Follow TV Tropes

Following

History UnintentionallyUnsympathetic / FanWorks

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Fanfic/GoAwayImWatchingPorn:
*** Kuroka in Chapter 17. She starts a catty argument with Raynare, gets all vicious when the Fallen Angel [[JerkassHasAPoint rightly calls her out on lying to Issei about her past]], and then tricks her into springing a trap out of petty vindictiveness. Raynare's subsequent punishment is viewed as LaserGuidedKarma in-universe, but it instead comes off as Kuroka being a DirtyCoward who can't take what she dishes out, with Vali and Jasmine simply [[MoralMyopia brushing it off.]]

to:

* ''Fanfic/GoAwayImWatchingPorn:
***
''Fanfic/GoAwayImWatchingPorn'':
**
Kuroka in Chapter 17. She starts a catty argument with Raynare, gets all vicious when the Fallen Angel [[JerkassHasAPoint rightly calls her out on lying to Issei about her past]], and then tricks her into springing a trap out of petty vindictiveness. Raynare's subsequent punishment is viewed as LaserGuidedKarma in-universe, but it instead comes off as Kuroka being a DirtyCoward who can't take what she dishes out, with Vali and Jasmine simply [[MoralMyopia brushing it off.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More people should know about this.


** Chapter 38 had some fans feeling Kurenai lost a lot of sympathy regarding her relationship with Naruto due to her being manipulative and openly controlling about who Naruto marries. Despite knowing for a fact that Naruto had been in a sexual (and later romantic) relationship with Ino even longer than she had, Kurenai only intended to tell Ino if Hinata decided not to marry him. Furthermore, Kurenai acts like it's a given that she'll be marrying Naruto and that she "can accept" him marrying other women. By contrast, Ino has long since come to the conclusion that she actually ''wants'' Naruto to marry her and Sakura.

to:

** Chapter 38 had some fans feeling Kurenai lost a lot of sympathy regarding her relationship with Naruto due to her being manipulative and openly controlling about who Naruto marries. Despite knowing for a fact that Naruto had been in a sexual (and later romantic) relationship with Ino even longer than she had, Kurenai only intended to tell Ino if Hinata decided not to marry him. Furthermore, Kurenai acts like it's a given that she'll be marrying Naruto and that she "can accept" him marrying other women. By contrast, Ino has long since come to the conclusion that she actually ''wants'' Naruto to marry her and Sakura.Sakura.
*''Fanfic/GoAwayImWatchingPorn:
**** Kuroka in Chapter 17. She starts a catty argument with Raynare, gets all vicious when the Fallen Angel [[JerkassHasAPoint rightly calls her out on lying to Issei about her past]], and then tricks her into springing a trap out of petty vindictiveness. Raynare's subsequent punishment is viewed as LaserGuidedKarma in-universe, but it instead comes off as Kuroka being a DirtyCoward who can't take what she dishes out, with Vali and Jasmine simply [[MoralMyopia brushing it off.]]
** Jasmine in Chapter 18. In a blatant AuthorTract to the constant complaints about Jasmine being a sex worker despite being in Issei's Harem, Jasmine proceeds to attack ''everyone'' sans Issei and Kiba, who are too busy fighting, with her Sacred Gear, using an attack she normally uses to ''shatter skulls''. Why? [[DisproportionateRetribution Because Sona insulted her for being a sex worker]], and only ''after'' she goaded Sona by hitting her insecurities with Serafall. The only reason Vali doesn't get affected is because he managed to put a finger in his ear which reduced the effects. Later, she brutally rapes Raynare with a sibian while beating her ass with a riding crop just because the Fallen Angel accused her of padding her breasts--and given what happened earlier, it's highly likely that Jasmine said or did something to provoke her first.
*** Her ensuing rant about what she suffered as a result of what happened to Issei is ''supposed'' to make her come across as sympathetic and make it look like Sona was needlessly antagonistic, but it rings hollow because, as Jasmine even admits, ''Sona is still being [[LockedOutOfTheLoop kept in the dark]] about everything'', and that she still only did this just because Sona is ''Serafall's'' sister. Making matters worse is that she hit ''everyone'' too, including Rias who Issei has started considering part of his hoard, just for being in the area, yet doesn't appear apologetic for her actions, and that instead of actually ''telling'' them about what they're being kept in the dark about, she just continues to keep them ''in'' the dark.
*** Likewise is her reasons for ''becoming'' a sex worker. [[spoiler:She says she became one as a way of sticking it to the people watching her and waiting for her degrade herself, a means of demonstrating they had no hold on her.]] Many have called out these reasons as flimsy ''at best'', and that regardless of her reasons, it doesn't change the fact she ''also'' abandoned Issei in order to pursue her own issues. She even notes that she could have easily stuck by Issei and let him help her instead of doing any of this, but asked him ''not'' to just so she could do this instead, and just for him to trust her, making it sound like she's angry at being in a position that she ''put herself in''.
*** Even the reveal that [[spoiler:her dad committed suicide years ago]] did ''nothing'' to win over her detractors, as they lambasted it as nothing more than a blatant attempt to make her look sympathetic without ''actually addressing the issues of the prior chapter.''
** Issei himself is slowly sliding into this trope. His brutal treatment of Raynare is particularly repulsive (ranging from threatening to deny her food to ''attempted rape''), he never outright apologizes for his mistakes even when acknowledging them, and he keeps excusing Jasmine's awful behavior--both towards others and himself--because he's too pathetically in love with her to care. He's got a traumatic past and his share of decent moments, to be sure, but he's such a colossal prick most of the time that a good number of readers just [[FreudianExcuseIsNoExcuse don't care anymore]] and want him to stop hiding behind what happened to him and move on
*** One particularly egregious issue is his hypocrisy: he mocks Kiba and Gasper's respective [[FreudianExcuse Freudian Excuses]] and forces them to confront their inner demons while [[NoSympathy obnoxiously telling them to get over it]]; and yet he staunchly clings to his own FreudianExcuse, [[ItsAllAboutMe demanding sympathy]] and various forms of compensation [[EntitledBastard when he's really owed nothing at all]], while viciously lashing out at ''anyone'' who tries to help him get over his own issues, or trying to turn it around on them without actually answering the criticism.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Fanfic/InfinityTrainBlossomingTrail'':
** While Chloe's reasons for not expressing her own interests and hobbies are comprehendible and worthy of some sympathy, it can be a bit hard to really be upset at others for not offering up things she was interested in if she kept her interests to a narrow circle and otherwise made it impossible for others to know about them. It is very easy to see a lot of the PoorCommunicationKills aspects of the story as being quite squarely on Chloe's shoulders even if the narrative would paint a picture that is more evenly split.
** It also doesn't help that Chloe is demonstrably uncaring about what everyone else is going through while she has her empowering adventure, not even her brother Parker who genuinely did nothing wrong by her. While she's shown relaxing and celebrating her new lease on life, '''everyone''' in Vermilion is beating themselves and each other up to a degree that can feel excessive (Ash gets no less than ''three'' lectures about how terrible he was for not doing more to spend time with someone who, from all appearances, didn't ''want'' to spend any time with him). Granted, this could be chalked up to FourthWallMyopia...except Chloe has her phone with her, and knows that Goh is driving himself insane looking for her and begging for forgiveness. And rather than confirm that she isn't dead in a ditch or even tell him that she won't accept his apologies for the sake of closure, she simply deletes the messages so Goh can keep suffering while she enjoys her adventure.
** Thankfully the author has been fully aware of what has been going on as the tail end of Arc 2 has Chloe determined to truly make amends with all she has hurt and truly begins to grow was as a person.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''UnintentionallyUnsympathetic/InfinityTrainBlossomingTrail''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/4854138/1/After-the-Metarex-Tails-Story After]][[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5302733/1/After-the-Metarex-Tails-and-Cosmo-s-Story The Metarex]]'': While the readers are meant to see Amadeus and Rosemary Prower as well meaning yet strict parents, instead they come off as stuck up and hypocritical SJWs, especially Rosemary considering that she behaves nastily towards Sonic just because he tries to get Tails to help him fight with Eggman and hating Knuckles and Amy just because they have anger problems and not trying to see that they are [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold good people at heart.]] While her forbeying Cosmo from dating Tails was meant to be seen as JerkassHasAPoint given that Cosmo couldn't prove that she had returned from the dead, it instead comes off as [[FantasticRacism racist]] considering that one of her reasons was because she was an alien.

