History NightmareFuel / TwoBestFriendsPlay

* Woolie getting his hand chopped off in [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s0UPlxqu23I&t=0s Life With Baiken]] is PlayedForLaughs, but the prop used to represent Woolie's now severed hand still looks realistic (but caucasian amusingly). Woolie screaming at his now bloody and dismembered arm doesn't help.
* Woolie's [=VaatiVidya=] style ''Franchise/{{Kirby}}'' lore videos, though spawned from a joke, can be genuinely creepy because of his consistent even tone throughout and the way a simple perspective flip can make the saccharine Kirby series into a CosmicHorrorStory. The ending of his video on [[AfterTheEnd Shiver Star]] paints a frightening possibility of [[spoiler: who he thinks the destroyer of Earth and a great deal of Humanity is.]]
-->'''Woolie:''' Snowy and cold, Shiver Star is a winter wonderland- a wonderland full of monsters and... ''[[WhamLine Dark Matter.]]'' (0[[superscript:2]] appears on screen for half a second)
** The Main/{{Spoiler}} warning preceding the lore videos is pretty creepy; It's a clip of the Hyper Zone from ''VideoGame/KirbysDreamLand3'' [[AStormIsComing pulsing ominously]] before the video [[NothingIsScarier suddenly and soundlessly]] [[SmashToBlack smashes to black,]] with the video proper starting seconds later.
** Some of the art for the lore videos can be quite disturbing as well. Special mention goes to the image of [[VideoGame/KirbyStarAllies Morpho Knight]]. Aside from the hellish background it's in, there's something very wrong with its [[NightmareFace "face"]].

* Aside from the ''VideoGame/{{Slender}}'' and the ''Shitstorm of Scariness'' videos, Pat felt this in the ''VideoGame/DeadlyPremonition'' LP when he accidently triggered to Other World to take over, and was soon attacked by a giant dog that was taller than York.

* The two get a bit of a JumpScare in episode 52 of ''VideoGame/DarkSoulsII'' when they are invaded by [[spoiler: Plague Of Gripes]], and after a little while trying to search for him the duo decides to continue on and readies a crossbow to snipe an enemy. Only to find the invader on the other side of the bridge and thanks to lag, it looks like he FlashStep across the bridge towards them.
-->'''Pat:''' That's the scariest thing I've seen in this game!
** Even better is that Woolsworth's head was blocking their view of the other side of the bridge until they went into first person aim, meaning that not only did he appear to flash step directly in front of them, but he just appears from nowhere to start with.
* In ''VideoGame/SonicDreamsCollection'', [[spoiler: a very horrific looking Big The Cat is found inside [[MakesJustAsMuchSenseInContext Rouge's Vagina.]]]] [[https://youtu.be/ciaYKjBxneA?t=3140 Everyone promptly freaks the fuck out, especially Woolie and Matt]].

* It's kind of unsettling when Matt starts screaming in anger, especially in the last minutes of ''Sonic Unleashed''.
* Matt and Pat seem to get legitimately unnerved by how the prologue to ''VideoGame/{{SOMA}}'' takes place in a very accurate portrayal of modern-day Toronto, Canada.

* Woolie plays ''VideoGame/TheBindingOfIsaac: Rebirth'' for the first time, and finds the opening cutscene far too relatable. [[OffingTheOffspring Considering what happens in that cutscene]], [[FridgeHorror it paints a darker light on Woolie's past]].

* During their ''VideoGame/LANoire'' playthrough, Woolie becomes increasingly bothered by the brutality of the murders he witnesses while on the Homicide desk, especially those having to do with the [[SerialKiller Black Dahlia murders]]. He and the other guys make mention about how things like this are what burn cops out, and why they'd never want to be the shoes of an officer investigating or responding to such a crime.

* The UncannyValley NightmareFace that is Pat/Jörmungandr on the title card of their ''VideoGame/GodOfWarPS4'' playthrough.

** Some of the art for the lore videos can be quite disturbing as well. Special mention goes to the image of [[VideoGame/KirbyStarAllies Morpho Knight]]. Aside from the hellish background it's in, there's something [[UncannyValley very wrong]] with its [[NightmareFace "face"]].

** Some of the art for the lore videos can be quite disturbing as well. Special mention goes to the image of [[VideoGame/KirbyStarAllies Morpho Knight]] (pictured above). Aside from the hellish background it's in, there's something [[UncannyValley very wrong]] with its [[NightmareFace "face"]].

[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/diwsrmawsaeu6xe.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:[[spoiler:''"The butterfly was a lurking god..."'']][[note]]Image by [[https://twitter.com/The_M0thman Mothmandraws on Twitter]]. Used with permission.[[/note]]]]

** Some of the art for the lore videos can be quite disturbing as well. Special mention goes to the image of [[VideoGame/KirbyStarAllies Morpho Knight]] (pictured above). Aside from the hellish background it's in, there’s something [[UncannyValley very wrong]] with its [[NightmareFace "face"]].

** The Main/{{Spoiler}} warning preceding the lore videos is pretty creepy; It's a clip of the Hyper Zone from ''VideoGame/KirbysDreamLand3'' [[AStormIsComing pulsing ominously]] before the video [[NothingIsScarier suddenly and soundlessly]] [[SmashToBlack smashes to black,]] with the video proper starting seconds later.

* The opening to the Ultimate Marvel vs Capcom 3 Fisticuffs begins with Liam arriving to Woolie's apartment, with most of the lights turned off. When he enters the game room, he finds Woolie sitting there with what looks like a makeshift ceremonial altar with a quilt over his head to mimic a cultist robe. When Liam elects to wait for Matt and Pat, he calmly urges him to stay. As Liam begins backing away, all pretense of sanity fades for a brief moment.

