Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* ArtisticLicenseBiology: Walruses eat fish and mollusks, not worms. It's never explained why the "wormones" for the transformation would be delivered in that form.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved from Characters/ page (was shared by both the mother and Zookeeper, not a characterisation trope)
Added DiffLines:
* WhatTheHellHero: The Zookeeper questions Johnny's mother for her willingness to value public opinion over the needs of her son after she nearly leaves Johnny at a Zoo to live as a Walrus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Deleted line(s) 14 (click to see context) :
* {{Allegory}}: The book is a very blatant one of gender transition, with people calling Matt's mother "phobic" if she doesn't let her child transition to a walrus. The medical doctor represents the medical community as a whole, which supports transition.
* {{Allegory}}: The book is a very blatant one of gender transition, with people calling Matt's mother "phobic" if she doesn't let her child transition to a walrus. The medical doctor represents the medical community as a whole, which supports transition.
* AmbiguouslyAbsentParent: Johnny's mother appears to be his only parent. His father is nowhere to be seen, but his whereabouts are never explained.
* AmbiguouslyAbsentParent: Johnny's mother appears to be his only parent. His father is nowhere to be seen, but his whereabouts are never explained.
Deleted line(s) 23 (click to see context) :
* DisappearedDad: Johnny's mother appears to be his only parent, his father is nowhere to be seen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Broken Aesop is now YMMV
Deleted line(s) 22 (click to see context) :
* BrokenAesop: Walsh's argument is supposed to be that children aren't mature enough to choose their own gender, but Johnny isn't the one who asks to be a walrus or genuinely believes himself to be one. In fact, he loudly complains about the transition process, something which would cause any trans healthcare specialist to immediately discontinue treatment. Furthermore, Johnny's in grade school, and while some trans kids do come out at a young age and start going by a new name and pronouns and might go on puberty blockers, they certainly aren't getting ''surgery''. In general, doctors don't approve of gender reassignment surgery or even hormones until the patient is a legal adult and can thus make a medically informed decision. None of this particularly matters in terms of the narrative the book is trying to convey (specifically the idea that being trans is itself the problem).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* CluelessAesop: The book is meant to be an allegory about why forcing kids to be trans is bad. But since it is a children's book, the book is forced to use a kid being forced to become a walrus as a metaphor. And since he cannot touch on how gender transitioning actually works, the book depicts the process as Johnny being forced to undergo cartoonishly ludicrous proceedures that are immediately reversed at the end. It's telling that when Matt Walsh read the book to a group of kids, they had absolutely no idea what Matt was talking about.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Restoring what looks like an attempt at whitewashing Matt Walsh's publicly known stance against trans' civil rights.
Changed line(s) 32 (click to see context) from:
* StrawmanU: The Doctor got a "Woke Doctor" degree from the "University of Doctoring".
to:
* StrawmanU: The Doctor got a "Woke Doctor" degree from the "University of Doctoring". This aligns with Walsh's belief that any sort of higher education amounts to liberal brainwashing.
Changed line(s) 36 (click to see context) from:
* WorldGoneMad: This is a world where doctors are trained to give surgeries to turn people into walruses, a procedure which activists support performing on minors.
to:
* WorldGoneMad: This is a world where doctors are trained to give surgeries to turn people into walruses, a procedure which activists support performing on minors.minors without their consent. The allegory being used suggests that to the author, a world in which trans people have rights is itself a World Gone Mad.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Matt Walsh is agaisnt the civil rights of trans people, such as their bodily autonomy, and is overall disrespectful to all trans people they address, so this is apropriate.
Added DiffLines:
* PropagandaPiece: This book is an introduction to transphobic rhetoric for kids, from a political pundit who is known for rallying against LGBT civil rights.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I don't believe he has ever rallied against civil rights, just argued against political ideas.
