Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheThreeMusketeers

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BoisterousBruiser: Porthos, more and moreso as the books go on. Makes sense, since his strength grows too. His boisterousness bites him in the ass once, when his temper allows a cardinal's agent to lure him into duel and Porthos [[CurbStompBattle gets run thorough with a sword before he can react]]. In his next fight he is much more careful and collected.

to:

* BoisterousBruiser: Porthos, more and moreso more as the books go on. Makes sense, since his strength grows too. His boisterousness bites him in the ass once, when his temper allows a cardinal's agent to lure him into duel and Porthos [[CurbStompBattle gets run thorough with a sword before he can react]]. In his next fight he is much more careful and collected.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


For a list of works based off or inspired by ''The Three Musketeers'' and its sequels, see [[DerivativeWorks/TheThreeMusketeers here]].

to:

For a list of works based off or inspired by ''The Three Musketeers'' and its sequels, see [[DerivativeWorks/TheThreeMusketeers [[DerivativeWorks/DArtagnanRomances here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Anadiplosis}}: The catchphrase of the group, in the original French, "Tous pour un, un pour tous", which is also {{Mesodiplosis}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EatsBabies: A sloshed-beyond-belief Athos cheerfully accuses two Englishmen of this when they try to break into the cellar he's barricaded himself in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ComedicSociopathy: Our heroes can be somewhat... callous in their singleminded focus on glory, fortune, honor, and propriety, especially to their social inferiors. Take d'Artagnan, who cheerfully beats his lackey Planchet for considering leaving his too-broke-to-pay service (under the genuine belief he's doing the man a favor, as he'll ''obviously'' be rich ''someday''); attributes Planchet's first display of genuine loyalty and courage with said beating, [[NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished and resolves to do it more often]]; and seducing a maid merely to gain access to her mistress, whom he happily sleeps with as the heartbroken maid listens nearby.


Added DiffLines:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: The narration will occasionally point out certain attitudes as being acceptable for the time period if not the readers' contemporary one. It outright admits that d'Artagnan heartlessly seducing a woman purely to gain access to his ''actual'' target is a scumbag move, yet morally acceptable at the time; and notes that a destitute musketeer making ends meet by [[GoldDigger squeezing an older, well-off mistress for cash]] falls entirely within the definition of "honorable" behavior.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: That said, from a certain perspective, it's still a BittersweetEnding of sorts. Namely, Porthos dies honorably for Aramis while Athos gets to reunite with his son in the afterlife. Likewise, D'Artagnan meets with Aramis one last time and successfully achieved his goal in life despite all odds, gladly departing to heaven soon after.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: That said, from a certain perspective, it's still a BittersweetEnding of sorts. Namely, each of them more or less foresaw their deaths beforehand and died on their own terms. Porthos dies honorably decided to sacrifice himself for Aramis Aramis, while Athos gets sought to reunite with his son join Raoul in the afterlife. Likewise, D'Artagnan meets with met Aramis one last time and successfully achieved his goal in life despite all odds, gladly departing to heaven soon after.happily reuniting with his loved ones in heaven.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: That said, from a certain perspective, it's still a BittersweetEnding of sorts. Namely, Porthos dies honorably while Athos gets to reunite with his son in the afterlife. Likewise, D'Artagnan meets with Aramis one last time and successfully achieved his goal in life despite all odds, gladly departing to heaven soon after.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: That said, from a certain perspective, it's still a BittersweetEnding of sorts. Namely, Porthos dies honorably for Aramis while Athos gets to reunite with his son in the afterlife. Likewise, D'Artagnan meets with Aramis one last time and successfully achieved his goal in life despite all odds, gladly departing to heaven soon after.]]

