Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / Bluebeard

Go To

OR

Changed: 105

Removed: 595

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
There is no good evidence that Bluebeard is in any way based on Gilles de Rais. Their only commonality is that they are both aristocratic serial killers. Only Bluebeard kills his wives; Gilles de Rais killed children. "Bluebeard" has far more similarity to the legend of Conomor, a 6th century Breton prince who is said to have murdered his wives. It's making big assumptions to call the legend of Conomor "a true story", though. There's no reason to believe that the tale of Bluebeard is "based on a true story".


* VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory:
** Some believe that the fairy tale has its origins in [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conomor Conomor the Cursed,]] known for murdering his wives as soon as they got pregnant.
** Bluebeard may also have been based on 15th century serial killer UsefulNotes/GillesDeRais (or de Retz). When you can say that an adaptation in which someone has a roomful of dead wives and a basin full of blood in their [[TortureCellar locked-away torture room]] is LighterAndSofter...
** Of course, there is also UsefulNotes/HenryVIII. ''Anime/GrimmsFairyTaleClassics'' lampshaded this.



* The Caster class of Servant in ''Literature/FateZero'' is UsefulNotes/GillesDeRais (the inspiration for the story), who refers to himself as Bluebeard.

to:

* The Caster class of Servant in ''Literature/FateZero'' is UsefulNotes/GillesDeRais (the inspiration for the story), who and refers to himself as Bluebeard.



* In the horror novel ''{{Literature/Dove Keeper}}'', the villain, UsefulNotes/GillesDeRais, is constantly compared to Bluebeard because of his crimes, which is appropriate, given that he likely inspired the fairy tale.

to:

* In the horror novel ''{{Literature/Dove Keeper}}'', the villain, UsefulNotes/GillesDeRais, is constantly compared to Bluebeard because of his crimes, which is appropriate, given that he likely inspired the fairy tale.crimes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bluebeard may also have been based on 15th century serial killer [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilles_de_Rais Gilles de Rais]] (or de Retz). When you can say that an adaptation in which someone has a roomful of dead wives and a basin full of blood in their [[TortureCellar locked-away torture room]] is LighterAndSofter...

to:

** Bluebeard may also have been based on 15th century serial killer [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilles_de_Rais Gilles de Rais]] UsefulNotes/GillesDeRais (or de Retz). When you can say that an adaptation in which someone has a roomful of dead wives and a basin full of blood in their [[TortureCellar locked-away torture room]] is LighterAndSofter...



* The Caster class of Servant in ''Literature/FateZero'' is Gilles de Rais (the inspiration for the story), who refers to himself as Bluebeard.

to:

* The Caster class of Servant in ''Literature/FateZero'' is Gilles de Rais UsefulNotes/GillesDeRais (the inspiration for the story), who refers to himself as Bluebeard.



* In the horror novel ''{{Literature/Dove Keeper}}'', the villain, Gilles de Rais, is constantly compared to Bluebeard because of his crimes, which is appropriate, given that he likely inspired the fairy tale.

to:

* In the horror novel ''{{Literature/Dove Keeper}}'', the villain, Gilles de Rais, UsefulNotes/GillesDeRais, is constantly compared to Bluebeard because of his crimes, which is appropriate, given that he likely inspired the fairy tale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RedRightHand: The antagonist's color of his facial hair is blue.

Added: 35

Changed: 418

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Russian folktale "The Cat with the Golden Tail" replaces Bluebeard with a ''bear'', who kidnaps girls and forces them to live in his house as his wife and housekeeper. He murders them for entering a forbidden storehouse with kegs of magic liquids (that can turn anything to gold, to silver, [[HealingSpring resurrect the dead]] or [[GrimyWater heal wounds but kill the patient]]). He also ends up storing the corpses next to kegs.[[note]] The third girl resurrects her sisters, tricks the bear into carrying them all home and arranges the accident that kills him.[[/note]]
* A Russian cartoon exists that toys with the story. Bluebeard's first wife was a dopey party girl who accidentally set herself on fire. The second wife was a snob who starved Bluebeard, and accidentally poisoned herself by eating a toadstool that Bluebeard was going to eat (believing it to be a mushroom). The third (and presumably final) bride was an adulteress and had her secret lover kill Bluebeard when he accidentally walked in on them (Bluebeard seems to have survived, however, as he is telling this to the narrator). Presumably, she made up the fairy tale to save face.

to:

* Russian folktale "The ''The Cat with the Golden Tail" Tail'' replaces Bluebeard with a ''bear'', who kidnaps girls and forces them to live in his house as his wife and housekeeper. He murders them for entering a forbidden storehouse with kegs of magic liquids (that can turn anything to gold, to silver, [[HealingSpring resurrect the dead]] or [[GrimyWater heal wounds but kill the patient]]). He also ends up storing the corpses next to kegs.[[note]] The third girl resurrects her sisters, tricks the bear into carrying them all home and arranges the accident that kills him.[[/note]]
* [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RtmrldwPVng A Russian cartoon cartoon]] exists that toys with the story. Bluebeard's story: Bluebeard tells everything to a modern detective. His first wife was a dopey party girl who girl, whom he accidentally set herself on fire. fire, stepping on her pet dragon's tail. The second wife was a snob snobbish health nut, who starved Bluebeard, Bluebeard and accidentally poisoned herself by eating a toadstool that Bluebeard was going to eat (believing it to be a mushroom). edible). The third (and presumably final) bride was an adulteress and adulteress, who had her secret lover kill Bluebeard when he accidentally walked in on them (Bluebeard seems to have survived, however, as he is telling this to the narrator).this). Presumably, she made up the fairy tale to save face. The weird thing was: before each death Bluebeard quickly grew an elbow-long blue beard. Then the detective's wife throws a jealous fit and ''the detective'' grows a blue beard bigger than his car.
-->Sorry, Love, it was an accident.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* VillainHasAPoint: The story does point out that it was wrong of Bluebeard's wives to break their promise to him, which is even treated as an aesop in some tellings. [[DisproportionateRetribution Not that it justifies murdering them]] or makes him any less of a monster.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"At first she saw nothing, for the windows were closed, but after a few moments she perceived dimly that the floor was entirely covered with clotted blood, and that in this there were reflected the dead bodies of several women that hung along the walls. These were all the wives of Blue Beard, whose throats he had cut, one after the other."''

to:

->''"At first she saw nothing, for the windows were closed, but after a few moments she perceived dimly that the floor was entirely covered with clotted blood, and that in this there were reflected the dead bodies of several women that hung along the walls. These were all the wives of Blue Beard, Bluebeard, whose throats he had cut, one after the other."''



** The text itself also makes it clear that the lady has a {{gut feeling}} that something is ''off'' about Blue Beard, but allows [[TheSociopath his courtly graces]] to convince her she should discard these instincts and marry him anyway. And when he first gives her the key, she has another {{gut feeling}} that something is ''wrong'', and she ''has ''to open the door to find out what it is. Doing so saves her life in the long run. The obvious moral seems to be, "Trust your instincts," yet the stated moral at the end seems to take the opposite view.

to:

** The text itself also makes it clear that the lady has a {{gut feeling}} that something is ''off'' about Blue Beard, Bluebeard, but allows [[TheSociopath his courtly graces]] to convince her she should discard these instincts and marry him anyway. And when he first gives her the key, she has another {{gut feeling}} that something is ''wrong'', and she ''has ''to open the door to find out what it is. Doing so saves her life in the long run. The obvious moral seems to be, "Trust your instincts," yet the stated moral at the end seems to take the opposite view.



* PeekABooCorpse: Several of them. This ''is'' the story of Blue Beard and the corpses of his many murdered wives in the closet.

to:

* PeekABooCorpse: Several of them. This ''is'' the story of Blue Beard Bluebeard and the corpses of his many murdered wives in the closet.



* TheSociopath: Implied. Blue Beard is superficially charming in public (known for his generosity and courtly graces), but behind closed doors he rather coldly and casually murders his many wives over the smallest disobediences or missteps, then stuffs their rotting corpses in a single room in the main manor in front of his next wife.

to:

* TheSociopath: Implied. Blue Beard Bluebard is superficially charming in public (known for his generosity and courtly graces), but behind closed doors he rather coldly and casually murders his many wives over the smallest disobediences or missteps, then stuffs their rotting corpses in a single room in the main manor in front of his next wife.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Bowdlerize}}: One version of the tale from the Indian comic "Tinkle Digest" changes Bluebeard's wives to his maids, and instead of being killed they are changed into statues. The main characters are sisters who are worried that their sister Elsa went missing after going to work for Bluebeard for a month; they decide to take the job to find out what happened to Elsa. Their older brother goes to get help from the army, and will arrive back in a month. He arrives just in same to save his little sisters, and when Bluebeard dies all of his statues turn back into normal women.

to:

* {{Bowdlerize}}: One version of the tale from the Indian comic "Tinkle Digest" changes Bluebeard's wives to his maids, and instead of being killed they are changed into statues. The main characters are sisters who are worried that their sister Elsa went missing after going to work for Bluebeard for a month; they decide to take the job to find out what happened to Elsa. Their older brother goes to get help from the army, and will arrive back in a month. He arrives just in same time to save his little sisters, and when Bluebeard dies all of his statues turn back into normal women.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigBad: Bluebeard, serial wife murderer extraordinaire.

to:

* BigBad: Bluebeard, The [[AntagonistTitle titular]] [[TheBluebeard Bluebeard]] turns out to be a serial wife murderer extraordinaire.and intends on making the protagonist his next victim.