Deleted line(s) 29 (click to see context) :
* PropagandaPiece: This book is an introduction to transphobic rhetoric for kids, from a political pundit who is known for rallying against LGBT civil rights.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed biased claim
Changed line(s) 32 (click to see context) from:
* StrawmanU: The Doctor got a "Woke Doctor" degree from the "University of Doctoring". This aligns with Walsh's belief that any sort of higher education amounts to liberal brainwashing.
to:
* StrawmanU: The Doctor got a "Woke Doctor" degree from the "University of Doctoring". This aligns with Walsh's belief that any sort of higher education amounts to liberal brainwashing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed false and biased claim, since human rights are not the focus
Changed line(s) 36 (click to see context) from:
* WorldGoneMad: This is a world where doctors are trained to give surgeries to turn people into walruses, a procedure which activists support performing on minors without their consent. The allegory being used suggests that to the author, a world in which trans people have rights is itself a World Gone Mad.
to:
* WorldGoneMad: This is a world where doctors are trained to give surgeries to turn people into walruses, a procedure which activists support performing on minors without their consent. The allegory being used suggests that to the author, a world in which trans people have rights is itself a World Gone Mad.minors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 19,20 (click to see context) from:
** Johnny is not the one who wants to start walrus treatment, and is in fact extremely vocal about ''not'' wanting to do it from the get go. No trans healthcare is going to force a kid to start treatment when they are literally explicitly stating, from the very beginning, that they do not want to do it.
** Johnny goes on "wormones". Judging by how old he seems to be, Johnny would actually be much too young to even potentially start hormones, or even puberty blockers.
** Johnny goes on "wormones". Judging by how old he seems to be, Johnny would actually be much too young to even potentially start hormones, or even puberty blockers.
to:
** Johnny is not the one who wants to start walrus treatment, and is in fact extremely vocal about ''not'' wanting to do it from the get go.get-go. No trans healthcare is going to force a kid to start treatment when they are literally explicitly stating, from the very beginning, that they do not want to do it.
** Johnny goes on"wormones". "wormones" which are said to make whiskers grow. Judging by how old he seems to be, his prepubescent appearance and childish behavior, Johnny would actually be much too young to even potentially start hormones, or even puberty blockers.blockers (which are obviously only taken when puberty starts).
** Johnny goes on
Changed line(s) 30 (click to see context) from:
* ScareCampaign: The book makes a distinct attempt to depict gender affirming treatment as scary and nonconsensual. One can draw parallels between the “Woke Doctor” trying to amputate Johnny’s legs to the canard of referring to GRS as “mutilation”.
to:
* ScareCampaign: The book makes a distinct attempt to depict gender affirming treatment as something scary and nonconsensual. that's forced upon children against their will. One can draw parallels between the “Woke Doctor” "Woke Doctor" trying to amputate Johnny’s Johnny's legs to the canard of referring to GRS gender-affirming surgery as “mutilation”. "mutilation".
Changed line(s) 32,33 (click to see context) from:
* StrawmanU: The Doctor got a "Woke Doctor" degree from the "University of Doctoring". This aligns with Walsh’s belief that any sort of higher education amounts to liberal brainwashing.
* ScareEmStraight: [[LiteralMetaphor Or “Scare ‘em Cisgender”, anyway.]]
* ScareEmStraight: [[LiteralMetaphor Or “Scare ‘em Cisgender”, anyway.]]
to:
* StrawmanU: The Doctor got a "Woke Doctor" degree from the "University of Doctoring". This aligns with Walsh’s Walsh's belief that any sort of higher education amounts to liberal brainwashing.
* ScareEmStraight:[[LiteralMetaphor Or “Scare ‘em Cisgender”, anyway.]]"[[LiteralMetaphor Scare 'em Cisgender]]", anyway. The book tries to warn readers about the harm of gender transition (using species transition as a metaphor).
* ScareEmStraight:
Changed line(s) 36 (click to see context) from:
* WorldGoneMad: This is a world where doctors are trained to give surgeries to turn people into walruses, and is overall supported by activists. The allegory being used suggests that a world in which trans people have rights is itself a BizarroWorld.
to:
* WorldGoneMad: This is a world where doctors are trained to give surgeries to turn people into walruses, and is overall supported by activists. a procedure which activists support performing on minors without their consent. The allegory being used suggests that to the author, a world in which trans people have rights is itself a BizarroWorld.World Gone Mad.