Added: 1062

Changed: 1636

Removed: 101

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Aramis in the final book (''The Man in the Iron Mask''), in which, ''not'' to be confused with the film, he alone (with Porthos tricked into it as {{dumb muscle}}) initiates the plot to [[spoiler:replace the King with his long-imprisoned twin brother]]--which is actually [[spoiler:foiled with D'Artagnan's assistance, although Fouquet takes the major credit and thus postpones his downfall by a few days]]. The point being that [[spoiler:it turns out the kingdom is best served by having the original Louis as king, Colbert as finance minister, and D'Artagnan in charge of the army, than it ever would have been served by his brother who, knowing nothing about the state of affairs but what Aramis told him, would have had to rely completely on Aramis and leave the likeable but corrupt Fouquet to embezzle and squander what was left of the treasury, and that D'Artagnan's loyalty to Louis ends up being the '''''right''''' choice, and Aramis's plot therefore makes him a traitor and a true Face Heel Turn since he betrays not only his King but also the whole Musketeers group by an act that he knew neither D'Artagnan nor Athos could be persuaded into, and Porthos only by trickery.]] And the irony being that [[spoiler:Fouquet plays a major role in saving Louis even though he knows Louis is working for his downfall, and it was in his interest to cooperate with the substitution: and Louis's first act after being saved is to dispose of Fouquet in favour of Colbert]].
** Part of the point of the book is that some of the older generation (like Athos) believe that a nobleman's duty is to [[MyMasterRightOrWrong serve the king no matter what]] (although he does add an escape clause in telling Raoul to serve royalty and not the king). [[spoiler:Aramis' actions violate this principle (and he manipulates Porthos into doing the same); d'Artagnan isn't sure what to think about this but ultimately lands on the side of the King]].
* FakeKing: One of the plots in ''The Man in the Iron Mask''. The king is replaced by his twin Louis.

to:

** Aramis in the final book (''The Man in the Iron Mask''), in which, ''not'' to be confused with the film, since he alone (with Porthos tricked into it as {{dumb muscle}}) initiates the plot to [[spoiler:replace the King with his long-imprisoned twin brother]]--which is actually ultimately [[spoiler:foiled with D'Artagnan's assistance, although Fouquet takes the major credit and thus postpones his downfall by a few days]]. The point being that [[spoiler:it turns out the kingdom is best served by having the original Louis as king, Colbert as finance minister, and D'Artagnan in charge of the army, than it ever would have been served by his brother who, knowing nothing about the state of affairs but what Aramis told him, would have had to rely completely on Aramis and leave the likeable but corrupt Fouquet to embezzle and squander what was left of the treasury, and that D'Artagnan's loyalty to Louis ends up being the '''''right''''' choice, and Aramis's plot therefore makes him a traitor and a true Face Heel Turn since he betrays not only his King but also the whole Musketeers group by an act that he knew neither D'Artagnan nor Athos could be persuaded into, and Porthos only by trickery.]] And the irony being that [[spoiler:Fouquet plays a major role in saving Louis even though he knows Louis is working for his downfall, and it was in his interest to cooperate with the substitution: and Louis's first act after being saved is to dispose of Fouquet in favour of Colbert]].
** Part of the point of the book is that some of the older generation (like Athos) believe that a nobleman's duty is to [[MyMasterRightOrWrong serve the king no matter what]] (although he does add an escape clause in telling Raoul to serve royalty and not the king). [[spoiler:Aramis' actions violate this principle (and he manipulates Porthos into doing the same); d'Artagnan isn't sure what to think about this but ultimately lands on the side of the King]].
days]].
* FakeKing: One of the main plots in ''The Man in the Iron Mask''. The king is replaced by his twin Louis.


