Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS03E07CivilDefense

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WorthyOpponent: Quark expresses this sentiment towards Odo, stating that if there were a slave revolt in progress, it's not surprising that the Cardassians would lock Odo in his office: Odo's sense of justice and morality would ensure he joined the fight on the side of the slaves.

to:

* WorthyOpponent: Quark expresses this sentiment towards Odo, stating that if there were a slave revolt in progress, it's not surprising that the Cardassians would lock Odo in his office: Odo's sense of justice and morality would ensure he joined prevent him from automatically siding with the fight on the side of the slaves.Cardassians. Subverted a moment later, as Quark follows this up by chiding Odo for those traits potentially getting them killed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Garak himself seems to have a moment of this, as it doesn't occur to him to wait for Kira and Dax to be ready with the sensor changeover before making the attempt to duplicate Dukat's access code.

Added: 170

Changed: 278

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DidntThinkThisThrough: Invoked; Dukat says he would have made an exception in the phaser turret program to target Garak if he knew Garak during the creation of the program. Garak then pokes at Dukat for being "short-sighted".

to:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: Invoked; Garak hits Dukat says he would with this, accusing Dukat of being so short-sighted as to not consider the possibility that his superiors may have overriden the program.
** Dukat previously lampshaded this on himself because he programmed the phaser turret to only target non-Cardassians, but wishes that he had
made an exception in the phaser turret program to target Garak if he knew Garak during the creation of the program. Garak then pokes at Dukat for being "short-sighted".Garak.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DidntThinkThisThrough: Garak hits Dukat with this, accusing Dukat of being so short-sighted as to not consider the possibility that his superiors may have overriden the program. Dukat then lampshades this on himself by saying that he would have made an exception in the phaser turret program to target Garak if he knew Garak during the creation of the program.

to:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: Garak hits Invoked; Dukat with this, accusing Dukat of being so short-sighted as to not consider the possibility that his superiors may have overriden the program. Dukat then lampshades this on himself by saying that says he would have made an exception in the phaser turret program to target Garak if he knew Garak during the creation of the program.program. Garak then pokes at Dukat for being "short-sighted".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnOfferYouCantRefuse: Dukat offers to deactivate the station's self-destruct in exchange for allowing his soldiers to establish a garrison on the station. When Kira refuses, Dukat reminds her that there are many more lives than her own at stake.

to:

* AnOfferYouCantRefuse: Dukat offers to deactivate the station's self-destruct in exchange for allowing his soldiers to establish a garrison on the station. When Kira refuses, Dukat reminds her that there are many more lives than her own at stake. It ends up backfiring on him, however.

Added: 2325

Changed: 696

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForeShadowing: Garak stands up in Ops, figuring that the replicator gun doesn't fire at Cardassians. Dukat comments that if he had known Garak at the time he would have made an exception. [[spoiler:Two years later in ''[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS05E15ByInfernosLight By Inferno's Light]]'' Cardassia allies with the Dominion and Garak is the only Cardassian ''not'' released from Dominion prison, precisely because Dukat - by then leader of Cardassia's government - ordered them to keep him.]]

to:

* ForeShadowing: EvilIsPetty: Dukat takes a moment to laugh at the sight of Garak crouching for safety and to knock Sisko's baseball off of his desk.
* {{Foreshadowing}}:
**
Garak stands up in Ops, figuring that the replicator gun doesn't fire at Cardassians. Dukat comments that if he had known Garak at the time he would have made an exception. [[spoiler:Two years later in ''[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS05E15ByInfernosLight By Inferno's Light]]'' Cardassia allies with the Dominion and Garak is the only Cardassian ''not'' released from Dominion prison, precisely because Dukat - by then leader of Cardassia's government - ordered them to keep him.]]
** According to Garak, Dukat's father expressed a regret that "his ambition outweighed his patriotism" during his trial. [[spoiler:The apple clearly didn't fall far; Dukat himself will later sell out Cardassia to the Dominion in order to get himself a place at the top of the Cardassian hierarchy.
]]



* {{Irony}}: Garak lampshades the irony that the one place in the galaxy that still recognizes his access codes is a Bajoran space station.



* PetTheDog: Dukat turns off the automated phaser in Ops, which is programmed to only target non-Cardassians, as "the least he can do."

to:

* PetTheDog: OpportunisticBastard: Dukat is happy to exploit the crisis to try and extort his way into getting a Cardassian garrison stationed on Deep Space Nine.
* PetTheDog:
** For whatever it's worth, Dukat's counterinsurgency program does offer several chances for the "rebelling workers" to surrender before resorting to force. [[SubvertedTrope Of course]], subsequent levels of the program involve killing everyone on the station, so this may be more a case of PragmaticVillainy.
**
Dukat turns off the automated phaser in Ops, which is programmed to only target non-Cardassians, as "the least he can do."



