Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / ASongOfIceAndFireCross

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* He's definitely broken enough for a spren to have been able to bond to him, and has been for a while. He acts as a guardian of humanity against a supernatural apocalypse, the precise function of the Knights Radiant. He has consistently followed the Skybreaker oath to "put the law before all else". Indeed, like their patron Herald, he follows that creed at times to the point of virtual insanity. We've seen repeatedly that someone can use the more basic Radiant powers (strength, speed, toughness, healing) without realizing it, so he could easily be making minor use of his powers without him or anyone else noticing. In addition, since magic is still very rare in Westeros, there won't be a lot of free Investiture around for him to tap into, which would further limit his use of Surgebindings and make it harder for people to notice his powers. This also explains why he favors Melisandre so much, she seems to leak magic, which means that when she's around, there's a ready supply of power for him to use. Finally, the real Lightbringer, the magic sword of heroes which shines with power and is potent to harm supernatural evils, sounds an awful lot like a Living Shardblade.

to:

* He's definitely broken enough for a spren to have been able to bond to him, and has been for a while. He acts as a guardian of humanity against a supernatural apocalypse, the precise function of the Knights Radiant. He has consistently followed the Skybreaker oath to "put the law before all else". Indeed, like their patron Herald, he follows that creed at times to the point of virtual insanity. We've seen repeatedly that someone can use the more basic Radiant powers (strength, speed, toughness, healing) without realizing it, so he could easily be making minor use of his powers without him or anyone else noticing. In addition, since magic is still very rare in Westeros, there won't be a lot of free Investiture around for him to tap into, which would further limit his use of Surgebindings and make it harder for people to notice his powers. This also explains why he favors Melisandre so much, she seems to leak magic, which means that when she's around, there's a ready supply of power for him to use. Finally, the real Lightbringer, the magic sword of heroes which shines with power and is potent to harm supernatural evils, sounds an awful lot like a Living Shardblade.Shardblade.

[[WMG: The world of Westeros overlaps with [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/TabletopGame/Planescape Planescape]]]]
* It's actually the 629th layer of the Abyss, which explains the [[http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/CrapsackWorld a lot about the setting]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Because he says "I am so sorry."

to:

* Because he says "I am so sorry.""


[[WMG: King Stannis Barethon is a [[Literature/TheStormlightArchive Skybreaker Radiant]]]]
* He's definitely broken enough for a spren to have been able to bond to him, and has been for a while. He acts as a guardian of humanity against a supernatural apocalypse, the precise function of the Knights Radiant. He has consistently followed the Skybreaker oath to "put the law before all else". Indeed, like their patron Herald, he follows that creed at times to the point of virtual insanity. We've seen repeatedly that someone can use the more basic Radiant powers (strength, speed, toughness, healing) without realizing it, so he could easily be making minor use of his powers without him or anyone else noticing. In addition, since magic is still very rare in Westeros, there won't be a lot of free Investiture around for him to tap into, which would further limit his use of Surgebindings and make it harder for people to notice his powers. This also explains why he favors Melisandre so much, she seems to leak magic, which means that when she's around, there's a ready supply of power for him to use. Finally, the real Lightbringer, the magic sword of heroes which shines with power and is potent to harm supernatural evils, sounds an awful lot like a Living Shardblade.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**Your Grace, does David Bowie know you raid his wardrobe?
**On a similar note, GRR will include a typical High School Clique at the Citadel as a ShoutOut to ''School of Thrones''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**Not necessarily. The name could simply be a ShoutOut, given his relationship to a major character. His self-esteem problems, arguably his defining characteristic, don't really describe Samwise that well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is mentioned in the ''ParksAndRecreation'' episode "Leslie and Ron," which takes place 2017.

to:

This is mentioned in the ''ParksAndRecreation'' ''Series/ParksAndRecreation'' episode "Leslie and Ron," which takes place 2017.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***Doubtful, unless they genetically engineered themselves to be the size of children, and to have claws, cat-like eyes, and four digits per hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Note that Martin is against ''unauthorized'' fan continuations. However, he has stated he is alright with them if the original creator gives their blessing (and he has actually written this type of fan fiction before, in fanzines). Creator/RogerZelazny, author of ''Lord Of Light'', was a personal friend of Martin's and is in fact mentioned in the acknowledgements for ''A Game of Thrones''.

to:

* Note that Martin is against ''unauthorized'' fan continuations. However, he has stated he is alright with them if the original creator gives their blessing (and he has actually written this type of fan fiction before, in fanzines). Creator/RogerZelazny, author of ''Lord Of Light'', was a personal friend of Martin's and is in fact mentioned in the acknowledgements for ''A Game of Thrones''.Thrones''.

