here, among other sources.) Restoring from this backup, however, requires a target to restore onto; with current levels of magic technology, that means a living human being's brain, which is overwritten with the restored brain-state.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Jossed by word of god. He confirm it was just an ordinary diary by Roger Bacon and even if it was Tom Riddle's diary, she still would had to touch it to be overwritten.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Or, as an alternative: Harry's new office really is up high in the internal structure of Hogwarts. It's just that the entire internal structure of Hogwarts is underground, while the castle only contains (magical equivalents of) [=WarpZones=], to make it look like a normal castle. The advantage of building Hogwarts like this was that its builders were not constrained by its outer physical shape and they could make any sort of arrangement to the inside without altering the external shape of the castle.

to:

* Or, as an alternative: Harry's new office really is up high in the internal structure of Hogwarts. It's just that the entire internal structure of Hogwarts is underground, while the castle only contains (magical equivalents of) [=WarpZones=], to make it look like a normal castle. The advantage of building Hogwarts like this was that its builders were not constrained by its outer physical shape and they could make any sort of arrangement to the inside without altering the external shape of the castle. As a nice side effect, it also makes the inside of Hogwarts almost invulnerable to external attacks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As a further corollary: this realization will make Harry wonder for a little while whether Cliff Bleszinski was a wizard, then he will dismiss it as an amusing coincindence.

to:

** As a further corollary: this realization will make Harry wonder for a little while whether Cliff Bleszinski was a wizard, then he will dismiss it as an amusing coincindence.coincindence.
* Or, as an alternative: Harry's new office really is up high in the internal structure of Hogwarts. It's just that the entire internal structure of Hogwarts is underground, while the castle only contains (magical equivalents of) [=WarpZones=], to make it look like a normal castle. The advantage of building Hogwarts like this was that its builders were not constrained by its outer physical shape and they could make any sort of arrangement to the inside without altering the external shape of the castle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Specifically, it's not "high enough in Hogwarts that nobody looking from the outside would see a piece of castle corresponding to where Harry now sat". Instead, it is underground, in a room that is only connected to the castle by an invisible portal. The office proper is surrounded by another room, where all walls, as well as the floor and ceiling, are enchanted to project a 3D image of the lands surrounding Hogwarts, as they would ''look like'' from somewhere high above the castle.

to:

Specifically, it's not "high enough in Hogwarts that nobody looking from the outside would see a piece of castle corresponding to where Harry now sat". Instead, it is underground, in a room that is only connected to the castle by an invisible portal. The office proper is surrounded by another room, where all walls, as well as the floor and ceiling, are enchanted to project a 3D image of the lands surrounding Hogwarts, as they would ''look like'' look like from somewhere high above the castle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As a further corollary: this realization will make Harry wonder for a little while whether Cliff Bleszinsky was a wizard, then he will dismiss it as an amusing coincindence.

to:

** As a further corollary: this realization will make Harry wonder for a little while whether Cliff Bleszinsky Bleszinski was a wizard, then he will dismiss it as an amusing coincindence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As a corollary: '''Harry will figure this out in 1998, after trying to edit an [[VideoGame/UnrealI Unreal]] level.''' The Unreal engine can handle this very effect: to implement it, it is enough to use two WarpZones to connect two locations, add a SkyZoneInfo high above the main part of the level, and check the ''Fake Backdrop'' and ''Unlit'' tags on every surface that must project the image of the skybox.

to:

* As a corollary: '''Harry will figure this out in 1998, after trying to edit an [[VideoGame/UnrealI Unreal]] level.''' The Unreal engine can handle this very effect: to implement it, it is enough to use two WarpZones [=WarpZones=] to connect two locations, add a SkyZoneInfo [=SkyZoneInfo=] high above the main part of the level, and check the ''Fake Backdrop'' and ''Unlit'' tags on every surface that must project the image of the skybox.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Voldemort is still alive. She has a nigh-indestructable, superhuman body that radiates an aura of pureness, and once again has Harry's trust to the point that Harry is sending her on missions.

to:

Voldemort is still alive. She has a nigh-indestructable, superhuman body that radiates an aura of pureness, and once again has Harry's trust to the point that Harry is sending her on missions.missions.

