Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / IWillPunishYourFriendForYourFailure

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/StarTrekTheOriginalSeries''. In "The Cage", Captain Pike doesn't know Vina and doesn't especially like her, but he objects when she's punished for ''his'' lack of cooperation. This is all part of the Talosians' plan to make him breed with her, because it causes Pike to feel empathy for Vina over her unjust punishment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* This technique is frequently used in sports and military training, although to a less severe punishment; if one member of the group fails whatever test the trainer imposes, such as running laps under the time limit, the whole group has to do it again. The idea, as in many other cases, is that the individual will go all-out so that their teammates aren't punished.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The movie ''Film/MoneyTrain'' revolves around John and Charlie, foster brothers who work as cops in New York City's transit system. Near the start of the movie Charlie, who has [[TheGamblingAddict a gambling problem]], loses big in a poker game with a criminal named Mr. Brown, who's implied to be a LoanShark, and winds up $15,000 dollars in debt. A little more than halfway through the film John clears out his savings and gives Charlie enough money to pay Mr. Brown back... except that while taking the train to go see Mr. Brown, a random pickpocket takes the money from Charlie. Naturally Mr. Brown doesn't believe Charlie, and his men begin to give Charlie a nasty beating. Charlie is so low down at this point (having recently lost his job, the woman he was infatuated with, his brother's savings, etc.) that he accepts and even possibly encourages the goons to kill him. Mr. Brown sees that hurting or killing Charlie isn't going to get him paid, so he has his goons stop, and then tells Charlie that if he doesn't get paid, Mr. Brown will start going after ''John'' instead. This gets Charlie so desperate that he decides to attempt a TrainJob, to steal from the special security train that takes in cash revenue from the transit system and might as well be a rolling bank vault.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''First Family'' by Creator/DavidBaldacci begins with a kidnapping where one of the kidnappers, Darryl, accidentally kills a young girl's mother, to the outrage of their TragicVillain boss, Darryl's father Sam. Due to their relationship, Sam can't bring himself to kill Darryl, but he feels that he has to kill ''someone'' over what happened, and so, despite his son's pleas, he shoots the man who accompanied Darryl on the kidnapping.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/FireAndBlood'': With three enemy armies about to lay siege to King's Landing and depose him, King Aegon II tells Lord Corlys Velaryon, one of the few military commanders he has left, that if he and his son fail to defeat the incoming attackers, Aegon will have Corlys's granddaughter Baela (who Aegon had been keeping hostage) executed in retaliation. Unfortunately, Corlys responds to the threat by [[TakeAThirdOption joining a conspiracy of like-minded nobles]] who promptly assassinate Aegon and negotiate a truce with the enemy commanders.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''Fanfic/MariaCampbellOfTheAstralClocktower'': When it comes time to teach Katarina etiquette for real, Maria puts Shana, one of her young wards who has been learning etiquette on her own, in charge of her education. She explains to Katarina that rather than punishing ''her'' when she makes mistakes, Shana will lose dessert privileges. Katarina is horrified. Of course, Maria doesn't tell her that Shana will retain her normal dessert, the only thing in danger is the ''extra'' dessert she earned by agreeing to teach Katarina.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''VisualNovel/DoubleHomework'', Dennis eventually tells Johanna about the protagonist’s and Tamara’s roles in the Barbarossa incident in order to blackmail her into doing his bidding. He threatens to expose them if she doesn’t do what he says.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While the affected characters aren’t villains, the slave owner doing this trope certainly is in the ''{{Series/Firefly}}'' fic ''[[https://m.fanfiction.net/s/5502176/1 Freedom To The Free]]''. Simon, Kaylee River and Wash are enslaved and Simon takes a lot of physical and sexual abuse because the overseers keep threatening Wash and Kaylee if he refuses. Kaylee is threatened with rape if he won’t service one of the women and he’s ordered to do a castration despite it being against his oath with a threat to do it without anesthesia and do the same to Wash. By the time the BigDamnHeroes come to the rescue, he’s recovering physically but River says he’s broken like her after he has a nightmare involving a lot of screaming and Jayne needing to shoot the door open to get to him.

to:

* While the affected characters aren’t villains, the slave owner doing this trope certainly is in the ''{{Series/Firefly}}'' fic ''[[https://m.fanfiction.net/s/5502176/1 Freedom To The Free]]''. Simon, Kaylee River and Wash are enslaved and Simon takes a lot of physical and sexual abuse because the overseers keep threatening Wash and Kaylee if he refuses. Kaylee is threatened with rape if he won’t service one of the women owner and he’s ordered to do a castration despite it being against his oath with a threat to do it without anesthesia and do the same to Wash.Wash. He’s also ordered to kill the injured Wash if Wash doesn’t wake up after being beaten, or Kaylee and River will die. Fortunately Wash does wake up. By the time the BigDamnHeroes come to the rescue, he’s recovering physically but River says he’s broken like her after he has a nightmare involving a lot of screaming and Jayne needing to shoot the door open to get to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While the affected characters aren’t villains, the slave owner doing this trope certainly is in the ''{{Series/Firefly}}'' fic ''[[https://m.fanfiction.net/s/5502176/1 Freedom To The Free]]''. Simon, Kaylee and Wash are enslaved and Simon takes a lot of physical and sexual abuse because the overseers keep threatening Wash and Kaylee if he refuses. Kaylee is threatened with rape if he won’t service one of the women and he’s ordered to do a castration despite it being against his oath with a threat to do it without anesthesia and do the same to Wash. By the time the BigDamnHeroes come to the rescue, he’s recovering physically but River says he’s broken like her after he has a nightmare involving a lot of screaming and Jayne needing to shoot the door open to get to him.

to:

* While the affected characters aren’t villains, the slave owner doing this trope certainly is in the ''{{Series/Firefly}}'' fic ''[[https://m.fanfiction.net/s/5502176/1 Freedom To The Free]]''. Simon, Kaylee River and Wash are enslaved and Simon takes a lot of physical and sexual abuse because the overseers keep threatening Wash and Kaylee if he refuses. Kaylee is threatened with rape if he won’t service one of the women and he’s ordered to do a castration despite it being against his oath with a threat to do it without anesthesia and do the same to Wash. By the time the BigDamnHeroes come to the rescue, he’s recovering physically but River says he’s broken like her after he has a nightmare involving a lot of screaming and Jayne needing to shoot the door open to get to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While the affected characters aren’t villains, the slave owner doing this trope certainly is in the ''{{Series/Firefly}}'' fic ''[[https://m.fanfiction.net/s/5502176/1 Freedom To The Free]]''. Simon, Kaylee and Wash are enslaved and Simon takes a lot of physical and sexual abuse because the overseers keep threatening Wash and Kaylee if he refuses. By the time the BigDamnHeroes come to the rescue, he’s recovering physically but River says he’s broken like her after he has a nightmare involving a lot of screaming and Jayne needing to shoot the door open to get to him.

to:

* While the affected characters aren’t villains, the slave owner doing this trope certainly is in the ''{{Series/Firefly}}'' fic ''[[https://m.fanfiction.net/s/5502176/1 Freedom To The Free]]''. Simon, Kaylee and Wash are enslaved and Simon takes a lot of physical and sexual abuse because the overseers keep threatening Wash and Kaylee if he refuses. Kaylee is threatened with rape if he won’t service one of the women and he’s ordered to do a castration despite it being against his oath with a threat to do it without anesthesia and do the same to Wash. By the time the BigDamnHeroes come to the rescue, he’s recovering physically but River says he’s broken like her after he has a nightmare involving a lot of screaming and Jayne needing to shoot the door open to get to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* While the affected characters aren’t villains, the slave owner doing this trope certainly is in the ''{{Series/Firefly}}'' fic ''[[https://m.fanfiction.net/s/5502176/1 Freedom To The Free]]''. Simon, Kaylee and Wash are enslaved and Simon takes a lot of physical and sexual abuse because the overseers keep threatening Wash and Kaylee if he refuses. By the time the BigDamnHeroes come to the rescue, he’s recovering physically but River says he’s broken like her after he has a nightmare involving a lot of screaming and Jayne needing to shoot the door open to get to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added example(s) to Real Life folder

Added DiffLines:

* In Malaysia, penalties for drunk driving involve not only automatic jail time, but a provision that spouses of married drunk drivers also face incarceration.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* On one episode of ''Series/LawAndOrderSVU'', the case of the week involves a group of human traffickers who would collectively punish all of their child slaves if one of them broke a rule. This ensured the kids wouldn't run away when sent out to work or prostitute, because they were certain the others would be beaten or even killed if they ran. It also ensured that if one of them ''did'' try to step out of line, the others would rein that one in for fear of punishment; one boy ultimately killed his own sister when she tried to run, because he was afraid of what would happen if she got away. (When detectives point out that she might have intended to get help for all of them, [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone he's horrified]].)

to:

* On one episode of ''Series/LawAndOrderSVU'', the case of the week involves a group of human traffickers who would collectively punish all of their child slaves if one of them broke a rule. This ensured the kids wouldn't run away when sent out to work or prostitute, because they were certain the others would be beaten or even killed if they ran. It also ensured that if one of them ''did'' try to step out of line, the others would rein that one in for fear of punishment; one boy ultimately killed his own sister when she tried to run, because he was afraid of what would happen to him and the other children if she got away. (When detectives point out that she might have intended been trying not just to get away, but also to get help for all of them, him and the others, [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone he's horrified]].)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/SpaceGlass'': Marvelous says this to Bob after giving him a No-Holds-Barred Beatdown on the Albatross.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Fanfic/RainbowFactory'', [[spoiler:Rainbow Dash]] orders for Orion to be sacrificed to the Pegasus Device first due to him trying to comfort Scootaloo in her DarkestHour.
-->'''[[spoiler:Rainbow Dash]]''' You can’t have happiness. You ''ruined'' me. Now I’ll ruin you. Workers! The brown one, there! Him first!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/StarWarsTheCloneWars'' Due to the selfless paragon behavior of the Jedi, the Zygerrian Slavers of Kadavo managed to torture and torment Obi-Wan Kenobi by punishing the other slaves around him even when he tried to apologize for speaking out of turn.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Manga/AttackOnTitan'', Marley punishes disloyal Eldians, especially members of the Warrior unit, by not only having them turned into mindless titans and used as weapons of war, but also having their loved ones suffer the same fate. Colt and Falco barely avoided that fate after their uncle was outed as an Eldian restorationist, and Falco is warned that if he expresses misgivings about the Warrior program (particularly that his friend Gabi will have, at most, 13 years to live if she gets selected), he and his family could all be punished.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added

Added DiffLines:

* This is Keyser Soze’s entire strategy in ''Film/TheUsualSuspects''. He makes it clear to each member of the group that “owe” him that if they don’t cooperate he will kill anyone they care about. He also makes a big point that to get ahead you don’t need to have more people or bigger weapons, just the will to do what the other guy isn’t willing to do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In season 5 of ''Series/TheExpanse'', whenever a Belter faction agrees to join Marco Inaros's Free Navy, he insists on a crew exchange, sending on of his own trusted crewmembers to serve on a ship in that faction, while a member of that faction serves on Inaros's flagship ''Pella''. The implication is that any betrayal or failure by that faction will result in the "hostage" paying for it. [[spoiler:That's exactly what happens with Serge when Drummer betrays Inaros and saves the ''Rocinante''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[FauxAffablyEvil Bambi]] [[PsychoForHire "Buck"]] [[TheBogan Hughes]] is holding Jason Brody's friend Keith captive in ''VideoGame/FarCry3'' as a SexSlave, and if Jason botches up his FetchQuest to find a rare Chinese knife for Buck, Buck makes sure to hurt Keith instead.
-->'''Jason:''' [[RantInducingSlight I don't have your knife, all right?]]\\
'''Buck:''' [[LittleNo No]]... ''[[RapidFireNo no, no, no, no!]]'' Jason, that's ''not'' all right! It's just a little fucking knife that I asked you to get me, but you're too bloody incompetent- too ''fucking lazy'' to get it for me! ''[[LampshadeHanging Too busy playing games, aren't ya?!]]'' Well, fine. I'll just go [[DeadlyEuphemism play a game of Pin the Tail on the Donkey]] with Keith.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/JusticeLeague'': Mongul forces his champion gladiator to keep fighting on the Warworld by threatening to blow up his home planet if he refuses. Mongul tries the same threat on Superman, only to be informed by him that's [[DeathByOriginStory he's too late]]. Mongul brushes it off, correctly guessing Superman would still be forced to fight if he threatened to blow up ''any'' inhabited world.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/ChildrenOfRemnant'': Whenever Jaune's sisters did anything wrong (such as fighting with each other, or stalking their mother through the halls, or ''asking for food''), their mother would punish Jaune for it by locking him in "[[PunishmentBox the Hole]]" for days or weeks. This has resulted in two clear consequences: Jaune's sisters are heavily dependent on him, seeing him as their shield and protector even though they are far stronger than him, and Jaune has gotten it into his head that everyone else can get what they want so long as ''he'' is punished enough. [[spoiler:This results in him walking unarmed into a meeting with people who already tried to assassinate him once, because he thinks that once he's dead there will be world peace... not realizing that his death will drive his sisters insane and start a world war]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/DieHard'', John [=McClane=] is messing up Hans Gruber's plans. John's wife's coworker (whom he met once) tries to get in Gruber's good graces by attempting to talk his "friend" [=McClane=] into giving himself up. [=McClane=], fully aware of what kind of a person Hans Gruber is, tries to get the guy to admit he's lying but to no avail. Gruber smiles, and shoots the guy for his trouble.

