Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / Thinner

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FatBastard: [[DeconstructedTrope Deconstructed.]] Billy Halleck is a seemingly nice guy with a good marriage and is a doting father (his daughter in fact [[DaddysGirl prefers Billy to her mother]]). However, he is clearly aware of his firm's tie to TheMafia, and is in fact good friends with a man who may be the head of the local mob family. After the accident, he doesn't deliberately use his connections to get him out of trouble, but he does nothing to dissuade them either. [[SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped There is blame enough to go around, but no one is willing to accept the consequences for their actions.]]

to:

* FatBastard: [[DeconstructedTrope Deconstructed.]] Billy Halleck is a seemingly nice guy with a good marriage and is a doting father (his daughter in fact [[DaddysGirl prefers Billy to her mother]]). However, he is clearly aware of his firm's tie to TheMafia, and is in fact good friends with a man who may be the head of the local mob family. After the accident, he doesn't deliberately use his connections to get him out of trouble, but he does nothing to dissuade them either. [[SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped There is blame enough to go around, but no one is willing to accept the consequences for their actions.]]

Added: 111

Removed: 124

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeathOfAChild: [[spoiler: Poor Linda doesn't make it thanks to Billy's pie which was intended for his wife.]]



* InfantImmortality: [[spoiler: Averted. Poor Linda doesn't make it thanks to Billy's pie which was intended for his wife.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InfantImmortality: [[spoiler: Averted. Poor Linda doesn't make it thanks to Billy's pie which was intended for his wife.]]


Added DiffLines:

* KarmaHoudiniWarranty: The entire story. Originally Billy gets away with little more than a slap on the wrist thanks to his connections but it turns out the old Gypsy that touched him actually gave him a devastating curse that causes him to waste away to nothing. And it wasn't just Billy who got cursed; the judge and police officer who helped him get away with it ''also'' get their just desserts with karmic curses...


Added DiffLines:

* PapaWolf: The reason why Taduz Lemke curses Billy, Judge Rossington, and Officer Hopley? All three of them were culpable in his daughter's death and the lack of justice only made him angrier.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No longer a trope.


** The ultimate result of eating a slice of the cursed pie. In the book, Lemke warns Billy that whomever eats it will not only takes on his withering curse, but it will be five-fold ''stronger''. In the film, it is mentioned that the curse will be stronger but we also get a chance to see exactly ''how'' [[spoiler: when Billy gives his [[YourCheatingHeart cheating wife]] a slice... The pie completely desiccates her body and turns her into a bizarre corpse-pie mishmash. Which Billy then [[{{Squick}} kisses]]. And then ''[[ImAHumanitarian eats]]'', nibbling on a bit of crusty lip that Billy espouses as delicious... But then reminds himself that he probably shouldn't have too much of.]]

to:

** The ultimate result of eating a slice of the cursed pie. In the book, Lemke warns Billy that whomever eats it will not only takes on his withering curse, but it will be five-fold ''stronger''. In the film, it is mentioned that the curse will be stronger but we also get a chance to see exactly ''how'' [[spoiler: when Billy gives his [[YourCheatingHeart cheating wife]] wife a slice... The pie completely desiccates her body and turns her into a bizarre corpse-pie mishmash. Which Billy then [[{{Squick}} kisses]]. And then ''[[ImAHumanitarian eats]]'', nibbling on a bit of crusty lip that Billy espouses as delicious... But then reminds himself that he probably shouldn't have too much of.]]

Added: 2081

Removed: 3162

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BratsWithSlingshots: Gina Lempke, great-granddaugther of Tadzu Lempke, is highly skilled with a slingshot, and even performs with it for money. She uses it to shoot a ball bearing through Billy's hand when he comes to the Gypsy camp to demand the curse is taken off, and it's strongly implied she killed Frank Spurton, the man Richie hired to spy on the Gypsies, with it.



* BratsWithSlingshots: Gina Lempke, great-granddaugther of Tadzu Lempke, is highly skilled with a slingshot, and even performs with it for money. She uses it to shoot a ball bearing through Billy's hand when he comes to the Gypsy camp to demand the curse is taken off, and it's strongly implied she killed Frank Spurton, the man Richie hired to spy on the Gypsies, with it.



* DreamSequence: Billy is plagued by nightmares, one of which takes up all of chapter 7.



