Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / HarryPotterAndThePhilosophersStone

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* RhymingWizardry: Subverted; Ron attempts a spell with a rhyming incantation (''"Sunshine, daisies, butter mellow, turn this stupid, fat rat yellow"''), but it has no effect. He thinks it may not even be a real spell, considering he learned it from his trickster brothers. It certainly doesn't follow the pattern of other spells in the series, which have short (one- or two-word) incantations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhatCliffHanger: As shown under WhamLine above, Chapter Sixteen ends with the reveal that the titular Stone's would-be thief isn't [[spoiler:Snape]] after all, but the much bigger reveal of who they ''actually'' are is saved for the start of the following chapter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Artistic License Chess has been created

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseChess: The chess scene makes it dubious if Creator/JKRowling had ever touched a chessboard in her life. For example, Ron at one point is said to take "one step forward", despite the fact that he is playing a knight (this error and some others were fixed in later reprintings).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WokenUpAtAnUngodlyHour: While on the run from the Hogwarts acceptance letters, [[AbusiveParents the Dursleys]] and Harry Potter were woken up by a knock at the hut door in the middle of the night. It was caused by [[GentleGiant Hagrid]] who was here to wish Harry a happy birthday and tell him that he's a wizard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There's a passing reference to an incident that occurred back when Harry was still attending Muggle school, and he "had to take a school report home to the Dursleys saying that he'd somehow turned his teacher's wig blue."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ObliviouslySuperpowered: Harry Potter himself turned out to be a somewhat extreme case. Given that his aunt and uncle were ObsessivelyNormal, he was raised to be normal and shouted at for even talking about anything remotely fantastical, so when Harry started showing signs of magic, he remained oblivious to it even in the face of increasingly ridiculous "accidents" - like flying/apparating onto the school roof in order to escape Dudley and trying to excuse it as the wind catching him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Unishment}}: Hermione decides to stop talking to Harry and Ron after a series of events nearly get the three of them (and Neville) killed one month into school. The boys consider the silence an improvement since they find her to be extremely grating.

to:

* {{Unishment}}: Hermione decides to stop talking to Harry and Ron after a series of events nearly get the three of them (and Neville) killed one month into school. The boys consider the silence an improvement since they find her to be extremely grating.annoying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Fingor}}: When Goyle attempts to steal Harry and Ron's food on the train to Hogwarts, Ron's rat Scabbers jumps on Goyle and bites his finger.

to:

* {{Fingor}}: {{Fingore}}: When Goyle attempts to steal Harry and Ron's food on the train to Hogwarts, Ron's rat Scabbers jumps on Goyle and bites his finger.

Added: 513

Changed: 2

Removed: 135

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alphabetization.


* ArtisticLicenceHistory: The first chapter takes place on Tuesday November 1, 1981. November 1 of that year was on a Saturday. Similarly, Harry's [=11th=] birthday, July 31 1991, is on a Tuesday (it was on a Wednesday in real life).



* {{Fingor}}: When Goyle attempts to steal Harry and Ron's food on the train to Hogwarts, Ron's rat Scabbers jumps on Goyle and bites his finger.



* TheGhost: Nicolas Flamel is mentioned on several occasions and he's tied to the Philosopher's Stone, but he never shows up in person.



* TheGhost: Nicolas Flamel is mentioned on several occasions and he's tied to the Philosopher's Stone, but he never shows up in person.



* MercyKill: When Hagrid goes into the Forbidden Forest to search for the wounded unicorn, he mentions that he might have to put it out of its misery if it’s hurt badly enough.

to:

* MercyKill: When Hagrid goes into the Forbidden Forest to search for the wounded unicorn, he mentions that he might have to put it out of its misery if it’s it's hurt badly enough.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MelancholyMoon: Risking the halls of the castle in the night, the way lit by moon light

to:

* MelancholyMoon: Risking the halls of the castle in the night, the way lit by moon lightlight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


JustForFun/{{The one|With}} that started it all.



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Expanding.

