Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / TheLegendOfZeldaTheWindWaker

Go To

OR

Added: 94

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Maybe Tetra was just ''really'' dirty and the Triforce cleaned her up? Her hair also looked a bit shinier and cleaner

to:

**** Maybe Tetra was just ''really'' dirty and the Triforce cleaned her up? Her hair also looked a bit shinier and cleanercleaner.
**** Living a life at sea sure builds up a tan, le's just assume magic just undid all of that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I don't know if he was the one who took those pictures. But, Lenzo was adventurous enough to get a picture of the Fairy Queen, who you not only needed to launch yourself in the sky with a ''tornado'' to see, but she didn't even appear to Link at first. And the King of Hyrule? Only three people have seen him. '''Three.''' Maybe it was an old pictograph that came before the gods decided to scrub all the floors in Hyrule.
** Maybe in Ganondorf's case, Lenzo or some poor schmuck made it to the Forsaken Fortress and got a picture of Ganondorf before he was tossed out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** GameplayAndStorySegregation. Aside from that, maybe Lenzo had a ridiculously high adventurous life when he was young.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* I'm aware that Orca and Sturgeon probably had what it took to defeat a Darknut, but how in the ''Hell'' did ''Lenzo'' get his hands on pictures of Laruto and Fado and the Great Fairy and the Fairy Queen and Jabun and the ''King of Hyrule'' and '''''Ganondorf?'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe the Kokiri and Koroks both reproduce asexually, like trees that self-pollinate and drop seeds. Or, I always assumed that there were a few stages of reincarnation between the Kokiri and the Koroks, and Makar is Fado's distant reincarnation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The boys of Outset Island are given copies of the Hero of Time's clothes when they reach the age he was when fighting Ganon, so we can assume that either this Link is OlderThanHeLooks, or the Hero of Time was YoungerThanHeLooks - either way, both Links are around the same age and are mature enough to wield the Master Sword.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Actually, it was stated that PH takes place in "The World of the Ocean King"- possibly an alternate world- so its Great Sea may or may not not actually take up any space in Hyrule or its surroundings.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[AllThereInTheManual Hyrule Historia]] (or at least [[http://www.glitterberri.com/hyrule-historia/page-123/ this translation of it]]) suggests that ''TWW'' takes place hundred'''s''' of years after ''OOT'', so there you go.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Given what happened the ''[[VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaOcarinaOfTime last]]'' time they vacuum sealed the hero for safekeeping, the sages (or whoever is responsible for that bit) probably made some tweaks to the system. Either that, or TWW Link is an incredibly small and young-looking sixteen-year-old.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** SkywardSword proposes a possible answer to this. The revelation that Princess Zelda is the reincarnation of the Goddess Hylia explains the mystery of why all the Zeldas look ''extremely'' similar, in contrast to the varying appearances of the Links. It's possible that the reason Tetra's skin tone changes when she becomes Zelda is because her body is being transformed in order to, as all Zeldas before her, resemble the Goddess. Tetra is Zelda as she was actually born and lives, while "Princess Zelda" is Zelda as the mortal form of the Goddess, and her appearance changes accordingly. This isn't an issue encountered with other Princess Zeldas in the series, because every other Zelda has been born into royalty and tradition, and raised to be Princess Zelda, while Tetra was not.

to:

** SkywardSword proposes a possible answer to this. [[spoiler: The revelation that Princess Zelda is the reincarnation of the Goddess Hylia explains the mystery of why all the Zeldas look ''extremely'' similar, in contrast to the varying appearances of the Links. It's possible that the reason Tetra's skin tone changes when she becomes Zelda is because her body is being transformed in order to, as all Zeldas before her, resemble the Goddess. Tetra is Zelda as she was actually born and lives, while "Princess Zelda" is Zelda as the mortal form of the Goddess, and her appearance changes accordingly. This isn't an issue encountered with other Princess Zeldas in the series, because every other Zelda has been born into royalty and tradition, and raised to be Princess Zelda, while Tetra was not.
not.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** SkywardSword proposes a possible answer to this. The revelation that Princess Zelda is the reincarnation of the Goddess Hylia explains the mystery of why all the Zeldas look ''extremely'' similar, in contrast to the varying appearances of the Links. It's possible that the reason Tetra's skin tone changes when she becomes Zelda is because her body is being transformed in order to, as all Zeldas before her, resemble the Goddess. Tetra is Zelda as she was actually born and lives, while "Princess Zelda" is Zelda as the mortal form of the Goddess, and her appearance changes accordingly. This isn't an issue encountered with other Princess Zeldas in the series, because every other Zelda has been born into royalty and tradition, and raised to be Princess Zelda, while Tetra was not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Evolutionary answer: Zora are already amphibious. Ocarina Zoras leave the water and walk on land ''all the time''. Zora's Domain has more land than it does water, and their king has a dry throne. They aren't fish, they're amphibians. Now, assuming that the world ''around'' Hyrule has oceans, that is where the water for flooding Hyrule would have come from. To flood Hyrule ''permanently'' as has happened in Wind Waker, the oceans would have to rise until they covered all of Hyrule, and remain there. Zoras being predominantly freshwater creatures, the sudden onset of saltwater would destroy their lungs and kill them. Zoras being amphibious, those that survived the flood would have done so by clinging to what vestiges of land remain above the ocean after it's risen. At this point, we're left with an amphibious race that can't actually survive in the water anymore, and that isn't naturally equipped to exist solely on land. Whether evolution or Valoo happened next, their only chance for survival at that point is to change.

