Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / TheCoverChangesTheGender

Go To

OR

Changed: 212

Removed: 187

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed duplicate entry.


* All of the various "I Kissed A Guy" covers on Website/YouTube.

to:

* All of the various "I Kissed A a Guy" covers on Website/YouTube.



* Music/SoftCell's {{cover|edUp}} of Gloria Jones' "Tainted Love" changes the line "all a girl could give" to "all a boy can give."

to:

* Music/SoftCell's {{cover|edUp}} of Gloria Jones' "Tainted Love" changes was originally sung by Gloria Jones in 1964. [[CoveredUp Due to several popular covers]], such as Music/SoftCell's and Music/MarilynManson's, the song is more often associated with male singers who change the line "all a girl could give" to "all a boy can give."



* "Tainted Love" was originally sung by Gloria Jones in 1964. Due to several popular covers, such as Soft Cell's and Marilyn Manson's, the song is more often associated with male singers.



* Averted by Max Vernon's cover of "I Kissed A Girl": he kept the lyrics, [[TheCoverChangesTheMeaning which changed the meaning of the song]].

to:

* Averted by Max Vernon's cover of "I Kissed A a Girl": he kept the lyrics, [[TheCoverChangesTheMeaning which changed the meaning of the song]].

Added: 928

Changed: 437

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s): Pat Benatar's cover version of "No You Don't" by Sweet


* Overlapping with WhatCouldHaveBeen, Music/PatBenatar's "Hit Me With Your Best Shot" was originally written from a male point of view. When Benatar got the song, only the line "before you put another notch in your lipstick case" had to be switched and became "before I put another notch in my lipstick case". This added the interesting implication that the female singer has a history of warding off suitors and might be a bit of a heartbreaker herself.

to:

* Music/PatBenatar:
** The original version of "No You Don't", as performed by Music/{{Sweet}}[[note]]and written by the record producers/songwriters Nicky Chinn and Mike Chapman[[/note]], contains the lyric "''Well, you think you've got my life in your hands, but I'm a man, I'm a man, and I've got my own plans, I'm a man''". Benatar's cover version (from ''In the Heat of the Night'') changes this to make it non-gender-specific: "[...] ''but you don't understand that I've got my own plans, my own plans''".
**
Overlapping with WhatCouldHaveBeen, Music/PatBenatar's "Hit Me With Your Best Shot" was originally written from a male point of view. When Benatar got the song, only the line "before you put another notch in your lipstick case" had to be switched and became "before I put another notch in my lipstick case". This added the interesting implication that the female singer has a history of warding off suitors and might be a bit of a heartbreaker herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the {{medley}} "Cold Heart" by Music/EltonJohn and Music/DuaLipa, the latter's rendition of the "Rocket Man" chorus retains "I'm not the man they think I am at home", perhaps to highlight their IncompatibleOrientation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* The cover of [[WesternAnimation/{{Hercules}} "Zero To Hero"]] by Music/JonathanYoung and Savannah Stuckmeyer doesn't change the pronouns, which makes sense considering the subject matter is Hercules. What ''is'' hilarious is all the lines where the Muses are DistractedByTheSexy are sung in Young's BassoProfundo.

to:

* The cover of [[WesternAnimation/{{Hercules}} "Zero To Hero"]] by Music/JonathanYoung and Savannah Stuckmeyer doesn't change the pronouns, which makes sense considering the subject matter is Hercules. What ''is'' hilarious is all the lines where the Muses are DistractedByTheSexy are sung in Young's BassoProfundo.[[MediaNotes/VoiceTypes basso profundo]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Maddie Ross' cover of Lustra's "Scotty Doesn't Know" doesn't change the gender of anyone but the singer, meaning that in the context of the song Scotty doesn't know that his girlfriend (Fiona) is cheating on him with a woman. Given that Maddie Ross is engaged to a woman, it's not hard to understand why she'd be comfortable singing a song about sleeping with someone's girlfriend.

to:

* Maddie Ross' cover of Lustra's "Scotty Doesn't Know" doesn't change the gender of anyone but the singer, meaning that in the context of the song Scotty doesn't know that his girlfriend (Fiona) is cheating on him with a woman. Given that Maddie Ross is engaged married to a woman, it's not hard to understand why she'd be comfortable singing a song about sleeping with someone's girlfriend.

