Follow TV Tropes

Following

History PlayingWith / VillainousBadlandHeroicArcadia

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The settting is a huge dry desert that isn't exactly a good place to be around no matter where you are, but Brightland is situated in a relatively lush floodplain of succulent cacti and does have it's own beauty to it, while Vileshade is in the middle of sand dunes that gets the worst heat.

to:

** The settting is a huge dry desert that isn't exactly a good place to be around no matter where you are, but Brightland is situated in a relatively lush floodplain of succulent cacti and does have it's its own beauty to it, while Vileshade is in the middle of sand dunes that gets the worst heat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Inverted''': The BarbarianHero [[MiseryBuildsCharacter was shaped]] by cold, harsh wastelands where his [[ProudWarriorRace valorous]] [[BarbarianTribe tribesmen]] live, while the decadent EvilSorcerer lives in an tropical paradise that easily supports a sprawling ViceCity.

to:

* '''Inverted''': The BarbarianHero Clay had his [[MiseryBuildsCharacter was character shaped]] by cold, harsh wastelands where his [[ProudWarriorRace valorous]] [[BarbarianTribe tribesmen]] live, while the decadent EvilSorcerer lives in an tropical paradise that easily supports a sprawling ViceCity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The settting is a huge dry desert that isn't exactly a good place to be around no matter where you are, but Brightland is situated in a relatively lush floodplain of succulents and does have it's own beauty to it, while Vileshade is in the middle of sand dunes that gets the woest heat.

to:

** The settting is a huge dry desert that isn't exactly a good place to be around no matter where you are, but Brightland is situated in a relatively lush floodplain of succulents succulent cacti and does have it's own beauty to it, while Vileshade is in the middle of sand dunes that gets the woest worst heat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The settting is a huge dry desert that isn't exactly a good place to be around no matter where you are, but Brightland is situated in a relatively lush floodplain of succulents.

to:

** The settting is a huge dry desert that isn't exactly a good place to be around no matter where you are, but Brightland is situated in a relatively lush floodplain of succulents.succulents and does have it's own beauty to it, while Vileshade is in the middle of sand dunes that gets the woest heat.

Added: 415

Changed: 405

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Downplayed''': Brightland is a typical temperate area with generally mild weather (cool summers and warm winters) while Vileshade tends to get a lot of rain and overly hot summers and cold winters, but is livable and occasionally has good weather.

to:

* '''Downplayed''': '''Downplayed''':
**
Brightland is a typical temperate area with generally mild weather (cool summers and warm winters) while Vileshade tends to get a lot of rain and overly hot summers and cold winters, but is livable and occasionally has good weather. weather.
** The settting is a huge dry desert that isn't exactly a good place to be around no matter where you are, but Brightland is situated in a relatively lush floodplain of succulents.



* Played for Drama: ???

to:

* Played '''Played for Drama: ???Drama''': [[AntiVillain Evulz]] at first tries to appeal to Brightland for help as his people are desperate, but Brightland refuses, a sign they're not as good as they seem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Each land is ruled by a FisherKing. Brightland is sustained by TheGoodKing, while Vileshade has been ruined by [[TheEmperor an evil emperor]].

to:

** Each land is ruled by a FisherKing. Brightland is sustained by TheGoodKing, while Vileshade has been ruined by [[TheEmperor [[TheCaligula an evil emperor]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Straight''': The [[TheKingdom peaceful kingdom]] of Brightland is a blooming pastoral {{Arcadia}} ruled by [[TheGoodKing Bob the Benevolent]]. They are invaded by the militaristic [[TheEmpire empire]] of Vileshade under [[TheCaligula Evulz the Cruel]], which is a [[GaiasLament polluted wasteland]] [[DeathWorld where few plants grow]] and [[{{Mordor}} landscapes are mostly]] [[SceneryGorn gloomy greys and browns]]. When the army of Vileshade takes over an area of Brightland, within a few years of their management it has turned just as bad as Vileshade.

to:

* '''Straight''': The [[TheKingdom [[TheGoodKingdom peaceful kingdom]] of Brightland is a blooming pastoral {{Arcadia}} ruled by [[TheGoodKing Bob the Benevolent]]. They are invaded by the militaristic [[TheEmpire empire]] of Vileshade under [[TheCaligula Evulz the Cruel]], which is a [[GaiasLament polluted wasteland]] [[DeathWorld where few plants grow]] and [[{{Mordor}} landscapes are mostly]] [[SceneryGorn gloomy greys and browns]]. When the army of Vileshade takes over an area of Brightland, within a few years of their management it has turned just as bad as Vileshade.