* IWillPunishYourFriendForYourFailure: After tracking down the gypsy camp, Billy and Richie start targeting Lemke's family to force him to remove the curse. In the book he terrorizes and shoots up the place while making some cold threats against people. In the film Richie kills his granddaughter's husband and threatens to scar her face with acid, Lemke gives in and puts Billy's curse in a pie (although in the book he kills Richie as well).



* IWillPunishYourFriendForYourFailure: After tracking down the gypsy camp, Billy and Richie start targeting Lemke's family to force him to remove the curse. In the book he terrorizes and shoots up the place while making some cold threats against people. In the film Richie kills his granddaughter's husband and threatens to scar her face with acid, Lemke gives in and puts Billy's curse in a pie (although in the book he kills Richie as well).



* {{Narm}}: Discussed trope. In one scene, Ginelli uses packing tape to secure a man to a tree. The narration acknowledges that taping someone to a tree sounds dumb, but goes on to point out how ''strong'' packing tape actually is, and how close to impossible escaping from those bindings would actually be.



* RedShirt: Richie's employee Frank, who is killed quickly without doing anything of importance or real interest.



* RedShirt: Richie's employee Frank, who is killed quickly without doing anything of importance or real interest.
* ScienceMarchesOn: At the start of the novel, Billy Halleck weighs in at 249 lbs. and is considered massively overweight by nearly everyone he meets with his Doctor in particular chiding him (mentioning his risk for a heart attack). Granted, his height is never given, but in TheNewTens in America his weight wouldn't be commented on quite so drastically. The 1996 film version boosts Billy's weight to an even 300 lbs. to emphasize his mass due to Robert John Burke's height. [[note]] Part of [[Creator/StephenKing Stephen King's]] inspiration for the book was a routine visit to the doctor's office where he was told "I don't know if you've noticed, but you've entered Heart Attack Country" due to his heavy smoking and being slightly overweight. King grudgingly lost the weight and quit smoking, but his Doctor's line made it into the book verbatim.[[/note]]



* WeirdnessCensor: Billy's wife, his physician, and the specialists he goes to see refuse to believe that Billy is cursed, despite finding nothing wrong with him in any of their tests. [[DefiedTrope Defied]] by [[TheDon Richie Ginelli]], who believes Billy upon seeing him and hearing his tale. Richie states that he can accept a supernatural cause because his high-stakes criminal lifestyle ''demands'' that he recognize threats when they appear - and refusing to acknowledge a threat as dangerous as Billy's curse would be ''suicidal''.
-->I believe in what I see. That's why I'm a relatively rich man. That's also why I'm a living man. Most people, they don't believe what they see. ...Some guys -- a lot of guys -- don't believe what they are seeing, especially if it gets in the way of what they eat or drink or think or believe. Me, I don't believe in God. But if I saw him, I would. I wouldn't just go around saying, "Jesus, that was a great special effect." The definition of an asshole is a guy who doesn't believe what he's seeing. And you can quote me.


Added DiffLines:

* WeirdnessCensor: Billy's wife, his physician, and the specialists he goes to see refuse to believe that Billy is cursed, despite finding nothing wrong with him in any of their tests. [[DefiedTrope Defied]] by [[TheDon Richie Ginelli]], who believes Billy upon seeing him and hearing his tale. Richie states that he can accept a supernatural cause because his high-stakes criminal lifestyle ''demands'' that he recognize threats when they appear - and refusing to acknowledge a threat as dangerous as Billy's curse would be ''suicidal''.
-->I believe in what I see. That's why I'm a relatively rich man. That's also why I'm a living man. Most people, they don't believe what they see. ...Some guys -- a lot of guys -- don't believe what they are seeing, especially if it gets in the way of what they eat or drink or think or believe. Me, I don't believe in God. But if I saw him, I would. I wouldn't just go around saying, "Jesus, that was a great special effect." The definition of an asshole is a guy who doesn't believe what he's seeing. And you can quote me.

Added: 313

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeadAnimalWarning: Twice:
** In taking revenge against the Gypsies, Richie kills their dogs with cyanide "treats".
** In revenge to this, Gabe tracks down his henchman, kills him, gouges his eyes out and stuffs a dead chicken in his mouth with a note mocking them saying that they won't remove the curse on Billy.



