Follow TV Tropes

Following

History VideoGame / HerStory

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AssholeVictim: Perhaps it's a stretch to call Simon an asshole, but he was happily cheating on his wife, and gifted the other woman with a mirror identical to Hannah's wedding gift.


Added DiffLines:

* DrivingQuestion: Just who is the woman and what has she done?


Added DiffLines:

* HeWhoMustNotBeSeen: The detectives conducting the interview are never seen. Supposedly the tapes with footage of them were lost in flood damage. [[HeWhoMustNotBeHeard They aren't heard either]], save for the moment where they clap after the 'Dreadful Wind and Rain' song.


Added DiffLines:

* LonelyPianoPiece: A portion of the soundtrack, especially the mood-setting title theme and credits song.


Added DiffLines:

* MinorCrimeRevealsMajorPlot: The player and the detectives believe they're just here to solve a murder. [[spoiler: In fact, they bear witness to a lengthy story about the twins' deceptions throughout their lives.]]

Added: 367

Changed: 753

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AntiFrustrationFeatures: For those going for OneHundredPercentCompletion, [[spoiler:after "finishing" the game, you are taught the search string "ADMIN_RANDOM" to help you further in finding more videos]]. This is particularly helpful for the lie-detector test videos.
** Similarly, [[spoiler:since all videos are tagged with the tag "BLANK", the player can just search for "blank" and erase the tagline from all the videos they see. This might not be intentional, however.]]

to:

* AntiFrustrationFeatures: AntiFrustrationFeatures:
**
For those going for OneHundredPercentCompletion, [[spoiler:after after "finishing" the game, you are taught the search string "ADMIN_RANDOM" command "ADMIN_RANDOM"[[note]]it only works after completing the game[[/note]] to help you further in finding more videos]].videos. It's not even as random as it claims to be, it has a chance, based on how many videos you've seen, to spit out an unseen one. This is particularly helpful for the lie-detector test videos.
** The search attempts to automatically search for plural and singular versions of words, as well as accounting for differences in american and british spelling.
** Similarly, [[spoiler:since all videos are tagged with the tag "BLANK", the player can just search for "blank" and erase the tagline from all the videos they see. This might not be intentional, however.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
dangit

Added DiffLines:

* GuideDangit: A few clips contain exactly one line, even to the point of being a single word.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Has nothing do with familiarity with in-universe fiction.


* GenreSavvy: [[spoiler: Eve, who has a tattoo where Hannah doesn't, wears a short sleeved shirt in the beginning of the interrogations. After one of the officers inquires about it, the following interrogation videos all have her in long sleeved shirts, or at least, long enough to cover up the tattoo.]]

Changed: 50

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImpersonatingTheEvilTwin: [[spoiler:Hannah wears Eve's blonde wig when she goes to confront Simon about his affair with Eve, pretending to be her just long enough for Simon to give her a mirror that was identical to the one he gave Hannah when they first married. [[AxCrazy She doesn't take it well.]]]]

to:

* ImpersonatingTheEvilTwin: [[spoiler:Hannah wears [[spoiler:If Eve's story is to be believed, Hannah wore Eve's blonde wig when she goes went to confront Simon about his affair with Eve, pretending to be her just long enough for Simon to give her a mirror that was identical to the one he gave Hannah when they first married. [[AxCrazy She doesn't didn't take it well.]]]]

Changed: 305

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GreenEyedMonster: [[spoiler:"Hannah" killed Simon because she was jealous of "Eve" stealing her perfect life together with him]].
* IdenticalStranger: [[spoiler:Eve was supposedly Hannah's twin, kidnapped at birth, and lived across the street from Hannah until she was eight years old. Of course, that might [[UnreliableNarrator all be in her head.]]]]

to:

* GreenEyedMonster: [[spoiler:"Hannah" [[spoiler:According to Eve, Hannah killed Simon because she was jealous of "Eve" Eve stealing her perfect life together with him]].
him. Mostly this trope comes into play the opposite way around however - Eve had clearly been bitter about Hannah seemingly getting everything she wanted, primarily a loving family, pregnancy, and of course Simon himself.]].
* IdenticalStranger: [[spoiler:Eve was supposedly Hannah's twin, kidnapped at birth, and lived across the street from Hannah until she was eight years old. Of course, that might [[UnreliableNarrator all be in her head.]]]]]]

