Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / AdaptationInducedPlotHole

Go To

OR

Changed: 1213

Removed: 21

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved from dub induced--it even *says* it\'s adaptation induced.



----
<<|DerivativeWorks|>>

to:

\n----\n<<|DerivativeWorks|>>* In ''MetroidPrime Trilogy'', the help for the combat visor in the first game notes that the visors you possesses are indicated in the lower left of the screen. This is not true for the trilogy version where they are in a separate menu accessed by holding - and selecting the visor from a menu, and only the current visor remains listed on the {{HUD}}.
** Another example, from the same game (also from the North American re-release of Metroid Prime). In the original release of Prime, the titular Metroid Prime had been captured by the Space Pirates and studied for a while. Then, it broke out, merged with some Pirate gear, and escaped back to where it came from. The problem is that where it came from was supposed to be behind an impenetrable barrier that you spend most of the game getting the key to. So this was changed in the re-releases to fix the plot hole; it was never captured by Pirates and so forth. However, in so doing, they ''introduced'' another plot hole: if the Metroid Prime never was captured by the Space Pirates, where did it get all that fancy Pirate gear that it uses on you in the first battle? And why is it even called "Metroid Prime;" since it was the Pirates who gave it that name?

Changed: 415

Removed: 271

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the AvatarTheLastAirbender, The Fire Nation keeps Earthbenders it captures on a metal platform at sea, far away from the rock and ground they could use to help escape. In the movie adaption, they are kept on land, yet do no earthbending at all for some reason.
** It takes a lot of unecessary movement and 7 different people to move a pebble in the movie. [[FridgeBrilliance Of course the Firebenders aren't worried about Earthbending from the people in the concentration camp; they're nowhere near as competent as in the cartoon!]]

to:

* In ''Film/TheLastAirbender'', Earthbenders are kept on land, yet do no earthbending at all. In the AvatarTheLastAirbender, The [[AvatarTheLastAirbender original show]] the Fire Nation keeps Earthbenders it captures on a metal platform at sea, far away from the rock and ground they could use to help escape. In Admittedly, both explain that the movie adaption, they are kept on land, yet do no earthbending at all for some reason.
** It takes a lot of unecessary movement
Earthbenders had their spirits broken and 7 different people to move a pebble no longer wanted any trouble (even in the movie. [[FridgeBrilliance Of course show when given access to their element the Firebenders aren't worried about Earthbending from Earthbenders didn't want to fight the people in prison guards). It's only that the concentration camp; they're nowhere near as competent as in the cartoon!]]explanation for their broken spirits (no earth to bend) wasn't present.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The first time Naruto meets Jiraiya, Naruto uses the Sexy Jutsu to convince Jiraiya to train him, noting to himself that "[[AllMenArePerverts This jutsu seems to work on all men]]". One of the more recent episodes, which aired ''years'' after the episode with the previous scene, had a scene that took place before Naruto met Jiraiya, where Naruto used the Sexy Jutsu on [[TheUnfunny Sasuke]], with no effect.

to:

* ** The first time Naruto meets Jiraiya, Naruto uses the Sexy Jutsu to convince Jiraiya to train him, noting to himself that "[[AllMenArePerverts This jutsu seems to work on all men]]". One of the more recent episodes, which aired ''years'' after the episode with the previous scene, had a scene that took place before Naruto met Jiraiya, where Naruto used the Sexy Jutsu on [[TheUnfunny Sasuke]], with no effect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The first time Naruto meets Jiraiya, Naruto uses the Sexy Jutsu to convince Jiraiya to train him, noting to himself that "[[AllMenArePerverts This jutsu seems to work on all men]]". One of the more recent episodes, which aired ''years'' after the episode with the previous scene, had a scene tah took place before Naruto met Jiraiya, where Naruto used the Sexy Jutsu on [[TheUnfunny Sasuke]], with no effect.

to:

* The first time Naruto meets Jiraiya, Naruto uses the Sexy Jutsu to convince Jiraiya to train him, noting to himself that "[[AllMenArePerverts This jutsu seems to work on all men]]". One of the more recent episodes, which aired ''years'' after the episode with the previous scene, had a scene tah that took place before Naruto met Jiraiya, where Naruto used the Sexy Jutsu on [[TheUnfunny Sasuke]], with no effect.

