Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / PhonyVeteran

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/BackToTheFuture'', while stuck in the 1950's, Marty uses the cover identity of a returning Coast Guard to explain away his 80's-era clothing.

to:

* In ''Film/BackToTheFuture'', ''Film/BackToTheFuture1'', while stuck in the 1950's, Marty uses the cover identity of a returning Coast Guard to explain away his 80's-era clothing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In one episode Elliot's father, the Chief of Medicine of a high-priced private hospital, visits Scared Herat and claims it's the worst he's seen since [[UsefulNotes/TheKoreanWar Korea]]. Dr. Kelso, a Korean War veteran who actually served in combat, sarcastically replies "Oh, where in Connecticut was your National Guard unit posted?"

to:

** In one episode Elliot's father, the Chief of Medicine of a high-priced private hospital, visits Scared Herat Heart and claims it's the worst he's seen since [[UsefulNotes/TheKoreanWar Korea]]. Dr. Kelso, a Korean War veteran who actually served in combat, sarcastically replies "Oh, where in Connecticut was your National Guard unit posted?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/TheSaint'': The ConMan title character of "The Ingenious Colonel":

to:

* ''Literature/TheSaint'': The ConMan title character of "The Ingenious Ingenuous Colonel":
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Perhaps because this is attention-seeking behavior in the first place, it's very common for a RealLife phony vet to claim to be a high-ranking and highly-decorated member of an elite special-forces unit, because ElitesAreMoreGlamorous. Ironically, this often makes them easier for actual veterans or well-informed civilians to spot. The more elite and senior a particular type of service member is, the fewer of them there tend to be, and them more likely a phony will get the uniform or knowledge about their supposed specialty wrong. Also, because this is somewhat immature behavior to begin with, they tend to be extremely young for their purported rank and time in service.

to:

Perhaps because this is attention-seeking behavior in the first place, it's very common for a RealLife phony vet to claim to be a high-ranking and highly-decorated member of an elite special-forces unit, because ElitesAreMoreGlamorous. Ironically, this often makes them easier for actual veterans or well-informed civilians to spot. The more elite and senior a particular type of service member is, the fewer of them there tend to be, and them the more likely a phony will get the uniform or knowledge about their supposed specialty wrong. Also, because this is somewhat immature behavior to begin with, they tend to be extremely young for their purported rank and time in service.

Added: 341

Changed: 685

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In other words, TruthInTelevision. See also MilesGloriosus and FakeUltimateHero.

to:

Perhaps because this is attention-seeking behavior in the first place, it's very common for a RealLife phony vet to claim to be a high-ranking and highly-decorated member of an elite special-forces unit, because ElitesAreMoreGlamorous. Ironically, this often makes them easier for actual veterans or well-informed civilians to spot. The more elite and senior a particular type of service member is, the fewer of them there tend to be, and them more likely a phony will get the uniform or knowledge about their supposed specialty wrong. Also, because this is somewhat immature behavior to begin with, they tend to be extremely young for their purported rank and time in service.

In other words, TruthInTelevision. See also MilesGloriosus and FakeUltimateHero.
FakeUltimateHero. WarReenactors are generally ''not'' phony vets; Despite dressing up in uniform, most are up front about it being a hobby, wear uniforms that are historically accurate and not those currently worn, and don't try to pass themselves off as actual service members.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''ComicBook/{{The Boys|2019}}'': One LegacyCharacter (an {{expy}} of ComicBook/CaptainAmerica) claims to have served in UsefulNotes/WorldWarII (the original one did, but was quickly killed as a result of his incompetence and starting the pattern of what happens when Vought Incorporated gets involved with warfare). When Billy (a veteran of the Falklands war) kills him, he tells him he's an insult to the men who truly served.

to:

* ''ComicBook/{{The Boys|2019}}'': ''ComicBook/TheBoys'': One LegacyCharacter (an {{expy}} of ComicBook/CaptainAmerica) claims to have served in UsefulNotes/WorldWarII (the original one did, but was quickly killed as a result of his incompetence and starting the pattern of what happens when Vought Incorporated gets involved with warfare). When Billy (a veteran of the Falklands war) kills him, he tells him he's an insult to the men who truly served.