to:

* In ''Film/DieHard'', John [=McClane=] is messing up Hans Gruber's plans. John's wife's coworker (whom he met once) tries to get in Gruber's good graces by attempting to talk his "friend" [=McClane=] into giving himself up. [=McClane=], fully aware of what kind of a person Hans Gruber is, tries to get the guy to admit he's lying but to no avail. Gruber smiles, and shoots the guy for his trouble.trouble, and then tells [=McClane=] that even if he was lying, he can start putting bullets into each and every hostage "until I find someone you care about".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Those Two Bad Guys is now Bumbling Henchmen Duo. If I'm cutting this example, it's either misuse or there's not enough context to tell if it's actually an example.


* Girem6 in ''Machinima/{{Smashtasm}}'' does this a lot to [[ThoseTwoBadGuys Grant and Gront]], as noted in this exchange:

to:

* Girem6 in ''Machinima/{{Smashtasm}}'' does this a lot to [[ThoseTwoBadGuys Grant and Gront]], Gront, as noted in this exchange:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* On one episode of ''Series/LawAndOrderSVU'', the case of the week involves a group of human traffickers who would collectively punish all of their child slaves if one of them broke a rule. This ensured the kids wouldn't run away when sent out to work or prostitute, because they were certain the others would be beaten or even killed if they ran. It also ensured that if one of them ''did'' try to step out of line, the others would rein that one in for fear of punishment; one boy ultimately killed his own sister when she tried to run, because he was afraid of what would happen if she got away. (When detectives point out that she might have been running to get help for the others, [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone he's horrified]].)

to:

* On one episode of ''Series/LawAndOrderSVU'', the case of the week involves a group of human traffickers who would collectively punish all of their child slaves if one of them broke a rule. This ensured the kids wouldn't run away when sent out to work or prostitute, because they were certain the others would be beaten or even killed if they ran. It also ensured that if one of them ''did'' try to step out of line, the others would rein that one in for fear of punishment; one boy ultimately killed his own sister when she tried to run, because he was afraid of what would happen if she got away. (When detectives point out that she might have been running intended to get help for the others, all of them, [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone he's horrified]].)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Anime/YuGiOh'', for the climactic battle of the Marik arc, Evil!Marik makes the board a setup which is basically this plus a SadisticChoice. He [[spoiler:pulls Yugi's soul and Normal!Marik's soul out of their respective bodies and hangs them up in the air. When the dueler loses life points, bits of the other's body are removed, and the loser's normal side "goes to the Shadow Realm" (as [[Creator/FourKidsEntertainment 4Kids]] [[{{Mackere}} puts it]]).]]

to:

* In ''Anime/YuGiOh'', for the climactic battle of the Marik arc, Evil!Marik makes the board a setup which is basically this plus a SadisticChoice. He [[spoiler:pulls pulls Yugi's soul and Normal!Marik's soul out of their respective bodies and hangs them up in the air. When the dueler loses life points, bits of the other's body are removed, and the loser's normal side "goes to vanishes. [[spoiler:He loses when normal Marik regains control of the Shadow Realm" (as [[Creator/FourKidsEntertainment 4Kids]] [[{{Mackere}} puts it]]).]]body and surrenders the match, erasing him instead]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The idea of the whipping boy is that misbehaving young princes cannot be physically disciplined by anyone but the king, due to the Divine Right of Kings, and it was impractical to constantly make requests of a reigning monarch to personally oversee his child's discipline, so a child of lesser status would be disciplined in their place, with the hope that this would make the young prince feel guilty. Specifically, the child chosen for this would be a lifelong companion to the prince, and was often one of the only -- if not ''the'' only -- same-age friends the prince had access to, so this method was often an effective tool for teaching noble children that their actions do have consequences and that those consequences will hurt others. The fact that they were forced to watch as someone who had become a close friend get punished for his own actions tended to serve as a deterrent in short order.

to:

* The idea of the whipping boy is that misbehaving young princes cannot be physically disciplined by anyone but the king, due to the Divine Right of Kings, and it was impractical to constantly make requests of a reigning monarch to personally oversee his child's discipline, so a child of lesser status (usually still a noble of some level, but not outright royalty) would be disciplined in their place, with the hope that this would make the young prince feel guilty. Specifically, the child chosen for this would be a lifelong companion to the prince, and was often one of the only -- if not ''the'' only -- same-age friends the prince had access to, so this method was often an effective tool for teaching noble royal children that their actions do have consequences and that those consequences will hurt others. The fact that they were forced to watch as someone who had become a close friend get punished for his own actions tended to serve as a deterrent in short order.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The idea of the whipping boy is that misbehaving young princes cannot be physically disciplined by anyone but the king, due to the Divine Right of Kings, and it was impractical to constantly make requests of a reigning monarch to personally oversee his child's discipline, so a child of lesser status would be disciplined in their place, with the hope that this would make the young prince feel guilty. To really drive this home, the whipping boy was put in a position to befriend the prince, and was often one of the only -- if not ''the'' only -- same-age friends the prince had access to, so this method was often an effective tool for teaching noble children that their actions do have consequences and that those consequences will hurt others. The fact that they were forced to watch as someone who had become a close friend get punished for his own actions tended to serve as a deterrent in short order.

to:

* The idea of the whipping boy is that misbehaving young princes cannot be physically disciplined by anyone but the king, due to the Divine Right of Kings, and it was impractical to constantly make requests of a reigning monarch to personally oversee his child's discipline, so a child of lesser status would be disciplined in their place, with the hope that this would make the young prince feel guilty. To really drive Specifically, the child chosen for this home, the whipping boy was put in would be a position lifelong companion to befriend the prince, and was often one of the only -- if not ''the'' only -- same-age friends the prince had access to, so this method was often an effective tool for teaching noble children that their actions do have consequences and that those consequences will hurt others. The fact that they were forced to watch as someone who had become a close friend get punished for his own actions tended to serve as a deterrent in short order.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The idea of the whipping boy is that misbehaving young princes cannot be physically disciplined by anyone but the king, due to the Divine Right of Kings, and it was impractical to constantly make requests of a reigning monarch to personally oversee his child's discipline, so a child of lesser status would be disciplined in their place, with the hope that this would make the young prince feel guilty. To really drive this home, the whipping boy was specifically someone who was put in a position to befriend the prince, and was often one of the only -- if not ''the'' only -- same-age friends the prince had access to, so this method was often an effective tool for teaching noble children that their actions do have consequences and that those consequences will hurt others. The fact that they were forced to watch as someone who had become a close friend get punished for his own actions tended to serve as a deterrent in short order.

to:

* The idea of the whipping boy is that misbehaving young princes cannot be physically disciplined by anyone but the king, due to the Divine Right of Kings, and it was impractical to constantly make requests of a reigning monarch to personally oversee his child's discipline, so a child of lesser status would be disciplined in their place, with the hope that this would make the young prince feel guilty. To really drive this home, the whipping boy was specifically someone who was put in a position to befriend the prince, and was often one of the only -- if not ''the'' only -- same-age friends the prince had access to, so this method was often an effective tool for teaching noble children that their actions do have consequences and that those consequences will hurt others. The fact that they were forced to watch as someone who had become a close friend get punished for his own actions tended to serve as a deterrent in short order.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The idea of the whipping boy is that misbehaving young princes cannot be physically disciplined by anyone but the king, due to the Divine Right of Kings, and it was impractical to constantly make requests of a reigning monarch to personally oversee his child's discipline, so a common-born child would be disciplined in their place, with the hope that this would make the young prince feel guilty. The whipping boy was usually himself a noble. Either from the lower nobility, or a distant cousin, and often one of -- if not the only -- same-age friend the prince had access to, so this method was often an effective tool for teaching noble children that their actions do have consequences and that those consequences will hurt others. The fact that they were forced to watch as someone who had become a close friend get punished for his own actions tended to serve as a deterrent in short order.

to:

* The idea of the whipping boy is that misbehaving young princes cannot be physically disciplined by anyone but the king, due to the Divine Right of Kings, and it was impractical to constantly make requests of a reigning monarch to personally oversee his child's discipline, so a common-born child of lesser status would be disciplined in their place, with the hope that this would make the young prince feel guilty. The To really drive this home, the whipping boy was usually himself specifically someone who was put in a noble. Either from position to befriend the lower nobility, or a distant cousin, prince, and was often one of the only -- if not the ''the'' only -- same-age friend friends the prince had access to, so this method was often an effective tool for teaching noble children that their actions do have consequences and that those consequences will hurt others. The fact that they were forced to watch as someone who had become a close friend get punished for his own actions tended to serve as a deterrent in short order.

Top