Follow TV Tropes

Following

History TheLordOfTheRings / TropesPeoples

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This applies in regard to the origins of Orcs as well, as mentioned under AmbiguouslyHuman above. Tolkien had great trouble settling on an answer of whether they were corrupted Elves, corrupted Men, minor spirits taking the form of ugly and malicious humanoid, or some combination of all three (depending on the type of Orc in question).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KeystoneArmy: Due to most of them being cowardly, simple-minded, poorly-organized, and prone to fighting other orc tribes as often as other races, the Orcs are reduced to minor threats in the Dark Lord's absence. After Sauron and his lieutenants are dealt with, the grand host assembled at the Black Gate quickly routs despite outnumbering their Gondor-Rohan opponents ten to one. By contrast, even as their allies flee, isolated pockets of Easterlings and Haradrim Men are described as fighting stalwartly. It's suggested that the remaining orcs are gradually hunted to extinction in the aftermath of the War of the Ring, never again able to muster large-scale organized resistance.

to:

* KeystoneArmy: Due to most of them being cowardly, simple-minded, poorly-organized, and prone to fighting other orc tribes as often as other races, the Orcs are reduced to minor threats in the Dark Lord's absence. After Sauron and his lieutenants are dealt with, the grand host assembled at the Black Gate quickly routs despite outnumbering their Gondor-Rohan opponents ten to one. By contrast, even as their allies flee, isolated pockets of Easterlings and Haradrim Men are described as fighting stalwartly. It's suggested that the remaining orcs are gradually hunted to extinction in the aftermath of the War of the Ring, never again able to muster large-scale organized resistance. The goblin kingdom at the Misty and Grey Mountains is the largest known "independent" ream of theirs, and its forces were still small and weak enough that a mere 2,000 Elves, Dwarves, Men, and Eagles were able to exterminate it.

Added: 1138

Changed: 688

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OurOrcsAreDifferent: To a degree they ''are'', despite being the TropeNamer. Tolkien's actual orcs are much more advanced and intelligent, and not as physically powerful, than the crude barbarians AlwaysChaoticEvil orcs are generally portrayed as. They're a very diverse lot, and numerous varieties were around during the War of the Ring, largely as a result of the various dark lords breeding them like livestock to suit their needs.

to:

* OurGoblinsAreDifferent: They resemble goblins ''far'' more so than the typical fantasy orcs that postdate them, especially the ones at Misty Mountain. In-universe, goblins and orcs are interchangeable words.
* OurOrcsAreDifferent: To a degree they ''are'', despite being the TropeNamer. Tolkien's actual orcs are much more advanced and intelligent, intelligent than, and not as physically powerful, than powerful or brave as, the crude barbarians AlwaysChaoticEvil barbarians that orcs are generally portrayed as. They're a very diverse lot, and numerous varieties were around during the War of the Ring, largely as a result of the various dark lords breeding them like livestock to suit their needs.



** The Orcs of Mordor, also called Black Uruks or just Uruks[[note]] Uruk just means "Orc" in the Black Speech[[/note]], are the "main" breed of Orcs during the War of the Ring, large and strong and ferocious (at least, compared to other orcs; they're still shorter than Men and prone to [[DirtyCoward fleeing at the slightest chance of defeat]], hence the need for the half-human Uruk-hai). Sauron bred them during the late Third Age from the remnants of Morgoth's armies, in order to obtain a superior fighting force.
** Saruman's Uruk-hai of Isengard are more-or-less explicitly created from crossbreeding Orcs and Men and created by Saruman as elite soldiers. They're larger than other Orc types, and more upright and humanoid -- the other Orcs are usually described as hunched over and ape-like. They do not fear the sun (most of Sauron's and Morgoth's creatures cannot stand sunlight and do not travel by day) and are usually described as being better-organized and more dangerous foes than "common" Orcs.

to:

** The Orcs of Mordor, also called Black Uruks or just Uruks[[note]] Uruk just means "Orc" in the Black Speech[[/note]], are the "main" breed of Orcs during the War of the Ring, large and strong and ferocious (at least, compared to other orcs; they're still shorter than Men and prone to [[DirtyCoward fleeing at the slightest chance of defeat]], hence the need for the half-human part-Man Uruk-hai). Sauron bred them during the late Third Age from the remnants of Morgoth's armies, in order to obtain a superior fighting force.
** Saruman's Uruk-hai of Isengard are more-or-less explicitly created from crossbreeding Orcs and Men and created by Saruman as elite soldiers. They're larger They resemble unmodified humans (Treebeard at one point speculates that they simply ''are'' Men) more so than the other Orc types, meaning that they're taller, braver, and more upright with straight backs and humanoid legs -- the other Orcs are usually described as hunched over over, bowlegged, and ape-like. They do not fear the sun (most of Sauron's and Morgoth's creatures cannot stand sunlight and do not travel by day) and are usually described as being better-organized and more dangerous foes than "common" Orcs.


Added DiffLines:

* KeystoneArmy: Due to most of them being cowardly, simple-minded, poorly-organized, and prone to fighting other orc tribes as often as other races, the Orcs are reduced to minor threats in the Dark Lord's absence. After Sauron and his lieutenants are dealt with, the grand host assembled at the Black Gate quickly routs despite outnumbering their Gondor-Rohan opponents ten to one. By contrast, even as their allies flee, isolated pockets of Easterlings and Haradrim Men are described as fighting stalwartly. It's suggested that the remaining orcs are gradually hunted to extinction in the aftermath of the War of the Ring, never again able to muster large-scale organized resistance.

Added: 270

Changed: 580

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Adaptations portray them with distinctly non-human attributes such as green/grey skin and tusks (see for example Tim Kirk's art), but none of Tolkien's writings and letters describe such attributes. It's perfectly possible that they're just a particularly ugly and selectively bred race of Man/Elf hybrids, and thus human (which is further hinted at by the fact that Orcs and Men are apparently inter-fertile). Notably, ''Morgoth's Ring'' contains a note from Tolkien on ''The Silmarillion'' saying: "Alter this. Orcs are not Elvish."

to:

** Adaptations portray them with distinctly non-human attributes such as green/grey skin skin, pointy ears, and tusks (see for example Tim Kirk's art), but none of Tolkien's writings and letters describe such attributes. It's perfectly possible that they're just a particularly ugly and selectively bred race of Man/Elf hybrids, Men, and thus human (which is further hinted at by the fact that Orcs and Men are apparently inter-fertile). Notably, ''Morgoth's Ring'' contains a note from Tolkien on ''The Silmarillion'' saying: "Alter this. Orcs are not Elvish."



** The section of ''Morgoth's Ring'' titled ''Myths Transformed, text ix, comments on this:

to:

** The section of ''Morgoth's Ring'' titled ''Myths Transformed, text ix, texts ix and x, comments on this:



** The same source also notes that the elves called any creature that caused fear and/or horror "orc", and that they applied to the same label to what men called "trolls", so it's likely that multiple distinct breeds were simply being lumped under one term for convenience.

to:

-->''This then, as it may appear, was my father's final view of the question: Orcs were bred from Men, and if 'the conception in mind of the Orcs may go far back into the night of Melkor's thought' it was Sauron who, during the ages of Melkor's captivity in Aman, brought into being the black armies that were available to his Master when he returned.''
** The same source also notes that the elves called any creature that caused fear and/or horror "orc", and that they applied to the same label to what men called "trolls", so it's likely that multiple distinct breeds were simply being lumped under one term for convenience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The same source also notes that the elves called any creature that caused fear and/or horror "orc", and that they applied to the same label to what men called "trolls", so it's likely that multiple distinct breeds were simply being lumped under one term for convenience.

to:

*** ** The same source also notes that the elves called any creature that caused fear and/or horror "orc", and that they applied to the same label to what men called "trolls", so it's likely that multiple distinct breeds were simply being lumped under one term for convenience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OurDemonsAreDifferent: One source of Orcs, per Tolkien's writings, is minor spirits corrupted and given physical shape by [[{{Satan}} Melkor]].

Added: 2689

Changed: 411

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguouslyHuman: Adaptations portray them with distinctly non-human attributes such as green/grey skin and tusks (see for example Tim Kirk's art), but none of Tolkien's writings and letters describe such attributes. It's perfectly possible that they're just a particularly ugly and selectively bred race of Man/Elf hybrids, and thus human (which is further hinted at by the fact that Orcs and Men are apparently inter-fertile).

to:

* AmbiguouslyHuman: AmbiguouslyHuman:
**
Adaptations portray them with distinctly non-human attributes such as green/grey skin and tusks (see for example Tim Kirk's art), but none of Tolkien's writings and letters describe such attributes. It's perfectly possible that they're just a particularly ugly and selectively bred race of Man/Elf hybrids, and thus human (which is further hinted at by the fact that Orcs and Men are apparently inter-fertile). Notably, ''Morgoth's Ring'' contains a note from Tolkien on ''The Silmarillion'' saying: "Alter this. Orcs are not Elvish."