to:

** Evolutionary answer: Zora are already amphibious. Ocarina Zoras leave the water and walk on land ''all the time''. Zora's Domain has more land than it does water, and their king has a dry throne. They aren't fish, they're amphibians. Now, assuming that the world ''around'' Hyrule has oceans, that is where the water for flooding Hyrule would have come from. To flood Hyrule ''permanently'' as has happened in Wind Waker, the oceans would have to rise until they covered all of Hyrule, and remain there. Zoras being predominantly freshwater creatures, the sudden onset of saltwater would destroy their lungs and kill them. Zoras being amphibious, those that survived the flood would have done so by clinging to what vestiges of land remain above the ocean after it's risen. At this point, we're left with an amphibious race that can't actually survive in the water anymore, and that isn't naturally equipped to exist solely on land. Whether evolution or Valoo happened next, their only chance for survival at that point is to change.adapt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Evolutionary answer: Zora are already amphibious. Ocarina Zoras leave the water and walk on land ''all the time''. Zora's Domain has more land than it does water, and their king has a dry throne. They aren't fish, they're amphibians. Now, assuming that the world ''around'' Hyrule has oceans, that is where the water for flooding Hyrule would have come from. To flood Hyrule ''permanently'' as has happened in Wind Waker, the oceans would have to rise until they covered all of Hyrule, and remain there. Zoras being predominantly freshwater creatures, the sudden onset of saltwater would destroy their lungs and kill them. Zoras being amphibious, those that survived the flood would have done so by clinging to what vestiges of land remain above the ocean after it's risen. At this point, we're left with an amphibious race that can't actually survive in the water anymore, and that isn't naturally equipped to exist solely on land. Whether or not evolution or Valoo happened next, their only chance for survival at that point is to change.

to:

** Evolutionary answer: Zora are already amphibious. Ocarina Zoras leave the water and walk on land ''all the time''. Zora's Domain has more land than it does water, and their king has a dry throne. They aren't fish, they're amphibians. Now, assuming that the world ''around'' Hyrule has oceans, that is where the water for flooding Hyrule would have come from. To flood Hyrule ''permanently'' as has happened in Wind Waker, the oceans would have to rise until they covered all of Hyrule, and remain there. Zoras being predominantly freshwater creatures, the sudden onset of saltwater would destroy their lungs and kill them. Zoras being amphibious, those that survived the flood would have done so by clinging to what vestiges of land remain above the ocean after it's risen. At this point, we're left with an amphibious race that can't actually survive in the water anymore, and that isn't naturally equipped to exist solely on land. Whether or not evolution or Valoo happened next, their only chance for survival at that point is to change.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Evolutionary answer: Zora are already amphibious. Ocarina Zoras leave the water and walk on land ''all the time''. Zora's Domain has more land than it does water, and their king has a dry throne. They aren't fish, they're amphibians. Now, assuming that the world ''around'' Hyrule has oceans, that is where the water for flooding Hyrule would have come from. To flood Hyrule ''permanently'' as has happened in Wind Waker, the oceans would have to rise until they covered all of Hyrule, and remain there. Zoras being predominantly freshwater creatures, the sudden onset of saltwater would destroy their lungs and kill them. Zoras being amphibious, those that survived the flood would have done so by clinging to what vestiges of land remain above the ocean after it's risen. At this point, we're left with an amphibious race that can't actually survive in the water anymore, and that isn't naturally equipped to exist solely on land. Whether or not evolution or Valoo happened next, their only chance for survival at that point is to change.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This troper believes ''Twilight Princess'' was the game actually stated to take place roughly a hundred years after ''Ocarina of Time''. ''The Wind Waker'' gives the impression it's been longer than a century - everything from the language to written history has been completely lost by the time the story starts. Ganondorf escaped by way of a breach in the seal over Hyrule, and considering that it was the goddesses themselves who originally entrapped him, it likely took awhile to weaken. Ganondorf is a BigBad with plenty of time, after all - the Triforce of Power makes him effectively immortal by WordOfGod.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler: Maybe she's a lucid dreamer.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Maybe 'conducting' in the Zelda-verse means something different from what it means in our world. All it literally means is 'to direct in an action or course', 'to direct (as a leader)', or 'to serve as a channel or medium for a force'. Link does all three of these with the Baton: he directs the winds into new courses, he acts as the leader/director for the winds by commanding them what to do, and he acts as a medium for the forces of the gods of the wind by using the baton.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I've always said that it sort of depends on how old Ganondorf is during the events of Ocarina. Considering that Gerudo seem to be able to live for hundreds of years (Kotone and Kotake are 380 or 400, after all) meaning it could be set something like 300 years later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe the flood didn't actually involve the water level of the world rising, but the altitude of Hyrule ''falling''. That is, maybe Hyrule was, more accurately, sunk to the bottom of the sea. This would explain why certain locations (such as the Forest Haven and Windfall/Kakariko) seem to have been kept above the water (they weren't sunk with the rest of the land). It also would imply that Hyrule is a peninsula, island or continent of its own. As noted, it's possible that locations like Labrynna are actually neighbouring New Hyrule, or alternatively that they were formed at other times due to other changes in geography. Oh, and it may also provide a mechanism - a major tectonic shift causes most of Hyrule to collapse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It could be that they were simply unable to isolate the flooding to just Hyrule alone, given how massive it would had to have been to have any lasting effect against Ganon. The Goddesses were faced with a SadisticChoice, and even they, with all their power, were unable to [[TakeAThirdOption find a way around it]]...flood the entire world to stop Ganondorf from conquering Hyrule and sending it into an age of darkness that makes the BadFuture from Ocarina of Time look like an episode of {{Hamtaro}}, or let Ganondorf run free and unopposed, dooming Hyrule and everyone who lived there...and eventually the rest of the world, once he realized there were lands other than Hyrule. With the first choice, there was at least a ''small'' hope of salvation, so they reluctantly went with it.