Added: 207

Changed: -1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Theatre/MammaMia'' turns "Lay All Your Love On Me", which was sung entirely from a female perspective, into a duet between Sophie and her fiancé Sky. Sky sings the first verse, altered from "Now every woman I see is a potential threat" into "Now every man that I see...".

to:

* ''Theatre/MammaMia'' turns "Lay All Your Love On Me", which was sung entirely from a female perspective, into a duet between Sophie and her fiancé Sky. Sky sings the first verse, altered from "Now every woman I see is a potential threat" into "Now every man that I see..."."
* "Never Can Say Goodbye" was originally written for Music/TheSupremes before it was given to Music/TheJacksonFive, then subsequently covered by Music/GloriaGaynor and Music/TheCommunards, among many others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Music/TheBeatles covered "Boys", originally by girl group The Shirelles. They did change the line "Mama says when you kiss my lips/I'll get a thrill through my fingertips" to "My girl says when I kiss her lips/She gets a thrill through her fingertips", but kept the overall lyrical focus of the song on boys rather than flipping it to be "Girls". Roughly half the song consists of variations on the line "Well, I'm talking about boys".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Music/TheBeatles covered "Boys", originally by girl group The Shirelles. They did change the line "Mama says when you kiss my lips/I'll get a thrill through my fingertips" to "My girl says when I kiss her lips/She gets a thrill through her fingertips", but kept the overall lyrical focus of the song on boys rather than flipping it to be "Girls". Roughly half the song consists of variations on the line "Well, I'm talking about boys".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Strangely done by two Har Mar Superstar songs originally intended for other artists: he wrote "Girls Only" and "Tall Boy" with the intention of giving them to Film/TheCheetahGirls and Music/BritneySpears respectively. When both declined, he put out his own versions without any lyrical changes. The former is about a girls' night out and finds him singing about having "the cutest little cuticles". The latter is ''technically'' about going to a party and drinking "tall boys", as in large cans of beer, but it's [[IntercourseWithYou also full of innuendo]] that could apply to wanting a literal "tall boy" ("where's my tall boy?/ to satisfy my needs/ feel like drinking/ so come on get inside of me").

to:

* Strangely done by two Har Mar Superstar songs originally intended for other artists: he wrote "Girls Only" and "Tall Boy" with the intention of giving them to Film/TheCheetahGirls and Music/BritneySpears respectively. When both declined, he put out his own versions without any lyrical changes. The former is about a girls' night out and finds him singing about having "the cutest little cuticles". The latter is ''technically'' about going to a party and an OdeToIntoxication drinking "tall boys", as in large cans of beer, but it's [[IntercourseWithYou also full of innuendo]] that could apply to wanting a literal "tall boy" ("where's my tall boy?/ to satisfy my needs/ feel like drinking/ so come on get inside of me").

Added: 189

Changed: 115

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


* Music/MichaelBuble's cover of "drivers license" by Music/OliviaRodrigo for Creator/TheBBC Radio 2 Piano Room, the lines "And you're probably with that blonde girl/Who always made me doubt/She's so much older than me/She's everything I'm insecure about" become "And you're probably with that blond guy/Who always made me doubt/He's so much smarter than me/He's everything I'm insecure about".

to:

* Music/MichaelBuble's cover of "drivers license" by Music/OliviaRodrigo for Creator/TheBBC Radio 2 Piano Room, the lines "And you're probably with that blonde girl/Who always made me doubt/She's so much older than me/She's everything I'm insecure about" become "And you're probably with that blond guy/Who always made me doubt/He's so much smarter than me/He's everything I'm insecure about". Music/RickAstley's version of the same song in a later Piano Room also has "blond guy", but makes him ''younger''.