Added DiffLines:

* GreyAndGreyMorality: The protagonists personally grapple with this issue.
** [[spoiler: For the kingdom of France, Louis and his chosen men are indeed better than Philip and his supporters. As leader, Philip knows little about the state of affairs, being dependent on Aramis. Similarly, Fouquet would squander what was left of the treasury.]] However, Louis's nature itself is not exactly "noble". In fact, despite [spoiler:Fouquet choosing to help him in the end, Louis' first act is to dispose of Fouquet for Colbert]].
** As one of the older generation, Athos believed that a nobleman is to [[MyMasterRightOrWrong serve the king no matter what]]. Yet, Louis' actions would affect this viewpoint, with Athos later telling Raoul to serve royalty and not the king.
** D'Artagnan is subject to this. [[spoiler:He has mixed feelings for the royal family, initially resigning as a musketeer in protest. Likewise, while ultimately supporting Louis over Philip, D'Artagnan is clearly upset at the former's sentencings toward Fouquet, Aramis, and especially Porthos.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: That said, from a certain perspective, it's still a BittersweetEnding of sorts. Namely, Porthos dies as his faithful self while Athos gets to reunite with his son in the afterlife. Likewise, D'Artagnan reunites with Aramis one last time and successfully achieved his goals despite all odds, gladly departing to heaven soon after.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: That said, from a certain perspective, it's still a BittersweetEnding of sorts. Namely, Porthos dies as his faithful self honorably while Athos gets to reunite with his son in the afterlife. Likewise, D'Artagnan reunites meets with Aramis one last time and successfully achieved his goals goal in life despite all odds, gladly departing to heaven soon after.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: The final book, ''The Vicomte of Bragelonne'', has a pretty[[DownerEnding crapsack ending]]. [[spoiler:Aramis breaks up the fellowship for good, his plan backfires spectacularly and gets Porthos killed and him exiled with guilt, Raoul loses his girlfriend and his will to live, Athos dies shortly after he hears of Raoul's death, and D'Artagnan finally receives that promotion he's been awaiting for decades... which arrives shortly before he dies from a cannonball.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: The final book, ''The Vicomte of Bragelonne'', has a pretty[[DownerEnding pretty [[DownerEnding crapsack ending]]. [[spoiler:Aramis breaks up the fellowship for good, his plan backfires spectacularly and gets Porthos killed and him exiled with guilt, Raoul loses his girlfriend and his will to live, Athos dies shortly after he hears of Raoul's death, and D'Artagnan finally receives that promotion he's been awaiting for decades... which arrives shortly before he dies from a cannonball.]]

Added: 345

Changed: 43

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: The final book, ''The Vicomte of Bragelonne'', has an outright [[DownerEnding crapsack ending]]. [[spoiler:Aramis breaks up the fellowship for good, his plan backfires spectacularly and gets Porthos killed and him exiled, Raoul loses his girlfriend and his will to live, Athos dies shortly after he hears of Raoul's death, and D'Artagnan finally receives that promotion he's been awaiting for decades... which arrives shortly before he dies of his wounds.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: The final book, ''The Vicomte of Bragelonne'', has an outright [[DownerEnding a pretty[[DownerEnding crapsack ending]]. [[spoiler:Aramis breaks up the fellowship for good, his plan backfires spectacularly and gets Porthos killed and him exiled, exiled with guilt, Raoul loses his girlfriend and his will to live, Athos dies shortly after he hears of Raoul's death, and D'Artagnan finally receives that promotion he's been awaiting for decades... which arrives shortly before he dies from a cannonball.]]
** [[spoiler: That said, from a certain perspective, it's still a BittersweetEnding
of sorts. Namely, Porthos dies as his wounds.]] faithful self while Athos gets to reunite with his son in the afterlife. Likewise, D'Artagnan reunites with Aramis one last time and successfully achieved his goals despite all odds, gladly departing to heaven soon after.]]