Added DiffLines:

** Treebeard, when speculating about the origin of the Uruk-hai, says "I wonder what he has done? Are they Men he has ruined, or has he blended the races of Orcs and Men?", the implication being that he wouldn't be able to tell the difference between Man/Orc hybrid and simply a corrupted Man.
** The section of ''Morgoth's Ring'' titled ''Myths Transformed, text ix, comments on this:
-->''Since Melkor could not 'create' an independent species, but had immense powers of corruption and distortion of those that came into his power, it is probable that these Orks had a mixed origin. Most of them plainly (and biologically) were corruptions of Elves (and probably later also of Men). But always among them (as special servants and spies of Melkor, and as leaders) there must have been numerous corrupted minor spirits who assumed similar bodily shapes... It would seem evident that they were corruptions of primitive human types... 'Melkor had corrupted many spirits - some great, as Sauron, or less so, as Balrogs. The least could have been primitive (and much more powerful and perilous) Orcs'.''
*** The same source also notes that the elves called any creature that caused fear and/or horror "orc", and that they applied to the same label to what men called "trolls", so it's likely that multiple distinct breeds were simply being lumped under one term for convenience.


Added DiffLines:

* RedemptionDemotion: Inverted. Compared to the Men and Elves they were (probably) bred from, Orcs are more numerous, crueler, and more subservient... and that's about it for useful traits. They're far smaller, more cowardly, and physically weaker than the average Man, and may be stupider as well. It reinforces the general theme of Tolkien's works that BeingEvilSucks.
* RiddleForTheAges: Tolkien never settled on and published a canonical origin for the orcs, throwing out various ones over the course of his decades of writing (such as golems made of slime, corrupted elves, corrupted men, animals given sapience, or crossbreeds between men and "beasts"), none of which adequately satisfied him. [[TakeAThirdOption It's possible that all of them are true to varying degrees.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OurDragonsAreDifferent: Monstrous, evil, greedy serpents directly inspired by Germanic myth; Tolkien's drawings portray them as winged, four-legged and very long and snakelike, with no horns but possessing external ears; the wings were a secondary addition, however, and the first dragons lacked them. They can hypnotize with their gaze and reach titanic sizes, and are divided between cold-drakes, who cannot breath fire, and the later ''urulóki'' fire-drakes, who can.

to:

* OurDragonsAreDifferent: Monstrous, evil, greedy serpents directly inspired by Germanic myth; Tolkien's drawings portray them as winged, four-legged and very long and snakelike, with no horns [[note]](Though there is a reference to the bow of Earendil being made of dragon horn in the Fellowship of the Ring, so at least some dragons seemed to have sported them.)[[/note]] but possessing external ears; the wings were a secondary addition, however, and the first dragons lacked them. They can hypnotize with their gaze and reach titanic sizes, and are divided between cold-drakes, who cannot breath fire, and the later ''urulóki'' fire-drakes, who can.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS has renamed Our Elves Are Better to Our Elves Are Different. Link changed accordingly.


* OurElvesAreBetter:

to:

* OurElvesAreBetter:OurElvesAreDifferent:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PunchClockVillain: Most of them fought for Sauron because he'd deceived and/or threatened them into joining him, and many more had legitimate grudges against the Númenóreans in general and Gondor in particular.

to:

* PunchClockVillain: Most of them fought for Sauron because he'd deceived and/or threatened them into joining him, him and they'd been under his sway for hundreds, even thousands of years, and many more had legitimate grudges against the Númenóreans in general and Gondor in particular.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmbiguouslyHuman: Adaptations portray them with distinctly non-human attributes such as green/grey skin and tusks (see for example Tim Kirk's art), but none of Tolkien's writings and letters describe such attributes. It's perfectly possible that they're just a particularly ugly and selectively bred race of Man/Elf hybrids, and thus human (which is further hinted at by the fact that Orcs and Men are apparently inter-fertile).
-->'''Tolkien''': The Orcs are definitely stated to be corruptions of the ‘human’ form seen in Elves and Men. They are (or were) squat, broad, flat-nosed, sallow-skinned, with wide mouths and slant eyes: in fact degraded and repulsive versions of the (to Europeans) least lovely Mongol-types.
-->'''Aragorn's narration:''' There were four goblin-soldiers of greater stature, swart, slant-eyed, with thick legs and large hands
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MadeOfIron: They are adapted to volcanic regions, and so the fumes in the Sammath Naur did not kill Frodo, Sam, or Gollum.

to:

* MadeOfIron: They are adapted to volcanic regions, and so the fumes in the Sammath Naur did not kill Frodo, Sam, or Gollum. Lampshaded by the House of Healing's Master when he's told that, while Faramir and Eowyn had to stay in bed for a while, Merry was going to be able to walk out of the bed ''the next morning''. Take note that all three was ill due to exposure to the Ring-Wraiths' corruption.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MadeOfIron: Played straigh. Literature/TheSilmarillion actually mention that Aulë make them that way, in order to resist against Morgoth and his armies.

to:

* MadeOfIron: Played straigh. Literature/TheSilmarillion straight. ''Literature/TheSilmarillion'' actually mention mentions that Aulë make made them that way, in order to resist against Morgoth and his armies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IncorruptiblePurePureness: Hobbits are the less corruptible of all Middle-Earth's races and they're chosen as the ones who bring the One Ring to be destroyed in Mordor because of this. Of all the four Hobbits that had the Ring in their hands at some point, none was fully corrupted, including Gollum, who even after ''five centuries'' having the Ring, a bit of his Smeagol persona still remains in him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MadeOfIron: Played straigh. Literature/TheSilmarillion actually mention that Aulë make them that way, in order to resist against Morgoth and his armies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected plural form to singular


* BornUnderTheSail: The Falmari elves were taught shipbuilding and seacraft by Ossë, a Maiar -- demigod -- of the sea, and consequently loved it more than any other elven people. They were the ones who built the swan-ships of the elves, and unlike the other elves of Aman dwell chiefly in the port city of Alqualondë and the island of Tol Eressëa.

to:

* BornUnderTheSail: The Falmari elves were taught shipbuilding and seacraft by Ossë, a Maiar Maia -- demigod -- of the sea, and consequently loved it more than any other elven people. They were the ones who built the swan-ships of the elves, and unlike the other elves of Aman dwell chiefly in the port city of Alqualondë and the island of Tol Eressëa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FlipFlopOfGod: On the relationship between orcs and goblins. At first Tolkien said that "orc" was simply the hobbit word for goblin. Later he said that goblins were a subtype of orc. Later still he said that goblins were completely separate creatures from orcs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Orcs of Mordor, also called Black Uruks or just Uruks,[[note]] Uruk just means "Orc" in the Black Speech[[/note]] were the "main" breed of Orcs during the War of the Ring, large and strong and ferocious (at least, compared to other orcs; they're still shorter than Men and prone to [[DirtyCoward fleeing at the slightest chance of defeat]], hence the need for the half-human Uruk-hai). Sauron bred them during the late Third Age from the remnants of Morgoth's armies, in order to obtain a superior fighting force.
** Saruman's Uruk-hai of Isengard are more-or-less explicitly created from crossbreeding Orcs and Men and created by Saruman as elite soldiers. They were larger than other Orc types, and more upright and humanoid -- the other Orcs were usually described as hunched over and ape-like. They did not fear the sun (most of Sauron's and Morgoth's creatures could not stand sunlight and did not travel by day) and were usually described as being better-organized and more dangerous foes than "common" Orcs.
** There are also several lesser Orcs in Mordor and Isengard, usually referred to as "Snaga" (meaning "slave" in the Black Speech). These appear to be used for labor and garrison duty, and are sent out to war when soldiers when numbers where needed. They tend to be described as small, impish and sneaky, preferring ambushes and other cunning tricks, while the bigger, stronger Uruks and Uruk-hai emphasize brute force and military discipline.

to:

** The Orcs of Mordor, also called Black Uruks or just Uruks,[[note]] Uruks[[note]] Uruk just means "Orc" in the Black Speech[[/note]] were Speech[[/note]], are the "main" breed of Orcs during the War of the Ring, large and strong and ferocious (at least, compared to other orcs; they're still shorter than Men and prone to [[DirtyCoward fleeing at the slightest chance of defeat]], hence the need for the half-human Uruk-hai). Sauron bred them during the late Third Age from the remnants of Morgoth's armies, in order to obtain a superior fighting force.
** Saruman's Uruk-hai of Isengard are more-or-less explicitly created from crossbreeding Orcs and Men and created by Saruman as elite soldiers. They were They're larger than other Orc types, and more upright and humanoid -- the other Orcs were are usually described as hunched over and ape-like. They did do not fear the sun (most of Sauron's and Morgoth's creatures could not cannot stand sunlight and did do not travel by day) and were are usually described as being better-organized and more dangerous foes than "common" Orcs.
** There are also several lesser Orcs in Mordor and Isengard, usually referred to as "Snaga" (meaning "slave" in the Black Speech). These appear to be used for labor and garrison duty, and are sent out to war when soldiers when numbers where are needed. They tend to be described as small, impish and sneaky, preferring ambushes and other cunning tricks, while the bigger, stronger Uruks and Uruk-hai emphasize brute force and military discipline.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OurDragonsAreDifferent: Monstrous, evil, greedy serpents directly inspired by Germanic myth; Tolkien's drawings portray them as winged, four-legged and very long and snakelike; the wings were a secondary addition, however, and the first dragons lacked them. They can hypnotize with their gaze and reach titanic sizes, and are divided between cold-drakes, who cannot breath fire, and the later ''urulóki'' fire-drakes, who can.

