History Main / FrequentlyBrokenUnbreakableVow

4th Jun '17 6:26:19 PM Gosicrystal
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Likewise, some Catholic bishops release priests from their duties and vows of celibacy, because they've fallen in love and want to get married. It's a relatively long process because of the seriousness of the change and the awareness that often such feelings pass and fade as above, but there is a process in place.

to:

* Likewise, some Some Catholic bishops release priests from their duties and vows of celibacy, because they've fallen in love and want to get married. It's a relatively long process because of the seriousness of the change and the awareness that often such feelings pass and fade as above, but there is a process in place.
9th Apr '17 5:13:38 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Dragon Shiryu in ''SaintSeiya'' has several of these with direct orders by his Old Master to never use such or such DangerousForbiddenTechnique. Instances include "being forbidden from using Rozan Shōryūha when weakened or OverdrawnAtTheBloodBank" (which he had to break against Black Dragon to take him down in a desperate situation ; [[spoiler:he only survived by virtue of HeelFaceTurn from Black Dragon impressed by his friendship]]), "being forbidden from using Rozan Kōryūha" (which he breaks against Capricorn Shura, but admittedly he was on his last leg and a TakingYouWithMe HeroicSacrifice was his only way out ; [[spoiler:he only survived by virtue of HeelFaceTurn from Shura]]). The reason why this feels like this trope is because every time he does it, he [[LampshadeHanging vocally points out]] he is breaking his promise with his Old Master, for the greater good, but in reality this is more like a sign that the GodzillaThreshold has been broken and it's time to bring out the big guns.

to:

* Dragon Shiryu in ''SaintSeiya'' ''Manga/SaintSeiya'' has several of these with direct orders by his Old Master to never use such or such DangerousForbiddenTechnique. Instances include "being forbidden from using Rozan Shōryūha when weakened or OverdrawnAtTheBloodBank" (which he had to break against Black Dragon to take him down in a desperate situation ; [[spoiler:he only survived by virtue of HeelFaceTurn from Black Dragon impressed by his friendship]]), "being forbidden from using Rozan Kōryūha" (which he breaks against Capricorn Shura, but admittedly he was on his last leg and a TakingYouWithMe HeroicSacrifice was his only way out ; [[spoiler:he only survived by virtue of HeelFaceTurn from Shura]]). The reason why this feels like this trope is because every time he does it, he [[LampshadeHanging vocally points out]] he is breaking his promise with his Old Master, for the greater good, but in reality this is more like a sign that the GodzillaThreshold has been broken and it's time to bring out the big guns.
18th Jan '17 2:09:25 PM gb00393
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/GameOfThrones'':
** Vows of chastity are integral to orders such as the Night's Watch, Kingsguard, and Maesters of the Citadel, but LoopholeAbuse is common since the ExactWords often only forbid wives and children. The nearest town to Castle Black even has a thriving brothel catering to black brothers of the Night's Watch.
** A major reason for Jaime Lannister's openness about his lack of honour is his disgust with being vilified as TheOathbreaker for killing the Mad King despite solemn oaths of loyalty and moral behaviour being violated on all sides.
** The Hound consistently refuses knighthood because he considers their vows to be this. Thoroughly reprehensible men like his brother Gregor are knights, so in the Hound's opinion knights are just killers pretending not to be. He prefers to forgo the pretense altogether.
15th Jan '17 9:49:01 PM DustSnitch
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* [[GrimReaper Death]] of the {{Literature/Discworld}} is bound by The Duty to impartially collect souls, and has apparently done so offscreen very diligently for thousands of years, but in the books themselves he has a breakdown and [[DeathTakesAHoliday runs off]] more than once, and also spares people's lives repeatedly because of curiosity or pity or personal relations or because [[BadAss Granny Weatherwax]] asks him to. (He also killed someone for no reason in the first book, but that was [[CharacterizationMarchesOn before his character was really decided]].)

to:

* [[GrimReaper Death]] of the {{Literature/Discworld}} is bound by The Duty to impartially collect souls, and has apparently done so offscreen very diligently for thousands of years, but in the books themselves he has a breakdown and [[DeathTakesAHoliday runs off]] more than once, and also spares people's lives repeatedly because of curiosity or pity or personal relations or because [[BadAss Granny Weatherwax]] Weatherwax asks him to. (He also killed someone for no reason in the first book, but that was [[CharacterizationMarchesOn before his character was really decided]].)
25th Dec '16 3:21:38 PM Morgenthaler
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** "The Drumhead" reveals that even ''Picard'', by far the most diplomatic Captain, nonetheless had ''nine'' separate violations on his record. This was a late season 4 episode, meaning he had dozens more episodes and four movies in which to rack up more violations.

to:

** ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'' episode "The Drumhead" reveals that even ''Picard'', by far the most diplomatic Captain, nonetheless had ''nine'' separate violations on his record. This was a late season 4 episode, meaning he had dozens more episodes and four movies in which to rack up more violations.
6th Dec '16 4:07:14 PM Dravencour
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Usef frequently, even to the point of RunningGag extremes. Many major groups in the setting take vows of chastity (Maesters of the Citadel, Black Brothers of the Night's Watch, brothers of the Kingsguard, etc.) and few of them take the vow even a little bit seriously. (The Night's Watch gets by on a bit of LoopholeAbuse: their vow is to [[ExactWords "take no wife and father no children,"]] and given the ubiquity of [[FantasyContraception moon tea and tansy]] in the setting, as long as they stick to whores who know their business, there's relatively little chance of that.)