-->'''Taduz Lemke:''' Then your friend comes. He poisons dogs, shoots guns in the night, uses his hands on a woman, threatens to throw acid in the faces of children. Take it off he says-take it off and take it off and take it off. And finally I say okay as long as he gets out of here! Not from what he did, but from what he will do-he is crazy, this friend of yours, and he will never stop. Even my 'Gelina says she sees from his eyes he will never stop. "But we will never stop either," she says, and I say, "Yes, we will. Yes, we will stop. Because if we don't, we are crazy like the town man's friend."

to:

-->'''Taduz -->'''Tadzu Lemke:''' Then your friend comes. He poisons dogs, shoots guns in the night, uses his hands on a woman, threatens to throw acid in the faces of children. Take it off he says-take it off and take it off and take it off. And finally I say okay as long as he gets out of here! Not from what he did, but from what he will do-he is crazy, this friend of yours, and he will never stop. Even my 'Gelina says she sees from his eyes he will never stop. "But we will never stop either," she says, and I say, "Yes, we will. Yes, we will stop. Because if we don't, we are crazy like the town man's friend."

Added: 1231

Changed: 478

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentalTruth: Hopley testified that Billy was sober, deliberately failing to do a breathalyzer on him. Billy ''was'' in fact sober during the accident, although he had been guilty of a different kind of reckless negligence.



* AmbiguousSyntax: [[spoiler:Lemke's warnings about the curse being transferred "whoever" eats the pie make it a bit unclear if it will just kill the first person to eat from it, or anyone who eats a piece, making it slightly ambiguous whether Billy's whole family dies from eating the pie or just his wife, especially in the movie]].



* AtLeastIAdmitIt: Hopley wearily acknowledges that he's earned Taduz's wrath even as Billy makes justifications.



* TheGhost: Billy employs private detectives to track down the gypsy camp, and later those same detectives are looking for Billy for his wife, but none of them ever appear in person, we just see their reports and have Billy consider ways to evade them in his head.

to:

* TheGhost: TheGhost:
**
Billy employs private detectives to track down the gypsy camp, and later those same detectives are looking for Billy for his wife, but none of them ever appear in person, we just see their reports and have Billy consider ways to evade them in his head.head.
** In the book (although not the movie) Harry the judge is referred to a lot but never appears in person: with the hit and run and the trial having taken place earlier, off-screen, and Harry having already snuck out of town to a hospital due to his curse by the time Billy wants to see him in person.



%% * SpoiledSweet: Linda is doted on by her father, and is one of the novels most sympathetic characters.

to:

%% * SpoiledSweet: Linda is doted on by her father, and is one of the novels story's most sympathetic characters.characters. She's upset without being bratty about the conflict between her parents, and shows some naive curiosity without being judgmental to either side when asking Billy about what happened with the car crash in the book.

Changed: 3

Removed: 25

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Being a Roma/ni is Not A Trope; insufficient context


* UsefulNotes/{{Roma|ni}}



* SpoiledSweet: Linda is doted on by her father, and is one of the novels most sympathetic characters.

to:

%% * SpoiledSweet: Linda is doted on by her father, and is one of the novels most sympathetic characters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BaitAndSwitch: In the movie, when Richie confronts Gina in the barn, he opens up a mason jar that seemingly contains acid and throws the contents onto her face. After she screams in pain:
-->'''Richie''': You scream again, and I'll kill you. You just got a face full of soda pop and baking soda.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Taduz Lemke:''' Then your friend comes. He poisons dogs, shoots guns in the night, uses his hands on a woman, threatens to throw acid in the faces of children. Take it off he says-take it off and take it off and take it off. And finally I say okay as long as he gets out of here! Not from what he did, but from what he will do-he is crazy, this friend of yours, and he will never stop. Even my 'Gelina says she sees from his eyes he will never stop. "But we will never stop either," she says, and I say, "Yes we will. Yes we will stop. Because if we don't, we are crazy like the town man's friend."

to:

-->'''Taduz Lemke:''' Then your friend comes. He poisons dogs, shoots guns in the night, uses his hands on a woman, threatens to throw acid in the faces of children. Take it off he says-take it off and take it off and take it off. And finally I say okay as long as he gets out of here! Not from what he did, but from what he will do-he is crazy, this friend of yours, and he will never stop. Even my 'Gelina says she sees from his eyes he will never stop. "But we will never stop either," she says, and I say, "Yes "Yes, we will. Yes Yes, we will stop. Because if we don't, we are crazy like the town man's friend."



