Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / MainstreamObscurity

Go To

OR

Added: 139

Changed: 375

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWire

to:

* TheWire
TheWire is possibly the most acclaimed drama series in the history of television. And more people have watched it on Netflix than in its original run.
**Though not necessarily to the same extent as TheWire, this applies to most HBO shows (aside from SexAndTheCity), including TheSopranos, and even {{TrueBlood}}'s ratings aren't that great for a show with as much fan buzz as it has.
* Likewise, AMC's MadMen and BreakingBad continue to get pretty mediocre ratings for show as well-known and award-winning as they both are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**YMMV, especially for those over 30. It's more understandable for those younger than 30.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***CriticalResearchFailure. Many fans outside of the UK knew a play existed before the movie. The movie was created based on the short-lived Broadway run of the play.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** Partly because of the overall dullness of the parts leaving and actually seeing the whale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This might happen with acclaimed games that received a highly limited print run when released and have yet to be rereleased. For example, every gamer knows about ''{{Earthbound}}'' due to its status as one of the best 16-bit RPGs and Ness' appearance in SuperSmashBros. However, if you want to play it, your only options are to purchase an extremely expensive used copy (upwards of $80 just for the cartridge), or acquire it using [[{{Emulation}} certain other means]]. As a result, everyone has heard of Earthbound and is familiar with the game's main character, but far fewer have played it.

to:

* This might happen with acclaimed games that received a highly limited print run when released and have yet to be rereleased. For example, every gamer knows about ''{{Earthbound}}'' due to its status as one of the best 16-bit RPGs [=RPGs=] and Ness' appearance in SuperSmashBros. However, if you want to play it, your only options are to purchase an extremely expensive used copy (upwards of $80 just for the cartridge), or acquire it using [[{{Emulation}} certain other means]]. As a result, everyone has heard of Earthbound and is familiar with the game's main character, but far fewer have played it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Partly because of the overall dullness of the parts leaving and actually seeing the whale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixed a title


* ''TheStrangeCaseOfDrJekyllAndMrHyde'' by Robert Louis Stevenson. Most people know the names and the basic premise, and [[JekyllAndHyde the expression for dramatic personality shift that it spawned]]. There have been over a hundred full adaptations made, and countless references in popular culture, usually involving people quaffing potions and becoming monsters. Now, who can name the narrator in the book?

to:

* ''TheStrangeCaseOfDrJekyllAndMrHyde'' ''TheStrangeCaseOfDoctorJekyllAndMrHyde'' by Robert Louis Stevenson. Most people know the names and the basic premise, and [[JekyllAndHyde the expression for dramatic personality shift that it spawned]]. There have been over a hundred full adaptations made, and countless references in popular culture, usually involving people quaffing potions and becoming monsters. Now, who can name the narrator in the book?

Added: 525

Changed: 129

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* May be justified in the case of ''Mein Kampf'', as selling this book is illegal in several countries.



** The whole idea that Machiavelli was some kind of EvilChancellor stems from the fact, that most people using the term ''machiavellism'' have neither read ''The Prince'' nor know anything about its contents. Actually the recurring theme of the book is that ruler suffering from ChronicBackstabbingDisorder will sooner or later be HoistedByHisOwnPetard.



** Just ask people what was the name of the Frankenstein's Monster...





to:

\n* Most Roman Catholics do not bother to read Catechism although they pretty well know that is contains all tenets of their faith.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Ask anyone what the plot of the original film is. Most people will give you an answer along the lines of "[[MenInRubberSuits Guy in dinosaur/lizard costume]] [[SpecialEffectsFailure smashes model buildings.]]". Likewise, people in general are surprised to find out that the original ''Gojira'' is a dark somber allegory rather than a cheesy "monster on the loose" film.