to:

** Usef Used frequently, even to the point of RunningGag extremes. Many major groups in the setting take vows of chastity (Maesters of the Citadel, Black Brothers of the Night's Watch, brothers of the Kingsguard, etc.) and few of them take the vow even a little bit seriously. (The Night's Watch gets by on a bit of LoopholeAbuse: their vow is to [[ExactWords "take no wife and father no children,"]] and given the ubiquity of [[FantasyContraception moon tea and tansy]] in the setting, as long as they stick to whores who know their business, there's relatively little chance of that.)
26th Oct '16 1:56:08 PM Morgenthaler
Is there an issue? Send a Message


[[folder: Live Action TV ]]

to:

[[folder: Live Action Live-Action TV ]]
26th Oct '16 1:55:46 PM Morgenthaler
Is there an issue? Send a Message


[[AC:{{Anime}} and {{Manga}}]]
* Roger Smith of ''Anime/TheBigO'' often says that violence is a last resort in his negotiations... but then, we would never get to see him kick ass in his HumongousMecha if negotiations didn't break down on a regular basis, now would we?

to:

[[AC:{{Anime}} [[foldercontrol]]

[[folder: Anime
and {{Manga}}]]
Manga ]]

* Roger Smith of ''Anime/TheBigO'' often says that violence is a last resort in his negotiations... but then, we would never get to see him kick ass in his HumongousMecha if negotiations didn't break down on a regular basis, now would we? we?



[[AC:ComicBooks]]

to:

[[AC:ComicBooks]] [[/folder]]

[[folder: Comic Books ]]



[[AC:Literature]]

to:

[[AC:Literature]][[/folder]]

[[folder: Literature ]]



[[AC:LiveActionTV]]

to:

[[AC:LiveActionTV]] [[/folder]]

[[folder: Live Action TV ]]



[[AC:VisualNovel]]

to:

[[AC:VisualNovel]][[/folder]]

[[folder: Visual Novel ]]



[[AC:WebOriginal]]

to:

[[AC:WebOriginal]] [[/folder]]

[[folder: Web Original ]]



[[AC: RealLife]]

to:

[[AC: RealLife]][[/folder]]

[[folder: Real Life ]]



* Averted by the Quakers (a religious group, also called "The society of friends"), who take the Bible's word on not swearing oaths seriously. Thus, they manage to stick to the principles that are in the Bible, the ones of their own religious society (there are several cases in history where Quakers got in trouble for refusing to swear oaths), and don't get into the predicament of having to break vows, as they never made them in the first place.

to:

* Averted by the Quakers (a religious group, also called "The society of friends"), who take the Bible's word on not swearing oaths seriously. Thus, they manage to stick to the principles that are in the Bible, the ones of their own religious society (there are several cases in history where Quakers got in trouble for refusing to swear oaths), and don't get into the predicament of having to break vows, as they never made them in the first place.place.

[[/folder]]
----
26th Oct '16 1:25:12 PM Morgenthaler
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Used frequently in ''{{A Song of Ice and Fire}}'', even to the point of RunningGag extremes. Many major groups in the setting take vows of chastity (Maesters of the Citadel, Black Brothers of the Night's Watch, brothers of the Kingsguard, etc.) and few of them take the vow even a little bit seriously. (The Night's Watch gets by on a bit of LoopholeAbuse: their vow is to [[ExactWords "take no wife and father no children,"]] and given the ubiquity of [[FantasyContraception moon tea and tansy]] in the setting, as long as they stick to whores who know their business, there's relatively little chance of that.)

to:

* Used frequently in ''{{A Song of Ice and Fire}}'', ''Literature/ASongOfIceAndFire'':
** Usef frequently,
even to the point of RunningGag extremes. Many major groups in the setting take vows of chastity (Maesters of the Citadel, Black Brothers of the Night's Watch, brothers of the Kingsguard, etc.) and few of them take the vow even a little bit seriously. (The Night's Watch gets by on a bit of LoopholeAbuse: their vow is to [[ExactWords "take no wife and father no children,"]] and given the ubiquity of [[FantasyContraception moon tea and tansy]] in the setting, as long as they stick to whores who know their business, there's relatively little chance of that.)
11th May '16 10:43:31 PM KingLyger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Discussed in the ''WritingExcuses'' episode on Comedy: putting a character in a situation in which violating their principles is easy and adhering to them is painful is a good and fairly easy way to create humour or drama, but you can't keep forcing them to break their principles or they stop being principles.

to:

* Discussed in the ''WritingExcuses'' episode on Comedy: putting Comedy. The podcast says that if an author puts a character in a situation in which violating their principles is easy would be easy, and adhering to them is painful is would be painful, that's a good and fairly easy way to create humour humor or drama, but you depending on what the author is going for. However, an author can't keep forcing them a character to break their principles principles, or they else they'll stop being principles.
This list shows the last 10 events of 71. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Main.FrequentlyBrokenUnbreakableVow