Added DiffLines:

JustForFun/{{The one|With}} that started it all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentalAthlete: Harry gets onto the Quidditch team by accidentally drawing his Head of House's attention to his flying skills -- but he wasn't trying out, he was just rescuing a dropped object before it smashed.

to:

* AccidentalAthlete: Harry gets onto the Quidditch team by accidentally drawing his Head of House's attention to his flying skills -- but he wasn't even trying out, he was just rescuing a dropped object before it smashed.



* AgonyOfTheFeet: When Harry reaches the Hogwarts express, he attempts to get his trunk on the train, but has no success, dropping it twice on his foot before Fred and George Weasley volunteer to help him.

to:

* AgonyOfTheFeet: When Harry reaches the Hogwarts express, Express, he attempts to get his trunk on the train, but has no success, dropping it twice on his foot before Fred and George Weasley volunteer to help him.



* CunningPeoplePlayPoker: [[GentleGiant Hagrid]] won a poker game against Professor Quarrel. The prize is a Norwegian Ridgeback egg. [[spoiler:Professor Quirrell gave Hagrid the egg just to get him in trouble since breeding dragons is illegal. Also he was possessed by [[BigBad Lord Voldemort]], a dark wizard who is cunning in every way.]]

to:

* CunningPeoplePlayPoker: [[GentleGiant Hagrid]] won a poker game against Professor Quarrel.[[spoiler:Professor Quirrell]]. The prize is a Norwegian Ridgeback egg. [[spoiler:Professor Quirrell gave Hagrid the egg just to get him in trouble since breeding dragons is illegal. Also he was possessed by [[BigBad Lord Voldemort]], a dark wizard who is cunning in every way.]]



** The school song, sung at the first dinner after Harry and the gang are Sorted, then never again[[note]]Except for the extended version of the ''[[Film/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire Goblet of Fire]]'' movie[[/note]].

to:

** The school song, sung at the first dinner after Harry and the gang are Sorted, then never again[[note]]Except again.[[note]]Except for the extended version of the ''[[Film/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire Goblet of Fire]]'' movie[[/note]].movie.[[/note]]



** Fred and George are introduced with a quick prank of [[TwinSwitch pretending to be the other]] on their mother, and then helping Harry with his trunk. This quickly sets them up as a pair of pranksters who love messing with people, but also very nice and kind-hearted guys.
** Severus Snape first appears when he's staring so hard at Harry that Harry believes ''he's'' the one hurting his scar, all because he wants to see Lily's eyes in Harry's face, and then, in his first speaking scene, he bullies Harry, Neville, and Hermione, showing that even though he loves Lily and will protect her son in her name even after her death, he won't be nice about it.

to:

** Fred and George are introduced with a quick prank of [[TwinSwitch pretending to be the each other]] on their mother, and then helping Harry with his trunk. This quickly sets them up as a pair of pranksters who love messing with people, but also very nice and kind-hearted guys.
** Severus Snape first appears when he's staring so hard at Harry that Harry believes ''he's'' the one hurting his scar, all because he wants to see Lily's eyes in Harry's face, and then, in his first speaking scene, he bullies Harry, Neville, and Hermione, showing that even [[spoiler:even though he loves Lily and will protect her son in her name even after her death, death]], he won't be nice about it.



* FluffyTheTerrible: Two examples, both kept as pets by Hagrid. The big, scary, three-headed dog guarding the Stone is named Fluffy, and he later acquires Norbert the dragon, who has a poisonous bite and the ability to breathe fire.

to:

* FluffyTheTerrible: Two examples, both kept as pets by Hagrid. The big, scary, three-headed dog guarding the Stone is named Fluffy, and he later acquires Norbert the dragon, who has a poisonous bite and the ability to can breathe fire.



** Just before the House Cup is awarded, Dumbeldore awards Gryffindor hundreds of points that allow them to overtake Slytherin.

to:

** Just before the House Cup is awarded, Dumbeldore Dumbledore awards Gryffindor hundreds of points that allow 170 points, allowing them to overtake Slytherin.