* SmugSnake: Dukat is at his most smug and self-important during this episode, cheerfully gloating about the situation, believing that only he can resolve it. When he tries to leave everyone to stew for a while, he ends up being trapped on the station, no longer in a position to fix the crisis, in exactly as bad a position as the people he was just mocking, and [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking subject to Garak's barbs]]. The rapid shift from his smug self-assurance to [[OhCrap realising how screwed he is]] is hilarious, made even moreso by the fact that Dukat clearly ''knows'' how much he's made an ass of himself.



** Odo praises Quark for his deviousness, until it turns out that he was just being nice in what seemed like their last few hours of life.

to:

** Odo praises Quark for his deviousness, until it turns out that he was just being nice in what seemed like their last few hours of life.life.
* YouKilledMyFather: Implied to be the source of Dukat's loathing for Garak; apparently, Dukat's father trusted Garak, which led to a trial, and given the Cardassian justice system, more than likely an execution. Garak seems to feel that the elder Dukat brought it on himself, which (unsurprisingly) doesn't mollify Dukat.

Added: 126

Changed: 54

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FunnyBackgroundEvent: Several times, while the main characters are discussing how to get out of the mess they're in, the recording of Dukat continues to prattle on in the background, encouraging the 'rebel Bajorans' to surrender, warning them how dangerous and barren Bajor is compared to the [[BlatantLies good life they have on Terok Nor]], and warning them that other Cardassian officers won't be as lenient as he is...

to:

* FunnyBackgroundEvent: Several times, while the main characters are discussing how to get out of the mess they're in, the recording of Dukat continues to prattle on in the background, encouraging the 'rebel Bajorans' to surrender, warning them how dangerous and barren Bajor is compared to the [[BlatantLies good life they have on Terok Nor]], and warning them that insisting the other Cardassian officers won't be as lenient and merciful as he is...



-->'''Garak:''' Even your own computer program turned against you! I always said your shortsightedness would be your downfall.



* NiceJobBreakingItHero: Each time the heroes think they've figured out a solution, the security program thinks it has to get even tougher on the "Bajoran workers."

to:

* NiceJobBreakingItHero: Each time the heroes think they've figured out a solution, the security program thinks [[MovingTheGoalposts it has to get even tougher tougher]] on the "Bajoran workers."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rewriting to remove redundancy after tahna_los's edit


Eager to capitalize on their distress, Dukat offers to shut down the program in exchange for allowing his troops to establish a garrison aboard the station. Unsurprisingly, Kira finds death a more appealing choice. Dukat decides to return to his ship to allow them time to think things over, but finds the security program has surprises even for him. As soon as Dukat tries to radio his ship, he finds he is unable to, and a new recording plays -- this time from his supervisor, who gives him a brutal TheReasonYouSuckSpeech for attempting to abandon his post in the middle of a Bajoran rebellion. The supervisor recording also reveals another twist: that Dukat's codes have been voided and that the self-destruct system can no longer be stopped.

Now that he's in the same boat as everyone else, Dukat is much more eager to help, but all security codes, including his (and Garak's) have been voided. Their only option is to try to deactivate the main reactor before it explodes. To that end, they {{Technobabble}} a way to overload the force fields on the station so that they can move freely again, but there's not enough time for them to get where they need.

to:

Eager to capitalize on their distress, Dukat offers to shut down the program in exchange for allowing his troops to establish a garrison aboard the station. Unsurprisingly, Kira finds death a more appealing choice. Dukat decides to return to his ship to allow them time to think things over, but finds the security program has surprises even for him. As soon as Dukat tries to radio his ship, he finds he is unable to, and a new recording plays -- this time from his supervisor, who gives him a brutal TheReasonYouSuckSpeech for attempting to abandon his post in the middle of a Bajoran rebellion. The supervisor recording also reveals another twist: that Dukat's all security codes have been voided and that the self-destruct system can no longer be stopped.

Now that he's in the same boat as everyone else, Dukat is much more eager to help, but all security codes, including his (and Garak's) have been voided.help. Their only option is to try to deactivate the main reactor before it explodes. To that end, they {{Technobabble}} a way to overload the force fields on the station so that they can move freely again, but there's not enough time for them to get where they need.

