Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / TrappedBehindEnemyLines

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This is the basis of the "hedgehog" system of defense, which has long roots in siege warfare, but modernized during World War II with the introduction of the possibility of resupply by air. Defending troops would be concentrated at strategic locations that are easily defensible, even if they can also be easily surrounded. Supply would be conducted by air and large numbers of enemy troops would be tied down and exhaust themselves besieging these positions. If done well, this can be very effective--for example, the Demyansk pocket during World War 2. If the defenses cannot hold, they can be a disaster, as the surrounded troops would have nowhere to retreat and are certain to be annihilated--eg. Dien Bien Phu during the French War in Vietnam.

to:

** This is the basis of the "hedgehog" system of defense, which has long roots in siege warfare, but modernized during World War II with the introduction of the possibility of resupply by air. Defending troops would be concentrated at strategic locations that are easily defensible, even if they can also be easily surrounded. Supply would be conducted by air and large numbers of enemy troops would be tied down and exhaust themselves besieging these positions. If done well, this can be very effective--for example, the Demyansk pocket during World War 2. If the defenses cannot hold, they can be a disaster, as the surrounded troops would have nowhere to retreat and are certain to be annihilated--eg. the Germans at Stalingrad and the French at Dien Bien Phu during the French War in Vietnam.

Added: 405

Changed: 140

Removed: 158

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{Battleground}}'' is about American soldiers besieged in Bastogne during the Battle of the Bulge.



* ''Film/TheLostBattalion'' features the eponymous unit of American soldiers surrounded by the Germans in the [[WorldWarI Argonne Forest]].
* The German film ''Film/{{Stalingrad}}'', when the entire German army is cut off and trapped inside Stalingrad by an attack on the flanks. Based on RealLife.



* ''Film/TheLostBattalion'' features the eponymous unit of American soldiers surrounded by the Germans in the [[WorldWarI Argonne Forest]].
* The German film ''Film/{{Stalingrad}}'', when the entire German army is cut off and trapped inside Stalingrad by an attack on the flanks. Based on RealLife.

to:

* ''Film/TheLostBattalion'' features the eponymous unit of American soldiers surrounded by the Germans in the [[WorldWarI Argonne Forest]].
* The German film ''Film/{{Stalingrad}}'', when the entire German army is cut off and trapped inside Stalingrad by an attack on the flanks. Based on RealLife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The British 14th Army under Bill Slim turned this concept into a science. When cut off in its first major battles at Kohima and Imphal, the British forces held out against attack, supplied by airdrop, until the Japanese - who had ''not'' provided for supply - were worn out.

to:

* The British 14th Army under Bill Slim turned this concept into a science. When cut off in its first major battles at Kohima and Imphal, the British forces held out against attack, supplied by airdrop, until the Japanese - who had ''not'' provided for supply - were worn out.out.
* The rescue of Bat 21 Bravo was a somewhat controversial case of this in the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar in which eleven rescue crew members died, two were captured and one ended up being rescued alongside the original pilot. It was worse that this also led to a massive reduction in air support for the South Vietnamese due to the amount of resources that were used to rescue the American.
** This was dramatized into the film Bat 21, itself based on a written dramatization of the same name (the main rescue pilot was a CompositeCharacter).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* An individual version often occurs with [[AbandonShip downed pilots]]. These can be especially problematic as pilots are generally [[ActionSurvivor less well trained at surviving in such scenarios]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The 101st Airborne divions in Bastogne, Belgium during the Battle of the Bulge. Their success at holding the town meant the stifled the German advance because all the important roads in the region went through Bastogne. The defense of the town combined with Patton's attack towards Bastogne from the south were key in defeating the German offensive.

to:

* The 101st Airborne divions and 10th armored divisons in Bastogne, Belgium during the Battle of the Bulge. Their success at holding the town meant the stifled the German advance because all the important roads in the region went through Bastogne.Bastogne. They kept the enemy back until Patton's Third Army broke through German lines to relieve them (note the word "relief" is used because no Bastogne defender will ever say they needed rescuing). The defense of the town combined with Patton's attack towards Bastogne from the south were key in defeating the German offensive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*The 101st Airborne divions in Bastogne, Belgium during the Battle of the Bulge. Their success at holding the town meant the stifled the German advance because all the important roads in the region went through Bastogne. The defense of the town combined with Patton's attack towards Bastogne from the south were key in defeating the German offensive.

