History NightmareFuel / Homestuck

* Gamzee's ancestor, Kurloz, chewed out his own tongue and sewed his lips shut as part of a vow of silence to keep Lord English's secrets.

** Betty Crocker's ads may be more fundamental to this timeline than just words. Consider for a minute what we appear to know about [[SubliminalSeduction Jane]], [[AmbiguouslyGay Dirk]], [[PosthumousCharacter Jake]] and [[BottleFairy Roxy]].

* A dreambubble and all the souls within - all the dead dreamselves and doomed timeline offshoots like the Beta-timeline John and felt Dave, and the godtier trolls that aren't Vriska and Aradia - have been obliterated, along with an unknown amount horrorterrors and possibly some of the very fabric of paradox space itself. All by Lord English himself with one single mouth-beam. No one is safe.

*** It's arguably even worse than that. Jack doesn't look shocked. He looks terrified. In addition, the destruction is so bad that even PM sets aside her [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge Roaring Rampage of Revenge]] at least long enough to share a glance with him.

* Doc Scratch's first and only message to Karkat is ParanoiaFuel incarnate: Don't turn your back on the body.

* Karkat finally gets in touch with [[TheStoner Gamzee]] only to learn that [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=005258 the chillest motherfuckin troll has FLIPPED HIS MOTHERFUCKIN SHIT.]]

* Although Terezi crying over Tavros is [[TearJerker sad enough]], [[ItGotWorse it gets worse]]. [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=005263 That little purple text at the bottom of the page....]]

* Gamzee reacts to [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=005350 Nepeta's attack]] by [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=005353 snatching her out of the air, breaking her wrist,]] and [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=005354 slowly]] [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=005355 dragging]] [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=005356 her claws]] ''across his own face. While grinning maniacally.''

* The Homestuck Album, [[http://homestuck.bandcamp.com/ Alterniabound]], while undeniably [[CrowningMusicOfAwesome awesome]], has managed to make the song [[NightmareFuel "Blackest Heart"]] even more disturbing and creepy than it originally was. What did they do? Added a dissonant symphony of honks and a [[HellIsThatNoise deep, warped voice]] snarling out the word "miracles" OVER AND OVER AND OVER. Sweet dreams, kids.

* From practically the start of Act 6 Act 3, he's already on Jane's planet. In the God Tiers. ''Selling the blood of his friends to her.''
** And the worst part? He actually filled the fridge he was standing on with something. Do you know what he stuffed it with? ''The dead bodies of Tavros and Vriska.'' Then ItGotWorse when he decided to ''prototype'' them '''''RIGHT IN FRONT OF A HORRIFIED JANE!''''' [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=006734 And the results are just as horrifying as you'd expect.]] [[hottip:*:[[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=006737 Fortunately not permanent, though.]]

* This [[http://mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=007010 page]] implies that Gamzee is omitting mentions of him and [[EldritchAbomination Lord English]] using ''Equius' blood.''

* Terezi's behavior in her live-action role playing is pretty chilling. She casually knifes one of the toys she claims to be her friends, and has hung dozens more of them out her windows and around her hive. Worse is that, apparently, that's pretty much how the ''real'' Alternian law enforcement system works.
* Tavros eventually gets robotic legs that let him walk! And to get them, he just needed to have his legs ''chainsawed off without anasthetic,'' ''while he was asleep''. And with the would-be builder of said legs just standing there and watching... from [[ScaryShinyGlasses what's been shown]], that's potentially even creepier.
* As of these updates from [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=004074 here]] on, ''Vriska.'' What's scarier than setting up an [[UnwinnableByDesign unwinnable game]] of extreme live-action roleplay, taunting Tavros for not being able to get out of her constructed death trap, then using mind control to brainwash him into ''jumping off a cliff to his doom,'' all the while [[EvilLaugh laughing maniacally?]]

* Feferi's lusus eats other lusii. Her voice itself kills trolls and if she ever preformed her "Vast Glub", every troll below Feferi on the hemospectrum would die. ''She does.''