** Hagrid [[spoiler:takes Harry, Neville, Hermione and Malfoy into the Forbidden Forest to look for a Unicorn killer]] for detention. HarmfulToMinors does not begin to describe Hagrid. Then again, he didn't really know what to expect. Justified in-universe by Hagrid telling Malfoy that this is the sort of useful thing students do for detention instead of 'writing lines', which is later retconned as there are multiple cases of that punishment in the series.

to:

** Hagrid [[spoiler:takes Harry, Neville, Hermione and Malfoy into the Forbidden Forest to look for a Unicorn killer]] for detention. HarmfulToMinors does not begin to describe Hagrid. Then again, he didn't really know what to expect. Justified in-universe by Hagrid telling Malfoy that this is the sort of useful thing students do for detention instead of 'writing lines', "writing lines", which is later retconned as there are multiple cases of that punishment in the series.



* LooseLips: Trust Rubeus Hagrid with your life, trust him with your loved ones' lives, hell, trust him with underage children's lives, but for goodness' sake, ''don't trust him with your secrets''. To his credit, he recognizes this flaw and says "ItsAllMyFault" when he visits Harry in the hospital wing at the end of the book.

to:

* LooseLips: Trust Rubeus Hagrid with your life, trust him with your loved ones' lives, hell, trust him with underage children's lives, but for goodness' sake, ''don't trust him with your secrets''. To his credit, he recognizes this flaw and says "ItsAllMyFault" admits "[[ItsAllMyFault It's all—my—ruddy—fault!]]" when he visits Harry in the hospital wing at the end of the book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MarketBasedTitle: Retitled ''Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone'' for the American release as the publishers were concerned that children would be put off by the word "philosopher" in the title, and something more suggestive of magic would be more likely to inspire interest.

to:

* MarketBasedTitle: Retitled ''Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone'' for the American release as the publishers were concerned that children would be put off by the word "philosopher" in the title, and thought something more suggestive of magic would be more likely to inspire interest.

Added: 281

Changed: 16

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsGunman: Hagrid makes an offhand remark about getting the flying motorbike off Sirius Black, who otherwise doesn't appear. Sirius debuts properly and becomes a major character in [[Literature/HarryPotterAndThePrisonerOfAzkaban in the third book]].

to:

* ChekhovsGunman: Hagrid makes an offhand remark about getting the flying motorbike off Sirius Black, who otherwise doesn't appear. Sirius debuts properly and becomes a major character in [[Literature/HarryPotterAndThePrisonerOfAzkaban in the third book]].



* MarketBasedTitle: Retitled ''Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone'' for the American release as the publishers were concerned that children would be put off by the word "philosopher" in the title, and something more suggestive of magic would be more likely to inspire interest.



* MayItNeverHappenAgain: Professor Dumbledore had destroyed the Sorcerer's Stone so Lord Voldemort won't use it to become immortal.

to:

* MayItNeverHappenAgain: Professor Dumbledore had destroyed the Sorcerer's Philosopher's Stone so Lord Voldemort won't use it to become immortal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MayItNeverHappenAgain: Professor Dumbledore had destroyed the Sorcerer's Stone so Lord Voldemort won't use it to become immortal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The school song, sung at the first dinner after Harry and the gang are Sorted, then never again.

to:

** The school song, sung at the first dinner after Harry and the gang are Sorted, then never again.again[[note]]Except for the extended version of the ''[[Film/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire Goblet of Fire]]'' movie[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BewareTheNiceOnes

to:

* BewareTheNiceOnesBewareTheNiceOnes:

Added: 80

Changed: 318

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Hagrid is pretty cheerful when he arrives to collect Harry, even being amused by Vernon Dursley [[BullyingADragon threatening him with a gun]]. [[BerserkButton Then Vernon insults Albus Dumbledore]], calling him a "crackpot old fool".

to:

** Hagrid is pretty cheerful when he arrives to collect Harry, even being amused by Vernon Dursley [[BullyingADragon threatening him with a gun]]. [[BerserkButton Then Vernon insults Albus Dumbledore]], calling him a "crackpot old fool".fool", and Hagrid retaliates by jinxing Dudley.