Added: 590

Changed: 249

Removed: 590

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added an example and alphabetized the literature section.


* The story of Guan Yu's journey through five passes in ''RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms''.



* Happens in just about every SvenHassel novel, including an obligatory scene where Sven and his colleagues find themselves in the midst of enemy troops and either get mistaken for a special unit (e.g. [[GermanRussians Volga Germans]] or Foreign Legion), or saved by [[CunningLinguist Porta's quick-thinking chatter]].



* At the end of the ''Literature/WingCommander'' novel ''Action Stations'', Max Krueger's ship is shot down over a Kilrathi-held human world during a raid on Kilrathi assets in the area.




to:

* ''Literature/TheReynardCycle'': This happens to Reynard and Hirsent after a particularly disastrous battle in ''The Baron of Maleperduys''. Somewhat ironically, they end up having to fight a group of mercenaries that were originally on their side.
* The story of Guan Yu's journey through five passes in ''RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms''.
* Happens in just about every SvenHassel novel, including an obligatory scene where Sven and his colleagues find themselves in the midst of enemy troops and either get mistaken for a special unit (e.g. [[GermanRussians Volga Germans]] or Foreign Legion), or saved by [[CunningLinguist Porta's quick-thinking chatter]].
* At the end of the ''Literature/WingCommander'' novel ''Action Stations'', Max Krueger's ship is shot down over a Kilrathi-held human world during a raid on Kilrathi assets in the area.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC: Comic Strips]]
* ''ComicStrip/{{Peanuts}}'': During one of Snoopy's many {{Imagine Spot}}s where he's a World War I Flying Ace, he gets trapped behind enemy lines and is rescued by a French girl (really Peppermint Patty).

Added: 204

Changed: 103

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-> “All units must get used to having Japanese parties in the rear and, when this happens, regard not themselves, but the Japanese, as surrounded.”
-->-- Lt. General '''Bill Slim''', 14th Army, Burma, WWII



* The British 14th Army under Bill Slim turned this concept into a science. Slim declared that outflanked British units should regard the Japanese, not themselves, as surrounded. When cut off in its first major battles at Kohima and Imphal, the British forces held out against attack, supplied by airdrop, until the Japanese - who had ''not'' provided for supply - were worn out.

to:

* The British 14th Army under Bill Slim turned this concept into a science. Slim declared that outflanked British units should regard the Japanese, not themselves, as surrounded. When cut off in its first major battles at Kohima and Imphal, the British forces held out against attack, supplied by airdrop, until the Japanese - who had ''not'' provided for supply - were worn out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Russian film ''Film/{{Stalingrad}}'', when the entire German army is cut off and trapped inside Stalingrad by an attack on the flanks. Based on RealLife.

to:

* The Russian German film ''Film/{{Stalingrad}}'', when the entire German army is cut off and trapped inside Stalingrad by an attack on the flanks. Based on RealLife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* To a (somewhat) lesser degree, the airborne landings during the Battle of Normandy. Due to the transport pilots attempting to avoid anti-aircraft fire (or sometimes failing to avoid it), Allied paratroopers were scattered all over the French countryside, lost and confused. The fact that they were able to rally and improvise (and generally cause masive confusion to the Germans trying to figure out just what the equally confused paratroopers were trying to accomplish), led to the military concept of Little Groups of Paratroopers ([=LGOPs=] for short), describing the resulting units as "A bunch of nineteen year olds, poorly supervised, pissed off, armed to the teeth, and vaguely recalling their orders as "Shoot anyone who is dressed differently."" Those troops that managed to link up with Allied forces moving inland from the beaches were able to pass on valuable intel, in addition to delaying German counter-attacks against the beachheads.