Added DiffLines:

* When Music/{{Texas}} were in Creator/TheBBC Radio 2 Piano Room, they did a version of "Would I Lie to You?" by Music/CharlesAndEddie with Sharleen Spiteri switching every "girl" to "boy".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Corey Cox's cover of Deana Carter's "Strawberry Wine," a LoveNostalgiaSong about a woman looking back on her first intimate relationship at the age of 17. He keeps the lyrics largely the same, which makes the song come off less like a woman discussing moving away from being TheIngenue and more like MoreExperiencedChasesTheInnocent. Particularly since it keeps the chorus the same, in which the girl's youth is emphasized ("Like strawberry wine/Seventeen/The hot July noon/Saw everything"); in the original, this just adds to her portrayal of herself as TheIngenue, while the gender flip in the cover makes it seem more like it's emphasizing the UnequalPairing of him being both college-aged and working for her grandfather.

to:

* Corey Cox's cover of Deana Carter's "Strawberry Wine," a LoveNostalgiaSong about a woman looking back on her first intimate relationship at the age of 17. He keeps the lyrics largely the same, which just flips the perspective so he's singing about her, rather than her singing about herself. Which makes the song come off less like a woman discussing moving away from being TheIngenue and more like MoreExperiencedChasesTheInnocent. Particularly since it keeps the chorus the same, in which the girl's youth is emphasized ("Like strawberry wine/Seventeen/The hot July noon/Saw everything"); in the original, this just adds to her portrayal of herself as TheIngenue, while the gender flip in the cover makes it seem more like it's emphasizing the UnequalPairing of him being both college-aged and working for her grandfather.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Corey Cox's cover of Deana Carter's "Strawberry Wine," a LoveNostalgiaSong about a woman looking back on her first intimate relationship at the age of 17. He keeps the lyrics largely the same, which makes the song come off less like a woman discussing moving away from being TheIngenue and more like MoreExperiencedChasesInnocent. Particularly since it keeps the chorus the same, in which the girl's youth is emphasized ("Like strawberry wine/Seventeen/The hot July noon/Saw everything"); in the original, this just adds to her portrayal of herself as TheIngenue, while the gender flip in the cover makes it seem more like it's emphasizing the UnequalPairing of him being both college-aged and working for her grandfather.

to:

* Corey Cox's cover of Deana Carter's "Strawberry Wine," a LoveNostalgiaSong about a woman looking back on her first intimate relationship at the age of 17. He keeps the lyrics largely the same, which makes the song come off less like a woman discussing moving away from being TheIngenue and more like MoreExperiencedChasesInnocent.MoreExperiencedChasesTheInnocent. Particularly since it keeps the chorus the same, in which the girl's youth is emphasized ("Like strawberry wine/Seventeen/The hot July noon/Saw everything"); in the original, this just adds to her portrayal of herself as TheIngenue, while the gender flip in the cover makes it seem more like it's emphasizing the UnequalPairing of him being both college-aged and working for her grandfather.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Corey Cox's cover of Deana Carter's "Strawberry Wine," a LoveNostalgiaSong about a woman looking back on her first intimate relationship at the age of 17. He keeps the lyrics largely the same, which makes the song come off less like a woman discussing moving away from being TheIngenue and more like MoreExperiencedChasesInnocent. Particularly since it keeps the chorus the same, in which the girl's youth is emphasized ("Like strawberry wine/Seventeen/The hot July noon/Saw everything"); in the original, this just adds to her portrayal of herself as TheIngenue, while the gender flip in the cover makes it seem more like it's emphasizing the UnequalPairing of him being both college-aged and working for her grandfather.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the Robots in Disguise cover of "[[Music/TheKinks You Really Got Me]]," all references to "girl" (i.e., "Girl, you really got me now") are changed to "boy".

to:

* In the Robots in Disguise cover of "[[Music/TheKinks You Really Got Me]]," all references to "girl" (i.e.(e.g., "Girl, you really got me now") are changed to "boy".