Added: 363

Changed: 150

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Eager to capitalize on their distress, Dukat offers to shut down the program in exchange for allowing his troops to establish a garrison aboard the station. Unsurprisingly, Kira finds death a more appealing choice. Dukat decides to return to his ship to allow them time to think things over, but finds the security program has surprises even for him. As soon as Dukat tries to radio his ship, he finds he is unable to, and a new recording plays -- this time from his supervisor, who gives him a brutal TheReasonYouSuckSpeech for attempting to abandon his post in the middle of a Bajoran rebellion.

to:

Eager to capitalize on their distress, Dukat offers to shut down the program in exchange for allowing his troops to establish a garrison aboard the station. Unsurprisingly, Kira finds death a more appealing choice. Dukat decides to return to his ship to allow them time to think things over, but finds the security program has surprises even for him. As soon as Dukat tries to radio his ship, he finds he is unable to, and a new recording plays -- this time from his supervisor, who gives him a brutal TheReasonYouSuckSpeech for attempting to abandon his post in the middle of a Bajoran rebellion.
rebellion. The supervisor recording also reveals another twist: that Dukat's codes have been voided and that the self-destruct system can no longer be stopped.


Added DiffLines:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: Garak hits Dukat with this, accusing Dukat of being so short-sighted as to not consider the possibility that his superiors may have overriden the program. Dukat then lampshades this on himself by saying that he would have made an exception in the phaser turret program to target Garak if he knew Garak during the creation of the program.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
some people are still getting caught up on the show


* ForeShadowing: Garak stands up in Ops, figuring that the replicator gun doesn't fire at Cardassians. Dukat comments that if he had known Garak at the time he would have made an exception. Two years later in ''[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS05E15ByInfernosLight By Inferno's Light]]'' Cardassia allies with the Dominion and Garak is the only Cardassian ''not'' released from Dominion prison, precisely because Dukat - by then leader of Cardassia's government - ordered them to keep him.

to:

* ForeShadowing: Garak stands up in Ops, figuring that the replicator gun doesn't fire at Cardassians. Dukat comments that if he had known Garak at the time he would have made an exception. Two [[spoiler:Two years later in ''[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS05E15ByInfernosLight By Inferno's Light]]'' Cardassia allies with the Dominion and Garak is the only Cardassian ''not'' released from Dominion prison, precisely because Dukat - by then leader of Cardassia's government - ordered them to keep him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Foreshadowing

Added DiffLines:

* ForeShadowing: Garak stands up in Ops, figuring that the replicator gun doesn't fire at Cardassians. Dukat comments that if he had known Garak at the time he would have made an exception. Two years later in ''[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS05E15ByInfernosLight By Inferno's Light]]'' Cardassia allies with the Dominion and Garak is the only Cardassian ''not'' released from Dominion prison, precisely because Dukat - by then leader of Cardassia's government - ordered them to keep him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Now that he's in the same boat as everyone else, Dukat is much more eager to help, but his (and even Garak's) security codes have been voided. Their only option is to try to deactivate the main reactor before it explodes. To that end, they {{Technobabble}} a way to overload the force fields on the station so that they can move freely again, but there's not enough time for them to get where they need.

to:

Now that he's in the same boat as everyone else, Dukat is much more eager to help, but all security codes, including his (and even Garak's) security codes have been voided. Their only option is to try to deactivate the main reactor before it explodes. To that end, they {{Technobabble}} a way to overload the force fields on the station so that they can move freely again, but there's not enough time for them to get where they need.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not only that, but even Dukat's superior wrote in a scenario in case Dukat was unable to quell the rebellion and tried to escape.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As it turns out, even this eventuality was considered by the program. As soon as life support is take offline, Dukat appears yet again to warn them that they have two hours to halt the imaginary revolt before the station self-destructs.

to:

As it turns out, even this eventuality was considered by the program. As soon as life support is take taken offline, Dukat appears yet again to warn them that they have two hours to halt the imaginary revolt before the station self-destructs.

