Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / GrandRomanticGesture

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the final chapter, [[spoiler:Kaguya (knowing that Shirogane was flying back to Japan unannounced to surprise her at graduation) prepares a surprise of her own by getting the entire student body to celebrate ''his'' graduation so he wouldn't feel left out after leaving several months early to attend Stanford.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Theatre/JasperInDeadland'', Agnes is in love with Jasper, but Jasper thinks they are BetterAsFriends because he is afraid that a relationship between them would break apart like his parent's marriage. In an attempt to get Jasper to face his fears, Agnes tries to face one of her own fears - she goes to the lake that Jasper enjoys swimming in, and dives into it from a great height, something that Jasper often did, but she was afraid to do. This quickly backfires; as Agnes isn't as good at swimming as Jasper, she ends up drowning before she can reach the shore, and Jasper gets sucked into Deadland when he tries to save her.

to:

* In ''Theatre/JasperInDeadland'', Agnes is in love with Jasper, but Jasper thinks they are BetterAsFriends because he is afraid that a relationship between them would break apart like his parent's parents' marriage. In an attempt to get Jasper to face his fears, Agnes tries to face one of her own fears - she goes to the lake that Jasper enjoys swimming in, and dives into it from a great height, something that Jasper often did, but she was afraid to do. This quickly backfires; as Agnes isn't as good at swimming as Jasper, she ends up drowning before she can reach the shore, and Jasper gets sucked into Deadland when he tries to save her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* It should also be reviewed in conjunction with past behavior, but grand romantic gestures are part of the tactic of love-bombing. While it ''can'' be used for benign purposes, for example for foster and adoptive parents to help troubled children who suffered from a lack of love and attention in their previous situation(s), the most common occurrence of this is within a cycle of abuse. It's a favored tactic of cults and abusive relationships, whether romantic or not. Victims are showered with gifts, attention, affection, promises for the future, grand gestures, etc. to make them feel that it's love at first sight or that this person is worthy of keeping around. What makes it distinct from actual infatuation and wanting to do nice things and say lovely things to the person they love is that once the victim displeases the abuser, or once the abuser feels secure in their relationship with the victim, they may do a complete 180: showing anger, passive aggression, accusing the victim of selfishness, withdrawing all of the nice things, punishing the victim with anything ranging from verbal, financial, to physical abuse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Rory's college boyfriend Logan is fond of these, but they don't typically read as "romantic," so much as "throwing his money around" and "using them as a replacement for communication." In the series proper, he often uses them to get back into Rory's good graces when he's done something wrong, to distract from what's actually wrong. It culminates in him blindsiding her with a proposal in front of their friends and family at her college graduation, then leaving her when she says she wants to wait. In the revival, Rory's last contact with Logan is a huge night of revelry and debauchery meant to cheer her up, but is also what makes her realize she needs to break off their affair, because he will never grow up and she needs to move on.

to:

** Rory's college boyfriend Logan is fond of these, but they don't typically read as "romantic," so much as "throwing his money around" and "using them as a replacement for communication." In the series proper, he often uses them to get back into Rory's good graces when he's done something wrong, to upset her, to distract from what's actually wrong. It culminates in him blindsiding her with a proposal in front of their friends and family at her college graduation, then leaving her when she says she wants to wait. In the revival, Rory's last contact with Logan is a huge night of revelry and debauchery meant to cheer her up, but is also what makes her realize she needs to break off their affair, because he will never grow up and she needs to move on.



** Meanwhile, the show portrays smaller, more personal, less flashy gestures as sincerely romantic, such as Luke building Lorelai a wooden archway for her wedding, ironically to the RomanticeFalseLead from earlier, which is seen as one of the sweetest things he does for her.

to:

** Meanwhile, the show portrays smaller, more personal, less flashy gestures as sincerely romantic, such as Luke building Lorelai a wooden archway for her wedding, ironically to the RomanticeFalseLead RomanticFalseLead from earlier, which is seen as one of the sweetest things he does for her.