to:

* ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/4854138/1/After-the-Metarex-Tails-Story After]][[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5302733/1/After-the-Metarex-Tails-and-Cosmo-s-Story The Metarex]]'': While the readers are meant to see Amadeus and Rosemary Prower as well meaning yet strict parents, instead they come off as stuck up and hypocritical SJWs, [=SJWs=], especially Rosemary considering that she behaves nastily towards Sonic just because he tries to get Tails to help him fight with Eggman and hating Knuckles and Amy just because they have anger problems and not trying to see that they are [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold good people at heart.]] While her forbeying Cosmo from dating Tails was meant to be seen as JerkassHasAPoint given that Cosmo couldn't prove that she had returned from the dead, it instead comes off as [[FantasticRacism racist]] considering that one of her reasons was because she was an alien.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/4854138/1/After-the-Metarex-Tails-Story After]][[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5302733/1/After-the-Metarex-Tails-and-Cosmo-s-Story The Metarex]]: While the readers are meant to see Amadeus and Rosemary Prower as well meaning yet strict parents, instead they come off as stuck up and hypocritical SJWs, especially Rosemary considering that she behaves nastily towards Sonic just because he tries to get Tails to help him fight with Eggman and hating Knuckles and Amy just because they have anger problems and not trying to see that they are [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold good people at heart.]] While her forbeying Cosmo from dating Tails was meant to be seen as JerkassHasAPoint given that Cosmo couldn't prove that she had returned from the dead, it instead comes off as [[FantasticRacism racist]] considering that one of her reasons was because she was an alien.

to:

* ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/4854138/1/After-the-Metarex-Tails-Story After]][[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5302733/1/After-the-Metarex-Tails-and-Cosmo-s-Story The Metarex]]: Metarex]]'': While the readers are meant to see Amadeus and Rosemary Prower as well meaning yet strict parents, instead they come off as stuck up and hypocritical SJWs, especially Rosemary considering that she behaves nastily towards Sonic just because he tries to get Tails to help him fight with Eggman and hating Knuckles and Amy just because they have anger problems and not trying to see that they are [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold good people at heart.]] While her forbeying Cosmo from dating Tails was meant to be seen as JerkassHasAPoint given that Cosmo couldn't prove that she had returned from the dead, it instead comes off as [[FantasticRacism racist]] considering that one of her reasons was because she was an alien.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/4854138/1/After-the-Metarex-Tails-Story After]][[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5302733/1/After-the-Metarex-Tails-and-Cosmo-s-Story The Metarex]]: While the readers are meant to see Amadeus and Rosemary Prower as well meaning yet strict parents, instead they come off as stuck up and hypocritical SJWs, especially Rosemary considering that she behaves nastily towards Sonic just because he tries to get Tails to help him fight with Eggman and hating Knuckles and Amy just because they have anger problems and not trying to see that they are [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold good people at heart.]] While her forbeying Cosmo from dating Tails was meant to be seen as JerkassHasAPoint given that Cosmo couldn't prove that she had returned from the dead, it instead comes off as [[FantasticRacism racist]] considering that one of her reasons was because she was an alien.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Blake is seen like this by many readers by chapter 13 for her lack of understanding as to how Adam is slowly changing throughout the story. This is taken even further in chapter 17 when she displays a NeverMyFault attitude when she leaks an edited video of Adam and Yang fighting that leads to Adam getting beaten by racist students in the cafeteria.

to:

*** Blake is seen like this by many readers by chapter 13 for her lack of understanding as to how Adam is slowly changing throughout the story. This is taken even further in chapter 17 when she displays a NeverMyFault attitude when she leaks an edited video of Adam and Yang fighting that leads to Adam getting beaten by racist students in the cafeteria.cafeteria.
* ''Fanfic/TheLastPrayer'':
** Hinata's shyness is turned UpToEleven, to the point she can barely keep from fainting around an ''illusion'' of Naruto that doesn't speak. Months of exposure therapy sees very little progress on her end, causing many fans to lose interest and wish the author would just get on with it already. It takes Hinata learning she's probably already lost her chance [[spoiler: due to multiple women already being in romantic and sexual relationships with Naruto]] for her to actually talk to him about her feelings.
** Chapter 38 had some fans feeling Kurenai lost a lot of sympathy regarding her relationship with Naruto due to her being manipulative and openly controlling about who Naruto marries. Despite knowing for a fact that Naruto had been in a sexual (and later romantic) relationship with Ino even longer than she had, Kurenai only intended to tell Ino if Hinata decided not to marry him. Furthermore, Kurenai acts like it's a given that she'll be marrying Naruto and that she "can accept" him marrying other women. By contrast, Ino has long since come to the conclusion that she actually ''wants'' Naruto to marry her and Sakura.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Thankfully the author has been fully aware of what has been going on as the tail end of Arc 2 has Chloe determined to truly make amends with all she has hurt and truly begins to grow was as a person.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It also doesn't help that Chloe is demonstrably uncaring about what everyone else is going through while she has her empowering adventure, not even her brother Parker who genuinely did nothing wrong by her. While she's shown relaxing and celebrating her new lease on life, '''everyone''' in Vermilion is beating themselves and each other up to a degree that can feel excessive (Ash gets no less than ''three'' lectures about how terrible he was for not doing more to spend time with someone who, from all appearances, didn't ''want'' to spend any time with him). Granted, this could be chalked up to FourthWallMyopia...except Chloe has her phone with her, and knows that Goh is driving himself insane looking for her and begging for forgiveness. And rather than confirm that she isn't dead in a ditch or even tell him that she won't accept his apologies for the sake of closure, she simply deletes the messages so Goh can keep suffering while she enjoys her adventure.

to:

** It also doesn't help that Chloe is demonstrably uncaring about what everyone else is going through while she has her empowering adventure, not even her brother Parker who genuinely did nothing wrong by her. While she's shown relaxing and celebrating her new lease on life, '''everyone''' in Vermilion is beating themselves and each other up to a degree that can feel excessive (Ash gets no less than ''three'' lectures about how terrible he was for not doing more to spend time with someone who, from all appearances, didn't ''want'' to spend any time with him). Granted, this could be chalked up to FourthWallMyopia...except Chloe has her phone with her, and knows that Goh is driving himself insane looking for her and begging for forgiveness. And rather than confirm that she isn't dead in a ditch or even tell him that she won't accept his apologies for the sake of closure, she simply deletes the messages so Goh can keep suffering while she enjoys her adventure.adventure.
* ''Creator/CoeurAlAran'''s works are guilty of this and how!
** FanFic/ForgedDestiny: Blake is considered to be this to a fair degree. Books 1 through 4 helped to establish a lot of sympathy for her and implied an interesting and complex past for her while still highlighting her genuine strengths and capacity to be a great teammate, friend, and lover. However from Book 5 onwards, she's begun to be stripped of a lot of the positive elements, and poor handling of her character results in her being seen as a self-righteous hypocrite who seems to expect others (Jaune especially) to treat her secrets with gentle hands, while she oftentimes is shown to have a disturbing lack of sympathy or understanding for others' issues or secrets (again, with Jaune). While the author has gone out of his way to try to establish her reasons for doing so (some more reasonable than others), the questionable logic and reasoning combined with a lackluster showing in the story, Jaune's sometimes excessive self-deprecation mixed with borderline Character Shilling of Blake's character have arguably only made her seem even more insufferable as a character.
*** Made all the worse in Book 8, where her abandoning the Guild in order to rush off and kill Raven on her own, and for reasons that either was never hinted at, if not expressly contradicted, cement her as a {{Hypocrite}} of the worse possible kind.
** FanFic/RelicoftheFuture:
*** Many readers feel that the narrative treats Raven far more kindly than she deserves to. Jaune considers her to be something of a friend and an ally worth trusting, despite the fact that she has, in the previous timeline, allied with Salem's servants and directly attacked Jaune's group. In contrast, Ozpin gets little trust or sympathy from Jaune, despite being portrayed far more sympathetically than Raven in canon, as he always tries his best to protect the people around him and to make the best out of a bad situation - though that is largely a result of CanonMarchesOn. Chapter 113 helped to alleviate this, with Raven still being a remorseless bandit and calling Jaune out for deluding himself into believing she's a good person at heart.
*** Some feel Pyrrha forfeited her right to sympathy in chapter 91. After insisting several times that she wanted to stop fighting in tournaments, especially once she started attending a Huntsman Academy, Pyrrha is pressured into entering another tournament but Helena helps her by announcing it's Pyrrha's final tournament before she retires. Despite finally having the perfect out to give up tournament fighting for good, Pyrrha still confirms in a press conference that she's not retiring and will continue fighting. Made worse by the fact one of Pyrrha's opponents in the tournament vastly outclassed her and offered the girl the chance to forfeit, but Pyrrha insisted on fighting on anyway rather than bowing out, and then she and Helena put all the blame on Jaune for “escalating the situation” when he continued to provide her an out.
*** Based on how the story is framed, the audience is supposed to accept the idea that Cinder could be swayed to the side of good if Jaune gave it a try, but Jaune is too set in his ways to try that. It's an interesting idea that Jaune doesn't seem to argue against, but the fact that Cinder is the exact same power-hungry psychopath that she was in canon despite all of Jaune's changes to the timeline really seems to suggest that Cinder is completely irredeemable.
** FanFic/TheBeastOfBeacon
*** Tsune's argument invoking HeWhoFightsMonsters on the now-disgraced Team CRMN comes off as this to a significant number of readers. They note how Adam literally had no other option to stop their bullying without making an example of them in a strong way that would discourage such behavior such as what Adam did during the match. This is because while Coeur attempts to invoke a GrayandGrayMorality in the fic itself, moments, where Adam would literally be in the wrong during his time in Beacon before Chapter 11, were sparse and few in between.
*** Blake is seen like this by many readers by chapter 13 for her lack of understanding as to how Adam is slowly changing throughout the story. This is taken even further in chapter 17 when she displays a NeverMyFault attitude when she leaks an edited video of Adam and Yang fighting that leads to Adam getting beaten by racist students in the cafeteria.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Fanfic/ToukenDanshiAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix'': Harry and the ''VideoGame/ToukenRanbu'' cast are supposed to be seen as cool, confident and assertive, but in practice they are snobbish (openly look down on and insult Hogwarts and wizarding Britain), entitled (verbally attack and threaten Dumbledore into allowing preferential treatment for Harry), myopic (given that Harry is a prince of Japan, they never consider how their actions can affect foreign relations) and violent (the swords often assault the British for the slightest perceived slights).

to:

* ''Fanfic/ToukenDanshiAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix'': Harry and the ''VideoGame/ToukenRanbu'' cast are supposed to be seen as cool, confident and assertive, but in practice they are snobbish (openly look down on and insult Hogwarts and wizarding Britain), entitled (verbally attack and threaten Dumbledore into allowing preferential treatment for Harry), myopic (given that Harry is a prince of Japan, they never consider how their actions can affect foreign relations) relations), annoying (assert their Japanese identity in tasteless ways, which include GratuitousJapanese towards people who don't speak the language) and violent (the swords often assault the British for the slightest perceived slights).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/ToukenDanshiAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix'': Harry and the ''VideoGame/ToukenRanbu'' cast are supposed to be seen as cool, confident and assertive, but in practice they are snobbish (openly look down on and insult Hogwarts and wizarding Britain), entitled (verbally attack and threaten Dumbledore into allowing preferential treatment for Harry), myopic (given that Harry is a prince of Japan, they never consider how their actions can affect foreign relations) and violent (the swords often assault the British for the slightest perceived slights).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It also doesn't help that Chloe is demonstrably uncaring about what everyone else is going through while she has her empowering adventure, not even her brother Parker who genuinely did nothing wrong by her (she does point out to Atticus how Parker truly cares for her in Chapter 10). While she's shown relaxing and celebrating her new lease on life, '''everyone''' in Vermilion is beating themselves and each other up to a degree that can feel excessive (Ash gets no less than ''three'' lectures about how terrible he was for not doing more to spend time with someone who, from all appearances, didn't ''want'' to spend any time with him). Granted, this could be chalked up to FourthWallMyopia...except Chloe has her phone with her, and knows that Goh is driving himself insane looking for her and begging for forgiveness. And rather than confirm that she isn't dead in a ditch or even tell him that she won't accept his apologies for the sake of closure, she simply deletes the messages so Goh can keep suffering while she enjoys her adventure.

to:

** It also doesn't help that Chloe is demonstrably uncaring about what everyone else is going through while she has her empowering adventure, not even her brother Parker who genuinely did nothing wrong by her (she does point out to Atticus how Parker truly cares for her in Chapter 10).her. While she's shown relaxing and celebrating her new lease on life, '''everyone''' in Vermilion is beating themselves and each other up to a degree that can feel excessive (Ash gets no less than ''three'' lectures about how terrible he was for not doing more to spend time with someone who, from all appearances, didn't ''want'' to spend any time with him). Granted, this could be chalked up to FourthWallMyopia...except Chloe has her phone with her, and knows that Goh is driving himself insane looking for her and begging for forgiveness. And rather than confirm that she isn't dead in a ditch or even tell him that she won't accept his apologies for the sake of closure, she simply deletes the messages so Goh can keep suffering while she enjoys her adventure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Fanfic/InfinityTrainBlossomingTrail:

to:

* Fanfic/InfinityTrainBlossomingTrail:''Fanfic/InfinityTrainBlossomingTrail'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While Chloe's reasons for not expressing her own interests and hobbies are comprehendible and worthy of some sympathy, it can be a bit hard to really be upset at others for not offering up things she was interested in if she kept her interests to a narrow circle and otherwise made it impossible for others to know about them. It is very easy to see a lot of the PoorCommunicationKills aspects of the story as being quite squarely on Chloe's shoulders even if the narrative would paint a picture that is more evenly split. The author even admits that it's hard to make the arguments on both sides equal without bringing up the DoubleStandard on Chloe's side.

to:

** While Chloe's reasons for not expressing her own interests and hobbies are comprehendible and worthy of some sympathy, it can be a bit hard to really be upset at others for not offering up things she was interested in if she kept her interests to a narrow circle and otherwise made it impossible for others to know about them. It is very easy to see a lot of the PoorCommunicationKills aspects of the story as being quite squarely on Chloe's shoulders even if the narrative would paint a picture that is more evenly split. The author even admits that it's hard to make the arguments on both sides equal without bringing up the DoubleStandard on Chloe's side.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I am tired of that story calliing out other characters for not trying harder to open up to Chloe, while not calling out Chloe on her complete refusal to open up to anyone. Poor communication is a two-way street.


* Izuku Midoriya in ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/series/1302101 All For Power]]'' loses his mother when Inko takes a bullet meant for him. Ordinarily, this would be heartbreaking, but Izuku willingly joined the League Of Villains twelve years prior in order to take over Japan and never once contacted Inko after he ran away. She died saving him because Izuku had befriended her under his new identity Imoku, roughly two years after he ran away. At Inko's funeral, Bakugou (who knows Izuku's true identity due to SomethingOnlyTheyWouldSay) calls out "Imoku" for letting her waste away and never once telling Inko he was still alive.

to:

* Izuku Midoriya in ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/series/1302101 All For Power]]'' loses his mother when Inko takes a bullet meant for him. Ordinarily, this would be heartbreaking, but Izuku willingly joined the League Of Villains twelve years prior in order to take over Japan and never once contacted Inko after he ran away. She died saving him because Izuku had befriended her under his new identity Imoku, roughly two years after he ran away. At Inko's funeral, Bakugou (who knows Izuku's true identity due to SomethingOnlyTheyWouldSay) calls out "Imoku" for letting her waste away and never once telling Inko he was still alive.alive.
* Fanfic/InfinityTrainBlossomingTrail:
** While Chloe's reasons for not expressing her own interests and hobbies are comprehendible and worthy of some sympathy, it can be a bit hard to really be upset at others for not offering up things she was interested in if she kept her interests to a narrow circle and otherwise made it impossible for others to know about them. It is very easy to see a lot of the PoorCommunicationKills aspects of the story as being quite squarely on Chloe's shoulders even if the narrative would paint a picture that is more evenly split. The author even admits that it's hard to make the arguments on both sides equal without bringing up the DoubleStandard on Chloe's side.
** It also doesn't help that Chloe is demonstrably uncaring about what everyone else is going through while she has her empowering adventure, not even her brother Parker who genuinely did nothing wrong by her (she does point out to Atticus how Parker truly cares for her in Chapter 10). While she's shown relaxing and celebrating her new lease on life, '''everyone''' in Vermilion is beating themselves and each other up to a degree that can feel excessive (Ash gets no less than ''three'' lectures about how terrible he was for not doing more to spend time with someone who, from all appearances, didn't ''want'' to spend any time with him). Granted, this could be chalked up to FourthWallMyopia...except Chloe has her phone with her, and knows that Goh is driving himself insane looking for her and begging for forgiveness. And rather than confirm that she isn't dead in a ditch or even tell him that she won't accept his apologies for the sake of closure, she simply deletes the messages so Goh can keep suffering while she enjoys her adventure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''Anime/AxisPowersHetalia'' Alternate Universe fanfic ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/7715672/1/Not-Everything-Is-Silver-and-Gold Not Everything is Silver and Gold]]'' tries to paint Prussia/Gilbert as sympathetic because [[spoiler: he lost Ludwig, and can't get him back unless he finds a Pure One, a being that can find treasure easily, to Arthur, the guy who murdered the reader's parents]]. However, the fact that chapter 2 involves [[spoiler: Gilbert raping you instead of explaining what's going on, and why]], then constantly forcing himself onto you and basically behaving like an abusive boyfriend doesn't exactly win sympathy from the readers.

to:

* The ''Anime/AxisPowersHetalia'' ''Webcomic/HetaliaAxisPowers'' Alternate Universe fanfic ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/7715672/1/Not-Everything-Is-Silver-and-Gold Not Everything is Silver and Gold]]'' tries to paint Prussia/Gilbert as sympathetic because [[spoiler: he lost Ludwig, and can't get him back unless he finds a Pure One, a being that can find treasure easily, to Arthur, the guy who murdered the reader's parents]]. However, the fact that chapter 2 involves [[spoiler: Gilbert raping you instead of explaining what's going on, and why]], then constantly forcing himself onto you and basically behaving like an abusive boyfriend doesn't exactly win sympathy from the readers.