Added: 269

Changed: 1028

Removed: 377

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The split personality theory is so wildly impossible that it belongs in WMG


* IdenticalTwinIDTag: [[spoiler:Hannah wears her hair up while Eve wears her hair down. In addition, Eve has a rather prominent tattoo of [[RuleOfSymbolism a snake and an apple]] on her arm (although considering both Hannah and Eve are wearing long sleeves in most of their interviews, the SplitPersonality theory is still plausible).]]

to:

* IdenticalTwinIDTag: [[spoiler:Hannah wears her hair up while Eve wears her hair down. In addition, Eve has a rather prominent tattoo of [[RuleOfSymbolism a snake and an apple]] on her arm (although considering both Hannah and Eve are wearing long sleeves in most of their interviews, the SplitPersonality theory is still plausible).apple]].]]



* LettingHerHairDown: [[spoiler:"Hannah" wears her hair tied up while "Eve" lets it down. Notably, she lets her hair down after having to leave the room at some point, which serves as another piece of evidence for the SplitPersonality theory.]]

to:

* LettingHerHairDown: [[spoiler:"Hannah" wears her hair tied up while "Eve" lets it down. Notably, she lets her hair down after having to leave the room at some point, which serves as another piece of evidence for the SplitPersonality theory.]]



* MaybeMagicMaybeMundane: [[spoiler:Eve seems to genuinely believe there is a magical connection between her and Hannah. Assuming they're [[SplitPersonality not just the same person]], there are certainly more than a few eerie parallels in their respective lives.]]

to:

* MaybeMagicMaybeMundane: [[spoiler:Eve seems to genuinely believe there is a magical connection between her and Hannah. Assuming they're [[SplitPersonality not just the same person]], there There are certainly more than a few eerie parallels in their respective lives.]]



* OccamsRazor: {{Averted|Trope}}. There are three primary explanations for Hannah and Eve's activities. All are highly implausible, and require a certain amount of contrivance to make sense.
** [[spoiler: You can take them at their word and believe that the two are identical twins that were SeparatedAtBirth. However, for their story to make sense, they would have needed to conceal Eve's existence ''for a decade,'' while she was living in the attic of Hannah's house, all the while Eve and Hannah were pulling TwinSwitch shenanigans on their parents and on the community as a whole. It does explain certain physical inconsistencies, however, like Hannah's bruise disappearing over the course of a single day, or Eve's tattoo seemingly disappearing between interviews.]]

to:

* OccamsRazor: {{Averted|Trope}}. There are three is one primary and two secondary explanations for Hannah and Eve's activities. All are highly implausible, and require a certain amount of contrivance to make sense.
** [[spoiler: You can take them at their word and believe that the two are identical twins that were SeparatedAtBirth. However, for their story to make sense, they would have needed to conceal Eve's existence ''for a decade,'' while she was living in the attic of Hannah's house, all the while Eve and Hannah were pulling TwinSwitch shenanigans on their parents and on the community as a whole. It Still, this is the most plausible theory as it does explain certain physical inconsistencies, however, inconsistencies like Hannah's bruise disappearing over the course of a single day, or Eve's tattoo seemingly disappearing between interviews.]]



** There's another likely explanation for the frequent repeating - [[spoiler: People who are lying often repeat the question they were asked in order to buy time for fabricating an answer. Indeed, most repeats you hear are followed by a lie if not avoided altogether.]]



** [[spoiler: It's revealed that the woman doing the interview is possibly a pair of twins, Hannah and Eve, that switch roles on different days. Or maybe she has a SplitPersonality. Or maybe ''both.'']]
** [[spoiler: Hannah killed her husband accidentally by swinging a broken mirror at him, which causes the shard to cut his throat.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: It's revealed that the woman doing the interview is possibly a pair of twins, Hannah and Eve, that switch roles on different days. Or maybe she has a SplitPersonality. Or maybe ''both.'']]\n]]
** [[spoiler: If Eve is to be believed, Hannah killed her husband accidentally by swinging a broken mirror at him, which causes the shard to cut his throat.throat. Of course this could just as well be Eve shifting the blame to her sister just like Hannah used to do to her in the past. It's impossible to say for certain.]]



