Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekStrangeNewWorldsS1E06LiftUsWhereSufferingCannotReach

Go To

OR

Added: 195

Changed: 113

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheChosenOne: Harshly {{Deconstructed|Trope}} and PlayedForHorror, as the First Servant is chosen to be jacked into the system that powers Majalis, draining the poor kid into a desiccated husk.



* CurbStompBattle: The dissident ship is completely disabled by a glancing blow from a single phaser shot at minimum power, and Uhura wasn't even trying to hit them.

to:

* CurbStompBattle: The dissident ship is may as well be firing spitballs at ''Enterprise'', for all the damage they do (or, rather, ''don't'' do). It's then completely disabled by a glancing blow from a single phaser shot at minimum power, and Uhura wasn't even trying to hit them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* FriendsWithBenefits: Implied between Pike and Marie Batel, given that he cheerfully jumps into bed with Alora.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Judging by the First Servant's quiet "Oh my God" when he sees the corpse of his predecessor being carried out of the chamber, it's {{implied}} that nobody told him what the ascension ceremony really entails.

to:

* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Judging by the First Servant's quiet "Oh my God" when he sees the corpse of his predecessor being carried out of the chamber, it's {{implied}} implied that nobody told him what the ascension ceremony really entails.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Judging by the First Servant's quiet "Oh my God" when he sees the corpse of his predecessor being carried out of the chamber, it's {{implied}} that nobody told him what the ascension cermony really entails.

to:

* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Judging by the First Servant's quiet "Oh my God" when he sees the corpse of his predecessor being carried out of the chamber, it's {{implied}} that nobody told him what the ascension cermony ceremony really entails.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WholePlotReference: The story sticks quite closely to Ursula K. Le Guin's "Literature/TheOnesWhoWalkAwayFromOmelas", in [[PoweredByAForsakenChild concept]] if not [[SillyRabbitCynicismIsForLosers theme]]. Omelas is a thought experiment about a utopia whose paradise hinges on the endless suffering of a small child, with the ones that walk away being those who rejected the idea that a better world had to be built on the suffering of others. The Majalans feed children into their technology for their continued prosperity, and Prospect VII is an entire colony that refused to live by it.

to:

* WholePlotReference: The story sticks quite closely to Ursula K. Le Guin's "Literature/TheOnesWhoWalkAwayFromOmelas", ''Literature/TheOnesWhoWalkAwayFromOmelas'', in [[PoweredByAForsakenChild concept]] if not [[SillyRabbitCynicismIsForLosers theme]]. Omelas is a thought experiment about a utopia whose paradise hinges on the endless suffering of a small child, with the ones that walk away being those who rejected the idea that a better world had to be built on the suffering of others. The Majalans feed children into their technology for their continued prosperity, and Prospect VII is an entire colony that refused to live by it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeathWorld: Majalis itself is uninhabitable, a mostly molten rock that could never support life. The Majalan settlement hovers above the clouds, where the air is breathable. Prospero is a downplayed example; it's a marginally habitable Class-L planet with a difficult climate and chemical makeup.
* DefectorFromDecadence: The Prospect colonists aren't from a different alien species, and aren't attacking the First Servant's retinue to hold him for ransom or for any other venal reason: they're Majalans who can't stomach a luxurious lifestyle that's PoweredByAForsakenChild, and they're trying to rescue him.

to:

* DeathWorld: Majalis itself is uninhabitable, a mostly molten rock that could never support life. The Majalan settlement hovers above the clouds, where the air is breathable. Prospero Prospect VII is a downplayed example; it's a marginally habitable Class-L planet with a difficult climate and chemical makeup.
* DefectorFromDecadence: The Prospect VII colonists aren't from a different alien species, and aren't attacking the First Servant's retinue to hold him for ransom or for any other venal reason: they're Majalans who can't stomach a luxurious lifestyle that's PoweredByAForsakenChild, and they're trying to rescue him.



* FatalFlaw: Unfortunately, even the Prospect colonists, despite leaving their culture for principled reasons, haven't shaken off the Majalan distrust and distaste for outsiders. In multiple ship engagements with the ''Enterprise'', they repeatedly refuse hails and will not explain themselves, which results in their deaths and the foiling of their mission to save the First Servant.

to:

* FatalFlaw: Unfortunately, even the Prospect VII colonists, despite leaving their culture for principled reasons, haven't shaken off the Majalan distrust and distaste for outsiders. In multiple ship engagements with the ''Enterprise'', they repeatedly refuse hails and will not explain themselves, which results in their deaths and the foiling of their mission to save the First Servant.