Added: 524

Changed: 715

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoldDigger: Milady probably qualifies, as she came from a much lower background than Athos (a rich Count) and deliberately kept her shady past from him in order to ensnare him into marriage. Porthos, meanwhile, is a rare male example. His M.O. consists of romancing and eventually marrying rich, elderly widows (or, well, the first one wasn't even widowed when he started romancing her). Whether it pays off is debatable. He does end up very rich, but his neighbours don't respect him, his wives are all way past child-bearing age so they cannot give him heirs, and since they die well before him he's also bereft of their company. Not that he seemed to particularly care about that last aspect. [[HoYay In fact, none of the Musketeers except maybe Aramis seem to find any spiritual or emotional fulfilment in their relationships with women.]

to:

* GoldDigger: Milady probably qualifies, as she came from a much lower background than Athos (a rich Count) and deliberately kept her shady past from him in order to ensnare him into marriage. Porthos, meanwhile, is a rare male example. His M.O. consists of romancing and eventually marrying rich, elderly widows (or, well, the first one wasn't even widowed when he started romancing her). Whether it pays off is debatable. He does end up very rich, but his neighbours don't respect him, his wives are all way past child-bearing age so they cannot give him heirs, and since they die well before him he's also bereft of their company. Not that he seemed to particularly care about that last aspect. [[HoYay In fact, none of the Musketeers except maybe Aramis seem to find any spiritual or emotional fulfilment in their relationships with women.]



* HistoricalDomainCharacter: UsefulNotes/LouisXIII, his wife Anne of Austria, his minister Cardinal Richelieu; UsefulNotes/LouisXIV, his mistress Louise de La Vallière, his ministers UsefulNotes/CardinalMazarin and Jean-Baptiste Colbert; the English monarch UsefulNotes/CharlesI of UsefulNotes/TheHouseOfStuart, his wife Henrietta Marie, his Parliamentary opponent UsefulNotes/OliverCromwell; and even The Man In The Iron Mask, who ''was'' an actual person, though very little is known of him. That's why he has been such a popular figure in fiction.

to:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: HistoricalDomainCharacter:
**
UsefulNotes/LouisXIII, his wife Anne of Austria, his minister Cardinal Richelieu; UsefulNotes/LouisXIV, his mistress Louise de La Vallière, his ministers UsefulNotes/CardinalMazarin and Jean-Baptiste Colbert; the English monarch UsefulNotes/CharlesI of UsefulNotes/TheHouseOfStuart, his wife Henrietta Marie, his Parliamentary opponent UsefulNotes/OliverCromwell; and even The Man In The Iron Mask, who ''was'' an actual person, though very little is known of him. That's why he has been such a popular figure in fiction.



%% * InnocentBlueEyes: Athos has "azure" eyes, presumably as a symbol of his pureness.

to:

%% * InnocentBlueEyes: Athos has "azure" eyes, presumably as a symbol of which symbolize his pureness.spiritual purity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No spoilers in work descriptions


The book has been [[AdaptationOverdosed adapted many times, in many countries and in virtually every medium]]. It has two sequels, which are much less well known: ''Twenty Years After'' (1845) and ''The Vicomte of Bragelonne'' (serialized 1847–1850). The latter is so massive that it's often divided into three, four or five volumes. Some parts of one particular subplot in the second sequel, related to [[spoiler:the imprisoned twin brother of UsefulNotes/LouisXIV]] (the famous ManInTheIronMask), have also inspired several films.

to:

The book has been [[AdaptationOverdosed adapted many times, in many countries and in virtually every medium]]. It has two sequels, which are much less well known: ''Twenty Years After'' (1845) and ''The Vicomte of Bragelonne'' (serialized 1847–1850). The latter is so massive that it's often divided into three, four or five volumes. Some parts of one particular subplot in the second sequel, related to [[spoiler:the the imprisoned twin brother of UsefulNotes/LouisXIV]] UsefulNotes/LouisXIV (the famous ManInTheIronMask), have also inspired several films.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IntergenerationalFriendship: At the beginning of the story, D'Artagnan is 19 and Athos is said to be twice his age. The age gap is explicitly noted in-universe, as well as the father/mentor role played by Athos.

to:

* IntergenerationalFriendship: At the beginning of the story, D'Artagnan is 19 18 and Athos is said to be twice his age. thirty. The age gap is explicitly noted in-universe, as well as the father/mentor role played by Athos.Athos, though given the actual age difference, it is somewhat downplayed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LikeASonToMe: Athos sometimes calls D'Artagnan "my son" in moments of great affection, even after he has a real son.

to:

* LikeASonToMe: Athos sometimes calls D'Artagnan "my son" in moments of great affection, even after he has a real son.son and despite being only twelve years older than him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not a franchise


For a list of works based off or inspired by ''The Three Musketeers'' and its sequels, see [[Franchise/TheThreeMusketeers here]].

to:

For a list of works based off or inspired by ''The Three Musketeers'' and its sequels, see [[Franchise/TheThreeMusketeers [[DerivativeWorks/TheThreeMusketeers here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fix Messiah greenlink


* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: ''Twenty Years After'' stops just short of making Charles I TheMessiah mk. II, both because it fits the ideals of the protagonists (such as seeing themselves as the last bastions of chivalry, defending royalty against a commoner uprising) and because it makes Mordaunt that much more of an AssholeVictim (not only did he give Cromwell the idea of bribing the last of the king's loyal soldiers, he volunteered to be his executioner, all because the king had denied him his inheritance and title).

to:

* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: ''Twenty Years After'' stops just short of making Charles I TheMessiah mk. II, [[MessianicArchetype the Messiah Mk II,]] both because it fits the ideals of the protagonists (such as seeing themselves as the last bastions of chivalry, defending royalty against a commoner uprising) and because it makes Mordaunt that much more of an AssholeVictim (not only did he give Cromwell the idea of bribing the last of the king's loyal soldiers, he volunteered to be his executioner, all because the king had denied him his inheritance and title).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoldDigger: Milady probably qualifies, as she came from a much lower background than Athos (a rich Count) and deliberately kept her shady past from him in order to ensnare him into marriage. Porthos, meanwhile, is a rare male example. His M.O. consists of romancing and eventually marrying rich, elderly widows (or, well, the first one wasn't even widowed when he started romancing her). Whether it pays off is debatable. He does end up very rich, but his neighbours don't respect him, his wives are all way past child-bearing age so they cannot give him heirs, and since they die well before him he's also bereft of their company. Not that he seemed to particularly care about that last aspect. [[HoYay] In fact, none of the Musketeers except maybe Aramis seem to find any spiritual or emotional fulfilment in their relationships with women.]

to:

* GoldDigger: Milady probably qualifies, as she came from a much lower background than Athos (a rich Count) and deliberately kept her shady past from him in order to ensnare him into marriage. Porthos, meanwhile, is a rare male example. His M.O. consists of romancing and eventually marrying rich, elderly widows (or, well, the first one wasn't even widowed when he started romancing her). Whether it pays off is debatable. He does end up very rich, but his neighbours don't respect him, his wives are all way past child-bearing age so they cannot give him heirs, and since they die well before him he's also bereft of their company. Not that he seemed to particularly care about that last aspect. [[HoYay] [[HoYay In fact, none of the Musketeers except maybe Aramis seem to find any spiritual or emotional fulfilment in their relationships with women.]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvenEvilHasLovedOnes: Mordaunt. His killing spree is in no small part dedicated to his dead mother. When he is finally given a choice of a) being saved from drowning by Athos or b) drowning and trying to take Athos with him, he choses option b). His last words are an apology to his mother for being able to give her the death of only one of the Musketeers, thought at least he gets to pick the one she hated the most.

to:

* EvenEvilHasLovedOnes: EvenEvilHasLovedOnes & EvenBadMenLoveTheirMamas: Mordaunt. His killing spree is in no small part dedicated to his dead mother. When he is finally given a choice of a) being saved from drowning by Athos or b) drowning and trying to take Athos with him, he choses option b). His last words are an apology to his mother for being able to give her the death of only one of the Musketeers, thought at least he gets to pick the one she hated the most.