Added: 410

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Naruto}}'' claims to have only read 10 pages of Jiraiya's latest novel, Make Out Tactics, in the anime as an extra joke that he was lying when he distracted Kakashi by pretending to spoil the ending. However, later on [[spoiler:when he's trying to decode a message Jiraiya left behind while dying]], it's revealed that he proofread Jiraiya's books, which would require reading the whole thing, and [[spoiler:knows Jiraiya's handwriting well enough to notice that he disguised a "ta" katakana as a 9]].

to:

* ''{{Naruto}}'' claims to have only read 10 pages of Jiraiya's latest novel, Make Out Tactics, in the anime as an extra joke that he was lying when he distracted Kakashi by pretending to spoil the ending. However, later on [[spoiler:when he's trying to decode a message Jiraiya left behind while dying]], it's revealed that he proofread Jiraiya's books, which would require reading the whole thing, and [[spoiler:knows Jiraiya's handwriting well enough to notice that he disguised a "ta" katakana (ã‚¿) as a 9]].


Added DiffLines:

* The first time Naruto meets Jiraiya, Naruto uses the Sexy Jutsu to convince Jiraiya to train him, noting to himself that "[[AllMenArePerverts This jutsu seems to work on all men]]". One of the more recent episodes, which aired ''years'' after the episode with the previous scene, had a scene tah took place before Naruto met Jiraiya, where Naruto used the Sexy Jutsu on [[TheUnfunny Sasuke]], with no effect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''SaintSeiya'' had one when they showed Scorpio Milo killing Shun's Master. Then the manga came out and it was [[spoiler: Pisces Aphrodite]]. A number of {{AssPull}}s had to be done to fix the problem of Shun swearing revenge against someone who didn't apply the coup de grace against his teacher.


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It takes a lot of unecessary movement and 7 different people to move a pebble in the movie. [[FridgeBrilliance Of course the Firebenders aren't worried about Earthbending from the people in the concentration camp; they're nowhere near as competent as in the cartoon!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWarriors video game, in lieu of changing the story of the film, opted to make most of the game a prequel depicting the Warrior's rise before the events of the main story. For the most part, it works. However, there is one scene where Masai demands to know who The Warriors are and none of the other Riffs can answer him. In the film this makes sense, since we have no reason to believe the Warriors ever did anything to stand out. In the game however, the missions involve fighting their way through several gangs (trashing dozens of members with only four, at most, of their own), beating up or killing several other gang leaders and overthrowing the rival gang of Coney Island who they split from. While the Riffs ARE the biggest gang in the city, and presumably don't follow everything that happens with the small-time gangs, it is strange to think that none of them would've hear about the Warriors given all the havoc they cause.

to:

* TheWarriors video game, in lieu of changing the story of the film, opted to make most of the game a prequel depicting the Warrior's rise before the events of the main story. For the most part, it works. However, there is one scene where Masai demands to know who The Warriors are and none of the other Riffs can answer him. In the film this makes sense, since we have no reason to believe the Warriors ever did anything to stand out. In the game however, the missions involve fighting their way through several gangs (trashing dozens of members with only four, at most, of their own), beating up or killing several other gang leaders and overthrowing the rival gang of Coney Island who they split from. While the Riffs ARE the biggest gang in the city, and presumably don't follow everything that happens with the small-time gangs, it is strange to think that none of them would've hear heard about the Warriors given all the havoc they cause.

Added: 960

Changed: 527

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The short story turned short film ''Paul's Case'' has an example of this, although it's not so much a plot hole as a moment of characterization kept in when it didn't fit with the other changes. In the original story, Paul is portrayed in a way that makes it easy to assume he has mental problems. In the film he's turned much more sympathetic, and is shown to be a victim of circumstances, yet the film keeps in a scene where Paul creepily fantasizes about his father shooting him when he crawls through his basement window.


Added DiffLines:

[[AC:{{VideoGames}}]]
* TheWarriors video game, in lieu of changing the story of the film, opted to make most of the game a prequel depicting the Warrior's rise before the events of the main story. For the most part, it works. However, there is one scene where Masai demands to know who The Warriors are and none of the other Riffs can answer him. In the film this makes sense, since we have no reason to believe the Warriors ever did anything to stand out. In the game however, the missions involve fighting their way through several gangs (trashing dozens of members with only four, at most, of their own), beating up or killing several other gang leaders and overthrowing the rival gang of Coney Island who they split from. While the Riffs ARE the biggest gang in the city, and presumably don't follow everything that happens with the small-time gangs, it is strange to think that none of them would've hear about the Warriors given all the havoc they cause.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the ''[=~Ranma ½~=]'' manga, [[GenderBender Ranma (as a girl)]] competes with [[WholesomeCrossdresser Tsubasa]] (who's disguise had yet to be revealed) in who can sell more food to the boys at school, but since all of them knew that Ranma wasn't a real girl they didn't buy any from her until she started wearing a disguise. However, in the anime Ranma's curse wasn't revealed by this point, so the boys bought nothing from her and started buying when she wore a disguise for no apparent reason.