* In ''Series/TheBoys'', [[spoiler:like the [[ComicBook/TheBoys original comic]], FakeUltimateHero and ComicBook/CaptainAmerica {{expy}} Soldier Boy never actually served in WWII, instead being used as a propaganda piece and SuperCop by the government. However, he's an AdaptationalBadass and {{narcissist}} who ends up BelievingTheirOwnLies to the point that he ''genuinely believes'' that he was a veteran discarded by his country, and decks Hughie for questioning it.]]

to:

* In ''Series/TheBoys'', ''Series/{{The Boys|2019}}'', [[spoiler:like the [[ComicBook/TheBoys original comic]], FakeUltimateHero and ComicBook/CaptainAmerica {{expy}} Soldier Boy never actually served in WWII, instead being used as a propaganda piece and SuperCop by the government. However, he's an AdaptationalBadass and {{narcissist}} who ends up BelievingTheirOwnLies to the point that he ''genuinely believes'' that he was a veteran discarded by his country, and decks Hughie for questioning it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''ComicBook/TheBoys'': One LegacyCharacter (an {{expy}} of ComicBook/CaptainAmerica) claims to have served in UsefulNotes/WorldWarII (the original one did, but was quickly killed as a result of his incompetence and starting the pattern of what happens when Vought Incorporated gets involved with warfare). When Billy (a veteran of the Falklands war) kills him, he tells him he's an insult to the men who truly served.

to:

* ''ComicBook/TheBoys'': ''ComicBook/{{The Boys|2019}}'': One LegacyCharacter (an {{expy}} of ComicBook/CaptainAmerica) claims to have served in UsefulNotes/WorldWarII (the original one did, but was quickly killed as a result of his incompetence and starting the pattern of what happens when Vought Incorporated gets involved with warfare). When Billy (a veteran of the Falklands war) kills him, he tells him he's an insult to the men who truly served.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/{{Planes}}'': Dusty's mentor [[GrumpyOldMan Skipper]] is an old reclusive war veteran who keeps telling heroic stories about his time serving in the Jolly Wrenches. When looking at the hall of fame during his stay on the U.S.S. Flysenhower, Dusty is shocked to find out that [[spoiler: Skipper only flew one mission, one that failed spectacularly as his entire squadron was shot down due to him miscalculating the danger. Still, the incident has traumatized Skipper so badly, that he couldn't bring himself to fly anymore, let alone tell anyone the truth. Dusty feels betrayed by this.]]

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/{{Planes}}'': A downplayed example where Dusty's mentor [[GrumpyOldMan Skipper]] is an old reclusive war veteran who keeps telling heroic stories about his time serving in the Jolly Wrenches. When looking at the hall of fame during his stay on the U.''U.S.S. Flysenhower, Flysenhower'', Dusty is shocked to find out that [[spoiler: Skipper only flew one mission, one that failed spectacularly as his entire squadron was shot down due to him miscalculating the danger. Still, the incident has traumatized Skipper so badly, that he couldn't bring himself to fly anymore, let alone tell anyone the truth. Dusty feels betrayed by this.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->''Lieutenant-Colonel Sir George Uppington, it must be admitted, was not a genuine knight; neither, as a matter of fact, was he a genuine colonel...But his military experience was certainly limited to a brief period during the latter days of [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarOne the war]] when {{conscription}} had gathered him up and set him to the uncongenial task of PeelingPotatos at Aldershot.''

to:

-->''Lieutenant-Colonel Sir George Uppington, it must be admitted, was not a genuine knight; neither, as a matter of fact, was he a genuine colonel...But his military experience was certainly limited to a brief period during the latter days of [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarOne the war]] when {{conscription}} had gathered him up and set him to the uncongenial task of PeelingPotatos {{peeling potatoes}} at Aldershot.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheSaint'': The ConMan title character of "The Ingenious Colonel":
-->''Lieutenant-Colonel Sir George Uppington, it must be admitted, was not a genuine knight; neither, as a matter of fact, was he a genuine colonel...But his military experience was certainly limited to a brief period during the latter days of [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarOne the war]] when {{conscription}} had gathered him up and set him to the uncongenial task of PeelingPotatos at Aldershot.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While he actually did serve in UsefulNotes/WorldWarOne, [[TheBarnum Grimes]] in Creator/EvelynWaugh's novel ''Decline and Fall'' serves as an example. He is missing a leg, and while he received the injury after the war from being hit by a car, his pupils (he's a schoolmaster) assume that this was a war injury, a notion of which he does nothing to disabuse them.

to:

* While he actually did serve in UsefulNotes/WorldWarOne, [[TheBarnum Grimes]] in Creator/EvelynWaugh's novel ''Decline and Fall'' ''Literature/DeclineAndFall'' serves as an example. He is missing a leg, and while he received the injury after the war from being hit by a car, his pupils (he's a schoolmaster) assume that this was a war injury, a notion of which he does nothing to disabuse them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/{{Barry}}'': Fuches actually did serve in the U.S. Army during the Vietnam War, but as a cook. When he tries to make his service sound more impressive than it was, Barry - usually an ExtremeDoormat - calls him out and points out he never even stepped foot in Vietnam, having spent the war working at a barrack in Connecticut.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Film/BackToTheFuture'', while stuck in the 1950's, Marty uses the cover identity of a returning Coast Guard to explain away his 80's-era clothing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/TheCode'' has an episode focusing on a Marine who exposes civilians posing as military veterans in public on video. It becomes complicated when one such phony Marine is beaten by a real one and dies of his injuries.

to:

* ''Series/TheCode'' ''Series/TheCode2019'' has an episode focusing on a Marine who exposes civilians posing as military veterans in public on video. It becomes complicated when one such phony Marine is beaten by a real one and dies of his injuries.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/{{Repton}}'': In the "OAP" scenario of ''The Life of Repton'', Repton collects war medals instead of diamonds. The comic strip cover implies that he tells stories at the local pub about his military career in order to get free drinks. Then a fellow drinker notices that one of the medals is from the Battle of Waterloo!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''VideoGame/{{Psychonauts}}'', Coach Oleander's mindscape is themed entirely around war due to having served himself, which is shown in a Memory Vault containing a recollection of the battles he took part in. [[spoiler: Upon revisiting the level, you can find a Memory Vault that reveals that Coach Oleander made ''everything up''. According to the memory, he was never involved in a war and was actually rejected by quite literally every branch of the military, including the ''catering corps''. Granted, as an official Psychonaut, he ''is'' a government agent - not quite military, but close enough.]]

to:

* In ''VideoGame/{{Psychonauts}}'', Coach Oleander's mindscape is themed entirely around war due to having served himself, which is shown in a Memory Vault containing a recollection of the battles he took part in. [[spoiler: Upon revisiting the level, you can find a Memory Vault that reveals that Coach Oleander made ''everything ''made everything up''. According to the memory, he was never involved in a war and was actually rejected by quite literally every branch of the military, including the ''catering corps''.corps'', just because of his height. Granted, as an official Psychonaut, he ''is'' a government agent - not quite military, but close enough.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In one episode Elliot's father, the Chief of Medicine of a high-priced private hospital, visits Scared Herat and claims it's the work he's seen since [[UsefulNotes/TheKoreanWar Korea]]. Dr. Kelso, a Korean War veteran who actually served in combat, replies "Where in Connecticut was your National Guard unit posted?"

to:

** In one episode Elliot's father, the Chief of Medicine of a high-priced private hospital, visits Scared Herat and claims it's the work worst he's seen since [[UsefulNotes/TheKoreanWar Korea]]. Dr. Kelso, a Korean War veteran who actually served in combat, sarcastically replies "Where "Oh, where in Connecticut was your National Guard unit posted?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''VideoGame/MassEffect2'', Conrad Verner, Shepard’s LoonyFan from the previous game, shows up at a bar on Illium wearing an N7 armor suit and threatening that “I’m a man on the edge! I’ve got nothing to lose!” He is attempting to extort the deed to the bar, claiming it is a front for a drug operation. When Shepard quizzes Conrad about how he got the armor, Conrad admits that it’s just a cheap knockoff replica and that he doesn’t have any military training or combat experience. Shepard can either just complain, kick Conrad way down there, or shoot his foot.
** In ''VideoGame/MassEffectAndromeda'', Ex-Alliance marine lieutenant turned settlement mayor, August Bradley will consider [[PlayerCharacter Ryder]] to be one, if you walk around in your dad’s N7 armor. Although Ryder also had a short stint in the Alliance marines, and is now the Initiative’s Pathfinder, Bradley admonishes you for wearing an armor you never actually qualified for.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The Tim Buckley song "Nighthawking" has the narrator do this to cool down an AxCrazy ShellShockedVeteran whom he picked up in his cab that started holding a switchblade to his throat.
--> ''"Then he whipped out this switch blade\\
Straight outta nowhere level to my throat\\
He said 'You ever been over to the war boy?'\\
I said 'Man I was a combat paratrooper daddy'\\
Well then he slump back cool and he pocket that steel\\
He said 'Take me down to Fourth and Main'\\
Ah that paratroop bluff always cools oh the red eyed geezers down"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Webcomic/TerminalLance'':
** [[https://terminallance.com/2012/07/03/terminal-lance-211-stolen-valor/ #211: "Stolen Valor"]]: Abe overhears a guy in a surplus-store uniform and ribbons telling tall tales to some bar girls, and shuts him down by telling the guy that "you left your HIV meds at my place." He then offers condoms to the girls, just to be nice. In TheRant, author Max Uriarte (a former Marine infantryman with service in Iraq) explains that he finds people who do this more pitiable than infuriating, believing that they think their real lives are so lame they have to spice them up by cosplaying as veterans.
** [[https://terminallance.com/2015/03/17/terminal-lance-370-stealing-the-valor/ #370: "Stealing the Valor"]]: Abe and Garcia run into a chubby guy in Marine fatigues and start yelling at him for stolen valor. Garcia asks him what his MOS is--assuming he'll say he was in some awesome combat job--and the guy replies "I'm a 92-Alpha Automated Logistical Specialist!" He leaves grinning evilly while Abe and Garcia try to figure out if that's even a real MOS. ([[https://www.operationmilitarykids.org/army-automated-logistical-specialist-mos-92a/ It is, albeit in the US Army rather than the Marines.]])
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As seen in one of the chapters of ''Manga/BlackLagoon'', Dutch may be one of these, as a military character points to flaws in Dutch's accounts of serving in Vietnam and the fact that Dutch appears ignorant of G.I. lingo. [[spoiler:Later chapters subvert this by suggesting he ''has'' experience, but is possibly just lying about when and for whom he was serving.]]

to:

* As seen in one ''Manga/BlackLagoon'': Dutch, the captain of the chapters boat and leader of ''Manga/BlackLagoon'', the company, long had a {{backstory}} of being a Vietnam-era riverboat veteran; however, during the "El Baile de la Muerte" arc, an Army Delta Force operator who was active in the same period realizes Dutch doesn't recognize common GI slang terms and claims to have been in a unit that wasn't at a battle he cites. [[spoiler:The newest arc, "L'homme sombre", is hinting that he may be one of these, as a military character points to flaws in Dutch's accounts of serving in Vietnam and the fact that Dutch appears ignorant of G.I. lingo. [[spoiler:Later chapters subvert this by suggesting he ''has'' experience, but is possibly just lying about when and for whom he was serving.be an escaped African war criminal.]]

Added: 581

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler: Inverted]] in the ''Franchise/DoctorWhoExpandedUniverse'' novel ''The Taking Of Chelsea 426'' with the character of the Major, an apparently senile old duffer forever droning on about his military career, with copious hints that he's really one of these. While he does prove to have a good deal of bravery and military knowledge, the punchline comes [[spoiler: after his HeroicSacrifice, when the Doctor reads the obituary of Field-Marshal Henry Whittington-Smythe and says "I ''knew'' he wasn't really a Major!"]]

to:

* [[spoiler: Inverted]] in the ''Franchise/DoctorWhoExpandedUniverse'' novel ''The Taking Of Chelsea 426'' with the character of the Major, an apparently senile old duffer forever droning on about his military career, with copious hints that he's really one of these. While he does prove to have a good deal of bravery and military knowledge, the punchline comes [[spoiler: after his HeroicSacrifice, when the Doctor reads the obituary of Field-Marshal Henry Whittington-Smythe and says "I ''knew'' he wasn't really a Major!"]]Major!"]].
* {{Discussed}} in ''Literature/{{Frontlines}}: Terms of Enlistment''. After transferring from the North American Territorial Army to the Navy and having to start at the bottom again, protagonist Andrew Grayson shows up to his new post sporting a Purple Heart and a Bronze Star, which would be deeply unusual for a fresh Navy recruit of his age. His CO briefly takes him to task for an apparently-common recruit tactic of trying to impress people with ribbons bought in the PX, but Andrew assures him he earned them the hard way and the CO apologizes after getting the explanation.

Added: 315

Removed: 315

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/SemiPro'': Lou, one of Jackie's buddies/game commentators, claims that he was in Vietnam during a poker game. The others at the table all groan as he "recalls" his experience fending off Charlie in "the shit", earning the rebuke "Is 'the shit' in Ann Arbor? Cause that's where ''you'' were during the war."