* WholePlotReference: The story sticks quite closely to Ursula K. Le Guin's "Literature/TheOnesWhoWalkAwayFromOmelas", in [[PoweredByAForsakenChild concept]] if not [[SillyRabbitCynicismIsForLosers theme]]. Omelas is a thought experiment about a utopia whose paradise hinges on the endless suffering of a small child, with the ones that walk away being those who rejected the idea that a better world had to be built on the suffering of others. The Majalans feed children into their technology for their continued prosperity, and Prospect IV is an entire colony that refused to live by it.

to:

* WholePlotReference: The story sticks quite closely to Ursula K. Le Guin's "Literature/TheOnesWhoWalkAwayFromOmelas", in [[PoweredByAForsakenChild concept]] if not [[SillyRabbitCynicismIsForLosers theme]]. Omelas is a thought experiment about a utopia whose paradise hinges on the endless suffering of a small child, with the ones that walk away being those who rejected the idea that a better world had to be built on the suffering of others. The Majalans feed children into their technology for their continued prosperity, and Prospect IV VII is an entire colony that refused to live by it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WouldHurtAChild: The whole Majalan civilization is built on hurting one child, so the rest are free of suffering.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Blade On A Stick is a disambig


* BoomStick: The BladeOnAStick used as a ceremonial weapon by the PraetorianGuard can also shoot blasts of energy that can disintegrate a person.

to:

* BoomStick: The BladeOnAStick spear used as a ceremonial weapon by the PraetorianGuard can also shoot blasts of energy that can disintegrate a person.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OhCrap: The First Servant whispers "Oh my God..." when he sees the body of his predecessor being carried away. He's also terrified when he's jacked into the machine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: Pike is unable to save the First Servant from "ascending"-- i.e., being mind-jacked into the computer core that maintains the FloatingContinent that makes up Majalis. All he can do is report it to Starfleet and the Federation, but even then there's nothing that can be done since it's not a Federation member planet. However, Elder Gamal expresses hope that he and the Prospect VII colonists might be able to save the next First Servant. He also meets with Dr. M'Benga and provides the theory for a treatment for his daughter's illness, the first step towards finding a cure.

to:

* BittersweetEnding: Pike is unable to save the First Servant from "ascending"-- "ascending" -- i.e., being mind-jacked into the computer core that maintains the FloatingContinent that makes up Majalis. All he can do is report it to Starfleet and the Federation, but even then there's nothing that can be done since it's not a Federation member planet. However, Elder Gamal expresses hope that he and the Prospect VII colonists might be able to save the next First Servant. He also meets with Dr. M'Benga and provides the theory for a treatment for his daughter's illness, the first step towards finding a cure.



* CreativeSterility: In terms of pure math, science and medicine, the Majalians can make Starfleet officers feel infantile. But it seems their entire society is built on LostTechnology from some {{Precursor}}s and they had given up on trying to modify or improve upon it, tragically in the case of needing to [[WetwareCPU plug children into the system]] to keep it working. And for all their knowledge they don't appear to have any ships even close to the size and power of the Enterprise, and their day-to-day life isn't notably more advanced than anywhere in the Federation.

to:

* CreativeSterility: In terms of pure math, science and medicine, the Majalians Majalans can make Starfleet officers feel infantile. But it seems their entire society is built on LostTechnology from some {{Precursor}}s and they had have given up on trying to modify or improve upon it, tragically in the case of needing to [[WetwareCPU plug children into the system]] to keep it working. And for all their knowledge knowledge, they don't appear seemingly can't apply it to have any ships even close create anything that runs independent of their colony, as Majalan starships are pathetic compared to the size ''Enterprise'' and power they can't colonize other worlds at a similar level of the Enterprise, and their day-to-day life isn't notably more advanced than anywhere in the Federation.technology.



* KillTheCutie: The episode makes the First Servant a likable kid, whose worst quality is that he can be a bit InnocentlyInsensitive from time to time about the advanced technology of his society (and even then, he goes out of his way to be kind and friendly with Spock and Rukiya in contrast to his father and most of the other Majalans) so it's all the more devastating when it's revealed what the "sacrifice" portion of his world's motto means.

to:

* KillTheCutie: The episode makes the First Servant a likable kid, whose worst quality is that he can be a bit InnocentlyInsensitive from time to time about the advanced technology of his society (and even then, he goes out of his way to be kind and friendly with Spock and Rukiya Rukiya, in contrast to his father and most of the other Majalans) so it's all the more devastating when it's revealed what the "sacrifice" portion of his world's motto means.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CreativeSterility: In terms of pure math, science and medicine, the Majalians can make Starfleet officers feel infantile. But it seems their entire society is built on LostTechnology from some {{Precursor}}s and they had given up on trying to modify or improve upon it, tragically in the case of needing to [[WetwareCPU plug children into the system]] to keep it working. And for all their knowledge they don't appear to have any ships even close to the size and power of the Enterprise, and their day-to-day life isn't notably more advanced than anywhere in the Federation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Captain Pike returns to the Majalis system for the first time in 10 years. Almost immediately, the ''Enterprise'' is called into action: a shuttlecraft is under attack by a warship. Pike uses a warning shot to scare the attackers away-- or at least intends to; Cadet Uhura is on the Security rotation this week, which somehow lands her in Ortegas's chair, and what was ''meant'' to be OnlyAFleshWound turns out to be a OneHitKill when the enemy ship changes course unexpectedly. Whatever the case, the assailants are dealt with, and ''Enterprise'' beams aboard the occupants of the shuttlecraft: a child, a man and a woman, who takes one look at the captain and blurts out, "Lt. Pike?" Even NumberOne recognizes the UnresolvedSexualTension.

to:

Captain Pike returns to the Majalis system for the first time in 10 years. Almost immediately, the ''Enterprise'' is called into action: a shuttlecraft is under attack by a warship. Pike uses a warning shot to scare the attackers away-- away -- or at least intends to; Cadet Uhura is on the Security rotation this week, which somehow lands her in Ortegas's chair, and what was ''meant'' to be OnlyAFleshWound turns out to be a OneHitKill when the enemy ship changes course unexpectedly. Whatever the case, the assailants are dealt with, and ''Enterprise'' beams aboard the occupants of the shuttlecraft: a child, a man and a woman, who takes one look at the captain and blurts out, "Lt. Pike?" Even NumberOne recognizes the UnresolvedSexualTension.

Added: 596

Changed: 588

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: Pike is unable to save the First Servant from "ascending"-- i.e., being mind-jacked into the computer core that maintains the FloatingContinent that makes up Majalis. All he can do is report it to Starfleet and the Federation, but even then there's nothing that can be done since it's not a Federation member planet. However, Elder Gamal meets with Dr. M'Benga and provides the theory for a treatment for his daughter's illness, the first step towards finding a cure.

to:

* AtLeastIAdmitIt: Alora tries to defend her society by pointing out that every civilization, including the Federation itself, is willing to tolerate ''some'' suffering for the greater good, and that the Majalans make a point of acknowledging that suffering rather than bury it under the rug. Pike doesn't buy it.
* BittersweetEnding: Pike is unable to save the First Servant from "ascending"-- i.e., being mind-jacked into the computer core that maintains the FloatingContinent that makes up Majalis. All he can do is report it to Starfleet and the Federation, but even then there's nothing that can be done since it's not a Federation member planet. However, Elder Gamal expresses hope that he and the Prospect VII colonists might be able to save the next First Servant. He also meets with Dr. M'Benga and provides the theory for a treatment for his daughter's illness, the first step towards finding a cure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoNameGiven: The First Servant's name is never spoken.

to:

* NoNameGiven: The First Servant's name is never spoken. Given that Servants are chosen at birth, it's possible he doesn't have one.



* WholePlotReference: The story sticks quite closely to Ursula K. Le Guin's "Literature/TheOnesWhoWalkAwayFromOmelas".

to:

* WholePlotReference: The story sticks quite closely to Ursula K. Le Guin's "Literature/TheOnesWhoWalkAwayFromOmelas"."Literature/TheOnesWhoWalkAwayFromOmelas", in [[PoweredByAForsakenChild concept]] if not [[SillyRabbitCynicismIsForLosers theme]]. Omelas is a thought experiment about a utopia whose paradise hinges on the endless suffering of a small child, with the ones that walk away being those who rejected the idea that a better world had to be built on the suffering of others. The Majalans feed children into their technology for their continued prosperity, and Prospect IV is an entire colony that refused to live by it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuityNod: The warship explodes when it attempts to go to warp while held in a tractor beam. In ''Series/StarTrekLowerDecks'', the ''Solvang'' was destroyed in a similar fashion when it attempted to warp away while a grapple was attached to one of the nacelles.

to:

* ContinuityNod: The warship explodes when it attempts to go to warp while held in a tractor beam. In ''Series/StarTrekLowerDecks'', ''WesternAnimation/StarTrekLowerDecks'', the ''Solvang'' was destroyed in a similar fashion when it attempted to warp away while a grapple was attached to one of the nacelles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Judging by the First Servant's quiet "Oh my God" when he sees the corpse of his predecessor being carried out of the chamber, it's {{implied}} that nobody told him what the ascension cermony really entails.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HyperspeedEscape: Brutally averted. When another warship is able to (apparently) capture the First Servant and try to escape, the ''Enterprise'' uses a tractor beam to stop them. However, they refuse to surrender and keep fighting the tractor beam, eventually jumping to warp in a desperate attempt to escape. The warship explodes before ''Enterprise'' can disengage the tractor beam.

to:

* HyperspeedEscape: Brutally averted. When Averted, when another warship is able to (apparently) capture the First Servant and try to escape, the ''Enterprise'' uses a tractor beam to stop them. However, they refuse to surrender and keep fighting the tractor beam, eventually jumping to warp in a desperate attempt to escape. The warship explodes before ''Enterprise'' can disengage the tractor beam.