----
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 22 (click to see context) from:
* BrokenAesop: Walsh's argument is supposed to be that children aren't mature enough to choose their own gender, but Johnny isn't the one who asks to be a walrus or genuinely believes himself to be one. In fact, he loudly complains about the transition process, something which would cause any trans healthcare specialist to immediately discontinue treatment. This doesn’t particularly matter in terms of the narrative the book is trying to convey (specifically the idea that being trans is itself the problem).
to:
* BrokenAesop: Walsh's argument is supposed to be that children aren't mature enough to choose their own gender, but Johnny isn't the one who asks to be a walrus or genuinely believes himself to be one. In fact, he loudly complains about the transition process, something which would cause any trans healthcare specialist to immediately discontinue treatment. This doesn’t Furthermore, Johnny's in grade school, and while some trans kids do come out at a young age and start going by a new name and pronouns and might go on puberty blockers, they certainly aren't getting ''surgery''. In general, doctors don't approve of gender reassignment surgery or even hormones until the patient is a legal adult and can thus make a medically informed decision. None of this particularly matter matters in terms of the narrative the book is trying to convey (specifically the idea that being trans is itself the problem).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleted as per ROCEJ thread, for the second time. Please don't add it back without discussion
Changed line(s) 3,4 (click to see context) from:
''Johnny the Walrus'' is a [[PictureBooks Picture Book]] written by conservative political commentator and self-proclaimed theocratic fascist Matt Walsh, and illustrated by K. Reese.
to:
''Johnny the Walrus'' is a [[PictureBooks Picture Book]] written by conservative political commentator and self-proclaimed theocratic fascist Matt Walsh, Walsh and illustrated by K. Reese.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3,4 (click to see context) from:
''Johnny the Walrus'' is a [[PictureBooks Picture Book]] written by conservative political commentator Matt Walsh and illustrated by K. Reese.
to:
''Johnny the Walrus'' is a [[PictureBooks Picture Book]] written by conservative political commentator and self-proclaimed theocratic fascist Matt Walsh Walsh, and illustrated by K. Reese.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 18,19 (click to see context) from:
* ArtisitcLicenseMedicine:
** Johnny is not the one who wants to start walrus treatment, and is in fact extremely vocal about ''not'' wanting to do it from the get go. No trans healthcare is going to force a kid to start treatment when they are literally explicitly stating they do not want to do it.
** Johnny is not the one who wants to start walrus treatment, and is in fact extremely vocal about ''not'' wanting to do it from the get go. No trans healthcare is going to force a kid to start treatment when they are literally explicitly stating they do not want to do it.
to:
* ArtisitcLicenseMedicine:
ArtisticLicenseMedicine:
** Johnny is not the one who wants to start walrus treatment, and is in fact extremely vocal about ''not'' wanting to do it from the get go. No trans healthcare is going to force a kid to start treatment when they are literally explicitlystating stating, from the very beginning, that they do not want to do it.
** Johnny is not the one who wants to start walrus treatment, and is in fact extremely vocal about ''not'' wanting to do it from the get go. No trans healthcare is going to force a kid to start treatment when they are literally explicitly
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* ArtisitcLicenseMedicine:
** Johnny is not the one who wants to start walrus treatment, and is in fact extremely vocal about ''not'' wanting to do it from the get go. No trans healthcare is going to force a kid to start treatment when they are literally explicitly stating they do not want to do it.
** Johnny goes on "wormones". Judging by how old he seems to be, Johnny would actually be much too young to even potentially start hormones, or even puberty blockers.
** Johnny is not the one who wants to start walrus treatment, and is in fact extremely vocal about ''not'' wanting to do it from the get go. No trans healthcare is going to force a kid to start treatment when they are literally explicitly stating they do not want to do it.
