Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / MutuallyAssuredDestruction

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In Season 7 of ''Series/{{Supernatural}}'' Dean invokes this trope by name when Sam questions their alliance with the demon, Meg. With their closest allies all dead or [[spoiler: in Castiel's case, insane]], they are out of options. They way Dean sees it, they are dead without each other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Discussed in ''Literature/TheHungerGames'' Mockingjay. While the movie only mentions the [[LaResistance rebels]] have a "special weapon", the book explicitly states both opposing side in the war posses nuclear missiles and any use of those would ensure mutual destruction of both parties, resulting in [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt the end of the human race]].

to:

* Discussed in ''Literature/TheHungerGames'' Mockingjay. While the movie only mentions the [[LaResistance rebels]] have a "special weapon", the book explicitly states both opposing side in the war posses possess nuclear missiles and any use of those would ensure mutual destruction of both parties, resulting in [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt the end of the human race]].

Added: 328

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/TheSoldier''. RenegadeRussian KGB operatives pose as terrorists and plant an atomic bomb in the Middle Eastern oilfields. If the US doesn't force the Israelis off the West Bank, they will irradiate the world's oil supply. In response the Soldier's Force take over an ICBM silo and threaten to launch on Moscow if the KGB doesn't cancel the operation.

to:

* ''Film/TheSoldier''. RenegadeRussian KGB operatives pose as terrorists and plant an atomic bomb in the Middle Eastern oilfields. If the US doesn't force the Israelis off the West Bank, they will irradiate the world's oil supply. In response the Soldier's Force force take over an ICBM silo and threaten to launch on Moscow if the KGB doesn't cancel the operation.


Added DiffLines:

* In the ''Series/{{Quatermass}}'' series, the eponymous British scientist is not happy about his planned Moonbase being used to launch nuclear missiles for a proposed Dead Man deterrence strategy--the idea being that if an aggressor nuked Britain, missiles would launch from the Moon and wipe out the attacker three days later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aw9yexAdteY Dead Hand]] by Music/{{Ferry}} is about [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin the]] [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_Hand Dead Hand system]], and features [[SarcasmMode cheery lyrics]] such as the following:
-->Turn up the volume, execute the protocol\\
You know it’s M.A.D. and it’s all about to blow\\
What an unfortunate way to end this show\\
I shed a tear as you vanish in the snow
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The goal of a MAD strategy is counter-intuitive: it is not to win a nuclear war, but actually to ''prevent'' one. The theory goes that if each side knows that there is no way it can survive a nuclear war, it will get too scared to start one. Unless one or more of the superpowers decides on TakingYouWithMe or is ruled by an OmnicidalManiac, the idea is that knowing that [[Film/WarGames "the only winning move is not to play"]] will keep either side from escalating matters to the point that mutual destruction becomes inevitable.

to:

The goal of a MAD strategy is counter-intuitive: it is not to win a nuclear war, but actually to ''prevent'' one. The theory goes that if each side knows that there is no way it can survive a nuclear war, it will get too scared to start one. Unless one or more of the superpowers decides on TakingYouWithMe or is ruled by an OmnicidalManiac, the idea is that knowing that [[Film/WarGames "the only winning move is not to play"]] will keep either side from escalating matters to the point that mutual destruction becomes inevitable.
inevitable. What happens if someone gains control of nukes who sees the horrible death of themselves and all their subjects as desirable? [[NightmareFuel Well...]] Let's just hope that never happens.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


One of the theories for why the UsefulNotes/ColdWar ended [[TheGreatPoliticsMessUp as peacefully as it did]] is that belief in this doctrine prevented the US and USSR from fighting any war directly against each other, for fear it would escalate to nuclear weapons and destroy both powers. Instead, it became a war of ideologies and economics, and [[WrittenByTheWinners according to the victors]], the US eventually out-converted and out-spent the Soviets, who then collapsed under the weight of their own system.[[labelnote:*]]This was not too far from the truth, but the reality was that the Soviet system was really good at lying to itself, and their economy had been in the shitter long before the Reagan era arms race. They were doomed either way, but the competition might have sped the process up a little.[[/labelnote]]

to:

One of the theories for why the UsefulNotes/ColdWar ended [[TheGreatPoliticsMessUp as peacefully as it did]] is that belief in this doctrine prevented the US and USSR from fighting any war directly against each other, for fear it would escalate to nuclear weapons and destroy both powers. Instead, it became a war of ideologies and economics, and [[WrittenByTheWinners according to the victors]], the US eventually out-converted and out-spent the Soviets, who then collapsed under the weight of their own system.[[labelnote:*]]This was not too far from the truth, but the reality was that the Soviet system was really good at lying to itself, and their economy had been in the shitter long before the Reagan era arms race. They were doomed either way, but the competition might have sped the process up a little.[[/labelnote]]
[[/labelnote]] That particular theory has been put to the test in 1999 when the nuclear powers of India and Pakistan fought a [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kargil_War limited shooting war]] that somehow did not escalate to the use of nukes. Luckily for us. Unluckily, the nukes did not prevent the shooting in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More accurate.


* ''Webcomic/SchlockMercenary'': Discussed. When the galaxy was bound by a PortalNetwork, there was no Mutually Assured Destruction; the wormgates limited the size of ships that could use them, meaning that it was far easier to defend a system than attack. With the invention of the [[{{Teleportation}} teraport]], that limit was removed, edging the galaxy closer to MAD--but the use of [[TeleportInterdiction Teraport Area Denial]] prevented the most dangerous uses of the technology. Then "long-guns" were invented, giant cannons that shoot through hyperspace and overwhelm TAD; with proper location data, they can shoot at anywhere in the galaxy from anywhere in the galaxy. The galaxy was well and truly back in a state of MAD, since there was no defense. The various galactic leaders insist that while this system is terrifying, that's why it works; no one likes the fail state. [[DeusEstMachina Petey]] points out that eventually they'll find someone who ''does'' like the fail state, and then the entire galaxy will die, so they need to find a better solution. Finally, there have been multiple previous epochs of galactic history that were destroyed by failed MAD policies. The very rare surviving species call the long-guns "end-guns" for this reason.

to:

* ''Webcomic/SchlockMercenary'': Discussed. When the galaxy was bound by a PortalNetwork, there was no Mutually Assured Destruction; the wormgates limited the size of ships that could use them, meaning that it was far easier to defend a system than attack. With the invention of the [[{{Teleportation}} [[DestructiveTeleportation teraport]], that limit was removed, edging the galaxy closer to MAD--but the use of [[TeleportInterdiction Teraport Area Denial]] prevented the most dangerous uses of the technology. Then "long-guns" were invented, giant cannons that shoot through hyperspace and overwhelm TAD; with proper location data, they can shoot at anywhere in the galaxy from anywhere in the galaxy. The galaxy was well and truly back in a state of MAD, since there was no defense. The various galactic leaders insist that while this system is terrifying, that's why it works; no one likes the fail state. [[DeusEstMachina Petey]] points out that eventually they'll find someone who ''does'' like the fail state, and then the entire galaxy will die, so they need to find a better solution. Finally, there have been multiple previous epochs of galactic history that were destroyed by failed MAD policies. The very rare surviving species call the long-guns "end-guns" for this reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Doomsday Machine was speculated to have been intended as the ultimate deterrent, "a weapon built primarily as a bluff. It's never meant to be used. So strong, it could destroy both sides in a war". But then someone actually used it. However, many ExpandedUniverse materials suggest that it was actually built as a weapon against the Borg.

to:

** The Doomsday Machine was speculated to have been intended as the ultimate deterrent, "a weapon built primarily as a bluff. It's never meant to be used. So strong, it could destroy both sides in a war". But then someone actually used it. However, many Many ExpandedUniverse materials suggest that it was actually built as a weapon against the Borg.Borg; this conflicts with the episode as aired, in which Spock states that the planet killer's course shows it to have a trans-galactic origin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Your end is at hand if they blow.

to:

Your end is at hand hand, if they blow.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Music/SonataArctica's "Destruction Preventer" is about how starting a nuclear war will lead to destruction.
-->Heat in the center, destruction preventer\\
If you release one, you release them all\\
You can't defend Her, kneel down and surrender\\
Your end is at hand if they blow.