* In the Danish 1970's pop song "Boom Boom" by ''Mabel'', a man goes the doctor because he feels ill with heavy heartbeat and other symptoms. In the chorus of the song, the doctor says "hjertet hamrer løs, når man er forelsket i en pige" ("the heart beats fast when you're in love with a girl"). When the Danish TeenPop group ''Small*Talk'', which consists of two (presumably straight) teen girls, covers the song, the doctor's line in the chorus is changed to "hjertet hamrer løs, når man er forelsket, lille pige" ("the heart beats fast when you're in love, little girl").

to:

* In the Danish 1970's 1970s pop song "Boom Boom" by ''Mabel'', a man goes the doctor because he feels ill with heavy heartbeat and other symptoms. In the chorus of the song, the doctor says "hjertet hamrer løs, når man er forelsket i en pige" ("the heart beats fast when you're in love with a girl"). When the Danish TeenPop group ''Small*Talk'', which consists of two (presumably straight) teen girls, covers the song, the doctor's line in the chorus is changed to "hjertet hamrer løs, når man er forelsket, lille pige" ("the heart beats fast when you're in love, little girl").



* Averted ''twice'' on [[Music/SonicYouth Ciccone Youth]]'s ''The Whitey Album'', with Kim Gordon's cover of RobertPalmer's "Addicted to Love" and Thurston Moore's cover of {{Music/Madonna}}'s "Into the Groove"; the album itself is a tongue-in-cheek "tribute" to 80's music and pop culture.

to:

* Averted ''twice'' on [[Music/SonicYouth Ciccone Youth]]'s ''The Whitey Album'', with Kim Gordon's cover of RobertPalmer's "Addicted to Love" and Thurston Moore's cover of {{Music/Madonna}}'s "Into the Groove"; the album itself is a tongue-in-cheek "tribute" to 80's 80s music and pop culture.



** 1,000 Mona Lisas did the same with their cover, which was something of a novelty hit in the 90's.

to:

** 1,000 Mona Lisas did the same with their cover, which was something of a novelty hit in the 90's.90s.



* The 1990's Randy Travis' song "I Told You So" is sung in the first person and has no gender-specific words. Carrie Underwood covered it with ease recently without having to change the lyrics.

to:

* The 1990's 1990s Randy Travis' Travis song "I Told You So" is sung in the first person and has no gender-specific words. Carrie Underwood covered it with ease recently without having to change the lyrics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Change the lyrics, of course! Most of the time this will entail no more than switching a couple of pronouns (a man would sing "and you're having my baby" while the woman might sing it "and I'm having my baby" or change it to "and I'm having ''our'' baby") or changing "boy" to "girl" (or vice versa) but in some cases it can require a much more extensive rewrite. Another common way of doing this is giving the song a PerspectiveFlip - i.e. "then he kissed me" becomes "then I kissed her."

to:

Change the lyrics, of course! Most of the time this will entail no more than switching a couple of pronouns (a man would sing "and you're having my baby" while the woman might sing it "and I'm having my baby" or change it to "and I'm having ''our'' baby") or changing "boy" to "girl" (or vice versa) but in some cases it can require a much more extensive rewrite. Another common way of doing this is giving the song a PerspectiveFlip - i.e.g. "then he kissed me" becomes "then I kissed her."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Male covers of the Christmas classic "Santa Baby" go in two directions: the straight version "Santa Buddy," which has been roundly mocked for removing all flirty undertones, and the gay version "Santa Daddy," which said to hell with ''under''tones.

to:

* Male covers of the Christmas classic "Santa Baby" generally go in two directions: the straight version "Santa Buddy," which has been roundly mocked for removing all flirty undertones, and the gay version "Santa Daddy," which said to hell with ''under''tones.