to:

* To a (somewhat) lesser degree, the airborne landings during the Battle of Normandy. Due to the transport pilots attempting to avoid anti-aircraft fire (or sometimes failing to avoid it), Allied paratroopers were scattered all over the French countryside, lost and confused. The fact that they were able to rally and improvise (and generally cause masive massive confusion to the Germans trying to figure out just what the equally confused paratroopers were trying to accomplish), led to the military concept of Little Groups of Paratroopers ([=LGOPs=] for short), describing the resulting units as "A bunch of nineteen year olds, poorly supervised, pissed off, armed to the teeth, and vaguely recalling their orders as "Shoot anyone who is dressed differently."" Those troops that managed to link up with Allied forces moving inland from the beaches were able to pass on valuable intel, in addition to delaying German counter-attacks against the beachheads.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The story of Guan Yu's journey through five passes in RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms.

to:

* The story of Guan Yu's journey through five passes in RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms.''RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms''.



* The Polish WW2 series "Czterej pancerni i pies" had this as a recurring plot device. The titular tank crew would find themselves behind enemy lines either because an enemy counterattack managed to cut off their position or because their mission was to move around the enemy and attack them from behind.

to:

* The Polish WW2 series "Czterej ''Czterej pancerni i pies" pies'' had this as a recurring plot device. The titular tank crew would find themselves behind enemy lines either because an enemy counterattack managed to cut off their position or because their mission was to move around the enemy and attack them from behind.



* ''Shadow Company: Left For Dead'' begins with your employer abandoning your mercenary group in the middle of enemy territory after a mission goes awry.

to:

* ''Shadow Company: ''ShadowCompany: Left For Dead'' begins with your employer abandoning your mercenary group in the middle of enemy territory after a mission goes awry.



* Happens quite a bit in the first book of TheSalvationWar, seeing as everyone who dies ends up in {{Hell}}. Leads to the formation of LaResistance, with the odd historical character or twelve joining, no less.

to:

* Happens quite a bit in the first book of TheSalvationWar, ''TheSalvationWar'', seeing as everyone who dies ends up in {{Hell}}. Leads to the formation of LaResistance, with the odd historical character or twelve joining, no less.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Battle of Mogadishu, which was the direct basis of the aforementioned ''BlackHawkDown''.

to:

* The Battle of Mogadishu, which was the direct basis of the aforementioned ''BlackHawkDown''.''Film/BlackHawkDown''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
minor edit - namespace


* The CiaphasCain novel ''Death or Glory'' starts with the titular protagonist and his faithful aide Jurgen [[EscapePod landing]] in the middle of an Ork-infested continent, half a world away from the front lines. [[AccidentalHero In Cain's attempts to find friendly forces to put between himself and danger]], things snowball until he's [[RagtagBunchOfMisfits cobbled together a small army of soldiers, civilians and militia]] cutting its way out from the heart of Orkish territory and turning the tide of the whole war.

to:

* The CiaphasCain Literature/CiaphasCain novel ''Death or Glory'' starts with the titular protagonist and his faithful aide Jurgen [[EscapePod landing]] in the middle of an Ork-infested continent, half a world away from the front lines. [[AccidentalHero In Cain's attempts to find friendly forces to put between himself and danger]], things snowball until he's [[RagtagBunchOfMisfits cobbled together a small army of soldiers, civilians and militia]] cutting its way out from the heart of Orkish territory and turning the tide of the whole war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The Russian film ''Film/{{Stalingrad}}'', when the entire German army is cut off and trapped inside Stalingrad by an attack on the flanks. Based on RealLife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The story of Guan Yu's journey through five passes in TheRomanceOfThreeKingdoms.