to:

* OurDragonsAreDifferent: Monstrous, evil, greedy serpents directly inspired by Germanic myth; Tolkien's drawings portray them as winged, four-legged and very long and snakelike; snakelike, with no horns but possessing external ears; the wings were a secondary addition, however, and the first dragons lacked them. They can hypnotize with their gaze and reach titanic sizes, and are divided between cold-drakes, who cannot breath fire, and the later ''urulóki'' fire-drakes, who can.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Orcs of Mordor, also called Black Uruks or just Uruks,[[note]] Uruk just means "Orc" in the Black Speech[[/note]] were the "main" breed of Orcs during the War of the Ring, large and strong and ferocious. Sauron bred them during the late Third Age from the remnants of Morgoth's armies, in order to obtain a superior fighting force.

to:

** The Orcs of Mordor, also called Black Uruks or just Uruks,[[note]] Uruk just means "Orc" in the Black Speech[[/note]] were the "main" breed of Orcs during the War of the Ring, large and strong and ferocious.ferocious (at least, compared to other orcs; they're still shorter than Men and prone to [[DirtyCoward fleeing at the slightest chance of defeat]], hence the need for the half-human Uruk-hai). Sauron bred them during the late Third Age from the remnants of Morgoth's armies, in order to obtain a superior fighting force.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!Dragons

The greatest living weapons created by Morgoth in the First Age, the dragons saw extensive use in the climactic battles of that time. They retreated to the far north of the world after their master's final defeat, and continued to plague the dwarves and men of the northern lands throughout the Second and Third Ages.
----
* BioweaponBeast: The dragons were bred by Morgoth to serve as living engines of war, a role they excelled at.
* BreathWeapon: ''Urulóki'' are capable of breathing fire, distinguishing them from the more primitive and fireless cold-drakes.
* DyingRace: They dragons have been steadily dying out since the end of the First Age -- the wars that ended Morgoth's reign killed most of them, and the rest fell one by one to clashes with men and dwarves. While numerous lesser drakes and worms endured in the Withered Heath, Smaug was the last true dragon left by the end of the Third Age.
* GiantFlyer: They are, without a shadow of a doubt, the biggest things to ever take to Middle-Earth's skies.
* HypnoticEyes: Dragons can ensnare anyone who looks them in the eyes.
* OurDragonsAreDifferent: Monstrous, evil, greedy serpents directly inspired by Germanic myth; Tolkien's drawings portray them as winged, four-legged and very long and snakelike; the wings were a secondary addition, however, and the first dragons lacked them. They can hypnotize with their gaze and reach titanic sizes, and are divided between cold-drakes, who cannot breath fire, and the later ''urulóki'' fire-drakes, who can.

Added: 347

Changed: 31

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Immortal beings of unearthly beauty. Elves were "the Firstborn" -- an older race than Men, more powerful, more learned, more beautiful, and (from a mortal point of view) more "magical." They are not TheFairFolk, though, for they are no more ethereal or amoral than Men. Elves are nearly immortal -- they live forever without aging, and while their bodies can be killed, their spirits can never leave the world until the end of time.

to:

Immortal beings of unearthly beauty. Elves were "the Firstborn" the Firstborn -- an older race than Men, more powerful, more learned, more beautiful, and (from a mortal point of view) more "magical." "magical". They are not TheFairFolk, though, for they are no more ethereal or amoral than Men. Elves are nearly immortal -- they live forever without aging, and while their bodies can be killed, their spirits can never leave the world until the end of time.



* BornUnderTheSail: The Falmari elves were taught shipbuilding and seacraft by Ossë, a Maiar -- demigod -- of the sea, and consequently loved it more than any other elven people. They were the ones who built the swan-ships of the elves, and unlike the other elves of Aman dwell chiefly in the port city of Alqualondë and the island of Tol Eressëa.



* ProudScholarRace[=/=]ProudWarriorRace: Both, to varying extents (the Noldor are more the former, while the Sindar are more the latter), though all of them become more the former as they fade into their twilight.

to:

* ProudScholarRace[=/=]ProudWarriorRace: Both, ProudScholarRace: Both this and ProudWarriorRace, to varying extents (the Noldor are more the former, while the Sindar are more the latter), though all of them become more the former as they fade into their twilight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImprobableAimingSkills: The prologue of the Lord of the Rings establishes that Hobbits are scarily accurate marksmen, not only with bows, but with stones. The films showcase this ability on occasion with Hobbits consistently making difficult shots by throwing rocks. [[RealityIsUnrealistic Fans often criticize these scenes for being unrealistic]].

to:

* ImprobableAimingSkills: The prologue of the Lord of the Rings establishes that Hobbits are scarily accurate marksmen, not only with bows, but with stones. Bilbo is also shown to be incredibly skilled at hitting targets with stones in The Hobbit. The films showcase this ability on occasion with Hobbits consistently making difficult shots by throwing rocks. [[RealityIsUnrealistic Fans often criticize these scenes for being unrealistic]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a bit about Hobbit ability to throw stones, since this is a somewhat well known trait of theirs.

Added DiffLines:

* ImprobableAimingSkills: The prologue of the Lord of the Rings establishes that Hobbits are scarily accurate marksmen, not only with bows, but with stones. The films showcase this ability on occasion with Hobbits consistently making difficult shots by throwing rocks. [[RealityIsUnrealistic Fans often criticize these scenes for being unrealistic]].

Added: 687

Removed: 687

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlantHair: Depicted with this in both the book and [[TheFilmOfTheBook the movie]]. Treebeard himself has this in WeirdBeard form.
* StarfishLanguage: Just like the Ents themselves, Entish is not a hasty language. It is a tonal language filled with subtle vowels and is extremely long-winded. It is unlikely that any other race could speak Old Entish, for example the word "A-lalla-lalla-rumba-kamanda-lindor-burúme" is part of their "word" for "hill" (or even a part of one specific hill in Fangorn Forest).
--> '''Treebeard:''' You must understand, young Hobbit, it takes a long time to say anything in Old Entish. And we never say anything unless it is worth taking a long time to say.



* PlantHair: Depicted with this in both the book and [[TheFilmOfTheBook the movie]]. Treebeard himself has this in WeirdBeard form.
* StarfishLanguage: Just like the Ents themselves, Entish is not a hasty language. It is a tonal language filled with subtle vowels and is extremely long-winded. It is unlikely that any other race could speak Old Entish, for example the word "A-lalla-lalla-rumba-kamanda-lindor-burúme" is part of their "word" for "hill" (or even a part of one specific hill in Fangorn Forest).
--> '''Treebeard:''' You must understand, young Hobbit, it takes a long time to say anything in Old Entish. And we never say anything unless it is worth taking a long time to say.

Added: 388

Removed: 398

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrouchingMoronHiddenBadass: Basically a racial trait. Hobbits in general are bucolic hedonists and tend to disdain nasty business like wars and adventures. However, those who push hobbits into conflict tend to find out that the pudgy little gardeners are seriously tough when they put their minds to it, and while they ''prefer'' frequent large meals, they're absurdly durable when pushed to it.


Added DiffLines:

* LetsGetDangerous: Basically a racial trait. Hobbits in general are bucolic hedonists and tend to disdain nasty business like wars and adventures. However, those who push hobbits into conflict tend to find out that the pudgy little gardeners are seriously tough when they put their minds to it, and while they ''prefer'' frequent large meals, they're absurdly durable when pushed to it.

Added: 213

Changed: 4232

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Arcadia}}: Subverted. Although Tolkien's love of the English countryside are part and parcel of the Shire's conception, effort is made to show that it is no more a utopian paradise than any other nice place to live. While the Shire does have the idyllic, rural and unspoiled look of the typical Arcadia, Tolkien portrays the Hobbits as very parochial, somewhat small-minded, and generally uncaring of what goes on outside the Shire.

to:

* {{Arcadia}}: Subverted. Although Tolkien's love of the English countryside are part and parcel of the Shire's conception, effort is made to show that it is no more a utopian paradise than any other nice place to live. While the Shire does have the idyllic, rural and unspoiled look of the typical Arcadia, Tolkien portrays the Hobbits as very parochial, somewhat small-minded, snooty towards 'strange' behaviour (such as Bilbo's adventurousness), and generally uncaring of what goes on outside the Shire.Shire, as well as suspicious of foreigners and foreign ideas.