Added: 793

Changed: 412

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Comes up with regard to Soulcutter in the ''Literature/BookOfSwords''. When drawn, the blade projects an aura of such absolute despair and apathy that anyone within miles of the drawn Sword can do nothing but lie down and wait to die. The thing is, the bearer of the Sword is ''not'' immune to this effect, so drawing the Sword is essentially a suicide attack and it's more common for the bearer to use the ''threat'' of drawing it as a bargaining chip.

to:

* Comes up with regard to Soulcutter a couple of the titular blades in the ''Literature/BookOfSwords''. ''Literature/BookOfSwords''.
** Farslayer: If thrown with a target in mind, Farslayer will vanish and reappear impaled through the chosen target's heart. Where it will stay, ready for anyone nearby to pick up. And "the person who just killed my friend/lover/relative" is an entirely legitimate target for the blade's magic. Stories are told of entire FeudingFamilies wiping each other out by sending Farslayer back and forth.
** Soulcutter:
When drawn, the blade projects an aura of such absolute despair and apathy that anyone within miles of the drawn Sword can do nothing but lie down and wait to die. The thing is, the bearer of the Sword is ''not'' immune to this effect, so drawing the Sword is essentially a suicide attack and it's more common for the bearer to use the ''threat'' of drawing it as a bargaining chip.

Changed: 234

Removed: 235

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/{{Community}}''
** One episode had Professor Duncan abuse Chang by using his restraining order to torment the guy. By the end of the episode, it is shown that Chang has gotten his own restraining order on Duncan, who then states the name of the trope.

to:

* ''Series/{{Community}}''
**
''Series/{{Community}}'': One episode had Professor Duncan abuse Chang by using his restraining order to torment the guy. By the end of the episode, it is shown that Chang has gotten his own restraining order on Duncan, who then states the name of the trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ComicBook/JudgeDredd'' shows why this doctrine wouldn't work if one side was led by an insane, jingoistic lunatic convinced that their country's way is the only way: American President Robert L. Booth declared that the entire world was living off America's back and proceed to send American troops to occupy key industrial sites all around the globe. When the UN demanded a cease of operations, Booth gave them an ultimatum: either back off or he'd personally order every city in the world to be nuked. Which he did. Once the ultimatum expired, Booth unleashed all the nuclear arsenal of the USA into the world and was hit with a massive counterattack. The subsequent atomic wars reduced the entire planet to a smoldering, radioactive wasteland.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/XMenFirstClass'' has Sebastian Shaw [[BeenThereShapedHistory causing the Cuban Missile Crisis]] exactly to make the United States and the Soviet Union attack each other, wiping out the human population and leaving room for the Mutants to rule.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:327:VideoGame/TheNewOrderLastDaysOfEurope So long.]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:327:VideoGame/TheNewOrderLastDaysOfEurope [[caption-width-right:327:[[VideoGame/TheNewOrderLastDaysOfEurope So long.]]
]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:327:''VideoGame/{{DEFCON}}'' illustrates [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt how devastating]] this theory could be in practice.]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:327:''VideoGame/{{DEFCON}}'' illustrates [[TheEndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt how devastating]] this theory could be in practice.[[caption-width-right:327:VideoGame/TheNewOrderLastDaysOfEurope So long.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2014-03-30 SMBC's Jack and the accidental invention of high-fantasy drop warheads]].

to:

* [[https://www.''Webcomic/SaturdayMorningBreakfastCereal'':[[https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2014-03-30 SMBC's Jack and the accidental invention of high-fantasy drop warheads]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The M.A.D. tank from ''VideoGame/CommandAndConquerRedAlert'' is a suicide unit that can destroy anything that isn't infantry in three shots- including itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Videogame/TheNewOrderLastDaysOfEurope:'' Only natural, since there is a Cold War with the powers changed utterly. It's a good part of what keeps the game from becoming paint-the-map conquest: Invade a nuclear power a bit too much, the nukes fly, and the playthrough ends there barring post-apocalyptic events. Ergo, any changes will need to be made slowly, through ways economical and political, if you want to make things better (or worse)... Interestingly, one downside to the M.A.D. policy that some other works merely mention is explored fully here: [[spoiler:Some people might ''like'' [[ApocalypseHow the fail-state]]. In this case, Burgundy, lead by an even-nastier-than-usual Heinrich Himmler. He has decided the only way to purge the untermensch in a proper, thorough manner is to scour the world clean with nuclear fire and let the Aryans live through it, and thus he eagerly throws metaphorical matches and gasoline everywhere in an effort to set it all alight]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Comes up with regard to Soulcutter in the ''Literature/BookOfSwords''. When drawn, the blade projects an aura of such absolute despair and apathy that anyone within miles of the drawn Sword can do nothing but lie down and wait to die. The thing is, the bearer of the Sword is ''not'' immune to this effect, so drawing the Sword is essentially a suicide attack and it's more common for the bearer to use the ''threat'' of drawing it as a bargaining chip.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/DuckDodgersInTheTwentyFourthAndAHalfCentury'', being an allegory for the Cold War, includes this as the end result of Dodgers’ and Marvin’s escalating conflict. Dodgers prepares his secret weapon, an explosive cage around Marvin’s ship, to which the Martian responds by using the exact same weapon on Dodgers’ ship. Both pull on their respective detonators at the same time, and [[EarthShatteringKaboom the resulting explosion takes out almost the entirety of Planet X]]. Dodgers then shoves Marvin off the remains of the planet, and declares himself victorious, [[PyrrhicVictory even though he’s destroyed the shaving cream atoms he was sent to retrieve and has no ship to return home]]. The Eager Young Space Cadet puts it best.
-->'''Eager Young Space Cadet''': B-B-B-Big deal
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


Needless to say, this theory made people on all sides of the UsefulNotes/ColdWar very nervous. Indeed, before [[TheGreatPoliticsMessUp the end of the Cold War]], most academics thought the acronym "MAD" was appropriate - the strategy seemed insane.[[labelnote:*]]To be fair, hindsight reveals that most politicians on both sides ''also'' thought it was insane, but didn't have any better alternative: nukes were a way of life since the 50's and the genie couldn't be put back in the bottle. This is also why the various nuclear weapon reduction treaties were so contentious and difficult: SALT and START faced the prospect of reducing nuclear stockpiles from "We can kill everything everywhere several times over" to "If we fired our missiles just right, we might win now."[[/labelnote]] It may come up in hypothetical WorldWarIII scenarios or works set in the late-era (1980s) of the UsefulNotes/ColdWar. With the fall of the Soviet Union, MAD has lost its value as the focus shifts to combating [[TheWarOnTerror terrorists]] who do not have access to a large stockpile of nuclear weapons.

to:

Needless to say, this theory made people on all sides of the UsefulNotes/ColdWar very nervous. Indeed, before [[TheGreatPoliticsMessUp the end of the Cold War]], most academics thought the acronym "MAD" was appropriate - the strategy seemed insane.[[labelnote:*]]To be fair, hindsight reveals that most politicians on both sides ''also'' thought it was insane, but didn't have any better alternative: nukes were a way of life since the 50's and the genie couldn't be put back in the bottle. This is also why the various nuclear weapon reduction treaties were so contentious and difficult: SALT and START faced the prospect of reducing nuclear stockpiles from "We can kill everything everywhere several times over" to "If we fired our missiles just right, we might win now."[[/labelnote]] It may come up in hypothetical WorldWarIII scenarios or works set in the late-era (1980s) of the UsefulNotes/ColdWar. With the fall of the Soviet Union, MAD has lost its value as the focus shifts to combating [[TheWarOnTerror [[UsefulNotes/TheWarOnTerror terrorists]] who do not have access to a large stockpile of nuclear weapons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Franchise/MassEffect'': this is the main reason given in the codex for why [[ColonyDrop meteor drops]] aren't more common in warfare. By towing in a decent-sized asteroid and attaching a few fusion torches to it, just about anyone with a medium-sized (or above) warship can easily create a WMD capable of wiping out all life on a planet. The flip-side is that with ''every'' power in the galaxy being capable of it, they all know that doing it against just about anyone else would see the same thing happen to them. So it's rarely used. The krogan did it during the Krogan Rebellions, and indeed did render several worlds totally uninhabitable, but all that did was confirm that they had crossed an InUniverse MoralEventHorizon, which then justified the turians hitting back with their ''own'' banned WMD: [[SterilityPlague a self-replicating bioweapon.]] Notably, the unrepentant batarian murderer and slaver Charn in the ''Bring Down the Sky'' DLC is horrified when he learns that his boss, Balak, intends to drop a meteor on the human colony of Terra Nova, as him doing so would force the Council races to retaliate in kind, very possibly to the point of exterminating the entire batarian race.
** Note that meteor drops ''can'' be stopped (either by shutting off/destroying the thrusters or by destroying the ship before it can tow in any asteroids), particularly if the defender has total space superiority. It's simply disproportionately difficult to do so unless the disparity in forces in capabilities is truly massive. In ''VideoGame/MassEffect3'', Garrus casually suggests dropping a few planet-killing meteors on geth-held Rannoch, and no one treats this suggestion as impossible even though the geth held space superiority at the time and were winning the space battle against the quarians. Instead the idea was shot down because it would [[ShaggyDogStory render pointless]] the entire mission, that being to take back Rannoch for habitation.
** Subverted in the lawless Terminus systems, where small states ("small" meaning "only controls one or a few planets") apparently use meteor drops against each other fairly often. They call that 20% of the galaxy the [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything "third galaxy"]] for a reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Natter. Also, not technically a failed MAD policy, just a standard Outside Context Problem. If it was an example of MAD failure, every nation would have assumed every other nation was to blame and started shooting.


* ''Webcomic/SchlockMercenary'': Discussed. When the galaxy was bound by a PortalNetwork, there was no Mutually Assured Destruction; the wormgates limited the size of ships that could use them, meaning that it was far easier to defend a system than attack. With the invention of the [[{{Teleportation}} teraport]], that limit was removed, edging the galaxy closer to MAD--but the use of [[TeleportInterdiction Teraport Area Denial]] prevented the most dangerous uses of the technology. Then "long-guns" were invented, giant cannons that shoot through hyperspace and overwhelm TAD; with proper location data, they can shoot at anywhere in the galaxy from anywhere in the galaxy. The galaxy was well and truly back in a state of MAD, since there was no defense. The various galactic leaders insist that while this system is terrifying, that's why it works; no one likes the fail state. [[DeusEstMachina Petey]] points out that eventually they'll find someone who ''does'' like the fail state, and then the entire galaxy will die, so they need to find a better solution[[note]]Turns out there is someone who loves the fail state: they're in another galaxy. And they're not made of regular matter so they love the prospect of watching not-matter burn on a galactic scale[[/note]]. Finally, there have been multiple previous epochs of galactic history that were destroyed by failed MAD policies. The very rare surviving species call the long-guns "end-guns" for this reason.

to:

* ''Webcomic/SchlockMercenary'': Discussed. When the galaxy was bound by a PortalNetwork, there was no Mutually Assured Destruction; the wormgates limited the size of ships that could use them, meaning that it was far easier to defend a system than attack. With the invention of the [[{{Teleportation}} teraport]], that limit was removed, edging the galaxy closer to MAD--but the use of [[TeleportInterdiction Teraport Area Denial]] prevented the most dangerous uses of the technology. Then "long-guns" were invented, giant cannons that shoot through hyperspace and overwhelm TAD; with proper location data, they can shoot at anywhere in the galaxy from anywhere in the galaxy. The galaxy was well and truly back in a state of MAD, since there was no defense. The various galactic leaders insist that while this system is terrifying, that's why it works; no one likes the fail state. [[DeusEstMachina Petey]] points out that eventually they'll find someone who ''does'' like the fail state, and then the entire galaxy will die, so they need to find a better solution[[note]]Turns out there is someone who loves the fail state: they're in another galaxy. And they're not made of regular matter so they love the prospect of watching not-matter burn on a galactic scale[[/note]].solution. Finally, there have been multiple previous epochs of galactic history that were destroyed by failed MAD policies. The very rare surviving species call the long-guns "end-guns" for this reason.

Added: 122

Changed: 209

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Webcomic/SchlockMercenary'': Discussed. When the galaxy was bound by a PortalNetwork, there was no Mutually Assured Destruction; the wormgates limited the size of ships that could use them, meaning that it was far easier to defend a system than attack. With the invention of the [[{{Teleportation}} teraport]], that limit was removed, edging the galaxy closer to MAD--but the use of [[TeleportInterdiction Teraport Area Denial]] prevented the most dangerous uses of the technology. Then "long-guns" were invented, giant cannons that shoot through hyperspace and overwhelm TAD; with proper location data, they can shoot at anywhere in the galaxy from anywhere in the galaxy. The galaxy was well and truly back in a state of MAD, since there was no defense. The various galactic leaders insist that while this system is terrifying, that's why it works; no one likes the fail state. [[DeusEstMachina Petey]] points out that eventually they'll find someone who ''does'' like the fail state, and then the entire galaxy will die, so they need to find a better solution. Finally, there have been multiple previous epochs of galactic history that were destroyed by failed MAD policies. The very rare surviving species call the long-guns "end-guns" for this reason.

to:

* ''Webcomic/SchlockMercenary'': Discussed. When the galaxy was bound by a PortalNetwork, there was no Mutually Assured Destruction; the wormgates limited the size of ships that could use them, meaning that it was far easier to defend a system than attack. With the invention of the [[{{Teleportation}} teraport]], that limit was removed, edging the galaxy closer to MAD--but the use of [[TeleportInterdiction Teraport Area Denial]] prevented the most dangerous uses of the technology. Then "long-guns" were invented, giant cannons that shoot through hyperspace and overwhelm TAD; with proper location data, they can shoot at anywhere in the galaxy from anywhere in the galaxy. The galaxy was well and truly back in a state of MAD, since there was no defense. The various galactic leaders insist that while this system is terrifying, that's why it works; no one likes the fail state. [[DeusEstMachina Petey]] points out that eventually they'll find someone who ''does'' like the fail state, and then the entire galaxy will die, so they need to find a better solution.solution[[note]]Turns out there is someone who loves the fail state: they're in another galaxy. And they're not made of regular matter so they love the prospect of watching not-matter burn on a galactic scale[[/note]]. Finally, there have been multiple previous epochs of galactic history that were destroyed by failed MAD policies. The very rare surviving species call the long-guns "end-guns" for this reason.reason.
* [[https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2014-03-30 SMBC's Jack and the accidental invention of high-fantasy drop warheads]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Fanfic/FalloutEquestria'': Fluttershy, as Equestria's Minister of Peace, created the megaspells as a part of the CARE initiative (Communally Assured Reciprocal Existence) with the intention of it being used to augment shields and healing magic. She gave the technology to both sides of the pony/zebra war, hoping that if neither side would kill the other, both would give up on the war. It took both sides about four seconds to weaponize it instead. But of course, neither side could use them without being annihilated by the other side, forcing them to fight a traditional war. [[spoiler:When the zebras were on the cusp of defeat, they used their megaspells, Equestria responded with their own, and that was the end. Since the zebras believed that they would never survive surrender, they had nothing to lose by just going all-in]].