[[WMG: The [[Series/DoctorWho 10th Doctor]] is a Sorrowful Man]]
* Because he says "I am so sorry."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Note that Martin is against ''unauthorized'' fan continuations. However, he has stated he is alright with them if the original creator gives their blessing, and Creator/RogerZelazny, author of ''Lord Of Light'', was a personal friend of Martin's and is in fact mentioned in the acknowledgements for ''A Game of Thrones''.

to:

* Note that Martin is against ''unauthorized'' fan continuations. However, he has stated he is alright with them if the original creator gives their blessing, and blessing (and he has actually written this type of fan fiction before, in fanzines). Creator/RogerZelazny, author of ''Lord Of Light'', was a personal friend of Martin's and is in fact mentioned in the acknowledgements for ''A Game of Thrones''.

Added: 323

Changed: 317

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Related to the theory that Westeros is a LostColony above, Westeros takes place on the same colony world as the novel ''Literature/LordOfLight''. Melisandre's Lord is quite literally Great-Souled Sam. The Seven, the Drowned God, and the various other gods were merely influential colonists from the starship ''Star of India'', recreating medieval feudalism and enforcing MedievalStasis to keep the descendants of the other colonists ignorant and unable to threaten their power structure. The magic some people possess was created by lost-lost advanced technology, now passed down through bloodlines. Note that Martin is against ''unauthorized'' fan continuations. However, he has stated he is alright with them if the original creator gives their blessing, and Creator/RogerZelazny, author of ''LordOfLight, was a personal friend of Martin's and is in fact mentioned in the acknowledgements for ''A Game of Thrones''.

to:

* Related to the theory that Westeros is a LostColony above, Westeros takes place on the same colony world as the novel ''Literature/LordOfLight''. Melisandre's Lord is quite literally Great-Souled Sam. The Seven, the Drowned God, and the various other gods were merely influential colonists from the starship ''Star of India'', recreating medieval feudalism and enforcing MedievalStasis to keep the descendants of the other colonists ignorant and unable to threaten their power structure. The magic some people possess was created by lost-lost advanced technology, now passed down through bloodlines.
*
Note that Martin is against ''unauthorized'' fan continuations. However, he has stated he is alright with them if the original creator gives their blessing, and Creator/RogerZelazny, author of ''LordOfLight, ''Lord Of Light'', was a personal friend of Martin's and is in fact mentioned in the acknowledgements for ''A Game of Thrones''.

Changed: 318

Removed: 317

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Related to the theory that Westeros is a LostColony above, Westeros takes place on the same colony world as the novel ''Literature/LordOfLight''. Melisandre's Lord is quite literally Great-Souled Sam. The Seven, the Drowned God, and the various other gods were merely influential colonists from the starship ''Star of India'', recreating medieval feudalism and enforcing MedievalStasis to keep the descendants of the other colonists ignorant and unable to threaten their power structure. The magic some people possess was created by lost-lost advanced technology, now passed down through bloodlines.

Note that Martin is against ''unauthorized'' fan continuations. However, he has stated he is alright with them if the original creator gives their blessing, and Creator/RogerZelazny, author of ''LordOfLight, was a personal friend of Martin's and is in fact mentioned in the acknowledgements for ''A Game of Thrones''.

to:

* Related to the theory that Westeros is a LostColony above, Westeros takes place on the same colony world as the novel ''Literature/LordOfLight''. Melisandre's Lord is quite literally Great-Souled Sam. The Seven, the Drowned God, and the various other gods were merely influential colonists from the starship ''Star of India'', recreating medieval feudalism and enforcing MedievalStasis to keep the descendants of the other colonists ignorant and unable to threaten their power structure. The magic some people possess was created by lost-lost advanced technology, now passed down through bloodlines.

bloodlines. Note that Martin is against ''unauthorized'' fan continuations. However, he has stated he is alright with them if the original creator gives their blessing, and Creator/RogerZelazny, author of ''LordOfLight, was a personal friend of Martin's and is in fact mentioned in the acknowledgements for ''A Game of Thrones''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sir Richard Carlisle dies shortly after Mary leaves him for Matthew and ends up falling for yet another beautiful woman whom he again betrays and is sent away from.

to:

* Sir Richard Carlisle dies shortly after Mary leaves him for Matthew and ends up falling for yet another beautiful woman whom he again betrays and is sent away from.from.