** Even better is that Woolsworth's head was blocking their view of the other side of the bridge until they went into first person aim, meaning that not only did he appear to flash step directly in front of them, but he just appears from nowhere to start with

* The opening of the fourth Shitstorm, where Matt and Pat are sitting on a bench in a creepy castle, shellshocked and dripping with blood. [[spoiler: Given the short flashbacks, Matt's bloody axe, and the fact that Woolie's severed head is between them, it's implied that they ''killed'' Woolie, Liam, and Plague.]]

* On the third episode of their Videogame/{{Undertale}} playthrough, Matt and Liam decide to reset the game to go for a no-kill run. The video has a cold opening in which Flowey directly addresses Matt. He mocks Matt for having being a murderer and having to restart. Then Flowey confronts [[TheFourthWallWillNotProtectYou the viewer]]. Flowey berates them for watching Matt and Liam suffer for their amusement because they [[DirtyCoward don't want to get their hands dirty]]. Given the game they're playing, the whole scene is unsettling yet fitting.
* It's kind of unsettling when Matt starts screaming in anger, especially in the last minutes of Sonic Unleashed.

* In part 28 of Omikron, the game became so stressful that, at one point, Woolie and Pat start ''screaming'' at each other. No, it's not PlayedForLaughs; they genuinely get super pissed at each other (for context, they were trying to figure out how to open the door. They kept giving each conflicting information). While they thankfully do make up and apologize, it's still very chilling to hear them be at each other's throat, while poor Matt is confused and little scared at what's happening.

* During one of the Podcasts, Woolie relates a story from when he was a boy visiting his relatives in Grenada. One evening, he was in his relative's home, when he went into another room by himself. When he did, he walked in on a shirtless man [[MacheteMayhem wielding a machete]] in the middle of a burglary. When the burglar noticed Woolie, he threatened him with "I'm coming back", before escaping out the window. While Woolie and the boys [[PlayedForLaughs play it for laughs]], its pretty clear that young Woolie was terrified.

* [[https://youtu.be/iVnzhISq0oY?t=1320 Woolie's monologue]] about ''Series/ReBootTheGuardianCode'', where he likens the characters to five bloated whale corpses ready to explode with bacterias and doom nearby villages, withe footage of it too to drive the point home.

* Woolie's [=VaatiVidya=] style Franchise/{{Kirby}} lore videos, though spawned from a joke, can be genuinely creepy because of his consistent even tone throughout and the way a simple perspective flip can make the saccharine Kirby series into a CosmicHorrorStory. The ending of his video on [[AfterTheEnd Shiver Star]] paints a frightening possibility of [[spoiler: who he thinks the destroyer of Earth and a great deal of Humanity is.]]

** The ending, for all it's silliness, is kinda scary too. First someone gets, presumably, killed by Zach. Then we see Matt and Pat in a ''disturbing'' art style sitting around a table with Woolie's head on a plate and presumably the rest of him on the others as Pat holds a chunk of flesh in his hand. The camera then zooms in on Pat uttering the "Welcome to the Family Son." line with his mouth animated through SynchroVox.

-->'''Woolie:''' Snowy and cold, Shiver Star is a winter wonderland- a wonderland full of monsters and... ''[[WhamLine Dark Matter.]]'' (0[[superscript:2]] appears on screen for half a second)

-->'''Woolie:''' Snowy and cold, Shiver Star is a winter wonderland- a wonderland full of monsters and... ''[[WhamLine Dark Matter.]]'' [[spoiler: (0[[superscript:2]] appears on screen for half a second)]]

-->'''Woolie:''' Snowy and cold, Shiver Star is a winter wonderland- a wonderland full of monsters and... [[spoiler: ''[[WhamLine Dark Matter.]]'' (0[[superscript:2]] appears on screen for half a second)]]

* Woolie getting his hand chopped off in [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s0UPlxqu23I&t=0s Life With Baiken]] is PlayedForLaughs, but the prop used to represent Woolie's now severed hand still looks realistic (but caucasian amusingly). Woolie screaming at his now bloody and dismembered arm doesn't help.

* Woolie getting his hand chopped off in [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s0UPlxqu23I&t=0s Life With Baiken]] is PlayedForLaughs, but the prop used to represent Woolie's now severed hand still looks realistic. Woolie screaming at his now bloody and dismembered arm doesn't help.

* Woolie getting his hand chopped off in [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s0UPlxqu23I&t=0s Life With Baiken]] is PlayedForLaughs, but the prop used to represent Woolie's now severed arm still looks realistic. Woolie screaming at his now bloody and dismembered arm doesn't help.

* The UncannyValley NightmareFace that is Pat/Jörmungandr on the title card of their ''VideoGame/GodOfWarPS4'' playthrough.

* While Pat advocating and openly enjoying being evil in games with a KarmaMeter is nothing new, his sheer, borderline-orgasmic joy over going full Dark Side in ''Knights of the Old Republic'' is rather unsettling. In particular, his reaction to [[spoiler:Pockets cementing her fall to the Dark Side by slaughtering her Light Side companions]] can only be described as "maniacal, orgasmic ecstasy". Even Woolie, who had been loving the ComedicSociopathy of the Dark Side playthrough, is starting to get unnerved by just how into it Pat has become.

* [[https://youtu.be/iVnzhISq0oY?t=1320 Woolie's monologue]] about ''Series/ReBootTheGuardianCode'', where he likens the characters to five bloated whale corpses ready to explode with bacterias and doom nearby villages, withe footage of it too to drive the point home.