Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / ThePhantomOfTheOpera

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AboveTheInfluence: Christine obviously expects several times to be raped during her two abductions, but it turns out the Phantom [[AffablyEvil respects her privacy and honor]].

to:

* AboveTheInfluence: Christine obviously expects several times to be raped during her two abductions, but it turns out the Phantom [[AffablyEvil respects her privacy and honor]].honor]], though it’s played with in that he comes off almost [[UsefulNotes/Asexuality asexual]] and seems to want Christine as his wife for dressing up, taking out on walks, and spoiling with presents, rather than sleeping with in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SnipeHunt: Inspector Mifroid attempts to send Raoul to one, claiming that his brother Philippe kidnapped Christine and is headed to Brussels. He nearly falls for it until he bumps into the Persian, who reveals that Christine is actually in Erik's captivity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Doesn't make sense without the are


* AnAesop: Nobody is born inherently cruel, and people who have most likely become so due to a [[FreudianExcuse traumatic past]], and while FreudianExcuseIsNoExcuse, it's still in society's best interest to be compassionate to those who are often shunned so [[HeWhoFightsMonsters they don't become monsters]].

to:

* AnAesop: Nobody is born inherently cruel, and people who are have most likely become so due to a [[FreudianExcuse traumatic past]], and while FreudianExcuseIsNoExcuse, it's still in society's best interest to be compassionate to those who are often shunned so [[HeWhoFightsMonsters they don't become monsters]].

Added: 138

Changed: 63

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnAesop: Nobody is born inherently cruel, and people who are have most likely become so due to a [[FreudianExcuse traumatic past]], and while FreudianExcuseIsNoExcuse, it's still in society's best interest to be compassionate to those who are often shunned so [[HeWhoFightsMonsters they don't become monsters]].

to:

* AnAesop: Nobody is born inherently cruel, and people who are have most likely become so due to a [[FreudianExcuse traumatic past]], and while FreudianExcuseIsNoExcuse, it's still in society's best interest to be compassionate to those who are often shunned so [[HeWhoFightsMonsters they don't become monsters]].



* CorruptTheCutie: Long time before even meeting Christine, [[{{Backstory}} Erik worked for the Sha-in-Sha]]: the little sultana, the favorite of the Shah-in-Shah, was boring herself to death. Erik built a HallOfMirrors for her. When she got bored of that, Erik transformed it into a RoboticTortureDevice aptly named “the chamber of horrors”, used to [[DrivenToSuicide execute people sentenced to death]]. He also taught her how to strangle people efficiently with the punjab lassoo. The little sultana [[MoralEventHorizon soon applied that knowledge to simple peasants]] ''[[MoralEventHorizon and her own friends.]]''

to:

* CorruptTheCutie: Long time before even meeting Christine, [[{{Backstory}} Erik worked for the Sha-in-Sha]]: the little sultana, the favorite of the Shah-in-Shah, was boring herself to death. Erik built a HallOfMirrors for her. When she got bored of that, Erik transformed it into a RoboticTortureDevice aptly named “the chamber of horrors”, used to [[DrivenToSuicide execute people sentenced to death]]. He also taught her how to strangle people efficiently with the punjab lassoo.Punjab lasso. The little sultana [[MoralEventHorizon soon applied that knowledge to simple peasants]] ''[[MoralEventHorizon and her own friends.]]''



* FramingDevice: Leroux framed the story as a result of his investigations of the Opera house and the mystery of the Phantom of the Opera.



* {{The Gentleman or the Scoundrel}}: Raoul and Erik.
* HallOfMirrors: The torture chamber in Erik's house is constructed with heat reflecting mirrors. The heat, along with the multiple reflections of trees, create the illusion that the victim is trapped in a desert forest.

to:

* {{The Gentleman or the Scoundrel}}: Raoul and Erik.
Erik, with Raoul being the gentleman and Erik being the scoundrel.
* HallOfMirrors: The torture chamber in Erik's house is constructed with heat reflecting heat-reflecting mirrors. The heat, along with the multiple reflections of trees, create creates the illusion that the victim is trapped in a desert forest.



