Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / NinetyThree

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Ninety-Three''' (''Quatrevingt-treize'') is the last novel by Creator/VictorHugo, published in 1874. The setting is the year 1793 of UsefulNotes/TheFrenchRevolution, which means the ReignOfTerror, and especially the War in the Vendée, a peasant uprising leading a royalist and pro-Church counterrevolution violently repressed by the Republic.

to:

'''Ninety-Three'''
''Ninety-Three''
(''Quatrevingt-treize'') is the last novel by Creator/VictorHugo, published in 1874. The setting is the year 1793 of UsefulNotes/TheFrenchRevolution, which means the ReignOfTerror, and especially the War in the Vendée, a peasant uprising leading a royalist and pro-Church counterrevolution violently repressed by the Republic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* GreyAndGrayMorality: The book despicts both royalists and republicans with sympathetic and ruthless characters, without really making one side look eviler than the other. It's flat-out stated Cimourdain and Lantenac [[NotSoDifferent are pretty much just as ruthless as each others]], and [[VillainHasAPoint Lantenac's final speech does raise many good points about the Revolution]].

to:

* GreyAndGrayMorality: The book despicts both royalists and republicans with sympathetic and ruthless characters, without really making one side look eviler than the other. It's flat-out stated Cimourdain and Lantenac [[NotSoDifferent [[NotSoDifferentRemark are pretty much just as ruthless as each others]], and [[VillainHasAPoint Lantenac's final speech does raise many good points about the Revolution]].

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ZeroPercentApprovalRating: Played for laugh. At one point in the book, Marat approaches two of his friends, one who is former aristocrat and the other a former priest, and asks their help to make sure a new law will be instaured. They both complain that nobody will listen to them, since they respectively are a noble and a priest. Marat's answer?

to:

* ZeroPercentApprovalRating: Played for laugh. At one point in the book, Marat approaches two of his friends, one who is former aristocrat and the other a former priest, and asks their help to make sure a new law will be instaured. They both complain that nobody will listen to them, since they respectively are a noble and a priest. Marat's answer?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InfantImmortality: [[spoiler:played straight]].

to:

* InfantImmortality: ImprobableInfantSurvival: [[spoiler:played straight]].

Added: 617

Removed: 617

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoodRepublicEvilEmpire: Discussed at the end of the novel, in the conversation between Cimourdain and Gauvain. Gauvain, being TheIdealist, chooses to take his execution with honor in the name of the good republic he holds dear, while Cimourdain defends the PeoplesRepublicOfTyranny. The discussion is also a juxtaposition between RousseauWasRight and HobbesWasRight.
* GracefulLoser: Lantenac surrenders without a fight when Cimourdin arrests him, even approving his action.
->— Je t'arrête, dit Cimourdain. (''“I arrest you,” said Cimourdain.'')
->— Je t'approuve, dit Lantenac. (''“I approve you,” said Lantenac.'')



* GoodRepublicEvilEmpire: Discussed at the end of the novel, in the conversation between Cimourdain and Gauvain. Gauvain, being TheIdealist, chooses to take his execution with honor in the name of the good republic he holds dear, while Cimourdain defends the PeoplesRepublicOfTyranny. The discussion is also a juxtaposition between RousseauWasRight and HobbesWasRight.
* GracefulLoser: Lantenac surrenders without a fight when Cimourdin arrests him, even approving his action.
->— Je t'arrête, dit Cimourdain. (''“I arrest you,” said Cimourdain.'')
->— Je t'approuve, dit Lantenac. (''“I approve you,” said Lantenac.'')

Added: 4

Changed: 741

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added image.


