Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / AdaptationInducedPlotHole

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Cell:''' You know, I still don't know how I learned how to do that.

to:

-->'''Cell:''' --->'''Cell:''' You know, I still don't know how I learned how to do that.

Added: 416

Changed: 21

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Vegeta [[DeathByAdaptation kills Ginyu]] rather than sparing him like he did in the source material. This eventually brings up a plot hole when the Ginyu Forces gather together at King Kai's planet yet Captain Ginyu himself is not present as he doesn't die in the canon. [[note]] However, the whole Ginyu Forces go to King Kai's planet is itself a non-canon mini arc so, make that what you will.[[/note]] HFIL clears this up by establishing that Ginyu's soul is a frog, and was thus unable to tell his team who he was.

to:

** Vegeta [[DeathByAdaptation kills Ginyu]] rather than sparing him like he did in the source material. This eventually brings up a plot hole when the Ginyu Forces gather together at King Kai's planet yet Captain Ginyu himself is not present as he doesn't die in the canon. [[note]] However, the whole Ginyu Forces go to King Kai's planet is itself a non-canon mini arc so, make that what you will.[[/note]] HFIL ''WebAnimation/{{HFIL}}'' clears this up by establishing that Ginyu's soul is a frog, and was thus unable to tell his team who he was.


Added DiffLines:

** Goku gained the ability to use Instant Transmission from the Yardtrats feeding him the flesh of their sick rather than just being taught it, meaning that Cell [[PowerCopying suddenly gaining the ability to do it]] after Goku's HeroicSacrifice doesn't make any sense. Cell himself even lampshades this when remembering the event in ''HFIL''.
-->'''Cell:''' You know, I still don't know how I learned how to do that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The UsefulNotes/PlayStation2 version of the first ''VideoGame/SplinterCell1'' includes an extra mission set in a nuclear power plant as an added bonus to make up for all the other content that had to be cut from the Xbox and PC versions. Despite this mission not being available on any other platform other than the original [=PS2=] release, however, it's still treated as plot-critical to ''all'' versions, as the mission explains how a rogue Chinese general got his hands on nuclear material he plans to make a bomb with - on any platform other than that, all this comes out to is a brief moment in the second Chinese Embassy mission where Lambert [[OhCrap suddenly starts freaking out]] about having found some "missing Americium-239" the player was never warned about before that point.
* ''[[VideoGame/{{Warcraft}} Warcraft 3]] [[UpdatedRerelease Reforged]]'' created one in the Scourge campaign. In the original game, Arthas had to use a waygate system or goblin zeppelins in order to get around Sylvanas destroying the bridges so he could reach the Sunwell and bring back Kel'Thuzad, with the Sunwell being located in Silvermoon city. ''VideoGame/WorldOfWarcraft'' would later move the Sunwell to it's own island located past Silvermoon city, making the original way Arthas got to it no longer possible, which the Arthas focused novel, ''[[Literature/{{Arthas}} Arthas: Rise of the Lich King]]'', explained away by having him use Frostmourne to make a ice path for his army to cross over to. Reforged adjusted the level to include the changes made since the original game's release, even including said explanation for how he got to the island, but still kept prior elements of the level the same, such as waygates and zeppelins, creating a plothole exclusive to Reforge about why Arthas never used ice to cross the destroyed gaps sooner, or why he didn't just use goblin zeppelins to get across instead.

to:

* The UsefulNotes/PlayStation2 Platform/PlayStation2 version of the first ''VideoGame/SplinterCell1'' includes an extra mission set in a nuclear power plant as an added bonus to make up for all the other content that had to be cut from the Xbox and PC versions. Despite this mission not being available on any other platform other than the original [=PS2=] release, however, it's still treated as plot-critical to ''all'' versions, as the mission explains how a rogue Chinese general got his hands on nuclear material he plans to make a bomb with - on any platform other than that, all this comes out to is a brief moment in the second Chinese Embassy mission where Lambert [[OhCrap suddenly starts freaking out]] about having found some "missing Americium-239" the player was never warned about before that point.
* ''[[VideoGame/{{Warcraft}} ''[[VideoGame/WarcraftIII Warcraft 3]] [[UpdatedRerelease Reforged]]'' created one in the Scourge campaign. In the original game, Arthas had to use a waygate system or goblin zeppelins in order to get around Sylvanas destroying the bridges so he could reach the Sunwell and bring back Kel'Thuzad, with the Sunwell being located in Silvermoon city. ''VideoGame/WorldOfWarcraft'' would later move the Sunwell to it's own island located past Silvermoon city, making the original way Arthas got to it no longer possible, which the Arthas focused novel, ''[[Literature/{{Arthas}} Arthas: Rise of the Lich King]]'', explained away by having him use Frostmourne to make a ice path for his army to cross over to. Reforged adjusted the level to include the changes made since the original game's release, even including said explanation for how he got to the island, but still kept prior elements of the level the same, such as waygates and zeppelins, creating a plothole exclusive to Reforge about why Arthas never used ice to cross the destroyed gaps sooner, or why he didn't just use goblin zeppelins to get across instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''[[VideoGame/{{Warcraft}} Warcraft 3]] [[UpdatedRerelease Reforged]]'' created one in the Scourge campaign. In the original game, Arthas had to use a waygate system or goblin zepplins in order to get around Sylvanas destroying the bridges so he could reach the Sunwell and bring back Kel'Thuzad, the Sunwell being located in Silvermoon city. ''VideoGame/WorldOfWarcraft'' would later move the Sunwell to it's own island located past Silvermoon city, which the Arthas focused novel, ''[[Literature/{{Arthas}} Arthas: Rise of the Lich King]]'', provided a reason he got to it by using Frostmourne to make a ice path to cross it. Reforged adjusted the level to include said explanation, but still kept prior elements of invasion the same, such as waygates and zeppelins, creating a plothole exclusive to Reforge about why Arthas never used ice to cross the destroyed gaps sooner.

to:

* ''[[VideoGame/{{Warcraft}} Warcraft 3]] [[UpdatedRerelease Reforged]]'' created one in the Scourge campaign. In the original game, Arthas had to use a waygate system or goblin zepplins zeppelins in order to get around Sylvanas destroying the bridges so he could reach the Sunwell and bring back Kel'Thuzad, with the Sunwell being located in Silvermoon city. ''VideoGame/WorldOfWarcraft'' would later move the Sunwell to it's own island located past Silvermoon city, making the original way Arthas got to it no longer possible, which the Arthas focused novel, ''[[Literature/{{Arthas}} Arthas: Rise of the Lich King]]'', provided a reason he got to it explained away by using having him use Frostmourne to make a ice path for his army to cross it. over to. Reforged adjusted the level to include the changes made since the original game's release, even including said explanation, explanation for how he got to the island, but still kept prior elements of invasion the level the same, such as waygates and zeppelins, creating a plothole exclusive to Reforge about why Arthas never used ice to cross the destroyed gaps sooner.sooner, or why he didn't just use goblin zeppelins to get across instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* A minor one in [[Recap/WhatIfS1E5WhatIfZombies the (loose) ''What If'' adaptation of]] ''ComicBook/MarvelZombies''. In both versions of the story, The Avengers get infected relatively early in the outbreak, and their zombified selves serve as antagonists for the rest of it. In the original, it was believable that Earth's Mightiest Heroes could fall so quickly because they were the first to respond to an [[NegativeSpaceWedgie anomaly,]] which turns out to be a zombified [[SupermanSubstitute Sentry]], meaning they unexpectedly found themselves confronted by the zombie-plague, in the form of a carrier far more powerful than any of them. But in the animated adaptation set in a divergent MCU, they [[LeeroyJenkins decide to all jump into the center of the hoard with no apparent plan,]] and are all infected off-screen, implicitly from being [[ZergRush overwhelmed by the zombies' numbers.]] This ill-thought out plan seems especially innexplicable because, [[Film/AvengersInfinityWar at that point in time in the MCU,]] the Avengers were disassembled, and would only have reassemble after they realized how massive a threat the zombies were.

to:

* A minor one in [[Recap/WhatIfS1E5WhatIfZombies the (loose) ''What If'' adaptation of]] ''ComicBook/MarvelZombies''. In both versions of the story, The Avengers get infected relatively early in the outbreak, and their zombified selves serve as antagonists for the rest of it. In the original, it was believable that Earth's Mightiest Heroes could fall so quickly because they were the first to respond to an [[NegativeSpaceWedgie anomaly,]] which turns out to be a zombified [[SupermanSubstitute Sentry]], meaning they unexpectedly found themselves confronted by the zombie-plague, in the form of a carrier far more powerful than any of them. But in the animated adaptation set in a divergent MCU, they [[LeeroyJenkins decide to all jump into the center of the hoard with no apparent plan,]] and are all infected off-screen, implicitly from being [[ZergRush overwhelmed by the zombies' numbers.]] This ill-thought out plan seems especially innexplicable inexplicable because, [[Film/AvengersInfinityWar at that point in time in the MCU,]] the Avengers were disassembled, and would only have reassemble reassembled after they realized how massive a threat the zombies were.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking

Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/ResidentEvil4Remake:''
** The game cuts a lot of exposition, to the point of effectively cutting entire plot points from [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil4 the original,]] without which parts of the story don’t make sense. For one, in the original, Ashley's disappearance was thought to be due to a leak or traitor within the American government, and so they call on [[PlayerCharacter Leon]] because he was not involved in the President's security team when Ashley disappeared, so he was not a suspect. This fact was even exploited by Los Illuminados, with some found files stating to expect a slow American response due to them combing for the traitor. None of this is ever stated or implied in the remake, and Leon has no trouble speaking with [[MissionControl Agent Hunnigan]] or requesting evac as soon as he’s with Ashley, making it seemingly nonsensical that Leon was not only sent on the mission alone, but didn’t call for reinforcements as soon as he realized the village was a BOW site.
** In both versions, Bitores Mendez accosts Leon in the Village Chief's Manor, grabbing him by the throat and noticing he is infected with the Plaga. Like in the original, Ada intervenes by shooting Mendez through a nearby window and causing him to release his grip on Leon. But in the original, Mendez threatened Leon with death if he continued to cause trouble, then jumped out of the window in pursuit of Ada. Here he calmly leaves without a word. Him sparing Leon can be (somewhat ) justified by Leon's Plaga infection, but Mendez doesn’t even seem interested in chasing Ada, an obvious second interloper he has zero reason to keep alive.
** Midway through the castle, Leon loses contact with Hunnigan but there is no evidence of jamming or foul play by Los Iluminados; the signal simply cuts out due to unknown interference. Despite this Leon makes no attempt later on to reestablish communications, even after he communicates with Luis and Ada just fine.
** It's never explained how Mike knew to show up at the island to assist Leon during the climax, since they agree upon a different extraction point a ways away earlier in the story, and a moment where Leon attempts to contact with the outside world using the island's communication facilities (not getting a reply, but it’s still implied his message got out.) is cut from the remake.
** The ''Separate Ways'' DLC retcons it so that [[spoiler: Wesker is actually in the village around the same time as Leon and Ada (in the original, he was just Ada’s employer.)]] But given [[spoiler: Wesker’s]] enhancements canonically made him a OneManArmy, even compared to Ada, it's unclear why he even sent Ada on the mission instead of handling it himself, or at least working with her if he had no problem showing up in person.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
General clarification on works content


* ''VideoGame/RamboTheVideoGame'' is a CompressedAdaptation based off the first three ''Franchise/{{Rambo}}'' films, and the segments based on ''Film/FirstBlood'', ends with Rambo getting arrested just like in the film. Unlike the film, where Rambo kills only a single policemen by accident, the game allows him to maim, shoot, and massacre aplenty without any guilt, which makes Rambo's imprisonment feel more like a slap on the wrist. Ironically, this rampage is much more faithful to the original story, except there it ends with Rambo being killed.

to:

* ''VideoGame/RamboTheVideoGame'' is a CompressedAdaptation based off the first three ''Franchise/{{Rambo}}'' films, and the segments based on ''Film/FirstBlood'', ends with Rambo getting arrested just like in the film. Unlike the film, where Rambo kills only a single kills, at most, three policemen by accident, the game allows him to maim, shoot, and massacre aplenty without any guilt, cops, which makes Rambo's imprisonment feel more like a slap on the wrist.wrist, and his later release in the adaptation of subsequent films, even as a BoxedCrook, nothing short of lunacy. This is likely also GameplayAndStorySegregation, since the game at least awards a higher score for incapacitating cops non-lethally, but a lot of the context needed to assume this is lost on those not familiar with the films. Ironically, this rampage is much more faithful to the original story, except there it ends with Rambo being killed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans2003'' does a very loose adaptation of the ''ComicBook/TheJudasContract'' storyline from the comics, but the AdaptationDistillation makes the heroes' eventual victory defy even WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief. In the comic storyline, Deathstroke and Terra were under orders from [[NebulousEvilOrganization The H.I.V.E.]] to capture the Teen Titans alive, and thanks to [[TheMole Terra's spywork,]] they succeed in capturing all but Dick Grayson, who narrowly escapes capture and joins forces with Jericho to free his teammates, who then defeat Terra, Deathstroke and the H.I.V.E. The series [[AdaptedOut removes H.I.V.E. and Jericho from the story;]] Slade just wants the Titans out of the way to terrorize the city, and so Terra fights and seemingly kills each Titan individually. But the Titans all [[UnexplainedRecovery survive the fights and regroup offscreen.]] Most of the Titans, the show at least presents as a case of NeverFoundTheBody both in-universe and out, but Robin gets crushed with a boulder, then Terra gives the insignia from his costume to Slade, yet appears fine later on, to Terra and Slade's surprise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Similarly, Scar backs Simba up to the ledge of Pride Rock to throw him to his death and gloats about how he is reminded of Mufasa's own demise in the same way. When Simba retaliates and confronts him for confessing to Mufasa's murder, Sarabi pipes up, having realized Scar's knowledge of Mufasa's last moments blows his cover, and even quotes him verbatim. If she could hear him perfectly, why didn't she try to do anything until after Simba saved himself?