Added: 275

Changed: 1044

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/GilmoreGirls'': Interestingly, despite being a show that puts its romances front and center, the writers takes a pretty dim view of the GrandRomanticGesture, constantly showing them but subverting the expected reaction or outcome.

to:

* ''Series/GilmoreGirls'': Interestingly, despite being a show that puts its romances front focuses half on parent/child relationships, and center, the other half on romantic relationships, the writers takes take a pretty dim view of on the GrandRomanticGesture, constantly showing them but subverting GrandRomanticGesture. While many are featured, the show often subverts the expected reaction or outcome. The gestures are grand, they're romantic, but they're superficial and not the way to a lasting relationship:



** In season one, Rory's boyfriend Dean builds her a car, which he presents with an "I love you." When she's not ready to say it back, he gets upset and breaks up with her.

to:

** In season one, 1, Rory's boyfriend Dean builds her a car, which he presents with an "I love you." When she's not ready to say it back, he gets upset and breaks up with her.



** Rory's college boyfriend Logan is fond of these, but they don't typically read as "romantic," so much as "throwing his money around" and "using them as a replacement for communication." In the series proper, it culminates in him proposing at her graduation, and then getting angry when she feels she doesn't want to be tied down at 22. In the revival, her last interaction with Logan is a huge, spectacular show of debauchery designed to raise her spirits, and is what makes her realize she can't keep doing this, because he will never grow up and she needs to.
** Meanwhile, the show interprets smaller, more meaningful gestures as sincerely romantic. One of Luke's moments is when he hand carves a wedding arch for Lorelai, for her upcoming wedding, ironically to the RomanticFalseLead from above. Though given Luke's subdued CourtlyLove approach, this is this trope, he just doesn't want to call it that.

to:

** Rory's college boyfriend Logan is fond of these, but they don't typically read as "romantic," so much as "throwing his money around" and "using them as a replacement for communication." In the series proper, it he often uses them to get back into Rory's good graces when he's done something wrong, to distract from what's actually wrong. It culminates in him proposing blindsiding her with a proposal in front of their friends and family at her college graduation, and then getting angry leaving her when she feels says she doesn't want wants to be tied down at 22. wait. In the revival, her Rory's last interaction contact with Logan is a huge, spectacular show huge night of revelry and debauchery designed meant to raise cheer her spirits, and up, but is also what makes her realize she can't keep doing this, needs to break off their affair, because he will never grow up and she needs to.
to move on.
** In season 7, Christopher buys out an entire restaurant in Paris in order to woo Lorelai. He proposes and talks her into eloping, even though Lorelai expresses concern that Rory isn't there. They don't even last the season.
** Meanwhile, the show interprets portrays smaller, more meaningful personal, less flashy gestures as sincerely romantic. One of Luke's moments is when he hand carves romantic, such as Luke building Lorelai a wedding arch for Lorelai, wooden archway for her upcoming wedding, ironically to the RomanticFalseLead RomanticeFalseLead from above. Though given Luke's subdued CourtlyLove approach, this earlier, which is this trope, seen as one of the sweetest things he just doesn't want to call it that.does for her.

Added: 338

Changed: 10

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In season 4, Jess visits Rory at her dorm room and begs her to run away with him. Her reaction is incredulous and angry that he would suggest it, and the entire thing is played for tearjerker, not romance. He gets increasingly desperate, even confessing that it was LoveAtFirstSight for him, but she turns him down and sends him away.