* SplitPersonality: [[spoiler:There are a ''lot'' of hints that Eve is a split personality of Hannah. Then again, the implausibility of a split personality is equaled by the implausibility of Hannah having a secret twin sister. Although based on the bruise that Hannah received and tattoo that Eve had in separate interviews, it's much more likely that she has a twin sister]].



* TwinSwitch: [[spoiler:Hannah and Eve, both several times during their lives and, it seems, the interrogations themselves. Although that depends on whether you believe they are twins or two halves of a Split Personality.]]
* UnreliableExpositor: The game is primarily about figuring out which parts of the woman's testimony you can trust, so you can piece together the events that unfolded. [[spoiler:Ultimately, you can't trust ''anything'' that Hannah/Eve tells you throughout the game, because both of the most likely explanations ("I have a split personality" and "I have a secret twin I kept in my attic without my parents finding out.") are equally ridiculous and none of her statements (like her "alibi" in Glasgow) are confirmed or refuted by the interrogating officer. As "Eve" says in the final video clip: "You have nothing. And all these stories we've been telling each other? Just that: stories."]]

to:

* TwinSwitch: [[spoiler:Hannah and Eve, both several times during their lives and, it seems, the interrogations themselves. Although that depends on whether you believe they are twins or two halves of a Split Personality.]]
* UnreliableExpositor: The game is primarily about figuring out which parts of the woman's testimony you can trust, so you can piece together the events that unfolded. [[spoiler:Ultimately, you can't trust ''anything'' that Hannah/Eve tells you throughout the game, because both of the most likely explanations ("I have a split personality" and "I have a secret twin I kept in my attic without my parents finding out.") are equally ridiculous game and none of her their statements (like her the "alibi" in Glasgow) are confirmed or refuted by the interrogating officer. As "Eve" Eve says in the final video clip: "You have nothing. And all these stories we've been telling each other? Just that: stories."]]



* WomanScorned: [[spoiler:If one believes that Hannah and Eve are separate people, Hannah's reason for accidentally killing Simon was rage at him telling her (posing as Eve) that he wanted to be with her, and presenting her with an identical mirror to the "unique" one he'd given Hannah earlier.]]

to:

* WomanScorned: [[spoiler:If one believes that Hannah and Eve are separate people, Eve's version of the story, Hannah's reason for accidentally killing Simon was rage at him telling her (posing as Eve) that he wanted to be with her, and presenting her with an identical mirror to the "unique" one he'd given Hannah earlier.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Fairy Tales. Specifically {{Rapunzel}}.

to:

** Fairy Tales. Specifically {{Rapunzel}}.''Literature/{{Rapunzel}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the year 1994, a woman (Viva Seifert) was called in by the police to give a number of interviews considering a recent disappearance. Your challenge is to piece together the facts of the case despite the limitations of the aged database software you are using.

to:

In the year 1994, a woman (Viva (played by Viva Seifert) was called in by the police to give a number of interviews considering a recent disappearance. Your challenge is to piece together the facts of the case despite the limitations of the aged database software you are using.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler: Except Hannah/Eve BOTH state that it was Hannah who did it, so if she was making up a person wouldn't she blame Eve, the one who didn't exist?]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* YouCalledMeXItMustBeSerious: [[spoiler: Eve states that Hannah called her immediately after killing Simon and called her "sister" when asking her to come over.]]

Added: 1418

Changed: 51

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler:Hannah's teenage pregnancy]].

to:

** [[spoiler:Hannah's teenage pregnancy]].pregnancy and ensuing miscarriage which left her infertile.]]


Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: Eve's tattoo is one of the first hints that she and Hannah may be different people.]]


Added DiffLines:

* GenreSavvy: [[spoiler: Eve, who has a tattoo where Hannah doesn't, wears a short sleeved shirt in the beginning of the interrogations. After one of the officers inquires about it, the following interrogation videos all have her in long sleeved shirts, or at least, long enough to cover up the tattoo.]]
* TheGhost: Simon. He is constantly discussed and described, but never shows up in the game proper, [[spoiler: because he's dead.]] This counts for every other character mentioned as well, but Simon's case is particularly egregious due to how often he is mentioned.