to:

* In the ''[=~Ranma ½~=]'' manga, [[GenderBender Ranma (as a girl)]] competes with [[WholesomeCrossdresser Tsubasa]] (who's disguise had yet to be revealed) in who can sell more food to the boys at school, but since all of them knew that Ranma wasn't a real girl they didn't buy any from her until she started wearing a disguise. However, in the anime Ranma's curse wasn't revealed by this point, so the boys bought nothing from her and started buying when she wore a disguise for [[PlayboyBunny no apparent reason.
reason]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** At the end of the fourth book, Harry gives his Triwizard Tournament winnings to Fred and George so they can start up their joke shop. The movie never shows this, leaving viewers wondering where they got the capital to start up the shop in the sixth movie.

Changed: 31

Removed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixed spoiler tags in The Departed example


* In ''InfernalAffairs'', only Superintendent Wong knows the identity of the police's mole. When [[spoiler:he's murdered, the mole has no one in the police department to turn to]]. In ''TheDeparted'', both Captain Queenan and his assistant Sergeant Dignam know who the mole is. When [[spoiler:Queenan is murdered, the mole acts like he has no one to turn to, but Dignam is simply away on suspension. Why no one bothers to look him up is never explained. Dignam's sudden reappearance at the end is treated as a surprise, but fans of the original would be waiting that dangling thread to resolve for half the
film]].

to:

* In ''InfernalAffairs'', only Superintendent Wong knows the identity of the police's mole. When [[spoiler:he's murdered, the mole has no one in the police department to turn to]]. In ''TheDeparted'', both Captain Queenan and his assistant Sergeant Dignam know who the mole is. When [[spoiler:Queenan is murdered, murdered]], the mole acts like he has no one to turn to, but Dignam [[spoiler:Dignam is simply away on suspension.suspension]]. Why no one bothers to look him up is never explained. Dignam's [[spoiler:Dignam's sudden reappearance at the end end]] is treated as a surprise, but fans of the original would be waiting that dangling thread to resolve for half the
film]].
the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fine, I'll tone down the "specifically because", but this stays. That "it wouldn't have worked anyway" is pure speculation and isn't even used as a Hand Wave. Logic dictates she should have at least tried.

Added DiffLines:

** One {{Filler}} episode had Hinata learn a unique, powerful technique featuring a myriad pinpoint-precision chakra laser beams. Later in the manga, a major villain is able to [[CurbStompBattle curb stomp]] her using his powerful gravity blast attack- she spends the fight repeatedly charging at him while trying to land a physical hit, which is ''hopeless''. The chakra lasers would have obviously been a much better bet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"Specifically"? Any range attack she had would have been blown away by the same Shinra Tensei that smash her into the ground.


** One {{Filler}} episode had Hinata learn a unique, powerful technique featuring a myriad pinpoint-precision chakra laser beams. Later in the manga, a major villain is able to [[CurbStompBattle curb stomp]] her specifically because he has a powerful distance attack and she doesn't.

Added: 265

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''InfernalAffairs'', only Superintendent Wong knows the identity of the police's mole. When [[spoiler:he's murdered, the mole has no one in the police department to turn to]]. In ''TheDeparted'', both Captain Queenan and his assistant Sergeant Dignam know who the mole is. When [[spoiler:Queenan is murdered, the mole acts like he has no one to turn to, but Dignam is simply away on suspension. Why no one bothers to look him up is never explained. Dignam's sudden reappearance at the end is treated as a surprise, but fans of the original would be waiting that dangling thread to resolve for half the film]].

to:

* In ''InfernalAffairs'', only Superintendent Wong knows the identity of the police's mole. When [[spoiler:he's murdered, the mole has no one in the police department to turn to]]. In ''TheDeparted'', both Captain Queenan and his assistant Sergeant Dignam know who the mole is. When [[spoiler:Queenan is murdered, the mole acts like he has no one to turn to, but Dignam is simply away on suspension. Why no one bothers to look him up is never explained. Dignam's sudden reappearance at the end is treated as a surprise, but fans of the original would be waiting that dangling thread to resolve for half the the
film]].
* In the AvatarTheLastAirbender, The Fire Nation keeps Earthbenders it captures on a metal platform at sea, far away from the rock and ground they could use to help escape. In the movie adaption, they are kept on land, yet do no earthbending at all for some reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also in the DragonBallZ anime, the line from the DragonBall manga is cut where Zarbon tells Vegeta that Freeza can transform, leaving a bit of a headscratching moment when Vegeta references it later on. Kai does not fix this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''InfernalAffairs'', only Superintendent Wong knows the identity of the police's mole. When [[spoiler:he's murdered, the mole has no one in the police department to turn to]]. In ''TheDeparted'', both Captain Queenan and his assistant Sergeant Dignam know who the mole is. When [[spoiler:Queenan is murdered, the mole acts like he has no one to turn to, but Dignam is simply away on suspension. Why no one bothers to look him up is never explained. Dignam's sudden reappearance at the end is treated as a surprise, but fans of the original would be waiting that dangling thread to resolve for half the film]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** One {{Filler}} episode had Hinata learn a unique, powerful technique featuring a myriad pinpoint-precision chakra laser beams. Later in the manga, a major villain is able to [[CurbStompBattle curb stomp]] her specifically because he has a powerful distance attack and she doesn't.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

If there is simply a lack of explanation as to why something happened, instead of a full-on PlotHole, it's AdaptationExplanationExtrication.

Changed: 214

Removed: 641

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Something simply being unexplained it not a Plot Hole, that's a different trope.


** Still many are left - with most of Barty Crouch Jr.'s ExpositionDump cut out of the 4th movie, no explanation is given as to how he escaped from Askaban and how no one noticed he was missing in a ''whole'' year.
* There are so many in the film adaptation of ''{{Eragon}}'' that [[StillbornFranchise continuing the movie franchise would almost be impossible]].
** Same goes for the first adaptation of the {{Percy Jackson And The Olympians}} books.
* The reason why Anton Gorodetski doesn't have his powers of premonition in ''Day Watch'': he didn't have them in the original cut of ''NightWatch'', but the adapted version that was distributed worldwide had his visions edited in.
* How is it that Sophie can save Calcifer in ''HowlsMovingCastle''? DianaWynneJones explains; it's in fact part of an important plot point. {{Film/HowlsMovingCastle}} does not.

to:

** Still many are left - with most of Barty Crouch Jr.'s ExpositionDump cut out of the 4th movie, no explanation is given as to how he escaped from Askaban and how no one noticed he was missing in a ''whole'' year.
* There are so many in the film adaptation of ''{{Eragon}}'' that [[StillbornFranchise continuing the movie franchise would almost be impossible]].
** Same goes for the first adaptation of the {{Percy Jackson And The Olympians}} books.
* The reason why Anton Gorodetski doesn't have his powers of premonition in ''Day Watch'': he didn't have them in the original cut of ''NightWatch'', but the adapted version that was distributed worldwide had his visions edited in.
* How is it that Sophie can save Calcifer in ''HowlsMovingCastle''? DianaWynneJones explains; it's in fact part of an important plot point. {{Film/HowlsMovingCastle}} does not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


[[AC:VideoGames]]
* The fact that in Europe, a censored version of ''NoMoreHeroes'' and an uncensored version of ''NoMoreHeroes2'' were released creates some of these plot-holes: Destroyman and Letz Shake were supposed to have been completely reduced to ash, yet they return, and Shinobu has a robotic limb for no apparent reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* How is it that Sophie can save Calcifer in ''HowlsMovingCastle''? DianaWynneJones explains; it's in fact part of an important plot point. {{Film/HowlsMovingCastle}} does not.

Added: 329

Changed: 231

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The reason why Anton Gorodetski doesn't have his powers of premonition in ''Day Watch'': he didn't have them in the original cut of ''NightWatch'', but the adapted version that was distributed worldwide had his visions edited in.


Added DiffLines:

[[AC:VideoGames]]
* The fact that in Europe, a censored version of ''NoMoreHeroes'' and an uncensored version of ''NoMoreHeroes2'' were released creates some of these plot-holes: Destroyman and Letz Shake were supposed to have been completely reduced to ash, yet they return, and Shinobu has a robotic limb for no apparent reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Well, we know Blofeld had plastic surgery in various instances to look different, and he's played by several different actors, so it is possible he didn't recognize him because he genuinely looked different. Which would make sense considering Blofeld's plan in that one. So, I guess, it's an unintentional AuthorsSavingThrow which actually makes a lot of sense in context if you look at it along with the events of ''Diamonds are Forever''.