to:

** Similarly, Scar backs Simba up to the ledge of Pride Rock to throw him to his death and gloats about how he is reminded of Mufasa's own demise in the same way. When Simba retaliates and confronts him for confessing to Mufasa's murder, Sarabi pipes up, having realized Scar's knowledge of Mufasa's last moments blows his cover, and even quotes him verbatim. If she could hear him perfectly, why didn't she try to do anything until after Simba saved himself?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/GoldenEye1997'': Because the game adds a number of original levels, including locations that Bond never visited in the film, Natalya is artificially dropped into multiple levels where Bond saves her, only for her to be inexplicably kidnapped again at the start of the next level. [=MI6=] specifically sent Bond to Russia to find the survivor of the Severnaya massacre, so they should have whisked her away right after Bunker II.

Added: 521

Changed: 524

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''WebVideo/DragonBallZAbridged'', Vegeta [[DeathByAdaptation kills Ginyu]] rather than sparing him like he did in the source material. This eventually brings up a plot hole when the Ginyu Forces gather together at King Kai's planet yet Captain Ginyu himself is not present as he doesn't die in the canon. [[note]] However, the whole Ginyu Forces go to King Kai's planet is itself a non-canon mini arc so, make that what you will.[[/note]] HFIL clears this up by establishing that Ginyu's soul is a frog, and was thus unable to tell his team who he was.

to:

* In ''WebVideo/DragonBallZAbridged'', ''WebVideo/DragonBallZAbridged'':
**
Vegeta [[DeathByAdaptation kills Ginyu]] rather than sparing him like he did in the source material. This eventually brings up a plot hole when the Ginyu Forces gather together at King Kai's planet yet Captain Ginyu himself is not present as he doesn't die in the canon. [[note]] However, the whole Ginyu Forces go to King Kai's planet is itself a non-canon mini arc so, make that what you will.[[/note]] HFIL clears this up by establishing that Ginyu's soul is a frog, and was thus unable to tell his team who he was.

Added: 353

Changed: 115

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added example from DBZA


* In ''WebVideo/DragonBallZAbridged'', Vegeta [[DeathByAdaptation kills Ginyu]] rather than sparing him like he did in the source material. This eventually brings up a plot hole when the Ginyu Forces gather together at King Kai's planet yet Captain Ginyu himself is not present as he doesn't die in the canon. [[note]] However, the whole Ginyu Forces go to King Kai's planet is itself a non-canon mini arc so, make that what you will.[[/note]]

to:

* In ''WebVideo/DragonBallZAbridged'', Vegeta [[DeathByAdaptation kills Ginyu]] rather than sparing him like he did in the source material. This eventually brings up a plot hole when the Ginyu Forces gather together at King Kai's planet yet Captain Ginyu himself is not present as he doesn't die in the canon. [[note]] However, the whole Ginyu Forces go to King Kai's planet is itself a non-canon mini arc so, make that what you will.[[/note]][[/note]] HFIL clears this up by establishing that Ginyu's soul is a frog, and was thus unable to tell his team who he was.
** Porunga teleporting Piccolo against his will was an added bit of funny, but made it rather confusing that he couldn't teleport Goku the same way. It is worth noting, however, that Goku was extremely powerful by this point, and Porunga had just created New Namek, as opposed to finding it like in the original, meaning he could've just been too tired.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the original, Scar's plan was to have Simba and Mufasa's deaths look like they died in a stampede. Prior to leaving to get Mufasa for a "surprise present", he halfheartedly tells Simba to work on his roar as a way to occupy himself. Simba's survival was an accident, so Scar tricked Simba into thinking he caused it, which considering it happened after Simba started practicing roaring, is understandable Simba would think he caused it and feel enough guilt to run away. The remake keeps this mostly the same, except it has Scar bring Simba to the valley for the explicit purpose of practicing roaring before he has the hyenas cause the stampede, which makes Simba's guilt no longer make sense since Scar basically ordered him to do it, makes it far less sensible for Scar to leave Simba alone rather than stay to watch him practice, and makes it seem like Scar wanted Simba to survive, since there was no reason to make him seem like he caused it.