Added DiffLines:

** The AudienceParticipation within the film also counts. Sure, people in general know you're supposed to use props and yell certain lines when watching the movie. But, ask anyone who hasn't seen the film what you're supposed to say and when.
** The ''Time Warp'' itself certainly counts. People know it's a DanceSensation song. People in general know how to do the moves, and will dance to it on Halloween. But, ask people in general which movie it's from.
** The original play. The movie is has a ''huge'' cult following, but people outside the UK (Where the original play is still being shown and is immensely popular) in general probably never heard of the play.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n* TheWire




to:

* HipHop for the most part subverts this. Most classic rap albums are well known at least regionally if not nationally. If it had a buzz and was critically acclaimed people knew about it and heard it cause most of those albums was insanely popular. The DJ's helped with said classic albums popularity as well. HOWEVER some younger Gen-Y rap fans admittedly are probably not familiar (unless they had older siblings whom played the music).



* TheWire

to:

* TheWire

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* TheWire
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* On an individual level, James Dean's career. He's one of the most iconic images of America, but you'd be hard-pressed to find someone who's watched ''Rebel Without a Cause.''

to:

* On an individual level, James Dean's career. He's one of the most iconic images of America, but you'd be hard-pressed to find someone who's watched ''Rebel Without a Cause.''RebelWithoutACause.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Niccolò Machiavelli. Everyone has heard of him, or at least the adjective that he spawned. Few have actually read the treatise that earned him his reputation. Come to that, not that many could ''name'' it. It's called ''Il Principe'' (The Prince), and is presented as advice to a young monarch on how to rule.
** Well, that and Discourses on the First Ten Books of Titus Livy (more often known as TheDiscourses), which probably presents his personal views on how things should be done as opposed to how they are done in practice as detailed in ''The Prince'', which was probably written with Pope Alexander VI's son Caesar in mind.

to:

* Niccolò Machiavelli. Everyone has heard of him, or at least the adjective that he spawned. Few have actually read the treatise that earned him his reputation. Come to that, not that many could ''name'' it. It's called ''Il Principe'' (The Prince), (ThePrince), and is presented as advice to a young monarch on how to rule.
** Well, that and [[DiscoursesOnLivy Discourses on the First Ten Books of Titus Livy Livy]] (more often known as TheDiscourses), The Discourses), which probably presents his personal views on how things should be done as opposed to how they are done in practice as detailed in ''The Prince'', which was probably written with Pope Alexander VI's son Caesar in mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** To the extent that fans of the game will at least grant credit to those that profess to disliking the game, merely because they've heard of it and played it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not sure if that counts. Most people aren't aware that the latter is based on anything, least of all a Japanese movie about samurai. If you told them to guess the plot of ''SevenSamurai'' after that revelation, they'd probably get it mostly right but not due to this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* There's also the fact that many gamers have played little of the console generations before the era in which they first started playing games. Among younger gamers, for example, MainstreamObscurity may apply to even something like the original ''TheLegendOfZelda'' or ''{{Metroid}}'', or even to something as recent as ''FinalFantasyVII''. This arguably crosses into FanMyopia territory, though.

to:

* There's also the fact that many gamers have played little of the console generations before the era in which they first started playing games. Among younger gamers, for example, MainstreamObscurity may apply to even something like the original ''TheLegendOfZelda'' or ''{{Metroid}}'', or even to something as recent as ''FinalFantasyVII''. This arguably crosses into FanMyopia territory, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Ico}} is considered ''the'' seminal example of how video games can be art (perhaps trailing only behind its SpiritualSuccessor, ''ShadowOfTheColossus''), but only sold 700,000 copies worldwide. Far more people have heard of it than played it.

to:

* {{Ico}} is considered often offered as ''the'' seminal example of how video games can be art (perhaps trailing only behind its SpiritualSuccessor, ''ShadowOfTheColossus''), but only sold 700,000 copies worldwide. Far more people have heard of it than played it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:VideoGames]]
* This might happen with acclaimed games that received a highly limited print run when released and have yet to be rereleased. For example, every gamer knows about ''{{Earthbound}}'' due to its status as one of the best 16-bit RPGs and Ness' appearance in SuperSmashBros. However, if you want to play it, your only options are to purchase an extremely expensive used copy (upwards of $80 just for the cartridge), or acquire it using [[{{Emulation}} certain other means]]. As a result, everyone has heard of Earthbound and is familiar with the game's main character, but far fewer have played it.
*There's also the fact that many gamers have played little of the console generations before the era in which they first started playing games. Among younger gamers, for example, MainstreamObscurity may apply to even something like the original ''TheLegendOfZelda'' or ''{{Metroid}}'', or even to something as recent as ''FinalFantasyVII''. This arguably crosses into FanMyopia territory, though.
*{{Ico}} is considered ''the'' seminal example of how video games can be art (perhaps trailing only behind its SpiritualSuccessor, ''ShadowOfTheColossus''), but only sold 700,000 copies worldwide. Far more people have heard of it than played it.
*''{{Psychonauts}}'' was considered a brilliant game but sold pitifully due to lack of marketing and mainstream appeal. It's always one of the first games mentioned when people discuss underrated games, but good luck finding large numbers of people that have played it.

Added: 280

Changed: 176

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The latter has been helped by a revival with ''RiffTrax''.




to:

* On an individual level, James Dean's career. He's one of the most iconic images of America, but you'd be hard-pressed to find someone who's watched ''Rebel Without a Cause.''


Added DiffLines:

** Take this and double it for any opinion of the U.S. Supreme Court. You could find fifty people with opinions about ''Roe v. Wade'' strong enough to provoke violence before you met a single one who'd actually read it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* More people would be able to identify [[HPLovecraft Cthulhu]] than have actually read an H.P. Lovecraft story, even The Call of Cthulhu. Most of them are still geeks, so Cthulhu isn't really ''mainstream'' yet, but Cthulhu is certainly more well known than the ''text'' of the work.

Added: 100

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



Feel free to brag about MainstreamObscurity works you actually read/watched at the TroperTales page.



[[AC:LiveActionTelevision]]
* BuffyTheVampireSlayer: Because of its attractive star and support from critics, it's not exactly ignored by the press. The name also makes it very memorable. Finally, there's generally a lack of A) Canonical vampire slayers, and 2) Female leads in genre programs, so Buffy the character usually finds a niche in the pop-culture conversation. However, the show ''itself'' was never highly watched in its prime.

to:

[[AC:LiveActionTelevision]]
[[AC:LiveActionTV]]
* BuffyTheVampireSlayer: ''BuffyTheVampireSlayer'': Because of its attractive star and support from critics, it's not exactly ignored by the press. The name also makes it very memorable. Finally, there's generally a lack of A) Canonical vampire slayers, and 2) Female leads in genre programs, so Buffy the character usually finds a niche in the pop-culture conversation. However, the show ''itself'' was never highly watched in its prime.



* Richard Wagner. You definitely know ''Ride of the Valkyries'' from ''Die Walküre'' and the ''Bridal Chorus'' from ''Lohengrin'' (though probably without the words), and you might know ''The Pilgrims' Chorus'' from ''Tannhauser'' (though it isn't performed in one chunk like that in the opera) but that will be about it. He wrote 113 compositions, including 13 operas (most of which were rather too long, making their MainstreamObscurity understandable).

to:

* Richard Wagner.RichardWagner. You definitely know ''Ride of the Valkyries'' from ''Die Walküre'' and the ''Bridal Chorus'' from ''Lohengrin'' (though probably without the words), and you might know ''The Pilgrims' Chorus'' from ''Tannhauser'' (though it isn't performed in one chunk like that in the opera) but that will be about it. He wrote 113 compositions, including 13 operas (most of which were rather too long, making their MainstreamObscurity understandable).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CharlesDickens - With the possible exception of ''AChristmasCarol'', which can be read in an afternoon, more people know the more vivid details than have actually read any of the books, which tend to be lengthy and not exactly easy going.