Added: 1680

Changed: 83

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Tropes added


* GoldDigger: Milady probably qualifies, as she came from a much lower background than Athos (a rich Count) and deliberately kept her shady past from him in order to ensnare him into marriage. Porthos, meanwhile, is a rare male example. His M.O. consists of romancing and eventually marrying rich, elderly widows (yes, he does that more than once). Whether it pays off is debatable. He does end up very rich, but his neighbours don't respect him, his wives are all way past child-bearing age so they cannot give him heirs, and since they die well before him he's also bereft of their company. Not that he seemed to particularly care about that last aspect. [[HoYay]In fact, none of the Musketeers except maybe Aramis seem to find any spiritual or emotional fulfilment in their relationships with women.]

to:

* GoldDigger: Milady probably qualifies, as she came from a much lower background than Athos (a rich Count) and deliberately kept her shady past from him in order to ensnare him into marriage. Porthos, meanwhile, is a rare male example. His M.O. consists of romancing and eventually marrying rich, elderly widows (yes, (or, well, the first one wasn't even widowed when he does that more than once).started romancing her). Whether it pays off is debatable. He does end up very rich, but his neighbours don't respect him, his wives are all way past child-bearing age so they cannot give him heirs, and since they die well before him he's also bereft of their company. Not that he seemed to particularly care about that last aspect. [[HoYay]In [[HoYay] In fact, none of the Musketeers except maybe Aramis seem to find any spiritual or emotional fulfilment in their relationships with women.]



* BlackWidow: Milady married Lord Winter's brother, then poisoned him.



* DoubleStandard: Milady being a bigamist is treated as some sort of horribly disgusting crime. Even though her first husband tried to kill her, then vanished without a trace, and actively makes sure no-one can connect the identity he uses now with his former name and rank. How was she to expect that he's still alive? Meanwhile, the Musketeers regularly sleep with married women (D'Artagnan with Constance, Aramis with Madame de Longueville, Porthos with Madame Coquenard - though the sex is only implied there), and no-one bats an eye.



* AngstWhatAngst: All the Musketeers feel some shame or remorse about their parts in Milady's execution - except Porthos, who's all "Oh yeah, that's a thing we did, I'd totally forgotten". Subverted in that a) twenty years have passed since the deed and b) his friends, especially Athos, still react with incredulity to this revelation.



* EvenEvilHasLovedOnes: Mordaunt. His killing spree is in no small part dedicated to his dead mother. When he is finally given a choice of a) being saved from drowning by Athos or b) drowning and trying to take Athos with him, he choses option b). His last words are an apology to his mother for being able to give her the death of only one of the Musketeers, thought at least he gets to pick the one she hated the most.



** Mazarin wants to know about two of the men involved in the Duke of Beaufort's flight, who D'Artagnan knows are Athos and Aramis. D'Artagnan promises to have dinner with someone who might be able to tell him of them. Then he goes off to dine with his friends. He does not intend to rat them out to Mazarin, though.



* HiddenBadass: Aramis, now a priest, recounts to D'Artagnan how a member of his congregation tried to pick a quarrel with him over his choice of sermon, believing Aramis to be a priest just like other priests (as opposed to be a former elite soldier). It didn't end well for the adversary.

to:

* HiddenBadass: Aramis, now a priest, recounts to D'Artagnan how a member of his congregation tried to pick a quarrel with him over his choice of sermon, believing Aramis to be a priest just like other priests (as opposed to be a former elite soldier). It didn't end well for the adversary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* GoldDigger: Milady probably qualifies, as she came from a much lower background than Athos (a rich Count) and deliberately kept her shady past from him in order to ensnare him into marriage. Porthos, meanwhile, is a rare male example. His M.O. consists of romancing and eventually marrying rich, elderly widows (yes, he does that more than once). Whether it pays off is debatable. He does end up very rich, but his neighbours don't respect him, his wives are all way past child-bearing age so they cannot give him heirs, and since they die well before him he's also bereft of their company. Not that he seemed to particularly care about that last aspect. [[HoYay]In fact, none of the Musketeers except maybe Aramis seem to find any spiritual or emotional fulfilment in their relationships with women.]

