Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / IntangibleTimeTravel

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Sometimes, this isn't time travel at all; the "traveler" is having a vision or visiting someone's memory. Other times, the line gets blurred.

to:

Sometimes, this isn't time travel at all; the "traveler" is having a vision or visiting someone's memory. Other times, the line gets blurred.
blurred. Functionally, there isn't really a difference.

Changed: 103

Removed: 129

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also PensieveFlashback. Compare MentalTimeTravel and CantTakeAnythingWithYou.

to:

See also PensieveFlashback. Compare MentalTimeTravel and CantTakeAnythingWithYou.
CantTakeAnythingWithYou. If the person observes another time through a device without going anywhere, that's a {{Chronoscope}}.



* In the short Creator/PhilipKDick story ''Paycheck'' a "timescope" exists which gives people the ability to see into the future.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Azmuth did this once in [[Recap/Ben10UltimateAlienS3E11SolitaryAlignment an episode]] of ''WesternAnimation/Ben10UltimateAlien'' in which he showed how he created [[CoolSword Ascalon]].

to:

* Azmuth did this once in [[Recap/Ben10UltimateAlienS3E11SolitaryAlignment an episode]] episode of ''WesternAnimation/Ben10UltimateAlien'' in which he showed how he created [[CoolSword Ascalon]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Zig-zagged in ''VideoGame/GhostTrickPhantomDetective''. One of the protagonist's ghost tricks is to travel back in time, to four minutes before a person's death. Despite being a ghost, he averts this trope; he can still interact with the world through the objects he possesses. However, other ghosts that don't have ghost tricks can tag along with him; they play this trope straight by only being able to speak with the protagonist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also: PensieveFlashback.

to:

See also: PensieveFlashback.
also PensieveFlashback. Compare MentalTimeTravel and CantTakeAnythingWithYou.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheWellOfMoments'' is a simple 5th-century stone pot with runes around the rim—except looking into it will show the viewer snippets of the past, their own or someone else's, as if they're really there reliving the experience. Its ringed "lid" is called the Eye of Sorrows, which looks to the future. Putting them together is a very bad idea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Unfortunately, that also means ''none'' of your senses work, since all of them operate via the interaction of molecules: no light particles strike your retinas, no sound waves jiggle your ear drums, no flavors reach your taste buds, no odors waft up your nostrils, and nothing on your skin or in your body could react to the surrounding environment. Also, depending on how space-time worked, your own personal time may also have to be frozen in order for the ''no disturbance'' rule to be obeyed.\\

to:

Unfortunately, that also means ''none'' of your senses work, since all of them operate via the interaction of molecules: no light particles strike your retinas, no sound waves jiggle your ear drums, no flavors reach your taste buds, no odors waft up your nostrils, and nothing on your skin or in your body could react to the surrounding environment. Also, depending on how space-time worked, is actually connected, your own personal time may also have to be frozen in order for to obey the ''no disturbance'' "no disturbance" rule to be obeyed.\\ (so you don't, say, asphyxiate shortly after you arrive in the past and fuck things up that way).



Thus, the trope would be inverted: you could be there, but not be able to witness anything.

to:

Thus, the trope would be inverted: you could be there, but not you'd be able to experience or witness anything.precisely nil.

Added: 93

Changed: 547

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Real Life]]

to:

[[folder:Real Life]][[folder:Theoretical Physics]]



Unfortunately, that means you wouldn't be able to ''see'' anything, because light wouldn't interact with your retinas. Or hear anything, because the sound waves wouldn't be able to vibrate against your inner ear. Thus, the trope would be inverted: you could be there but not be able to witness anything.

to:

Unfortunately, that also means you wouldn't be able to ''see'' anything, because ''none'' of your senses work, since all of them operate via the interaction of molecules: no light wouldn't interact with particles strike your retinas. Or hear anything, because the retinas, no sound waves wouldn't be able to vibrate against jiggle your inner ear. ear drums, no flavors reach your taste buds, no odors waft up your nostrils, and nothing on your skin or in your body could react to the surrounding environment. Also, depending on how space-time worked, your own personal time may also have to be frozen in order for the ''no disturbance'' rule to be obeyed.\\
\\
Thus, the trope would be inverted: you could be there there, but not be able to witness anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
add to this


