Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Manga / KnightsOfSidonia

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AbortedArc: Doubles as WhatCouldHaveBeen, and AbortedArc. [[Spoiler: A Hinoka sister, Shou is assimilated by the Gauna in the middle of a battle. The plot actually shifts to her perspective, and she’s fully cognizant; possibly making her the first successful human chimera produced by the Gauna, and throwing the door wide open on new possibilities regarding human / Gauna communication. Before we can find out any more, she’s promptly head-shotted by a rail gun and dissipates. This never happens again for the remainder of the plot, and its never explored any further.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HaremComedy: It's not easy for Nagate to navigate between the affections of [[spoiler: a variable gender teammate with ArtificialLimbs, a command officer directly responsible for his MissionControl, and an absolutely adorable and innocent human-Gauna crossbreed the size of his mech. Nearly every other lady in the cast also has her moments.]]

to:

* HaremComedy: It's not easy for Nagate to navigate between the affections of [[spoiler: a variable gender teammate with ArtificialLimbs, a command officer directly responsible for his MissionControl, and an absolutely adorable and innocent human-Gauna crossbreed the size of his mech. Nearly every other lady in the cast also has her moments.]] [[spoiler: ...even the [[FaceFullOfAlienWingWong Gauna]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FaceFullOfAlienWingWong: First, the Gauna gets its copies of humanity correct enough to know that its trying to immitate, but it always gets it wrong in an incredibly disturbing way. Add in an assimilated sexual love interest, and have her reform in the object of her effection’s lap... aaaannnnnd... FaceFullOfAlienWingWong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BiggerStick: The series escalates into an arms race between Sidonia and the Gauna, with some cases, the ‘new stick’ is the only reason the Sidonia survives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the first season, this starts gaining momentum. In the second season, this turns into “...of the episode,” with a new tech debuting for each new battle.
** Justified since Sidnonia is so vulnerable, and the Gaunas change their strategy in every encounter. In some episodes, the series would have just ended, or had to switch to another seed ship if it wasn’t for a newly introduced trump card.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The practical reasons behind Sidonia’s hardships are mostly speculative. However, unless the other seed ships ditched everything that attracted the Gauna to Earth in the first place, its very likely the surviving ships had to take similar measures as Sidonia to just keep their populations going. If that’s the case, then ‘conventional humans’ are probably already extinct by the start of the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also averted. The prosethics are certainly awesome looking, and behave as significant upgrades beyond just their biological counterparts. Also, there isn’t really at point at which a character ‘couldn’t’ get biological replacements at a later time if they choose to. In regards to Lala’s bear body, its arguable she keeps it as a choice, considering the tech is at a level, where consciousness can be transferred to a clone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TechnologyMarchesOn: By a hair’s width. While the piloted mechas aren’t without their benefits, extensive automated technology, such as cheap support drones would help significantly in the Gauna fight. Pilots would still be necessary, but the number of people casualties would be significantly lower.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One possible interpretation is they are sort of child like. They struggle to immitate, yet at the same time their immitations are usually hostile, almost like someone learning fighting tactics and then immediately using them against their teacher in an effort to constantly supplant them as superior. This can be seen throughout season 1, where the first attempt to imitate an individual pilot, then the mechas, followed by a mass with a meteor inside of it, almost as if its trying to imitate Sidonia itself. Each time, they are brought down by desperate tactics.

to:

** One possible interpretation is they are sort of child like. They struggle to immitate, yet at the same time their immitations are usually hostile, almost like someone learning fighting tactics and then immediately using them against their teacher in an effort to constantly supplant them as superior. This can be seen throughout season 1, where the first attempt to imitate an individual pilot, then the mechas, followed by a mass with a meteor inside of it, almost as if its trying to imitate Sidonia itself. Each time, they are brought down by desperate tactics.human tactics used out of desperation. Of the ‘naturally’ produced Gauna capable of interacting, none of them display higher-level thought processes. Its only the chimeras that end up communicative.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** One possible interpretation is they are sort of child like. They struggle to immitate, yet at the same time their immitations are usually hostile, almost like someone learning fighting tactics and then immediately using them against their teacher in an effort to constantly supplant them as superior. This can be seen throughout season 1, where the first attempt to imitate an individual pilot, then the mechas, followed by a mass with a meteor inside of it, almost as if its trying to imitate Sidonia itself. Each time, they are brought down by desperate tactics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In some ways, subverted. None of the characters in the series lived on Earth. There’s maybe less than a minute of dialogue spent on the topic. As far as the series is concerned, the truly relevant timeline begins at the moment all but 300 off Sidonia’s inhabitants were wiped out by Gauna.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That's not what Does This Remind You Of Anything is about.


* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: Take Macross and Battlestar Galactica, add them in a drink mixer and shake. If you loved both of those, then you’ll love this.
** The crew is notably more civil to each other, like Macross.
** The main conflict is as bleak, if not bleaker than Galactica’s.
** The Sidonia crew doesn’t benefit from an enemy that can be negotiated with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The crew is notably more civil to each other, like Macross.
** The main conflict is as bleak, if not bleaker than Galactica’s.
** The Sidonia crew doesn’t benefit from an enemy that can be negotiated with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: Take Macross and Battlestar Galactica, add them in a drink mixer and shake. If you loved both of those, then you’ll love this.

Added: 596

Changed: 17

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Homage}}: The camerawork in a lot of the space battle scenes is pretty blatantly done in the style of ''Series/{{Battlestar Galactica|2003}}''

to:

* {{Homage}}: The camerawork in a lot of the space battle scenes is pretty blatantly done in the style of ''Series/{{Battlestar Galactica|2003}}''Galactica|2003}}'' (to good effect)


Added DiffLines:

* HumanAliens: All the seed ships are essentially mobile civilizations. By the time the series starts, all these ships have lost contact with each other (due to distance) for 100+ years. The crew of Sidonia had to extensively rework to human genome just to keep from being snuffed out entirely. By our real-world human standards, they are already quite alien. Considering the time, distances, and each seed ship having its own R&D, with no unified governing body shared between the ships, if the descendants of any two ships happen to meet again, they might be unrecognizable as the same species.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HolyShitQuotient: Fairly low in the first season of the anime. In Season 2, however, the HSQ skyrockets, to the point where it gets hard to tell if it's actually still the same show.


Added DiffLines:

** In the anime, the Nonoha sisters all have pink hair, and Midorikawa Yuhata has dark green hair.


Added DiffLines:

** In the Season 2 finale, every single Gauna on Lem IX attempts this against Nagate's Tsugumori Mark 2. Samari counters this in a particularly awesome way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Taken to ridiculous levels in one scene in Season 2 of the anime, where Nagate, Tsumugi, Izana and Yuhata are literally watching the {{Manga/Blame}} anime movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** All episodes in the anime have titles that consist of only a single word, such as "Home", "Mission" or "Adrift".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That doesn't even go into how such things as emergency maneuvers can and will override Sidonian gravity, leading to anyone not protected by PlotArmor to go smashing into whatever's in the way at up to five G (gravties, in other words, five times Earth's gravity) acceleration.

to:

** That doesn't even go into how such things as emergency maneuvers can and will override Sidonian gravity, leading to anyone not protected by PlotArmor to go smashing into whatever's in the way at up to five G (gravties, (gravities, in other words, five times Earth's gravity) acceleration.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActionPrologue: The beginning of the anime shows Nagate attacking a Guana, then [[ProsceniumReveal stumbling out of the simulator]] after executing that particularly challenging maneuver.

to:

* ActionPrologue: The beginning of the anime shows Nagate attacking a Guana, Gauna, then [[ProsceniumReveal stumbling out of the simulator]] after executing that particularly challenging maneuver.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigDumbObject: The deep space artifact, a regular triangular pyramid covered in irregular circular holes discovered by the Sidonia many years ago. It's connected to the Gauna somehow, as the Kabi were found inside it, but nothing about it is ever learned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In episode 8 of season 2, there’s a brief scene where Tanikaze, Tsumugi, Yuhata, and Izana are all watching a movie. Then Tsumugi openly wonders what happened to [[{{Anime/Blame}} Killy]] after all that...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EldritchAbomination: The Gauna are massive, shapeshifting fetus-like creatures with the ability to assimilate humans with their CombatTentacles. While their placenta bodies can be injured, Gauna are only able to be killed if their True Bodies are destroyed. Gauna are further capable of replicating human technology, something they become increasingly proficient at after assimilating Hoshijiro.

to:

* EldritchAbomination: The Gauna are massive, shapeshifting fetus-like creatures with the ability to assimilate humans with their CombatTentacles. While their placenta "Ena" bodies can be injured, Gauna are only able to be killed if their True Bodies are destroyed. Gauna are further capable of replicating human technology, something they become increasingly proficient at after assimilating Hoshijiro.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HonorBeforeReason: Kunato never gets over Tanikaze getting the first chance to pilot the Type 17, nor for Tanikaze getting a Gauna kill before he does. This drives Kunato to screw with Tanikaze in a number of ways, most notably [[spoiler: sabotaging Tanikaze in a fight with a Hive-Type Gauna, which results in a number of his squadmates being killed unnecessarily and [[NiceJobBreakingItHero indirectly enabling the creation of the Benisuzume.]]]]

to:

* HonorBeforeReason: Kunato never gets over Tanikaze getting the first chance to pilot the Type 17, nor for Tanikaze getting a Gauna kill before he does. This drives Kunato to screw with Tanikaze in a number of ways, most notably [[spoiler: sabotaging Tanikaze in a fight with a Hive-Type Gauna, which results in a number of his squadmates being killed unnecessarily and [[NiceJobBreakingItHero indirectly enabling the creation of the Benisuzume.Crimson Hawk Moth.]]]]



** The asteroid Gauna's propulsion core needs to be disabled before it can be destroyed, to prevent evasive maneuvers. Ninety percent of it is destroyed...[[spoiler: only for the Crimson Hawkmoth Gauna to break off from the main body and slaughter the squad taking care of it, and the propulsion system quickly regenerates]].

to:

** The asteroid Gauna's propulsion core needs to be disabled before it can be destroyed, to prevent evasive maneuvers. Ninety percent of it is destroyed...[[spoiler: only for the Crimson Hawkmoth Hawk Moth Gauna to break off from the main body and slaughter the squad taking care of it, and the propulsion system quickly regenerates]].



** Much is made of the issue of communication with gauna, but the aforementioned adaptation shows the possible motive for the eldritch beings out of space falling upon and shattering the Earth in the first place. The gauna combine material and act as hive entities, showing communion and learning through shared genetic memory. It should be noted that the growing sophistication and technological equivalence comes as Sidonians are absorbed by gauna, organic Higgs-boson cannon and the Benisuzume being fairly blatant examples.

to:

** Much is made of the issue of communication with gauna, but the aforementioned adaptation shows the possible motive for the eldritch beings out of space falling upon and shattering the Earth in the first place. The gauna combine material and act as hive entities, showing communion and learning through shared genetic memory. It should be noted that the growing sophistication and technological equivalence comes as Sidonians are absorbed by gauna, organic Higgs-boson Heigus cannon and the Benisuzume Crimson Hawk Moth being fairly blatant examples.



* MirrorMatch: The Garde versus Benisuzume, [[spoiler:a replica of a Garde eaten by the Gauna]].

to:

* MirrorMatch: The Garde versus Benisuzume, the Crimson Hawk Moth, [[spoiler:a replica of a Garde eaten by the Gauna]].