** Meanwhile, the show interprets smaller, more meaningful gestures as sincerely romantic. One of Luke's moments is when he hand carves a wedding arch for Lorelai, for her upcoming wedding, ironically to the FalseRomanticLead from above. Though given Luke's subdued CourtlyLove approach, this is this trope, he just doesn't want to call it that.

to:

** Meanwhile, the show interprets smaller, more meaningful gestures as sincerely romantic. One of Luke's moments is when he hand carves a wedding arch for Lorelai, for her upcoming wedding, ironically to the FalseRomanticLead RomanticFalseLead from above. Though given Luke's subdued CourtlyLove approach, this is this trope, he just doesn't want to call it that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/GilmoreGirls'': Interestingly, despite being a show that puts its romances front and center, the writers takes a pretty dim view of the GrandRomanticGesture.

to:

* ''Series/GilmoreGirls'': Interestingly, despite being a show that puts its romances front and center, the writers takes a pretty dim view of the GrandRomanticGesture.GrandRomanticGesture, constantly showing them but subverting the expected reaction or outcome.



** Meanwhile, the show interprets smaller, more meaningful gestures as sincerely romantic. One of Luke's moments is when he hand carves a wedding arch for Lorelai, for her upcoming wedding, ironically to the FalseRomanticLead from above.

to:

** Meanwhile, the show interprets smaller, more meaningful gestures as sincerely romantic. One of Luke's moments is when he hand carves a wedding arch for Lorelai, for her upcoming wedding, ironically to the FalseRomanticLead from above. Though given Luke's subdued CourtlyLove approach, this is this trope, he just doesn't want to call it that.

Added: 973

Changed: 572

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/GilmoreGirls'': Lorelai says that a proposal should be big and epic and have "a thousand yellow daisies". Cue her RomanticFalseLead boyfriend proposing to her by sending one thousand yellow daisies to her workplace.
** Rory's college boyfriend Logan is fond of these, but they don't typically read as "romantic," so much as "throwing his money around" and "using them as a replacement for communication."

to:

* ''Series/GilmoreGirls'': Interestingly, despite being a show that puts its romances front and center, the writers takes a pretty dim view of the GrandRomanticGesture.
**
Lorelai says that a proposal should be big and epic and have "a thousand yellow daisies". Cue her RomanticFalseLead boyfriend proposing to her by sending one thousand yellow daisies to her workplace.
workplace. She ends up leaving him at the altar.
** In season one, Rory's boyfriend Dean builds her a car, which he presents with an "I love you." When she's not ready to say it back, he gets upset and breaks up with her.
** Rory's college boyfriend Logan is fond of these, but they don't typically read as "romantic," so much as "throwing his money around" and "using them as a replacement for communication."" In the series proper, it culminates in him proposing at her graduation, and then getting angry when she feels she doesn't want to be tied down at 22. In the revival, her last interaction with Logan is a huge, spectacular show of debauchery designed to raise her spirits, and is what makes her realize she can't keep doing this, because he will never grow up and she needs to.
** Meanwhile, the show interprets smaller, more meaningful gestures as sincerely romantic. One of Luke's moments is when he hand carves a wedding arch for Lorelai, for her upcoming wedding, ironically to the FalseRomanticLead from above.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Played straighter later in the film when Allie visits Noah at the house he renovated, and she realizes he renovated it to her specifications in a one-off conversation they had years ago.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Noah pulls one of the most alarming possible versions of this trope in ''Film/TheNotebook'' by hanging off a ferris wheel until Allie agrees to date him. It's dangerous within the movie because, yeah, he's hanging off a damn ferris wheel. This is also a variant of the trope that represents extreme danger to the person ''receiving'' the gesture in real life; threatening self harm as a way to control or manipulate your partner is incredibly abusive, not romantic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The show even points out that such gestures can be considered creepy and stalker-ish if the intended recipient does not welcome the gesture. This is referred to as the Dobler-Dahmer Theory. The example given: In college, Marshall sneaked into Lily's dorm room to sing her a ukulele song to ask her out. Lily was interested in him and so it worked, like Lloyd Dobler with the boombox outside the apartment in ''Film/SayAnything''. If Lily was not interested then he would come across SerialKiller creepy and crazy a la [[ComicBook/MyFriendDahmer Jeffrey Dahmer]].