to:

** In the original, Scar's plan was to have Simba and Mufasa's deaths look like they died in a stampede. Prior to leaving to get Mufasa for a "surprise present", he halfheartedly tells Simba to work on his roar as a way to occupy himself. Simba's survival was an accident, so Scar tricked Simba into thinking he caused it, which considering it happened after Simba started practicing roaring, is understandable Simba would think he caused it and feel enough guilt to run away. The remake keeps this mostly the same, except it has Scar bring Simba to the valley for the explicit purpose of practicing roaring before he has the hyenas cause the stampede, which makes Simba's guilt no longer make sense since Scar basically ordered him to do it, makes making it far less sensible for Scar to leave Simba alone rather than stay to watch him practice, and makes it seem like Scar wanted Simba to survive, since there was no reason to make him seem like he caused it.

Changed: 115

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/RamboTheVideoGame'' is a CompressedAdaptation based off the first three ''Franchise/{{Rambo}}'' films, and the segments based on ''Film/FirstBlood'', ends with Rambo getting arrested just like in the film. Unlike the film, where Rambo kills only a single policemen by accident, the game allows him to maim, shoot, and massacre aplenty without any guilt, which makes Rambo's imprisonment feel more like a slap on the wrist.

to:

* ''VideoGame/RamboTheVideoGame'' is a CompressedAdaptation based off the first three ''Franchise/{{Rambo}}'' films, and the segments based on ''Film/FirstBlood'', ends with Rambo getting arrested just like in the film. Unlike the film, where Rambo kills only a single policemen by accident, the game allows him to maim, shoot, and massacre aplenty without any guilt, which makes Rambo's imprisonment feel more like a slap on the wrist. Ironically, this rampage is much more faithful to the original story, except there it ends with Rambo being killed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the [[WesternAnimation/TheLionKing1994 original film]], it's made fairly clear why the hyenas are so willing to go along with Scar's plan: they're a bunch of bickering louts with no leader, he's able to bribe them with food, he's responsible for their initial attack on Simba and rewards them even after they fail, and based on the way they speak to him, it seems like they've known each other for a while. In the remake, it's made clear that Scar only met the hyenas after said attack, he doesn't offer them anything apart from his word, and the hyenas already have a clear leader in the form of an AdaptationalBadass-ified Shenzi. Yet the hyenas are still happy to fall in line for a very risky plan, based on the statements of the brother of the guy who just ripped through them like tissue paper. If anything, it makes one wonder why the hyenas didn't try to attack Scar the moment he showed up. And if they did want Simba dead so badly, why didn't they try to kill him themselves earlier in the rescue scene, when they had him surrounded, outnumbered about 12-1, and their leader present? (In the original, there's only three hyenas at the scene, one of which is Shenzi but she, again, isn't any kind of leader, and Simbra literally got the jump on them before quickly scaring them off instead of talking to Shenzi for a few minutes.)

to:

** In the [[WesternAnimation/TheLionKing1994 original film]], it's made fairly clear why the hyenas are so willing to go along with Scar's plan: they're a bunch of bickering louts with no leader, he's able to bribe them with food, he's responsible for their initial attack on Simba and rewards them even after they fail, and based on the way they speak to him, it seems like they've known each other for a while. In the remake, it's made clear that Scar only met the hyenas after said attack, he doesn't offer them anything apart from his word, and the hyenas already have a clear leader in the form of an AdaptationalBadass-ified Shenzi. Yet the hyenas are still happy to fall in line for a very risky plan, based on the statements of the brother of the guy who just ripped through them like tissue paper. If anything, it makes one wonder why the hyenas didn't try to attack Scar the moment he showed up. And if they did want Simba Mufasa dead so badly, why didn't they try to kill him themselves earlier in the rescue scene, when they had him surrounded, outnumbered about 12-1, and their leader present? (In the original, there's only three hyenas at the scene, one of which is Shenzi but she, again, isn't any kind of leader, and Simbra Mufasa literally got the jump on them before quickly scaring them off instead of talking to Shenzi for a few minutes.)

Top