Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Narm / STARWARS

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* One of the sequences in the final episode that builds up tension for Maarva's funeral and the various people and groups gathering around it is a short shot of Syril Karn and Linus Mosk sitting stoically on a transport bound for Ferrix City, then wordlessly trading hats without looking at one another. While likely intended to highlight the camaraderie they've developed since losing their jobs at Pre-Mor, it's such a strange and silly gesture that many viewers couldn't help finding it funny rather than tense.

Added: 310

Removed: 266

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Red Leader's horrified scream as Darth Vader shoots him down is undermined by the fact that it looks like he's ''trying not to laugh'' as he does so.
* The mere existence of Porkins. Really, [[Creator/GeorgeLucas George]], that's the name you give to the fat pilot?


Added DiffLines:

* Luke's [[BigNo Big No]] when Obi-Wan dies.
* Red Leader's horrified scream as Darth Vader shoots him down is undermined by the fact that it looks like he's ''trying not to laugh'' as he does so.
* The mere existence of Porkins. Really, [[Creator/GeorgeLucas George]], that's the name you give to the fat pilot?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When Mace Windu disarms Palpatine and tells him that he's lost, Palpatine's NoYou response makes him sound like a petulant toddler.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Obi-Wan sneaks Leia out of an Imperial fortress while he's dressed as an Imperial officer, with her hidden under a stolen coat. The moment is played for drama, despite Obi-Wan trying to pass past a garrison while pretending to be a four-legged officer who hasn't shaved in months. The scene even cuts to a shot of Leia peeking out of his coat, as if [[ViewersAreMorons the show didn’t trust viewers to realize Leia was hiding under there.]]

to:

* Obi-Wan sneaks Leia out of an Imperial fortress while he's dressed as an Imperial officer, with her hidden under a stolen coat. The moment is played for drama, despite Obi-Wan trying to pass past a garrison while pretending to be a four-legged officer who hasn't shaved in months. The scene even cuts to a shot of Leia peeking out of his coat, as if [[ViewersAreMorons the show didn’t trust viewers to realize Leia was hiding under there.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* While briefing the Resistance before the attack on Exegol, Poe says of the Final Order's fleet that "nav can't tell which way is up out there." While it's likely meant to be hyperbole describing the harshness of Exegol's weather and how hard it is for the Star Destroyers to take off, nothing in the movie actually demonstrates this (no other ships have trouble flying in Exegol's atmosphere and Resistance troops even stand on the exterior of a Star Destroyer without facing the slightest bit of turbulence), making it easier to take his claim at face value and assume the Final Order are so inept that they can't tell up from down without assistance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Classically trained Alec Guinness does his best in the sword fight with Vader, but he doesn't really look like a badass Grand Master of the Jedi Order, he looks like a 62 year old man doing a silly spin. Given it's Creator/AlecGuinness... he sells it pretty well, but the special effects and choreography just weren't there in 1977. Given that he was holding a rotating pole with reflective tape on it to create the lightsaber effect, he probably couldn't go full Errol Flynn.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
As noted right on top of the page "similarities to other works" don't count


* Obi-Wan sneaks Leia out of an Imperial fortress while he's dressed as an Imperial officer, with her hidden under a stolen coat. The moment is played for drama, despite Obi-Wan trying to pass past a garrison while pretending to be a four-legged officer who hasn't shaved in months. It can bring to mind the scene from ''[[Film/AustinPowers Austin Powers in Goldmember]]'' where Austin walks on top of Mini-Me's shoulders to infiltrate a submarine. The scene even cuts to a shot of Leia peeking out of his coat, as if [[ViewersAreMorons the show didn’t trust viewers to realize Leia was hiding under there.]]

to:

* Obi-Wan sneaks Leia out of an Imperial fortress while he's dressed as an Imperial officer, with her hidden under a stolen coat. The moment is played for drama, despite Obi-Wan trying to pass past a garrison while pretending to be a four-legged officer who hasn't shaved in months. It can bring to mind the scene from ''[[Film/AustinPowers Austin Powers in Goldmember]]'' where Austin walks on top of Mini-Me's shoulders to infiltrate a submarine. The scene even cuts to a shot of Leia peeking out of his coat, as if [[ViewersAreMorons the show didn’t trust viewers to realize Leia was hiding under there.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the original theatrical release, Obi-Wan scares away the Tusken Raiders from Luke by imitating a krayt dragon with a short, guttural yell. The 2011 Blu-Ray and later releases replace it with a rather goofy echoed "''woooooo!''", rather incongruous with the tone of the scene, sounding less like a creature and more like a guy who's stubbed his toe. Audiences were quick to meme this moment, citing what the voice was trying to resemble, to the point where one person even compared it to Kramer passing a kidney stone in Series/{{Seinfeld}}.

to:

* In the original theatrical release, Obi-Wan scares away the Tusken Raiders from Luke by imitating a krayt dragon with a short, guttural yell. The 2011 Blu-Ray and later releases replace it with a rather goofy echoed "''woooooo!''", rather incongruous with the tone of the scene, sounding less like a creature and more like a guy who's stubbed his toe. Audiences were quick to meme this moment, citing what the voice was trying to resemble, to the point where one person even compared it to Kramer passing a kidney stone in Series/{{Seinfeld}}.''Series/{{Seinfeld}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The initially deleted scene with Jabba was unfortunately forced by outside factors into being pretty laughable. First, the Greedo scene was altered so that the exposition about why Han is on the run could still get across. Some of the dialogue simply transplanted over wholesale, which means we're now quite noticeably getting the same lines twice almost back-to-back ("Even I get boarded sometimes. You think I had a choice?"). Additionally, Jabba was modeled on-set by a regular actor who would've had stop-motion footage superimposed on him; Han repeatedly walks around him during their conversation, which would be physically impossible under the intended circumstances. Thus, when the scene was completed for the Special Edition with CGI, the filmmakers were forced to have Han step on Jabba's tail to his discomfort, which helps destroy the scene's efforts to portray Jabba as a terrifying crime boss that no one wants to be on the bad side of.[[note]](The other thing that hurts the scene in this regard is that Han visibly isn't treating Jabba as a serious threat, mostly because in the script Jabba ''wasn't'' supposed to be a terrifying crime lord with a criminal empire that spanned multiple systems, but rather a SmallNameBigEgo gangster who was still rich enough to make sure Han would be up to his neck in bounty hunters until he was paid off; Jabba's more familiar characterisation wasn't solidified until ''Return fo the Jedi'')[[/note]] However, this can fall under NarmCharm because this shows how Han can be such a bad-ass to the point of stepping on the tail of a crime boss like Jabba.

to:

* The initially deleted scene with Jabba was unfortunately forced by outside factors into being pretty laughable. First, the Greedo scene was altered so that the exposition about why Han is on the run could still get across. Some of the dialogue simply transplanted over wholesale, which means we're now quite noticeably getting the same lines twice almost back-to-back ("Even I get boarded sometimes. You think I had a choice?"). Additionally, Jabba was modeled on-set by a regular actor who would've had stop-motion footage superimposed on him; Han repeatedly walks around him during their conversation, which would be physically impossible under the intended circumstances. Thus, when the scene was completed for the Special Edition with CGI, the filmmakers were forced to have Han step on Jabba's tail to his discomfort, which helps destroy the scene's efforts to portray Jabba as a terrifying crime boss that no one wants to be on the bad side of.[[note]](The other thing that hurts the scene in this regard is that Han visibly isn't treating Jabba as a serious threat, mostly because in the script Jabba ''wasn't'' supposed to be a terrifying crime lord with a criminal empire that spanned multiple systems, but rather a SmallNameBigEgo gangster who was still rich enough to make sure Han would be up to his neck in bounty hunters until he was paid off; Jabba's more familiar characterisation wasn't solidified until ''Return fo of the Jedi'')[[/note]] However, this can fall under NarmCharm because this shows how Han can be such a bad-ass badass to the point of stepping on the tail of a crime boss like Jabba.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* During the end battle between Yoda and Dooku, Yoda screams while jumping. While it's meant to show Yoda exerting himself in the fight, any Internet user today will recognize this as the source for [[VideoGame/LegoStarWars LEGO Yoda's death sound]].