* TheBluebeard: TropeNamer.

to:

* TheBluebeard: TropeNamer.TropeNamer, about the man who is discovered to have killed his previous wives for money and stuffed their bodies in his secret room.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The story ''The Bloody Chamber'' in British author Creator/AngelaCarter's fairy tale anthology of the same name is based on the story of Bluebeard, with the heroine's rescue coming at the hands of her [[MamaBear formidable mother]].

to:

* The story ''The Bloody Chamber'' ''Literature/TheBloodyChamber'' in British author Creator/AngelaCarter's fairy tale anthology of the same name is based on the story of Bluebeard, with the heroine's rescue coming at the hands of her [[MamaBear formidable mother]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''Mr. Fox'' has a recurring rhyme which acts as the Aesop of that version:
-->''Be bold, be bold, but not too bold,''
-->''Lest your heart’s blood should run cold''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Bowdlerize}}: One version of the tale from the Indian comic "Tinkle Digest" changes Bluebeard's wives to his maids, and instead of being killed they are changed into statues. The main characters are sisters who are worried that their sister Elsa went missing after going to work for Bluebueard for a month; they decide to take the job to find out what happened to Elsa. Their older brother goes to get help from the army, and will arrive back in a month. He arrives just in same to save his little sisters, and when Bluebeard dies all of his statues turn back into normal women.

to:

* {{Bowdlerize}}: One version of the tale from the Indian comic "Tinkle Digest" changes Bluebeard's wives to his maids, and instead of being killed they are changed into statues. The main characters are sisters who are worried that their sister Elsa went missing after going to work for Bluebueard Bluebeard for a month; they decide to take the job to find out what happened to Elsa. Their older brother goes to get help from the army, and will arrive back in a month. He arrives just in same to save his little sisters, and when Bluebeard dies all of his statues turn back into normal women.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Bowdlerize}}: One version of the tale from the Indian comic "Tinkle Digest" changes Bluebeard's wives to his maids, and instead of being killed they are changed into statues. The main characters are sisters who are worried that their sister Elsa went missing after going to work for Bluebueard for a month; they decide to take the job to find out what happened to Elsa. Their older brother goes to get help from the army, and will arrive back in a month. He arrives just in same to save his little sisters, and when Bluebeard dies all of his statues turn back into normal women.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The TabletopGame ''Bluebeard's Bride'' casts the players in the roles of the Bride's [[SplitPersonality fragmented personalities]] as she explores the castle's rooms and decides whether what she finds in them (which is typically horrific) increases or decreases her suspicions about her husband, which influences her ultimate fate when she reaches the room he forbade her to enter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheCavalry: The wife's brothers in Perrault's version. They arrive right in time to save her and kill Bluebeard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
not a trope


* UsefulNotes/VictimBlaming: Charles Perrault tries to paint the wife as being in the wrong for looking into the room. Though it's possible he was being [[SarcasmMode sarcastic]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VictimBlaming: Charles Perrault tries to paint the wife as being in the wrong for looking into the room. Though it's possible he was being [[SarcasmMode sarcastic]].

to:

* VictimBlaming: UsefulNotes/VictimBlaming: Charles Perrault tries to paint the wife as being in the wrong for looking into the room. Though it's possible he was being [[SarcasmMode sarcastic]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*In the horror novel ''{{Literature/Dove Keeper}}'', the villain, Gilles de Rais, is constantly compared to Bluebeard because of his crimes, which is appropriate, given that he likely inspired the fairy tale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In many versions, the key is a SecretTestOfCharacter that the wife inevitably fails. This gives Bluebeard the thin excuse of killing them because he can't trust them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Some versions of the text mentions that the wife invites friends over and is having a party when she goes down to the cellar and discovers Bluebeard's secret. During the climax the friends inexplicably disappear from the castle and don't appear in the story again despite the fact they were there when the wife went downstairs.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Some versions of the text mentions mention that the wife invites friends over and is having a party when she goes down to the cellar and discovers Bluebeard's secret. During the climax the friends inexplicably disappear from the castle and don't appear in the story again despite the fact they were there when the wife went downstairs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The text mentions that the wife invites friends over and is having a party when she goes down to the cellar and discovers Bluebeard's secret. During the climax the friends inexplicably disappear from the castle and don't appear in the story again despite the fact they were there when the wife went downstairs.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The Some versions of the text mentions that the wife invites friends over and is having a party when she goes down to the cellar and discovers Bluebeard's secret. During the climax the friends inexplicably disappear from the castle and don't appear in the story again despite the fact they were there when the wife went downstairs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In some versions, the wife discovers the secret room while throwing a party. So why doesn't she leave with her friends when they depart or at the very least ''tell them'' what she saw?

to:

** In some versions, the wife discovers the secret room while throwing a party. So why doesn't she leave with her friends when they depart or at the very least ''tell them'' what she saw?saw so they can send for help?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In some versions, the wife discovers the secret room while throwing a party. So why doesn't she leave with her friends when they depart or at the very least ''tell them'' what she saw?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RememberTheNewGuy: The wife's sister, Anne, randomly shows up at the castle during the climax to call for their brothers to comes rescue them despite the fact she was never mentioned previously in the story.

to:

* RememberTheNewGuy: The wife's sister, Anne, [[DeusExMachina randomly shows up at the castle during the climax to call for their brothers to comes rescue them them]] despite the fact she was never mentioned previously in the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RememberTheNewGuy: The wife's sister, Anne, randomly shows up at the castle during the climax to call for their brothers to comes rescue them despite the fact she was never mentioned previously in the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The text mentions that the wife invites friends over and is having a party when she goes down to the cellar and discovers Bluebeard's secret. During the climax the friends inexplicably disappear from the castle and don't appear in the story again despite the fact they were there when the wife went downstairs.

Added: 156

Removed: 156

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UglyGuyHotWife: Bluebeard's blue beard puts people off. But his wealth and apparent generosity keeps getting him young, beautiful wives from time to time.



* UglyGuyHotWife: Bluebeard's blue beard puts people off. But his wealth and apparent generosity keeps getting him young, beautiful wives from time to time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IdiotBall: Good lord, why would the murderer give his wife a ''key to the room that he's desperate to keep a secret?''

to:

* IdiotBall: Good lord, grief, why would the murderer give his wife a ''key to the room that he's desperate to keep a secret?''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[OffWithHisHead OffWithHerHead]]: In some versions of the story, the wife doesn't find the ''bodies'' of her predecessors, but only their [[DecapitationPresentation severed heads]], all lined up in the cupboard.

to:

* [[OffWithHisHead OffWithHerHead]]: Off With Her Head!]]: In some versions of the story, the wife doesn't find the ''bodies'' of her predecessors, but only their [[DecapitationPresentation severed heads]], all lined up in the cupboard.

Added: 899

Changed: 640

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InterplayOfSexAndViolence: In some versions, instead of the wife's making increasingly feeble pleas for Bluebeard to hold off murdering her a little longer (and his inexplicably granting her a respite each time long enough for the DeusExMachina to occur), the tale has the more clever device of having her ask him to wait while she puts on various parts of her wedding dress. Due to an ancient version of this trope, this tricks Bluebeard into thinking that she's preparing for an imminent marriage to Death, i.e. that she's resigned to dying and just insists on doing it with ''[[FaceDeathWithDignity honor]]''; which he decides to allow because he's rather WickedCultured that way.

to:

* IdiotBall: Good lord, why would the murderer give his wife a ''key to the room that he's desperate to keep a secret?''
* InterplayOfSexAndViolence: In some versions, instead of the wife's making increasingly feeble pleas for Bluebeard to hold off murdering her a little longer (and his inexplicably granting her a respite each time long enough for the DeusExMachina to occur), the tale has the more clever device of having her ask him to wait while she puts on various parts of her wedding dress. Due to an ancient version of this trope, this tricks Bluebeard into thinking that she's preparing for an imminent marriage to Death, i.e. that she's resigned to dying and just insists on doing it with ''[[FaceDeathWithDignity honor]]''; which he decides to allow because he's rather WickedCultured that way. way.
* [[OffWithHisHead OffWithHerHead]]: In some versions of the story, the wife doesn't find the ''bodies'' of her predecessors, but only their [[DecapitationPresentation severed heads]], all lined up in the cupboard.

Top