Changed: 1

Removed: 1234

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Better fits Designated Hero as fails to explain why they were supposed to be sympathetic.


* Iris lands in this territory in ''Franchise/AceAttorney'' fic ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9550053/1/The-Fey-Family-Cousin The Fey Family Cousin]]''. Not only in this continuity she was watching Phoenix's trial and haven't lifted a finger to help him(in canon it was heavily implied that she didn't know about it until it was already over), but her motivation for not telling him the truth about herself mas moved from canon "IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy" to "I don't want to be hated" and from there to "just leave me alone" making her seem rather selfish.
* In ''Fanfic/MyBravePonyStarfleetMagic'', pretty much all the protagonists are this. The {{Original Character}}s come off as racist and sexist, treat everyone with different views than them as enemies that need to be destroyed or re-educated, and change Equestria's society into [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything what reads uncomfortably like a fascist regime]]. The canon characters have been [[{{Flanderization}} reduced to one-note caricatures]] almost solely devoted to either CharacterShilling the [=OCs=] or clutching the IdiotBall. As a result, it becomes hard to sympathize with any of them.
* In ''The Real Us'', Harry and Hermione are pathological liars (The ''entire canon series'' is pretty much lies they told), have a sociopathic disregard for anyone who isn't them and won't worship at their feet (for example, manipulating the Weasleys, including by using memory charms at the slightest provocation), manipulate the law and their status as heroes of the Wizarding World to visit DisproportionateRetribution on their personal enemies, and are [[SmugSnake insufferably smug]] about everything, outright ''boasting'' about how they lied to and manipulated everyone. Is it any wonder that they come off as outright villainous?

to:

* Iris lands in this territory in ''Franchise/AceAttorney'' fic ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9550053/1/The-Fey-Family-Cousin The Fey Family Cousin]]''. Not only in this continuity she was watching Phoenix's trial and haven't lifted a finger to help him(in him (in canon it was heavily implied that she didn't know about it until it was already over), but her motivation for not telling him the truth about herself mas moved from canon "IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy" to "I don't want to be hated" and from there to "just leave me alone" making her seem rather selfish.
* In ''Fanfic/MyBravePonyStarfleetMagic'', pretty much all the protagonists are this. The {{Original Character}}s come off as racist and sexist, treat everyone with different views than them as enemies that need to be destroyed or re-educated, and change Equestria's society into [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything what reads uncomfortably like a fascist regime]]. The canon characters have been [[{{Flanderization}} reduced to one-note caricatures]] almost solely devoted to either CharacterShilling the [=OCs=] or clutching the IdiotBall. As a result, it becomes hard to sympathize with any of them.
* In ''The Real Us'', Harry and Hermione are pathological liars (The ''entire canon series'' is pretty much lies they told), have a sociopathic disregard for anyone who isn't them and won't worship at their feet (for example, manipulating the Weasleys, including by using memory charms at the slightest provocation), manipulate the law and their status as heroes of the Wizarding World to visit DisproportionateRetribution on their personal enemies, and are [[SmugSnake insufferably smug]] about everything, outright ''boasting'' about how they lied to and manipulated everyone. Is it any wonder that they come off as outright villainous?
selfish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Izuku Midoriya in ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/series/1302101 All For Power]]'' loses his mother when Inko takes a bullet meant for him. Ordinarily, this would be heartbreaking, but Izuku willingly joined the League Of Villains twelve years prior in order to take over Japan and never once contacted Inko after he ran away. She died saving him because Izuku had befriended her under his new identity Imoku, roughly two years after he ran away. At Inko's funeral, Bakugou (who knows Izuku's true identity due to SomethingOnlyTheyWouldSay) calls out "Imoku" for letting her waste away and never once telling Inko he was still alive.
----

to:

* Izuku Midoriya in ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/series/1302101 All For Power]]'' loses his mother when Inko takes a bullet meant for him. Ordinarily, this would be heartbreaking, but Izuku willingly joined the League Of Villains twelve years prior in order to take over Japan and never once contacted Inko after he ran away. She died saving him because Izuku had befriended her under his new identity Imoku, roughly two years after he ran away. At Inko's funeral, Bakugou (who knows Izuku's true identity due to SomethingOnlyTheyWouldSay) calls out "Imoku" for letting her waste away and never once telling Inko he was still alive.
----
alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''FanFic/TheRealUs'', Harry and Hermione are pathological liars (The ''entire canon series'' is pretty much lies they told), have a sociopathic disregard for anyone who isn't them and won't worship at their feet (for example, manipulating the Weasleys, including by using memory charms at the slightest provocation), manipulate the law and their status as heroes of the Wizarding World to visit DisproportionateRetribution on their personal enemies, and are [[SmugSnake insufferably smug]] about everything, outright ''boasting'' about how they lied to and manipulated everyone. Is it any wonder that they come off as outright villainous?

to:

* In ''FanFic/TheRealUs'', ''The Real Us'', Harry and Hermione are pathological liars (The ''entire canon series'' is pretty much lies they told), have a sociopathic disregard for anyone who isn't them and won't worship at their feet (for example, manipulating the Weasleys, including by using memory charms at the slightest provocation), manipulate the law and their status as heroes of the Wizarding World to visit DisproportionateRetribution on their personal enemies, and are [[SmugSnake insufferably smug]] about everything, outright ''boasting'' about how they lied to and manipulated everyone. Is it any wonder that they come off as outright villainous?

