Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / AdaptationalHeroism

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Franchise/{{Godzilla}} in ''Film/ShinGodzilla'' was portrayed in a similar manner to the original Godzilla of ''Film/{{Gojira}}'', a TragicMonster lashing out because of his mutation. The ride uses the Godzilla from ''Shin'', but portrays him in a manner similar to the later Showa and Franchise/MonsterVerse incarnations as his fight with Shinji, Rei, and Asuka is the result of Godzilla [[spoiler:coming on land to head off King Ghidorah]] and surprising NERV in the process.

to:

** Franchise/{{Godzilla}} in ''Film/ShinGodzilla'' was portrayed in a similar manner to the original Godzilla of ''Film/{{Gojira}}'', ''Film/Godzilla1954'', a TragicMonster lashing out because of his mutation. The ride uses the Godzilla from ''Shin'', but portrays him in a manner similar to the later Showa and Franchise/MonsterVerse incarnations as his fight with Shinji, Rei, and Asuka is the result of Godzilla [[spoiler:coming on land to head off King Ghidorah]] and surprising NERV in the process.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** AdaptationalHeroism/TheDCU
** AdaptationalHeroism/MarvelUniverse
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** AdaptationalHeroism/TheDCU
** AdaptationalHeroism/MarvelUniverse
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** AdaptationalHeroism/TheDCU
** AdaptationalHeroism/MarvelUniverse

Changed: 31

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:Poison Ivy: From heartless and vindictive eco-terrorist to friendly and well-meaning activist.]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:Poison Ivy: [[caption-width-right:350:[[Characters/BatmanPoisonIvy Poison Ivy]]: From heartless and vindictive eco-terrorist to friendly and well-meaning activist.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Total Recall'':
** The Piers Anthony novelization of ''Film/TotalRecall1990'' has Hauser being geniune in turning against Cohaagen, with the plan to mindwipe himself and become Quaid, seemingly done to get to Kuato as in the film, really done as part of KansasCityShuffle in the hopes of getting Quaid to activate the alien device and free Mars from Cohaagen.
** Likewise, ''Film/TotalRecall2012'' sees Hauser's seeming HeelFaceTurn be legitimate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Theatre/PinocchioTheMusical'' makes Lampwick more heroic towards the end: he realizes that going to the Land of Toys was a bad idea, blames himself for carrying Pinocchio along and attacks the ringmaster when he decides that Pinocchio will be drowned and skinned, which results into him getting also punished.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A subtrope of AdaptationPersonalityChange. Compare AdaptationalNiceGuy and AdaptationalSympathy (with which this trope can overlap), HistoricalHeroUpgrade (when this is done to a historical person in a work), DracoInLeatherPants (when fandom does this to a canon villain), RousseauWasRight (for when the story is LighterAndSofter [[ReverseCerebusSyndrome compared to its original incarnation]]), and EverybodyLovesZeus (when this is done with gods associated with light and the heavens). Contrast AdaptationalVillainy.

to:

A subtrope of AdaptationPersonalityChange. Compare AdaptationalNiceGuy and AdaptationalSympathy (with which this trope can overlap), HistoricalHeroUpgrade (when this is done to a historical person in a work), DracoInLeatherPants (when fandom does this to a canon villain), RousseauWasRight (for when the story is LighterAndSofter [[ReverseCerebusSyndrome compared to its original incarnation]]), and EverybodyLovesZeus (when this is done with gods associated with light and the heavens). Contrast AdaptationalVillainy.
AdaptationalVillainy. Might overlap with HeinousnessRetcon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:ComicBook/PoisonIvy: From heartless and vindictive eco-terrorist to friendly and well-meaning activist.]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:ComicBook/PoisonIvy: [[caption-width-right:350:Poison Ivy: From heartless and vindictive eco-terrorist to friendly and well-meaning activist.]]

Added: 525

Changed: 188

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/CthulhuArmageddon'': Joseph Curwen was a CompleteMonster and never showed any redeeming qualities in ''Literature/TheCaseOfCharlesDexterWard'' while Alan Ward (his reincarnation) is a WellIntentionedExtremist.

to:

* ''Literature/CthulhuArmageddon'': ''Literature/CthulhuArmageddon'':
**
Joseph Curwen was a CompleteMonster and never showed any redeeming qualities in ''Literature/TheCaseOfCharlesDexterWard'' while Alan Ward (his reincarnation) ([[spoiler: his reincarnation]]) is a WellIntentionedExtremist.WellIntentionedExtremist.
** A very DownplayedTrope version with Great Cthulhu himself. Cthulhu destroyed the Earth, yes, but wasn't necessarily even aware of humanity when destroying it. He certainly didn't pay any attention to the ReligionOfEvil CargoCult types who worshiped him. He also helps destroy the Unimaginable Horror for a second time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/CthulhuArmageddon'': Joseph Curwen was a CompleteMonster and never showed any redeeming qualities in ''Literature/TheCaseOfCharlesDexterWard'' while Alan Ward (his reincarnation) is a WellIntentionedExtremist.