** In Chapter XX, Raoul and the Persian come across a mysterious appearance while on the trail of the phantom. When asked by Raoul if this is another member of the theater police, the Persian responds "It's some one much worse than that!", the authors note attached to it further more states how the author "can give no further explanation touching the apparition of this shade", saying the reader must have to try and guess for himself. The nature of this mysterious person is then dropped, never to be mentioned again.

to:

** In Chapter XX, Raoul and the Persian come across a mysterious appearance while on the trail of the phantom. When asked by Raoul if this is another member of the theater police, the Persian responds "It's some one someone much worse than that!", the authors note attached to it further more furthermore states how the author "can give no further explanation touching the apparition of this shade", saying the reader must have to try and guess for himself. The nature of this mysterious person is then dropped, never to be mentioned again.



* RedundantRescue: Raoul's and the Persian's rescue mission ends with Christine forced to save ''them'' from the Phantom's DeathTrap.

to:

* RedundantRescue: Raoul's and the Persian's rescue mission ends with Christine being forced to save ''them'' from the Phantom's DeathTrap.



--> ''"Then, tired of his adventurous, formidable and monstrous life, he longed to be some one [[IJustWantToBeNormal "like everybody else."]] And he became a contractor, like any ordinary contractor, building ordinary houses with ordinary bricks. He tendered for part of the foundations in the Opera. His estimate was accepted."''

to:

--> ''"Then, tired of his adventurous, formidable and monstrous life, he longed to be some one someone [[IJustWantToBeNormal "like everybody else."]] And he became a contractor, like any ordinary contractor, building ordinary houses with ordinary bricks. He tendered for part of the foundations in the Opera. His estimate was accepted."''



* SmallNameBigEgo: InUniverse: [[PointyHairedBoss Pointy-Haired Bosses]] Richard and Moncharmin and ThePrimaDonna Carlotta. Madam Giry is lampshaded as this (see ItsAllAboutMe), a humble usher who thinks of herself as an equal to the Opera’s administrators… just moments before they fire her. But FridgeBrilliance shows us how this is subverted: In Parisian society at this point, [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveConnections it’s not what you do, it’s who you know]]. Madam Giry ''knows the Phantom and he is happy with her work''. Therefore, ''she is more important that Richard and Moncharmin''. She gets her job back pretty quickly.
* StageMoney: How Erik gets his 20,000 francs each month without being caught. Moncharmin and Richard give Madame Giry an envelope containing the cash to place in Box Five as instructed by Erik. She has a second, identical envelope full of fake bills, given to her by Erik; she puts the fake in the box, pockets the real one, and drops it into a manager's coat pocket. Later, while the managers are in their office, Erik opens a small trapdoor in the floor and swipes the cash from that pocket.

to:

* SmallNameBigEgo: InUniverse: [[PointyHairedBoss Pointy-Haired Bosses]] Richard and Moncharmin and ThePrimaDonna Carlotta. Madam Giry is lampshaded as this (see ItsAllAboutMe), a humble usher who thinks of herself as an equal to the Opera’s administrators… just moments before they fire her. But FridgeBrilliance shows us how this is subverted: In Parisian society at this point, [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveConnections it’s not what you do, it’s who you know]]. Madam Giry ''knows the Phantom and he is happy with her work''. Therefore, ''she is more important that than Richard and Moncharmin''. She gets her job back pretty quickly.
* StageMoney: How Erik gets his 20,000 francs each month without being caught. Moncharmin and Richard give Madame Giry an envelope containing the cash to place in Box Five as instructed by Erik. She has a second, identical envelope full of fake bills, given to her by Erik; she puts the fake in the box, pockets the real one, and drops it into a manager's coat pocket. Later, while the managers are in their office, Erik opens a small trapdoor in on the floor and swipes the cash from that pocket.



* SupervillainLair: Erik's an architect who's had plenty of time to trick out his underground lair with both elaborate death-traps ''and'' sumptuous living quaters.

to:

* SupervillainLair: Erik's an architect who's had plenty of time to trick out his underground lair with both elaborate death-traps ''and'' sumptuous living quaters.quarters.