Added DiffLines:

* RedOniBlueOni: [[spoiler: Eve is the red to Hannah's blue.]]


Added DiffLines:

* TwinDesynch: [[spoiler:Eve begins the interrogations with her hair pulled back like Hannah and with a similar demeanor to her, but ends up letting her hair down, both figuratively and literally, and becomes the more confident, outspoken, and brazen of the two. The difference between them is evident not only due to their differing hairstyles, but because of their manner of speaking.]]


Added DiffLines:

* WomanScorned: [[spoiler:If one believes that Hannah and Eve are separate people, Hannah's reason for accidentally killing Simon was rage at him telling her (posing as Eve) that he wanted to be with her, and presenting her with an identical mirror to the "unique" one he'd given Hannah earlier.]]

Added: 93

Removed: 93

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: Although you do at least learn exactly who is searching the database and why.]]



** [[spoiler: Although you do at least learn exactly who is searching the database and why.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NothingIsScarier: All you do is listen to a woman tell stories about her life. It gets more unsettling the more you listen. [[spoiler:Especially when the player's reflection randomly shows up on screen.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SelfMadeOrphan: [[spoiler:Heavily implied. Eve's mother died after falling down the stairs. Later, Hannah's parents both died from food poisoning by eating Death Cap Mushrooms, despite her father being an expert. Eve comments that the police never checked the attic, as though the reason for the deaths was up there, where Eve lives.]]

to:

* SelfMadeOrphan: [[spoiler:Heavily implied. Eve's mother died after falling down the stairs.stairs not long after Eve found her mother's journal detailing how she kidnapped her at birth. Later, Hannah's parents both died from food poisoning by eating Death Cap Mushrooms, despite her father being an expert. Eve comments that the police never checked the attic, as though the reason for the deaths was up there, where Eve lives.]]

Added: 207

Changed: 94

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Similarly, [[spoiler:since all videos are tagged with the tag "BLANK", the player can just search for "blank" and erase the tagline from all the videos they see. This might not be intentional, however.]]



** The song that Hannah sings is about [[spoiler: two sisters who fell for the same man]].

to:

** The song that Hannah sings is about [[spoiler: two sisters who fell for the same man]].man. It also involves one sister drowning the other, which Hannah admits to have tried to do once]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Wham Line: "So... [[spoiler: you think you understand why your mother did what she did?]]"

to:

* Wham Line: WhamLine: "So... [[spoiler: you think you understand why your mother did what she did?]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Wham Line "So... [[spoiler: you think you understand why your mother did what she did?]]"

to:

* Wham Line Line: "So... [[spoiler: you think you understand why your mother did what she did?]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Wham Line "So...{ [spoiler: you think you understand why your mother did what she did?]]"

to:

* Wham Line "So...{ [spoiler: [[spoiler: you think you understand why your mother did what she did?]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Wham Line "So... [spoiler: you think you understand why your mother did what she did?]]"

to:

* Wham Line "So... { [spoiler: you think you understand why your mother did what she did?]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Wham Line "So... [spoiler: you think you understand why your mother did what she did?]]"

Removed: 265

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ExcusePlot: [[spoiler:The game starts off with clips of the woman/women being questioned about Simon's disappearance. However, as you search more, it becomes clear that the game is less about Simon's disappearance/murder, and more about the lives of Hannah/Eve.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: Although you do at least learn exactly who is searching the database and why.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Unfortunately, if the twins story is to be believed Eve also [[spoiler:took [[Twincest Hannah's virginity]] (or '''innocence''') with a hair brush.]]

to:

*** Unfortunately, if the twins story is to be believed Eve also [[spoiler:took [[Twincest Hannah's virginity]] virginity (or '''innocence''') ''innocence'' ) with a hair brush.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***Unfortunately, if the twins story is to be believed Eve also [[spoiler:took [[Twincest Hannah's virginity]] (or '''innocence''') with a hair brush.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mirrors and reflections.

to:

** Mirrors and reflections.reflections appear constantly.



* NoEnding: [[spoiler:At some point, a chat box will appear on the screen, asking you if you're done searching and are satisfied with what you've learned. Answering "yes" to both questions will take the game to the credits, and teach you the "ADMIN_RANDOM" command to help you should you choose to continue. However, aside from that, nothing happens even if you manage to view all 271 videos on the database]].

to:

* NoEnding: [[spoiler:At some point, a chat box will appear on the screen, with 'SB' (who is never introduced besides the message they leave you on the desktop) asking you if you're done searching and are satisfied with what you've learned. Answering "yes" to both questions will take the game to the credits, and teach you the "ADMIN_RANDOM" command to help you should you choose to continue. However, aside from that, nothing happens even if you manage to view all 271 videos on the database]].