to:

** The show even points out that such gestures can be considered creepy and stalker-ish if the intended recipient does not welcome the gesture. This is referred to as the Dobler-Dahmer Theory. The example given: In college, Marshall sneaked into Lily's dorm room to sing her a ukulele song to ask her out. Lily was interested in him and so it worked, like Lloyd Dobler with the boombox outside the apartment in ''Film/SayAnything''. If Lily was not interested then he would come across SerialKiller creepy and crazy a la [[ComicBook/MyFriendDahmer Jeffrey Dahmer]]. This also implicitly means that one cannot "win over" an uninterested party with a grand gesture, as the recipient must already have feelings for it to work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Theatre/JasperInDeadland'', Agnes is in love with Jasper, but Jasper thinks they are BetterAsFriends because he is afraid that a relationship between them would break apart like his parent's marriage. In an attempt to get Jasper to face his fears, Agnes tries to face one of her own fears - she goes to the lake that Jasper enjoys swimming in, and dives into it from a great height, something that Jasper often did, but she was afraid to do. This quickly backfires; as Agnes isn't as good at swimming as Jasper, she ends up drowning before she can reach the shore, and Jasper ends up getting sucked into Deadland when he tries to save her.

to:

* In ''Theatre/JasperInDeadland'', Agnes is in love with Jasper, but Jasper thinks they are BetterAsFriends because he is afraid that a relationship between them would break apart like his parent's marriage. In an attempt to get Jasper to face his fears, Agnes tries to face one of her own fears - she goes to the lake that Jasper enjoys swimming in, and dives into it from a great height, something that Jasper often did, but she was afraid to do. This quickly backfires; as Agnes isn't as good at swimming as Jasper, she ends up drowning before she can reach the shore, and Jasper ends up getting gets sucked into Deadland when he tries to save her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Theatre/JasperInDeadland'', Agnes is in love with Jasper, but Jasper thinks they are BetterAsFriends because he is afraid that a relationship between would break apart like his parent's marriage. In an attempt to get Jasper to face his fears, she tries to face one of her own fears - she goes to the lake that Jasper enjoys swimming in, and dives into it from a great height, something that Jasper often did, but she was afraid to do. This quickly backfires; as Agnes isn't as good at swimming as Jasper, she ends up drowning before she can reach the shore, and Jasper ends up getting sucked into the Underworld when he tries to save her.

to:

* In ''Theatre/JasperInDeadland'', Agnes is in love with Jasper, but Jasper thinks they are BetterAsFriends because he is afraid that a relationship between them would break apart like his parent's marriage. In an attempt to get Jasper to face his fears, she Agnes tries to face one of her own fears - she goes to the lake that Jasper enjoys swimming in, and dives into it from a great height, something that Jasper often did, but she was afraid to do. This quickly backfires; as Agnes isn't as good at swimming as Jasper, she ends up drowning before she can reach the shore, and Jasper ends up getting sucked into the Underworld Deadland when he tries to save her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/{{Twins}}'', Vincent has his love interest's room fully decorated with flowers. She is floored when she enters.

to:

* In ''Film/{{Twins}}'', ''Film/Twins1988'', Vincent has his love interest's room fully decorated with flowers. She is floored when she enters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Theatre]]
* In ''Theatre/JasperInDeadland'', Agnes is in love with Jasper, but Jasper thinks they are BetterAsFriends because he is afraid that a relationship between would break apart like his parent's marriage. In an attempt to get Jasper to face his fears, she tries to face one of her own fears - she goes to the lake that Jasper enjoys swimming in, and dives into it from a great height, something that Jasper often did, but she was afraid to do. This quickly backfires; as Agnes isn't as good at swimming as Jasper, she ends up drowning before she can reach the shore, and Jasper ends up getting sucked into the Underworld when he tries to save her.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Webcomic/TilDebtDoUsPart'': While at a friend's wedding on Jeju Island, Subin engineers romantically meeting Yejun where she has laid out a ton of candles and flowers. Subin asks him to be her real husband and have a happy life with her, and he accepts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Examples aren't supposed to be general