* TogetherInDeath: The Phantom's back-up plan.

to:

* TogetherInDeath: The Phantom's back-up backup plan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AbominableAuditorium: The Opera House in The Phantom of the Opera was designed by the Phantom himself, and comes equipped with dozens of secret passages and hidden chambers that he can use to his advantage, including a private lair deep beneath the building. For most of the story, the Phantom is terrorizing the staff, extorting money from the managers, grooming a young ingenue for stardom, and is fully prepared to murder both audience members and employees if he doesn't get what he wants.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**And yet simultaneously, and equally to his disadvantage, people of his era were much more used to mundane birth defects and scars than we are today, simply because we can now fix most forms of disfiguration with reconstructive surgery. Erik's unspecified condition (which largely resembles congenital syphilis, which would also explain his erratic mental state even aside from the lifetime of abuse) is so horrific to look at that no one has any context for it besides comparing him to a rotting corpse rather than a disfigured living person, which cannot have helped his baggage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswick Faint In shock


* {{Fainting}}:
** Christine faints on stage after her splendid gala performance in chapter 2. Either an emotional or exhaustion type.
** Christine faints again during her first abduction when Erik grabs her. Fits both the monster reveal type faint, since it is the smell of death on his hand that causes her to faint, and also the emotional type faint, since she is already freaked out with what's going on.
** When Raoul first comes face to face with Erik unmasked in the Perros graveyard, he faints. Fits both the monster reveal and emotional type faints, since Erik had already been trying to freak him out by playing the ghost and throwing skulls at him.

to:

* {{Fainting}}:
FaintInShock:
** Christine faints on stage after her splendid gala performance in chapter 2. Either an emotional or exhaustion type.
performance. Possibly exacerbated by exhaustion.
** The first time the Phantom abducts her, Christine faints again during her first abduction when Erik grabs her. Fits both the monster reveal type faint, since it is due to the smell of death on his hand that causes her to faint, and also the emotional type faint, since she is already freaked out with what's going on.
hand.
** When Raoul first comes face to face with Erik unmasked in the Perros graveyard, he faints. Fits both the monster reveal and emotional type faints, since Understandable, as Erik had already has been trying to freak him out by playing the ghost and throwing skulls at him. him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And the skeleton of Erik's featured in the novel was inspired by the persistent RealLife rumors that a real skeleton had been utilized for the 1841 Paris Opera staging of the "Der Freischütz".

to:

** And the skeleton of Erik's featured in the novel was inspired by the persistent RealLife rumors that a real skeleton had been utilized for the 1841 Paris Opera staging of the "Der Freischütz". The rumors themselves were just that, however.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And the skeleton of Erik's featured in the novel was inspired by the persistent RealLife rumors that a real skeleton had been utilized for the 1841 Paris Opera staging of the "Der Freischütz".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnAesop: Nobody is born inherently cruel, and people who are have most likely become so due to a [[FreudianExcuse traumatic past]]; however, even if there's a reason, [[FreudianExcuseIsNoExcuse it's still no excuse to be cruel]].

to:

* AnAesop: Nobody is born inherently cruel, and people who are have most likely become so due to a [[FreudianExcuse traumatic past]]; however, even if there's a reason, [[FreudianExcuseIsNoExcuse past]], and while FreudianExcuseIsNoExcuse, it's still no excuse in society's best interest to be cruel]].compassionate to those who are often shunned so [[HeWhoFightsMonsters they don't become monsters]].

Added: 404

Changed: 2366

Removed: 2300

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
realizing this whole Fate Worse Than Death entry is quite nattery and unnecessarily long. | fixing some other things (I don't see what's the point of the commented out natter, for example) | Pretty sure Love Makes You Evil doesn't apply since Erik was already a murderer before loving Christine. | attributing a Moral Event Horizon to the author for suggesting Erik be celebrated posthumously is... odd.


* FateWorseThanDeath: Christine tries to kill herself before the Phantom can force her to "marry" him in the climax.
** It's worth noting, that Erik seems to have an almost humorously non-sexual view of marriage- his chief goal in having a pretty wife, as described to Christine herself, is to buy her nice things and take her for walks in the park on Sundays, while he wears a mask that (he thinks) sufficiently makes him look "like anyone else".
*** From a ''modern'' perspective, the threat of Christine being unable to be with the man she loves (and actually ''wants'' to marry) and in a forced state of virginity thanks to a sexless marriage with a repulsive man who treats her like a living doll could be seen as a Fate Worse Than Death in itself.
*** For all his talk about the happily married life they're going to have, Erik seems to be dead-set on a double-suicide with his new wife, once they've been married; he explains in the end that he only began seeing her as his ''living'' wife once she promised herself to him to save Raoul, and her holding up her end of this and showing him compassion is what prompts him to let her go. It has to be remembered that Erik is extremely unhinged and has a morbid obsession with death which doesn't let him go even when he's trying to become "normal".

to:

* FateWorseThanDeath: Christine sees being married to Erik as this, as she tries to kill herself before when she's abducted for the Phantom can force final time. The Persian is likewise convinced that she will decline Erik's marriage proposal and choose death, and rushes to warn her to "marry" him in the climax.
** It's worth noting,
that Erik seems to have an almost humorously non-sexual view of marriage- his chief goal in having a pretty wife, as described to Christine herself, is to buy her nice things will blow up the opera house and take her for walks in the park on Sundays, while he wears a mask that (he thinks) sufficiently makes him look "like anyone else".
*** From a ''modern'' perspective, the threat of Christine being unable to be
kill everyone else with the man her if she loves (and actually ''wants'' to marry) and in a forced state of virginity thanks to a sexless marriage with a repulsive man who treats her like a living doll could be seen as a Fate Worse Than Death in itself.
*** For all his talk about the happily married life they're going to have, Erik seems to be dead-set on a double-suicide with his new wife, once they've been married; he explains in the end that he only began seeing her as his ''living'' wife once she promised herself to him to save Raoul, and her holding up her end of this and showing him compassion is what prompts him to let her go. It has to be remembered that Erik is extremely unhinged and has a morbid obsession with death which doesn't let him go even when he's trying to become "normal".
does.



* HallOfMirrors: The Phantom uses one to convince Raoul and the Persian that they are trapped in a desert.

to:

* HallOfMirrors: The Phantom uses one to convince Raoul and torture chamber in Erik's house is constructed with heat reflecting mirrors. The heat, along with the Persian multiple reflections of trees, create the illusion that they are the victim is trapped in a desert.desert forest.



* InterruptedSuicide: The Persian only just manages to stop Raoul from shooting himself in the torture chamber.

to:

* InterruptedSuicide: InterruptedSuicide:
**
The Persian only just manages to stop Raoul from shooting himself in the torture chamber.chamber.
** After abducting Christine to force her to marry him, Erik finds her trying to kill herself and ends up binding her to prevent another attempt.



* IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy: The Phantom, at the end.

to:

* IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy: The Phantom, at the end.end, as he lets Christine go because he knows she loves Raoul and won't be happy married to him.



* LivingMacGuffin: ''Christine.''
%% ** On the other hand, she could be this trope until the end of the novel, but then we discover that any normal woman would have GoneMadFromTheRevelation or be DrivenToSuicide rather than marry Erik. Only Christine could have really agreed to marry him without trying suicide, and Erick is so shocked that he quits his plan to KillThemAll.

to:

* LivingMacGuffin: ''Christine.''
%% ** On the other hand, she could be this trope until the end of the novel, but then we discover
Christine, whose very presence sets in motion Erik's downward spiral that any normal woman would have GoneMadFromTheRevelation or be DrivenToSuicide rather than marry Erik. Only Christine could have really agreed leads to marry him without trying suicide, and Erick is so shocked that he quits his plan almost blowing up the whole opera house, in addition to KillThemAll.being the object of Raoul's affection.



* LoveHurts:
* LoveMakesYouCrazy and [[LoveMakesYouEvil Evil]] ''and'' [[LoveRedeems Redeems]]: Probably one of the few cases of a single character managing to hit all three of these.
* LoveTriangle

to:

%%* LoveHurts
* LoveHurts:
* LoveMakesYouCrazy and [[LoveMakesYouEvil Evil]] ''and'' [[LoveRedeems Redeems]]: Probably one
LoveMakesYouCrazy: Erik is already an unbalanced individual by the start of the few cases book, but a point is made of a single character managing how falling in love with Christine, and becoming convinced that she loves him back, led to hit all three him becoming even worse than before.
* LoveRedeems: After finally getting Christine to marry him, and after kissing her on the forehead--in what was certainly the first time he'd ever been allowed to show affection to anyone in his life--Erik breaks down and lets Christine and Raoul go free, knowing that she'll be happier with the man she truly loves than with him.
* LoveTriangle: Raoul and Erik are both after Christine's affection, although on Christine's part, her feelings for Erik are a mix
of these.
* LoveTriangle
pity and horror rather than love.



* MailerDaemon: The Phantom's M.O. for seducing Christine is particularly HilariousInHindsight, considering it pre-dates the Internet by almost a century!

to:

* MailerDaemon: The Phantom's M.O. for seducing Christine (speaking to her merely as a voice and not showing his face until the time comes to abduct her) is particularly HilariousInHindsight, considering it pre-dates the Internet by almost a century!