Unfortunately, that means you wouldn't be able to ''see'' anything, because light wouldn't interact with your retinas. Or hear anything, because the sound waves wouldn't be able to vibrate against your inner ear.

to:

Unfortunately, that means you wouldn't be able to ''see'' anything, because light wouldn't interact with your retinas. Or hear anything, because the sound waves wouldn't be able to vibrate against your inner ear. Thus, the trope would be inverted: you could be there but not be able to witness anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Game of Thrones

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/GameOfThrones'': During Bran's visions of the past with (and later without) the Three-Eyed Raven, he experiences events this way: he feels as if he were physically present, but other than the Raven, no one else takes notice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jacen Solo has this ability, called "flow-walking", in the StarWarsExpandedUniverse books, in a universe which only [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Time_travel rarely]] features "regular" time travel.

to:

* Jacen Solo has this ability, called "flow-walking", in the StarWarsExpandedUniverse ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'' books, in a universe which only [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Time_travel rarely]] features "regular" time travel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Comicbook/{{Savage}}'' introduced the Thousand Year Stare, a technique developed by Volgan scientists [[spoiler:in collaboration with Ro-Busters]] that forces its victims to view millennia over the course of three days. This is used to develop war robots based on the ABC Warriors they see in the future - robots which will eventually develop into those same ABC Warriors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The Star Trek EU trilogy ''Literature/TheQContinuum'' has Q take Picard on a trip through Q's past to show him why he has to abort his current mission. Throughout the trip they remain in "observer mode".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/AChristmasCarol'' and its derivatives, the protagonist is usually taken backwards and forwards in time to see the errors he has committed how they will leave him unmourned. He is completely invisible, inaudible and intangible through these scenes.

to:

* In ''Literature/AChristmasCarol'' and [[YetAnotherChristmasCarol its derivatives, the protagonist many adaptations]], Ebeneezer Scrooge is usually taken backwards and forwards in through time to see the errors he has committed in the past, how it affects those in the present, and how they will leave him unmourned. He unmourned in the future. Scrooge is completely invisible, inaudible inaudible, and intangible through these scenes.scenes to anyone in the time period itself.



** Winked at again in WesternAnimation/{{Arthur}}'s send-up of the story. Prunella is in the role of "Scrooge." Her ghostly guide tells her that she can't be seen or heard by anybody while in the past. She's then bonked in the head by a rogue soccer-ball...

to:

** Winked at again in WesternAnimation/{{Arthur}}'s send-up of the story. Prunella is in the role of "Scrooge." Her ghostly guide tells her that she can't be seen or heard by anybody while in the past. She's then bonked in the head by a rogue soccer-ball...soccer-ball.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The novel ''The Light of Other Days'', by ArthurCClarke and StephenBaxter, is about the invention of a kind of wormhole technology that allows it's user to view any location, in real-time. Due to it being relatively easy to replicate, the technology soon gets out of the hands of the government and is available to the general public, which immediately has drastic social consequences (since, essentially, the concept of "privacy" no longer has any meaning). Then, it's discovered that the wormholes can also be projected into the ''past''...

to:

* The novel ''The Light of Other Days'', by ArthurCClarke Creator/ArthurCClarke and StephenBaxter, Creator/StephenBaxter, is about the invention of a kind of wormhole technology that allows it's user to view any location, in real-time. Due to it being relatively easy to replicate, the technology soon gets out of the hands of the government and is available to the general public, which immediately has drastic social consequences (since, essentially, the concept of "privacy" no longer has any meaning). Then, it's discovered that the wormholes can also be projected into the ''past''...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving page and wicks to UsefulNotes/, see Useful Notes Pages In Main


* Fans of sci-fi and/or TheInklings have been [[MissingEpisode looking for a long time for the]] TimeTravel story Creator/CSLewis alluded to in the prologue to ''Literature/TheGreatDivorce'' (1945), wherein a guy goes into the past, but its immutability means he cannot even eat a sandwich, or keep a raindrop from piercing him clear through.\\

to:

* Fans of sci-fi and/or TheInklings UsefulNotes/TheInklings have been [[MissingEpisode looking for a long time for the]] TimeTravel story Creator/CSLewis alluded to in the prologue to ''Literature/TheGreatDivorce'' (1945), wherein a guy goes into the past, but its immutability means he cannot even eat a sandwich, or keep a raindrop from piercing him clear through.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Azmuth did this once in [[Recap/Ben10UltimateAlienS3E11SolitaryAlignment an episode]] of ''Ben10UltimateAlien'' in which he showed how he created [[CoolSword Ascalon]].

to:

* Azmuth did this once in [[Recap/Ben10UltimateAlienS3E11SolitaryAlignment an episode]] of ''Ben10UltimateAlien'' ''WesternAnimation/Ben10UltimateAlien'' in which he showed how he created [[CoolSword Ascalon]].

Changed: 25

Removed: 71

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
link; film examples don't belong in the literature section


* At first, in ''{{Pastwatch}}: the Redemption of Christopher Columbus'', a machine called the Tempoview allows researchers to view and record history, supposedly unnoticed. (Turns out this isn't the case, and the technology is developed to allow standard TimeTravel.)
** The concept of the technology was used for the ''Film/DejaVu'' film.

to:

* At first, in ''{{Pastwatch}}: the Redemption of Christopher Columbus'', ''Literature/PastwatchTheRedemptionOfChristopherColumbus'', a machine called the Tempoview allows researchers to view and record history, supposedly unnoticed. (Turns out this isn't the case, and the technology is developed to allow standard TimeTravel.)
** The concept of the technology was used for the ''Film/DejaVu'' film.
)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The time travel based [[RealTimeStrategy RTS]] game ''{{Achron}}'' has this in the gameplay. The player is able to freely look at any point on the timeline, but if the time you are looking at is too far in the past you will be unable to make any changes to it.

to:

* The time travel based [[RealTimeStrategy RTS]] game ''{{Achron}}'' ''VideoGame/{{Achron}}'' has this in the gameplay. The player is able to freely look at any point on the timeline, but if the time you are looking at is too far in the past you will be unable to make any changes to it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The manga version of ''ChronoCrusade'' has Rosette taking a JourneyToTheCenterOfTheMind in Chrono's soul, allowing her to walk through his memories and see them first-hand.

to:

* The manga version of ''ChronoCrusade'' ''Manga/ChronoCrusade'' has Rosette taking a JourneyToTheCenterOfTheMind in Chrono's soul, allowing her to walk through his memories and see them first-hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Negi uses this in ''{{Mahou Sensei Negima}}'' to show Asuna, and accidentally all his other students (Nadoka used her book to see what they were talking about and ended up showing everyone else the visions), in order to show her what happened to his village and the reason he became a mage so that he could look for the Thousand Master. It was meant to show how them the kind of world they would end up in if they continued to help him as his contractors, and the very real possibility that any or all of them could end up killed (or some equal fate) by demons, or other mages, or what the hell ever else you could think of, the idea being that if he could scare them away they would be safe. And it does scare them... for all of about six seconds, until the realization of the things hes been through (his village being destroyed and the path hes been pushed into as such a young child, having to basically give up his childhood to find out the truth about himself and his family, and find a way to save the villagers who got turned to stone) makes them all so FURIOUS that they basically vow to be his personal army to help him.

to:

* Negi uses this in ''{{Mahou Sensei Negima}}'' ''Manga/MahouSenseiNegima'' to show Asuna, and accidentally all his other students (Nadoka used her book to see what they were talking about and ended up showing everyone else the visions), in order to show her what happened to his village and the reason he became a mage so that he could look for the Thousand Master. It was meant to show how them the kind of world they would end up in if they continued to help him as his contractors, and the very real possibility that any or all of them could end up killed (or some equal fate) by demons, or other mages, or what the hell ever else you could think of, the idea being that if he could scare them away they would be safe. And it does scare them... for all of about six seconds, until the realization of the things hes been through (his village being destroyed and the path hes been pushed into as such a young child, having to basically give up his childhood to find out the truth about himself and his family, and find a way to save the villagers who got turned to stone) makes them all so FURIOUS that they basically vow to be his personal army to help him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Murdoch Glourie, from the film ''Film/TheGhostGoesWest'', ghosts around for 200 years into the future (1935 being the future for him, and the present for the other characters), because he has some UnfinishedBusiness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Music]]
* Music/DanielAmos's ''Music/{{Alarma}}'' has a story in the liner notes where the narrator is transported via a dream into a city and finds he's completely invisible, inaudible, and intangible to everyone there. Which proves frustrating, as the narrator is also the OnlySaneMan, and he wants to scream at everyone to stop being such fools.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The [[UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks Golden Age]] and [[TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks Silver Age]] ''Comicbook/{{Superman}}'' comics had instances where Superman went intangible whenever he time-traveled under his own power. Of course, this was only in some issues; the writers [[TimeyWimeyBall changed the rules whenever it was convenient]]. This eventually calcified into a hard rule of time travel in TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks--travelers heading to a time they already existed in would be reduced to intangibility, but would remain solid and able to interact with others if there was no other copy of themselves around (the idea being that by making it impossible to physically be in two places at once, the universe was preventing [[TimeParadox paradoxes]]).
** Used to heartbreaking effect in ''ComicBook/WhateverHappenedToTheManOfTomorrow'' by Creator/AlanMoore, the last [[TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks Silver Age]] {{Superman}} story--the Legion of Superheroes comes to bid Superman farewell, and Supergirl, being a member, comes with them. The story takes place after Supergirl's death, and Supergirl wonders why she didn't turn intangible and asks Superman what she's like when she grows up. Superman tells her that "Supergirl is in the past", assures her that she grows up to be beautiful... and breaks down sobbing when they leave.

to:

* The [[UsefulNotes/TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks Golden Age]] and [[TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks [[UsefulNotes/TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks Silver Age]] ''Comicbook/{{Superman}}'' comics had instances where Superman went intangible whenever he time-traveled under his own power. Of course, this was only in some issues; the writers [[TimeyWimeyBall changed the rules whenever it was convenient]]. This eventually calcified into a hard rule of time travel in TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks--travelers UsefulNotes/TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks--travelers heading to a time they already existed in would be reduced to intangibility, but would remain solid and able to interact with others if there was no other copy of themselves around (the idea being that by making it impossible to physically be in two places at once, the universe was preventing [[TimeParadox paradoxes]]).
** Used to heartbreaking effect in ''ComicBook/WhateverHappenedToTheManOfTomorrow'' by Creator/AlanMoore, the last [[TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks [[UsefulNotes/TheSilverAgeOfComicBooks Silver Age]] {{Superman}} story--the Legion of Superheroes comes to bid Superman farewell, and Supergirl, being a member, comes with them. The story takes place after Supergirl's death, and Supergirl wonders why she didn't turn intangible and asks Superman what she's like when she grows up. Superman tells her that "Supergirl is in the past", assures her that she grows up to be beautiful... and breaks down sobbing when they leave.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The [[DreamLand dreamscape]] in ''{{Candorville}}'' connects to all places and times, so those who are asleep can view the past and the future (though they forget it when they wake.) They can interact with other dreamers in other times and places, but attempts to change the past [[YouCantFightFate never seem to work]].

to:

* The [[DreamLand dreamscape]] in ''{{Candorville}}'' ''ComicStrip/{{Candorville}}'' connects to all places and times, so those who are asleep can view the past and the future (though they forget it when they wake.) They can interact with other dreamers in other times and places, but attempts to change the past [[YouCantFightFate never seem to work]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''QuantumLeap'', Al is able to project himself into the past, but he is visible only to Sam and a selected few other characters (e.g. young children, animals, mentally ill). Sam has to do the hard physical work of [[SetRightWhatOnceWentWrong putting right what once went wrong]], and has to partially take the bodyspace of someone already in that time, he can't just appear via a portal.

to:

* In ''QuantumLeap'', ''Series/QuantumLeap'', Al is able to project himself into the past, but he is visible only to Sam and a selected few other characters (e.g. young children, animals, mentally ill). Sam has to do the hard physical work of [[SetRightWhatOnceWentWrong putting right what once went wrong]], and has to partially take the bodyspace of someone already in that time, he can't just appear via a portal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Manga/MiraiNikki'' had this when Murumuru showed Yuki the "true" behind Yuno´s secret [[spoiler:...killing her current timeline version in the past and proceeding to impersonating her. However, Yuki´s desire to save this alternative Yuno in this vision was strong enough to defy the trope and make the second world Yuno hear (or at least sense) him in some way and even (in a very sad scene) call him for help by writing with her blood in a wall, but all in vain...]]