Changed: 374

Removed: 377

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Music/MichaelBuble:
** His cover of "drivers license" by Music/OliviaRodrigo for Creator/TheBBC Radio 2 Piano Room, the lines "And you're probably with that blonde girl/Who always made me doubt/She's so much older than me/She's everything I'm insecure about" become "And you're probably with that blond guy/Who always made me doubt/He's so much smarter than me/He's everything I'm insecure about".

to:

* Music/MichaelBuble:
** His
Music/MichaelBuble's cover of "drivers license" by Music/OliviaRodrigo for Creator/TheBBC Radio 2 Piano Room, the lines "And you're probably with that blonde girl/Who always made me doubt/She's so much older than me/She's everything I'm insecure about" become "And you're probably with that blond guy/Who always made me doubt/He's so much smarter than me/He's everything I'm insecure about".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Male covers of the Christmas classic "Santa Baby" go in two directions: the straight male version "Santa Buddy," which has been roundly mocked for removing all flirty undertones, and the gay male version "Santa Daddy," which said to hell with ''under''tones.

to:

* Male covers of the Christmas classic "Santa Baby" go in two directions: the straight male version "Santa Buddy," which has been roundly mocked for removing all flirty undertones, and the gay male version "Santa Daddy," which said to hell with ''under''tones.

Added: 637

Changed: 377

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Music/MichaelBuble's cover of "drivers license" by Music/OliviaRodrigo for Creator/TheBBC Radio 2 Piano Room, the lines "And you're probably with that blonde girl/Who always made me doubt/She's so much older than me/She's everything I'm insecure about" become "And you're probably with that blond guy/Who always made me doubt/He's so much smarter than me/He's everything I'm insecure about".

to:

* In Music/MichaelBuble's Music/MichaelBuble:
** His
cover of "drivers license" by Music/OliviaRodrigo for Creator/TheBBC Radio 2 Piano Room, the lines "And you're probably with that blonde girl/Who always made me doubt/She's so much older than me/She's everything I'm insecure about" become "And you're probably with that blond guy/Who always made me doubt/He's so much smarter than me/He's everything I'm insecure about".


Added DiffLines:

* Male covers of the Christmas classic "Santa Baby" go in two directions: the straight male version "Santa Buddy," which has been roundly mocked for removing all flirty undertones, and the gay male version "Santa Daddy," which said to hell with ''under''tones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Music/{{Blondie}}'s [[CoveredUp more famous version]] of "The Tide Is High" by The Paragons does this ("I'm not the kind of man that gives up just like that" becomes "I'm not the kind of ''girl''...", for instance)

to:

* Music/{{Blondie}}'s Music/{{Blondie|Band}}'s [[CoveredUp more famous version]] of "The Tide Is High" by The Paragons does this ("I'm not the kind of man that gives up just like that" becomes "I'm not the kind of ''girl''...", for instance)



* In recent years, since Music/AshleyTisdale did a cover of "Kiss The Girl" in 2006, it's become common for that song to be sung by women. Before that, in TheNineties it was a rarely covered song and it was done by men, but look on Website/YouTube and you'll find cover songs of "Kiss The Girl" done by women outnumber those done by men by about 20 to 1. It's gotten to where people forget that it was sung by Sebastian and not Ariel in ''WesternAnimation/{{The Little Mermaid|1989}}''. The unusual thing is, the words entirely remain the same, but the connotations completely change, when sung by a man it's always a third person urging to just follow his heart and kiss the girl he loves, when sung by a woman it becomes a not-so-subtle hint to the guy she likes that she's growing impatient with his hesitation.

to:

* In recent years, since Music/AshleyTisdale did a cover of "Kiss The Girl" in 2006, it's become common for that song to be sung by women. Before that, in TheNineties The90s it was a rarely covered song and it was done by men, but look on Website/YouTube and you'll find cover songs of "Kiss The Girl" done by women outnumber those done by men by about 20 to 1. It's gotten to where people forget that it was sung by Sebastian and not Ariel in ''WesternAnimation/{{The Little Mermaid|1989}}''. The unusual thing is, the words entirely remain the same, but the connotations completely change, when sung by a man it's always a third person urging to just follow his heart and kiss the girl he loves, when sung by a woman it becomes a not-so-subtle hint to the guy she likes that she's growing impatient with his hesitation.