* BigFriendlyDog: Hagrid keeps one named [[DeathbringerTheAdorable Fang.]]

to:

* BigFriendlyDog: Hagrid keeps one has a large boarhound named [[DeathbringerTheAdorable Fang.]]



* CunningPeoplePlayPoker: [[GentleGiant Hagrid]] won a poker game against Professor Quarrel. The prize is a Norwegian Ridgeback egg. [[spoiler:Professor Quarrel gave Hagrid the egg just to get him in trouble since breeding dragons is illegal. Also he was possessed by [[BigBad Lord Voldemort]], a dark wizard who is cunning in every way.]]

to:

* CunningPeoplePlayPoker: [[GentleGiant Hagrid]] won a poker game against Professor Quarrel. The prize is a Norwegian Ridgeback egg. [[spoiler:Professor Quarrel Quirrell gave Hagrid the egg just to get him in trouble since breeding dragons is illegal. Also he was possessed by [[BigBad Lord Voldemort]], a dark wizard who is cunning in every way.]]



* TheDogWasTheMastermind: [[spoiler:"Who would suspect poor, st-st-st-stuttering Professor Quirrell?"]]

to:

* TheDogWasTheMastermind: [[spoiler:"Who The person trying to get the Philospher's Stone turns out to be [[spoiler:a Voldemort-possessed Professor Quirrell]], who the book had established as being relatively harmless. When Harry confronts them at the end, they lampshade how they were BeneathSuspicion.
-->"Who
would suspect poor, st-st-st-stuttering [[spoiler:st-st-st-stuttering Professor Quirrell?"]]Quirrell]]?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ClothesForChristmasCringe:
** Molly knits sweaters for her children every year for Christmas. Ron complains that his is always maroon, and he hates that colour.
** Inverted by Professor Dumbledore who tells Harry that he wants socks for Christmas, but never gets any. "People will insist on giving me books."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PullingYourChildAway: Before Harry learned that he was a wizard, he once went shopping with his Aunt Petunia. When they encountered a witch and her child, Petunia ran out with Harry without buying everything because she's afraid of wizards and witches.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CunningPeoplePlayPoker: [[GentleGiant Hagrid]] won a poker game against Professor Quarrel. The prize is a Norwegian Ridgeback egg. [[spoiler:Professor Quarrel gave Hagrid the egg just to get him in trouble since breeding dragons is illegal. Also he was possessed by [[BigBad Lord Voldemort]], a dark wizard who is cunning in every way.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SecretPetPlot: Hagrid gets hold of a dragon egg and intends to keep the baby dragon as a pet, despite it being illegal to do so. Eventually, the logistical challenges, such as that the dragon's rapid growth will make it impossible to keep hidden, and that, as Hermione points out, keeping a fire-breathing creature in a wooden house is not the brightest idea, lead him to send the dragon to Ron's brother, Charlie, who works with dragons already.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Actually Accidentally Correct Writing, so moving to the trivia page.


* AluminumChristmasTrees: The American edition actually kept the line in about Harry wanting to buy as many Mars Bars as he could eat, even though this was referencing the European version (closer to what Americans call a Milky Way). However, at the time the book takes place ''and'' when it was printed, there was a candy bar called [[https://lerevdr.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/us-mars-bar.jpg?w=584 Mars]] available in the U.S.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BecomingTheBoast: Before the first flying lesson, Draco touts his skill at flying ''ad nauseam'' to everyone, especially Harry. Ron thinks he's exaggerating. On the day of the lesson, he shows that he isn't.

to:

* BecomingTheBoast: Before the first flying lesson, Draco touts his skill at flying ''ad nauseam'' to everyone, especially Harry. Ron thinks he's exaggerating. On the day of the lesson, he shows that he isn't.isn't (although Harry proves to be even better.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HoistByHisOwnPetard: The mountain troll is knocked out when Ron uses a spell to drop the troll's club onto its' owner's head.

to:

* HoistByHisOwnPetard: The mountain troll is knocked out when Ron uses a spell to drop the troll's club onto its' its owner's head.



