Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekStrangeNewWorldsS2E1TheBrokenCircle

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Pelia:''' You want to know the worst thing about living almost forever?\\
'''Spock:''' The loss of those you love.\\
'''Pelia:''' Oh, you sweet un-Vulcan Vulcan. No. That's a pain shared by all those who live with even a half-open heart. No. It's boredom. And on that ship of yours, there seems to be a shortage of that. I like it. Hm. I might even try and stick around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Later, Admiral April is very upset that Spock broke direct orders, despite saving the peace. However, he realizes Spock is nursing a wicked hangover and lets that be his punishment and next time - and there better not be - it's his commission. Spock visits Chapel in sickbay, confused by his emotions despite M'Benga reassuring him. In Starbase One, Commodore Tafune tells April that he treated Spock lightly. He agrees, but points out Spock prevented a potential war on two fronts and they need good men like him as a war with the Gorn Hegemony is very likely...

to:

Later, Admiral April is very upset that Spock broke direct orders, despite saving the peace. However, he realizes Spock is nursing a wicked hangover and lets that be his punishment and next time - and there better not be - it's his commission. Spock visits Chapel in sickbay, confused by his emotions despite M'Benga reassuring him. In Starbase One, Commodore Tafune tells April that he treated Spock lightly. He agrees, but points out Spock prevented a potential war on two fronts and they need good men like him as a war with the his viewscreen alerts him to an incoming Gorn Hegemony is very likely...
attack ship...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CatchPhrase: The bridge crew needle Spock about a "go to warp" phrase. His initial offering is ... less than impressive.

to:

* CatchPhrase: CharacterCatchphrase: The bridge crew needle Spock about a "go to warp" phrase. His initial offering is ... less than impressive.



* FalseFlagOperation: The Broken Circle have managed to gather enough Federation tech to build their own Federation ship -- a ''[[Series/StarTrekDiscovery Crossfield]]''-class-like starship, to be precise -- from the ground up, which they plan to use to attack the Klingons to reignite the war.

to:

* FalseFlagOperation: The Broken Circle have managed to gather enough Federation tech to build their own Federation ship -- a an ersatz ''[[Series/StarTrekDiscovery Crossfield]]''-class-like Crossfield]]''-class starship, to be precise -- from the ground up, which they plan to use to attack the Klingons to reignite the war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HangoverSensitivity: After drinking too much bloodwine, Spock is visibly hung over, asking April to dress him down more quietly.

to:

* HangoverSensitivity: After drinking too much bloodwine, Spock is visibly hung over, asking April to dress him down more quietly. Admiral April picks up on this, and admonishes Spock that the hangover is his penance for his disobedient antics... ''this time''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoWrongRight: Commander Pelia's only criticism of the attempt to steal the ''Enterprise'' is that it's too transparent, so she tells them how to make it look more convincing so that Spacedock will release them for the safety of everyone else.

to:

* DoWrongRight: Commander Pelia's only criticism of the attempt to steal the ''Enterprise'' is that it's too transparent, so she tells the conspirators to simply vent the warp nacelles' plasma charge to more quickly prompt Starbase 1 to tell them how to make it look more convincing so that Spacedock will release them for evacuate the safety of everyone else.dockyard. By the time Starbase 1 command would start asking questions, the ''Enterprise'' would already be escaping at warp.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TastesLikeFriendship: To prove his good intentions with the Klingon commander skeptical of his claims, Spock joins him for blood wine on the planet. It works but he is suffering one hell of a handover later on.

to:

* TastesLikeFriendship: To prove his good intentions with the Klingon commander skeptical of his claims, Spock joins him for blood wine on the planet. It works but he is suffering one hell of a handover hangover later on.

Added: 957

Removed: 176

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Spock invites the Klingon Commander to a round of blood wine to ease tensions. This was a similar, if slightly less successful, tactic used in ''Film/StarTrekVITheUndiscoveredCountry'' with Romulan Ale.