* Eridan and Vriska [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=004360 reminisce about their FLARPing days.]] What makes it terrifying? The fact that Vriska is [[PsychicAssistedSuicide using mind-control to force trolls to commit suicide]], just like she did to Tavros, ''over and over again''. We've been told that she's a serial killer before, but this is the first time the full impact of it hits you. [[NothingIsScarier Not to mention the fact that the entire scene is in silhouette.]]
* Vriska at the beginning of [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=004478 [S] Make her pay.]] She's missing an eye and an arm, the stump for said arm is ''visibly dripping blood'', and she is ''pissed the fuck off''.
** And then Aradia actually ''kills'' Vriska later.

* Kanaya was a big fan of 'rainbow drinkers.' When Terezi found Feferi's body, she also found two new wounds in her neck... ''fang marks''. And Kanaya's body is gone. OhCrap.

** [[http://mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=005507 THE DEMONIC CLOWN.]]

* All of [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=005647 Mindfang's trial]], where she uses her mind control powers to get the audience to ''lynch'' Redglare.

* Everything that's wrong with troll society--''Lord English and his minions were responsible for it.''

** [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=006713 Hussie is dead.]] ''[[TheFourthWallWillNotProtectYou No one]] [[ParanoiaFuel is safe.]]''
* A dreambubble and all the souls within - all the dead dreamselves and doomed timeline offshoots like the Beta-timeline John and felt Dave, and the godtier trolls that aren't Vriska and Aradia - have been obliterated, along with an unknown amount horrorterrors and possibly some of the very fabric of paradox space itself. All by ''Lord English himself with one single mouth-beam.'' ''NO ONE. IS. SAFE.''

*** It's arguably even worse than that. Jack doesn't look shocked. He looks ''terrified''. In addition, the destruction is so bad that even PM sets aside her [[RoaringRampageOfRevenge Roaring Rampage of Revenge]] at least long enough to share a glance with him.

* When Jane checks her instant messenger, [=BettyBother=], which spams her desktop with Betty Crocker ads. Each of them flashes for a split second, each of them saying things like [[SubliminalSeduction 'OBEY', 'CEASE REPRODUCTION', 'SUBMIT', 'STAY ASLEEP', and 'CONSUME']]. God, Jane, what the hell ''is'' this program?!

* Not only Jake share a last name with Lord English, there's [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=006036 hints of him]] ''everywhere.''
** Then there was [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=006038 THIS]] lovely change. The readers have all known for a while now, but the ever-present threat of it is so paranoia-inducing.
* The B2 World in general has been super creepy. Nothing has happened, everything's happy... but there's something VERY WRONG just under the surface. The biggest source of anxiety is waiting for the other shoe to drop, so to speak. When's it gonna happen? When's the shit gonna hit the fan? When is the warm comfortable blanket of lies going to be ripped aside for this innocent girl, exposing her to the mind-shattering horror of reality? Hussie is proving himself an absolute ''master'' of DramaticIrony.

* [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=006102 John's corpse is stuffed and in front of the fireplace]]. Sure, other dead people got the treatment as well, but this is ''John.'' An alternate reality John, but John all the same.
** And then [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=006105 Jane accidentally tears his arm off]], then later he's decapitated by the bunny Bro built for Jane. And it wasn't so much the fact that his stuffed body is getting more and more mutilated that's creepy. What ''is'' creepy is just how the actual decapitation plays out. At first, Poppop's body just simply begins to shake slightly, which isn't too creepy. Then his neck bulges up and outward, his head now slightly lopsided. ''Then'', the bunny's blade emerges from his neck, and he manages to take it off with one clean slice! To top it off, the thing was actually ''sleeping inside of his body''.
** Add in the realization that he is now missing one arm, and has a slice/scar going vertically across his eye... ''the exact same mutilated features as B1's harlequin''.