Added: 267

Changed: 127

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuityNod: The warship explodes when it attempts to go to warp while held in a tractor beam. In ''Series/StarTrekLowerDecks'', the ''Solvang'' was destroyed in a similar fashion when it attempted to warp away while a grapple was attached to one of the nacelles.



* HyperspeedEscape: Brutally averted. When another warship is able to (apparently) capture the First Servant and try to escape, the ''Enterprise'' uses a tractor beam to stop them. However, they continue to keep trying to escape and the warship jumps to warp, exploding before ''Enterprise'' can disengage the tractor beam.

to:

* HyperspeedEscape: Brutally averted. When another warship is able to (apparently) capture the First Servant and try to escape, the ''Enterprise'' uses a tractor beam to stop them. However, they continue refuse to surrender and keep trying to escape and fighting the tractor beam, eventually jumping to warp in a desperate attempt to escape. The warship jumps to warp, exploding explodes before ''Enterprise'' can disengage the tractor beam.



* WholePlotReference: The story sticks quite closely to Ursula K. Le Guin's "Literature/TheOnesWhoWalkAwayFromOmelas."

to:

* WholePlotReference: The story sticks quite closely to Ursula K. Le Guin's "Literature/TheOnesWhoWalkAwayFromOmelas.""Literature/TheOnesWhoWalkAwayFromOmelas".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The First Servant and his father, Elder Gamal, remain in Sickbay. Gamal is a doctor, though ever since his son was chosen (by lottery) he has had only one patient. He and the First Servant declare M'Benga's technology as primitive; the First Servant is equipped with quantum bio-implants, far beyond the Federation's TechnologyLevels. M'Benga asks if such technology could be used to treat TheLittlestCancerPatient -- say, an 11-year-old daughter with cytokinesia he happens to be storing in a pattern buffer -- but Elder Gamal rebuffs him, saying that Majalis does not share its technology with outsiders. Of course, he's curt with everyone, including his son.

to:

The First Servant and his father, Elder Gamal, remain in Sickbay. Gamal is a doctor, though ever since his son was chosen (by lottery) he has had only one patient. He and the First Servant declare M'Benga's technology as primitive; the First Servant is equipped with quantum bio-implants, far beyond the Federation's TechnologyLevels. M'Benga asks if such technology could be used to treat TheLittlestCancerPatient other diseases -- say, an a DelicateAndSickly 11-year-old daughter with cytokinesia cygnokemia he happens to be storing in a pattern buffer -- but Elder Gamal rebuffs him, saying that Majalis does not share its technology with outsiders. Of course, he's curt with everyone, including his son.
son, so his gruffness might not mean much.

Added: 163

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrapsaccharineWorld: Majalis (or, at least, the floating city) really does look like a beautiful paradise. Too bad about the whole PoweredByAForsakenChild thing.



* ImperialStormTrooperMarksmanshipAcademy: Uhura accidentally lands a direct phaser hit on the warship when she was just supposed to graze it. She apologizes as the warship had taken aim at the ''Enterprise'' and moved directly into the phaser beam in the moments between her confirming the target and firing.

to:

* ImperialStormTrooperMarksmanshipAcademy: ImperialStormtrooperMarksmanshipAcademy: {{Inverted}} as Uhura accidentally lands a direct phaser hit on the warship when she was just supposed to graze it. She apologizes as the warship had taken aim at the ''Enterprise'' and moved directly into the phaser beam in the moments between her confirming the target and firing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BriefAccentImitation: Pike imitates La'an when reminding Uhura of her first security lesson.
-->"A Rigelian tiger pounces with no warning."


Added DiffLines:

* DownerEnding: Hoo boy. The First Servant is jacked into the computer that sustains Majalis, despite Pike's attempt to save him. Any chance of a relationship between Majalis and TheFederation is gone, along with any chance of Pike and Rukiya benefitting from their medical science.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChildProdigy: The First Servant seems to know more about subspace technology than ''Spock''.

Top