to:

* During the end battle between Yoda and Dooku, Yoda screams while jumping. While it's meant to show Yoda exerting himself in the fight, any Internet user today will recognize it just comes across as a little goofy, especially since this as happens to be the source for [[VideoGame/LegoStarWars LEGO Yoda's death sound]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]
[[folder:''Andor'']]
* While the series did an excellent job at avoiding narm in its first season, a lot of viewers found the bright and colorful [[https://preview.redd.it/arkina-5-boots-v0-dcj2jsekelw91.jpg?width=640&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=5cd6091b66f8013fc9ebff9ea667a68bea90f2a9 protective boots]] that the Narkina 5 prison guards wear to be extremely goofy, given their resemblance to Moon Boots from the 1980s, or snowboarding boots.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "It’s a trap!"

to:

* "It’s "It's a trap!"''trap!''"[[labelnote:Explanation]]Admiral Ackbar's hammy exclamation at the realization that the Rebellion is being [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin led into]] [[CaptainObvious a trap]] by the Empire. [[/labelnote]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* During the end battle between Yoda and Dooku, Yoda screams while jumping. While it's meant to show Yoda exerting himself in the fight, any Internet user today will recognize this as the source for [[VideoGame/LegoStarWars LEGO Yoda's death sound]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This is followed by one of the most awkward utilization of Yoda's StrangeSyntaxSpeaker dialogue in the whole franchise.

to:

** This is followed by one of perhaps the most awkward utilization of Yoda's StrangeSyntaxSpeaker dialogue in the whole franchise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In Part III Obi-Wan struggles with the controls of a large laser gate to turn it off, then opts to shoot the console, deactivating the gate. Only, the subsequent wide shot shows that the gate was only good for stopping large vehicles, and he could have simply walked around it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Darth Maul reveals himself at the end of the film, it’s a shocking moment, until he activates his lightsaber which makes the whole thing quite silly as he’s on a holo call with Qi’ra so him brandishing his weapon while she’s lightyears away looks like a pointless attempt at intimidation.

to:

* When Darth Maul reveals himself at the end of the film, it’s a shocking moment, until he activates his lightsaber which makes the whole thing quite silly silly, as he’s on a holo call with Qi’ra so him brandishing his weapon while she’s lightyears away looks like a pointless attempt at intimidation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Just the fact that Palpatine inadvertently ends up electrocuting with his own force lightning for a '''third''' time really ruins any drama that could be pulled out of the scene. It both makes him look like an incompetent dumbass who can't learn from his past mistakes while simultaneously robbing Rey of any actual agency in defeating him, souls of all the past Jedi be damned.

Added: 178

Changed: 23

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Anakin's infamous tirade about Obi-Wan and killing the Tusken Raiders, including the women and children, which serves as the page image. It's meant as dark {{Foreshadowing}} of Anakin succumbing to the dark side, but the dialogue and Creator/HaydenChristensen's delivery makes it come off as {{Wangst}}y, particularly when he screams "I hate them!" A riff on "The Imperial March" plays to hammer home the not-so-subtle foreshadowing.

to:

* Anakin's infamous tirade about Obi-Wan and killing the Tusken Raiders, including the women and children, which serves as the page image. It's meant as dark {{Foreshadowing}} of Anakin succumbing to the dark side, but the ham-fisted dialogue and Creator/HaydenChristensen's overwrought delivery makes it come off as {{Wangst}}y, particularly when he screams "I hate them!" A riff on "The Imperial March" plays to hammer home the not-so-subtle foreshadowing.