Added: 47

Changed: 180

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Conversed''' ???

to:

* '''Conversed''' ???"What's the connection between bad guys and wastelands? Are they evil because they live in a wasteland, or do they live in a wasteland because they're evil?"




to:

* Played for Laughs: ???
* Played for Drama: ???
* Played for Horror: ???
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** (3) Brightland's damming of the Great River has robbed Vileshade of its main source of water. They are only interested in getting it back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Downplayed''': Brightland is a typical temperate area with genuinely mild weather (cool summers and warm winters) while Vileshade tends to rain a lot and get overly hot summers and cold winters, but is livable and occasionally has good weather.

to:

* '''Downplayed''': Brightland is a typical temperate area with genuinely generally mild weather (cool summers and warm winters) while Vileshade tends to rain get a lot of rain and get overly hot summers and cold winters, but is livable and occasionally has good weather.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Straight''': The [[TheKingdom peaceful kingdom]] of Brightland is a blooming pastoral {{Arcadia}} ruled by [[TheGoodKing Bob the Benevolent]]. They are invaded by the militaristic [[TheEmpire empire]] of Vileshade under [[TheCaligula Evulz the Cruel]], which is [[DeathWorld a polluted wasteland]] [[SceneryGorn where few plants grow and landscapes are mostly gloomy greys and browns]]. When the army of Vileshade takes over an area of Brightland, within a few years of their management it has turned just as bad as Vileshade.

to:

* '''Straight''': The [[TheKingdom peaceful kingdom]] of Brightland is a blooming pastoral {{Arcadia}} ruled by [[TheGoodKing Bob the Benevolent]]. They are invaded by the militaristic [[TheEmpire empire]] of Vileshade under [[TheCaligula Evulz the Cruel]], which is [[DeathWorld a [[GaiasLament polluted wasteland]] [[SceneryGorn [[DeathWorld where few plants grow grow]] and [[{{Mordor}} landscapes are mostly mostly]] [[SceneryGorn gloomy greys and browns]]. When the army of Vileshade takes over an area of Brightland, within a few years of their management it has turned just as bad as Vileshade.

Changed: 279

Removed: 81

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** (2) Brightland is vivid, colorful, flower-covered and rife with fauna, while Vileshade is a depressing wasteland nearly devoid of life... except it became that way due to an invasion by the Brightland army ages ago that utterly devastated Vileshade. As a side effect, it motivated General Evulz, the highest-ranking officer of Vileshade military who survived Brightland's onslaught, to [[EmergencyAuthority declare himself Emperor]] and rule the country with an iron grip to build a military force that could return the favor to Brightland.

to:

** (2) Brightland is vivid, colorful, flower-covered and rife with fauna, while Vileshade is a barren, depressing wasteland nearly devoid of life... except it became that way due to an invasion by the Brightland army ages ago that utterly devastated Vileshade. As a side effect, it motivated General Evulz, the highest-ranking officer of Vileshade military who survived Brightland's onslaught, to [[EmergencyAuthority declare himself Emperor]] and rule the country with an iron grip to build a military force that could return the favor to Brightland.



** (2) However, the Brightland's invasion actually was a counter-offensive to a conquest started by the previous king of Vileshade in an attempt to grab the most fertile territories of Brightland.

to:

** (2) However, the Brightland's invasion actually was a counter-offensive to a conquest started by the previous king of Vileshade in an attempt to grab the most fertile territories of Brightland. While Brightlanders admittedly went rather too far with "ScrewTheRulesTheyBrokeThemFirst" in their retribution, most of the fertile land in Vileshade was depleted before that war due to mismanagement and poor farming practices.