* AFriendInNeed: When his wife fails to believe he is cursed (and in fact conspires with a local doctor to commit him to a Mental Institution should he return home), Billy turns to [[TheDon Richie Ginelli]], a Mafioso who he is acquainted with. Richie sends Billy a doctor, then shows up himself to wreak havoc on the Gypsies until the they agree to lift the curse. [[spoiler: He dies for his troubles, but accepted that fact beforehand.]]

to:

* AFriendInNeed: When his wife fails to believe he is cursed (and in fact conspires with a local doctor to commit him to a Mental Institution should he return home), Billy turns to [[TheDon Richie Ginelli]], a Mafioso who he is acquainted with. Richie sends Billy a doctor, then shows up himself to wreak havoc on the Gypsies until the they agree to lift the curse. [[spoiler: He dies for his troubles, but accepted that fact beforehand.]]



** ''Unknown'' - Sheriff Hopley's curse. The name of the curse was not given, but it give him horrendous acne. And by "horrendous", I don't mean "looks like chicken pox" - I mean... well...

to:

** ''Unknown'' - Sheriff Hopley's curse. The name of the curse was not given, but it give gives him horrendous acne. And by "horrendous", I don't mean "looks like chicken pox" chickenpox" - I mean... well...



* NeverMyFault: Billy Halleck blames everybody but himself for his having run Susanna Lemke over, including Susanna herself. Taduz Lemke even tells Billy that he feels a bit sorry for him when they meet for the last time, because he can't take responsibility; "You tell yourself you can't be asked to pay for it - there is no blame, you say. It slides off you because your shoulders are broken." Also applies to Lemke who seems to forget that his daughter was jaywalking in the middle of the night.

to:

* NeverMyFault: Billy Halleck blames everybody but himself for his having run Susanna Lemke over, including Susanna herself. Taduz Lemke even tells Billy that he feels a bit sorry for him when they meet for the last time, time because he can't take responsibility; "You tell yourself you can't be asked to pay for it - there is no blame, you say. It slides off you because your shoulders are broken." Also applies to Lemke who seems to forget that his daughter was jaywalking in the middle of the night.



* RedemptionEqualsDeath: [[spoiler:Billy Halleck finally takes responsibility for his actions when he discovers that his daughter, who was in no way responsible for Susanna Lemke's death, has eaten a slice of the Gypsy pie and is doomed to die of the curse that Billy Halleck brought upon himself and passed on to his wife for jerking him off. He decides to eat a slice of the Gypsy pie himself, choosing to join his wife and child in death.]]

to:

* RedemptionEqualsDeath: [[spoiler:Billy [[spoiler: Billy Halleck finally takes responsibility for his actions when he discovers that his daughter, who was in no way responsible for Susanna Lemke's death, has eaten a slice of the Gypsy pie and is doomed to die of the curse that Billy Halleck brought upon himself and passed on to his wife for jerking him off. He decides to eat a slice of the Gypsy pie himself, choosing to join his wife and child in death.]]



* SparedByTheAdaptation: Richie isn't killed by the gypsys in the film.

to:

* SparedByTheAdaptation: Richie isn't killed by the gypsys gypsies in the film.

Added: 71

Changed: 150

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IWillPunishYourFriendForYourFailure: After tracking down the gypsy camp, Billy and Richie start targeting Lemke's family to force him to remove the curse. After Richie kills his granddaughter's husband and scars her face with acid, Lemke gives in and puts Billy's curse in a pie, but later kills Richie as well.

to:

* IWillPunishYourFriendForYourFailure: After tracking down the gypsy camp, Billy and Richie start targeting Lemke's family to force him to remove the curse. After In the book he terrorizes and shoots up the place while making some cold threats against people. In the film Richie kills his granddaughter's husband and scars threatens to scar her face with acid, Lemke gives in and puts Billy's curse in a pie, but later pie (although in the book he kills Richie as well.well).


Added DiffLines:

* SparedByTheAdaptation: Richie isn't killed by the gypsys in the film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IWillPunishYourFriendForYourFailure: After tracking down the gypsy camp, Billy and Richie start targeting Lemke's family to force him to remove the curse. After Richie kills his granddaughter's husband and scars her face with acid, Lemke gives in and puts Billy's curse in a pie, but later kills Richie as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The film also makes it more explicit that [[spoiler: his daughter ate a piece of pie nd was presumably infected with the curse to if it didn't stop with one victim]]. while in the book he only suspects it, albeit with good reason, after seeing two plates in the sink.

to:

** The film also makes it more explicit that [[spoiler: his daughter ate a piece of pie nd and was presumably infected with the curse to too if it didn't stop with one victim]]. while in the book he only suspects it, albeit with good reason, after seeing two plates in the sink.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It could be seen that he helped both the Judge and Halleck ''save face'', but could not save his own face.

to:

*** It could be seen that he helped both the Judge and Halleck ''save face'', but could not save his own face.face, as well as his "rotten" nature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalHeroism: Downplayed. Billy Halleck is still a mob lawyer and corrupt slimeball in the film who uses his connections to get away with manslaughter, but his wife's marital infidelity is original to the film. [[spoiler:He kills her with the cursed pie in the book as well, but because he simply hated her, not out of revenge for any betrayal.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The film also makes it more explicit that [[spoiler: his daughter ate a piece of pie nd was presumably infected with the curse to if it didn't stop with one victim]]. while in the book he only suspects it, albeit with good reason, after seeing two plates in the sink.


Added DiffLines:

* TheGhost: Billy employs private detectives to track down the gypsy camp, and later those same detectives are looking for Billy for his wife, but none of them ever appear in person, we just see their reports and have Billy consider ways to evade them in his head.


Added DiffLines:

* RedShirt: Richie's employee Frank, who is killed quickly without doing anything of importance or real interest.


Added DiffLines:

* SpoiledSweet: Linda is doted on by her father, and is one of the novels most sympathetic characters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Tadzu Lemke:''' Then your friend comes. He poisons dogs, shoots guns in the night, uses his hands on a woman, threatens to throw acid in the faces of children. Take it off he says-take it off and take it off and take it off. And finally I say okay as long as he gets out of here! Not from what he did, but from what he will do-he is crazy, this friend of yours, and he will never stop. Even my 'Gelina says she sees from his eyes he will never stop. "But we will never stop either," she says, and I say, "Yes we will. Yes we will stop. Because if we don't, we are crazy like the town man's friend."

to:

-->'''Tadzu -->'''Taduz Lemke:''' Then your friend comes. He poisons dogs, shoots guns in the night, uses his hands on a woman, threatens to throw acid in the faces of children. Take it off he says-take it off and take it off and take it off. And finally I say okay as long as he gets out of here! Not from what he did, but from what he will do-he is crazy, this friend of yours, and he will never stop. Even my 'Gelina says she sees from his eyes he will never stop. "But we will never stop either," she says, and I say, "Yes we will. Yes we will stop. Because if we don't, we are crazy like the town man's friend."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvenEvilHasStandards: After having his clan be terrorized by Ginelli, the old gypsy decides to relent because of this:
-->'''Tadzu Lemke:''' Then your friend comes. He poisons dogs, shoots guns in the night, uses his hands on a woman, threatens to throw acid in the faces of children. Take it off he says-take it off and take it off and take it off. And finally I say okay as long as he gets out of here! Not from what he did, but from what he will do-he is crazy, this friend of yours, and he will never stop. Even my 'Gelina says she sees from his eyes he will never stop. "But we will never stop either," she says, and I say, "Yes we will. Yes we will stop. Because if we don't, we are crazy like the town man's friend."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Narm}}: Discussed trope. In one scene, Billy uses packing tape to secure a man to a tree. The narration acknowledges that taping someone to a tree sounds dumb, but goes on to point out how ''strong'' packing tape actually is, and how close to impossible escaping from those bindings would actually be.

to:

* {{Narm}}: Discussed trope. In one scene, Billy Ginelli uses packing tape to secure a man to a tree. The narration acknowledges that taping someone to a tree sounds dumb, but goes on to point out how ''strong'' packing tape actually is, and how close to impossible escaping from those bindings would actually be.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RealityIsUnrealistic: There is a [[https://www.healthline.com/health/ichthyosis-vulgaris medical condition]] in which skin becomes actual scales. One [[https://abcnews.go.com/Health/memphis-woman-world-fingernails-growing-hair/story?id=16974423 case]] had a woman's hair becoming fingernails.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MagicalRomani: ''Thinner'' is about an ancient Gypsy man who casts the book's titular GypsyCurse, as well as several others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalHeroism: Downplayed. Billy Halleck is still a mob lawyer and corrupt slimeball in the film who uses his connections to get away with manslaughter, but his wife's marital infidelity is original to the film. [[spoiler:He kills her with the cursed pie in the book as well, but because he simply hated her, not out of revenge for any betrayal.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BratsWithSlingshots: Gina Lempke, great-granddaugther of Tadzu Lempke, is highly skilled with a slingshot, and even performs with it for money. She uses it to shoot a ball bearing through Billy's hand when he comes to the Gypsy camp to demand the curse is taken off, and it's strongly implied she killed Frank Spurton, the man Richie hired to spy on the Gypsies, with it.