* BigEater: Hobbits are really, really into food. Maybe it's their small size giving them a hyperactive metabolism, but they eat more than full-sized Men. Legolas at one point comments, while Aragorn tracks Merry and Pippin, that the mere fact that they sat down to eat immediately after [[spoiler:escaping from Orcs]] proves the tracks were left by Hobbits.
* BindingAncientTreaty: The Shire is theoretically a protectorate of the King of Arnor and while Arnor no longer exists, the Rangers do, and protect the Shire from nasty artifacts of the ancient wars. Hobbit laws are based on the laws of Arnor.

to:

* BigEater: Hobbits are really, really into food. Maybe it's their small size giving them a hyperactive metabolism, but they eat more than full-sized Men. Legolas at one point comments, while Aragorn tracks Merry and Pippin, that the mere fact that they sat down to eat immediately after [[spoiler:escaping from Orcs]] proves the tracks were left by Hobbits.
Hobbits. However, they don't ''have'' to be this, and can survive on short commons and function perfectly well for a long time (even if they don't like it very much).
* BindingAncientTreaty: The Shire is theoretically a protectorate of the King of Arnor and while Arnor no longer exists, the Rangers do, and protect the Shire from nasty artifacts artefacts and remaining creatures of the ancient wars. Hobbit laws are based on the laws of Arnor.



* CrouchingMoronHiddenBadass: Basically a racial trait. Hobbits in general are bucolic hedonists and tend to disdain nasty business like wars and adventures. However, those who push hobbits into conflict tend to find out that the pudgy little gardeners are seriously tough when they put their minds to it.

to:

* CrouchingMoronHiddenBadass: Basically a racial trait. Hobbits in general are bucolic hedonists and tend to disdain nasty business like wars and adventures. However, those who push hobbits into conflict tend to find out that the pudgy little gardeners are seriously tough when they put their minds to it, and while they ''prefer'' frequent large meals, they're absurdly durable when pushed to it.



* FantasyCounterpartCulture: The culture of the Shire is based on Tolkien's idealized view of the English countryside... though they're also not without rural England's perceived faults as well, such as small-mindedness and an overly provincial worldview.

to:

* FantasyCounterpartCulture: The culture of the Shire is based on Tolkien's idealized view of the English countryside... though they're also not without rural England's perceived faults as well, such as small-mindedness small-mindedness, a suspicion of foreigners, and an overly provincial worldview.worldview, to the point where Frodo voices Tolkien's point of view when he remarks that he sometimes thinks that an invasion of dragons or some such would be good for the Shire, if only to shake them out of their complacency... but that at the same time, he wants to preserve the peace and innocence it represents.



* {{Jerkass}}: Only a couple, like the Sackville-Bagginses and Déagol. Sméagol rather transcends Jerkass.

to:

* {{Jerkass}}: Only a couple, like the Sackville-Bagginses and Déagol. Sméagol began as an example, but as Gollum, he rather transcends Jerkass.



* MustHaveNicotine: Tolkien liked his pipe, [[AuthorAppeal so he decided to make smoking A Thing]] for Hobbits, with the Shire a major producer of excellent pipeweed.

to:

* MustHaveNicotine: Tolkien liked his pipe, [[AuthorAppeal so he decided to make smoking A Thing]] for Hobbits, with the Shire a major producer of excellent pipeweed. Indeed, it is pretty much confirmed InUniverse that Hobbits ''invented'' smoking.



Humans[[labelnote:*]]Tolkien preferred "Men" and "Mannish" over "human", probably because of the former words' Germanic roots[[/labelnote]]. Men are the last of the Free Peoples to come into existence (aside from hobbits, who are really an offshoot of Men) and are the most easily swayed to darkness. They possess "the Gift of Men" -- mortality and freedom from fate -- and unlike the Elves, they depart the material world after death.

to:

Humans[[labelnote:*]]Tolkien preferred "Men" and "Mannish" over "human", probably because of the former words' Germanic roots[[/labelnote]]. Men are the last of the Free Peoples to come into existence (aside from hobbits, Hobbits, who are really an offshoot of Men) and are the most easily swayed to darkness. They possess "the Gift of Men" -- mortality and freedom from fate -- and unlike the Elves, they depart the material world after death.



** The template for modern fantasy elves, being neither the divine beings of Myth/NorseMythology nor the little pixies of Victorian time, but essentially unfallen humans. A lot of characteristics assumed in posterior works [[UnbuiltTrope are already addressed here]], however: in spite of their superiority in many aspects, Elves are still prone to mistakes and outright evil, and their immortality is treated as a curse.
** That said, much of that addressing happens in the ''Silmarillion'' and ''Unfinished Tales'', with the remaining Elves having mellowed considerably by the time of the far better known works, ''The Hobbit'' and ''Lord of the Rings''. Elrond and Galadriel, as their OlderAndWiser selves, are far better known than Feanor (who created the Silmarils and led the first Kinslaying on the way to get them back), the Sons of Feanor (who led the second and third Kinslayings, also trying to get the Silmarils back), or Maeglin (who betrayed Gondolin).
* PermaShave: In general, Elves don't grow beards until they're almost prehistoric. [[note]]Specifically, in their "third cycle of life" according to a footnote in ''The Shibboleth of Fëanor'', which also notes that Fëanor's father-in-law Mahtan was a rare exception who had one in his "second cycle."[[/note]] The only Elf in ''The Lord of the Rings'' who has one is Círdan, who's well over seven thousand years old.
* ProudScholarRace / ProudWarriorRace: Both, though more the former as they fade into their twilight.

to:

** The template for modern fantasy elves, being neither the divine beings of Myth/NorseMythology nor the little pixies of Victorian time, times, but essentially unfallen humans. A lot of characteristics assumed in posterior works [[UnbuiltTrope are already addressed here]], however: in spite of their superiority in many aspects, Elves are still prone to mistakes and outright evil, evil (and when they ''do'' fall off the slippery slope, it tends to be absolutely ''spectacular'', on a scale that mere men can't even get close to), and their immortality is treated as a curse.
** That said, much of that addressing happens in the ''Silmarillion'' and ''Unfinished Tales'', with the remaining Elves having mellowed considerably by the time of the far better known works, ''The Hobbit'' and ''Lord of the Rings''. Elrond and Galadriel, as their OlderAndWiser selves, are far better known than Feanor (who created the Silmarils and led the first Kinslaying on the way to get them back), the Sons of Feanor (who led the second and third Kinslayings, also trying to get the Silmarils back), back - though not all of them really wanted to, being compelled by the Oath. On the other hand, some of them went above and beyond to be monsters), or Maeglin (who betrayed Gondolin).
** In short, they're far more physically, and to an extent, spiritually superior to humans. This does not mean that they're ''morally'' superior, being prone to arrogance, overwhelming ambition, and FantasticRacism between the High Elves and everyone else, then between the elves and, again, more or less everyone else, even in the Third Age, albeit in an affably condescending kind of way. As the above points note, most of the elves we meet in the late Third Age are OlderAndWiser (and even then, the elves of Mirkwood, and to a lesser extent Lothlorien, are pretty close to TheFairFolk), with the real troublemakers having died a long time ago or been dragged back to Valinor by their pointy ears at the end of the First Age.
* PermaShave: In general, Elves don't grow beards until they're almost prehistoric. [[note]]Specifically, in their "third cycle of life" according to a footnote in ''The Shibboleth of Fëanor'', which also notes that Fëanor's father-in-law Mahtan was a rare exception who had one in his "second cycle."[[/note]] The only Elf in ''The Lord of the Rings'' who has one is Círdan, who's well over seven thousand years old.
old, and may well ''literally'' be prehistoric, if the theory that he's one of the first Elves to awaken at Cuivienen is true.
* ProudScholarRace / ProudWarriorRace: ProudScholarRace[=/=]ProudWarriorRace: Both, to varying extents (the Noldor are more the former, while the Sindar are more the latter), though all of them become more the former as they fade into their twilight.twilight.



* HeroicWillpower: Race-wide (and justified in [[Literature/TheSilmarillion the story of their creation]]). To cite the most evident example, Sauron's One Ring utterly enslaved the wearers of the Nine (and supposedly would have done so for the Three as well): the seven dwarf-kings wearing the Rings of the Dwarves were pulled toward TheDarkSide to some extent, but retained their own wills. Even their aging wasn't affected.

to:

* HeroicWillpower: Race-wide (and justified in [[Literature/TheSilmarillion the story of their creation]]). To cite the most evident example, Sauron's One Ring utterly enslaved the wearers of the Nine (and supposedly would have done so for the Three as well): the seven dwarf-kings wearing the Rings of the Dwarves were pulled toward TheDarkSide to some extent, extent (mainly, they got incredibly greedy), but retained their own wills. Even their aging ageing wasn't affected.