''Ninety-Three'' (''Quatrevingt-treize'') is the last novel by Creator/VictorHugo, published in 1874. The setting is the year 1793 of UsefulNotes/TheFrenchRevolution, which means the ReignOfTerror, and especially the War in the Vendée, a peasant uprising leading a royalist and pro-Church counterrevolution violently repressed by the Republic.

to:

''Ninety-Three'' [[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/ninety_three_hugo.png]]
'''Ninety-Three'''
(''Quatrevingt-treize'') is the last novel by Creator/VictorHugo, published in 1874. The setting is the year 1793 of UsefulNotes/TheFrenchRevolution, which means the ReignOfTerror, and especially the War in the Vendée, a peasant uprising leading a royalist and pro-Church counterrevolution violently repressed by the Republic.



* YouHaveFailedMe: A surprisingly more complex case than the usual villainous application of this trope. Lantenac has one of the sailors on his ship executed for committing a mistake when taking care of a cannon, but he actually gives a pretty good reason for his decision. The sailor's mistake caused an accident leading to the death of several of his comrads, which then left the ship defenseless against the enemy, forcing what remained of them to sacrifice themselves so Lantenac could reach France. Even the sailor's brother, after being pointed that out by Lantenac, admits he was in the right to punish him.

to:

* YouHaveFailedMe: A surprisingly more complex case than the usual villainous application of this trope. Lantenac has one of the sailors on his ship executed for committing a mistake when taking care of a cannon, but he actually gives a pretty good reason for his decision. The sailor's mistake caused an accident leading to the death of several of his comrads, which then left the ship defenseless against the enemy, forcing what remained of them to sacrifice themselves so Lantenac could reach France. Even the sailor's brother, after being pointed that out by Lantenac, admits he was in the right to punish him.him.
----


* IDieFree: Played straight by Gauvain, making his own death a CrowningMomentOfAwesome by shouting "Vive La Republique" (long live the Republic) before he is executed.

to:

* IDieFree: Played straight by Gauvain, making his own death a CrowningMomentOfAwesome by shouting "Vive La Republique" (long live the Republic) before he is executed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TokenEnemyMinority: While the revolutionary heroes are French, most of the peasant army the fight consists of Bretons. This was TruthInTelevision, but the author seems to have ''some'' problems with his leanings towards flat out racism on the subject. He tries to even the score though.

to:

* TokenEnemyMinority: While the revolutionary heroes are French, most of the peasant army the they fight consists of Bretons. This was TruthInTelevision, but the author seems to have ''some'' problems with his leanings towards flat out flat-out racism on when he touches the subject. He tries to even the score though.

Added: 289

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BoisterousBruiser: The "Redcaps" (who presents themselves at the very beginning). Most prominently their leader, a seargent who turns out to be a OneManArmy and wisecracker of proportions.

to:

* BoisterousBruiser: The "Redcaps" (who presents themselves at the very beginning). Most prominently their leader, leader Radoub, a seargent who turns out to be a OneManArmy and wisecracker of proportions.


Added DiffLines:

* TokenEnemyMinority: While the revolutionary heroes are French, most of the peasant army the fight consists of Bretons. This was TruthInTelevision, but the author seems to have ''some'' problems with his leanings towards flat out racism on the subject. He tries to even the score though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BoisterousBruiser: The "Redcaps" (who presents themselves at the very beginning). Most prominently their leader, a seargent who turns out to be a LoneFighter and wisecracker of proportions.

to:

* BoisterousBruiser: The "Redcaps" (who presents themselves at the very beginning). Most prominently their leader, a seargent who turns out to be a LoneFighter OneManArmy and wisecracker of proportions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BoisterousBruiser: The "Redcaps" (who presents themselves at the very beginning). Most prominently their leader, a seargent who turns out to be a LoneFighter and wisecracker of proportions.


Added DiffLines:

* ComicallyMissingThePoint: Michelle Fléchard at the beginning of the novel, when she is surrounded by a company of revolutionaries, interrogating her on whether she is of the white or the blue: "Now I understand; You are French, I am Breton!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
misuse.


* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: a lot of them, often in WallOfText, sometimes bordering on HannibalLecture.

to:

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: a lot of them, often in WallOfText, sometimes bordering on HannibalLecture.and all about someone's flaws.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GracefulLoser:

to:

* GracefulLoser:GracefulLoser: Lantenac surrenders without a fight when Cimourdin arrests him, even approving his action.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This only happens once, and he is shown to be reluctant at least once; in fact, this very quote has him protesting against the guy sacrificing himself to help him escape.


* {{Hypocrite}}: Lantenac, for all his talk of the honor of old-school nobility, has a habit of letting people sacrifice themselves to let him escape.
-->—Je le sais, nous avons chacun un devoir différent. (''“I know it, we have both a different duty.”'')
-->—Non, monseigneur, nous avons, vous et moi, le même devoir, qui est de vous sauver. (''“No, my lord, we have, you and I, the same duty, which is to save you.”'')
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Ninety-Three'' (''Quatrevingt-treize'') is the last novel by VictorHugo, published in 1874. The setting is the year 1793 of UsefulNotes/TheFrenchRevolution, which means the ReignOfTerror, and especially the War in the Vendée, a peasant uprising leading a royalist and pro-Church counterrevolution violently repressed by the Republic.

to:

''Ninety-Three'' (''Quatrevingt-treize'') is the last novel by VictorHugo, Creator/VictorHugo, published in 1874. The setting is the year 1793 of UsefulNotes/TheFrenchRevolution, which means the ReignOfTerror, and especially the War in the Vendée, a peasant uprising leading a royalist and pro-Church counterrevolution violently repressed by the Republic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricaHeroUpgrade: ''Averted'', which was quite a rarity for the time of its publication; neither of the two sides get romanticized, and both Republican and Vendeeans get their share of atrocities and sympathetic sides.

to:

* HistoricaHeroUpgrade: HistoricalHeroUpgrade: ''Averted'', which was quite a rarity for the time of its publication; neither of the two sides get romanticized, and both Republican and Vendeeans get their share of atrocities and sympathetic sides.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HistoricaHeroUpgrade: ''Averted'', which was quite a rarity for the time of its publication; neither of the two sides get romanticized, and both Republican and Vendeeans get their share of atrocities and sympathetic sides.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ZeroPercentApprovalRating: Played for laugh. At one point in the book, Marat approaches two of his friends, one who is former aristocrat and the other a former priest, and asks their help to make sure a new law will be instaured. They both complain that nobody will listen to them, since they respectively are a noble and a priest. Marat's answer?
-->"And nobody will listen to me, I am Marat."



* YouHaveFailedMe: A surprisingly more complex case than the usual villainous application of this trope. Lantenac has one of the sailors on his ship executed for committing a mistake when taking care of a cannon, but he actually gives a pretty good reason for his decision. The sailor's mistake caused an accident leading to the death of several of his comrads, which then left the ship defenseless against the enemy, forcing what remained of them to sacrifice themselves so Lantenac could reach France. Even the sailor's brother, after being pointed that out by Lantenac, admits he was in the right to punish him.

to:

* YouHaveFailedMe: A surprisingly more complex case than the usual villainous application of this trope. Lantenac has one of the sailors on his ship executed for committing a mistake when taking care of a cannon, but he actually gives a pretty good reason for his decision. The sailor's mistake caused an accident leading to the death of several of his comrads, which then left the ship defenseless against the enemy, forcing what remained of them to sacrifice themselves so Lantenac could reach France. Even the sailor's brother, after being pointed that out by Lantenac, admits he was in the right to punish him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MagneticHero: Gauvain is so beloved by his own soldiers they [[spoiler:practically beg Cimourdain to not execute him at the end.]]
** Unless you consider him a villain, Lantenac counts as well; the number of his men willing to sacrifice themselves for him is spectacular.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MoralityPet: Gauvain to Cimourdain, to the point nobody expected [[spoiler:the latter to have the former executed for helping Lantenac escape]]. In the end, [[spoiler:Cimourdain shoots himself when Gauvain dies.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GreyAndGrayMorality: The book despicts both royalists and republicans with sympathetic and ruthless characters, without really making one side look eviler than the other. It's flat-out stated Cimourdain and Lantenac [[NotSoDifferent are pretty much just as ruthless as each others]], and [[VillainHasAPoint Lantenac's final speech does raise many good points about the Revolution]].

