Follow TV Tropes

Following

History PlayingWith / ArbitrarySkepticism

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** No matter how many times Bob the paranormal investigator exposes a ScoobyDooHoax, he'll always assume that whatever supernatural being he confronts is real.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Because MagicAIsMagicA, and there are too many types of magic around (and mundane things that just look at first glance as magic), Bob is just being diligent about making damned sure that the "unicorn sighting" is neither a hallucination (mental imbalance or "pink elephant"-related), an imp with illusion magic or an elf with a brand-new drone with hologram projectors being cute.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bob is also a harden and cynical/realist reporter...and despite seeing the likes of dragons, zombies, and even aliens....unicorns and floating islands seems way too much at best...thus rendering a forgotten world to the void of time....thus Bob is fired from his job for being a well-made butthole.

to:

** Bob is also a harden and cynical/realist reporter... and despite seeing the likes of dragons, zombies, and even aliens....aliens... unicorns and floating islands seems way too much at best...best... thus rendering a forgotten world to the void of time....time... thus Bob is fired from his job for being a well-made butthole.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The univorns manipulate Bob to help enforce TheMasquerade.

to:

** The univorns unicorns manipulate Bob to help enforce TheMasquerade.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Alternatively, they use him to help enforce TheMasquarade.

to:

*** Alternatively, they use him ** The univorns manipulate Bob to help enforce TheMasquarade.TheMasquerade.

Added: 166

Changed: 101

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Exploited''': Unicorns can get away with their schemes around Bob, since he won't believe that they're responsible.

to:

* '''Exploited''': '''Exploited''':
**
Unicorns can get away with their schemes around Bob, since he won't believe that they're responsible.responsible.
*** Alternatively, they use him to help enforce TheMasquarade.

Added: 565

Changed: 121

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Defied''': After seeing the impossible once, Bob decides to believe anything he hears as long as it comes from a trustworthy source.

to:

* '''Defied''': '''Defied''':
**
After seeing the impossible once, Bob decides to believe anything he hears as long as it comes from a trustworthy source.source.
** Bob decides to apply a Pascal's Wager approach to the situation, which means that unless he gets absolute proof that what is running around causing mayhem is ''not'' a unicorn (and no, the fact it [[MagicAIsMagicA breaks some rules of what allegedly makes a unicorn]] does not count because it could be that he's in one of those stories where "[[Film/ReturnOfTheLivingDead the movie lied]]") he cannot dismiss the possibility out of hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Just because there's a main page for ArbitrarySkepticism doesn't mean it's possible to go there! Why don't you prove it then?

to:

Just because there's a main page for ArbitrarySkepticism doesn't mean it's possible to go there! Why don't you prove it it, then?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Normally, I would think that Alice should go to therapy for her delusions. But I encountered unicorns and vampires in one day, so I'm not sure what's real anymore."

to:

** "Normally, I would think that Alice should go to therapy for her delusions. But I encountered saw vampires and unicorns and vampires in one day, just yesterday, so I'm not sure what's real anymore."

Added: 284

Changed: 113

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Discussed''': "Just because we've proven several myths have basis in fact (if not literal truth) doesn't mean AllMythsAreTrue."

to:

* '''Discussed''': '''Discussed''':
**
"Just because we've proven several myths have basis in fact (if not literal truth) doesn't mean AllMythsAreTrue.""
** "Normally, I would think that Alice should go to therapy for her delusions. But I encountered unicorns and vampires in one day, so I'm not sure what's real anymore."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Unicorns don't actually have anything to do with magic, so why would one existing automatically prove the other?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bob is in a universe where MagicAIsMagicA and unicorns don't fit in with the rules, such as they are, or at least not the version of the rule that Bob knows.

to:

** Bob is in a universe where MagicAIsMagicA and unicorns don't fit in with the rules, such as they are, or at least not the version of the rule rules that Bob knows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bob is in a universe where MagicAIsMagicA and unicorns don't fit in with the rules, or at least the version Bob knows.

to:

** Bob is in a universe where MagicAIsMagicA and unicorns don't fit in with the rules, such as they are, or at least not the version of the rule that Bob knows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Bob is also a harden and cynical/realist reporter...and despite seeing the likes of dragons, zombies, and even aliens....unicorns and floating islands seems way too much at best...thus rendering a forgotten world to the void of time....thus Bob is fired from his job for being a well-made butthole.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bob is a vampire, but refuses to belive in werewolves.

to:

** Bob is a vampire, but refuses to belive believe in werewolves.

Added: 158

Changed: 239

Removed: 63

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Basic Trope''': A character in a world where strange things happened finds it difficult to believe in another strange thing

to:

'''Basic Trope''': A character in a world where strange things happened happen finds it difficult to believe in another strange thingthing.