[[WMG: The series is a sequel to ''Lord of Light'']]
* Related to the theory that Westeros is a LostColony above, Westeros takes place on the same colony world as the novel ''Literature/LordOfLight''. Melisandre's Lord is quite literally Great-Souled Sam. The Seven, the Drowned God, and the various other gods were merely influential colonists from the starship ''Star of India'', recreating medieval feudalism and enforcing MedievalStasis to keep the descendants of the other colonists ignorant and unable to threaten their power structure. The magic some people possess was created by lost-lost advanced technology, now passed down through bloodlines.

Note that Martin is against ''unauthorized'' fan continuations. However, he has stated he is alright with them if the original creator gives their blessing, and Creator/RogerZelazny, author of ''LordOfLight, was a personal friend of Martin's and is in fact mentioned in the acknowledgements for ''A Game of Thrones''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Unsullied formed the planet's tithe to the Imperial Guard.

to:

* The Unsullied formed the planet's tithe to the Imperial Guard.Guard.

[[WMG: Several Series/HarryPotter and Series/DowntonAbbey characters ended up in Westeros after the series ended]]
* Mrs. Granger, while living in Australia after having her memory modified, began to regain memories of her former life. She went mad after realising that she once had a daughter who had made her and her husband forget her. After unsuccessfully trying to convince her husband of the truth, she goes mad and ends up creating world where she gets revenge on all those who wronged her.
* Argus Filch dies and goes to his version of heaven where he gets to torment others just as much as they tormented him.
* Sir Richard Carlisle dies shortly after Mary leaves him for Matthew and ends up falling for yet another beautiful woman whom he again betrays and is sent away from.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixed wick


[[WMG: George R. R. Martian does NOT hate his characters and his fans. He's an obsessive fan of TheArtOfWar]]

to:

[[WMG: George R. R. Martian does NOT hate his characters and his fans. He's an obsessive fan of TheArtOfWar]]''Literature/TheArtOfWar'']]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is mentioned in the ''ParksAndRecreation'' episode "Leslie and Ron," which takes place 2017.

to:

This is mentioned in the ''ParksAndRecreation'' episode "Leslie and Ron," which takes place 2017.2017.

[[WMG: The series takes place on a Feudal World in the ''TabletopGame/{{Warhammer 40000}}'' universe]]
* The legend of the long night refers to the time when Chaos ruled the planet before it was brought into Imperial Compliance by the Emperor of Mankind, who became known as Azor Ahai to the locals.
* Shortly after the Horus Heresy, when Lemen Russ left the Space Wolves, he spent some time in Westeros living under the pseudonym, 'Brandon Stark', and subsequently built The Wall, Winterfell, etc. and founded House Stark.
** The Dire Wolves are descended from Fenrisian Wolves that accompanied him on his journey.
* The Unsullied formed the planet's tithe to the Imperial Guard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** One of George R.R. Martin's earlier stories, "Bitterblooms" (collected in ''Dreamsongs'') takes place on a LostColony where winter and summer last for years. And one of the main characters was a "witch" using LostTechnology from an ancient starship to fake magic, and other stories in the same universe had Psychics and in one case CosmicHorror.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Rickon Stark = Richard of Shrewsbury

to:

* Rickon Stark = Richard of ShrewsburyShrewsbury

[[WMG: At the end of the series, Khaleesi will marry Jack Sparrow from ''PiratesOfTheCaribbean.'']]
This is mentioned in the ''ParksAndRecreation'' episode "Leslie and Ron," which takes place 2017.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Dragons and other supernatural entities have already been introduced into what is otherwise a more realistic take on medieval fantasy fiction. As magic (greenseers, wargs, shadow magic, etc) and more magical races (the children of the forest, for example) become more widespread and widely-known, the world will start to more closely resemble a typical high fantasy setting. The tone of the series may even shift enough for it to end on an optimistic note.