Added: 1293

Changed: -46

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AntiVillain: Lantenac is a ruthless man who doesn't hesitate to [[YouHaveFailedMe punish people's incompetence with death]] and have women executed. However, his ruthlessness is motivated by a devotion to the royalist cause rather than cruelty, and he draws the lines at harming children, [[spoiler:even willingly letting himself arrested to save them.]]



-> — Je le sais, nous avons chacun un devoir différent. (''“I know it, we have both a different duty.”'')
-> — Non, monseigneur, nous avons, vous et moi, le même devoir, qui est de vous sauver. (''“No, my lord, we have, you and I, the same duty, which is to save you.”'')

to:

-> — Je -->—Je le sais, nous avons chacun un devoir différent. (''“I know it, we have both a different duty.”'')
-> — Non, -->—Non, monseigneur, nous avons, vous et moi, le même devoir, qui est de vous sauver. (''“No, my lord, we have, you and I, the same duty, which is to save you.”'')



-> — Je t'arrête, dit Cimourdain. (''“I arrest you,” said Cimourdain.'')
-> — Je t'approuve, dit Lantenac. (''“I approve you,” said Lantenac.'')

to:

-> — ->— Je t'arrête, dit Cimourdain. (''“I arrest you,” said Cimourdain.'')
-> — ->— Je t'approuve, dit Lantenac. (''“I approve you,” said Lantenac.'')


Added DiffLines:

* TheMentor: Cimourdain is this to Gauvain.


Added DiffLines:

* ShadowArchetype: Lantenac and Cimourdain are both this to each others; it's outright stated the only real difference between them is that they defend opposite causes.


Added DiffLines:

* TakingTheBullet: Cimourdain does this for Gauvain when they first are reunited. He survives the shot, however.


Added DiffLines:

* YouHaveFailedMe: A surprisingly more complex case than the usual villainous application of this trope. Lantenac has one of the sailors on his ship executed for committing a mistake when taking care of a cannon, but he actually gives a pretty good reason for his decision. The sailor's mistake caused an accident leading to the death of several of his comrads, which then left the ship defenseless against the enemy, forcing what remained of them to sacrifice themselves so Lantenac could reach France. Even the sailor's brother, after being pointed that out by Lantenac, admits he was in the right to punish him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Interesting note: Creator/AynRand wrote an introduction to one of the editions to this novel. This intro was later included in her ''Romantic Manifesto''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Ninety-Three'' (''Quatrevingt-treize'') is the last novel by VictorHugo, published in 1874. The setting is the year 1793 of TheFrenchRevolution, which means the ReignOfTerror, and especially the War in the Vendée, a peasant uprising leading a royalist and pro-Church counterrevolution violently repressed by the Republic.

to:

''Ninety-Three'' (''Quatrevingt-treize'') is the last novel by VictorHugo, published in 1874. The setting is the year 1793 of TheFrenchRevolution, UsefulNotes/TheFrenchRevolution, which means the ReignOfTerror, and especially the War in the Vendée, a peasant uprising leading a royalist and pro-Church counterrevolution violently repressed by the Republic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IDieFree: Played straight by Gauvain, making his own death a CrowningMomentOfAwesome by shouting "Vive La Republique" (long live the Republic) before he is executed.


Added DiffLines:

* GoodRepublicEvilEmpire: Discussed at the end of the novel, in the conversation between Cimourdain and Gauvain. Gauvain, being TheIdealist, chooses to take his execution with honor in the name of the good republic he holds dear, while Cimourdain defends the PeoplesRepublicOfTyranny. The discussion is also a juxtaposition between RousseauWasRight and HobbesWasRight.