Added: 2230

Changed: 35

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Examples added


* VagueAge: Athos. In the first book, he's said to be twice the others' age. In the second, he's fourty-nine to D'Artagnan's fourty and Aramis' fourty-three. He still calls D'Artagnan "my son", though!



* LookWhatICanDoNow: Aramis' backstory. As a youth, he was studying to become a priest. One day a nobleman quarreled with him. Aramis dropped out of priest school, trained for a year with the best fencing master he could find, and, after the year had passed, dueled the nobleman and killed him. The resulting scandal is the reason why he had to join the Musketeers under an assumed name.



* AgeInsecurity: When D'Artagnan and Aramis reconnect, Aramis mentions being thirty-seven years old. D'Artagnan immediately points out that this cannot be true, as he himself is fourty and Aramis used to be three years older than he. Aramis then admits the truth, making it out to be a maths error on his part rather than an outright lie. At the same time, he beseeches D'Artagnan not to to tell any of his (Aramis') friends his true age.



** D'Artagnan does this, too. For example he makes a toast to Charles in full hearing of Cromwell's guards by toasting "the one who presides over the feast" while making eye-contact with the King.
** At one point, the imprisoned Charles' faithful servant Perry reads to him from the Bible. The Musketeers enter the room (two of them disguised as prisoners and the other two disguised as Cromwell supporters). We then get Perry skipping over several pages before reading aloud a poignant quote about the Lord having sent friends who will become saviours.



** Averted with Constance Bonacieux. Even twenty years after her death, D'Artagnan still remembers her.
* HiddenBadass: Aramis, now a priest, recounts to D'Artagnan how a member of his congregation tried to pick a quarrel with him over his choice of sermon, believing Aramis to be a priest just like other priests (as opposed to be a former elite soldier). It didn't end well for the adversary.



* KinslayingIsASpecialKindOfEvil: Among the people Mordaunt kills is Lord Winter, his uncle. Even Mordaunt's master Cromwell is creeped out by Mordaunt's complete disregard of familial bonds. Mordaunt covers by claiming he doesn't consider a "traitor" family.



** At the same time, Athos may count as an Inversion. In the first book, he was perfectly happy to duel (and kill!) people he didn't even know. He challenged D'Artagnan to a duel merely for bumping into him and deliberately murdered one of Lord Winter's friends for knowing his true name. Which Athos had deliberately told him! And even though the guy wasn't French and was therefore unlikely to tell anyone who cared. Meanwhile, in the sequel, he rides into battle with his sword sheated and his pistols holstered, and looks sadly at all the slaughter. He also refuses to kill Mordaunt, to stand by and let anyone else kill Mordaunt, or to even stand by and watch Mordaunt get HoistByHisOwnPetard. This despite Mordaunt having already committed several heinous crimes, and having made it perfectly clear that he won't stop until Athos and all his friends are dead.

to:

** At the same time, Athos may count as an Inversion. In the first book, he was perfectly happy to duel (and kill!) people he didn't even know. He challenged D'Artagnan to a duel merely for bumping into him and deliberately murdered one of Lord Winter's friends for knowing his true name. Which Athos had deliberately just told him! And even though the guy wasn't French French, and was therefore unlikely to tell anyone who cared. cared! Meanwhile, in the sequel, he rides into battle with his sword sheated and his pistols holstered, and looks gazes sadly at all upon the slaughter. He also refuses to kill Mordaunt, to stand by and let anyone else kill Mordaunt, or to even stand by and watch Mordaunt get HoistByHisOwnPetard. This despite Mordaunt having already committed several heinous crimes, and having made it perfectly clear that he won't stop until Athos and all his friends are dead.