[[WMG: Harry's new office is not where it appears to be]]
Specifically, it's not "high enough in Hogwarts that nobody looking from the outside would see a piece of castle corresponding to where Harry now sat". Instead, it is underground, in a room that is only connected to the castle by an invisible portal. The office proper is surrounded by another room, where all walls, as well as the floor and ceiling, are enchanted to project a 3D image of the lands surrounding Hogwarts, as they would ''look like'' from somewhere high above the castle.
* As a corollary: '''Harry will figure this out in 1998, after trying to edit an [[VideoGame/UnrealI Unreal]] level.''' The Unreal engine can handle this very effect: to implement it, it is enough to use two WarpZones to connect two locations, add a SkyZoneInfo high above the main part of the level, and check the ''Fake Backdrop'' and ''Unlit'' tags on every surface that must project the image of the skybox.
** As a further corollary: this realization will make Harry wonder for a little while whether Cliff Bleszinsky was a wizard, then he will dismiss it as an amusing coincindence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 456

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Everything speaks for Quirrell doing it. He notices stuff, like Margaret Bulstrode having a Time Turner. He would have noticed that the Weasley twins somehow knew when to hide and where to go – maybe already when helping them with Skeeter, which he most likely did – and he would have found out how. And memory charmed them again, since they obviously didn't remember that it was a map they had. He must have been hoping that Harry would shed his restraints when Hermione was dead.

to:

Everything speaks for Quirrell doing it. He notices stuff, like Margaret Bulstrode having a Time Turner. He would have noticed that the Weasley twins somehow knew when to hide and where to go – maybe already when helping them with Skeeter, which he most likely did and he would have found out how. And memory charmed them again, since they obviously didn't remember that it was a map they had. He must have been hoping that Harry would shed his restraints when Hermione was dead.



* Confirmed.

to:

* Confirmed.Confirmed.

[[WMG: Hermione is Voldemort now]]
Going off the 'Roger Bacon diary is Tom Riddle's journal' theory. Killing Quirrell was just for show (and to get rid of a loose end). Giving Hermione the journal was really just to allow the Voldemort save state to copy itself.

Voldemort is still alive. She has a nigh-indestructable, superhuman body that radiates an aura of pureness, and once again has Harry's trust to the point that Harry is sending her on missions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Not so, but the Grangers did become the Noble House of Granger, with Hermione as it's only magical member.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Nope, turns out he was serious.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


He was "delinquent" in that he failed to keep the Death Eaters together. He was extremely useful during the original establishment of the DE, because, as he said to Neville, the Dark Lord needed the cooperation of House Malfoy to get people to join his cause. And he has lost much, including his wife.

to:

He was "delinquent" in that he failed to keep the Death Eaters together. He was extremely useful during the original establishment of the DE, because, as he said to Neville, the Dark Lord needed the cooperation of House Malfoy to get people to join his cause. And he has lost much, including his wife.wife.
* Confirmed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Turns out it was an excuse to give him a Time Turner, but it ''also'' wasn't natural, but induced on purpose. By ''Dumbledore,'' of all people.

to:

** [[spoiler: Turns out it was an excuse to give him a Time Turner, but it ''also'' wasn't natural, but induced on purpose. By ''Dumbledore,'' of all people.
people.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Dumbledore, following some prophetic clue that he didn't quite know the meaning of, but understood after Harry befriended Draco first.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


He was "delinquent" in that he failed to keep the Death Eaters together. He was extremely useful during the original establishment of the DE, because, as he said to Neville, the Dark Lord needed the cooperation of House Malfoy to get people to join his cause.

to:

He was "delinquent" in that he failed to keep the Death Eaters together. He was extremely useful during the original establishment of the DE, because, as he said to Neville, the Dark Lord needed the cooperation of House Malfoy to get people to join his cause. And he has lost much, including his wife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As foreshadowed by Voldemort. She will become a real daredevil now that she can't get permanently hurt, and reform the school's bullying system. All before her third year.

to:

As foreshadowed by Voldemort. She will become a real daredevil now that she can't get permanently hurt, and reform the school's bullying system. All before her third year.year.