* NoMatterHowMuchIBeg: Christine eventually tells Raoul to take her out of the country away from Erik no matter how much she protests later (see StockholmSyndrome).
* OffscreenTeleportation: The Phantom is everywhere and sees and hears everything!
** JustifiedTrope: The Phantom can move through the hatches on the Opera, and some rooms were intentionally designed to be spied upon.

to:

* NoMatterHowMuchIBeg: Christine eventually tells Raoul to take her out of the country away from Erik no matter how much she protests later (see StockholmSyndrome).
later.
* OffscreenTeleportation: The Phantom is everywhere and sees and hears everything!
** JustifiedTrope:
everything! [[JustifiedTrope This is later explained in that The Phantom can move through the hatches on the Opera, and some rooms were intentionally designed to be spied upon.]]



* SaveTheVillain: The Persian did this in the past; he now ''frequently'' laments "MyGodWhatHaveIDone"
* ScarpiaUltimatum: The Phantom threatens to blow up the Opera, killing everyone inside, if Christine doesn't "marry" him.

to:

* SaveTheVillain: The Persian did this saved Erik's life during their backstory in the past; Persia; he now ''frequently'' laments "MyGodWhatHaveIDone"
* ScarpiaUltimatum: The Phantom threatens to blow up the Opera, killing everyone inside, if Christine doesn't "marry" marry him.



* StockholmSyndrome: Christine -- she herself {{lampshade|Hanging}}s it in everything but name, and Raoul is saddened but not at all surprised or confused to see how much she evidently truly loves her psychotic, jealous, possessive stalker while fearing him at the same time.

to:

* StockholmSyndrome: Christine -- she herself {{lampshade|Hanging}}s it in everything but name, and Raoul is saddened but not at all surprised or confused to see how much she evidently truly loves cares for her psychotic, jealous, possessive stalker while fearing him at the same time.



* SympathyForTheDevil: The narrator pities Erik as much as the Persian did after hearing the end of his love story. He succeeded in making his readers agree with him... [[GoneHorriblyRight perhaps even a little too well]].
** On the other hand, the {{Narrator}} never justifies Erik's atrocities before he even becomes The Phantom. Erik is shown as a PsychopathicManchild [[EvilCannotComprehendGood truly surprised he let Christine and Raoul go]]. In the epilogue, the narrator [[{{Hypocrite}} claims to pity Erik, but never attacks the shallow societies that persecuted him.]] Instead, he justifies their attitudes because Erik is ''really'' [[BeautyEqualsGoodness ugly]]. Instead of giving Erik a grave (or even the common grave) [[MoralEventHorizon his last line is a plea for Erik to become a]] DeadGuyOnDisplay in the archives of the National Academy of Music.

to:

* SympathyForTheDevil: The narrator pities Erik as much as suggests that the Persian did after hearing the end of his love story. He succeeded in making his readers agree pity Erik for the life that he lived, and the fact that he was not able to reach his full potential of the good he could have done the world with him... [[GoneHorriblyRight perhaps even a little too well]].
** On
his genius if not for his hideous appearance that led society to reject him. During the other hand, the {{Narrator}} never justifies Erik's atrocities before he even becomes The Phantom. Erik is shown as a PsychopathicManchild [[EvilCannotComprehendGood truly surprised he let story itself, Christine and Raoul go]]. In the epilogue, the narrator [[{{Hypocrite}} claims to pity is also shown as having immense sympathy for Erik, but never attacks as one of her reasons for not cutting and running from the shallow societies opera house when she has the chance is that persecuted it would be "too cruel" to him.]] Instead, he justifies their attitudes because Erik is ''really'' [[BeautyEqualsGoodness ugly]]. Instead of giving Erik a grave (or even the common grave) [[MoralEventHorizon his last line is a plea for Erik to become a]] DeadGuyOnDisplay in the archives of the National Academy of Music.



* TragicMonster: Erik.

to:

* %%* TragicMonster: Erik.



* VampiresSleepInCoffins: Erik does.
* {{Ventriloquism}}: The Persian declares that Erik is the best ventriloquist in the whole world. He must be, because he uses this skill to do a lot of {{Practical Joke}}s, including convincing Opera Singer Carlotta (an all the Opera’s audience) [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments that she croaked like a toad]].

to:

* VampiresSleepInCoffins: Erik does.Erik, who has to an extent internalized his appearance as a walking corpse, sleeps in a coffin.
* {{Ventriloquism}}: The Persian declares that Erik is the best ventriloquist in the whole world. He must be, because he uses this skill to do a lot of {{Practical Joke}}s, including convincing Opera Singer Carlotta (an all the Opera’s audience) [[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments that she croaked like a toad]].toad.



* WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds: Leroux's original Erik -- he murders at least three people over the course of the plot and is definitely not the sanest person on the block, but Leroux expresses pity for him in the epilogue, lamenting what Erik's genius could have given to the world if only the world had not mistreated him.

to:

* WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds: Leroux's original Erik -- he murders at least three people over the course of the plot and is definitely not the sanest person on the block, but Leroux expresses pity for him in the epilogue, lamenting what Erik's genius could have given to the world if only the world had not mistreated him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
sorry, trying to find a more accurate way to word this


*** For all his talk about the happily married life they're going to have, Erik seems to be dead-set on a double-suicide with his new wife, once they've been married; he explains in the end that he only began seeing her as his ''living'' wife once she let him him kiss her forehead out of pity, and this prompted him to let her go. It has to be remembered that Erik is extremely unhinged and has a morbid obsession with death which doesn't let him go even when he's trying to become "normal".

to:

*** For all his talk about the happily married life they're going to have, Erik seems to be dead-set on a double-suicide with his new wife, once they've been married; he explains in the end that he only began seeing her as his ''living'' wife once she let promised herself to him him kiss to save Raoul, and her forehead out holding up her end of pity, and this prompted and showing him compassion is what prompts him to let her go. It has to be remembered that Erik is extremely unhinged and has a morbid obsession with death which doesn't let him go even when he's trying to become "normal".

Changed: 161

Removed: 66

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
checked the book—unless the translation has really messed it up, Christine doesn't kiss Erik until after he's already had a change of heart, and it's not a "true love's kiss". Erik kisses her on the forehead and then has his change of heart.


* EvilCannotComprehendGood: [[AnAesop The whole point of the novel]] is that Erik never believed that Christine could love him and so [[WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds he was ready to destroy himself, her and everyone in the Opera house]], [[ThePowerOfLove but when she really accepts to be with him if he spares Raoul]] and kisses him, Erik is so moved that he lets her go.

to:

* EvilCannotComprehendGood: [[AnAesop The whole point of the novel]] is that Erik never believed that Christine could love him and so [[WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds he was ready to destroy himself, her and everyone in the Opera house]], [[ThePowerOfLove but when she really accepts to be with him if he spares Raoul]] and kisses him, lets him kiss her, Erik is so moved that he lets her go.



*** For all his talk about the happily married life they're going to have, Erik seems to be dead-set on a double-suicide with his new wife, once they've been married; he explains in the end that he only began seeing her as his ''living'' wife once she kissed him out of pity, and this prompted him to let her go. It has to be remembered that Erik is extremely unhinged and has a morbid obsession with death which doesn't let him go even when he's trying to become "normal".

to:

*** For all his talk about the happily married life they're going to have, Erik seems to be dead-set on a double-suicide with his new wife, once they've been married; he explains in the end that he only began seeing her as his ''living'' wife once she kissed let him him kiss her forehead out of pity, and this prompted him to let her go. It has to be remembered that Erik is extremely unhinged and has a morbid obsession with death which doesn't let him go even when he's trying to become "normal".



* TheMoralSubstitute: Erik is Theatre/DonGiovanni done right: While Don Giovanni (and all versions of the Don Juan legend) is TheCasanova who [[BastardBoyfriend never cared if he hurts the women he claims to love]] [[EnforcedTrope and is sent to hell at the finale of the opera only to please the]] MoralGuardians who insist that Don Giovanni must be punished so the audience [[DoNotDoThisCoolThing would not do this cool thing]], Erik (who is Don Giovanni's {{Fanboy}}) also plays BastardBoyfriend to Christine while claiming to love her, but after breaking Christine’s spirit and successfully blackmailing her into being her wife, let her go with Raoul ''by his own will'' after Christine gives Erik his first TrueLovesKiss.

to:

* TheMoralSubstitute: Erik is Theatre/DonGiovanni done right: While Don Giovanni (and all versions of the Don Juan legend) is TheCasanova who [[BastardBoyfriend never cared if he hurts the women he claims to love]] [[EnforcedTrope and is sent to hell at the finale of the opera only to please the]] MoralGuardians who insist that Don Giovanni must be punished so the audience [[DoNotDoThisCoolThing would not do this cool thing]], Erik (who is Don Giovanni's {{Fanboy}}) also plays BastardBoyfriend to Christine while claiming to love her, but after breaking Christine’s spirit and successfully blackmailing her into being her wife, let her go with Raoul ''by his own will'' after Christine gives Erik his first TrueLovesKiss.let him kiss her.