* OneGenderRace: Subverted. They all ''look'' male to non-Dwarves, because the women are just as flat-chested and beard-y as the men, and they all sound male too, leading some Men to think they're all guys. But Dwarves themselves can tell the difference, somehow. This is subverted in [[Film/TheHobbitAnUnexpectedJourney the first part]] of the film adaptation of ''Film/TheHobbit'', where in the prologue, the dwarven women of Erebor are depicted as noticeably more feminine.
* OurDwarvesAreAllTheSame: ...Kind of. Obviously, these dwarves are the template from which the modern fantasy dwarf was built, and share the now standard profile of a short, proud, mountain-dwelling and often fading people fond of smith-work and highly unfond of orcs and dragons -- but there are notable deviations.
** For just one example, these dwarves love music and song more than strong drink. Every dwarf in ''Literature/TheHobbit'' is an adept musician, and a great deal of their history and culture is passed down through song -- and among these songs, the melancholy poem of Durin in ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' devotes an entire verse to the instruments that played in Khazad-dûm when the people relaxed after the day's work was done.
** Strongly averted for the Dwarven language and conceptual background -- in contrast to the stereotypical Norse or pseudo-Scottish dwarves of virtually all later fantasy works, Tolkien's Dwarves are actually a FantasyCounterpartCulture to the Jews. Their language, Khuzdul, was actually developed by Tolkien (through nowhere near as extensively as the Elvish languages) and [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khuzdul was explicitly based on Semitic languages]], with the intended direct comparison explicitly stated by the author himself. The backstory of the Dwarves losing their ancestral home and being forced to live in a diaspora among other cultures, with partial assimilation occuring over the centuries despite strong attempts to keep their identity, also fits the bill. The Norse-derived names of all Dwarves are mentioned to be "outer names", pseudonyms for interaction with their host societies and likely taken from these cultures (hence the similarity between the Norse-sounding names of e.g. the men of Dale to the Dwarven names) - the true Khuzdul names are never revealed to outsiders and only used in secrecy among themselves, just like the language. Think of, for example, the Spanish "''marranos''", ostensibly converts to Christianity, many of whom remained "crypto-Jews"...see the pattern? So, Tolkien's Dwarves are essentially fantasy Jews masquerading as fantasy Vikings, in a way.
* ParadoxPerson: Dwarves were not created with the world and therefore would not exist in its first designing. They were created when Aulë, the smith god, grew impatient for the first of Ilúvatar's children (the elves) to awaken; he decided to create creatures for himself. However, because he didn't have the power of true creation, they were originally little more than automatons, with no free will. Ilúvatar questioned Aulë's intentions for stepping outside the plans for the universe which led to the creation of a mockery of real life. Aulë responded that he did it only because he was compelled by his love for creating which drove him to give life to creatures to share in that love. He then repented and was sorrowfully preparing to destroy the first dwarves but because unlike Melkor he genuinely respected his creations and didn't see them as an extension of his will, Ilúvatar, seeing Aulë's grief, gave the dwarves free will. As a result, the dwarves exist in Tolkien's world, but they occupy a strange place in it: they are like the Children of Ilúvatar (elves and humans), and yet separate from them as they technically were made by the force of craft and skill.

to:

* OneGenderRace: Subverted. They all ''look'' male to non-Dwarves, because the women are just as flat-chested and beard-y as the men, and they all sound male too, leading some Men to think they're all guys. But Dwarves themselves can tell the difference, somehow. This is subverted in [[Film/TheHobbitAnUnexpectedJourney the first part]] of the film adaptation of ''Film/TheHobbit'', where in the prologue, the dwarven women of Erebor are depicted as noticeably more feminine.
feminine (but still masculine by human standards, complete with short beards).
* OurDwarvesAreAllTheSame: ...Kind of. Obviously, these dwarves are the template from which the modern fantasy dwarf was built, and share the now standard profile of a short, proud, mountain-dwelling and often fading people fond of smith-work and highly unfond of with a raging hatred for orcs and dragons (and they're not that fond of elves, either) -- but there are notable deviations.
** For just one example, these dwarves love music and song even more than strong drink. Every dwarf in ''Literature/TheHobbit'' is an adept musician, and a great deal of their history and culture is passed down through song -- and among these songs, the melancholy poem of Durin in ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' devotes an entire verse to the instruments that played in Khazad-dûm when the people relaxed after the day's work was done.
** Strongly averted for the Dwarven language and conceptual background -- in contrast to the stereotypical Norse or pseudo-Scottish dwarves of virtually all later fantasy works, Tolkien's Dwarves are actually a FantasyCounterpartCulture to the Jews. Their language, Khuzdul, was actually developed by Tolkien (through nowhere near as extensively as the Elvish languages) and [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khuzdul was explicitly based on Semitic languages]], with the intended direct comparison explicitly stated by the author himself. The backstory of the Dwarves losing their ancestral home and being forced to live in a diaspora among other cultures, with partial assimilation occuring occurring over the centuries despite strong attempts to keep their identity, also fits the bill. The Norse-derived names of all Dwarves are mentioned to be "outer names", pseudonyms for interaction with their host societies and likely taken from these cultures (hence the similarity between the Norse-sounding names of e.g. the men of Dale to the Dwarven names) - the true Khuzdul names are never revealed to outsiders and only used in secrecy among themselves, just like the language. Think of, for example, the Spanish "''marranos''", ostensibly converts to Christianity, many of whom remained "crypto-Jews"... see the pattern? So, Tolkien's Dwarves are essentially fantasy Jews masquerading as fantasy Vikings, in a way.
* ParadoxPerson: Dwarves were not created with the world and therefore would not exist in its first designing. They were created when Aulë, the smith god, grew impatient for the first of Ilúvatar's children (the elves) to awaken; awaken, because he wanted to teach them; as a result, he decided to create creatures for himself. However, because he didn't have the power of true creation, they were originally little more than automatons, with no free will. Ilúvatar questioned Aulë's intentions for stepping outside the plans for the universe which led to the creation of a mockery of real life. Aulë responded that he did it only because he was compelled by his love for creating which drove him to give life to creatures to share in that love. He then repented and was sorrowfully preparing to destroy the first dwarves but because unlike Melkor he genuinely respected his creations and didn't see them as an extension of his will, Ilúvatar, seeing Aulë's grief, gave the dwarves free will. As a result, the dwarves exist in Tolkien's world, but they occupy a strange place in it: they are like the Children of Ilúvatar (elves and humans), and yet separate from them as they technically were made by the force of craft and skill.skill - functionally, they're the adopted siblings.



* AmbiguouslyHuman: Per ''Literature/TheSilmarillion'', wizards are [[OurAngelsAreDifferent Maiar]]. However, what they are exactly is not explained in either ''The Hobbit'' or ''The Lord Of The Rings''.

to:

* AmbiguouslyHuman: Per ''Literature/TheSilmarillion'', wizards are [[OurAngelsAreDifferent Maiar]]. However, what they are exactly is not explained in either ''The Hobbit'' or ''The Lord Of The Rings''.Rings'', with vague allusions to the fact that they're not entirely human (but not exactly anything else) being as close as it gets.



* PowerCorrupts: Out of the five, Gandalf is the only one who we know saw through his mission to the end, and he has a decisive role in the winning of the War of the Ring. Saruman, the most powerful wizard and their leader, ends up turning to evil. Radagast the Brown appears to have gotten lost just tending to animals, and we don't hear much about the two Blue Wizards (although supplemental materials by Tolkien suggest that they stirred up some rebellions in the Eastern lands Sauron ruled).

to:

* PowerCorrupts: Out of the five, Gandalf is the only one who we know saw through his mission to the end, and he has a decisive role in the winning of the War of the Ring. Saruman, the most powerful wizard and their leader, ends up turning to evil. Radagast the Brown appears to have gotten lost just tending to animals, animals (though that might have been part of his mission - he was a Maia of Yavanna and it's not explicitly stated what his specific job was), and we don't hear much about the two Blue Wizards (although supplemental materials by Tolkien suggest that they stirred up some rebellions in the Eastern lands Sauron ruled).



* TokenGoodTeammate: Gandalf, although Radagast remains on the side of good but doesn't help much with the war against Sauron.

to:

* TokenGoodTeammate: Gandalf, although Depending on interpretation. Gandalf is the only one we know for sure was ''active'' on the side of good. However, Radagast remains on the side of good but good, even if he doesn't help much with the war against Sauron.Sauron - his house at Rhosgobel is found to be empty just after the War of the Ring, with Gandalf having previously mentioned that he only leaves it at great need (suggesting that he had ''some'' pressing business elsewhere, even if it isn't clear what that was). Additionally, the Blue Wizards may or may not have helped out by disrupting Sauron's business in the East, possibly inspiring rebellions against his rule (Tolkien's ideas changed over time).



* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The two blue wizards are unnamed in the book and go into the east and south of Middle-Earth. What they do there, and their ultimate fate, is unknown, and Tolkien's ideas of what they did there changed throughout his life.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The two blue wizards Blue Wizards are unnamed in the book (several possible names are given for them, but none are definitive) and go into the east and south of Middle-Earth. What they do there, and their ultimate fate, is unknown, and Tolkien's ideas of what they did there changed throughout his life.life - i.e. whether they actively helped disrupt Sauron's actions there and inspired rebellions, or just ended up creating magical cults and whatnot.



* NoCureForEvil: Averted. Orcish medicine is pretty good, though it tends to be somewhat painful and causes scarring. It's designed to get you back into the fight as quickly as possible, and if you're not tough enough to take it you don't deserve it.

to:

* NoCureForEvil: Averted. Orcish medicine is actually pretty good, though it tends to be somewhat painful and causes scarring. It's designed to get you back into the fight as quickly as possible, and if you're not tough enough to take it you don't deserve it.