to:

* ''Fanfic/FalloutEquestria'': Fluttershy, as Equestria's Minister of Peace, created the megaspells megaspell as a part of the CARE initiative (Communally Assured Reciprocal Existence) with the intention of it being used to augment shields and healing magic. She gave the technology to both sides of the pony/zebra war, hoping that if neither side would kill the other, both would give up on the war. It took both sides about four seconds to weaponize it instead. But of course, neither side could use them without being annihilated by the other side, forcing them to fight a traditional war. [[spoiler:When the zebras were on the cusp of defeat, they used their megaspells, Equestria responded with their own, and that was the end. Since the zebras believed that they would never survive surrender, they had nothing to lose by just going all-in]].

Added: 186

Changed: 811

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The backstory of ''Fanfic/FalloutEquestria'' was that the megaspell was created and given to both sides to invoke this scenario and end the pony/zebra war. However, when the zebras believed they were doomed to lose the war anyway, they decided to go the "TakingYouWithMe" route and both sides ended up flinging them off.
** [[spoiler: The truth is a little more complicated. Equestria's Minister of Peace created the megaspell as a part of the CARE initiative (Communually Assured Reciprocal Existence) with the intention of it being used to augment shields and healing magic. She gave the technology to both sides, hoping that if neither side would kill the other, both would give up on the war. It took both sides about four seconds to weaponize it instead.]]

to:


* The backstory of ''Fanfic/FalloutEquestria'' was that the megaspell was created and given to both sides to invoke this scenario and end the pony/zebra war. However, when the zebras believed they were doomed to lose the war anyway, they decided to go the "TakingYouWithMe" route and both sides ended up flinging them off.
** [[spoiler: The truth is a little more complicated.
''Fanfic/FalloutEquestria'': Fluttershy, as Equestria's Minister of Peace Peace, created the megaspell megaspells as a part of the CARE initiative (Communually (Communally Assured Reciprocal Existence) with the intention of it being used to augment shields and healing magic. She gave the technology to both sides, sides of the pony/zebra war, hoping that if neither side would kill the other, both would give up on the war. It took both sides about four seconds to weaponize it instead.]] But of course, neither side could use them without being annihilated by the other side, forcing them to fight a traditional war. [[spoiler:When the zebras were on the cusp of defeat, they used their megaspells, Equestria responded with their own, and that was the end. Since the zebras believed that they would never survive surrender, they had nothing to lose by just going all-in]].
-->'''Steelhooves:''' In a world where not everyone is sane, it is the height of insanity to believe you could create a weapon so devastating, so horrible, that no one would dare use it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* This concept is basically what makes the world of ''Literature/NineteenEightyFour'' so utterly horrible. There's three big superpowers that are all at war with each other but they have a gentleman's agreement to not seriously try to conquer or destroy each other: war is a great excuse to waste resources, keep the standard of living down and control the population through MyCountryRightOrWrong. The leaders of Oceania, Eurasia and Eastasia can't take their sadistic tendencies out on each others' peoples, [[HumansAreBastards so they take it out on their own people instead]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''WesternAnimation/YoungJustice: Outsiders'', The Light considers their "Nuclear Option" this, since said "Nuclear Option" is to murder every last member of the Justice League's family, which would lead to the grief-stricken Leaguers to hunt down The Light and destroy them. They treat this as their GodzillaThreshold, murdering Ocean-Master when he attempts it for shits and giggles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


Compare MutualKill and TakingYouWithMe.

Top