Added: 296

Changed: 341

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In Greek mythology, Ares was always the spirit of bloodlust and is portrayed as a vicious brute, primarily a destructive and destabilizing force. The Romans' Mars began as a god of agriculture, and even as a {{war god}} he was seen as defender of the land, a paternal figure who fights first and foremost to secure peace.

to:

** In Greek mythology, Ares was always the spirit of bloodlust and is portrayed as a vicious brute, primarily a destructive and destabilizing force.force who was also a DirtyCoward that ran away the moment he faced an opponent who could actually harm him. The Romans' Mars began as a god of agriculture, and even as a {{war god}} he was seen as defender of the land, a paternal figure who fights first and foremost to secure peace.



** Hades often gets this treatment in modern media due to the fact that he only abducted and raped ''one'' person, compared to either of his brothers.

to:

** Hades often gets this treatment in modern media due to the fact that he only abducted and raped ''one'' person, compared to either of his brothers. It's also common for the relationship to be portrayed as unambiguously consentual, with Persephone being just in love with him as he is with her, largely thanks to Greek myth actually depicting him as being a faithful and devoted husband.
** Hera is often given decidedly more heroically in modern works as "the woman who has to deal with actually running things and handle the inevitable fallout from her husband's total lack of fidelity" rather than "the jealous crazy wife who tries to murder her husband's kids on a regular basis."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Webcomic/BatmanWayneFamilyAdventures'': Red Hood is a murderous vigilante in the comic books, but in the webcomic he's a much nicer JerkWithAHeartOfGold who's still friends with the rest of the Batman Family and still follows Batman's ThouShallNotKill rule.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The story of [[Literature/{{Frankenstein}} Frankenstein and his Monster]] (introduced in ''LightNovel/FateApocrypha'') was much more {{Black and White|Morality}} than what the novel portrayed. Originally created to be the [[GenderFlip "Eve"]] to the Original Human race, the Creature was a genuine success and had a childlike innocence, though not without her anger issues; a far cry from her scheming, embittered literary counterpart. Frankenstein on the other hand was turned into a [[AdaptationalVillainy pettier man]] who still broke his promise to create a partner for her even though she never [[spoiler:killed several of his family]] like in the book, to the point she goes berserk just thinking about him. In fact, all the more unsavory bits were [[DirectLineToTheAuthor written up by Mary Shelley]] when Frankenstein commissioned her.

to:

** The story of [[Literature/{{Frankenstein}} Frankenstein and his Monster]] (introduced in ''LightNovel/FateApocrypha'') ''Literature/FateApocrypha'') was much more {{Black and White|Morality}} than what the novel portrayed. Originally created to be the [[GenderFlip "Eve"]] to the Original Human race, the Creature was a genuine success and had a childlike innocence, though not without her anger issues; a far cry from her scheming, embittered literary counterpart. Frankenstein on the other hand was turned into a [[AdaptationalVillainy pettier man]] who still broke his promise to create a partner for her even though she never [[spoiler:killed several of his family]] like in the book, to the point she goes berserk just thinking about him. In fact, all the more unsavory bits were [[DirectLineToTheAuthor written up by Mary Shelley]] when Frankenstein commissioned her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Roleplay/ProjectionQuest'' has [[Literature/{{Worm}} Trainwreck]] never become a part of the Merchants, instead opting to join Taylor in her heroic group and eventually become second in command of the Oathbound.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Saturn/Cronus is one notable example. In Roman mythology, Saturn ruled in a golden age and was still worshiped as a patron of agriculture, even sacaping to Rome after his overthrow by Jupiter to continue his golden age. Greek mythology, on the other hand? Cronus ''EatsBabies''.

to:

** Saturn/Cronus is one notable example. In Roman mythology, Saturn ruled in a golden age and was still worshiped as a patron of agriculture, even sacaping escaping to Rome after his overthrow by Jupiter to continue his golden age. Greek mythology, on the other hand? Cronus ''EatsBabies''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Theatre/ThePhantomOfTheOpera'':
** Raoul gets this in the musical compared to Leorux's [[Literature/ThePhantomOfTheOpera orignal novel]]. While not a villain and actually the protagionist/point of view character for most of the book, Raoul is far less bratty and more traditionally heroic here than his literary version who was clingy and even insulting to Christine after getting strung around by her, at one point even calling her a "wench" during his DespairEventHorizon. Even after learning her side of the story, Raoul still wants Christine to hate Erik and even pettily accuses her of loving the Phantom. His musical version lacks this these inherent character flaws and is a NiceGuy to Christine throughout, although it arguably makes him a FlatCharacter in the process. PlayedWith also as musical Raoul uses Christine as bait to capture the Phantom, unlike book Raoul who despite his flaws just wanted and urged Christline to flee the Opera House as soon as possible.
** The Phantom himself gets this to a degree. In the book he's an unbashed PsychopathicManchild who has killed and tortured numerous people and has an EvilLaugh at multiple points. Christine is literally the only person he shows any compassion to and even then after she demasks him and sees his NightmareFace, he fully intends to keep her underground with him ''forever'', and if she rejects his marriage proposal blow up a portion of Paris with gunpowder. Thankfully stopped when Christine gives him all the love and pity she can offer. His musical version by comparsion isn't nearly as overtly evil and more sensual. He doesn't attempt to blow up Paris if Christine rejects him (only strangle Raoul), and even his murder of Joseph Buquet is framed in an ambigous fashion, so that it could possibly be self-defence. Creator/AndrewLloydWebber seeing the Phantom as his AuthorAvatar was also a factor in this treatment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A subtrope of AdaptationPersonalityChange. Compare AdaptationalNiceGuy and AdaptationalSympathy (with which this trope can overlap), HistoricalHeroUpgrade (when this is done to a historical person in a work), DracoInLeatherPants (when fandom does this to a canon villain), and EverybodyLovesZeus (when this is done with gods associated with light and the heavens). Contrast AdaptationalVillainy.

to:

A subtrope of AdaptationPersonalityChange. Compare AdaptationalNiceGuy and AdaptationalSympathy (with which this trope can overlap), HistoricalHeroUpgrade (when this is done to a historical person in a work), DracoInLeatherPants (when fandom does this to a canon villain), RousseauWasRight (for when the story is LighterAndSofter [[ReverseCerebusSyndrome compared to its original incarnation]]), and EverybodyLovesZeus (when this is done with gods associated with light and the heavens). Contrast AdaptationalVillainy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:ComicBook/PoisonIvy: From heartless eco-terrorist to awkward activist.]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:ComicBook/PoisonIvy: From heartless and vindictive eco-terrorist to awkward friendly and well-meaning activist.]]



-->-- ''{{Website/Cracked}}'', [[http://www.cracked.com/blog/4-movies-that-got-source-materials-point-exactly-wrong/#ixzz30P6hR45A "4 Movies That Got the Source Material's Point Exactly Wrong,"]] about the ''Film/MenInBlack'' movie and the ''ComicBook/MenInBlack'' comicbook

to:

-->-- ''{{Website/Cracked}}'', -->--''Website/{{Cracked}}'', [[http://www.cracked.com/blog/4-movies-that-got-source-materials-point-exactly-wrong/#ixzz30P6hR45A "4 Movies That Got the Source Material's Point Exactly Wrong,"]] about the ''Film/MenInBlack'' movie and the ''ComicBook/MenInBlack'' comicbook
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Despite there being a trope named for the contrary, "Sexy" isn't really a synonym for "Evil".


[[caption-width-right:350:ComicBook/PoisonIvy: From sexy eco-terrorist to awkward activist.]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:ComicBook/PoisonIvy: From sexy heartless eco-terrorist to awkward activist.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Machinima/DarkSecretsOfGarrysMod'': [[Videogame/HalfLife1 G-Man]] is AmbiguouslyEvil with [[BlueAndOrangeMorality varying degrees of morality]] in his source material. In this series however, he has the innocence of an immature child.

to:

* ''Machinima/DarkSecretsOfGarrysMod'': ''WebAnimation/DarkSecretsOfGarrysMod'': [[Videogame/HalfLife1 G-Man]] is AmbiguouslyEvil with [[BlueAndOrangeMorality varying degrees of morality]] in his source material. In this series however, he has the innocence of an immature child.