* Interestingly, whenever a {{Yaoi}} manga features a filthy rich suitor, it often ends up with exactly this. The most common case is often that the poor guy's porch/garden/etc. is filled with flowers/his favorite food/whatever he stated he likes or with the suitor appearing with the most ridiculous flower bouquet. A bit rarer is the suitor giving something apparently common to his love (a ring, a dessert, a decorative object), just to explain that the price is actually equal to that of a house or race car.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In 1996's ''Film/BedOfRoses'', Lewis sends Lisa bouquet after bouquet of all the thornless "sterling roses" he can get from every florist and supplier he can call after she mentions a fondness for him. Lisa is touched, but also kind of disturbed by the excessive scale of the gesture.

to:

* In 1996's ''Film/BedOfRoses'', ''Film/{{Bed Of Roses|1996}}'', Lewis sends Lisa bouquet after bouquet of all the thornless "sterling roses" he can get from every florist and supplier he can call after she mentions a fondness for him. Lisa is touched, but also kind of disturbed by the excessive scale of the gesture.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In 1996's ''Bed of Roses'', Lewis sends Lisa bouquet after bouquet of all the thornless "sterling roses" he can get from every florist and supplier he can call after she mentions a fondness for him. Lisa is touched, but also kind of disturbed by the excessive scale of the gesture.

to:

* In 1996's ''Bed of Roses'', ''Film/BedOfRoses'', Lewis sends Lisa bouquet after bouquet of all the thornless "sterling roses" he can get from every florist and supplier he can call after she mentions a fondness for him. Lisa is touched, but also kind of disturbed by the excessive scale of the gesture.

Changed: 98

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Runs heavy on RuleOfRomantic. In RealLife, be warned: this has appeared on [[http://www.doctornerdlove.com/2011/10/four-lies-movies-taught-us-about-dating/all/1/ lists]] in the lines of "stupid things movies taught us would work," particularly if you're not already in a relationship with them; doing something stupidly, outrageously romantic for your established significant other is ''very'' different from doing it for someone you aren't even dating, and the latter is liable to be massively awkward. (See also: [[StalkerWithACrush stalking]].)

to:

Runs heavy on RuleOfRomantic. In RealLife, be warned: this has appeared on [[http://www.doctornerdlove.com/2011/10/four-lies-movies-taught-us-about-dating/all/1/ lists]] in the lines of "stupid things movies taught us would work," particularly if you're not already in a relationship with them; them, and double-especially if they're not interested and the gesture is supposed to change their mind; doing something stupidly, outrageously romantic for your established significant other is ''very'' different from doing it for someone you aren't even dating, and the latter is liable to be massively awkward. (See also: [[StalkerWithACrush stalking]].)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/JasonsLyric'', Jason intends to win [[LoveInterest Lyric]]'s heart by taking her on a date, borrowing a city bus for themselves and setting up a mock picnic in an abandoned bus station. Later, he takes her to a secluded bayou before eventually kissing and making love to her in the woods.

to:

* In ''Film/JasonsLyric'', ''Jason's Lyric'', Jason intends to win [[LoveInterest Lyric]]'s heart by taking her on a date, borrowing a city bus for themselves and setting up a mock picnic in an abandoned bus station. Later, he takes her to a secluded bayou before eventually kissing and making love to her in the woods.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Jason's Lyric'', Jason intends to win [[LoveInterest Lyric]]'s heart by taking her on a date, borrowing a city bus for themselves and setting up a mock picnic in an abandoned bus station. Later, he takes her to a secluded bayou before eventually kissing and making love to her in the woods.

to:

* In ''Jason's Lyric'', ''Film/JasonsLyric'', Jason intends to win [[LoveInterest Lyric]]'s heart by taking her on a date, borrowing a city bus for themselves and setting up a mock picnic in an abandoned bus station. Later, he takes her to a secluded bayou before eventually kissing and making love to her in the woods.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Monica:''' Don't get me wrong, Frasier. Everything you did was nice, it was just... too much. You made me feel like a project and not a person.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/TheWestWing'': Toby buys his pregnant ex-wife her "dream house", which she's had her eye on for years, as part of his newest attempt to propose to her. As much as Andy loves the house, when she realises why Toby bought it [[SubvertedTrope she turns him down]] and asks if he can get his deposit back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Many episodes feature Homer performing one of these to make up for doing something especially stupid and/or selfish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/{{Opalescent}}'': For Christmas, Otto, with the help of Oscar, gets Opal a teal Schwinn bike, one that she's wanted but could not afford due to being in dire financial straits for most of her life. When she receives the gift on Christmas morning, she's absolutely ecstatic, but doesn't realize whom the gift-givers are until a year later, when Otto tells her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Jason's Lyric'', Jason intends to win [[LoveInterest Lyric]]'s heart and takes her on a date by borrowing a city bus to themselves and set up a mock of picnic in an abandoned bus station. Later, he takes her to a secluded bayou before eventually making love to her in the woods.

to:

* In ''Jason's Lyric'', Jason intends to win [[LoveInterest Lyric]]'s heart and takes by taking her on a date by date, borrowing a city bus to for themselves and set setting up a mock of picnic in an abandoned bus station. Later, he takes her to a secluded bayou before eventually kissing and making love to her in the woods.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Subverted in ''WesternAnimation/TheOwlHouse''. [[spoiler:[[ThinksLikeARomanceNovel Luz is an avid consumer of fantasy media]] and was often made fun of back on Earth for being cheesy, so she's convinced that asking Amity out would need to be "breathtaking, emotional, and real". Ultimately, Eda convinces her that it's better to just do it now rather than wait for the "perfect" moment to come along.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Jason's Lyric'', Jason borrows a city bus just to take [[LoveInterest Lyric]] on a date and already set up a mock of picnic in an abandoned bus station. Later he takes her to a secluded bayou before eventually making love to her in the woods.

to:

* In ''Jason's Lyric'', Jason borrows a city bus just intends to take win [[LoveInterest Lyric]] Lyric]]'s heart and takes her on a date by borrowing a city bus to themselves and already set up a mock of picnic in an abandoned bus station. Later Later, he takes her to a secluded bayou before eventually making love to her in the woods.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Jason's Lyric'', Jason borrows a city bus just to take [[LoveInterest Lyric]] on a date and already set up a mock of picnic in an abandoned bus station. Later he takes her to a secluded bayou before eventually making love to her in the woods.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Runs heavy on RuleOfRomantic. In RealLife, be warned: this has appeared on [[http://www.doctornerdlove.com/2011/10/four-lies-movies-taught-us-about-dating/all/1/ lists]] in the lines of "stupid things movies taught us would work," particularly if you're not already in a relationship with them; doing something stupidly, outrageously romantic for your established significant other is ''very'' different from doing it for someone you aren't even dating. A massive gesture by someone you're not into is liable to be massively awkward. (See also: [[StalkerWithACrush stalking]].)

to:

Runs heavy on RuleOfRomantic. In RealLife, be warned: this has appeared on [[http://www.doctornerdlove.com/2011/10/four-lies-movies-taught-us-about-dating/all/1/ lists]] in the lines of "stupid things movies taught us would work," particularly if you're not already in a relationship with them; doing something stupidly, outrageously romantic for your established significant other is ''very'' different from doing it for someone you aren't even dating. A massive gesture by someone you're not into dating, and the latter is liable to be massively awkward. (See also: [[StalkerWithACrush stalking]].)

Top