Added DiffLines:

* MoralityChain: Billy surprisingly acts one towards Richard Ginelli, asking the latter not to hurt anyone as he sets out to scare the Gypsies into lifting the curse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FlatEarthAtheist: [[DefiedTrope Defied]] by Richie Ginelli. After Billy's disastrous first encounter with the Gypsies, Richie surveys his emaciated friend and immediately concludes that he's been cursed. The mobster says that while he may be an atheist, he's also willing to face facts:
--> '''Ginelli''': Some guys don't believe what they're seeing, especially if it gets in the way of what they want to eat, drink, and believe. [...] The definition of an asshole is a guy who doesn't believe what he's seeing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalAlternateEnding: In both the book and the film, [[VillainProtagonist Billy Halleck]] manages to get the GypsyCurse on himself lifted by forcing the sorcerer to place it inside a pie. [[spoiler:Billy feeds it to his wife (whom he hates), before his daughter (whom he dotes on) eats a piece of it by mistake. Wracked with guilt, [[DrivenToSuicide Billy then eats the pie himself]]. The movie added a subplot of a man that Billy suspects his wife is cheating on him with, who rings the door right at that moment. [[KillEmAll Billy invites him in so he can have a slice of pie as well]].]]

to:

* AdaptationalAlternateEnding: In both the book and the film, [[VillainProtagonist Billy Halleck]] manages to get gets the GypsyCurse on himself lifted by forcing the sorcerer to place it inside a pie. [[spoiler:Billy feeds it to his wife (whom he hates), before his daughter (whom he dotes on) eats a piece of it by mistake. Wracked with guilt, [[DrivenToSuicide Billy then eats the pie himself]]. The movie added a subplot of a man that Billy suspects his wife is cheating on him sleeping with, who rings the door right at that moment. [[KillEmAll Billy invites him in so he can have a slice of pie as well]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalAlternateEnding: In both the book and film versions [[VillainProtagonist Billy Halleck]] manages to get the GypsyCurse on himself lifted by forcing the sorcerer to place it inside a pie. [[spoiler:Billy feeds it to his wife (whom he hates), before his daughter (whom he dotes on) eats a piece of it by mistake. Wracked with guilt, [[DrivenToSuicide Billy then eats the pie himself]]. The movie added a subplot of a man that Billy suspects his wife is cheating on him with, who rings the door right at that moment. [[KillEmAll Billy invites him in so he can have a slice of pie as well]].]]

to:

* AdaptationalAlternateEnding: In both the book and film versions the film, [[VillainProtagonist Billy Halleck]] manages to get the GypsyCurse on himself lifted by forcing the sorcerer to place it inside a pie. [[spoiler:Billy feeds it to his wife (whom he hates), before his daughter (whom he dotes on) eats a piece of it by mistake. Wracked with guilt, [[DrivenToSuicide Billy then eats the pie himself]]. The movie added a subplot of a man that Billy suspects his wife is cheating on him with, who rings the door right at that moment. [[KillEmAll Billy invites him in so he can have a slice of pie as well]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:300:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/44099963.png]]

to:

[[quoteright:300:http://static.[[quoteright:250:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/44099963.png]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:266:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/ea277046b2743d2ecf464435a63c1824.jpg]]

to:

[[quoteright:266:http://static.[[quoteright:300:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/ea277046b2743d2ecf464435a63c1824.jpg]]
org/pmwiki/pub/images/44099963.png]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FaceDeathWithDignity: [[spoiler: Averted, but Lemke suggests this to Halleck when giving him the pie. The pie would lift the curse from him if someone else ate it (since it now contained the curse), unless he ate the pie himself. Which he suggests. "Die clean, white man from town. Die clean."]]

to:

* FaceDeathWithDignity: [[spoiler: Averted, but Lemke suggests this to Halleck when giving him the pie. The pie would lift transfer the curse from him if someone else to whoever ate it (since it now contained the curse), unless and lift it from him. But Lemke suggests he ate eat the pie himself. Which he suggests.himself rather than make someone else suffer for him. "Die clean, white man from town. Die clean."]]

Top