* "Triad" was originally a CutSong from Music/TheByrds' ''Notorious Byrd Brothers'' album, then David Crosby gave it to Music/JeffersonAirplane to record - the original lyrics had a male narrator suggesting a two woman, one man threesome, while the Jefferson Airplane version, sung by Grace Slick, changes some pronouns to make it two men and a woman. Interestingly, their version still mentions "your long hair flowing"; since both versions were recorded in TheSixties, that description could apply to someone of either gender.

to:

* "Triad" was originally a CutSong from Music/TheByrds' ''Notorious Byrd Brothers'' album, then David Crosby gave it to Music/JeffersonAirplane to record - the original lyrics had a male narrator suggesting a two woman, one man threesome, while the Jefferson Airplane version, sung by Grace Slick, changes some pronouns to make it two men and a woman. Interestingly, their version still mentions "your long hair flowing"; since both versions were recorded in TheSixties, The60s, that description could apply to someone of either gender.



* Music/{{Blondie}} have a couple of examples of playing this straight, but have also averted it with their cover of Music/BuddyHolly's "I'm Gonna Love You Too". Granted, the only line in the original that mentioned gender was "after all, another fella took ya", but leaving that in does change potential interpretations of the song: in the Buddy Holly version it's "another fella" as in "a man other than me", but having a woman sing that line makes it sound like both the subject of the song and the person he's currently with are men.

to:

* Music/{{Blondie}} Music/{{Blondie|Band}} have a couple of examples of playing this straight, but have also averted it with their cover of Music/BuddyHolly's "I'm Gonna Love You Too". Granted, the only line in the original that mentioned gender was "after all, another fella took ya", but leaving that in does change potential interpretations of the song: in the Buddy Holly version it's "another fella" as in "a man other than me", but having a woman sing that line makes it sound like both the subject of the song and the person he's currently with are men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* "If I Were a Rich Man" from ''Theatre/FiddlerOnTheRoof'' was gender-flipped into "Rich Girl" by reggae duo Louchie Lou & Michie One, then their version was in turn covered by Music/GwenStefani.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Per TRS, Just For Pun was renamed to Punny Trope Names due to misuse.


* Averted by Me First And The Gimme Gimmes' [[JustForPun Are A Drag]], an entire album of non-gender-flipped covers of originally female songs.

to:

* Averted by Me First And The Gimme Gimmes' [[JustForPun ''[[PunBasedTitle Are A Drag]], Drag]]'', an entire album of non-gender-flipped covers of originally female songs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "Blues in the Night" was originally written to be sung by a male prisoner about women with lines like "a woman's a two-face, a worrisome thing who'll leave you to sing the blues in the night." Rosemary Clooney and Dinah Shore later recorded versions where a woman is being warned about men by her mother. The song's second line in this version is [[GirlishPigtails "when I was in pigtails"]] instead of "when I was in kneepants."

to:

* "Blues in the Night" was originally written for a movie of the same title to be sung by a male prisoner about women with lines like "a woman's a two-face, a worrisome thing who'll leave you to sing the blues in the night." Rosemary Clooney and Dinah Shore Creator/DinahShore later recorded versions where a woman is being warned about men by her mother. The song's second line in this version is [[GirlishPigtails "when I was in pigtails"]] [[GirlishPigtails pigtails]]" instead of "when I was in kneepants.[[BoyishShorts kneepants]]."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Theatre/MammaMia'' turns "Lay All Your Love On Me", which was sung entirely from a female perspective, into a duet between Sophie and her fiancé Sky. Sky sings the first verse, altered from "Now every woman I see is a potential threat" into "Now every man that I see...".

Top