to:

Dragons and other supernatural entities have already been introduced into what is otherwise a more realistic take on medieval fantasy fiction. As magic (greenseers, wargs, shadow magic, etc) and more magical races (the children of the forest, for example) become more widespread and widely-known, the world will start to more closely resemble a typical high fantasy setting. The tone of the series may even shift enough for it to end on an optimistic note.note.

[[WMG: Theon's storyline is based on the later life of Richard III.]]
Theon is almost like a brother to Robb Stark, who, in this case, would represent Richard's older brother, Edward IV. Edward, like Robb with Theon, was very different to his brother, but their relationship seems to have been alright, although there has been speculation as to whether Edward and Richard had the same father (Edward was much taller than both his father and brother). As for Richard himself, there's the Robb/Edward parallel, but there's also Bran and Rickon. In this context, Bran and Rickon would represent Edward's sons, Edward V and Richard of Shrewsbury, better known as the Princes in the Tower. Popular history would have you believe that they were killed by their Uncle Richard, but the truth is that there's actually no real evidence that this was the case. It could have been something else, or they could have simply run away or been smuggled out of the Tower by someone else. Either way, history doesn't record what happened to them afterwards, and nobody's found their remains yet. This ties in with everybody thinking Theon murdered Bran and Rickon, when in fact they simply ran away. Combined with Robb's death and Theon's descent into unpopularity, this WMG can be summed up thusly:
* Theon Greyjoy = Richard III
* Robb Stark = Edward IV
* Bran Stark = Edward V
* Rickon Stark = Richard of Shrewsbury
N

Added: 527

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


After several hundred or thousand years of summer, winter came to Westeros. Since the majority of society assumed that the world had entered the Eternal Summer, only a handful of survivalists had prepared for the climate's dramatic turn for the worst, and even their meager preparations weren't enough. To the North, the Wall had been unguarded for centuries except for a ceremonial honor guard who were intended to remind the world of the horrors that it had lived with in the distant past. As a result, the Wall was destroyed, commencing the long night that never ends.

to:

After several hundred or thousand years of summer, winter came to Westeros. Since the majority of society assumed that the world had entered the Eternal Summer, only a handful of survivalists had prepared for the climate's dramatic turn for the worst, and even their meager preparations weren't enough. To the North, the Wall had been unguarded for centuries except for a ceremonial honor guard who were intended to remind the world of the horrors that it had lived with in the distant past. As a result, the Wall was destroyed, commencing the long night that never ends.ends.

[[WMG: The series will be a reconstruction of the high fantasy genre.]]
Dragons and other supernatural entities have already been introduced into what is otherwise a more realistic take on medieval fantasy fiction. As magic (greenseers, wargs, shadow magic, etc) and more magical races (the children of the forest, for example) become more widespread and widely-known, the world will start to more closely resemble a typical high fantasy setting. The tone of the series may even shift enough for it to end on an optimistic note.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: George R. R. Martin created all the Great Houses to represent subgenres of Music/HeavyMetal.]]

to:

[[WMG: George R. R. Martin created all the Great Houses to represent subgenres of Music/HeavyMetal.HeavyMetal.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The ASOIAF-planet is not Earth, it is a LostColony. The rest of spacefaring humanity has long rediscovered it, but does not contact and intervene directly because of the prime directive. The Iron Bank of Braavos is actually a front for Earthling progressors who try to stimulate capitalism and industry.

to:

** The ASOIAF-planet is not Earth, it is a LostColony. The rest of spacefaring humanity has long rediscovered it, but does not contact and intervene directly because of the prime directive. The Iron Bank of Braavos is actually a front for Earthling progressors who try to subtly stimulate capitalism and industry.industry. Only in a case of a total White Walker victory will the main Earth forces intervene and stop them with [[DeusExNukina the nuclear option]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The ASOIAF-planet is not Earth, it is a LostColony. The rest of spacefaring humanity has long rediscovered it, but does not contact and intervene directly because of the prime directive. The Iron Bank of Braavos is actually a front for Earthling progressors who try to stimulate capitalism and industry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Many depictions of Harrenhal make it look more like a medieval moron's impression of a dilapidated district of skyscrapers than any castle. Perhaps that's exactly what it is: an attempt to reproduce a very ancient and advanced architectural style with low technology which, predictably, failed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Westeros is the far distant past of Gallifrey. Eventually they will harness the power of the weirwoods to perceive past, present and future simultaneously and become Time Lords.