** Firstly, there are the [[OurGoblinsAreDifferent goblins]] of the Misty Mountains, also referred to as northern Orcs or "Northerners". They're generally assumed to have descended from the survivors of Morgoth's First Age armies, who fled beneath the Misty Mountains following their lord's defeat. They're usually described as smaller than other kinds, possibly from having lived underground and on their own for so long, possibly from their ancestors not being as "refined" for war as later breeds.

to:

** Firstly, there are the [[OurGoblinsAreDifferent goblins]] of the Misty Mountains, also referred to as northern Orcs or "Northerners". They're generally assumed to have descended from the survivors of Morgoth's First Age armies, who fled beneath the Misty Mountains following their lord's defeat. They're usually described as smaller than other kinds, possibly from having lived underground and on their own for so long, possibly from their ancestors not being as "refined" for war as later breeds. They're also suggested by ''The Hobbit'' to be smarter and more technologically innovative than their relatives, with the narration noting that they have a certain genius for weapons and machines built for cruelty.

Added: 4082

Changed: 7349

Removed: 531

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



* {{Arcadia}}: Subverted. Though Tolkien's love of the English countryside are part and parcel of the Shire's conception, effort is made to show that it is no more a utopian paradise than any other nice place to live. While the Shire does have the idyllic, rural and unspoiled look of the typical Arcadia, Tolkien portrays the Hobbits as very parochial, somewhat small-minded, and generally uncaring of what goes on outside the Shire.

to:

\n----
* {{Arcadia}}: Subverted. Though Although Tolkien's love of the English countryside are part and parcel of the Shire's conception, effort is made to show that it is no more a utopian paradise than any other nice place to live. While the Shire does have the idyllic, rural and unspoiled look of the typical Arcadia, Tolkien portrays the Hobbits as very parochial, somewhat small-minded, and generally uncaring of what goes on outside the Shire.



* BadassNormal/ BadassAdorable: The Shire has only ever been invaded twice, three times if you count the wolves during the Long Winter. All three times, it ended ''very'' badly for the invaders.

to:

* BadassNormal/ BadassAdorable: BadassNormal: The Shire has only ever been invaded twice, twice -- three times if you count the wolves during the Long Winter. All three times, it ended ''very'' badly for the invaders.



* {{Hobbits}}: TropeNamer, TropeCodifier, and quite likely the UrExample.

to:

* {{Hobbits}}: The TropeNamer, TropeCodifier, and quite likely the UrExample.UrExample. Tolkien's Hobbits are ''the'' original short, hearty, pastoral and pipe-smoking fantasy people that later fantasy works would all draw from.



The greatest civilization in history was Númenor, home of the Dúnedain, or Men of the West. Númenor fell to hubris and its successor states were destroyed or weakened by Sauron, leaving only the crumbling kingdom of Gondor and the scattered Rangers of the North as heirs to Númenor's glory.

to:

The Their greatest civilization in history was Númenor, home of the Dúnedain, or Men of the West. Númenor fell to hubris and its successor states were destroyed or weakened by Sauron, leaving only the crumbling kingdom of Gondor and the scattered Rangers of the North as heirs to Númenor's glory.




to:

----




to:

----



* BlessedWithSuck: Although Men often view the Elves' immortality, eternal youth and ability to be reborn with considerable envy, the Elves themselves consider their lot -- and thus their inability to leave the world and their dying civilization behind, and their being doomed after death to linger on as phantoms until the end of time -- to be on the whole less desirable than mankind's freedom from the ties of fate. Eternity is not a very kind thing when your fate is to fade and diminish for all time.




* DyingRace: Dwarves have an abysmally low birth rate due to men outnumbering women three to one, and the women's frequent unwillingness to take a husband. The constant warfare after the fall of Khazad-dûm didn't help. It's implied that they become extinct some time in the Fourth Age.
* FightingForAHomeland: Erebor in ''Literature/TheHobbit'', Khazad-dûm in the {{Backstory}} to ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings''.

to:

\n----
* DyingRace: Dwarves have an abysmally low birth rate rate, due to their men outnumbering women three to one, one and the their women's frequent unwillingness to take a husband. The Further, the loss of almost every Dwarven realm over the Second Age to cataclysms, the Balrog, Smaug and constant warfare after with orcs and lesser dragons cost the fall of Khazad-dûm didn't help.Dwarves a great deal in both culture and numbers. It's implied that they become extinct some time in the Fourth Age.
* FightingForAHomeland: By the late Third Age, the Dwarves have lost most of their ancient kingdoms and deeply wish to take them back, expending great amounts of time, lives and effort into doing so. Erebor plays this role in ''Literature/TheHobbit'', and Khazad-dûm in the {{Backstory}} to ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings''.



* OurDwarvesAreAllTheSame: ...Kind of. Obviously, these dwarves are the template from which the modern fantasy dwarf was built, but there are notable deviations. For just one example, these dwarves love music and song more than strong drink. Every dwarf in ''Literature/TheHobbit'' is an adept musician, and the melancholy poem of Durin in ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' devotes an entire verse to the instruments that played in Khazad-dûm when the people relaxed after the day's work was done.
** Seriously averted for the Dwarven language and conceptual background--in contrast to the stereotypical Norse or pseudo-Scottish dwarves of virtually all later fantasy works, Tolkien's Dwarves are actually a FantasyCounterpartCulture to the Jews. Their language, Khuzdul, was actually developed by Tolkien (through nowhere near as extensively as the Elvish languages) and [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khuzdul was explicitly based on Semitic languages]], with the intended direct comparison explicitly stated by the author himself. The backstory of the Dwarves losing their ancestral home and being forced to live in a diaspora among other cultures, with partial assimilation occuring over the centuries despite strong attempts to keep their culture, also fits the bill. The Norse-derived names of all Dwarves are mentioned to be "outer names", pseudonyms for interaction with their host societies and likely taken from these cultures (hence the similarity between the Norse-sounding names of e.g. the men of Dale to the Dwarven names) - the true Khuzdul names are never revealed to outsiders and only used in secrecy among themselves, just like the language. Think of, for example, the Spanish "''marranos''", ostensibly converts to Christianity, many of whom remained "crypto-Jews"...see the pattern? So, Tolkien's Dwarves are essentially fantasy Jews masquerading as fantasy Vikings, in a way.

to:

* OurDwarvesAreAllTheSame: ...Kind of. Obviously, these dwarves are the template from which the modern fantasy dwarf was built, and share the now standard profile of a short, proud, mountain-dwelling and often fading people fond of smith-work and highly unfond of orcs and dragons -- but there are notable deviations. deviations.
**
For just one example, these dwarves love music and song more than strong drink. Every dwarf in ''Literature/TheHobbit'' is an adept musician, and a great deal of their history and culture is passed down through song -- and among these songs, the melancholy poem of Durin in ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' devotes an entire verse to the instruments that played in Khazad-dûm when the people relaxed after the day's work was done.
** Seriously Strongly averted for the Dwarven language and conceptual background--in background -- in contrast to the stereotypical Norse or pseudo-Scottish dwarves of virtually all later fantasy works, Tolkien's Dwarves are actually a FantasyCounterpartCulture to the Jews. Their language, Khuzdul, was actually developed by Tolkien (through nowhere near as extensively as the Elvish languages) and [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khuzdul was explicitly based on Semitic languages]], with the intended direct comparison explicitly stated by the author himself. The backstory of the Dwarves losing their ancestral home and being forced to live in a diaspora among other cultures, with partial assimilation occuring over the centuries despite strong attempts to keep their culture, identity, also fits the bill. The Norse-derived names of all Dwarves are mentioned to be "outer names", pseudonyms for interaction with their host societies and likely taken from these cultures (hence the similarity between the Norse-sounding names of e.g. the men of Dale to the Dwarven names) - the true Khuzdul names are never revealed to outsiders and only used in secrecy among themselves, just like the language. Think of, for example, the Spanish "''marranos''", ostensibly converts to Christianity, many of whom remained "crypto-Jews"...see the pattern? So, Tolkien's Dwarves are essentially fantasy Jews masquerading as fantasy Vikings, in a way.




to:

----



* {{Treants}}: The {{Trope Maker}}s. In-universe, the Ents were explicitly created by the nature goddess Yavanna to protect the wilderness from the axes of civilization (and to keep the trees from becoming homicidal). They have an odd sort of immortality: they don't age and live more or less forever, but over time become stiffer, sleepier and more "treeish", rooting themselves and not stirring for increasingly long periods, eventually becoming indistinguishable from normal trees. They still live extremely long before this happens, giving them a very patient and long-term view on things: they consider reaching a decision after three days of continuous debate almost unseemly hasty.
** In a mild case of UnbuiltTrope, they have a number of characteristics later imitations lack, such as a highly variable numbers of fingers and toes and a form of gender dimorphism: male Ents live in deep forests and guard nature like later examples, but the women, the Entwives, favor agriculture and farmlands and resemble various crops and domestic trees, and were the ones who taught agriculture to early Men.

to:

* {{Treants}}: The {{Trope Maker}}s. In-universe, the Ents were explicitly created by the nature goddess Yavanna to protect the wilderness from the axes of civilization (and to keep the trees from becoming homicidal). They have an odd sort of immortality: they don't age and live more or less forever, but over time become stiffer, sleepier and more "treeish", rooting themselves and not stirring for increasingly long periods, eventually becoming indistinguishable from normal trees. They still live extremely long before this happens, giving them a very patient and long-term view on things: they consider reaching a decision after three days of continuous debate almost unseemly hasty.
** In a mild case Like most of UnbuiltTrope, they Tolkien's races, the Ents are something of an UnbuiltTrope and have a number of characteristics later imitations lack, such as a highly variable numbers of fingers and toes and a form of gender dimorphism: male Ents live in deep forests and guard nature like later examples, but the women, the Entwives, favor agriculture and farmlands and resemble various crops and domestic trees, and were the ones who taught agriculture to early Men.




to:

----





to:

\n----



* DeusExMachina: Frequently in ''Literature/TheHobbit'' and ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings''.
* GiantFlyer: Big enough to carry multiple human beings.

to:

* DeusExMachina: Frequently They frequently appear in ''Literature/TheHobbit'' and ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings''.
''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' to dramatically pull people's chestnuts out of the fire at the last possible minute.
* GiantFlyer: Big They're big enough to carry multiple human beings.










to:

----



The sole surviving Númenórean Realm in Exile following the fall of Arnor and Arthedain and the corruption of Umbar. An exceedingly ancient civilization of learning and tradition, now a VestigialEmpire fighting continuously to survive. For all of its history Gondor has fought territorial wars against the Southrons of Harad and the Easterlings of Rhûn, and now contends with the threat of Mordor rebuilt. Hundreds of years ago the last king of Gondor was killed by the Lord of the Nazgûl, leaving no heir, and the nation is ruled by the line of the Ruling Stewards -- currently Denethor -- until the day a rightful heir -- i.e., Aragorn -- returns. See ''Characters/TheSilmarillion'' character sheet for its founding rulers, Elendil and his son Isildur.

to:

The sole surviving Númenórean Realm in Exile following the fall of Arnor and Arthedain and Cardolan and the corruption of Umbar.Umbar and Rhudaur. An exceedingly ancient civilization of learning and tradition, now a VestigialEmpire fighting continuously to survive. For all of its history Gondor has fought territorial wars against the Southrons of Harad and the Easterlings of Rhûn, and now contends with the threat of Mordor rebuilt. Hundreds of years ago the last king of Gondor was killed by the Lord of the Nazgûl, leaving no heir, and the nation is ruled by the line of the Ruling Stewards -- currently Denethor -- until the day a rightful heir -- i.e., Aragorn -- returns. See ''Characters/TheSilmarillion'' character sheet for its founding rulers, Elendil and his son Isildur.
----




to:

----



* FantasyCounterpartCulture: If Gondor is the Byzantine Empire, then by extension Arnor is the Western Roman Empire in the period between the sacking of Rome by the Goths and the crowning of Charlemagne as the Holy Roman Emperor. The parallels are actually quite striking once you look for them: Arnor/Gondor and Rome/Constantinople both trace their lineage to a mythical homeland from which they were displaced due to a great and self-inflicted tragedy (Numenor and Ar-Pharazon's rebellion against the Valar/Troy and Paris' abduction of Helen), Arnor/Rome's fall coming after a lengthy period of decline caused by a combination of bad luck and poor decisions by their rulers, and the eventual "resurrection" of the land by a great leader (Aragorn/Charlemagne).
** The biggest differences are that Rome was the historical (as opposed to mythical) origin of the unified state, whereas Gondor doesn't trace its historical origins from Arnor, and that the Holy Roman Empire under Charlemagne and his various successors was very different to the former Western Roman Empire - for starters, Charlemagne had no blood connection to the Western Empire. And complicating things, like Arnor, Charlemagne's Empire fractured into three after the death of his son Louis, whose three sons claimed various pieces of the Empire). In general though, Tolkien was fairly explicit about the Roman parallels with the two Numenorean successor kingdoms.

to:

* FantasyCounterpartCulture: If Gondor is the Byzantine Empire, then by extension Arnor is the Western Roman Empire in the period between the sacking of Rome by the Goths and the crowning of Charlemagne as the Holy Roman Emperor. Emperor.
**
The parallels are actually quite striking once you look for them: Arnor/Gondor and Rome/Constantinople both trace their lineage to a mythical homeland from which they were displaced due to a great and self-inflicted tragedy (Numenor and Ar-Pharazon's rebellion against the Valar/Troy and Paris' abduction of Helen), Arnor/Rome's fall coming after a lengthy period of decline caused by a combination of bad luck and poor decisions by their rulers, and the eventual "resurrection" of the land by a great leader (Aragorn/Charlemagne).
** The biggest differences are that Rome was the historical (as opposed to mythical) origin of the unified state, whereas Gondor doesn't trace its historical origins from Arnor, and that the Holy Roman Empire under Charlemagne and his various successors was very different to the former Western Roman Empire - -- for starters, Charlemagne had no blood connection to the Western Empire. And complicating things, like Arnor, Charlemagne's Empire fractured into three after the death of his son Louis, whose three sons claimed various pieces of the Empire). In general though, Tolkien was fairly explicit about the Roman parallels with the two Numenorean successor kingdoms.




to:

----







to:

----



* EliteMooks: The Uruk-hai ("Orc-people" in Black Speech, the language of Mordor), a stronger and tougher type of orc. It appears there were two distinct kinds called "Uruk", both superior to the average orc - the Black Uruks of Mordor and the Fighting Uruk-hai of Isengard - though the latter group uses the full name much more often despite appropriating it. The Uruks of Mordor were broader and were more ape-like, while Saruman's Uruks were brand-new, taller and more humanoid - and could function in sunlight. At least one Uruk of Mordor was a captain among the Moria orcs, who struck Frodo and was killed by Aragorn.

to:

* EliteMooks: The Uruk-hai ("Orc-people" in Black Speech, the language of Mordor), a stronger and tougher type of orc. It appears that there were are two distinct kinds called "Uruk", both superior to the average orc - -- the Black Uruks of Mordor and the Fighting Uruk-hai of Isengard - though -- although the latter group uses the full name much more often despite appropriating it. The Uruks of Mordor were are broader and were more ape-like, while Saruman's Uruks were are brand-new, taller and more humanoid - -- and could can function in sunlight. At least one Uruk of Mordor was a captain among the Moria orcs, who struck Frodo and was killed by Aragorn.orcs.



* EvenEvilHasStandards: They regard accusations of cannibalism (that is, eating other Orcs -- eating other races is fine) as a grave insult. (Though whether or not they do it anyway is an open question...)
** They regard leaving their wounded comrades behind as disgraceful: "A regular Elvish trick". On the other hand, when they find an old comrade trussed up to be eaten alive by Shelob at her leisure, they leave him to his fate... after having a good laugh at the expression on his face.
* EverybodyCallsHimBarkeep: In ''The Return of the King'', an orc called Snaga is bullied by bigger, stronger orcs. In the Appendices it's revealed that ''snaga'' is the Black Speech/Orc-language word for "slave" and the Uruks of Mordor called lesser common orcs that.
* EvilIsBigger: ''Inverted'', atypical for fantasy. On average, orcs are much shorter than men let alone elves, closer in size to dwarves and hobbits; a "huge orc chieftain" is described as Frodo as "nearly man-high." Their posture is also said to be crooked, with bent backs, making them look shorter than they already are. Only the Uruk-hai of Saruman were as tall as men, being part-human hybrids. However, the shorter breeds of orcs were also often described as very broad, so these may have been "bigger" than men in that way.

to:

* EvenEvilHasStandards: They regard accusations of cannibalism (that is, eating other Orcs -- eating other races is fine) as a grave insult. (Though whether or not they do it anyway is an open question...)
**
) They also regard leaving their wounded comrades behind as disgraceful: "A disgraceful -- "a regular Elvish trick".trick", as they put it. On the other hand, when they find an old comrade trussed up to be eaten alive by Shelob at her leisure, they leave him to his fate... after having a good laugh at the expression on his face.
* EverybodyCallsHimBarkeep: In ''The Return of the King'', an orc called Snaga is bullied by bigger, stronger orcs. In the Appendices it's revealed that ''snaga'' is the Black Speech/Orc-language word for "slave" "slave", and that the Uruks of Mordor called call lesser common orcs that.
* EvilIsBigger: ''Inverted'', atypical atypically for fantasy. On average, orcs are much shorter than men let alone elves, men, being closer in size to dwarves and hobbits; a "huge orc chieftain" is described as Frodo as "nearly man-high." man-high". Their posture is also said to be crooked, with bent backs, making them look shorter than they already are. Only the Uruk-hai of Saruman were as tall as men, being part-human hybrids. However, the shorter breeds of orcs were also often described as very broad, so these may have been "bigger" than men in that way.



