Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheGirlWhoOwnedACity

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheCaligula: Lisa, quite possibly. She shows an aversion to voting and sharing, at times seems to have a lack of empathy, and thinks everyone should be forced to fend for themselves and that this apocalyptic situation is ''fun'', and individuals like that usually grow into sociopathy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SequelHook: The liner notes said that O.T. Nelson was working on a sequel, but this never came to pass for fans. There was never any stated reason why, but [[http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Is_there_a_sequel_to_the_book_The_girl_who_owned_a_city_by_OT_nelson this entry on Answers.com]] says that the publisher said it didn't stand up to the original-though there are no references on the answer to check.

to:

* SequelHook: The liner notes said that O.T. Nelson was working on a sequel, but this never came to pass for fans. There was never any stated reason why, but [[http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Is_there_a_sequel_to_the_book_The_girl_who_owned_a_city_by_OT_nelson this entry on Answers.com]] says that the publisher said it didn't stand up to the original-though original, but there are no references on the answer to check.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheCaligula: Lisa, quite possibly. She has shown an aversion to voting and sharing, she at times seems to have a lack of empathy, and thinks everyone should be forced to fend for themselves and that this apocalyptic situation is ''fun'', and individuals like that usually grow into sociopathy.

to:

* TheCaligula: Lisa, quite possibly. She has shown shows an aversion to voting and sharing, she at times seems to have a lack of empathy, and thinks everyone should be forced to fend for themselves and that this apocalyptic situation is ''fun'', and individuals like that usually grow into sociopathy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A case could also be made for the fact that these are kids and kids are not exactly the world experts on property rights. Quite a few children in the age group of the characters in the book are firm believers in the Finders-Keepers Rule, as well as the Dibs Law and the No Take-Backs Accord. Add in the survival drive brought on by catastrophe and regardless of being made "older than they are" by the hardship, they're still going to hold to an [[JustifiedTrope understandably]] [[IncrediblyLamePun childish]] view on who gets what for which reasons.

to:

** A case could also be made for the fact that these are kids and kids are not don't exactly the world experts on have perfect knowledge of property rights. Quite a few children in the age group of the characters in the book are firm believers in the Finders-Keepers Rule, as well as the Dibs Law and the No Take-Backs Accord. Add in the survival drive brought on by catastrophe and regardless of being made "older than they are" by the hardship, they're still going to hold to an [[JustifiedTrope understandably]] [[IncrediblyLamePun childish]] view on who gets what for which reasons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Published in 1975, the book is still considered a popular choice for required reading in schools, due to the depth of characters and subject matter. It must be mentioned than many of the political themes have particular appeal for budding Objectivists, something the author was more than happy to provide.

to:

Published in 1975, the book is still considered a popular choice for required reading in schools, due to the depth of characters and subject matter. It must be mentioned than many of the political themes have particular appeal for budding Objectivists, [[UsefulNotes/{{Objectivism}} Objectivists]], something the author was more than happy to provide.



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cross wicking.



to:

* WorthlessCurrency: Lisa is gathering supplies from a store and notes that the cash register has been broken into and all the money removed. Since this is AfterTheEnd, the United States Government no longer exists, and so dollars are just fancy pieces of paper.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleted natter.


** [[ImprobableAge She read that at 12 years old?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NonResidentialResidence: The plot is about kids setting up residence in a school after the EndOfTheWorldAsWeKnowIt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

A post-apocalyptic sci-fi YA novel by O.T. Nelson.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseBiology: No disease that kills that fast, with a 100% fatality rate, could spread that quickly.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseBiology: No disease that kills that fast, with a 100% fatality mortality rate, could spread that quickly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
X Meets Y isn't supposed to get crosswicks.


* XMeetsY: ''Literature/AtlasShrugged'' meets ''Literature/LordOfTheFlies''.

to:

* XMeetsY: ''Literature/AtlasShrugged'' meets ''Literature/LordOfTheFlies''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moved to trivia.