* ''Film/SemiPro'': Lou, one of Jackie's buddies/game commentators, claims that he was in Vietnam during a poker game. The others at the table all groan as he "recalls" his experience fending off Charlie in "the shit", earning the rebuke "Is 'the shit' in Ann Arbor? Cause that's where ''you'' were during the war."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/BenSnow'': In "Snow in Yucatan", Ben travels to Mexico in search of Wade Chancer, a DangerousDeserter from the Rough Riders. When Ben finds him, he is assembling an army of Indians and styling himself as a general. His uniform includes two medals he stole off dead men and claims to have won.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Subverted in ''VideoGame/BioshockInfinite'': According to a soldier from the Battle of Wounded Knee, Zachary Comstock never fought in the war and the accomplishments he takes credit for aren't his. [[spoiler: He actually ''did'' fight in the war when he was still known as Booker [=DeWitt=]. However, he ''is'' lying about the extent of his wartime accomplishments. And they're both deluded about the actual "accomplishment" of slaughtering two towns of underequipped civilians fighting in desperate self-defense.]]

to:

* Subverted in ''VideoGame/BioshockInfinite'': ''VideoGame/BioShockInfinite'': According to a soldier from the Battle of Wounded Knee, Zachary Comstock never fought in the war and the accomplishments he takes credit for aren't his. [[spoiler: He [[spoiler:He actually ''did'' fight in the war when he was still known as Booker [=DeWitt=]. However, he ''is'' lying about the extent of his wartime accomplishments. ]] And they're both deluded about the actual "accomplishment" of slaughtering two towns of underequipped civilians fighting in desperate self-defense.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Per TRS, Aluminum Christmas Trees is YMMV. Removed the bullet point because it's natter.


** It should be noted that [[AluminumChristmasTrees the US Coast Guard really was active in combat operations in Vietnam]], with multiple Cutters patrolling the "Gun Line" offshore, providing fire support to ground troops, and shooting up North Vietnamese gunboats. Tayback clearly wasn’t among them, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* An episode of ''Series/BetterCallSaul'' involves one of these, where Jimmy carts up an old man in uniform to an Air Force base to hang out in front of a B-29. The guy in question is just some weirdo who owes Jimmy a favor [[DirtyOldMan after Jimmy defended him for public masturbation.]] Ironically, it's implied that by some coincidence, he may have had ''some'' history with the war, since he corrects Jimmy about whether the B-29 was used against the Nazis.

to:

* An In an episode of ''Series/BetterCallSaul'' involves one of these, where ''Series/BetterCallSaul'', Jimmy carts up dresses an old man in uniform and uses the story that he flew bombers in WWII to scam his way onto an active Air Force base to hang out in front of so he can shoot a B-29.commercial. The guy in question is just some weirdo who owes Jimmy a favor [[DirtyOldMan after Jimmy defended him for public masturbation.]] Ironically, it's implied that by some coincidence, coincidence he may have had ''some'' history with some actual service in the war, since he accurately corrects Jimmy about whether the service of the B-29 was used against the Nazis.bomber.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/FuggetAboutIt'': When Cheech realizes that his WitnessProtection alias is 100 years old, he decides to pretend to be a World War II veteran in order to get free beer. Real World War II veterans eventually realize the truth and beat him up.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/FuggetAboutIt'': When Cheech realizes that his WitnessProtection alias is 100 years old, he decides to pretend to be a World War II veteran in order to get free a discount on beer. Real World War II veterans eventually realize the truth and beat him up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In one episode, Homer claims to be a Vietnam vet in order to get free admittance to the State Fair.

to:

** In one episode, Homer claims to be a Vietnam vet in order to get free admittance to the State Fair.Fair telling the ticket vendor that he lost his friends at the [[RefugeInAudacity Battle of]] Creator/MargaretCho.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Film/Ronin}}'': When Sam suspects one of his colleagues isn't telling the truth about his background, he tests him with questions like "What's the color of the boathouse at Hereford?" Sam doesn't know either, but he knows that a real SAS veteran wouldn't have been so flustered by the question that Sam could get the drop on him.

to:

* ''{{Film/Ronin}}'': ''Film/Ronin1998'': When Sam suspects one of his colleagues isn't telling the truth about his background, he tests him with questions like "What's the color of the boathouse at Hereford?" Sam doesn't know either, but he knows that a real SAS veteran wouldn't have been so flustered by the question that Sam could get the drop on him.

Top