* Jane is about to get the mail when it ''explodes in her face''. [[AdultFear While her father was watching.]]
* As awesome as [S] Prince of Heart: Rise Up is, the shot where Brobot punches Jake and his glasses go flying is ''freaky''. Not only do his glasses fly off, but his ''eyes'' too, giving Jake an EyelessFace! It's a humorous LampshadeHanging of EyeGlasses, but the creepy factor is still there.
* The A-R's line in [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=006476 this]] pester log is just ''unsettling''.

* Absolutely everything about the Land of Crypts and Helium. It used to be lush and filled with consorts... until their holy writings suddenly changed to reflect that their heroes would all sacrifice themselves and their "lights would be snuffed out" save for one, after which the Salamanders stopped farming and instead started ''digging their own graves''.

* Everything about the Earth after the Batterwitch takes over. She tries to make human society more like troll society, in the process wreaking havoc so devastating that ''Dirk and Roxy are the only humans left alive''.
* The B2 incarnation of Rose kills [[ItMakesSenseInContext Guy Fieri]] by ''[[EyeScream stabbing him in the eyes with knitting needles]]''. She then rides his body down a waterfall of blood.

*** It's [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=007041 already]] [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=007083 started]]. Not even PlotArmor will save you. '''No-one''' can escape the Miles.

* Something has gone ''[[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?game=save&s=6&p=006882 badly wrong]]'' with Skaia in uu and UU's session. It looks ''dead''...

* The general appearance of a cherub is mildly unsettling. Even a friendly character like Calliope can come off as a little disturbing, especially when you compare her with ''Lord English''.

* The first time Calliope appeared on screen, this troper was rather shocked, but eventually got used to her appearance. The first full look at an awake Caliborn's face was ''still'' scary. That puts things in perspective.

*** Oh, did he gnaw it off? Because it looked to this troper like he just bit into it, '''then ripped it clean in half.''' '''''With his teeth.''''' Holy. Jegus.

* There's a good reason why Lil' Cal is the header picture for the DemonicDummy page, ''and'' used to also be on the [[NightmareFuel/{{Webcomics}} Webcomics sub-page]] of NightmareFuel. As one person on the forums described, marionettes are already creepy, firmly in the UncannyValley. Lil' Cal lives in the ''Uncanny Laurentian Abyss'' ([[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/scraps/cal_gamebro.gif animated GIF link for reference]]). Hussie took this to eleven by making Lord English basically a giant demonic Cal.

* [S]: Wake. Feferi and Nepeta's dream selves are hacked apart by Bec Noir at the beginning, and at the end, Vriska goes over to Tavros, grabs his lance, IMPALES HIM THROUGH THE HEART and drops him off a balcony.

** The black ''thing'' following her in the intro, and the increasing corpses of the Prospitians and Dersites.
** Rose's reaction to her mother's corpse--namely, that she ''doesn't react at all.''

*** If you listen closely, it actually sounds like someone choking or screaming. We could have been hearing the demise of the ''Sufferer'' or Equius being '''strangled''' to death.
* The last two tracks on "The Wanderers." ''What A Daring Dream'' has eerie whispering voices that seem to be quoting the Morse code from WV's nightmare and ''Nightmare''...well, [[{{ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin}} it's called "Nightmare" for a reason.]]
* The whole idea of Sburb: The fact that a seemingly harmless game can basically ruin your entire perception of the universe, religion, and the laws of physics while simultaneously destroying everything and ''everyone'' you love on your home planet. And there's absolutely ''nothing you can do about it'' but keep trudging on.

* Courtyard Droll killed Jake's dreamself by feeding him [[PlotAllergy peanuts in his sleep]]. He's the ''least'' competent of the Crew, wears a giant, silly hat, and is still able to sneak into Jake's tower and murder him.