* UnderminedByReality: One of the examples Lisa gives for why it's a good idea for her as an individual to be an "owner" of a city is cities like that worked fine pre-crisis, specifically mentioning the Republic of Minerva... [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Minerva which didn't work out at all.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheNounWhoVerbed: The title.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenAesop - Lisa goes on a great deal about rightful ownership etc., but the fact remains that she is a scavenger.
** A case could easily be made that she believes ownership ends at death. After all, she's not at all hypocritical about not stealing supplies from the living (although it could be considered dubious that she's the only one owning the school when Jill, Craig, Steve, Charlie and Todd all claimed it along with her at the same time and indeed helped build the "city" as it was). The book would have made a better case if it acknowledged this point about only the living retaining their ownership rights, though... And of course, the fact that the main source of conflict is over a school building, presumably something paid for with tax money, and thus belonged to a public society which, even if dissolved, makes her only argument that she is the rightful the fact that she was there first.

to:

* BrokenAesop - BrokenAesop: Lisa goes on a great deal about rightful ownership etc., but the fact remains that she is a scavenger.
** A case could easily be made that she believes ownership ends at death. After all, she's not at all hypocritical about not stealing supplies from the living (although it could be considered dubious that she's the only one owning the school when Jill, Craig, Steve, Charlie and Todd all claimed it along with her at the same time and indeed helped build the "city" as it was). The book would have made a better case if it acknowledged this point about only the living retaining their ownership rights, though... And of course, the fact that the main source of conflict is over a school building, presumably something paid for with tax money, and thus belonged to a public society which, even if dissolved, makes her only argument that she is the rightful owner the fact that she was there first.



** However, since all the adults, who paid the taxes, have died, this might be considered now "up for grabs." That still doesn't mean an individual is capable of owning the entire school herself necessarily though...

to:

** However, since all the adults, adults who paid the taxes, taxes have died, this might be considered now "up for grabs." That still doesn't mean an individual is capable of owning the entire school herself necessarily though...



* TheComplainerIsAlwaysWrong - Everyone who isn't Lisa. Jill in particular.
* CosyCatastrophe - A world full of dead adults is surprisingly rot and disease free and, for the protagonist, apparently more fun than she's ever had before. It's also remarkably free of children injuring themselves, and the older children tasked with caring for infants and toddlers seem to be a little ''too'' responsible for their age.
* GreatBigBookOfEverything - Lisa is said to have gotten most of her ideas on what to do from "a great book." Said book is heavily implied to be ''Literature/AtlasShrugged.''

to:

* TheComplainerIsAlwaysWrong - TheComplainerIsAlwaysWrong: Everyone who isn't Lisa. Jill in particular.
* CosyCatastrophe - CosyCatastrophe: A world full of dead adults is surprisingly rot and disease free and, for the protagonist, apparently more fun than she's ever had before. It's also remarkably free of children injuring themselves, and the older children tasked with caring for infants and toddlers seem to be a little ''too'' responsible for their age.
* GreatBigBookOfEverything - GreatBigBookOfEverything: Lisa is said to have gotten most of her ideas on what to do from "a great book." Said book is heavily implied to be ''Literature/AtlasShrugged.''



* ImprobableWeaponUser - One of the children, afraid of hurting someone with an actual gun, suggests using fire extinguishers to scare people away.
* OnlyFatalToAdults - ThePlague
* SequelHook - The liner notes said that O.T. Nelson was working on a sequel, but this never came to pass for fans. There was never any stated reason why, but [[http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Is_there_a_sequel_to_the_book_The_girl_who_owned_a_city_by_OT_nelson this entry on Answers.com]] says that the publisher said it didn't stand up to the original - though there are no references on the answer to check.
* TalkingTheMonsterToDeath - Lisa literally scolds an enemy leader into surrender.
* ThereAreNoAdults - Literally.
* UnderminedByReality - One of the examples Lisa gives for why it's a good idea for her as an individual to be an "owner" of a city is cities like that worked fine pre-crisis, specifically mentioning the Republic of Minerva... [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Minerva which didn't work out at all.]]
* XMeetsY - ''Literature/AtlasShrugged'' meets ''Literature/LordOfTheFlies''.

to:

* ImprobableWeaponUser - ImprobableWeaponUser: One of the children, afraid of hurting someone with an actual gun, suggests using fire extinguishers to scare people away.
* OnlyFatalToAdults - ThePlague
OnlyFatalToAdults: ThePlague.
* SequelHook - SequelHook: The liner notes said that O.T. Nelson was working on a sequel, but this never came to pass for fans. There was never any stated reason why, but [[http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Is_there_a_sequel_to_the_book_The_girl_who_owned_a_city_by_OT_nelson this entry on Answers.com]] says that the publisher said it didn't stand up to the original - though original-though there are no references on the answer to check.
* TalkingTheMonsterToDeath - TalkingTheMonsterToDeath: Lisa literally scolds an enemy leader into surrender.
* ThereAreNoAdults - ThereAreNoAdults: Literally.
* UnderminedByReality - UnderminedByReality: One of the examples Lisa gives for why it's a good idea for her as an individual to be an "owner" of a city is cities like that worked fine pre-crisis, specifically mentioning the Republic of Minerva... [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Minerva which didn't work out at all.]]
* XMeetsY - XMeetsY: ''Literature/AtlasShrugged'' meets ''Literature/LordOfTheFlies''.

Added: 370

Changed: 30

Removed: 370

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheCaligula: Lisa, quite possibly. She has shown an aversion to voting and sharing, she at times seems to have a lack of empathy, and thinks everyone should be forced to fend for themselves and that this apocalyptic situation is ''fun'', and individuals like that usually grow into sociopathy.
* TheComplainerIsAlwaysWrong - Everyone who isn't Lisa. Jill in particular.



* TheCaligula: Lisa, quite possibly. She has shown an aversion to voting and sharing, she at times seems to have a lack of empathy, and thinks everyone should be forced to fend for themselves and that this apocalyptic situation is ''fun'', and individuals like that usually grow into sociopathy.
* TheComplainerIsAlwaysWrong - Everyone who isn't Lisa. Jill in particular.



* XMeetsY - AtlasShrugged meets LordOfTheFlies.

to:

* XMeetsY - AtlasShrugged ''Literature/AtlasShrugged'' meets LordOfTheFlies.
''Literature/LordOfTheFlies''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GreatBigBookOfEverything - Lisa is said to have gotten most of her ideas on what to do from "a great book." Said book is heavily implied to be ''AtlasShrugged.''

to:

* GreatBigBookOfEverything - Lisa is said to have gotten most of her ideas on what to do from "a great book." Said book is heavily implied to be ''AtlasShrugged.''Literature/AtlasShrugged.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Taking out Complaining About Shows You Dont Like. Most of that is already covered in the article.


Published in 1975, the book is still considered a popular choice for required reading in schools, despite the ridiculously {{Anvilicious}} plot and one-dimensional characters. It must be mentioned than many of the political themes have particular appeal for budding Objectivists, something the author was more than happy to provide.

to:

Published in 1975, the book is still considered a popular choice for required reading in schools, despite due to the ridiculously {{Anvilicious}} plot depth of characters and one-dimensional characters.subject matter. It must be mentioned than many of the political themes have particular appeal for budding Objectivists, something the author was more than happy to provide.

Changed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Published in 1975, the book is still considered a popular choice for required reading in schools, despite the lack of depth of characters and subject matter. It must be mentioned than many of the political themes have particular appeal for budding Objectivists, something the author was more than happy to provide.

to:

Published in 1975, the book is still considered a popular choice for required reading in schools, despite the lack of depth of characters ridiculously {{Anvilicious}} plot and subject matter.one-dimensional characters. It must be mentioned than many of the political themes have particular appeal for budding Objectivists, something the author was more than happy to provide.

Changed: 15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Published in 1975, the book is still considered a popular choice for required reading in schools, due to the depth of characters and subject matter. It must be mentioned than many of the political themes have particular appeal for budding Objectivists, something the author was more than happy to provide.

to:

Published in 1975, the book is still considered a popular choice for required reading in schools, due to despite the lack of depth of characters and subject matter. It must be mentioned than many of the political themes have particular appeal for budding Objectivists, something the author was more than happy to provide.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleted discussion under cosy catastrophe and improbable weapon use.


** Easily Truth In Fiction. Young children forced into hard times of any sort tend to be "older" than they really are out of simple necessity. When you're constantly worrying about whether or not the people you love will be able to feed themselves regularly, you simply don't have the luxury of being a typical boisterous youngster ignorant of the hardships of life and the need for responsibility to survive.