* OffTheShelfFX: InUniverse, the Broken Circle appeared to have found a derelict Starfleet ship and rebuilt it with other parts just enough to fly and armed with photon torpedoes as part of a FalseFlagOperation. Basically a large-scale Kit Bash. It can put on a good show with weapons fire but was otherwise quite fragile since it needed to serve a single purpose.
* OutOfFocus: Despite ostensibly being the lead actor of the show, Pike (Anson Mount) barely appears. Same with Number One (Creator/RebeccaRomijn) and her "AndStarring" credit.



* OutOfFocus: Despite ostensibly being the lead actor of the show, Pike (Anson Mount) barely appears. Same with Number One (Creator/RebeccaRomijn) and her "AndStarring" credit.


Added DiffLines:

* TastesLikeFriendship: To prove his good intentions with the Klingon commander skeptical of his claims, Spock joins him for blood wine on the planet. It works but he is suffering one hell of a handover later on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtEvolution: Klingon make-up is modified once more, leaning towards the design of the Next Generation era with less alterations on the face but with a more bulbous and bizarre forehead and hair designs that feel like a blend of ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery'' and ''Film/StarTrekIntoDarkness''.


Added DiffLines:

* CostumeEvolution: Klingon armor resembles metal and leather outfits from the Next Generation era but with a more bronze tint and fabric baldrics that they had in the Original Series. The more gothic and medieval designs from ''Discovery'' are largely gone with only the metallic color being any indication of continuity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Add example

Added DiffLines:

* TortureAlwaysWorks: On a ''Klingon'', no less.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TruceTrickery: A group of [[FromCamouflageToCriminal renegade ex-Klingon and -Federation soldiers]] fly a salvaged Federation starship in a {{false flag|Operation}} attack on a Klingon D7 battlecruiser. This is supposed to look like a breach of the ceasefire between the Federation and the Klingon Empire, meant to restart the war and [[WarForFunAndProfit increase profits from the dilithium mine the renegades are guarding]]. The ''Enterprise'' destroys the ship before it can do any damage and Spock is able to convince the Klingon captain that [[NotMeThisTime the Federation wasn't involved]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
rm spoilers


* FrankenVehicle: {{Implied}}. The ship used in the [[spoiler:FalseFlagOperation against the Klingon battlecruiser]] is identified based on its transponder as a ''Crossfield''-class starship (e.g. USS ''Discovery'') and has a ''Crossfield''-style dual-ring saucer section, but also a ventrally mounted bridge like a ''Walker''-class (USS ''Shenzhou'') and a twin-boom after section and nacelles resembling an inverted [[Series/StarTrekEnterprise NX-class]], suggesting that the conspirators built it from several different salvaged wrecks. An {{enforced}} example, as the ship originally ''was'' going to be an NX-class, but budget constraints forced the reuse of sets from ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery''.

to:

* FrankenVehicle: {{Implied}}. The ship used in the [[spoiler:FalseFlagOperation FalseFlagOperation against the Klingon battlecruiser]] battlecruiser is identified based on its transponder as a ''Crossfield''-class starship (e.g. USS ''Discovery'') and has a ''Crossfield''-style dual-ring saucer section, but also a ventrally mounted bridge like a ''Walker''-class (USS ''Shenzhou'') and a twin-boom after section and nacelles resembling an inverted [[Series/StarTrekEnterprise NX-class]], suggesting that the conspirators built it from several different salvaged wrecks. An {{enforced}} example, as the ship originally ''was'' going to be an NX-class, but budget constraints forced the reuse of sets from ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FrankenVehicle: {{Implied}}. The ship used in the [[spoiler:FalseFlagOperation against the Klingon battlecruiser]] is identified based on its transponder as a ''Crossfield''-class starship (e.g. USS ''Discovery'') and has a ''Crossfield''-style dual-ring saucer section, but also a ventrally mounted bridge like a ''Walker''-class (USS ''Shenzhou'') and a twin-boom after section and nacelles resembling an inverted [[Series/StarTrekEnterprise NX-class]], suggesting that the conspirators built it from several different salvaged wrecks. An {{enforced}} example, as the ship originally ''was'' going to be an NX-class, but budget constraints forced the reuse of sets from ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FromCamouflageToCriminal: The plot revolves around a dilithium mine shared between the Federation and the Klingon Empire, guarded by ex-Federation and -Klingon soldiers that have effectively become an organized crime gang, whose share of the profits has been significantly reduced by the reduction in tensions three years on from the war's end. They attempt to launch a {{false flag|Operation}} attack on a Klingon battlecruiser with a salvaged Starfleet ship in hopes of restarting the war. The ''Enterprise'' foils the attack and is able to convince the Klingons that the Federation wasn't involved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** An interesting variant as, discounting Worf in ''Series/StarTrekPicard'' season 3, this is the first time we see the Klingons in live action since the end of ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery'' season 2, though they resemble the Klingons seen since ''Film/StarTrekTheMotionPicture'' and not the more alien-esque ones from ''Discovery'' and not yet the flat-browed ones from ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries''.
** The Broken Circle's self-built Starfleet vessel is mentioned to be a ''Crossfield''-class like ''[[Series/StarTrekDiscovery Discovery]]'', but though it has the same type of double-ringed saucer section, it looks more like the ''Miranda'' class than ''Discovery'' or her ill-fated sister ship the ''Glenn'', as it lacks a noticeable secondary hull. This can be handwaved by the fact that it's a mongrel assembled from pieces of other ships scavenged by the Broken Circle; the transponder may simply have come from a ''Crossfield''-class rather than the ship itself actually being one.

to:

** An interesting variant as, discounting Worf in ''Series/StarTrekPicard'' season 3, this is the first time we see the Klingons in live action since the end of ''Series/StarTrekDiscovery'' season 2, though they resemble the Klingons seen since ''Film/StarTrekTheMotionPicture'' and not the more alien-esque ones from ''Discovery'' and not yet or the flat-browed ones from ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries''.
** The Broken Circle's self-built Starfleet vessel vessel, identified on scanners as [[https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/NCC-1279 NCC-1279]], is mentioned to be identified as a ''Crossfield''-class like ''[[Series/StarTrekDiscovery Discovery]]'', but though it has the same type of double-ringed saucer section, it looks much more like the ''Miranda'' class ''Walker''-class USS ''Shenzhou'' than like ''Discovery'' or her ill-fated sister ship the ''Glenn'', as ''Glenn'': it lacks a noticeable the ''Crossfield''[='s=] chevron-shaped secondary hull. This can be handwaved by hull, instead appearing to have an inverted version of the fact that it's twin-boom aft end from the [[Series/StarTrekEnterprise NX-class]], and appears to have the bridge mounted on the underside of the saucer. It's implied to be a mongrel Franken-ship assembled from pieces of other ships scavenged by the Broken Circle; salvaged wrecks: the transponder and saucer may simply have come from a ''Crossfield''-class rather than the ship itself actually being built as one.

Added: 490

Changed: 272

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: When doing CPR to revive Chapel, Spock inevitably ends up hurting her and it's implied that he broke or at least cracked some of her ribs; this can easily happen in real life with a normal human performing the technique, let alone if someone with enhanced strength did so.

to:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome:
** The Enterprise crew simulates a fake coolant leak in their attempt to steal the ship, but Pelia figures out what's going on right away. If she hadn't decided to join them, the plan would have been a dismal failure.
**
When doing CPR to revive Chapel, Spock inevitably ends up hurting her and it's implied that he broke or at least cracked some of her ribs; this can easily happen usually happens in real life with a normal human performing the technique, let alone if someone with enhanced strength did so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HangoverSensitivity: After drinking too much bloodwine, Spock is visibly hung over, asking April to dress him down more quietly.


Added DiffLines:

* HiddenDepths: A Vulcan who's willing to indulge in bloodwine? The Klingon captain lampshades it in a toast.
-->"To the Vulcan who acts nothing like a Vulcan!"