* Remember when Calsprite was laughing his ass off at Dave near the middle of Act 4? Well, the good folks over at [[http://www.youtube.com/user/HomestuckColab?feature=watch Let's Read Homestuck]] replicated this using - [[TheLongList are you ready]]? '''A mixture of Heaven Smile from Killer 7, Laugh from the beginning of Feel Good Inc., Gruntilda from Banjo Kazooie, Tidus from Final Fantasy X, Woody the Woodpecker, Joker (Hamill), Joker (Ledger), Joker (Romero), Joker (Nicholson) or the laughing box at the end of '89 batman, Mandark from Dexter's Lab, Jack Spicer from Xiaolin Showdown, and Kefka from Final Fantasy VI.''' Oh, and as if that wasn't enough, they then ''[[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FddbkYIxcNw&feature=plcp looped it for a whole hour]]''. Good luck sleeping tonight.

*** If you listen closely, it actually sounds like [[spoiler: someone choking or screaming.]] We could have been hearing [[spoiler: the demise of the ''Sufferer'' or Equius being '''strangled''' to death.]]

* Feferi's lusus is a literal CosmicHorror that eats other lusii. Her voice itself kills trolls and if she ever preformed her "Vast Glub", every troll below Feferi on the hemospectrum would die. ''She does.''

** Before Rose finds John, she walks by a few survivors, most of them in a room (and one hiding by himself next to a pillar). After you retrieve him and go back, all of them are dead...

* The first time Calliope appeared on screen, this troper was rather shocked, but eventually got used to her appearance. The first full look at an awake Caliborn's face was ''still'' scary.
** Oh, you thought Caliborn was scary before? His [[TheReveal Reveal]] puts it UpToEleven. He doesn't follow up his previous {{Saw}} references by cutting off his leg. He [[AnArmAndALeg GNAWS it off]], crudely fitting a robot leg on the fresh wound and spitting out the tooth that's in the same position as LE's golden tooth. Then, we see a familiar object-duality weapon: LE's cane-gun, except in black. Finally, because his Cruxtruder apparently releases both his and Calliope's kernelsprites at the same time, their combination creates a black hole that sucks in his planet and the meteor before it could enter the game, and all he can do the whole time is grin or smug in glee and contentedness. Oh, and not to mention THAT THE RED SUN AND THE AFOREMENTIONED BLACK HOLE TOGETHER LOOK LIKE FUCKING [[{{Earthbound}} GIYGAS]]!?

* Oh, you thought undyingUmbrage, now Caliborn was scary before? His [[TheReveal Reveal]] puts it UpToEleven. He doesn't follow up his previous {{Saw}} references by cutting off his leg. He [[AnArmAndALeg GNAWS it off]], crudely fitting a robot leg on the fresh wound and spitting out the tooth that's in the same position as LE's golden tooth. Then, we see a familiar object-duality weapon: LE's cane-gun, except in black. Finally, because his Cruxtruder apparently releases both his and Calliope's kernelsprites at the same time, their combination creates a black hole that sucks in his planet and the meteor before it could enter the game, and all he can do the whole time is grin or smug in glee and contentedness. Oh, and not to mention THAT THE RED SUN AND THE AFOREMENTIONED BLACK HOLE TOGETHER LOOK LIKE FUCKING [[{{Earthbound}} GIYGAS]]!?

* A dreambubble and all the souls within - all the dead dreamselves and doomed timeline offshoots like the Beta-timeline John and felt Dave, and the godtier trolls that aren't Vriska and Aradia - have been obliterated, along with an unknown amount horrorterrors and possibly some of the very fabric of paradox space itself. All by ''Lord English himself with one single mouth-beam.'' ''[[BeyondTheImpossible NO ONE. IS. SAFE.]]''

> PERUSE BAD DREAM CATALYSTS

* How about [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=006992 UU fearing she may never wake up until someone else calls her brother by her name?]] To experience an involuntary DeepSleep while someone plays GrandTheftMe with your body? Yeah, that counts as Paranoia Fuel, but it's made worse by how the audience has not seen yet how the BodySurf works. Chances are TheReveal will be [[TemptingFate terrifying]] [[NothingIsScarier to]] [[BodyHorror watch.]]

* A dreambubble and all the souls - all the dead dreamselves and doomed timeline offshoots - within have been obliterated, along with an unknown amount horrorterrors and possibly some of the very fabric of paradox space itself. ''[[BeyondTheImpossible NO ONE. IS. SAFE.]]''