* In ''Machinima/MinecraftDiaries'', Zane is a CardCarryingVillain with zero redeeming qualities. In the more lighthearted spin-off ''Machinima/MyStreet'', he starts off antagonistic but ends up undergoing a HeelFaceTurn; now he's a loyal friend of Aphmau and an AntiHero on his worst days.

to:

* In ''Machinima/MinecraftDiaries'', ''WebVideo/MinecraftDiaries'', Zane is a CardCarryingVillain with zero redeeming qualities. In the more lighthearted spin-off ''Machinima/MyStreet'', ''WebVideo/MyStreet'', he starts off antagonistic but ends up undergoing a HeelFaceTurn; now he's a loyal friend of Aphmau and an AntiHero on his worst days.



* ''Machinima/ZsdavAdventures'': [[Franchise/StarWars Darth Maul]] appears as the [[Literature/AChristmasCarol ghost of Christmas present]] to teach Zsdav the true meaning of Christmas in ''[[YetAnotherChristmasCarol Karácsonyi külön kiadás]]'' (''Christmas special'').

to:

* ''Machinima/ZsdavAdventures'': ''WebAnimation/ZsdavAdventures'': [[Franchise/StarWars Darth Maul]] appears as the [[Literature/AChristmasCarol ghost of Christmas present]] to teach Zsdav the true meaning of Christmas in ''[[YetAnotherChristmasCarol Karácsonyi külön kiadás]]'' (''Christmas special'').
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''AdaptationalHeroism/{{Arrowverse}}''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In Greek mythology, Ares was always the spirit of bloodlust and is portrayed as a vicious brute, primarily a destructive and destabilizing force. The Romans' Mars began as a god of agriculture, and as a war god he was seen as defender of the land, a paternal figure who fights first and foremost to secure peace.

to:

** In Greek mythology, Ares was always the spirit of bloodlust and is portrayed as a vicious brute, primarily a destructive and destabilizing force. The Romans' Mars began as a god of agriculture, and even as a war god {{war god}} he was seen as defender of the land, a paternal figure who fights first and foremost to secure peace.



* ''Theatre/LesMiserables'': Like in its film adaptation (see above), Eponine is considerably more sympathetic (and saner) than she is in the original novel.

to:

* ''Theatre/LesMiserables'': Like in its film adaptation (see above), the Live-Action Film page), Eponine is considerably more sympathetic (and saner) than she is in the original novel.



** Here, Ramses actually demurs from attacking the Hebrews at the Red Sea. Hotep, on the other hand...

to:

** Here, Ramses actually demurs from attacking the Hebrews at the Red Sea. Hotep, [[AdaptationalVillainy Hotep]], on the other hand...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*''Machinima/ZsdavAdventures'': [[Franchise/StarWars Darth Maul]] appears as the [[Literature/AChristmasCarol ghost of Christmas present]] to teach Zsdav the true meaning of Christmas in ''[[YetAnotherChristmasCarol Karácsonyi külön kiadás]]'' (''Christmas special'').
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'': In ''Literature/{{Wintersmith}}'', the Summer Lady is callous and uncaring, and it's made very clear that eternal summer would have been just as bad as eternal winter; it's just not what happened. The song "The Summer Lady" in the Music/SteeleyeSpan ConceptAlbum ''Wintersmith'' is about how wonderful she is for ending the cold. (Although the earlier "Fire and Ice" correctly portrays both the Summer Lady and the Wintersmith as neither good nor evil, just balanced.)

to:

* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'': In ''Literature/{{Wintersmith}}'', the Summer Lady is callous and uncaring, and it's made very clear that eternal summer would have been just as bad as eternal winter; it's just not what happened. The song "The Summer Lady" in the Music/SteeleyeSpan ConceptAlbum ''Wintersmith'' ''Music/{{Wintersmith}}'' is about how wonderful she is for ending the cold. (Although the earlier "Fire and Ice" correctly portrays both the Summer Lady and the Wintersmith as neither good nor evil, just balanced.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*''Machinima/DarkSecretsOfGarrysMod'': [[Videogame/HalfLife1 G-Man]] is AmbiguouslyEvil with [[BlueAndOrangeMorality varying degrees of morality]] in his source material. In this series however, he has the innocence of an immature child.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Hades often gets this treatment in modern media due to the fact that he only abducted and raped ''one'' person, compared to either of his brothers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WebAnimation/DeathBattle'' due [[HypotheticalFightDebate the nature of the show]], usually has the [[AdaptationalVillainy inverse]] of this with perfectly heroic and nice characters willingly to kill their opponents over minor disputes or for no reason at all, but ''[[Recap/DEATHBATTLES02E21IronManVSLexLuthor Iron Man Vs Lex Luthor]]'' has this in regard to Tony. His line ''"Being a god can't be that hard. I'm the most intelligent, capable person on the planet. I'm not playing god. All this time... I've been playing human"'' comes from ''ComicBook/SuperiorIronMan'' where Tony being a VillainProtagonist says it to Comicbook/{{Daredevil}} after curing his blindness without consent, showing how megolomania has gotten to him. In the context of the good vs evil Death Battle however, Tony says it during a HeroicSecondWind after SmugSnake Lex (thinking he's beaten Iron Man) [[EvilGloating gloats]] that ''he's'' the only human worthy of [[AGodIAm playing god]], the ''"I'm not playing god. All this time... I've been playing human"'' line instead comes off as a heroic ShutUpHannibal putting Luthor in his place.

to:

* ''WebAnimation/DeathBattle'' due to [[HypotheticalFightDebate the nature of the show]], usually has the [[AdaptationalVillainy inverse]] of this with perfectly heroic and nice characters willingly to kill their opponents over minor disputes or for no reason at all, but ''[[Recap/DEATHBATTLES02E21IronManVSLexLuthor Iron Man Vs Lex Luthor]]'' has this in regard to Tony. His line ''"Being a god can't be that hard. I'm the most intelligent, capable person on the planet. I'm not playing god. All this time... I've been playing human"'' comes from ''ComicBook/SuperiorIronMan'' where Tony being a VillainProtagonist says it to Comicbook/{{Daredevil}} after curing his blindness without consent, showing how megolomania has gotten to him. In the context of the good vs evil Death Battle however, Tony says it during a HeroicSecondWind after SmugSnake Lex (thinking he's beaten Iron Man) [[EvilGloating gloats]] that ''he's'' the only human worthy of [[AGodIAm playing god]], the ''"I'm not playing god. All this time... I've been playing human"'' line instead comes off as a heroic ShutUpHannibal putting Luthor in his place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WebAnimation/DeathBattle'' due [[HypotheticalFightDebate the nature of the show]], usually has the [[AdaptationalVillainy inverse]] of this with perfectly heroic and nice characters willingly to kill their opponents over minor disputes or for no reason at all, but ''[[Recap/DEATHBATTLES02E21IronManVSLexLuthor Iron Man Vs Lex Luthor]]'' has this in regard to Tony. His line ''"Being a god can't be that hard. I'm the most intelligent, capable person on the planet. I'm not playing god. All this time... I've been playing human"'' comes from ''ComicBook/SuperiorIronMan'' where Tony being a VillainProtagonist says it to Comicbook/{{Daredevil}} after curing his blindness with consent, showing how megolomania has gotten to him. In the context of the good vs evil Death Battle however, Tony says it during a HeroicSecondWind after SmugSnake Lex (thinking he's beaten Iron Man) [[EvilGloating gloats]] that ''he's'' the only human worthy of [[AGodIAm playing god]], the ''"I'm not playing god. All this time... I've been playing human"'' line instead comes off as a heroic ShutUpHannibal putting Luthor in his place.

to:

* ''WebAnimation/DeathBattle'' due [[HypotheticalFightDebate the nature of the show]], usually has the [[AdaptationalVillainy inverse]] of this with perfectly heroic and nice characters willingly to kill their opponents over minor disputes or for no reason at all, but ''[[Recap/DEATHBATTLES02E21IronManVSLexLuthor Iron Man Vs Lex Luthor]]'' has this in regard to Tony. His line ''"Being a god can't be that hard. I'm the most intelligent, capable person on the planet. I'm not playing god. All this time... I've been playing human"'' comes from ''ComicBook/SuperiorIronMan'' where Tony being a VillainProtagonist says it to Comicbook/{{Daredevil}} after curing his blindness with without consent, showing how megolomania has gotten to him. In the context of the good vs evil Death Battle however, Tony says it during a HeroicSecondWind after SmugSnake Lex (thinking he's beaten Iron Man) [[EvilGloating gloats]] that ''he's'' the only human worthy of [[AGodIAm playing god]], the ''"I'm not playing god. All this time... I've been playing human"'' line instead comes off as a heroic ShutUpHannibal putting Luthor in his place.

Top