Added: 1304

Changed: 529

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Additions and a correction


* YouFightLikeACow: Several characters, the most serious offender being Porthos. He quips so much that it's actually part of his combat technique. In the first sword fight from the book the duel between d'Artagnan and all three of the musketeers, that got interrupted by the cardinal's guards, Porthos gets stuck fighting two adversaries at once and he finishes first because he keeps tormenting them with questions about the time, what they thought of this and that social event at court, corrections about their fighting styles, etc. He of course is not the only offender, all of the characters engaging in this behavior from time to time.

to:

* YouFightLikeACow: Several characters, the most serious offender being Porthos. He quips so much that it's actually part of his combat technique. technique, though clearly not a very effective one. In the first sword fight from the book book, the duel between d'Artagnan and all three of the musketeers, musketeers that got gets interrupted by the cardinal's guards, Porthos gets stuck fighting two adversaries at once and he finishes first because last. The narration notes that while he keeps tormenting them his single adversary with questions about the time, what they thought of references to current events, and so on, this and that social event at court, corrections about doesn't actually gain him anything. By the end, everyone else has finished off their fighting styles, etc. He adversaries (even Aramis, who got stuck with two adversaries to everyone else's one, and Athos, who was already badly wounded before the fight!), but Porthos' adversary has to be talked into surrendering by his commanding officer. Porthos of course is not the only offender, all of the characters engaging in this behavior from time to time.


Added DiffLines:

* RememberTheNewGuy: In "Twenty Years After", all the Musketeers are well aware that Milady had a son (Mordaunt, the sequel's villain). This fact was never brought up in the first book. Given that Milady was dead by the end of the first book, that none of the Musketeers liked to think about (let alone discuss) her death, and that they all went their seperate ways, it seems unlikely that it would have come up in conversation afterwards.


Added DiffLines:

** At the same time, Athos may count as an Inversion. In the first book, he was perfectly happy to duel (and kill!) people he didn't even know. He challenged D'Artagnan to a duel merely for bumping into him and deliberately murdered one of Lord Winter's friends for knowing his true name. Which Athos had deliberately told him! And even though the guy wasn't French and was therefore unlikely to tell anyone who cared. Meanwhile, in the sequel, he rides into battle with his sword sheated and his pistols holstered, and looks sadly at all the slaughter. He also refuses to kill Mordaunt, to stand by and let anyone else kill Mordaunt, or to even stand by and watch Mordaunt get HoistByHisOwnPetard. This despite Mordaunt having already committed several heinous crimes, and having made it perfectly clear that he won't stop until Athos and all his friends are dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Natter


- What? That’s not true at all! Aramis (not Porthos) is the one who gets stuck with two adversaries, and by the time D’Artagnan finishes with his (one) adversary, he notes that Aramis has already killed one of his two adversaries and is holding up well against the other. Porthos, meanwhile, finishes last. The narration even notes that while Porthos keeps running his mouth, he makes little to no headway against his stubborn adversary (who is eventually persuaded to surrender by his already-wounded commanding officer after everyone else has finished their duels).

to:

- What? That’s not true at all! Aramis (not Porthos) is the one who gets stuck with two adversaries, and by the time D’Artagnan finishes with his (one) adversary, he notes that Aramis has already killed one of his two adversaries and is holding up well against the other. Porthos, meanwhile, finishes last. The narration even notes that while Porthos keeps running his mouth, he makes little to no headway against his stubborn adversary (who is eventually persuaded to surrender by his already-wounded commanding officer after everyone else has finished their duels).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correction



to:

- What? That’s not true at all! Aramis (not Porthos) is the one who gets stuck with two adversaries, and by the time D’Artagnan finishes with his (one) adversary, he notes that Aramis has already killed one of his two adversaries and is holding up well against the other. Porthos, meanwhile, finishes last. The narration even notes that while Porthos keeps running his mouth, he makes little to no headway against his stubborn adversary (who is eventually persuaded to surrender by his already-wounded commanding officer after everyone else has finished their duels).

Top