to:

Westeros is the far distant past of Gallifrey. Eventually they will harness the power of the weirwoods to perceive past, present and future simultaneously and become Time Lords.Lords.

[[WMG: ''TheRoad'' is a distant future sequel to A Song of Ice and Fire.]]
After several hundred or thousand years of summer, winter came to Westeros. Since the majority of society assumed that the world had entered the Eternal Summer, only a handful of survivalists had prepared for the climate's dramatic turn for the worst, and even their meager preparations weren't enough. To the North, the Wall had been unguarded for centuries except for a ceremonial honor guard who were intended to remind the world of the horrors that it had lived with in the distant past. As a result, the Wall was destroyed, commencing the long night that never ends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


One of the few things we know about The Drowned God is that he has these awesome underwater parties involving mermaids, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC_mV1IpjWA sounds familiar?]]

to:

One of the few things we know about The Drowned God is that he has these awesome underwater parties involving mermaids, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC_mV1IpjWA sounds familiar?]]familiar?]]

[[WMG: The TARDIS runs on weirwood sap.]]
Westeros is the far distant past of Gallifrey. Eventually they will harness the power of the weirwoods to perceive past, present and future simultaneously and become Time Lords.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ...and then the author woke up from his happy dream and realized he is back in a cell deep down in the Dreadfort. "Hello Reek, sweet dreams?" said Ramsay Bolton. "You past out from our little "session" from the other day. Let us continue from there, shall we?"

to:

* ...and then the author woke up from his happy dream and realized he is back in a cell deep down in the Dreadfort. "Hello Reek, sweet dreams?" said Ramsay Bolton. "You past passed out from our little "session" from the other day. Let us continue from there, shall we?"





to:

\n* [[TheAristocrats So, George R. R. Martin goes to see his publisher and says "I've got a great idea for a new book series...,"]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: The true natyre of The Drowned God]]
So among what little we know about The Drowned God is that he has these awesome underwater parties with mermaids and stuff. [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC_mV1IpjWA Sounds familiar?]]

to:

[[WMG: The true natyre nature of The Drowned God]]
So among what little One of the few things we know about The Drowned God is that he has these awesome underwater parties with mermaids and stuff. involving mermaids, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC_mV1IpjWA Sounds sounds familiar?]]

Added: 231

Changed: 264

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



[[WMG: The people of Valyria dug deep into their volcanoes to find dragons and unleashed [[Literature/TheLordOfTheRings Balrogs]].]]

to:

\n[[WMG: The people of Valyria dug deep into their volcanoes to find dragons and unleashed [[Literature/TheLordOfTheRings Balrogs]].]]]]

[[WMG: The true natyre of The Drowned God]]
So among what little we know about The Drowned God is that he has these awesome underwater parties with mermaids and stuff. [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC_mV1IpjWA Sounds familiar?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Such is [[ChronicallyKilledActor the Curse of]] SeanBean.

to:

** Such is [[ChronicallyKilledActor the Curse of]] SeanBean.
Creator/SeanBean.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Goes along with the theory that there will be a DistantFinale featuring modern technology. [[MindScrew Both stories are historical fiction in the context of the other one.]]

to:

Goes along with the theory that there will be a DistantFinale featuring modern technology. [[MindScrew Both stories are historical fiction in the context of the other one.]]


[[WMG: The people of Valyria dug deep into their volcanoes to find dragons and unleashed [[Literature/TheLordOfTheRings Balrogs]].
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As a point, Hornswoggle being Vince's son was revealed to be a ruse by Finlay, Hornswoggle's actual father. Tyrion as Hornswoggle goes with the theory that he's not Tywin's actual son.


Added DiffLines:

** Does that make R'hllor Kane?

Top