** The final dreambubble and all the souls within have been obliterated, along with at least a few horrorterrors, possibly some of the very fabric of paradox space, and [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking Dave's shades]]. ''[[BeyondTheImpossible NO ONE. IS. SAFE.]]''
*** [[EvenEvilHasStandards When even]] [[OmnicidalManiac Jack]] [[EvenEvilHasStandards is shocked by destruction that wide scale]], you know there's a problem.

* Oh, you thought Caliborn was scary before? His [[TheReveal Reveal]] puts it UpToEleven. He doesn't follow up his previous {{Saw}} references by cutting off his leg. He [[AnArmAndALeg GNAWS it off]], crudely fitting a robot leg on the fresh wound and spitting out the tooth that's in the same position as LE's golden tooth. Then, we see a familiar object-duality weapon: LE's cane-gun, except in black. Finally, because his Cruxtruder apparently releases both his and Calliope's kernelsprites at the same time, their combination creates a black hole that sucks in his planet and the meteor before it could enter the game, and all he can do the whole time is grin or smug in glee and contentedness. Oh, and not to mention LORD ENGLISH IS DESTROYING THE FINAL DREAMBUBBLE, ITS INHABITANTS, AND THE FABRIC OF PARADOX SPACE THE WHOLE TIME, AND THAT THE RED SUN AND THE AFOREMENTIONED BLACK HOLE TOGETHER LOOK LIKE FUCKING [[{{Earthbound}} GIYGAS]]!?

* Oh, you thought Caliborn was scary before? His [[TheReveal Reveal]] puts it UpToEleven. He doesn't follow up his previous {{Saw}} references by cutting off his leg. He [[AnArmAndALeg KNAWS it off]], crudely fitting a robot leg on the fresh wound and spitting out the tooth that's in the same position as LE's golden tooth. Then, we see a familiar object-duality weapon: LE's cane-gun, except in black. Finally, because his Cruxtruder apparently releases both his and Calliope's kernelsprites at the same time, their combination creates a black hole that sucks in his planet and the meteor before it could enter the game, and all he can do the whole time is grin or smug in glee and contentedness. Oh, and not to mention LORD ENGLISH IS DESTROYING THE FINAL DREAMBUBBLE, ITS INHABITANTS, AND THE FABRIC OF PARADOX SPACE THE WHOLE TIME, AND THAT THE RED SUN AND THE AFOREMENTIONED BLACK HOLE TOGETHER LOOK LIKE FUCKING [[{{Earthbound}} GIYGAS]]!?

* Oh, you thought Caliborn was scary before? His [[TheReveal Reveal]] puts it UpToEleven. He doesn't follow up his previous {{Saw}} references by cutting off his leg. He [[AnArmAndALeg KNAWS it off]], crudely fitting a robot leg on the fresh wound and spitting out the tooth that's in the same position as LE's golden tooth. Then, we see a familiar object-duality weapon: LE's cane-gun, except in black. Finally, because his Cruxtruder apparently releases both his and Calliope's kernelsprites at the same time, their combination creates a black hole that sucks in his planet and the meteor before it could enter the game, and all he can do the whole time is grin or smug in glee and contentedness. Oh, and not to mention LORD ENGLISH IS DESTROYING THE FINAL DREAMBUBBLE, ITS INHABITANTS, AND THE FABRIC OF PARADOX SPACE THE WHOLE TIME, AND THAT THE RED SUN AND THE AFOREMENTIONED BLACK HOLE TOGETHER LOOK LIKE FUCKING [[Earthbound GIYGAS]]!?