Added DiffLines:

** This is followed by one of the most awkward utilization of Yoda's StrangeSyntaxSpeaker dialogue in the whole franchise.
--->'''Yoda:''' Not if anything to say about it, I have.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, Rose saves Finn's life by...crashing into his ship with hers, in a risky move that could have killed them both. It makes her remark afterward of "I saved you, dummy!" hilarious.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's revealed that Zorii and Babu Frik survived their home planet being blown up - and Babu just rises up in the former's cockpit with his loud, eccentric voice going, "Hey-heeeeyyyy!" It becomes a lot more comedic than triumphant at that moment.

to:

* It's revealed that Zorii and Babu Frik survived their home planet being blown up - and Babu just rises up in the former's cockpit with his loud, eccentric voice going, "Hey-heeeeyyyy!" It becomes a lot more comedic than triumphant at that moment. Made funnier by the knowledge that it wasn't originally there, but after being invited to view the rough cut of the film, Creator/StevenSpielberg was concerned that Babu Frik had died when Kajimi was destroyed, which led to him being haphazardly inserted into that shot to show that he survived.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ochi’s incompetence becomes funnier in hindsight when he is shown to be somewhat of a ButtMonkey in-universe according to the ''Darth Vader (2020)'' comics.

to:

** Ochi’s incompetence becomes funnier in hindsight when he is shown to be somewhat of a ButtMonkey in-universe according to the ''Darth Vader (2020)'' comics. It makes his dagger funnier too - it is so ridiculously specific in how it aligns with a part of the ruins of the Second Death Star that it gives the impression that no matter how many times Ochi took out the Sith Wayfinder from the throne room, he kept ''forgetting'' how to get back there to lock it up again and had to make the dagger that way as a reminder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The opening crawl of the movie starts with "War!" As if it's a huge deal that there's a war in ''Star WARS''.

Added: 391

Changed: 103

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Vd2iA5Tiis A deleted scene]] featured a squad of traitorous clones attempting to pass themselves off as Jedi, but their disguise only consists of cloaks with no attempt whatsoever to hide that they all have the same face. One wonders how the scene got as far as actually being filmed before the writers finally realized this was too silly, especially coming on the heels of a scene as dark as Order 66.

to:

* [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Vd2iA5Tiis A deleted scene]] featured a squad of traitorous clones attempting to pass themselves off as Jedi, but their disguise only consists of cloaks with no attempt whatsoever to hide that they all have the same face. One wonders how the scene got as far as actually being filmed before the writers finally realized this was too silly, especially coming on the heels of a scene as dark as Order 66. Notably the scene made it into ''VideoGame/LEGOStarWars'', a game that was generally silly on purpose.
* During the climactic duel between Anakin and Obi-Wan, there's a moment where the two are in the middle of clashing sabers and, out of nowhere, twirl their lightsabers around for about three seconds before striking each other again. The abruptness with which the moment comes and goes makes it even more comical, especially since the choreography is fairly intense for the rest of the duel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Exclusive to the 1997 Special Edition, Luke’s scream while falling down the shaft falls into this hard. Not only is the scream itself incredibly goofy-sounding due to it being Palpatine’s death scream set to a lower pitch, which isn’t even remotely close to what Luke’s voice actually sounds like, but it was also edited in right after the iconic and incredibly dramatic Luke, I Am Your Father reveal, which means that its comical nature completely ruins the mood and makes Luke’s Driven to Suicide moment hilarious. To his credit, George Lucas seemed to realize how Narmy this was and removed it from the DVD release a few years later despite keeping the other Special Edition changes.

to:

* Exclusive to the 1997 Special Edition, Luke’s scream while falling down the shaft falls into this hard. Not only is the scream itself incredibly goofy-sounding due to it being [[Film/ReturnOfTheJedi Palpatine’s death scream scream]] set to a lower pitch, which isn’t even remotely close to what Luke’s voice actually sounds like, but it was also edited in right after the iconic and incredibly dramatic Luke, I Am Your Father LukeIAmYourFather reveal, which means that its comical nature completely ruins the mood and makes Luke’s Driven to Suicide DrivenToSuicide moment hilarious. To his credit, George Lucas Creator/GeorgeLucas seemed to realize how Narmy this was and removed it from the DVD release a few years later despite keeping the other Special Edition changes.