to:

* ''Manga/MiraiNikki'' ''Manga/FutureDiary'' had this when Murumuru showed Yuki the "true" behind Yuno´s secret [[spoiler:...killing her current timeline version in the past and proceeding to impersonating her. However, Yuki´s desire to save this alternative Yuno in this vision was strong enough to defy the trope and make the second world Yuno hear (or at least sense) him in some way and even (in a very sad scene) call him for help by writing with her blood in a wall, but all in vain...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the first collection of ''ComicBook/TheBooksOfMagic'' by NeilGaiman, young Tim Hunter, a potentially very powerful human magician, gets taken back in time in this manner by ComicBook/ThePhantomStranger as part of his education on magic. Later, unusually, he physically travels into one possible future (which people generally tend to see as spirits rather than physical beings) with Mister E.

to:

* In the first collection of ''ComicBook/TheBooksOfMagic'' by NeilGaiman, Creator/NeilGaiman, young Tim Hunter, a potentially very powerful human magician, gets taken back in time in this manner by ComicBook/ThePhantomStranger as part of his education on magic. Later, unusually, he physically travels into one possible future (which people generally tend to see as spirits rather than physical beings) with Mister E.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/ItsAWonderfulLife'', after the Senior Angel assigns Clarence to go to Earth and talk George Bailey out of committing suicide, the two travel to various key moments in George's life so Clarence can observe what kind of man he is and how he has come to be in his current situation. For all intents and purposes, they appear to be literally watching the movie along with the viewers at home, MST3K-style, and the Senior Angel can even pause the "footage" to explain certain events in more detail.

to:

* In ''Film/ItsAWonderfulLife'', after the Senior Angel assigns Clarence to go to Earth and talk George Bailey out of committing suicide, the two travel to various key moments in George's life so Clarence can observe what kind of man he is and how he has come to be in his current situation. For all intents and purposes, they appear to be literally watching the movie along with the viewers at home, MST3K-style, [[Series/MysteryScienceTheater3000 MST3K]]-style, and the Senior Angel can even pause the "footage" to explain certain events in more detail.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added namespaces.


* In ''IncarnationsOfImmortality'', this happens if one time travels to a time period where they never existed.

to:

* In ''IncarnationsOfImmortality'', ''Literature/IncarnationsOfImmortality'', this happens if one time travels to a time period where they never existed.



* In HowToLiveSafelyInAScienceFictionalUniverse, the physics of the universe prevents you from going back to an event you weren't at and changing that event by throwing you into another timeline. A heartbreaking example is of a young woman who uses time travel to get back to the moment when her grandmother died, because she wasn't there the first time. The grandmother can neither see nor hear her; even though they're in the same room, they're actually separated by a universe.
* Fans of sci-fi and/or TheInklings have been [[MissingEpisode looking for a long time for the]] TimeTravel story Creator/CSLewis alluded to in the prologue to ''TheGreatDivorce'' (1945), wherein a guy goes into the past, but its immutability means he cannot even eat a sandwich, or keep a raindrop from piercing him clear through.\\

to:

* In HowToLiveSafelyInAScienceFictionalUniverse, Literature/HowToLiveSafelyInAScienceFictionalUniverse, the physics of the universe prevents you from going back to an event you weren't at and changing that event by throwing you into another timeline. A heartbreaking example is of a young woman who uses time travel to get back to the moment when her grandmother died, because she wasn't there the first time. The grandmother can neither see nor hear her; even though they're in the same room, they're actually separated by a universe.
* Fans of sci-fi and/or TheInklings have been [[MissingEpisode looking for a long time for the]] TimeTravel story Creator/CSLewis alluded to in the prologue to ''TheGreatDivorce'' ''Literature/TheGreatDivorce'' (1945), wherein a guy goes into the past, but its immutability means he cannot even eat a sandwich, or keep a raindrop from piercing him clear through.\\

Top