* RepeatingSoTheAudienceCanHear: Hannah speaks like this, since the audience can't hear the detective's voices (this is explained by the detective's questions being in a separate volume of the database that was since damaged by a flood).

to:

* RepeatingSoTheAudienceCanHear: Hannah The woman speaks like this, since the audience can't hear the detective's voices (this is explained by the detective's questions being in a separate volume of the database that was since damaged by a flood). Even then, it is sometimes averted, particularly when the conversation isn't important to the plot. A prime example of this is during the lie detector test, which is just a handful of clips with nothing but 'yes' and 'no'. The only part that we know about is [[spoiler: Eve being outed as not-Hannah when she fails a question concerning her name]] because the women helpfully repeats what the detective says to her.



* SelfMadeOrphan: [[spoiler:Heavily implied. Eve's mother died after falling down the stairs. Later, Hannah's parents both died from food poisoning by eating Death Cap Mushrooms, despite her father being an expert.]]
* SeparatedAtBirth: [[spoiler:Hannah and Eve (allegedly). The midwife had told their mother Eve died and raised her as her own.]]

to:

* SelfMadeOrphan: [[spoiler:Heavily implied. Eve's mother died after falling down the stairs. Later, Hannah's parents both died from food poisoning by eating Death Cap Mushrooms, despite her father being an expert. Eve comments that the police never checked the attic, as though the reason for the deaths was up there, where Eve lives.]]
* SeparatedAtBirth: [[spoiler:Hannah and Eve (allegedly). The midwife Florence, the midwife, had told their mother Eve died and raised her as her own.]]

Added: 131

Changed: 50

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: The blonde wig, worn by the woman when she wants to be in disguise.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: The blonde wig, worn by the woman Eve when she wants to be in disguise.disguise. Hannah wore it when she murdered Simon.]]


Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: Eve]] is a singer and guitarist. This is how she [[spoiler: met Simon. She was singing in a bar when she met Simon.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InterfaceSpoiler: After certain videos are played for the first time, the lights behind the PlayerCharacter would flicker for a bit, or police sirens and accompanying blue and red lights would sound. [[spoiler:These tend to happen whenever the videos are very close to the truth behind what happened]].

to:

* InterfaceSpoiler: After certain videos are played for the first time, the lights behind the PlayerCharacter would flicker for a bit, or police sirens and accompanying blue and red lights would sound.sound, accompanied by flashing red and blue lights. [[spoiler:These tend to happen whenever the videos are very close to the truth behind what happened]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AntiFrustrationFeatures: For those going for OneHundredPercentCompletion, [[spoiler:after "finishing" the game, you are taught the search string "ADMIN_RANDOM" to help you further in finding more videos]]. This is particularly helpful for the lie-detector test videos.


Added DiffLines:

* NoEnding: [[spoiler:At some point, a chat box will appear on the screen, asking you if you're done searching and are satisfied with what you've learned. Answering "yes" to both questions will take the game to the credits, and teach you the "ADMIN_RANDOM" command to help you should you choose to continue. However, aside from that, nothing happens even if you manage to view all 271 videos on the database]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler:There are two videos which each have Hannah and Eve reciting the exact same testimony of their alibi for Simon's death, ''almost'' word-for-word. The only difference is that Hannah specifically names Simon's parents (Doug and Eleanor), while Eve only refers to them as such]].


Added DiffLines:

* InterfaceSpoiler: After certain videos are played for the first time, the lights behind the PlayerCharacter would flicker for a bit, or police sirens and accompanying blue and red lights would sound. [[spoiler:These tend to happen whenever the videos are very close to the truth behind what happened]].

Top