History PlayingWith / HonorRelatedAbuse

22nd Dec '17 5:31:25 PM marcoasalazarm
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Aerith breaks some minor promise, which overall is seen by everybody as a good thing because not doing it otherwise would have been much more abominable (such as, for example, telling the whereabouts of a runaway multiple rapist after being sworn not to say). Aerith's parents, however, see the breaking of the promise as an act abominable enough on its own that killing her (their own, and sole, daughter) in the goriest fashion possible is the best retribution they can think of.
22nd Dec '17 4:36:27 PM AgentKyles
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** If Aerith's parents choose not to punish her, their society will kill them ([[ConvictedByPublicOpinion or at least their social cred]]) as well as her(s) "[[VillainByProxyFallacy for tolerating]] [[AccompliceByInaction her indecency]]". They had to choose LesserOfTwoEvils.

to:

** If Aerith's parents choose not to punish her, their society will kill them ([[ConvictedByPublicOpinion or at least their social cred]]) as well as her(s) "[[VillainByProxyFallacy for tolerating]] [[AccompliceByInaction her indecency]]". They had to choose LesserOfTwoEvils. ([[FalseDichotomy Couldn't they]] TakeAThirdOption and let her go, then say everyone that she fled?)
27th Jul '17 12:59:06 AM AgentKyles
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** AerithAndBob are together, but Aerith's [[ParentalMarriageVeto parents don't approve of Bob]]. They lecture her, saying some rather unnecessarily hurtful things, and tell her she's grounded.

to:

** AerithAndBob are together, but Aerith's [[ParentalMarriageVeto parents don't approve of Bob]]. [[BreakThemByTalking They lecture her, saying some rather unnecessarily hurtful things, things]], and tell finish their rant by telling her [[YouAreGrounded she's grounded.grounded]].



** If Aerith's parents choose not to punish her, their society will kill them as well as her. They had to choose LesserOfTwoEvils.

to:

** If Aerith's parents choose not to punish her, their society will kill them ([[ConvictedByPublicOpinion or at least their social cred]]) as well as her.her(s) "[[VillainByProxyFallacy for tolerating]] [[AccompliceByInaction her indecency]]". They had to choose LesserOfTwoEvils.



** Rather than harm Aerith, her parents kill or injure Bob.

to:

** Rather than harm Aerith, [[KnightTemplarParent her parents parents]] kill or injure Bob.



** [[NoWomansLand The setting of the story]] [[ValuesDissonance demands it]].

to:

** [[NoWomansLand The setting of the story]] [[ValuesDissonance [[DeliberateValuesDissonance demands it]].
12th Apr '17 3:49:36 AM AgentKyles
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** When Aerith's parents find out that she wants to refuse an ArrangedMarriage, they lock her up in a [[TortureCellar cellar]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starve her]], [[ATasteOfLash whip her]], beat her, wound her, and [[ParentalIncest rape her]] until she either dies or [[TwoPlusTortureEqualsFive changes her mind]].

to:

** When Aerith's parents find out that she wants to refuse an ArrangedMarriage, they lock her up in a [[TortureCellar cellar]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starve her]], [[ATasteOfLash [[ATasteOfTheLash whip her]], beat her, wound her, and [[ParentalIncest rape her]] until she [[OffingTheOffspring either dies dies]] or [[TwoPlusTortureEqualsFive changes her mind]].
7th Apr '17 9:04:46 AM AgentKyles
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** When Aerith's parents find out that she wants to refuse an ArrangedMarriage, they lock her up in a [[TortureCellar cellar]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starve her]], whip her, beat her, wound her, and [[{{Squick}} rape her]] until she either dies or [[TwoPlusTortureEqualsFive changes her mind]].

to:

** When Aerith's parents find out that she wants to refuse an ArrangedMarriage, they lock her up in a [[TortureCellar cellar]], [[DeniedFoodAsPunishment starve her]], [[ATasteOfLash whip her, her]], beat her, wound her, and [[{{Squick}} [[ParentalIncest rape her]] until she either dies or [[TwoPlusTortureEqualsFive changes her mind]].



** Aerith is part of a BigScrewedUpFamily

to:

** Aerith is part of a BigScrewedUpFamilyBigScrewedUpFamily.



* '''Plot Foundation''' (combined with Rule of Drama UpToEleven): Aerith was a cheerful young girl who loved her family. However, she learned the hard way that her feelings are one-sided when she finds herself on the receiving end of an attempt to OffingTheOffspring for dating a boy from a wrong family because they thought it would damage the rep of their family. [[CorneredRattlesnake Desperate for her life]], [[SelfMadeOrphan she kills the parents]] and is soon arrested and sentenced to a long prison term for the CrimeOfSelfDefense. She comes out of the prison a [[BrokenBird bitter, roguish, antisocial shadow of her former persona]]. Now there are (usually) two ways to pick from: a) become [[HadToComeToPrisonToBeACrook a full-on criminal]] with no remorse or pity towards members of their society and a ''massive'' FreudianExcuse; or b) [[MiseryBuildsCharacter overcome her troubles]], mobilize her fellow women to stand up for their rights and grow into [[RebelLeader a head of a rebellion against the ultra-patriarchal society]] that tears it down and sets up a much more just one.