Added DiffLines:

* InVinoVeritas: The captain of the D-7 isn't willing to trust Spock until they share some bloodwine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: When doing CPR to revive Chapel, Spock inevitably ends up hurting her and it's implied that he broke or at least cracked some of her ribs; this can easily happen in real life with a normal human performing the technique, let alone if someone with enhanced strength did so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Leitmotif}}: When the mystery ship on April's viewscreen is identified as a Gorn attack ship, their theme from last season plays.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OutOfFocus: Despite ostensibly being the lead actor of the show, Pike (Anson Mount) barely appears. Same with Number One (Creator/RebeccaRomijn) and her "AndStarring" credit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CPRCleanPrettyReliable: Spock is forced to do this to revive Chapel when she and M'Benga return from being ThrownOutTheAirlock. In a subversion, Spock doesn't do mouth-to-mouth, when she comes to, she complains about how strong he was and she's put into Sickbay soon after with wraps around her chest implying that he damaged her ribs in the process.

to:

* CPRCleanPrettyReliable: Spock is forced to do this to revive Chapel when she and M'Benga return from being ThrownOutTheAirlock. In a subversion, Spock doesn't do mouth-to-mouth, and when she comes to, she complains about how strong he was and she's put into Sickbay soon after with wraps around her chest chest, implying that he damaged her ribs in the process.



* ReallySevenHundredYearsOld: Pelia is a Lanthanite, a species of long-lived HumanAliens who apparently lived on Earth among humans until the 22nd century.

to:

* ReallySevenHundredYearsOld: Pelia is a Lanthanite, a species of long-lived HumanAliens who apparently lived on Earth among humans incognito until the 22nd century.



* SuperSerum: M'Benga carries vials of something that lets him and Chapel fight an entire shipworth of Klingons, unarmed.

to:

* SuperSerum: M'Benga carries vials of something that lets him and Chapel fight an entire shipworth ship's worth of Klingons, unarmed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As the doctors try to figure out how to escape, La’an still can’t find them… until the ship busts out of the ground and rockets towards space. At the same time, a Klingon D-7 arrives over the planet as the ''Enterprise'' hides in the planet’s ice crystal rings. Then, they detect the new ship. Navigator Mitchell tentatively notes it’s a ''Crossfield''-class… as well as a coded message: "''Enterprise'', destroy this ship". As the ''Enterprise'' chases the other ship, the doctors finds pieces of EV suits and plan to launch out with hopes their friends can pick them up. As they are ThrownOutTheAirlock, Spock reluctantly orders the ship destroyed. Fearing his friends dead at his hands, he’s relieved they are found and orders them beamed up.

to:

As the doctors try to figure out how to escape, La’an still can’t find them… until the ship busts out of the ground and rockets towards space. At the same time, a Klingon D-7 arrives over the planet as the ''Enterprise'' hides in the planet’s ice crystal rings. Then, they detect the new ship. Navigator Mitchell tentatively notes it’s a ''Crossfield''-class… as well as a coded message: "''Enterprise'', destroy this ship". As the ''Enterprise'' chases the other ship, the doctors finds find pieces of EV suits and plan to launch out with in hopes their friends can pick them up. As they are ThrownOutTheAirlock, Spock reluctantly orders the ship destroyed. Fearing his friends dead at his hands, he’s relieved they are found and orders them beamed up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeadlyDoctor: Dr. M'Benga apparently always carries around a serum that allows him to boost his and Chapel's strength, stamina, and speed so far as to allow them to beat the stuffing out of ''numerous'' Klingons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhoWantsToLiveForever: Commander Pelia lampshades this when she points out that while anyone who lives long enough and has normal human empathy will experience grief when people they love die, her immortality makes it easy for her to get "bored", and this is the real worst part of being effectively immortal.

to:

* WhoWantsToLiveForever: Commander Pelia lampshades this when she points out that while anyone who lives long enough and has normal human empathy will experience grief when people they love die, her immortality makes it easy for her to get "bored", ''bored'', and this is the real worst part of being effectively immortal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


The episode ends with a dedication to the late Creator/NichelleNichols.

Top