to:

* CharlesDickens - With the possible exception of ''AChristmasCarol'', which can be read in an afternoon, more people know the more vivid details than have actually read any of the books, which tend to be lengthy and not exactly easy going.
going.
* ''ArabianNights''. Made even worse by the facts that many old translations were heavily {{Bowdlerised}}. And well known tales like Aladdin and Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves? Yeah, they weren't originally part of the work, but were added by European translators. So think twice if you think you know ''ArabianNights''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The works of Alexandre Dumas. People may be familiar with ''TheCountOfMonteCristo'', but few will have read it. They will almost certainly be familiar with ''TheThreeMusketeers'', but they won't have read it either, and quite likely aren't aware that it has sequels. (Extreme cases may even be unaware that it was a book to begin with, and not just general folklore a la RobinHood).

to:

* The works of Alexandre Dumas.AlexandreDumas. People may be familiar with ''TheCountOfMonteCristo'', but few will have read it. They will almost certainly be familiar with ''TheThreeMusketeers'', but they won't have read it either, and quite likely aren't aware that it has sequels. (Extreme cases may even be unaware that it was a book to begin with, and not just general folklore a la RobinHood).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* CharlesDickens - With the possible exception of ''AChristmasCarol'', which can be read in an afternoon, more people know the more vivid details than have actually read any of the books, which tend to be lengthy and not exactly easy going.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Which is a great shame because it is a very enjoyable film, not just 'worthy'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The reverse of FanMyopia. Often happens when a CultClassic becomes so well known for being a Cult Classic (due to PopculturalOsmosis) that the Cult Classic becomes mainstream. This can of course lead to AdaptationDisplacement and BeamMeUpScotty. The opposite is [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontWatch Complaining About Shows You Don't Watch]], where people, well, [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin do exactly that]].

to:

The reverse of FanMyopia. Often happens when a CultClassic becomes so well known for being a Cult Classic (due to PopculturalOsmosis) that the Cult Classic becomes mainstream. This can of course lead to AdaptationDisplacement and BeamMeUpScotty. The opposite is [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontWatch Complaining About Shows You Don't Watch]] and [[PraisingShowsYouDontWatch Praising Shows You Don't Watch]], where people, well, [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin do exactly that]].



***Ancillary merchandise actually helps in this matter greatly, keeping these properties that rarely make the best-seller lists of books in the public eye. Go into a discount store, Wal-Mart, etc. and look for the tie-in items such as coloring books, plastic cups, ice cream, etc. In the case of Superman and perhaps Dick Tracy and a few others, cut rate DVD copies of public domain films and shorts from the 1930's and 1940's also help.

to:

***Ancillary merchandise actually helps in this matter greatly, keeping these properties that rarely make the best-seller lists of books in the public eye. Go into a discount store, Wal-Mart, etc. and look for the tie-in items such as coloring books, plastic cups, ice cream, etc. In the case of Superman and perhaps Dick Tracy DickTracy and a few others, cut rate DVD copies of public domain films and shorts from the 1930's and 1940's also help.



*Kurosawa's ''SevenSamurai'' is an interesting example, in that more people have seen ''The Magnificent Seven'' than the film upon which it is based.

to:

*Kurosawa's ''SevenSamurai'' is an interesting example, in that more people have seen ''The Magnificent Seven'' ''TheMagnificentSeven'' than the film upon which it is based.