** This causes FridgeLogic when you know how fire extinguishers work and having that stuff sprayed at you would likely be much more debilitating and painful than a quick death from a bullet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** However, since all the adults, who paid the taxes, have died, this might be considered now "up for grabs." That still doesn't mean an individual is capable of owning the entire school herself necessarily though...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:304:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/GirlWhoOwnedCityBook_8820.jpg]]

When a plague sweeps through the world and kills off anyone over 12 years of age, the children of the world are left without anyone to care for them. So when young Lisa decides she's sick of scavenging for food and fearing the new young gangs that roam the area, she decides to unite the survivors and lead them back to the way things were, even though nothing will ever be the same.

Published in 1975, the book is still considered a popular choice for required reading in schools, due to the depth of characters and subject matter. It must be mentioned than many of the political themes have particular appeal for budding Objectivists, something the author was more than happy to provide.
----
!!This book contains examples of:

* ArtisticLicenseBiology: No disease that kills that fast, with a 100% fatality rate, could spread that quickly.
* BrokenAesop - Lisa goes on a great deal about rightful ownership etc., but the fact remains that she is a scavenger.
** A case could easily be made that she believes ownership ends at death. After all, she's not at all hypocritical about not stealing supplies from the living (although it could be considered dubious that she's the only one owning the school when Jill, Craig, Steve, Charlie and Todd all claimed it along with her at the same time and indeed helped build the "city" as it was). The book would have made a better case if it acknowledged this point about only the living retaining their ownership rights, though... And of course, the fact that the main source of conflict is over a school building, presumably something paid for with tax money, and thus belonged to a public society which, even if dissolved, makes her only argument that she is the rightful the fact that she was there first.
** A case could also be made for the fact that these are kids and kids are not exactly the world experts on property rights. Quite a few children in the age group of the characters in the book are firm believers in the Finders-Keepers Rule, as well as the Dibs Law and the No Take-Backs Accord. Add in the survival drive brought on by catastrophe and regardless of being made "older than they are" by the hardship, they're still going to hold to an [[JustifiedTrope understandably]] [[IncrediblyLamePun childish]] view on who gets what for which reasons.
* CosyCatastrophe - A world full of dead adults is surprisingly rot and disease free and, for the protagonist, apparently more fun than she's ever had before. It's also remarkably free of children injuring themselves, and the older children tasked with caring for infants and toddlers seem to be a little ''too'' responsible for their age.
** Easily Truth In Fiction. Young children forced into hard times of any sort tend to be "older" than they really are out of simple necessity. When you're constantly worrying about whether or not the people you love will be able to feed themselves regularly, you simply don't have the luxury of being a typical boisterous youngster ignorant of the hardships of life and the need for responsibility to survive.
* GreatBigBookOfEverything - Lisa is said to have gotten most of her ideas on what to do from "a great book." Said book is heavily implied to be ''AtlasShrugged.''
** [[ImprobableAge She read that at 12 years old?]]
* ImprobableWeaponUser - One of the children, afraid of hurting someone with an actual gun, suggests using fire extinguishers to scare people away.
** This causes FridgeLogic when you know how fire extinguishers work and having that stuff sprayed at you would likely be much more debilitating and painful than a quick death from a bullet.
* OnlyFatalToAdults - ThePlague
* SequelHook - The liner notes said that O.T. Nelson was working on a sequel, but this never came to pass for fans. There was never any stated reason why, but [[http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Is_there_a_sequel_to_the_book_The_girl_who_owned_a_city_by_OT_nelson this entry on Answers.com]] says that the publisher said it didn't stand up to the original - though there are no references on the answer to check.
* TalkingTheMonsterToDeath - Lisa literally scolds an enemy leader into surrender.
* TheCaligula: Lisa, quite possibly. She has shown an aversion to voting and sharing, she at times seems to have a lack of empathy, and thinks everyone should be forced to fend for themselves and that this apocalyptic situation is ''fun'', and individuals like that usually grow into sociopathy.
* TheComplainerIsAlwaysWrong - Everyone who isn't Lisa. Jill in particular.
* ThereAreNoAdults - Literally.
* UnderminedByReality - One of the examples Lisa gives for why it's a good idea for her as an individual to be an "owner" of a city is cities like that worked fine pre-crisis, specifically mentioning the Republic of Minerva... [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Minerva which didn't work out at all.]]
* XMeetsY - AtlasShrugged meets LordOfTheFlies.

----

Top