Added: 76

Changed: 69

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeelRealization: Lantenac [[spoiler:deciding to save the children]].

to:

* HeelRealization: Lantenac [[spoiler:deciding to save the children]]. Gauvain, deciding to save Lantenac (because he saved said children).


Added DiffLines:

* OhCrap: Cimourdain when he finds Gauvain in the cell instead of Lantenac.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving off hyphenated title

Added DiffLines:

''Ninety-Three'' (''Quatrevingt-treize'') is the last novel by VictorHugo, published in 1874. The setting is the year 1793 of TheFrenchRevolution, which means the ReignOfTerror, and especially the War in the Vendée, a peasant uprising leading a royalist and pro-Church counterrevolution violently repressed by the Republic.

The story focuses on the Marquis de Lantenac, a nobleman from Brittany who fled to England and secretly comes to Vendée to take the lead of the uprising and prepare a British landing. On the side of the Revolution are Gauvain, a nobleman leading one of the armies sent by the Republic to quench the uprising, and Cimourdain, a former priest whose role is to keep a civilian (and non-noble) eye on Gauvain.

----

!This novel has examples of the following tropes:

* AuthorTract: this is a Victor Hugo novel, after all, but he can pull it off.
* ChekhovsGun: the ladder, [[spoiler:the secret escape route]].
* ColourCodedForYourConvenience: the royalists are “''les blancs''” (“the whites”) and the republicans are “''les bleus''” (“the blues”).
* {{Determinator}}: Michelle Fléchard, whose children have been taken hostage by Lantenac.
* DrivenToSuicide: [[spoiler:Cimourdain shoots himself in the heart at the exact moment his surrogate son is executed. On his own order.]]
* HeelRealization: Lantenac [[spoiler:deciding to save the children]].
* {{Hypocrite}}: Lantenac, for all his talk of the honor of old-school nobility, has a habit of letting people sacrifice themselves to let him escape.
-> — Je le sais, nous avons chacun un devoir différent. (''“I know it, we have both a different duty.”'')
-> — Non, monseigneur, nous avons, vous et moi, le même devoir, qui est de vous sauver. (''“No, my lord, we have, you and I, the same duty, which is to save you.”'')
* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Danton, Robespierre and Marat.
* InfantImmortality: [[spoiler:played straight]].
* GracefulLoser:
-> — Je t'arrête, dit Cimourdain. (''“I arrest you,” said Cimourdain.'')
-> — Je t'approuve, dit Lantenac. (''“I approve you,” said Lantenac.'')
* LastStand: Lantenac and eighteen men in a stronghold against Gauvain and four and a half thousand soldiers.
** Also ''the Claymore'' facing the French navy while Lantenac escapes in a rowboat.
* MoreExpendableThanYou: how Lantenac's people consider themselves.
* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: Tellmarch, upon realizing the man he saved the day before (on the condition that he ''did not come to do evil'') just ordered a whole town torched and women shot down.
-> — Si j'avais su ! (''“If only I knew!”'')
* OffWithHisHead: a ''lot'' of talk of [[PublicExecution guillotining people]], which is TruthInTelevision, but it only actually happens once, in the very last page.
* RagtagBunchOfMisfits: most soldiers have no shoes.
* ShotAtDawn: both sides have mostly stopped taking prisoners. And a guillotine is too bulky.
* TalkingIsAFreeAction: Radoub has plenty of time for insulting Chante-en-hiver during the time Chante-en-hiver needs to aim a pistol at him from a few meters away.
* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: a lot of them, often in WallOfText, sometimes bordering on HannibalLecture.
* WellIntentionedExtremist: Lantenac for the royalty, Church and traditions, Cimourdain for the Republic and freedom of the people.

Top