Added: 147

Changed: 53

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


---> '''O'Brien:''' I heard stories that the temperature in here reached 55 degrees. [[note]]That's 131 in Fahrenheit. [[/note]]\\

to:

---> '''O'Brien:''' I heard stories that the temperature in here reached 55 degrees. [[note]]That's 131 in Fahrenheit.Fahrenheit, roughly the temperature of Death Valley, California. [[/note]]\\


Added DiffLines:

* UnwittingInstigatorOfDoom: All O'Brien wanted to do was set an unfamiliar program aside. He had no idea it would trigger this episode's problems.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Garak:''' Plenty, Major. Unfortunately, all of it bad.

to:

-->'''Garak:''' Plenty, Major. [[BaitAndSwitchComment Unfortunately, all of it bad.bad]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FunnyBackgroundEvent: Several times, while the main characters are discussing how to get out of the mess they're in, the recording of Dukat continues to prattle on in the background, encouraging the 'rebel Bajorans' to surrender, warning them how dangerous and barren Bajor is compared to the [[BlatantLies good life they have on Terok Nor]], and warning them that other Cardassian officers won't be as lenient as he is...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseGunSafety: Kira aims her phaser at the door to Ops -- while Bashir is still in the line of fire. Does she really find him ''that'' annoying?

to:

* ArtisticLicenseGunSafety: Kira aims her phaser at the door to Ops -- while Bashir is still in the line of fire. Does she really find him ''that'' annoying?annoying? No surprise that the two redshirts manning the life support station are in such a hurry to get away when Kira takes aim at their console later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Lockdown}}: The whole point of the counterinsurgency program.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DidntSeeThatComing: Dukat clearly did not expect that his superiors had a few surprises for him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoodleIncident: The bad blood between Dukat and Garak is first mentioned, as it involved the former's father.


Added DiffLines:

* SpotOfTea: Dukat pauses the replicator's automated phaser turret to order a cup of red leaf tea. After he takes his drink, the phaser is reactivated.

Added: 157

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseGunSafety: Kira aims her phaser at the door to Ops -- while Bashir is still in the line of fire. Does she really find him ''that'' annoying?



--> '''Dukat:''' ''(sighs)'' Let me guess--someone tried to duplicate my access codes, hmm?

to:

--> '''Dukat:''' ''(sighs)'' Let me guess--someone guess -- someone tried to duplicate my access codes, hmm?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


O'Brien, Jake, and Sisko are in one of the station's abandoned ore processing facilities, getting started on a project to turn it into a deuterium refinery. While trying to reformat the computer, Jake comes across a mysterious Cardassian file that doesn't want to be deleted. When O'Brien tries to mess with it, the file triggers an old security program that locks down the room and shows them a prerecorded video of everyone's favorite prefect, Gul Dukat. Turns out the computer thinks the trio are "revolting workers", and without the password, no one - not even the staff in Ops - know how to convince it otherwise.

to:

O'Brien, Jake, and Sisko are in one of the station's abandoned ore processing facilities, getting started on a project to turn it into a deuterium refinery. While trying to reformat the computer, Jake comes across a mysterious Cardassian file that doesn't want to be deleted. When O'Brien tries to mess with it, the file triggers an old security program that locks down the room and shows them a prerecorded video of everyone's favorite prefect, Gul Dukat. Turns out the computer thinks the trio are "revolting workers", and without the password, no one - -- not even the staff in Ops - -- know how to convince it otherwise.



Ops is sealed - ostensibly to protect the senior staff, but it also means they are trapped there. Odo, who has been trying to help shut down the program, is also sealed inside his office along with Quark, who [[{{Foreshadowing}} had a bad feeling about this whole thing and decided it would be a safe place to hide]].

to:

Ops is sealed - -- ostensibly to protect the senior staff, but it also means they are trapped there. Odo, who has been trying to help shut down the program, is also sealed inside his office along with Quark, who [[{{Foreshadowing}} had a bad feeling about this whole thing and decided it would be a safe place to hide]].



A new strategy for disabling the security program fails when a force field comes on over a circuit box in Ops and nearly takes off Dax's hands. In response, the program again tightens its grip, threatening to kill everyone on the habitat ring with neurocine if the "revolt" is not put down soon. Garak, whose old Cardassian codes give him enough access to move through the force fields, shows up in Ops with fresh ideas on how to defeat the program. His first recommendation is to destroy the life support system, preventing the neurocine gas from being released and giving them a new time limit - 12 hours, then they run out of air.

to:

A new strategy for disabling the security program fails when a force field comes on over a circuit box in Ops and nearly takes off Dax's hands. In response, the program again tightens its grip, threatening to kill everyone on the habitat ring with neurocine if the "revolt" is not put down soon. Garak, whose old Cardassian codes give him enough access to move through the force fields, shows up in Ops with fresh ideas on how to defeat the program. His first recommendation is to destroy the life support system, preventing the neurocine gas from being released and giving them a new time limit - -- 12 hours, then they run out of air.