* NiceJobBreakingItHero: If Kunato hadn't been so obsessed with his vendetta against Tanikaze, it's likely that [[spoiler: Toshijiro would not have been integrated by the Gauna, which would also mean the Benisuzume wouldn't exist either.]] An unusual example in that Kunato ''knew'' he was breaking it; he just wanted to pin the blame on Tanikaze.

to:

* NiceJobBreakingItHero: If Kunato hadn't been so obsessed with his vendetta against Tanikaze, it's likely that [[spoiler: Toshijiro would not have been integrated by the Gauna, which would also mean the Benisuzume Crimson Hawk Moth wouldn't exist either.]] An unusual example in that Kunato ''knew'' he was breaking it; he just wanted to pin the blame on Tanikaze.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmbiguouslyEvil: The Gauna. No one knows anything about their motives or why they destroyed Earth. On the one hand, they attack relentlessly and kill any human they get hold of. On the other, the fact that they continuously attempt to imitate humans and human technology leads some characters to wonder if they aren't trying to communicate somehow. It's an open question as to whether any of the human copies spawned by Gauna are actually intelligent or if they are just mimicking actions they've observed without any real understanding of what they're doing. [[spoiler:And the giant Mass Union Cluster destroyed in the finale of the story? Despite ''Sidonia'' having spent the entire story fighting against it, its last act as it disintegrated was to seed the planet Lem-VII with its own biomass, which terraformed the whole planet within a few years into a place humanity could live comfortably.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheUriahGambit: The Immortal Council wants Tanikaze dead for reasons not immediately explained and to this end has the Captain order him to fly in every single mission against the Gaunas in the hope that they'll eventually kill him. [[spoiler:This backfires as not only Nagate always survives but he eventually becomes ''Sidonia'''s greatest hero. The reason for this is that [[spoiler:Tanikaze is an immortal and they couldn't tolerate an immortal outside of the committee hierarchy, so as a compromise to outright killing him, the captain agreed to put him on what should have been a suicide mission as a compromise. As long as he keeps succeeding, he can live. Of course once the committee is offed in a coup by the captain, he's no longer required to attend missions but tends to do so anyway due to having become used to being a hero.]]

to:

* TheUriahGambit: The Immortal Council wants Tanikaze dead for reasons not immediately explained and to this end has the Captain order him to fly in every single mission against the Gaunas in the hope that they'll eventually kill him. [[spoiler:This backfires as not only Nagate always survives but he eventually becomes ''Sidonia'''s greatest hero. The reason for this is that [[spoiler:Tanikaze Tanikaze is an immortal and they couldn't tolerate an immortal outside of the committee hierarchy, so as a compromise to outright killing him, the captain agreed to put him on what should have been a suicide mission as a compromise. As long as he keeps succeeding, he can live. Of course once the committee is offed in a coup by the captain, he's no longer required to attend missions but tends to do so anyway due to having become used to being a hero.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding Gendered Outfit

Added DiffLines:

* GenderedOutfit: Played with the cadets and pilots' uniforms. The male ones use trousers, the females the same design but with skirts, and the third gender get to wear shorts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AttackItsWeakPoint: The only weak point on the Gauna is their core, or "True Body", which when sufficiently damaged cause them to explode. Most engagements boil down to the Guardians desperately trying to chip through the Gauna's nigh-invulnerable regenerating armor to reach the weakpoint.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForMassiveDamage: The only weak point on the Gauna is their core, or "True Body", which when sufficiently damaged cause them to explode. Most engagements boil down to the Guardians desperately trying to chip through the Gauna's nigh invulnerable regenerating armor to reach the weakpoint.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
How To Create A Works Page explicitly says "No bolding is used for work titles."


'''''Knights of Sidonia''''' is the latest manga from Creator/TsutomuNihei, creator of ''Manga/{{Blame}}'' and ''{{Manga/Biomega}}''.

to:

'''''Knights ''Knights of Sidonia''''' Sidonia'' is the latest manga from Creator/TsutomuNihei, creator of ''Manga/{{Blame}}'' and ''{{Manga/Biomega}}''.

Top