* OurOrcsAreDifferent: To a degree they ''are'', despite being the TropeNamer. Tolkien's actual orcs are much more advanced and intelligent, and not as physically powerful, than the crude barbarians AlwaysChaoticEvil orcs are generally portrayed as. And there are umpteen breeds of orcs, both because Morgoth and Sauron bred them for different uses and because they absolutely refuse to mate outside their own tribe.
** There are many variations within the Orcoid race, making each variant different from the rest - Moria or Misty Mountain Orcs are more goblin-like, while the Mordor Uruk-hai and Orcs are ape-like and muscular. In general, regular Orcs around are small, impish and sneaky, preferring ambushes and other cunning tricks, while Uruk-hai are human-sized and muscular and emphazise brute force.

to:

* OurOrcsAreDifferent: To a degree they ''are'', despite being the TropeNamer. Tolkien's actual orcs are much more advanced and intelligent, and not as physically powerful, than the crude barbarians AlwaysChaoticEvil orcs are generally portrayed as. And They're a very diverse lot, and numerous varieties were around during the War of the Ring, largely as a result of the various dark lords breeding them like livestock to suit their needs.
** Firstly,
there are umpteen breeds the [[OurGoblinsAreDifferent goblins]] of orcs, both because Morgoth the Misty Mountains, also referred to as northern Orcs or "Northerners". They're generally assumed to have descended from the survivors of Morgoth's First Age armies, who fled beneath the Misty Mountains following their lord's defeat. They're usually described as smaller than other kinds, possibly from having lived underground and on their own for so long, possibly from their ancestors not being as "refined" for war as later breeds.
** The Orcs of Mordor, also called Black Uruks or just Uruks,[[note]] Uruk just means "Orc" in the Black Speech[[/note]] were the "main" breed of Orcs during the War of the Ring, large and strong and ferocious.
Sauron bred them for different uses during the late Third Age from the remnants of Morgoth's armies, in order to obtain a superior fighting force.
** Saruman's Uruk-hai of Isengard are more-or-less explicitly created from crossbreeding Orcs
and because they absolutely refuse to mate outside their own tribe.
Men and created by Saruman as elite soldiers. They were larger than other Orc types, and more upright and humanoid -- the other Orcs were usually described as hunched over and ape-like. They did not fear the sun (most of Sauron's and Morgoth's creatures could not stand sunlight and did not travel by day) and were usually described as being better-organized and more dangerous foes than "common" Orcs.
** There are many variations within the Orcoid race, making each variant different from the rest - Moria or Misty Mountain also several lesser Orcs are more goblin-like, while the in Mordor Uruk-hai and Orcs Isengard, usually referred to as "Snaga" (meaning "slave" in the Black Speech). These appear to be used for labor and garrison duty, and are ape-like and muscular. In general, regular Orcs around are sent out to war when soldiers when numbers where needed. They tend to be described as small, impish and sneaky, preferring ambushes and other cunning tricks, while the bigger, stronger Uruks and Uruk-hai are human-sized and muscular and emphazise emphasize brute force.force and military discipline.
** Finally, a specialized breed of small Orcs known as "snufflers" appear to be meant to act as trackers, possessing a highly developed nose and sense of smell. Only one snuffler is seen in the books, in the service of Mordor.




* AllTrollsAreDifferent: Tolkien's trolls are giant-like monsters and beast-like intelligence.[[note]]Though, since Aragorn recognises their old cave as a typical troll-cave (which had a hinged door), trolls smart enough to build simple shelters are implicitly at least relatively common.[[/note]] (The talking trolls in ''The Hobbit'' may or may not have been artistic license on Bilbo's part.) They permanently turn to stone when exposed to sunlight. The exceptions are Sauron's Olog-hai, more intelligent trolls that are resistant to the effects of sunlight.

to:

\n----
* AllTrollsAreDifferent: Tolkien's trolls are giant-like monsters and beast-like intelligence.[[note]]Though, However, since Aragorn recognises their old cave -- which had a hinged door -- as a typical troll-cave (which had a hinged door), troll-cave, trolls smart enough to build simple shelters are implicitly at least relatively common.[[/note]] common. (The talking trolls in ''The Hobbit'' may or may not have been artistic license on Bilbo's part.) They permanently turn to stone when exposed to sunlight. The exceptions are Sauron's Olog-hai, more intelligent trolls that are resistant to the effects of sunlight. A number of troll variants and breeds are mentioned at various points, including snow-trolls, cave-trolls, hill-trolls, mountain-trolls and stone-trolls, but what distinguishes these from one another is never explained in detail.



* "Troll-men" or "black men like half-trolls," black-skinned people from Far Harad. (Whether they're just ordinary Men with black skin that the westerners are unfamiliar enough with to find strange or actual men altered with magic to resemble trolls is unclear and varies with the source. In the original text, whether the two are even supposed to refer to the same race is unknown.)

to:

* "Troll-men" or "black men like half-trolls," half-trolls", black-skinned people from Far Harad. (Whether Whether they're just ordinary Men with black skin that the westerners are unfamiliar enough with to find strange or actual men altered with magic to resemble trolls is unclear and varies with the source. In the original text, whether the two are even supposed to refer to the same race is unknown.)
unknown.




* BarbarianTribe: The Dunlendings.

to:

\n* ----
%%*
BarbarianTribe: The Dunlendings.



* HeelFaceTurn: After the War of the Ring, they're implied to mostly live in peace with Gondor and Rohan. (Though in the Appendices both Aragorn and Éomer waged war in the East and South in the early Fourth Age because of Sauron's still potent legacy of hatred, but even here the wars are noted to be not clashes between good and evil but simple disputes between ordinary men.)

to:

* HeelFaceTurn: After the War of the Ring, they're implied to mostly live in peace with Gondor and Rohan. (Though However, in the Appendices Appendices, both Aragorn and Éomer waged war in the East and South in the early Fourth Age because of Sauron's still potent legacy of hatred, but even here the wars are noted to be not clashes between good and evil but simple disputes between ordinary men.)



* HordesFromTheEast: The Easterlings and Variags.

to:

* HordesFromTheEast: The Easterlings and Variags.Variags often came as large armies of conquerors from the unmapped lands east of Mordor and Rhun.



* {{Pirate}}: The Corsairs of Umbar.

to:

* {{Pirate}}: The Corsairs of Umbar.Umbar, cruel raiders who rule the seas south of Gondor.






Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Created by Morgoth in mockery of the Ents, Trolls are hulking, brutish giants with rocky skin who turn to stone when exposed to the light of the sun. Most Trolls are barely more intelligent than wild beasts and live in small groups in the hills, mountains, and caves of Middle-Earth. Shortly before the War of the Ring, Sauron bred the Olog-hai, a more intelligent breed of Trolls that were extremely resistant (or even immune) to the debilitating effects of sunlight and may have been totally unrelated to the Stone-Trolls.

* AllTrollsAreDifferent: Tolkien's trolls are giant-like monsters with rocky hides and beast-like intelligence.[[note]]Though, since Aragorn recognises their old cave as a typical troll-cave (which had a hinged door), trolls smart enough to build simple shelters are implicitly at least relatively common.[[/note]] (The talking trolls in ''The Hobbit'' may or may not have been artistic license on Bilbo's part.) They permanently turn to stone when exposed to sunlight. The exceptions are Sauron's Olog-hai, more intelligent trolls that are resistant to the effects of sunlight.

to:

Created by Morgoth in mockery of the Ents, Trolls are hulking, brutish giants with rocky skin scaly, horny hides who turn to stone when exposed to the light of the sun. Most Trolls are barely more intelligent than wild beasts and live in small groups in the hills, mountains, and caves of Middle-Earth. Shortly before the War of the Ring, Sauron bred the Olog-hai, a more intelligent breed of Trolls that were extremely resistant (or even immune) to the debilitating effects of sunlight and may have been totally unrelated to the Stone-Trolls.

* AllTrollsAreDifferent: Tolkien's trolls are giant-like monsters with rocky hides and beast-like intelligence.[[note]]Though, since Aragorn recognises their old cave as a typical troll-cave (which had a hinged door), trolls smart enough to build simple shelters are implicitly at least relatively common.[[/note]] (The talking trolls in ''The Hobbit'' may or may not have been artistic license on Bilbo's part.) They permanently turn to stone when exposed to sunlight. The exceptions are Sauron's Olog-hai, more intelligent trolls that are resistant to the effects of sunlight.



* DumbMuscle: Aforementioned trolls were also stupid enough to be easily tricked by a wizard mimicking their voices until the sun came up and they literally argued themselves to death.

to:

* DumbMuscle: Aforementioned trolls were also stupid enough to be easily tricked by a wizard mimicking their voices until the sun came up and they literally argued themselves to death. Much later, cave-trolls appear in Moria as brute force, trying to pry a barred door open or carrying huge slabs of stone so the orcs could bypass the great bridge. Later, it's mountain-trolls who operate the giant battering ram Grond.



* MadeOfIron: They die hard.

to:

* MadeOfIron: They die hard. A cave troll in Moria took a blow from Boromir's sword without effect, though Frodo's elven knife Sting pierced its foot and made it retreat.



* TakenForGranite: Sunlight permanently turns them into stone, although the Olog-hai, a variant bred by Sauron, are immune to this.

to:

* TakenForGranite: Sunlight permanently turns them at least the Stone-Trolls into stone, although the Olog-hai, a variant bred by Sauron, are immune to this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EliteMook: The Attack Trolls, followed by the Olog-hai.

to:

* EliteMook: The Attack Trolls, followed by Olog-hai are a new, stronger type of troll not seen before the Olog-hai.Battle of the Black Gate.

Top