[[WMG: Mr. White was Lucius.]]
He was "delinquent" in that he failed to keep the Death Eaters together. He was extremely useful during the original establishment of the DE, because, as he said to Neville, the Dark Lord needed the cooperation of House Malfoy to get people to join his cause.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Theories confirmed/jossed also Francis Bacon and Roger Bacon are not the same dude



to:

* Point of order, it's just [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roger_Bacon Roger Bacon.]] [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Bacon Francis Bacon]] is a different guy who lived centuries later.




to:

* As it turns out, those opening lines are [[spoiler:foreshadowing of the way Harry defeats Voldemort and all the Death Eaters. The "tiny fragment of silver, a fraction of a line" refers to a thread of carbon nanofiber Harry transfigures and wraps around the necks of the Death Eaters and Voldemort's wrists. The falling black robes are the robes of the Death Eaters. The Blood is their blood as they are decapitated simultaneously, and Voldemort's as his hands are cut off. The word is Flitwick's swerving stunner, "STUPORFY!" which Harry uses to incapacitate Voldemort, who he didn't bother killing thanks to his hundreds of horcruxes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Turns out Dumbledore killed the pet rock



to:

* Actually, it turns out Dumbledore did it. All part of an elaborate scheme to [[spoiler: prevent Harry from destroying the people in the world when he's foretold to "tear apart the very stars in heaven"]]




to:

* Jossed, turns out Dumbledore did it!




to:

* He does know, but because ''he killed it.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Theory was sort of confirmed?



to:

** Turns out it was an excuse to give him a Time Turner, but it ''also'' wasn't natural, but induced on purpose. By ''Dumbledore,'' of all people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What about The Doctor from DoctorWho?

to:

* What about The the Doctor from DoctorWho?''Series/DoctorWho''?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** [[spoiler: Confirmed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Confirmed -- but [[spoiler: Voldemort has well over a hundred ''additional'' Horcruxes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Harry can't very well tranfigure Voldemort back into his original body; since all his memories are gone, it'll probably be better to turn him into a child. Harry will use a memory charm to make his parents believe that he's always had a younger brother who is a year younger than him. Harry has to think of a name to call him, but decides Tom would be tempting fate, so chooses the name Dudley out of thin air.

to:

Harry can't very well tranfigure Voldemort back into his original body; since all his memories are gone, it'll probably be better to turn him into a child. Harry will use a memory charm to make his parents believe that he's always had a younger brother who is a year younger than him. Harry has to think of a name to call him, but decides Tom would be tempting fate, so chooses the name Dudley out of thin air.air.

[[WMG: Hermione will be transferred to Gryffindor.]]
As foreshadowed by Voldemort. She will become a real daredevil now that she can't get permanently hurt, and reform the school's bullying system. All before her third year.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Quirrell's battle magic class is an allegory for the ColdWar.]]

to:

[[WMG: Quirrell's battle magic class is an allegory for the ColdWar.UsefulNotes/ColdWar.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Of course, that depends on the Guess about the imprisoned Sirius Black being Pettigrew being right. He did know Harry's parents.

to:

Of course, that depends on the Guess about the imprisoned Sirius Black being Pettigrew being right. He did know Harry's parents.parents.

[[WMG: Oblivated!TomRiddle will be Dudley]]
Harry can't very well tranfigure Voldemort back into his original body; since all his memories are gone, it'll probably be better to turn him into a child. Harry will use a memory charm to make his parents believe that he's always had a younger brother who is a year younger than him. Harry has to think of a name to call him, but decides Tom would be tempting fate, so chooses the name Dudley out of thin air.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I imagine she will feel remorse at once, thus unhorcruxing her soul. She won't even have to be told she has to feel remorse to do that.

to:

* I imagine she will feel remorse at once, thus unhorcruxing her soul. She won't even have to be told she has to feel remorse to do that.that.

[[WMG: Mr. Grim is the real Sirius Black.]]
Of course, that depends on the Guess about the imprisoned Sirius Black being Pettigrew being right. He did know Harry's parents.

Top