* On that subject, [[hottip:*:especially as it was partly inspired the The Count of Monte Cristo, ]] ''BenHur: A Tale of the Christ'' by Lew Wallace. Yes, the [[AdaptationDisplacement films were based on a book]]. No, the book is a well-researched but original work of historical fiction and title character Judah Ben-Hur was not based on a real person of that era. [[PopculturalOsmosis Everyone knows]] there was a rather brutal chariot race near the end, but that's often as far as it goes. As for actually ''reading'' the book or even ''knowing'' about it... that's rather less common. And the classic films themselves possess a similar MainstreamObscurity to ''{{Casablanca}}'' or ''CitizenKane''.

to:

* On that subject, [[hottip:*:especially as it was partly inspired the The Count of Monte Cristo, ]] ''BenHur: A Tale of the Christ'' by Lew Wallace. Yes, the [[AdaptationDisplacement films were based on a book]]. No, the book is a well-researched but original work of historical fiction and title character Judah Ben-Hur was not based on a real person of that era. [[PopculturalOsmosis Everyone knows]] there was a rather brutal chariot race near the end, but that's often as far as it goes. As for actually ''reading'' the book or even ''knowing'' about it... that's rather less common. And the classic films themselves possess a similar MainstreamObscurity to ''{{Casablanca}}'' or ''CitizenKane''.''CitizenKane'' - many people just know that the 1959 film has CharltonHeston, a chariot race and is long as hell.



* ''The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde'' by Robert Louis Stevenson. Most people know the names and the basic premise, and the expression for dramatic personality shift that it spawned. There have been over a hundred full adaptations made, and countless references in popular culture, usually involving people quaffing potions and becoming monsters. Now, who can name the narrator in the book?

to:

* ''The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde'' ''TheStrangeCaseOfDrJekyllAndMrHyde'' by Robert Louis Stevenson. Most people know the names and the basic premise, and [[JekyllAndHyde the expression for dramatic personality shift that it spawned.spawned]]. There have been over a hundred full adaptations made, and countless references in popular culture, usually involving people quaffing potions and becoming monsters. Now, who can name the narrator in the book?



* Many of the most critically hailed rock albums of all time suffer from this. Most people recognize ''The Velvet Underground and Nico'' for its AndyWarhol banana cover, but only hardcore rock fans can name any of its tracks. Radiohead's ''OK Computer'' was named the best album of the '90s in a recent poll, but, again, few people can name a single track from it. And Richard (with or without Linda) Thompson always has several albums on best-of lists, but few people can name any of his songs.

to:

* Many of the most critically hailed rock albums of all time [[http://www.jericsmith.com/sacredcows.htm suffer from this. this]]. Most people recognize ''The Velvet Underground ''TheVelvetUnderground and Nico'' for its AndyWarhol banana cover, but only hardcore rock fans can name any of its tracks. Radiohead's {{Radiohead}}'s ''OK Computer'' was named the best album of the '90s in a recent poll, but, again, few people can name a single track from it. And Richard (with or without Linda) Thompson always has several albums on best-of lists, but few people can name any of his songs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Which can be kind of sad as the stories are very short and easy to get into.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Though ''[=~2001: A Space Odyssey~=]'' is consistently considered a film classic, and most people recognize the calming red orb of HAL9000 and will quote him on command, relatively few have the patience to sit through one of the slowest and most boggling movies ever made. Healthy doses of ''RealityIsUnrealistic'' and ''SpaceDoesNotWorkThatWay'' are probably to blame, as Kubrick's realist vision of apes and zero-g toilets just doesn't mesh with what most audiences expect from a movie about aliens and spaceships.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Stephen Hawking's ''ABriefHistoryOfTime'' has sold more than 9 million copies and is probably the first thing people think of when anyone mentions Stephen Hawking (aside from his voice), but is often cited as an example of an "unread bestseller".

to:

* Stephen Hawking's ''ABriefHistoryOfTime'' StephenHawking's ''A Brief History of Time'' has sold more than 9 million copies and is probably the first thing people think of when anyone mentions Stephen Hawking (aside from his voice), but is often cited as an example of an "unread bestseller".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Stephen Hawking's ''ABriefHistoryOfTime'' has sold more than 9 million copies and is probably the first thing people think of when anyone mentions Stephen Hawking (aside from his voice), but is often cited as an example of an "unread bestseller".

Top