to:

* The story of Guan Yu's journey through five passes in TheRomanceOfThreeKingdoms.RomanceOfTheThreeKingdoms.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''Film/TheLostBattalion'' features the eponymous unit of American soldiers surrounded by the Germans in the [[WorldWarI Argonne Forest]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''BehindEnemyLines'' and its sequels.
* ''BlackHawkDown'' - Based on RealLife.

to:

* ''BehindEnemyLines'' ''Film/BehindEnemyLines'' and its sequels.
* ''BlackHawkDown'' ''Film/BlackHawkDown'' - Based on RealLife.



* ''Centurion''
* ''FlightOfTheIntruder'', both the book and the [[Film/FlightOfTheIntruder movie]].

to:

* ''Centurion''
''Film/{{Centurion}}''
* ''FlightOfTheIntruder'', ''Film/FlightOfTheIntruder'', both the book and the [[Film/FlightOfTheIntruder movie]].



* ''TheWildGeese'' (1978) and its remake (2010). In the 1978 version a group of mercenaries is sent to Africa to free a captured rebel leader. After they succeed, their patron cuts a deal with the local government, cancels their transport home and abandons them to their fate.

to:

* ''TheWildGeese'' ''Film/TheWildGeese'' (1978) and its remake (2010). In the 1978 version a group of mercenaries is sent to Africa to free a captured rebel leader. After they succeed, their patron cuts a deal with the local government, cancels their transport home and abandons them to their fate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Mechwarrior 3'', not so much "Behind Enemy Lines" as it is "Stuck on Enemy's Planet".

to:

* ''Mechwarrior ''VideoGame/MechWarrior 3'', not so much "Behind Enemy Lines" as it is "Stuck on Enemy's Planet".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


May lead to a YouAreInCommandNow situation. Usually contains at least some FieldPromotion. YouShallNotPass may be required -- or worse, a LastStand.

to:

May lead to a YouAreInCommandNow situation. Usually contains at least some FieldPromotion. YouShallNotPass may be required -- or worse, a LastStand.
LastStand. If an escape is made, it may be by means of VehicularTurnabout.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The trope probably applies to commando operations in general, as these troops are usually trained to infiltrate behind enemy lines and conduct sabotage intentionally, with the expectation that they may not be extricated easily if at all.

to:

** The trope probably applies to commando operations in general, as these troops are usually trained to infiltrate behind enemy lines and conduct sabotage sabotage--essentially, trapping themselves behind enemy lines intentionally, with the expectation that they may not be extricated easily if at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The trope probably applies to commando operations in general, as these troops are usually trained to infiltrate behind enemy lines and conduct sabotage intentionally, with the expectation that they may not be extricated easily if at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And occasionally nabbing unsuspecting Germans who didn't expect Americans behind their lines. The commander of the German 91st Infantry Division was ambushed and killed by one such group of paratroopers.

to:

** And occasionally nabbing unsuspecting Germans who didn't expect Americans behind their lines. The commander of the German 91st Infantry Division was ambushed and killed by one such group of paratroopers.paratroopers, for example.



** This was the basis of the "hedgehog" system of defense. Defending troops would be concentrayed at strategic locations that are easily defensible, even if they can be easily surrounded. Supply would be conducted by air and large numbers of enemy troops would be tied down and exhaust themselves besieging these positions. If done well, this can be very effective--for example, the Demyansk pocket during World War 2. If the defenses cannot hold, they can be a disaster, as the surrounded troops would have nowhere to retreat--eg. Dienbienphu during the French War in Vietnam.

to:

** This was is the basis of the "hedgehog" system of defense. defense, which has long roots in siege warfare, but modernized during World War II with the introduction of the possibility of resupply by air. Defending troops would be concentrayed concentrated at strategic locations that are easily defensible, even if they can also be easily surrounded. Supply would be conducted by air and large numbers of enemy troops would be tied down and exhaust themselves besieging these positions. If done well, this can be very effective--for example, the Demyansk pocket during World War 2. If the defenses cannot hold, they can be a disaster, as the surrounded troops would have nowhere to retreat--eg. Dienbienphu retreat and are certain to be annihilated--eg. Dien Bien Phu during the French War in Vietnam.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And occasionally nabbing unsuspecting Germans who didn't expect Americans behind their lines. The commander of the German 91st Infantry Division was ambushed and killed by one such group of paratroopers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This was the basis of the "hedgehog" system of defense. Defending troops would be concentrayed at strategic locations that are easily defensible, even if they can be easily surrounded. Supply would be conducted by air and large numbers of enemy troops would be tied down and exhaust themselves besieging these positions. If done well, this can be very effective--for example, the Demyansk pocket during World War 2. If the defenses cannot hold, they can be a disaster, as the surrounded troops would have nowhere to retreat--eg. Dienbienphu during the French War in Vietnam.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:{{Literature}}]

to:

[[AC:{{Literature}}][[AC:{{Literature}}]]

Added: 82

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:{{Literature}}]]

to:

[[AC:{{Literature}}]][[AC:{{Literature}}]
* The story of Guan Yu's journey through five passes in TheRomanceOfThreeKingdoms.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Literature/HonorHarrington's fate after the break-out from the StateSec ship ''Tepes'', at the end of ''In Enemy Hands''. Followed in the next book by probably one of the biggest {{prison break}}s in all of history, fictional or RealLife, escaping with roughly half a million prisoners.

to:

* Literature/HonorHarrington's fate after the break-out from the StateSec ship ''Tepes'', at the end of ''In Enemy Hands''. Followed in the next book by probably one of the biggest {{prison break}}s in all of history, fictional or RealLife, escaping with roughly half a million prisoners.
prisoners and a [[VehicularTurnabout squadron of large warships]].
** This basically takes UpToEleven a similar (but much smaller) exploit of HoratioHornblower (of whom Honor is an {{Expy}}) in ''Flying Colours''. He brought home twenty men and a tiny cutter.

Added: 674

Changed: 39

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Battle of Timor in 1942, in which several hundred survivors of the Australian defense of the island (mostly commandos from the 2/2nd Independent Company) withdrew into the Portuguese colony and held out there, eventually being withdrawn in January 1943 after keeping an entire Japanese ''division'' busy for ten months.

to:

* The Battle of Timor in 1942, in which several hundred survivors of the Australian Dutch/Australian defense of the island (mostly commandos from the 2/2nd Independent Company) withdrew fell back into the Portuguese colony East Timor and held out there, eventually being withdrawn in January 1943 after keeping an entire Japanese ''division'' busy for ten months.months.
** The man who trained the Australian commandos, Freddie Spencer Chapman, was himself trapped behind enemy lines in Malaya for over three years. Like the Australians on Timor, he was presumed dead, but lived out the war with Communist guerrillas and wrote a memoir, ''The Jungle Is Neutral.''
* The British 14th Army under Bill Slim turned this concept into a science. Slim declared that outflanked British units should regard the Japanese, not themselves, as surrounded. When cut off in its first major battles at Kohima and Imphal, the British forces held out against attack, supplied by airdrop, until the Japanese - who had ''not'' provided for supply - were worn out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Several of the Wehrmacht's 'moving pocket' operations on the Russian Front.

to:

* Several of the Wehrmacht's 'moving pocket' operations on the Russian Front.Front.
* The Battle of Timor in 1942, in which several hundred survivors of the Australian defense of the island (mostly commandos from the 2/2nd Independent Company) withdrew into the Portuguese colony and held out there, eventually being withdrawn in January 1943 after keeping an entire Japanese ''division'' busy for ten months.

Top