* '''Invoked''': The villains were former inhabitants of Brightland who were exiled to Vileshade as punishment for their villainy.

to:

* '''Invoked''': The villains were former inhabitants of Brightland who were [[ReassignedToAntarctica exiled to Vileshade Vileshade]] as punishment for their villainy.



* '''Implied''': The story is set in neither Brightland nor Vileshade, but in a different area that hosts many adventurers from both lands. Two Brightlandian adventures reminisce about their beloved home, and a Vileshade spy looking in on them, who has earlier said that he has no interest in going back home, seems sad and angry at them when she hears their conversation.

to:

* '''Implied''': The story is set in neither Brightland nor Vileshade, but in a different area that hosts many adventurers from both lands. Two Brightlandian adventures reminisce about their beloved home, and a Vileshade spy looking in on them, who has earlier said that he she has no interest in going back home, seems sad and angry at them when she hears their conversation.



* '''Reconstructed''': Vileshade is a hard, cruel land, but the volcanic soil regions are ''very'' fertile, the rest of the region [[HadToBeSharp raises tough people]], and there's a lot of mineral wealth to be had beneath the earth.

to:

* '''Reconstructed''': Vileshade is [[DeathWorld a hard, cruel land, land]], but the volcanic soil regions are ''very'' fertile, the rest of the region [[HadToBeSharp raises tough people]], and there's a lot of mineral wealth to be had beneath the earth.



%% * '''Implied''': ???
%% * '''Deconstructed''': ???
%% * '''Reconstructed''': ???

Added: 1084

Changed: 1197

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Straight''': The [[TheKingdom peaceful kingdom]] of Brightland is a blooming pastoral {{Arcadia}}. They are invaded by the cruel [[TheEmpire empire]] of Vileshade, which is a polluted wasteland where few plants grow. When Vileshade takes over an area of Brightland, within a few years of their management it has turned just as bad as Vileshade.
* '''Exaggerated''': Brightland is such a SugarBowl that every time you leave your house you are surrounded by adorable chirping birds and cute rabbits. There is never bad weather and the plants are magically blessed to never rot and die. Meanwhile Vileshade is nothing but desert interspersed with giant heaps of garbage, with no plants or animals in sight. As soon as a resident of Vileshade sets foot in any other land, it instantly turns into the same decrepit wasteland.

to:

* '''Straight''': The [[TheKingdom peaceful kingdom]] of Brightland is a blooming pastoral {{Arcadia}}. {{Arcadia}} ruled by [[TheGoodKing Bob the Benevolent]]. They are invaded by the cruel militaristic [[TheEmpire empire]] of Vileshade, Vileshade under [[TheCaligula Evulz the Cruel]], which is [[DeathWorld a polluted wasteland wasteland]] [[SceneryGorn where few plants grow. grow and landscapes are mostly gloomy greys and browns]]. When the army of Vileshade takes over an area of Brightland, within a few years of their management it has turned just as bad as Vileshade.
* '''Exaggerated''': Brightland is such a SugarBowl that every time you leave your house you are surrounded by adorable chirping birds and cute rabbits. There is never bad weather and the plants are magically blessed to never rot and die. Meanwhile Vileshade is nothing but desert interspersed with giant heaps of garbage, with no plants or animals in sight. As soon as [[WalkingWasteland a resident of Vileshade sets foot in any other land, land]], it instantly turns into the same decrepit wasteland.



* '''Inverted''': The heroic BarbarianTribe was shaped by cold, harsh wastelands, while the decadent EvilSorcerer lives in an tropical paradise that easily supports a sprawling ViceCity.
* '''Subverted''': We are first introduced to Bob from Brightland, who lives in a house with a beautiful garden, and Violet from Vileshade, a soldier fighting in a barren wasteland. We later learn that Bob is very wealthy and most people in Brightland live in less pleasant parts of the area, and Violet was traveling through an area devastated by war but the rest of Vileshade is quite green and beautiful.
* '''Double Subverted''': This information is told to us by a propagandist for Vileshade, who is trying to make Brightland look bad by emphasizing their income inequality that is really far more mild, with everyone living in beautiful pastoral areas, and wants to hide that many in Vileshade are living in horrible conditions and starving.

to:

* '''Inverted''': The heroic BarbarianTribe BarbarianHero [[MiseryBuildsCharacter was shaped shaped]] by cold, harsh wastelands, wastelands where his [[ProudWarriorRace valorous]] [[BarbarianTribe tribesmen]] live, while the decadent EvilSorcerer lives in an tropical paradise that easily supports a sprawling ViceCity.
* '''Subverted''': '''Subverted''':
** (1)
We are first introduced to Bob from Brightland, who lives in a house with a beautiful garden, and Violet from Vileshade, a soldier fighting in a barren wasteland. We later learn that Bob is very wealthy and most people in Brightland live in less pleasant parts of the area, and Violet was traveling through an area devastated by war but the rest of Vileshade is quite green and beautiful.
beautiful.
** (2) Brightland is vivid, colorful, flower-covered and rife with fauna, while Vileshade is a depressing wasteland nearly devoid of life... except it became that way due to an invasion by the Brightland army ages ago that utterly devastated Vileshade. As a side effect, it motivated General Evulz, the highest-ranking officer of Vileshade military who survived Brightland's onslaught, to [[EmergencyAuthority declare himself Emperor]] and rule the country with an iron grip to build a military force that could return the favor to Brightland.
* '''Double Subverted''': Subverted''':
** (1)
This information is told to us by a propagandist for Vileshade, who is trying to make Brightland look bad by emphasizing their income inequality that is really far more mild, with everyone living in beautiful pastoral areas, and wants to hide that many in Vileshade are living in horrible conditions and starving.starving.
** (2) However, the Brightland's invasion actually was a counter-offensive to a conquest started by the previous king of Vileshade in an attempt to grab the most fertile territories of Brightland.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Each land is ruled by a FisherKing. Brightland is sustained by TheGoodKing, while Vileshade has been ruined by [[TheEmperor an evil emperor]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Double Subverted''': This information is told to us by a propagandist for Vileshade, who is trying to make Brightland look like the bad emphasizing their income inequality that is really far more mild, with everyone living in beautiful pastoral areas, and wants to hide that everyone in Vileshade is living in horrible conditions and starving.

to:

* '''Double Subverted''': This information is told to us by a propagandist for Vileshade, who is trying to make Brightland look like the bad by emphasizing their income inequality that is really far more mild, with everyone living in beautiful pastoral areas, and wants to hide that everyone many in Vileshade is are living in horrible conditions and starving.

Added: 315

Changed: 313

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Justified''': The people of Vileshade would normally live peacefully just like the people of Brightland, and their acts of conquest that make them the villains of the story are all motivated by obtaining enough arable land so they don't starve. Brightland was chosen to take over ''because'' it was the most prosperous region.

to:

* '''Justified''': '''Justified''':
**
The people of Vileshade would normally live peacefully just like the people of Brightland, and their acts of conquest that make them the villains of the story are all motivated by obtaining enough arable land so they don't starve. Brightland was chosen to take over ''because'' it was the most prosperous region.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* '''Reconstructed''': Vileshade is a hard, cruel land, but the volcanic soil regions are ''very'' fertile, the rest of the region [[HadToBeSharp raises tough people]], and there's a lot of mineral wealth to be had beneath the earth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Inverted''': The peaceful kingdom of Brightland is a decrepit desert interspersed with polluted cities, while the evil empire of Vileshade is a flourishing {{Arcadia}}.

to:

* '''Inverted''': The peaceful kingdom of Brightland is a decrepit desert interspersed with polluted cities, heroic BarbarianTribe was shaped by cold, harsh wastelands, while the evil empire of Vileshade is decadent EvilSorcerer lives in an tropical paradise that easily supports a flourishing {{Arcadia}}. sprawling ViceCity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

