History Headscratchers / TheWheelOfTime

17th Jan '17 5:30:51 AM DustSnitch
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** On the other hand we have Mat, a certified BadAss who is basically Rand's greatest general, a personal friend of the Dragon Reborn and ta'veren to boot.
** Mat clearly knows how to defend himself, yet allows Tylin to do whatever she wants to him. He pisses and moans about it yet never once considers reminding Tylin that he's a close friend of someone who could easily destroy Ebou Dar by himself if he felt the need. This is made even more shocking by the fact that Mat had been building up his BadAss credentials over the past few books and yet Tylin manages to reduce him to a snivelling wreck. One can only assume that Robert Jordan subscribed to the DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale philosophy.

to:

** On the other hand we have Mat, a certified BadAss badass who is basically Rand's greatest general, a personal friend of the Dragon Reborn and ta'veren to boot.
** Mat clearly knows how to defend himself, yet allows Tylin to do whatever she wants to him. He pisses and moans about it yet never once considers reminding Tylin that he's a close friend of someone who could easily destroy Ebou Dar by himself if he felt the need. This is made even more shocking by the fact that Mat had been building up his BadAss badass credentials over the past few books and yet Tylin manages to reduce him to a snivelling wreck. One can only assume that Robert Jordan subscribed to the DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale philosophy.
9th Jan '17 5:28:58 PM Aquillion
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Balefire isn't even impossible to redirect in reality (Androl does it with a gateway.) People are so terrified of it that they don't stop to think about its limitations - as long as you don't touch the beam and have something that can redirect it without being erased, you can handle it just fine.
9th Jan '17 5:23:32 PM Aquillion
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* A bigger question: Why didn't Verin make a duplicate copy of all those messages and give them ''to Egwene''? At that point she was free of her oaths, and making sure Egwene was aware of those things would have served as an important backup plan. Egwene had access to gateways, so she could have easily had the White Tower handle all those things.
9th Jan '17 5:06:47 PM Aquillion
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]


[[folder: Why are people from the Two Rivers so much better than everyone else at everything?]]
They apparently have unbelievably awesome archers, riders, and (when using a quarterstaff) fighters; this doesn't just apply to the main characters, but is repeatedly mentioned to awe people who see Perrin's the Two Rivers troops in action in later books. Wha? While it's true that the longbow is something you learn your entire life as a hunter, there's no particular reason why the Two Rivers should be ''uniquely'' amazing at it compared to other small sleepy towns, and there's certainly no reason they should be particularly good with horses or the quarterstaff. Is it just Perrin's Ta'veren nature calling out their awesomeness?
9th Jan '17 5:02:33 PM Aquillion
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]


[[folder: Why are there so many Darkfriends?]]
For the past 3000 years, the Dark One has been sealed; only one of the Forsaken has been able to act on the world, and only in extremely limited ways for very brief periods of time at 1000-year intervals. Outside of him, every nation in the world has treated being a Darkfriend as deserving instant death. There are no rewards whatsoever to remaining one, and even their own prophecies are mostly about how the Dark One will bring ruin and pain and despair to everyone, including you. There seems to be a single wretched Dark One loyalist town near Shayol Ghul and that's it. How on earth did their beliefs survive for three thousand years in the face of all this? When Rand and Mat are traveling in the early books, they run into multiple Darkfriends in every village they pass through (and many of these seem surprised to see them, so they weren't all gathered for that purpose.) Where are they all coming from?
9th Jan '17 4:56:50 PM Aquillion
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]


[[folder: Where do the Whitecloaks get their authority?]]
Everyone who isn't a Whitecloak seems to hate them. They don't appear to have any particular religious basis outside their own texts and historical figures, which nobody else cares about (that is to say, they might style themselves after a church militant, but in the absence of a pope or any form of centralized religious authority, nobody has any reason to respect their claims, especially since nobody outside the Whitecloaks seems to believe they actually stand for or advance the cause of the Light.) They're essentially a militia based out of a tiny nation without the power to confront them, fine, but how are they able to march around in other countries randomly jailing or executing people? Andor seems like it could crush them like a bug (and has every reason to, since they constantly denounce Aes Sedai, which includes the queen.) They're treated like an NGOSuperpower, basically, but it's completely unclear where they're getting this power from.
4th Jan '17 9:09:19 AM Alas_Poor_Donny
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** It's likely less "the gods are male" and more "we've all agreed not to talk about this ever again". Because obviously the logical way that it would work given every other cultural gender division in Randland is for one of them to be male and the other female, and considering how quick the various patriarchies and matriarchies are to resort to mutual slaughter even all else being equal, there have probably been enough genocides over the question that the modern states have learned to avoid it, and stick to the gender-neutral pronouns (which, in English as of the first book being written in the 1980s, was definitively he/him/his/etc) and carefully never elaborate.
24th Dec '16 9:35:35 PM rTicWolf
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Since they didn't actually revert to babies, (unless they did and were then re-aged up with the Power, which would be far in excess of any ability shown elsewhere) it wasn't ''literally'' being reborn, it was just a Power-created simulated experience of it.
22nd Dec '16 7:28:15 AM Morgenthaler
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** I always imagined it as tradition, but tradition that's so strong and been around so long it might as well be considered The Rules. The Reds in particular would probably ostracize any member of their Ajah who bonded a Warder, considering how uptight and humorless they are even when ''not'' being outright antagonistic. The Greens I imagine started bonding multiple warriors because as the Battle Ajah, the more people you have watching your back the better, and that gradually became "Greens have multiple Warders, no-one else does". As for Warders being men, I imagine something similar- in the Westlands, at least, physical Action Girls (as opposed to {{Badass}} female channelers) seem to be very much the exception rather than the rule (this, of course, doesn't go for the Aiel, Seanchan, or Sea Folk), so the Warders started out as being drawn from men, until it was just taken as a given that "a Warder is a man". At least, that's my take.

to:

** I always imagined it as tradition, but tradition that's so strong and been around so long it might as well be considered The Rules. The Reds in particular would probably ostracize any member of their Ajah who bonded a Warder, considering how uptight and humorless they are even when ''not'' being outright antagonistic. The Greens I imagine started bonding multiple warriors because as the Battle Ajah, the more people you have watching your back the better, and that gradually became "Greens have multiple Warders, no-one else does". As for Warders being men, I imagine something similar- in the Westlands, at least, physical Action Girls (as opposed to {{Badass}} badass female channelers) seem to be very much the exception rather than the rule (this, of course, doesn't go for the Aiel, Seanchan, or Sea Folk), so the Warders started out as being drawn from men, until it was just taken as a given that "a Warder is a man". At least, that's my take.
24th Nov '16 9:54:13 AM Deadlock
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

**** Two that I remember - the story of the man who flew to the moon in the belly of an iron eagle ("Houston, the ''Eagle'' has landed"); and the circular metal amulet with three spokes found in Tarabon that "reeked of wealth and privilege" (Mercedes-Benz hood ornament).
This list shows the last 10 events of 345. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.TheWheelOfTime