Added: 699

Changed: 38

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[folder:''The Empire Strikes Back'']]
* Exclusive to the 1997 Special Edition, Luke’s scream while falling down the shaft falls into this hard. Not only is the scream itself incredibly goofy-sounding due to it being Palpatine’s death scream set to a lower pitch, which isn’t even remotely close to what Luke’s voice actually sounds like, but it was also edited in right after the iconic and incredibly dramatic Luke, I Am Your Father reveal, which means that its comical nature completely ruins the mood and makes Luke’s Driven to Suicide moment hilarious. To his credit, George Lucas seemed to realize how Narmy this was and removed it from the DVD release a few years later despite keeping the other Special Edition changes.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:Ladies and gentlemen, the man who will become Darth Vader.]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:Ladies and gentlemen, the man who will become Darth Vader.]]
Vader!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One scene has Jar Jar talking to Queen Amidala and is supposed to sound serious. It doesn't work.
-->'''Jar Jar''': Gungans not dyin without a fight. Weesa warriors, weesa got a grand army.

to:

* One scene has Jar Jar talking to and Queen Amidala and discussing their plans to resist the Trade Federation's invasion of Naboo, which is supposed to sound serious. It doesn't work.
-->'''Jar Jar''': Gungans not dyin dyin' without a fight. Weesa warriors, weesa got a grand army.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[Memes/TheLastJedi "Ben Swolo"]], Kylo Ren's infamous ShirtlessScene where Rey reacts by telling him to PleasePutSomeClothesOn. It's trying to establish Kylo as MrFanservice, but he's standing against a black background, he's wearing black pants with a high waist, and his black hair covers up the sides of his face, which all contribute to making him look like he has a tiny head and a really wide torso.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Both the Greedo scene and the Jabba scene were originally supposed to be in the film; Jabba's line about Han frying Greedo was still in the original version where Jabba was a human


* The initially deleted scene with Jabba was unfortunately forced by outside factors into being pretty laughable. First, the Greedo scene was inserted as a replacement so that the exposition about why Han is on the run could still get across. Some of the dialogue simply transplanted over wholesale, which means we're now quite noticeably getting the same lines twice almost back-to-back ("Even I get boarded sometimes. You think I had a choice?"). Additionally, Jabba was modeled on-set by a regular actor who would've had stop-motion footage superimposed on him; Han repeatedly walks around him during their conversation, which would be physically impossible under the intended circumstances. Thus, when the scene was completed for the Special Edition with CGI, the filmmakers were forced to have Han step on Jabba's tail to his discomfort, which destroys the scene's efforts to portray Jabba as a terrifying crime boss that no one wants to be on the bad side of. However, this can fall under NarmCharm because this shows how Han can be such a bad-ass to the point of stepping on the tail of a crime boss like Jabba.

to:

* The initially deleted scene with Jabba was unfortunately forced by outside factors into being pretty laughable. First, the Greedo scene was inserted as a replacement altered so that the exposition about why Han is on the run could still get across. Some of the dialogue simply transplanted over wholesale, which means we're now quite noticeably getting the same lines twice almost back-to-back ("Even I get boarded sometimes. You think I had a choice?"). Additionally, Jabba was modeled on-set by a regular actor who would've had stop-motion footage superimposed on him; Han repeatedly walks around him during their conversation, which would be physically impossible under the intended circumstances. Thus, when the scene was completed for the Special Edition with CGI, the filmmakers were forced to have Han step on Jabba's tail to his discomfort, which destroys helps destroy the scene's efforts to portray Jabba as a terrifying crime boss that no one wants to be on the bad side of. of.[[note]](The other thing that hurts the scene in this regard is that Han visibly isn't treating Jabba as a serious threat, mostly because in the script Jabba ''wasn't'' supposed to be a terrifying crime lord with a criminal empire that spanned multiple systems, but rather a SmallNameBigEgo gangster who was still rich enough to make sure Han would be up to his neck in bounty hunters until he was paid off; Jabba's more familiar characterisation wasn't solidified until ''Return fo the Jedi'')[[/note]] However, this can fall under NarmCharm because this shows how Han can be such a bad-ass to the point of stepping on the tail of a crime boss like Jabba.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Chairman Chi Cho's [[https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/9/93/Chi_Cho_dead.png/revision/latest?cb=20120928031726 death face]]. It's literally ''impossible'' to take seriously.

to:

* Chairman Chi Cho's [[https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/9/93/Chi_Cho_dead.png/revision/latest?cb=20120928031726 png death face]]. It's literally ''impossible'' to take seriously.

Top