'''Basic Trope''': The heroes of a work live in a pleasant and flourishing land while the villains live in a dark and degraded one.
* '''Straight''': The [[TheKingdom peaceful kingdom]] of Brightland is a blooming pastoral {{Arcadia}}. They are invaded by the cruel [[TheEmpire empire]] of Vileshade, which is a polluted wasteland where few plants grow. When Vileshade takes over an area of Brightland, within a few years of their management it has turned just as bad as Vileshade.
* '''Exaggerated''': Brightland is such a SugarBowl that every time you leave your house you are surrounded by adorable chirping birds and cute rabbits. There is never bad weather and the plants are magically blessed to never rot and die. Meanwhile Vileshade is nothing but desert interspersed with giant heaps of garbage, with no plants or animals in sight. As soon as a resident of Vileshade sets foot in any other land, it instantly turns into the same decrepit wasteland.
* '''Downplayed''': Brightland is a typical temperate area with genuinely mild weather (cool summers and warm winters) while Vileshade tends to rain a lot and get overly hot summers and cold winters, but is livable and occasionally has good weather.
* '''Justified''': The people of Vileshade would normally live peacefully just like the people of Brightland, and their acts of conquest that make them the villains of the story are all motivated by obtaining enough arable land so they don't starve. Brightland was chosen to take over ''because'' it was the most prosperous region.
** Vileshade is FascistButInefficient, so it has trouble making any headway in environmental legislation. Brightland's functioning government allows it to avoid destroying its environment.
** Vileshade's obsession with conquest means it depletes all of its resources to engage in constant war, slowly ruining its environment, while Brightland's general avoidance of war means it conserves its resources.
* '''Inverted''': The peaceful kingdom of Brightland is a decrepit desert interspersed with polluted cities, while the evil empire of Vileshade is a flourishing {{Arcadia}}.
* '''Subverted''': We are first introduced to Bob from Brightland, who lives in a house with a beautiful garden, and Violet from Vileshade, a soldier fighting in a barren wasteland. We later learn that Bob is very wealthy and most people in Brightland live in less pleasant parts of the area, and Violet was traveling through an area devastated by war but the rest of Vileshade is quite green and beautiful.
* '''Double Subverted''': This information is told to us by a propagandist for Vileshade, who is trying to make Brightland look like the bad emphasizing their income inequality that is really far more mild, with everyone living in beautiful pastoral areas, and wants to hide that everyone in Vileshade is living in horrible conditions and starving.
* '''Parodied''': ???
* '''Zig-Zagged''': It soon becomes apparent that both sides are trying to make their living conditions look better for the sake of propaganda, and both Brightland and Vileshade are so vast in area that they can have both idyllic areas and degraded ones, so no character is really sure which one is in better shape overall or can find a reliable source to tell them.
* '''Averted''': Brightland and Vileshade look basically the same.
* '''Enforced''': "This is a kids' show, and we need the kids to be able to tell which people are good and which people are evil."
* '''Lampshaded''': "Wow, there's so little growing here that I really don't understand how the emperor of Vileshade is feeding his army!"
* '''Invoked''': The villains were former inhabitants of Brightland who were exiled to Vileshade as punishment for their villainy.
* '''Exploited''': To win the war against Vileshade, the heroes try to engage them in a drawn-out war that drains their resources, knowing that in the state they are in, Vileshade will run out far earlier.
* '''Defied''': The emperor of Vileshade engages in a tree-planting program, funds farmers, and runs a pollution clean-up initiative to make sure his empire is in good shape.
* '''Discussed''': "Hey, a lot of the enemies we fight tend to live in pretty horrible wastelands." "Yeah, it kind of makes me reluctant to leave my home... but we have to go to Vileshade to save everyone, even if it won't be fun."
* '''Conversed''' ???
* '''Implied''': The story is set in neither Brightland nor Vileshade, but in a different area that hosts many adventurers from both lands. Two Brightlandian adventures reminisce about their beloved home, and a Vileshade spy looking in on them, who has earlier said that he has no interest in going back home, seems sad and angry at them when she hears their conversation.
* '''Deconstructed''': Brightland beats Vileshade in a CurbStompBattle because everyone in Vileshade is starving and they aren't able to have good weapons since they don't have the resources to build them or trade for them.

----
Back to VillainousBadlandHeroicArcadia
----
%% Optional items, added after Conversed, at your discretion:
%% * '''Implied''': ???
%% * '''Deconstructed''': ???
%% * '''Reconstructed''': ???
%% * '''Played for Laughs''': ???
%% * '''Played for Drama''': ???
%% * '''Played for Horror''': ???

Top