Added: 635

Changed: 57

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9166728/1/Purple-Jealousy This]] ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans'' story. We're meant to root for Raven and hope that she gets with Beast Boy. However, between Raven's irrational jealousy of Beast Boy's new girlfriend and her controlling, downright abusive attitude, it's hard to really feel for her. During one chapter where she questions and criticizes Beast Boy for finding his new significant other, she berates him and insults his choice in women; when he retorts that she too once fell in love with someone who manipulated her, Raven [[{{Hypocrite}} acts shocked and hurt]] and we're meant to be on her side, despite the fact that she instigated the entire confrontation. Raven comes across as more of a SpoiledBrat who is upset because her LoveInterest doesn't bow to her every whim. It's a story where you actually [[UnintentionallySympathetic feel more inclined]] toward the RomanticFalseLead.

to:

* [[https://www.''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9166728/1/Purple-Jealousy This]] ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans'' story. Purple Jealousy]]'': We're meant to root for Raven and hope that she gets with Beast Boy. However, between Raven's irrational jealousy of Beast Boy's new girlfriend and her controlling, downright abusive attitude, it's hard to really feel for her. During one chapter where she questions and criticizes Beast Boy for finding his new significant other, she berates him and insults his choice in women; when he retorts that she too once fell in love with someone who manipulated her, Raven [[{{Hypocrite}} acts shocked and hurt]] and we're meant to be on her side, despite the fact that she instigated the entire confrontation. Raven comes across as more of a SpoiledBrat who is upset because her LoveInterest doesn't bow to her every whim. It's a story where you actually [[UnintentionallySympathetic feel more inclined]] toward the RomanticFalseLead.RomanticFalseLead.
* Izuku Midoriya in ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/series/1302101 All For Power]]'' loses his mother when Inko takes a bullet meant for him. Ordinarily, this would be heartbreaking, but Izuku willingly joined the League Of Villains twelve years prior in order to take over Japan and never once contacted Inko after he ran away. She died saving him because Izuku had befriended her under his new identity Imoku, roughly two years after he ran away. At Inko's funeral, Bakugou (who knows Izuku's true identity due to SomethingOnlyTheyWouldSay) calls out "Imoku" for letting her waste away and never once telling Inko he was still alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Despite Creator/CoriFalls going out of her way to make them sympathetic [[TheWoobie woobies]], her versions of Jessie, James, and Meowth become ''very'' unsympathetic as her stories go on, not only in their [[NoHoldsBarredBeatdown brutal]] [[DisproportionateRetribution treatment]] of characters like Ash, but in their self-righteous behavior, [[{{Wangst}} constant whining about their bad lot in life]], and [[NeverMyFault blaming their (usually self-inflicted) problems on anyone but themselves]].

to:

* Despite Creator/CoriFalls Cori Falls going out of her way to make them sympathetic [[TheWoobie woobies]], her versions of Jessie, James, and Meowth become ''very'' unsympathetic as her stories go on, not only in their [[NoHoldsBarredBeatdown brutal]] [[DisproportionateRetribution treatment]] of characters like Ash, but in their self-righteous behavior, [[{{Wangst}} constant whining about their bad lot in life]], and [[NeverMyFault blaming their (usually self-inflicted) problems on anyone but themselves]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Fanfic/{{Coyote}}'': Riley and Izuku, due to the discrimination they faced for being a foreigner and Quirkless respectively, dig up information on all of their potential teachers and send it to any student who wants to know more information about those teachers. Barring how {{disproportionate|Retribution}} this attitude is, Riley is even worse in this regard by deciding to charge people money for this information. Additionally, if his treatment of Aizawa is any indication, Riley is not above physically assaulting teachers he does not like. Moreover, the story does not acknowledge the possibility of how their system could be used to spread false information about teachers they don't like and get their way (especially in [[EveryoneIsASuper a world where nearly everyone has a Quirk]]).

to:

* ''Fanfic/{{Coyote}}'': Riley and Izuku, due to the discrimination they faced for being a foreigner and Quirkless respectively, dig up information on all of their potential teachers and send it to any student who wants to know more information about those teachers. Barring how {{disproportionate|Retribution}} this attitude is, Riley is even worse in this regard by deciding to charge people money for this information.information, a decision that seems to be motivated by only greed considering neither Riley nor Izuku has any financial problems and Riley's family are rather well-off as {{Royalties Heir}}s. Additionally, if his treatment of Aizawa is any indication, Riley is not above physically assaulting teachers he does not like. Moreover, the story does not acknowledge the possibility of how their system could be used to spread false information about teachers they don't like and get their way (especially in [[EveryoneIsASuper a world where nearly everyone has a Quirk]]).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Chapter 25 of ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13438258/25/ 151 Pokeshipping Stories]] has a flashback of the death of Misty's mother. The thing is supposed to play out as a tragedy and the reason why Mother's Day isn't a happy day for Misty. Problem is, it's too rushed and happens so brusquely, it fails to sink in. Not to mention that Misty's mother (who is supposedly a Water Pokémon expert, by the way) ended up killed was because she didn't keep a hold on her daughter, or better, get away from there ASAP when there was a ''freaking'' Gyarados sleeping on the shore, which borders on TooDumbToLive.

to:

** Chapter 25 of ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13438258/25/ 151 Pokeshipping Stories]] Stories]]'' has a flashback of the death of Misty's mother. The thing is supposed to play out as a tragedy and the reason why Mother's Day isn't a happy day for Misty. Problem is, it's too rushed and happens so brusquely, it fails to sink in. Not to mention that Misty's mother (who is supposedly a Water Pokémon expert, by the way) ended up killed was because she didn't keep a hold on her daughter, or better, get away from there ASAP when there was a ''freaking'' Gyarados sleeping on the shore, which borders on TooDumbToLive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Chapter 25 of ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13438258/25/ 151 Pokeshipping Stories]] has a flashback of the death of Misty's mother. The thing is supposed to play out as a tragedy and the reason why Mother's Day isn't a happy day for Misty. Problem is, it's too rushed and happens so brusquely, it fails to sink in. Not to mention that Misty's mother (who is supposedly a Water Pokémon expert, by the way) ended up killed was because she didn't keep a hold on her daughter, or better, get away from there ASAP when there was a ''freaking'' Gyarados sleeping on the shore, which borders on TooDumbToLive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One notorious ''[[Literature/{{Redwall}}]]'' Rule34 fic featured Matthias and Cornflower, the supposed Messiah figure and his girlfriend, responding to overhearing someone being raped and tortured to death by randomly starting to have sex.

to:

* One notorious ''[[Literature/{{Redwall}}]]'' ''Literature/{{Redwall}}'' Rule34 fic featured Matthias and Cornflower, the supposed Messiah figure and his girlfriend, responding to overhearing someone being raped and tortured to death by randomly starting to have sex.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One notorious [[Literature/{{Redwall}}]] Rule34 fic featured Matthias and Cornflower, the supposed Messiah figure and his girlfriend, responding to overhearing someone being raped and tortured to death by randomly starting to have sex.

to:

* One notorious [[Literature/{{Redwall}}]] ''[[Literature/{{Redwall}}]]'' Rule34 fic featured Matthias and Cornflower, the supposed Messiah figure and his girlfriend, responding to overhearing someone being raped and tortured to death by randomly starting to have sex.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One notorious Rule34 fic featured [[Literature/{{Redwall}} Matthias and Cornflower]], the supposed Messiah figure and his girlfriend, responding to overhearing someone being raped and tortured to death by randomly starting to have sex.

to:

* One notorious [[Literature/{{Redwall}}]] Rule34 fic featured [[Literature/{{Redwall}} Matthias and Cornflower]], Cornflower, the supposed Messiah figure and his girlfriend, responding to overhearing someone being raped and tortured to death by randomly starting to have sex.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9166728/1/Purple-Jealousy This]] ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans'' story. We're meant to root for Raven and hope that she gets with Beast Boy. However, between Raven's irrational jealousy of Beast Boy's new girlfriend and her controlling, downright abusive attitude, it's hard to really feel for her. During one chapter where she questions and criticizes Beast Boy for finding his new significant other, she berates him and insults his choice in women; when he retorts that she too once fell in love with someone who manipulated her, Raven [[{{Hypocrite}} acts shocked and hurt]] and we're meant to be on her side. She comes across as more of a SpoiledBrat who is upset because her LoveInterest doesn't bow to her every whim. It's a story where you actually [[UnintentionallySympathetic feel more inclined]] toward the RomanticFalseLead.

to:

* [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9166728/1/Purple-Jealousy This]] ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans'' story. We're meant to root for Raven and hope that she gets with Beast Boy. However, between Raven's irrational jealousy of Beast Boy's new girlfriend and her controlling, downright abusive attitude, it's hard to really feel for her. During one chapter where she questions and criticizes Beast Boy for finding his new significant other, she berates him and insults his choice in women; when he retorts that she too once fell in love with someone who manipulated her, Raven [[{{Hypocrite}} acts shocked and hurt]] and we're meant to be on her side. She side, despite the fact that she instigated the entire confrontation. Raven comes across as more of a SpoiledBrat who is upset because her LoveInterest doesn't bow to her every whim. It's a story where you actually [[UnintentionallySympathetic feel more inclined]] toward the RomanticFalseLead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9166728/1/Purple-Jealousy This]] ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans'' story. We're meant to root for Raven and hope that she gets with Beast Boy. However, between Raven's irrational jealousy of Beast Boy's new girlfriend and her controlling, downright abusive attitude, it's hard to really feel for her. During one chapter where she questions and criticizes Beast Boy for finding his new significant other, she berates him and insults his choice in women; when he retorts that she too once fell in love with someone who manipulated her, [[{{Hypocrite}}Raven acts shocked and hurt]] and we're meant to be on her side. She comes across as more of a SpoiledBrat who is upset because her LoveInterest doesn't bow to her every whim. It's a story where you actually [[UnintentionallySympathetic feel more inclined]] toward the RomanticFalseLead.

to:

* [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9166728/1/Purple-Jealousy This]] ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans'' story. We're meant to root for Raven and hope that she gets with Beast Boy. However, between Raven's irrational jealousy of Beast Boy's new girlfriend and her controlling, downright abusive attitude, it's hard to really feel for her. During one chapter where she questions and criticizes Beast Boy for finding his new significant other, she berates him and insults his choice in women; when he retorts that she too once fell in love with someone who manipulated her, [[{{Hypocrite}}Raven Raven [[{{Hypocrite}} acts shocked and hurt]] and we're meant to be on her side. She comes across as more of a SpoiledBrat who is upset because her LoveInterest doesn't bow to her every whim. It's a story where you actually [[UnintentionallySympathetic feel more inclined]] toward the RomanticFalseLead.

Top