** Johnny goes on "wormones". Judging by how old he seems to be, Johnny would actually be much too young to even potentially start hormones, or even puberty blockers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Changed line(s) 3,4 (click to see context) from:
''Johnny the Walrus'' is a work of transphobic propaganda in the form of a [[PictureBooks Picture Book]] written by conservative political commentator and self-avowed “theocratic fascist” Matt Walsh and illustrated by K. Reese.
to:
''Johnny the Walrus'' is a work of transphobic propaganda in the form of a [[PictureBooks Picture Book]] written by conservative political commentator and self-avowed “theocratic fascist” Matt Walsh and illustrated by K. Reese.
Changed line(s) 7,8 (click to see context) from:
The story is a not-so-subtle allegory for gender transition written by someone who both does not understand and staunchly opposes such treatment, as Matt Walsh claims it [[https://archive.ph/mi8jc should be banned for everyone of all ages]]. The book was written in response to progressive children's books Walsh disliked like ''C is for Consent'' and ''The [=GayBCs=]''.
to:
The story is a not-so-subtle allegory for gender transition written by someone who both does not understand and staunchly opposes such treatment, as Matt Walsh claims it [[https://archive.ph/mi8jc should be banned for everyone of all ages]]. The book was written in response to progressive children's books Walsh disliked like ''C is for Consent'' and ''The [=GayBCs=]''.
Changed line(s) 16 (click to see context) from:
** The book's intended lesson is "Don't force transgenderism on children who are too young to understand what it is and haven't really figured themselves out yet, and just let them be kids in their own way.".
to:
** The book's intended lesson is "Don't force transgenderism being transgender on children who are too young to understand what it is and haven't really figured themselves out yet, and just let them be kids in their own way.".
Changed line(s) 26 (click to see context) from:
* PropagandaPiece: This book is essentially an introduction to transphobic rhetoric for kids, from a political pundit who is known for rallying against LGBT civil rights.
to:
* PropagandaPiece: This book is essentially an introduction to transphobic rhetoric for kids, from a political pundit who is known for rallying against LGBT civil rights.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 29 (click to see context) from:
* StrawmanU: The Doctor got a "Woke Doctor" degree from the "University of Doctoring".
to:
* StrawmanU: The Doctor got a "Woke Doctor" degree from the "University of Doctoring". This aligns with Walsh’s belief that any sort of higher education amounts to liberal brainwashing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3,4 (click to see context) from:
''Johnny the Walrus'' is a work of transphobic propaganda in the form of a [[PictureBooks Picture Book]] written by conservative political commentator Matt Walsh and illustrated by K. Reese.
to:
''Johnny the Walrus'' is a work of transphobic propaganda in the form of a [[PictureBooks Picture Book]] written by conservative political commentator and self-avowed “theocratic fascist” Matt Walsh and illustrated by K. Reese.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3,4 (click to see context) from:
''Johnny the Walrus'' is a work of anti-trans rights propaganda in the form of a [[PictureBooks Picture Book]] written by conservative political commentator Matt Walsh and illustrated by K. Reese.
to:
''Johnny the Walrus'' is a work of anti-trans rights transphobic propaganda in the form of a [[PictureBooks Picture Book]] written by conservative political commentator Matt Walsh and illustrated by K. Reese.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 7,8 (click to see context) from:
The story is a not-so-subtle allegory for gender transition written by someone who opposes such treatment, as Matt Walsh claims it [[https://archive.ph/mi8jc should be banned for everyone of all ages]]. The book was written in response to progressive children's books Walsh disliked like ''C is for Consent'' and ''The [=GayBCs=]''.
to:
The story is a not-so-subtle allegory for gender transition written by someone who both does not understand and staunchly opposes such treatment, as Matt Walsh claims it [[https://archive.ph/mi8jc should be banned for everyone of all ages]]. The book was written in response to progressive children's books Walsh disliked like ''C is for Consent'' and ''The [=GayBCs=]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3,4 (click to see context) from:
''Johnny the Walrus'' is a [[PictureBooks Picture Book]] written by conservative political commentator Matt Walsh and illustrated by K. Reese.
to:
''Johnny the Walrus'' is a work of anti-trans rights propaganda in the form of a [[PictureBooks Picture Book]] written by conservative political commentator Matt Walsh and illustrated by K. Reese.