** Bob fights against vampires every day, but refuses to believe in aliens.

to:

** Bob fights against vampires every day, but refuses to believe in aliens.



** FlatEarthAtheist - A character refuses to believe in something that appears ''right in front of their very eyes'', that can't be easily dismissed as an illusion.
** Through the episodes of this series, the earth was attacked by aliens, the city had a ZombieApocalypse, Alice becomes a superhero that prevented many disasters, in the Christmas Special, Santa Claus is missing and no one is getting any more presents, the city had a problem with vampires, had a demon invasion, the local zoo had a dragon as an exhibit, gravity stopped working thanks to an evil scientist, Napoleon and his army come to the present by time travel and attack the city, and all these events were witnessed by everyone and shown in the news, but in the newest episode, no one believes Bob's new dog is talking and even laugh at him.
* '''Downplayed''':

to:

** FlatEarthAtheist - A -- a character refuses to believe in something that appears ''right in front of their very eyes'', them'', that can't be easily dismissed as an illusion.
** Through the episodes of this series, the earth was attacked by aliens, {{alien|Invasion}}s, the city had a ZombieApocalypse, Alice becomes a superhero that prevented many disasters, in the [[SavingChristmas Christmas Special, Santa Claus special]], SantaClaus is missing and no one is getting any more presents, the city had a problem with vampires, had a demon invasion, the local zoo had a dragon as an exhibit, gravity stopped working thanks to an evil scientist, Napoleon a MadScientist, UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte and his army come to the present by time travel {{time travel}} and attack the city, and all these events were witnessed by everyone and shown in the news, but in the newest episode, no one nobody believes [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking Bob's new dog is talking talking]] and they even laugh at him.
* '''Downplayed''': '''Downplayed''':



** Bob has proof of magic, and expects the same amount of evidence for unicorns.

to:

** Bob has proof of magic, magic and expects the same amount of evidence for unicorns.



** When all the supernatural events of the previous episodes were witnessed by the population, they made sure to erase the memories of almost everyone.
** Even with all of the crazy stuff Bob has had to deal with on a daily basis, even facing off against dragons, as far as he knows the only kind of alien life mankind has officially encountered is fossilized bacteria.
* '''Inverted''':

to:

** When all the supernatural events of the previous episodes were witnessed by the population, they made sure to [[LaserGuidedAmnesia erase the memories of almost everyone.
everyone]].
** Even with all of the crazy stuff Bob has had to deal with on a daily basis, daily, even facing off against dragons, as far as he knows the only kind of alien life mankind has officially encountered is fossilized bacteria.
* '''Inverted''': '''Inverted''':



* '''Zig Zagged''': Bob doesn't believe unicorns exist just because dragons do, but his bias is because he thinks unicorns are girly and stupid, but he admits he would still disbelieve in the existence of unicorns even if they were [[VideoGame/RobotUnicornAttack awesome robots.]]

to:

* '''Zig Zagged''': '''Zig-Zagged''': Bob doesn't believe unicorns exist just because dragons do, but his bias is because he thinks unicorns are girly and stupid, but he admits he would still disbelieve in the existence of unicorns even if they were [[VideoGame/RobotUnicornAttack awesome robots.]]



* '''Defied''': After seeing the impossible once, Bob decides to believe anything he hears as long as it comes from a trusted source.

to:

* '''Defied''': After seeing the impossible once, Bob decides to believe anything he hears as long as it comes from a trusted trustworthy source.



* '''Plotted A Good Waste''': The author is trying to say that this is present in most or all people to some degree, and uses Bob as an extreme example to make that point.

to:

* '''Plotted A a Good Waste''': The author is trying to say that this is present in most or all people to some degree, and uses Bob as an extreme example to make that point.point.
* '''Implied''': Bob is the only main character who doesn't go after the MonsterOfTheWeek, with Alice saying offhand that he didn't believe it could be there.



%% Optional items, added after Conversed, at your discretion:
%%
%%* '''Implied''': ???
%%* '''Played For Laughs''': ???
%%* '''Played For Drama''': ???

to:

%% Optional %%Optional items, added after Conversed, at your discretion:
%%
%%* '''Implied''': ???
%%* '''Played For for Laughs''': ???
%%* '''Played For for Drama''': ???
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bob and his friends fought aliens in the previous episode, only they witnessed, but his friends are have a little doubt about the recent vampire rumors.

to:

** Bob and his friends fought aliens in the previous episode, only they witnessed, but his friends are have a little doubt about the recent vampire rumors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bob accepts the existence of unicorns, buts doubts that there is anything magical about them.

to:

** Bob accepts the existence of unicorns, buts but doubts that there is anything magical about them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bob uses magic every day, but refuses to believe belive in unicorns.

to:

** Bob uses magic every day, but refuses to believe belive in unicorns.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Even with all of the crazy stuff Bob has had to deal with on a daily basis, even facing off against dragons, as far as he knows the only kind of alien life mankind has officially encountered is fossilized bacteria.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Bob uses magic every day, but refuses to believe belive in unicorns.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bob fights against aliens every day, but refuses to believe in vampires.
** Bob uses magic every day but refuses to believe in unicorns.

to:

** Bob fights against aliens vampires every day, but refuses to believe in vampires.
aliens.
** Bob uses magic every day is a vampire, but refuses to believe belive in unicorns.werewolves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Bob fights against aliens every day, but refuses to believe in vampires.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alice is from a world with magic and refuses to believe that earth never had any magic despite talking to a human with lower magical potential than warda specifically designed against mafic.

to:

** Alice is from a world with magic and refuses to believe that earth never had any magic despite talking to a human with lower magical potential than warda wards specifically designed against mafic.magic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** When presented with evidence of a unicorn in a FantasyKitchenSink world, Bob disagrees with it not out of this trope, but because he's seen unicorns and doesn't think it fits the pattern.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Through the episodes of this series, the earth was attacked by aliens, the city had a ZombieApocalypse, Alice becomes a superhero that prevented many disasters, in the Christmas Special, Santa Claus is missing and no one is getting any more presents, the city is had a problem with vampires, it had a demon invasion, the local zoo is had a dragon as an exhibit, gravity stopped working thanks to an evil scientist, Napoleon and his army come to the present by time travel and attack the city, and all these events were witnessed by everyone and shown in the news, but in the newest episode, no one believes Bob's new dog is talking and even laugh at him.

to:

** Through the episodes of this series, the earth was attacked by aliens, the city had a ZombieApocalypse, Alice becomes a superhero that prevented many disasters, in the Christmas Special, Santa Claus is missing and no one is getting any more presents, the city is had a problem with vampires, it had a demon invasion, the local zoo is had a dragon as an exhibit, gravity stopped working thanks to an evil scientist, Napoleon and his army come to the present by time travel and attack the city, and all these events were witnessed by everyone and shown in the news, but in the newest episode, no one believes Bob's new dog is talking and even laugh at him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In episode 5, the earth was attacked by aliens, in episode 11, the city has a ZombieApocalypse, in episode 13, Alice becomes a superhero that prevented many disasters, in episode 17, the Christmas Special, Santa Claus is missing and no one is getting any more presents, in episode 21, the city is having a problem with vampires, in episode 24, now we have a demon invasion, in episode 27, the local zoo is having a dragon as an exhibit, in episode 31, gravity stops working thanks to an evil scientist, in episode 34, Napoleon and his army come to the present by time travel and attack the city, and all these events were witnessed by everyone and shown in the news, you get the point, but in episode 42, no one believes Bob's new dog is talking.

to:

** In episode 5, Through the episodes of this series, the earth was attacked by aliens, in episode 11, the city has had a ZombieApocalypse, in episode 13, Alice becomes a superhero that prevented many disasters, in episode 17, the Christmas Special, Santa Claus is missing and no one is getting any more presents, in episode 21, the city is having had a problem with vampires, in episode 24, now we have it had a demon invasion, in episode 27, the local zoo is having had a dragon as an exhibit, in episode 31, gravity stops stopped working thanks to an evil scientist, in episode 34, Napoleon and his army come to the present by time travel and attack the city, and all these events were witnessed by everyone and shown in the news, you get the point, but in episode 42, the newest episode, no one believes Bob's new dog is talking.talking and even laugh at him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In episode 5, the earth was attacked by aliens, in episode 11, the city has a ZombieApocalypse, in episode 13, Alice becomes a superhero that prevented many disasters, in episode 17, the Christmas Special, Santa Claus is missing and no one is getting anymore presents, in episode 21, the city is having a problem with vampires, in episode 24, now we have a demon insvasion, in episode 27, the local zoo is having a dragon as an exhibit, in episode 31, gravity stops working thanks to an evil scientist, in episode 34, Napoleon and his army come to the present by time travel and attack the city, and all these events were witnessed by everyone and shown in the news, you get the point, but in episode 42, no one believes Bob's new dog is talking.

to:

** In episode 5, the earth was attacked by aliens, in episode 11, the city has a ZombieApocalypse, in episode 13, Alice becomes a superhero that prevented many disasters, in episode 17, the Christmas Special, Santa Claus is missing and no one is getting anymore any more presents, in episode 21, the city is having a problem with vampires, in episode 24, now we have a demon insvasion, invasion, in episode 27, the local zoo is having a dragon as an exhibit, in episode 31, gravity stops working thanks to an evil scientist, in episode 34, Napoleon and his army come to the present by time travel and attack the city, and all these events were witnessed by everyone and shown in the news, you get the point, but in episode 42, no one believes Bob's new dog is talking.

Top