* TenderTears: When Erik and Christine kiss, both weep: Erik because no one has ever kissed him before, and Christine because she realizes this.

to:

* TenderTears: When Erik and Christine kiss, kisses Christine, both weep: Erik because no one has ever kissed him he's never been able to kiss someone before, not even his own mother, and Christine because she realizes this.



** This was Erik's real plan all along. Erik really never believed that Christine could marry him without being DrivenToSuicide. When Christine convinces him she will not attempt suicide and kiss him, Erik is so shocked he lets her go.

to:

** This was Erik's real plan all along. Erik really never believed that Christine could marry him without being DrivenToSuicide. When Christine convinces him she will not attempt suicide and lets Erik kiss him, her, Erik is so shocked he lets her go.



* TrueLovesKiss: Well, the way the Phantom describes it, anyway...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DirectLineToTheAuthor: The {{Narrator}} claims he put together the story from firsthand accounts from people who lived and worked at the Opera House

to:

* DirectLineToTheAuthor: The {{Narrator}} claims he put together the story from firsthand accounts from people who lived and worked at the Opera HouseHouse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DirectLineToTheAuthor: The {{Narrator}} claims he put together the story from firsthand accounts from people who lived and worked at the Opera House
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
misuse; please compare Direct Lin E To The Author and Character Narrator before re-adding


* LiteraryAgentHypothesis: The {{Narrator}} ''really'' insists that he's telling a true story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* VampiresSleepInCoffins: Erik does.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnAesop: Nobody is born inherently cruel, and people who are have most likely become so due to a traumatic past; however, even if there's a reason, it's still no excuse to be cruel.

to:

* AnAesop: Nobody is born inherently cruel, and people who are have most likely become so due to a [[FreudianExcuse traumatic past; past]]; however, even if there's a reason, [[FreudianExcuseIsNoExcuse it's still no excuse to be cruel.cruel]].

Added: 244

Changed: 1056

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ElaborateUndergroundBase

to:

* ElaborateUndergroundBaseElaborateUndergroundBase: When your evil genius's skillset involve architecture, you end up with a sprawling underground lair complete with lake, pipe organ, and mechanized death pits.



%%%* LoveAtFirstNote:
%%%* LoveHurts:

to:

%%%* LoveAtFirstNote:
%%%*
* LoveAtFirstNote: Erik falls in love with Christine because her voice, while untrained, is full of glorious potential; Christine falls in love with her "Angel of Music" because his voice is incomparably beautiful. (Subverted, in that the Phantom's voice remains incomparably beautiful but Christine very quickly falls out of love with him for a multitude of valid reasons.)
*
LoveHurts:



* MasqueradeBall

to:

* MasqueradeBallMasqueradeBall: Central enough to the story that the chapter in which it appears is named for it.



* {{Melodrama}}

to:

* {{Melodrama}}{{Melodrama}}; Pretty justified, given the time period in which the book was written.



* ShoutOut: To Creator/EdgarAllanPoe's "The Masque of the Red Death." Prior to ''Phantom,'' LeRoux was best known as a detective novelist (''Phantom'' itself is technically a mystery), and Poe was one of the first writers of detective fiction.



* SupervillainLair

to:

* SupervillainLairSupervillainLair: Erik's an architect who's had plenty of time to trick out his underground lair with both elaborate death-traps ''and'' sumptuous living quaters.



* TenderTears

to:

* TenderTearsTenderTears: When Erik and Christine kiss, both weep: Erik because no one has ever kissed him before, and Christine because she realizes this.



* WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds: Leroux's original Erik -- he murders at least three people over the course of the plot and is definitely not the sanest person on the block, but Leroux expresses pity for him in the epilogue.

to:

* WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds: Leroux's original Erik -- he murders at least three people over the course of the plot and is definitely not the sanest person on the block, but Leroux expresses pity for him in the epilogue.epilogue, lamenting what Erik's genius could have given to the world if only the world had not mistreated him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed to Head Turning Beauty per TRS; lacks context


* HelloNurse: La Sorelli.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MeetCute: Raoul and Christine met as children when the wind blew Christine's favorite red scarf into the sea and Raoul jumped in to rescue it. When they reunite as adults, they reminisce over the incident.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StageMoney: How Erik gets his 20,000 francs each month without being caught. Moncharmin and Richard give Madame Giry an envelope containing the cash to place in Box Five as instructed by Erik. She has a second, identical envelope full of fake bills, given to her by Erik; she puts the fake in the box, pockets the real one, and drops it into a manager's coat pocket. Later, while the managers are in their office, Erik opens a small trapdoor in the floor and swipes the cash from that pocket.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[Franchise/ThePhantomOfTheOpera Also has a good number of adaptations throughout the years]].

to:

[[Franchise/ThePhantomOfTheOpera Also has had a good number of adaptations throughout the years]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I think only the ALW stuff believes this idea. Lon Chaney and Robert Englund's Phantoms are pretty wicked, and the nicer Phantoms like Charles Dance and Herbert Lom are much more sympathetic adaptations.


* BastardBoyfriend: Erik could be a {{deconstruction}} if not an UnbuiltTrope: In the original book the author wants you to think Erik's a {{Jerkass}} and Christine is a saint for putting up with him: (DomesticAbuser meets LoveMartyr), but the MisaimedFandom (and [[LostInImitation all the adaptations]]) wants you to think Erik's totally hot and the relationship is [[CorruptTheCutie deliciously kinky]].

to:

* BastardBoyfriend: Erik could be a {{deconstruction}} if not an UnbuiltTrope: In the original book the author wants you to think Erik's a {{Jerkass}} and Christine is a saint for putting up with him: (DomesticAbuser meets LoveMartyr), but the MisaimedFandom (and [[LostInImitation all some of the adaptations]]) wants you to think Erik's totally hot and the relationship is [[CorruptTheCutie deliciously kinky]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"And how!" and "Writ large!" are superlatives. They mean nothing.


* LoveAtFirstNote: Writ large!
* LoveHurts: And how!

to:

* LoveAtFirstNote: Writ large!
*
%%%* LoveAtFirstNote:
%%%*
LoveHurts: And how!



* UglyGuyHotWife: What would have been, had Erik carried through with his ultimate plan.

to:

* UglyGuyHotWife: What would have been, had Erik carried through with his ultimate plan.plan, given his deformities and Christine's beauty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheMoralSubstitute: Erik is DonGiovanni done right: While Don Giovanni (and all versions of the Don Juan legend) is TheCasanova who [[BastardBoyfriend never cared if he hurts the women he claims to love]] [[EnforcedTrope and is sent to hell at the finale of the opera only to please the]] MoralGuardians who insist that DonGiovanni must be punished so the audience [[DoNotDoThisCoolThing would not do this cool thing]], Erik (who is DonGiovanni's {{Fanboy}}) also plays BastardBoyfriend to Christine while claiming to love her, but after breaking Christine’s spirit and successfully blackmailing her into being her wife, let her go with Raoul ''by his own will'' after Christine gives Erik his first TrueLovesKiss.

to:

* TheMoralSubstitute: Erik is DonGiovanni Theatre/DonGiovanni done right: While Don Giovanni (and all versions of the Don Juan legend) is TheCasanova who [[BastardBoyfriend never cared if he hurts the women he claims to love]] [[EnforcedTrope and is sent to hell at the finale of the opera only to please the]] MoralGuardians who insist that DonGiovanni Don Giovanni must be punished so the audience [[DoNotDoThisCoolThing would not do this cool thing]], Erik (who is DonGiovanni's Don Giovanni's {{Fanboy}}) also plays BastardBoyfriend to Christine while claiming to love her, but after breaking Christine’s spirit and successfully blackmailing her into being her wife, let her go with Raoul ''by his own will'' after Christine gives Erik his first TrueLovesKiss.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CaptainObvious: Christine, when warning Raoul and the Persian: "You're inside the Torture Room! Get back the way you came from! There must be a reason for the room to be called like that!".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory: The story was inspired by an incident at the Palais Garnier opera house in 1893, where a counterweight from the chandelier fell through the ceiling and struck a concierge below, killing her instantly. Gaston Leroux, then a journalist, based the story's mystery elements on a theory that the tragedy was actually a failed murder plot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnAesop: Nobody is born inherently cruel, and people who are have most likely become so due to a traumatic past; however, even if there's a reason, it's still no excuse to be cruel.

Top