Eager to capitalize on their distress, Dukat offers to shut down the program in exchange for allowing his troops to establish a garrison aboard the station. Unsurprisingly, Kira finds death a more appealing choice. Dukat decides to return to his ship to allow them time to think things over, but finds the security program has surprises even for him. As soon as Dukat tries to radio his ship, he finds he is unable to, and a new recording plays - this time from his supervisor, who gives him a brutal TheReasonYouSuckSpeech for attempting to abandon his post in the middle of a Bajoran rebellion.

to:

Eager to capitalize on their distress, Dukat offers to shut down the program in exchange for allowing his troops to establish a garrison aboard the station. Unsurprisingly, Kira finds death a more appealing choice. Dukat decides to return to his ship to allow them time to think things over, but finds the security program has surprises even for him. As soon as Dukat tries to radio his ship, he finds he is unable to, and a new recording plays - -- this time from his supervisor, who gives him a brutal TheReasonYouSuckSpeech for attempting to abandon his post in the middle of a Bajoran rebellion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added image

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:350:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/civildefense.png]]
[[caption-width-right:350:"Would you allow 2000 people aboard this station to die simply because you don't like... us?"]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrazyPrepared: Cardassians tend to plan ahead and Gul Dukat's counterinsurgency program was ready for pretty much every possible scenario.

to:

* CrazyPrepared: Cardassians tend to plan ahead and Gul Dukat's counterinsurgency program was ready for pretty much every possible scenario. The only one it didn't account for was the failure of the self-destruct mechanism, as the program presumably shuts down on its own after the reactor overload fails to destroy the station.



** The audience learns that Cardassian forcefields are designed to be lethal. The reason they aren't on [=DS9=] is because the Federation wisely disabled that "feature" when they took over.

to:

** The audience learns that Cardassian forcefields are designed to be lethal.lethal (or at least have no safeguards to limit the damage they can do). The reason they aren't on [=DS9=] is because the Federation wisely disabled that "feature" when they took over.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Dukat gets a fairly spectacular one from his former commanding officer. It leaves him, for once, at a complete loss for words
-->"Dukat, if you are seeing this recording, it means you tried to abandon your post while the station's self-destruct sequence was engaged. That will not be permitted. You have lost control of Terok Nor, disgracing yourself and Cardassia. Your attempt to escape is no doubt a final act of cowardice. All fail-safes have been eliminated, your personal access codes have been rescinded. The destruct sequence can no longer be halted. All you can do now is contemplate the depth of your disgrace... and try to die like a Cardassian."


Added DiffLines:

* {{Troll}}: Dukat is clearly enjoying himself strolling around Ops while everyone else hides from the phaser. He even invites Kira into Sisko's office to talk, seemingly "forgetting" the phaser is there before he stops it.
* VengefulVendingMachine: The replicator creates a phaser in Ops and starts shooting people. Now ''that's'' vengeful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LastSecondWordSwap: When Dukat asks Kira, "Are you willing to let two thousand people aboard this station die simply because you don't like... ''us?"'', he was clearly about to say "me" but changed his mind at the last instant.

to:

* LastSecondWordSwap: When Dukat asks Kira, "Are "Would you willing to let allow two thousand people aboard this station to die simply because you don't like... ''us?"'', he was clearly about to say "me" but changed his mind at the last instant.

Added: 349

Changed: 84

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DissonantSerenity: Dukat strolling about the command center talking while everyone else is hiding under any available cover.

to:

* DissonantSerenity: Dukat strolling about the command center talking while everyone else is hiding under any available cover. (Then again, he knows the replicator is programmed to only attack non-Cardassians.)


Added DiffLines:

* LastSecondWordSwap: When Dukat asks Kira, "Are you willing to let two thousand people aboard this station die simply because you don't like... ''us?"'', he was clearly about to say "me" but changed his mind at the last instant.


Added DiffLines:

* VillainousCrush: Dukat clearly has one on Kira. Garak bluntly points this out, and takes great delight in mocking him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CannedOrdersOverLoudspeaker: It says a lot about Dukat that he saw fit to delegate the task of handling riots to a recording of himself.

to:

* CannedOrdersOverLoudspeaker: It says a lot about Dukat that he saw fit to delegate the task of handling riots to a recording of himself. He shows up later because he got a distress call from himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

--> '''Sisko:''' You know, I never knew how much this man's voice annoyed me.


Added DiffLines:

--> '''Dukat:''' ''(sighs)'' Let me guess--someone tried to duplicate my access codes, hmm?

Top