to:

* '''Plot Foundation''' (combined with Rule of Drama UpToEleven): Aerith was a cheerful young girl who loved her family. However, she learned the hard way that her feelings are one-sided when she finds herself on the receiving end of an attempt to OffingTheOffspring for dating a boy from a wrong family because they thought it would damage the rep of their family. [[CorneredRattlesnake Desperate for her life]], [[SelfMadeOrphan she kills the parents]] and is soon arrested and sentenced to a long prison term for the CrimeOfSelfDefense. She comes out of the prison a [[BrokenBird bitter, roguish, antisocial shadow of her former persona]]. Now there are (usually) two ways to pick from: a) become [[HadToComeToPrisonToBeACrook a full-on criminal]] with no remorse or pity towards members of their society and a ''massive'' FreudianExcuse; or b) [[MiseryBuildsCharacter overcome her troubles]], [[MisfitMobilizationMoment mobilize her fellow women women]] to stand up for their rights and grow into [[RebelLeader a head of a rebellion against the ultra-patriarchal society]] that tears it down and sets up a much more just one.
2nd Apr '17 4:32:28 AM AgentKyles
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Aerith is rewarded (not punished) for being involved with Bob.

to:

** Aerith is rewarded (not punished) for being involved with Bob. (See also MyGirlIsASlut.)
11th Feb '17 9:54:35 PM AgentKyles
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Aerith is ConvenientlyAnOrphan and an only child that made it into becoming an adult, so no one is able to mess with her life.

to:

** Aerith is ConvenientlyAnOrphan and [[LonelyRichKid an only child child]] of a rich family that made it into becoming an adult, so no one is able to mess with her life.



** Aerith's parents realize that she is a person, and that she may do things they don't approve of. If religion is the issue, they pray to the PowersThatBe for her forgiveness, and [[BeYourself they accept her as she is]].

to:

** Aerith's parents realize [[KnowWhenToFoldEm realize]] that she is a person, and that she may do things they don't approve of. If religion is the issue, they pray to the PowersThatBe for her forgiveness, and [[BeYourself they accept her as she is]].
11th Feb '17 9:43:49 PM AgentKyles
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Aerith is ConvenientlyAnOrphan and an only child that made it into becoming an adult, so no one is able to mess with her life.
9th Feb '17 9:28:58 AM AgentKyles
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Bob comes to her rescue and he and Aerith fight back against the abuse. [[NiceJobFixingItVillain Their bonds strengthened because of that]].

to:

** Bob comes to her rescue and he and Aerith fight back against the abuse. [[FireForgedFriends Their bonds strengthened]] [[NiceJobFixingItVillain Their bonds strengthened because of that]].
4th Feb '17 5:02:52 AM AgentKyles
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* '''Plot Foundation''' (combined with Rule of Drama UpToEleven): Aerith was a cheerful young girl who loved her family. However, she learned the hard way that her feelings are one-sided when she finds herself on the receiving end of an attempt to OffingTheOffspring for dating a boy from a wrong family because they thought it would damage the rep of their family. [[CorneredRattlesnake Desperate for her life]], [[SelfMadeOrphan she kills the parents]] and is soon arrested and sentenced to a long prison term for the CrimeOfSelfDefense. She comes out of the prison a [[BrokenBird bitter, roguish, antisocial shadow of her former persona]]. Now there are (usually) two ways to pick from: a) become [[HadToComeToPrisonToBeACrook a full-on criminal]] with no remorse or pity towards members of their society and a ''massive'' FreudianExcuse; or b) [[MiseryBuildsTheCharacter overcome her troubles]] and mobilize her fellow women to stand up for their rights and grow into [[RebelLeader a head of a rebellion against the ultra-patriarchal society]] that tears it down and sets up a much more just one.

to:

* '''Plot Foundation''' (combined with Rule of Drama UpToEleven): Aerith was a cheerful young girl who loved her family. However, she learned the hard way that her feelings are one-sided when she finds herself on the receiving end of an attempt to OffingTheOffspring for dating a boy from a wrong family because they thought it would damage the rep of their family. [[CorneredRattlesnake Desperate for her life]], [[SelfMadeOrphan she kills the parents]] and is soon arrested and sentenced to a long prison term for the CrimeOfSelfDefense. She comes out of the prison a [[BrokenBird bitter, roguish, antisocial shadow of her former persona]]. Now there are (usually) two ways to pick from: a) become [[HadToComeToPrisonToBeACrook a full-on criminal]] with no remorse or pity towards members of their society and a ''massive'' FreudianExcuse; or b) [[MiseryBuildsTheCharacter [[MiseryBuildsCharacter overcome her troubles]] and troubles]], mobilize her fellow women to stand up for their rights and grow into [[RebelLeader a head of a rebellion against the ultra-patriarchal society]] that tears it down and sets up a much more just one.
This list shows the last 10 events of 39. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=PlayingWith.HonorRelatedAbuse