** Harry and Hermione both inexplicably forget to put the invisibility cloak back on after delivering Norbert to Charlie's friends, landing them in detention. This mistake is especially out of character for the normally well-organised and reliable Hermione. Creator/JKRowling had them make this blunder in order to further the plot by having Harry encounter Voldemort in the Forbidden Forest.

to:

** Harry and Hermione both inexplicably forget to put the invisibility cloak back on after delivering Norbert to Charlie's friends, landing them in detention. This mistake is especially out of character for the normally well-organised and reliable Hermione. Creator/JKRowling Rowling had them make this blunder in order to further the plot by having Harry encounter Voldemort in the Forbidden Forest.



** Severus Snape: On the general scope, he gives obscenely unfair advantage to his own student house (Slytherin) at every opportunity, while ignoring their transgressions, while simultaneously jumping at any chance to punish students of other houses. [[ItsPersonal He even holds a special hatred for Harry]] because [[spoiler:his father saved his life.]]

to:

** Severus Snape: On the general scope, he gives obscenely unfair advantage to his own student house (Slytherin) at every opportunity, while ignoring their transgressions, transgressions while simultaneously jumping at any chance to punish students of other houses. [[ItsPersonal He even holds a special hatred for Harry]] because [[spoiler:his father [[NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished saved his life.]]]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* DieOrFly: Neville Longbottom. %%(Zero Context Example)%%
* DividedIntoDisaster: While doing work as punishment for getting caught late outside their dormitories, Harry, Hermione, Neville and Malfoy are sorted in two teams, with Neville and Malfoy (the latter bullying the former) in the same team.

to:

%%* DieOrFly: Neville Longbottom. %%(Zero Context %%(Zero-Context Example)%%
* DividedIntoDisaster: While doing work in the Forbidden Forest as punishment for getting caught late outside their dormitories, Harry, Hermione, Neville and Malfoy are sorted in two teams, with Neville and Malfoy (the latter bullying the former) in the same team.team. After Malfoy pranks Neville, Hagrid switches Neville and Harry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Some of [=McGonagall's=] early behaviour, such as reading a map in cat form openly long enough for Vernon to see her doing so, is very uncharacteristic for her in later books.

to:

** Some of [=McGonagall's=] early behaviour, such as reading a map in cat form openly long enough for Vernon to see her doing so, is very uncharacteristic for her in later books.books- and a little hypocritical, given she complains to Dumbledore only a few hours later that by flamboyantly celebrating Voldemort's demise, wizards are risking the exposure of their community.

Added: 489

Changed: 294

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added eg


* BrickJoke: Mrs. Weasley warns Fred and George not to blow up a toilet. They jokingly tell Ginny they'll send her a Hogwarts toilet seat. Fast-forward to the end, when Dumbledore says that the twins attempted to give Harry a toilet seat while Harry was out for three days, assuming it would make him laugh.

to:

* BrickJoke: BrickJoke:
** The second chapter, set on Dudley's birthday, mentions that Harry thinks his cousin looks like a pig in a wig. Flash forward to Harry's birthday, and Hagrid gives Dudley a literal pig tail.
**
Mrs. Weasley warns Fred and George not to blow up a toilet. They jokingly tell Ginny they'll send her a Hogwarts toilet seat. Fast-forward to the end, when Dumbledore says that the twins attempted to give Harry a toilet seat while Harry was out for three days, assuming it would make him laugh.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope's been disambig'd


* FriendlessBackground: Harry, Ron, and Hermione share this. Both Harry and Hermione knew nothing of magic for most of their respective lives hitherto, Hermione is also a HollywoodNerd, and Ron's family isn't prestigious.

to:

* FriendlessBackground: Harry, Ron, and Hermione share this. Both Harry and Hermione knew nothing of magic for most of their respective lives hitherto, Hermione is also a HollywoodNerd, nerd, and Ron's family isn't prestigious.

Top