Changed: 261

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** As with Dobby, the filmmakers were going to cut [[spoiler: Kreacher]] altogether, but Rowling insisted on his presence due to his role in future books.

to:

*** As ** Still many are left - with Dobby, most of Barty Crouch Jr.'s ExpositionDump cut out of the filmmakers were going 4th movie, no explanation is given as to cut [[spoiler: Kreacher]] altogether, but Rowling insisted on his presence due to his role how he escaped from Askaban and how no one noticed he was missing in future books.a ''whole'' year.

Added: 575

Removed: 575

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC:{{TableTopGames}}]]
* More of an edition change induced plothole, but in the ''DungeonsAndDragons'' 3.5 player's handbook, a priest of Pelor, the quintessentially good deity of Greyhawk, is seen using a Symbol of Pain spell, which good aligned gods cannot grant. What happened was that they reused some artwork from the 3.0 PHB of the priest using the pain aspect of the Symbol spell, which was originally an unaligned spell.
** This, along with other artwork of said cleric being a dick to his party, resulted in the creation of [[EpilepticTrees Pelor the Burning Hate]].


Added DiffLines:


[[AC:{{TableTopGames}}]]
* More of an edition change induced plothole, but in the ''DungeonsAndDragons'' 3.5 player's handbook, a priest of Pelor, the quintessentially good deity of Greyhawk, is seen using a Symbol of Pain spell, which good aligned gods cannot grant. What happened was that they reused some artwork from the 3.0 PHB of the priest using the pain aspect of the Symbol spell, which was originally an unaligned spell.
** This, along with other artwork of said cleric being a dick to his party, resulted in the creation of [[EpilepticTrees Pelor the Burning Hate]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** As with Dobby, the filmmakers were going to cut [[spoiler: Kreacher]] altogether, but Rowling insisted on his presence due to his role in future books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No headshot in the manga.


* ''{{Hellsing}}'': In his fight with Alucard, Luke Valentine is shown to have a strong HealingFactor, surviving after getting shot in the head by Alucard's specialized gun. However he is unable to regenerate his legs. In the manga this inconsistency could be explained by the fact that Casull inflicted the head shot, while his legs were shot off by Jackal. In the OVA, Jackal was the cause of all three wounds.

to:

* ''{{Hellsing}}'': In his fight with Alucard, Luke Valentine is shown to have a strong HealingFactor, surviving after getting shot in the head by Alucard's specialized gun. However he is unable to regenerate his legs. In the manga this inconsistency could be explained there was no headshot. He was instead shot in the stomach by the fact that Casull inflicted the head shot, Casull, while his legs were shot off by Jackal. In the OVA, Jackal was the cause of all three wounds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
none of those are really Plot Holes, see discussion, at most Fridge Logic with some It Just Bugs Me, see discussion


* Several in ''[[Film/TheLastAirbender The Last Airbender]]''. Most noticeably, the firebenders now need a source of fire to bend it. But considering that fire can be put out by water, earth, and air, while the other three elements can not be put out, it becomes unbelievable that the fire nation could have actually conquered any of the other three nations.
** Also the fire nation prison is no longer set on an iron platform in the middle of the ocean. Now the firebenders keep captured earthbenders in a prison with a completely dirt floor, with not even the slightest explanation about why the earthbenders never fought back.
** Just the fact that Jet wasn't introduced in the first movie, leaves a ton of plot that needs to be made up in the second movie.
** And the Kyoshi Warriors - How the hell is Azula supposed to conquer Ba Sing Se?
** Also, Aang leaves because he is told that avatars can't have a family, but if Avatar Roku didn't have a family, then Zuko and Azula couldn't have been born.
*** Actually, this works if you consider the fact that it's specifically Aang who was told this. Avatars ''can'' have families, it's just that the ''Air Nomad elders'' don't think Aang should have personal attachments like that. Sure, you can't interpret this unless you see the actual show, but [[{{FridgeBrilliance}} it does work.]]
** And Katara never learns about the healing arts because A) Jeong Jeong isn't in the movie and B) Pakku is such a nice guy that he allows her to be a student. How is she going to know how to bring Aang back to life after Azula electrocutes him?

Top