* Oh, you thought Caliborn was scary before? His [[TheReveal Reveal]] puts it UpToEleven. He doesn't follow up his previous {{Saw}} references by cutting off his leg. He [[AnArmAndALeg KNAWS it off]], crudely fitting a robot leg on the fresh wound and spitting out the tooth that's in the same position as LE's golden tooth. Then, we see a familiar object-duality weapon: LE's cane-gun, except in black. Finally, because his Cruxtruder apparently releases both his and Calliope's kernelsprites at the same time, their combination creates a black hole that sucks in his planet and the meteor before it could enter the game, and all he can do the whole time is grin or smug in glee and contentedness. Oh, and not to mention LORD ENGLISH IS DESTROYING THE FINAL DREAMBUBBLE, ITS INHABITANTS, AND THE FABRIC OF PARADOX SPACE THE WHOLE TIME?

* Soon after Calliope's reveal and a series of updates featuring her getting ready to sleep, we suddenly get uu taunting her by making fun of the B2 kids' apparent deaths/[=KOs=] (which he is watching), drawing pictures of what's supposed to be their dead bodies, and generally laughing at her and the B2 kids. [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=007037 It's much worse than it sounds]] (click on the images left to right for full effect).

* Remember when Calsprite was laughing his ass off at Dave near the middle of Act 4? Well, the good folks over at [[http://www.youtube.com/user/HomestuckColab?feature=watch Let's Read Homestuck]] replicated this using - are you ready? "A mixture of Heaven Smile from Killer 7, Laugh from the beginning of Feel Good Inc., Gruntilda from Banjo Kazooie, Tidus from Final Fantasy X, Woody the Woodpecker, Joker (Hamill), Joker (Ledger), Joker (Romero), Joker (Nicholson) or the laughing box at the end of '89 batman, Mandark from Dexter's Lab, Jack Spicer from Xiaolin Showdown, and Kefka from Final Fantasy VI." Oh, and as if that wasn't enough, they then [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FddbkYIxcNw&feature=plcp looped it for a whole hour]]. Good luck sleeping tonight.

-->[[color:#2b0057: FTC: HONK.]]\\
-->[[color:#626262: CCG: OH GOD OH GOD OH GOD OH GOD OH GOD OH GOD OH GOD]]\\
-->[[color:#2b0057: FTC: i'm in your future, best friend.]]\\
-->[[color:#2b0057: FTC: I KNOW WHERE YOU MOTHERFUCKING ARE.]]\\

* In the act 4 finale, right after Jack started his rampage, there is one moment, just one moment, when he looks absolutely terrifying. [[http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa281/Jiminiminy/127566327117.gif Well hello there.]]

* Spades Slick is still [[http://mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=006567 alive...]] and now he comes equipped with [[http://mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=006575 super-fast robotic stabbin' arms.]] Great. Because what Paradox Space needs is ''another'' super-powered Jack Noir running around.

* [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=006653 Meenah wants to kill Roxy ''just'' for the hell of it.]]
** She also comes ''this'' close to killing John (and the fact that he was pushing Roxy out of the way meant that it would've counted as a heroic, and thus permanent, death).

----> uu: HELLO DIRK.
----> uu: [[{{Saw}} I WANT TO PLAY A GAME.]]

----> uu: NOIR IS THE BEST THERE IS.
---->uu: VERY uSEFuL.
---->uu: VERY STABBY.

** In the above image, look to the right of Prospit. If you look closely enough at the lower half of Skaia, you should be able to notice the clouds resembling a nose, two cheeks, a smile, and two eyes (the left eye would form at the bottom of a white-black cloud curving downward) resembling a HaveANiceDaySmile. What's creepy about it? Either this version of Skaia looks happy to be dying, or that it closely resembles those bloody smiles insane Gamzee had painted while corpse collecting.

* Um, may I please interject here for a second and point out that cherubs have ''[[http://mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=007033 forked tongues.]]''
** Could you explain, dear troper, why that is so nightmare inducing?
*** It's just so dissonant to the rest of her. After you've had a few pages to get used to her green color scheme, that comes right the fuck outta nowhere, and it's just '''so goddamn dissonant.'''

* Jade was flying around going to finally wake up her best friend and the world exploded around her. [[TearJerker And then she died.]]

* Right in the middle of [[http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=007138 Dirk being awesome]], he [[TeleFrag cuts off his own head.]]