to:

** It could be that they were simply unable to isolate the flooding to just Hyrule alone, given how massive it would had to have been to have any lasting effect against Ganon. The Goddesses were faced with a SadisticChoice, and even they, with all their power, were unable to [[TakeAThirdOption find a way around it]]...flood the entire world to stop Ganondorf from conquering Hyrule and sending it into an age of darkness that makes the BadFuture from Ocarina of Time look like an episode of {{Hamtaro}}, Anime/{{Hamtaro}}, or let Ganondorf run free and unopposed, dooming Hyrule and everyone who lived there...and eventually the rest of the world, once he realized there were lands other than Hyrule. With the first choice, there was at least a ''small'' hope of salvation, so they reluctantly went with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** IIRC, Rauru, the sage of light, was the one who kept link in stasis in the sacred realm for seven years. He wasn't present to do that in Wind Waker. Even if he was, he probably saw that this era's Link was old enough to wield it and defeat Ganon without having to age him first.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Didn't I read somewhere that WW was set a hundred years after OoT?

Added: 1137

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I'd say around 12

to:

** I'd say around 1212.


Added DiffLines:

* How long after Ocarina of Time is this supposed to take place? It seems like it has to have been quite a ways after, given how the Zoras and Kokiris have turned into the the Ritos and Koroks, and the intro states that "none remain" who remember what happened to Hyrule. If it was only 100 years like I've seen a lot of people guessing, it would be fairly likely that the characters we see in-game are at most great-grandchildren of the characters we see in Ocarina, so it seems weird that they'd have little accurate info on what had happened -- I mean, ''Triumph Forks'', really? But on the other hand, it can't have been ''too'' much longer afterwards either; Ganondorf seems to have gotten quite a bit of CharacterDevelopment and become OlderAndWiser, so I doubt it would seriously take him that long to come up with his plans in this game. Plus, since [[spoiler:Tetra is Zelda and has the Triforce of Wisdom]], that makes it seem fairly likely that [[spoiler:Ocarina's Zelda couldn't have left ''too'' many descendants, as too many generations later would make Tetra having the Triforce of Wisdom a complete ContrivedCoincidence]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** But [[spoiler: Fi's asleep...]]

to:

*** But [[spoiler: [[TheLegendofZeldaSkywardSword Fi's asleep...]]]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** But [[spoiler: Fi's asleep...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****** I vaguely recall that being stated somewhere, but can't remember where exactly. Follow [[http://www.zeldadungeon.net/Zelda12-phantom-hourglass-treasures.php this link]] for the Treasure descriptions. The one for the Zora Scale says "It is said that a Zora dropped this rare and sparkling scale!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Desperate times call for desperate measures. The Master Sword probably realized it wasn't getting anybody better anytime soon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This troper always assumed the game designers did that on purpose, as to make it less obvious who the sages were right off the bat.

to:

** This troper always assumed the game designers did that on purpose, as to make it less obvious who the sages were right off the bat.
were.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** This troper always assumed the game designers did that on purpose, as to make it less obvious who the sages were right off the bat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** We're also approaching the issue from a human perspective - time is endless from a god's. To the goddesses, having to destroy Hyrule may have been a unfortunate and necessary choice, but it's also one that will eventually be a miniscule part of the long history of the world. With centuries and millenia to come, it will move on and rebuild anew. Consider the Deku Tree statements about the forests that may come after his Koroks plant the seeds of new Deku trees - his thinking far outstrips any human conception of time.

Top